Introduction to Nat Bar Nat
נותן טעם בר נותן טעם — מבוא
Opening shiur of the zman. Reviews basar b'chalav fundamentals (hana'ah, achilah, bishul), introduces nat bar nat (נותן טעם בר נותן טעם), surveys the Gemara in Chullin (דגים שעלו בקערה), Tosafos in Zevachim, and a three-way machlokes Rishonim: Rivan/Rashi, Sefer HaTerumah/Rosh, and Rambam. Covers Shulchan Aruch Siman 95, seifim 1–2, and the Rema's chumra. Concludes with practical shailos on ice cream (Dayan Weiss / Minchas Yitzchak) and the pareve cake question.
Audio
DownloadNotes
Key Takeaways
- ▸ The Gemara in Chullin (111b) debates whether hot parve fish placed on a fleishig plate may be eaten with dairy — Rav forbids, Shmuel permits.
- ▸ נ"ט בר נ"ט (nat bar nat): flavor that transfers twice is sufficiently weakened and does not create a basar b'chalav prohibition.
- ▸ Three-way machlokes Rishonim: Rivan/Rashi (only allows placement, not cooking), Sefer HaTerumah (allows cooking in pot but not frying in pan), Rambam (allows even frying).
- ▸ S"A (95:1) rules like the Rambam — parve food cooked in a clean fleishig ben-yomo pot may be eaten with dairy.
- ▸ Rama is machmir: le'chatchilla one may not add dairy to parve food cooked in a ben-yomo fleishig pot, but bedi'eved it is permitted.
- ▸ Practical: "DE" (Dairy Equipment) labeling — for Sephardim fully parve, for Ashkenazim depends on whether machines are ben-yomo. Minchas Yitzchak rules a hechsher should follow the stricter view.
- ▸ Parve cake baked for dessert in an eino ben-yomo fleishig pan may be eaten with dairy coffee (Minchas Yitzchak / Minchas Sefer).
Yes, for the first time, welcome. There is a WhatsApp group, there is a Google Drive that will have all of the shiurim and all of the folders and all of the notes and everything including chazarah notes later in this zman.
I apologize in advance for any jokes that I say, any food that I make fun of. Okay. So as I mentioned this zman, we just finished zman of basar b'chalav. So we're really just continuing, which I think actually is good.
While the information is fresh and the terms and the ideas and the lomdus that we learned in the last zman about basar b'chalav and ta'aroves and things like that, chaticha na'ases neveila and things like that, that is very very much
relevant for what we are going to be doing this zman. So this zman will take us through if you see the, if you see in the booklet, so you have siman tzadi hey which we're going to do over the next
a number of weeks. Siman tzadi hey is mostly focused on issues of nat bar nat, which we'll talk about tonight, נותן טעם בר נותן טעם. That's so you can keep the regular. And then you'll have to get a new Shulchan
Aruch for kuf kaf gimmel which we're going to talk eventually about yayin nesech and stam yeinam, yayin mevushal, you know basically things that if you drink other wines than just Moscato will affect you. So in my house we'll be alright,
but maybe your house you'll have to figure this out. So let's go if you take the, open up the Shulchan Aruch to siman tzadi hey and the booklet to page number one. Let's review something very quickly. We mentioned that the
Torah in three places says that you cannot cook meat and milk together and that teaches me three issurim. What are those three issurim? Hana'ah, achilah, and bishul. And bishul. That sounds like that sounds right. There are three things the Halacha
tells us. Now we also learned that when we create an issur of basar b'chalav, that is because a ta'am is created in the pot itself. So again, I'll make it easy. There is going to be a lot of terms over
the next few weeks that are very like parve, dairy, eino ben yomo, so you just have to like hold kop as they say for a little bit. But we mentioned that there's this idea of nosein ta'am, okay? That means that
if I have a pot and I make meatballs in that pot, within the walls of the pot there is nesinas ta'am, the pot, the meat gave flavor into the walls of the pot. That is true for the walls of a
pot, that is true for anything. If you take a pot of meatballs and you throw something parve in that pot of meatballs and then you pull out that parve thing, okay, you pull out a potato, even though we did talk
about a Rema that maybe is meikel, that if you cooked it together, there is meat flavor in that potato. If I ate that potato, what am I? I am fleishig. Now if I take a ben yomo pot, that means I
cooked this morning meatballs and I cleaned it out then I cooked something else in that pot, I cooked something parve in that pot, could I eat those noodles? Sure. Of course you could. Thank you Eddie. Of course you could eat
those noodles, but would those noodles make you fleishig? No. Could you eat those noodles with milchig? That's what we're going to discuss right now. We believe probably not, but we are going to discuss very relevant shaylos of what happened, I
just had this shayla in my house erev pesach, erev the last days, no sorry, erev Shabbos. One of my boys was making something and he tasted an onion that was cut up with a fleishig knife. And there was a shayla
of now he wants to eat something milchig. So I told him he'd better call somebody else. Okay. So the Gemara in Chullin, the Gemara the first source, the Gemara in Chullin tells us the following. The Gemara, we learned this Gemara
last time, but now we didn't spend as much time on nat bar nat or נתינת טעם בר נתינת טעם. But let's go. The following: itmar, דגים שעלו בקערה. So the Gemara tells us that if I had fish, okay if I
had fish, let's take one step back. Just to flush out the rest of this, there is nesinas ta'am, but after twenty-four hours we call that nosein ta'am lifgam. That means that after twenty-four hours, I'm not as concerned anymore because whatever
