1
00:00:00,000 --> 00:00:29,999
We're finishing up <i>Tzadi Hei</i> about <i>Nosen Ta'am Lifgam</i>. Okay, so we touched about