flavor is actually there is no longer a positive flavor but is a negative flavor. It's going to make the taste bad. We focus on ta'am. So if I made meatballs in a fleishig pot and twenty-eight hours later I made something
in that same pot, I made something milchig even in that pot, we would say what's the status of the food? You could eat it. It's nesinas ta'am, it's nosein. Now if you didn't clean it, it's gross. That would be an
issue. But nosein ta'am lifgam means after twenty-four hours, that's when we're definitely more lenient. So the first shayla the rabbi's going to ask when you call, the first shayla's going to be, was it cold? Then it's going to be, when
was the last time the thing was used? So now let's get into this concept. So the Gemara... The Gemara tells us that a machlokes between Rav and Shmuel regarding the status of hot pareve fish, okay, דגים שעלו בקערה. That means
I cooked fish. רב אמר אסור לאכלן בכותח. So Rav says you can't, that fish cannot be eaten with dairy. Why not? What is the reason according to Rav? Because there is no way that well here the k'arah is a fleishig
ben yomo. So according to Rav why can't I eat that fish with dairy with milchig? Because the fish absorbed taam from the meat. It was a ben yomo. I made meatballs in the morning, I cleaned it out, I made fish
later in the afternoon, completely pareve fish, but the taam of the meatballs is still in the walls of the pot and there that when I heat it up the taam comes into the fish, the fish is now fleishig. Why would
that be a question? Hold on a sec, hold on a sec, hold on a sec. שמואל אמר מותר לאכלן בכותח. Shmuel says you can eat it with the some kutach is a dairy kind of thing you could eat it with
that because רב אמר נותן טעם הוא. Rav says it's noten taam. What do you mean? The meat was noten taam from the wall into the fish. Shmuel amar muttar because נותן טעם בר נותן טעם הוא. There's a concept called for
the rest of the zman we're going to call it nat bar nat, not נותן טעם בר נותן טעם. You know for example in the Gemara the Gemara is in Gittin, we're learning Gittin in the yeshiva this year. So the Gemara
in Gittin the first eight blatt is בפני נכתב ובפני נחתם. When you sign a get you have to say בפני נכתב ובפני נחתם but you learn Gittin no one ever says בפני נכתב ובפני נחתם you say בפני נכתב ובפני נחתם.
You say like that. Say very fast. So we told our seniors when the Roshei Yeshiva come to interview you for the yeshivas and they say what are you learning in Gittin they don't say בפני נכתב ובפני נחתם you have to
speed through it so you know it sounds like you know what you're talking about, okay? So nat bar nat, okay? They do know what they're talking about but it's always good to help them. Okay? There's a concept called nat bar
nat. Nat bar nat means according to Shmuel the meatballs were noten taam into the walls of the pot. The walls of the pot are noten taam into the fish. That is a very very weak taste. That is not strong enough
and נותן טעם בר נותן טעם we think is according to Shmuel which the Gemara paskens like is going to be okay. The Gemara the Tosafos in Zevachim in source number two explains that we saw a little bit of this Tosafos.
Says the Tosafos in Zevachim ואם לא הביא ראיה לדבריו מקדירה שבישלו בה בשר לא יבשלו בה חלב בשביל דנותן טעם when I if I cooked meat, don't cook in it milk because it's noten taam. דהתם לאו נותן טעם בר נותן
טעם הוא that's not נותן טעם בר נותן טעם שפעמים שהטעם השני באיסור דהיינו בשר וחלב sometimes the second taste is in a prohibition namely basar vechalav takes effect when the meat and the milk are fused together okay like when I
cook milk in a fleishig pot that's an issue אבל כאן הטעם השני בהיתר וקודם שיבא לידי איסור נתבטל הטעם בדגים לפי שהוא שני meaning when the fish is muttar by itself the meatballs are muttar by themselves so what happens? I
have two muttar items in that situation I didn't fuse any issur together. When I made mamash basar vechalav and I created an entity a cheftza shel issur that's a problem and that's going to be noten taam. But you're telling me
according to Shmuel I have fish the fish is pareve. The meat's fleishig. They're both noten taam into other things by the time they meet together it's a weak noten taam and therefore we do not imply that it's already inherently forbidden
and noten taam is going to be okay. Halacha lemaaseh this how we pasken if you look in the Beis Yosef. Says the Beis Yosef in source number three. The Beis Yosef says you're right we pasken like Shmuel nat bar nat
not a problem. However says the Beis Yosef it is a three way machlokes how to understand what it means דגים שעלו בקערה. So before we even see these three Rishonim, the Rivan, the Sefer HaTerumah, and the Rambam and there's a
fourth what does it sound like? I gave you a lot of information I said that דגים שעלו בקערה fish that is in a plate is fish that was cooked in a fish cooked in a ben yomo fleishig pot. What does
it sound like דגים שעלו בקערה? It was no water. Otherwise it was touching. So where was the fish was cooked where? Up against the metal. Some fish. Right. It doesn't even sound like... so okay that's a machlokes. It could be
that it was cooked in that pot or it could be as Joel is saying it was cooked in another pot and then it came onto a pot maybe that is fleishig. So let's see three machlokes Rishonim. So the Rivan chosno
the father in law of the Rivan was. The Rivan chasno, Rashi, kasav mishmo, אלו אין נתבשלו לו. Says the Rivan that Shmuel only allows eating the fish when the, okay, again, eating the fish with milkchik when the hot fish was
placed on a fleishig dish. Okay, אף על גב דבאלו נמי קבלו כדי קליפה, טעמן בשר בבליעה מועטת התיר נותן טעם בר נותן טעם. אבל נתבשלו ונבלעו כל טעם הבשר שבלוע בקדירה, but if you're telling me that I mamish did what?
I cooked the fish in that fleishig ben yomo pot, asur le'ochlo bekutach. According to, good, the Rivan, Rashi, and Rabbi Doug say the following: if you cook fish in a fleishig pot, that is not, that is not נותן טעם בר
נותן טעם. That is mamish cooking it and therefore the only time that Shmuel really held that it's okay is when I cooked it by, I cooked the fish, I took the fish that was cooked in a parve pot, on a
whatever pot, it doesn't matter, and then I took that fish and I put it on a ben yomo fleishig plate. Okay, that's נותן טעם בר נותן טעם. Why? Because the meat, the whatever, the meatballs were the nosein ta'am, then I
took it onto the plate, that plate's not a real fleishig plate, the fleishig plate is a נותן טעם בר נותן טעם plate, it's a nab bar nab plate. What? We're gonna talk, we're gonna talk about all those things in a
second. Okay, so says the Rivan in the name of Rashi, that's the only time he's going to be meikel. In comes the Sefer HaTruma and the Rosh and others and the Tur, וכתב הראש וספר התרומה the other way, התיר ירקות
וקטניות שנתבשלו בקדירה בת יומא חלבת, the other way around. They allow the fish that was cooked in a fleishig ben yomo pot to be eaten with milkchik, רק שמנקה מחלב לאכל בתבשיל של בשר, so long as obviously it's been cleaned
out, because they believe אפילו נאמר אלו אין נצלו לו כשנתבשלו שרי, משום דאיכא שלשה נותן טעם. They actually say it was weakened three times. Forget nosein ta'am, forget nat bar nat, actually weakened, one sec, hold on, hold on, nat bar
nat to the third degree. The meat to the pot is one, what's next? The pot קדירה במים והמים בירק. So don't view the water as everything. I cooked meatballs this morning, meatballs went into my pot. That is nosein ta'am one.
The meatballs went into the water, nosein ta'am two. The water was nosein ta'am into the fish, that's crazy. That's נותן טעם בר נותן טעם בר נותן טעם, that's mutar. That's what's the logic though, that the water cooks before the item
in the water? Yes, because you need a medium to transfer heat. I need a medium to transfer ta'am. We don't, it's not just a magic potion, something has to transfer heat, transfer the taste. So the water transfers the taste, but
it doesn't happen at the same time. The water absorbs from the thing and then it puts it in, it's floating in the pot, so the water is, is being is transferred even if it happens in a split second. But the
Tur, the Sefer HaTruma, and the Rosh say that's enough and therefore if I made meatballs this morning and I cooked fish this afternoon, do not leave here before we do halacha lema'aseh and go home, but according to the Tur and
the Rosh and the Sefer HaTruma I could go ahead and eat that fish with whatever milkchik you wanted to eat it with. Hold on, hold on, hold on, hold on, there's a lot of details. I want to get through a
number more mekomos unless it's I don't understand what that source was, because that's fine, but according to the Rosh, how you're translating this, he says the yerakos that were cooked in a ben yomo chalavas. Chalavas? Where are you getting this
was cooked in a fleishig pot to start with? The fish was cooked in the Rosh pot. But the vegetables, yerakos, ben yomos, shenisbashlu bak... He's saying the other way I just said the other way around. If I cooked it in
a milkchik pot it's a fleishig, other just do the other way around. If I cooked them all in a, he says, if I cooked it all in a bas yoma chalavas, as long as it's clean, I could, if I later
cooked something betavshil shel basar I can eat it. I made macaroni and cheese this morning, I cleaned it out, I made something fleishig in there, I can eat it together, I can eat it. Meaning whatever is as long as it's
been cleaned out, whatever I put in that pot afterwards doesn't have the status of what it was this morning. No, no, then he continues in the underline, he continues in the underline, חלב בקדירה קדירה במים ומים בירק, even though if
it's it's. 24 hours? That's what he's saying, yeah. According to the Rashi he's talking about boiling vegetables, but he equates boiling vegetables where you have a full pot of a liquid medium as opposed to if you were frying a piece
of meat that had lachluchit on it. So we're talking about that, potentially but depends on how much oil you have. Yeah, that might, that might be. We're going to talk about that. And then he quotes the third is the Rambam.
וכן נראה דעת הרמבם. Then he quotes the Rambam to, you know, just like to your point, שכתבו בפרק ט מהלכות מאכלות אסורות, קערה שאכלו בה בשר, if I have a plate that I was eating meat, ובשלו בה דגים אותם דגים
מותר לאוכלן בכותח. So according to the Rambam, he says ולא חילק בין צליה לבישול כלל. According to the Rambam, even if the fish I allowed, I can eat the fish with dairy if it was cooked in a fleishig ben yomo
pot, even if it was fried. Again because of nat bar nat. He quotes here in the footnote, by the way, a comment of the Issur v'Hetter that you can eat it like the Rivash, a little bit of like a, we'll
call it a fourth opinion or a three-eighths, or B, but anyway, these are the three opinions. So according to the Rambam, the plate, it says אכלו בה בשר ובשלו בה דגים. So is he saying that you cooked meat in that,
but it says אכלו? That's not just you cooked? Yeah, yeah, yeah. Yeah, we'll see, we'll see a little bit later in the Rema about plates and stuff like that. Okay. So now go to the Shulchan Aruch in Tzadi-Hei. Is this
davar charif? A little bit later. Yeah, a little bit, a little bit. Okay, so if you go into Siman Tzadi-Hei the following. Shulchan Aruch in Seif Aleph says דגים שנתבשלו או שנתצלו בקדירה של בשר. The fish that I cooked in
a meat, in a meat pot. rechuza yafeh. All I gotta do is clean it out really, really well. Right? If I clean it out really, really well שאין שום שומן דבוק בה. As long as there's really nothing that's left there,
then mutar l'ochlan b'kutach. Right? Like the Rambam, I can eat it with the dairy thing. Why? Exactly as we just said. משום דהוי נותן טעם בר נותן טעם דהיתרא. It's why d'heteira? Because there is נט בר נט דאיסורא. Right? Certain
things that become an issur just because the ta'am is weakened doesn't matter. If I took treifus tonight and cooked it in my pot and then I said, \"Oh, I cooked treifus in this morning and now I had other treifus\". I
don't care that you have other treifus in there. I don't care that it's later. I don't care that you cleaned it out. It's treifus. Treifus is an issur no matter what. Doesn't matter. But נותן טעם בר נותן טעם דהיתרא of
meat in a pot and milk in a pot that later are because of נותן טעם בר נותן טעם joined together, that's what we're talking about. ואם לא היה רחוצה יפה, and if you didn't wash it out so nicely, אם יש
ממש על פני הקדירה יוצא ממנו בשישים מהדגים אסור לאוכלן בכותח. All right, then you have to figure out if you had shishim or not. Okay, exactly we just saw in the Gemara and then in the Rambam. Seif Beis. Okay, now
the Shulchan Aruch is going to clarify what exactly is this halacha of nat bar nat. So let's follow. ביצה שנתבשלה במים בקדירה חולבת. I take an egg, okay, and I cooked it in a milchig pot. I want to take that
egg. An egg is parve or fleishig? Parve. There we go. מותר לתת אותה בתוך התרנגולת. If you're thinking, \"What does that mean?\" That is exactly what that sounds like. It's Thanksgiving morning and you take that egg and you shove it
in the turkey. Afilu l'chatchila says the, now why? All right, now I took the, I had a milchig pot. ביצה שנתבשלה במים בקדירה חולבת, a milchig pot. I cooked an egg in a milchig pot. I could stick that egg in
a turkey, or hen, chicken, whichever you like. Afilu l'chatchila I could even do it l'chatchila. Why is that okay? Because אבל אם נתבשלה בקדירה עם בשר, that's different. If I had a milchig pot, that means that maybe this morning I
made macaroni and cheese. I cleaned it out. It is a milchig pot. For the next 24 hours that pot is a milchig pot. But when I cooked the eggs alone, what was milchig inside the pot? Nothing. The only thing that
was milchig inside the pot was the ta'am from this morning of the macaroni and cheese that was back into, but the egg isn't a milchig egg. So if I took that egg and I put it in a turkey, that's not
going to do anything, that's not a problem. But if I had meat sauce and I threw an egg in there, and then I took that egg, right, and I took that egg, that, I'm sorry, what's a macaroni and cheese and
I took that egg, that egg is now what? Milchig. נתבשלה בקדירה עם בשר. He says it by the meat. But if the parve item is cooked together with meat, afilu b'klippa... Asur le'ochlo bechutach. Okay, an egg cooked with meat or
cooked with dairy could not be eaten, you can't use it for the other one. Okay. Good. Fershteis? Veiter. Says the Rema: Veyesh machmirim. So the Rema says, there are those that are machmir בצליה ובשול לאסור נותן טעם בר נותן טעם.
Oh, so close. Says the Rema, like the Rivan, quoting Rashi, and the Aruch, and the Mordechai, there are those that are machmir even if it's נותן טעם בר נותן טעם, even if it's not bar nat, to be machmir not to
use it. The Rema says, let's continue, right? The Rema actually a little bit later, we'll put him back to that Issur Veheter, but let's continue. Vehaminhag le'asor lechatchila, and the Rema says, and the minhag is to be to assur this.
That means that what? The fish that was cooked in a fleishig ben yomo pot, not with fleishig, a fleishig ben yomo pot, that fish the Rema says lechatchila should not be eaten together with dairy. Okay. What about bedieved? Excellent. We're
going to come back to that next time. Okay. But this is how the Rema paskens. So, but ובדיעבד מותר בכל ענין דדוקא לאכלם עם חלב ובשר עצמו. The Rema says, but if dairy was added to it, meaning I made, I
made meatballs in the morning, I cleaned it out, I have, I made fish in there in the afternoon, I didn't realize the pot was, I took the fish and I, I added milk and I add all this other stuff, says
the Rema, you could eat that fish. You could eat that fish. The shaila we're going to talk about soon is can I do that lechatchila? Okay. We have the shaila, we have the shaila a lot. The shaila comes up a
lot. I'm running out of pots. It's Friday afternoon. I only have a milchig pot. Can I use, these are going to come up. So the Rema says, bedieved it's going to be mutar. Meaning, in essence, why does the Rema say
that? Let's understand how the Rema comes to this. The Rema's not, if it's mutar it's mutar, if it's assur it's assur. The Rema says, yes, really we don't, we don't in essence pasken like the Rivan. I, we pasken like how
the Shulchan Aruch paskens, like the Rambam, that it's nosein ta'am it's not bar nat. However, we're going to be machmir about it, but in any situation it's a, this is a good reminder of what machmir generally means. Machmir is a
good thing. Machmir is not a bad thing. Machmir is not a person who's a religious fanatic. A chumra means there is basis in halacha for such a thing. Right? So the Rema says, this is what it means to be machmir.
Yes, the Rivan, yes, the Shulchan Aruch says this, we follow the Rivan. However, in cases of need, a bedieved, it's mutar because it's only a chumra. Right? A person who keeps 72 minutes after Shabbos is a chumra, right? That's the
Rabbeinu Tam, and in case of need if they keep it as a chumra, they're able to be meikel on certain things because it's a chumra. Okay. Fine. That's the Rema. Okay. Yeah. The Rema adds, okay, so now if you look
ואפילו אם ליתן בה כלי שלהם מותר לכתחילה. Okay. Vechein nahagu. So we pasken like this. This is how we pasken as Ashkenazim. This is how we pasken. Then the Rema begins to add four different halachos. We're going to talk about
a few of them right now. So let's go one by one. Okay. He says first, וכן אם לא נתבשלו או נצלו תחילה. Let's say that I actually didn't cook them at all together. Rather what did I do? רק עלו בכלי
של בשר מותר לאכלן עם חלב עצמו וכן להיפך. Fish cooked in a ben yomo pot, okay, in a fleishig ben yomo pot, got that? Fish cooked in a fleishig ben yomo pot can be put lechatchila on a dairy ben yomo
plate. Okay? Clean plate, not like full of yogurt. Okay? Next. That's number one. I'll tell you where the shaila comes up. Shaila comes up that a person makes pasta in a fleishig ben yomo pot. Okay? They make pasta in a
fleishig ben yomo pot and they want to know if they could add cheese or not to it. Shulchan Aruch would say yes. The Rema would say no. That's how we pasken. That's how we pasken. That the noodles aren't, the spaghetti
will not make you fleishig, you cannot eat that spaghetti. If you by accident did it and you didn't realize, the Rema would say it's fine. Okay? That's number one. But what would the Rema say if it was an eino ben
yomo pot? I made... I'm just telling you, do not share this halacha in your house. You will get yelled at. Okay? This is a regular halacha, it's the Rema paskins, I could take the. The reason is you find this in
a lot of the in the Rishonim, that's why we have multiple sets of pots. If yes, you could have one pot and every other day make something in it, it gets confusing. But if you had an eino ben yomo fleishig
pot, you made spaghetti in there and you wanted to add cheese lechatchila the Rema would say go ahead. Okay? You'd feel weird doing it. You took that pot that it came out of the fleishig dishwasher and then you'd feel weird
doing it, but that's how the Rema paskins. Next. היה הכלי שנתבשלו או נצלו בו לפגם. Before we get to the second halacha, okay, go to the source for one second to source number four to the Bedek HaBayis. Say the question
is as we just mentioned can I do this or not lechatchila? Just I know we said this outside but let's look at it inside. Bedek HaBayis is Rabbi Yosef Karo. So if I made vegetables שנתבשלו בקדרה חולבת אפילו בת יומא,
even if it's that day, מותר לאכלו בתבשיל של בשר, ונראה דדוקא בדיעבד אבל לכתחילה אין לו לבשל בכלי של חלב. So the Bedek HaBayis quotes, here it's actually quoting the Rabbeinu Yerucham, that actually the Rabbeinu Yerucham says no, you shouldn't
do it lechatchila, bedieved like the Rema says. Says the Bedek HaBayis, says Rabbi Yosef Karo, ein devarav nirim. No. לכתחילה נמי מותר לבשל בכלי של חלב. That's fine. You could do it even like we just said, it would be fine
to intentionally do this kind of thing. That's how the Sephardim might give a psak. We obviously do not follow that psak. If you turn the page, because from the language of the Shulchan Aruch it sounds like shenisbashlu or shenitzlu. It
sounds like they already did it. Can I do it lechatchila? So here you have in Halichot Olam, Rav Ovadia. So Rav Ovadia writes ולא עוד אלא אפילו הוא יודע מראש. I know, says Rav Ovadia. I am cooking with intention that
later I'm going to eat this with dairy, that's fine. שעתיד לעשות לבן או חמאה באורז מותר לבשל האורז בקדירה בשר בת יומא. Says Rabbi Yosef Karo, I took a pot, it's a fleishig pot, it's ben yomo, and it's clean. I'm
going to cook rice in there and later I am going to eat that rice with butter. Says Rav Ovadia, that is going to be okay. Even cooking it lechatchila to do it is going to be okay. That's what I mean.
But the Rema's lechatchila is that adding the cheese lechatchila? Yeah. No, or cooking, meaning is the lechatchila or the Rema says it's a problem is you when you decide to cook it in the fleishig pot or when you decide to
put the cheese on? So no, so the Rema says we don't do it. Rema says we don't do it. But I'm saying what where are we measuring? Oh, if you want to eat a pareve, no one's going to care. No,
no, I'm saying you cooked in the fleishig pot. That's fine. No, and then you want to add cheese on. That's the lechatchila. For the Rema, that's a problem still. For the Rema it's a problem. Yeah, yeah, yeah. Okay, so that's
how the Rav Ovadia paskins. If you look in, okay so let's go now to source number six to the Badai HaShulchan, Shagapo Cohen? 508? The great Sephardic that he put out all on Yoreh Deah. So he says the following. He
says the opinion of the Rema, he quotes the Gra. Ube'er HaGra da'ato. This we're going to see a machlokes here, a very, very fundamental machlokes right now, the Gra in this source and the Chachmat Adam in the next source. Okay.
So by the opinion of the Rema, which we just said we don't do this, we don't cook there lechatchila, באר הגר''א דעתו דמותר אף לכתחילה. He quotes the Gra that says the Rema allows cooking pareve food in only an eino
ben yomo pot. Okay? That's okay lechatchila. That means that if I have a pot over twenty-four hours and I want to use it, that would be okay lechatchila. ואף בקדירה אין אסור לכתחילה שאינו בן יומא אלא משום גזירה אטו בן
יומא. Okay, so okay, a gezeira atu. We have this concept a lot of times, we have a gezeira atu, which means we're doing this because we don't want you to come to do something else, right? We don't want you to
come to cook in a ben yomo and therefore we asser in eino ben yomo. But an eino ben yomo by itself is not really going to be a problem. But he continues מה שאין כן כאן. However, דאף בן יומו מותר
מדינא כנזכר לעיל. However, a ben yomo pot really he says should be allowed if you cooked pareve. Meaning Chazal are concerned that I might come to use a ben yomo pot. You're not going to cook in it? So what the
Gra is saying is that even if I cook pareve... I cooked pareve in a dairy Ben yomo pot. Okay, I cooked pareve in a dairy Ben yomo pot, the Rama really holds that that's okay. Okay, if I cooked dairy in
a pareve Ben yomo pot, that would be okay to eat it with something else because that's really how he holds. And he continues and he says in the underline: חזינן דבדיעבד מותר בזה רק לכתחילה נוהגים להחמיר. This whole thing that
we just mentioned that on lechatchila we're machmir, אין חומרא זו אלא בבן יומו. That's when it comes to a Ben yomo. אבל באינו בן יומו הדרינן לעיקר הדין דנת בר נת שרי אף בישול לכתחילה באינו בן יומו מותר אף לכתחילה.
What the Gra holds is that the whole this whole thing is only about a Ben yomo. I don't want you to use a Ben yomo and therefore we're going to be machmir. But if I use an eino Ben yomo even
with intention to do it with the other food, the Rama would say not a problem. So if I had an eino Ben yomo pot and I cooked spaghetti in that eino Ben yomo pot, it doesn't matter. I cook fish, doesn't
matter. Even lechatchila if I called it a fleishig eino Ben yomo pot, that means I made meatballs thirty-six hours ago, I take it out tonight, I make fish and I know I'm going to eat that fish with dairy, the Rama
according to the Gra says it's not a problem. The Chazal were not machmir about that, that's not gezeira atu, we're only gezeira atu a Ben yomo. Okay, the Chachmas Adam argues. Chachmas Adam argues and he says the Rama only allows
eating fish with dairy if it was already cooked in an eino Ben yomo pot, but not lechatchila. And he says: אם היה הכלי שנתבשל בו אינו בן יומו. If I have a kli that I cooked in that was an eino
Ben yomo, okay, מותר לאכלו בחלב אפילו לדידן אבל אסור לכתחילה. Says the Chachmas Adam, I can't do it lechatchila, לבשל בכלי שאינו בן יומו כדי לאכלו בחלב, okay, because that's assur lechatchila. The noten ta'am lifgam assur lechatchila. What does that
mean? Means like this: so this is a very, very fundamental machlokes, Gra and Chachmas Adam. If we follow the Gra we'd be in a better spot, but we actually don't in this situation, we follow the Chachmas Adam. The Chachmas Adam
says again if I took an eino Ben yomo fleishig pot and I made fish and then by accident I mixed milk into it, totally fine. The Chachmas Adam says but to take an eino Ben yomo fleishig pot, cook spaghetti in
there with the intention that I'm going to melt cheese onto those spaghetti noodles, says the Chachmas Adam, that's assur. Why? Because even though you're going to throw at me noten ta'am lifgam, that's all good and dandy if it was by
accident. But this is lechatchila. We don't do it lechatchila. I don't utilize anything lechatchila when it's an issur. So says the Chachmas Adam, we are therefore machmir. Most of the modern day poskim including Rav Elyashiv and including if you look
in the kashrus books, follow this Chachmas Adam. So therefore, you can't really have one pot in your house. Because that one pot is always going to be an eino Ben yomo of something. Lechatchila... bediavad it would be okay. Or maybe
bediavad means I only have one pot, but to rely that I'm going to use it to make pasta to eat with cheese when it was fleishig thirty-six hours ago, that we're machmir about. Okay. But the Chachmas Adam's whole point is
saying for lechatchila here is still to say eino Ben yomo. It's to cook it with intention to use. Correct. Add cheese if you... No, you could cooking's never a problem. No no no, I'm saying there's diff... No, one second. But
if I have a thirty-six hour pot, okay? I'm gonna make... it was fleishig yesterday morning. Tonight, I'm gonna make spaghetti in this pot and I know that afterwards I'm gonna put cheese in. Right, that's lechatchila for sure. Right, but I
can make spaghetti in that pot, it's not a problem. No but if I already... let's say I make spaghetti in this eino Ben yomo pot yesterday and today I decide I want to put cheese on. Is that lechatchila or bediavad?
So that seems to be okay, correct. Meaning, if I... now you can't you can't harama it, yeah yeah. I don't know what I want to make it for and your whole fridge is full of cheese. Yeah yeah, correct, correct. Doesn't...
I don't have to know my intention but as long as my intention is not to do that thing, so long that that would be okay. Now if a person's like, well I didn't really know what I wanted yesterday. Right. Okay,
but that's the point because you're not creating an issur. Right. You're cooking pareve pasta. That's fine. But if your intention was that I'm going to cook it and then put cheese to it so it's a problem. They have in the
in the notes I'll send that later a whole chart of everything that you can go over and you can review, it's really wonderful and amazing for... you can look at that on your own. Okay. So a few examples. You go
to source number eight. Okay. So we just mentioned the Rema paskens that parve food in an eino ben yomo pot could be eaten with fleishig. There's a machlokes could I do it lechatchila? So they quote here something very fascinating. So
in many many kosher ice cream places, they make both lines of parve and dairy, they're not necessarily like, they could be on the same line. So you look in Dayan Weiss, the Minchas Yitzchak, they're making parve ice cream in eino
ben yomo dairy utensils. Okay? It's an eino ben yomo dairy pot and they're calling that ice cream parve. So Dayan Weiss, Dayan Weiss was one of the great great poskim in Eretz Yisrael, was the dayan of the Edah Hachareidis and
the Bedatz, massive massive talmid chacham. So it says Dayan Weiss: מה שנשאלתי בענין גלידה פרוה שנעשה שביום שלפניו נעשה באותו כלי גלידה חלבי yesterday or it just means eino ben yomo, it was in a milchig pot. ואוכלים אותה עם בשר.
Now, did they really eat it with meat? Not but they're calling it parve. If I call something parve, I could eat it with meat. והעליתי שם לאסור לעשות כן לכתחילה. And I thought that this should be assur, right? Because when
you label it parve, that's implying that if something is parve, it could be eaten with parve or meat or dairy, 'cause it's parve. He's- he don't hold anything yet. וכתבתי לדחות הצד להיתר. So he says ובנידון דהוי נט בר נט
כתבתי וזה הלשון אחר מעת לעת אבד כחו יפה ונותן טעם לפגם מכל מקום יש להחמיר לכתחילה. How- it doesn't matter. Even if you clean it well, that- that we should be machmir. The Rema does not really allow us to do
that. If you go to the next source though- There's no cooking involved. Right, there's no- there's no heat involved in making ice cream. So how is it right or wrong? There's cold. Right, it's all cold. It's all cold ingredients. I
have no idea. I'm just going to trust Dayan Weiss. I don't- Okay, so in other words he's- I get it, I don't know. I don't know. I don't know. In other words, he's holding that that should be labeled not parve
but dairy equipment. We're not at dairy equipment yet. Not dairy equipment. Hold on. He's saying that you can't use- that's a good question, I don't know. I'd have to find that. But the Ohel Yaakov here, they quote the following: that
actually don't because what do most people make- make ice cream for? Dessert. Dessert is not usually, even if you're a big meat guy, you don't have meat for dessert. So when you make it, says the Ohel Yaakov, גלידה נאכלת ברוב
העולם לקינוח for dessert, שהיו אוכלים לבד ולכן כשבעלת הבית עושה גלידה נעשה על דעת they're not making it like, no, they're making it for parve and therefore everything is going to be okay. This leads us to a very common shaila
in source number ten. If I baked a parve cake, okay, a chocolate cake for dessert in an eino ben yomo fleishig pan. This is a very common shaila. I didn't, right? Most people will have parve dishes or parve baking sheets,
but I didn't use it. I used a fleishig eino ben yomo fleishig pan. And now, so again, I had meatballs, I made in my pot, Wednesday morning. Wednesday morning I made meatballs. Thursday night I make a chocolate cake. I have
that chocolate cake, I finish Shabbos and now it's Sunday morning and I have a coffee and I want to know, could I eat that cake some of that cake with the coffee? To not real coffee because we're talking about milchig
coffee here with cream, like normal people. Good. Let's get back to that zman. Okay. Says the Megillas Sefer the following: וכן נראה שמותר לבשל שוקולד וכיוצא בזה בסיר בשרי שאינו בן יומו כדי לעשותם בעוגה אף שאוכלים עם כוס קפה שיש
בו חלב. That would be okay. Why would that be okay? shelo naaseh and Jules, this gets back to your point, להדיא רק בשביל זה. This goes even further. When I made my chocolate cake, unless you really made it, I'm going
to make this for Sunday morning, if you want a piece of it on Shabbos go ahead but that's my- that's my coffee cake. You're making it dessert for Shabbos. That's your intention. You don't have to start like figuring out every
scenario and every like- you made it for Shabbos, dessert for Shabbos. If you end up wanting it on Sunday morning, okay, so that's Sunday morning and therefore it would be okay. This leads us to the whole discussion about DE and
things like that. I'm going to leave it to you, you can read it partially in the notes. But I'm going to skip it 'cause you can read it for you but I do want to point one thing out and we'll-
we'll end with this. A very common... A very common misconception when it comes to DE and these kind of things which, okay, the OU stopped doing DE a long time ago. Okay? Either it got confusing, Kashrus organizations, they, I'm sorry,
the companies didn't like it, they wanted it to be uniform and what was actually on like, they didn't like it. DE or not DE. Still used for a few things. So all of that, all of that, all of that. Let
me just give me this, we'll do Ma'ariv and then everybody, we could talk afterwards. There are certain things that like, like Oreos, there are certain things that are, you know, DE, should always check back with the OU. I know somebody
who's like always so nervous because the OU says you should check back in and every like six months he's always like, I don't know, maybe they changed it again, so he wouldn't eat them. Like Oreos are DE and things like
that, right? There are certain things that you can look at the ingredients and you can say, oh, there's no, there's no milk in there. Bederech klal, that is not a way. There are certain things, I think if there's no like,
no concern of allergy for milk. Looking at ingredients, I tell my students all the time, looking at ingredients does you nothing because what we require as what makes something milchig or not is not only the line in which it was
produced and the heat and the ben yomo and eino ben yomo. There are certain things that the FDA says that is so little milk you don't have to call that dairy. We don't consider that so little milk. So sometimes a
product might say contains dairy, it's dairy-free. It's not what we, and it says OUD. So some people are like, ah, there's no way it's OUD, I looked in the ingredients, there must be DE. It's not DE. Sometimes, sometimes things are
DE, you've got to call the OU because email Webby Rabbi, Rabbi Webby at ou.org. And sometimes, I mentioned this last month, there were these, there are parve ice cream brands that have OUD. Talenti was one of them. It says OUD,
but it says dairy-free. People were mamash eating it after, after Shabbos meals. It's mamash milchig. It has milk in it. Ah, it says dairy-free? Yeah, because the FDA says that so little milk you don't require it, but that doesn't mean,
forgetting ben yomo and eino ben yomo, it doesn't necessarily mean that something's always dairy-free. We'll pick it up again next week.
1. What is the core principle of נ"ט בר נ"ט (nat bar nat)?
2. According to the S"A (Siman 95, Seif 1), parve pasta cooked in a clean fleishig ben-yomo pot:
3. The Rama rules: if dairy was already added to parve food that was cooked in a ben-yomo fleishig pot, the food is:
4. What does the kosher symbol "DE" (Dairy Equipment) signify?
5. The Minchas Yitzchak (Dayan Weiss) ruled regarding parve ice cream made in eino ben-yomo dairy equipment and labeled "parve":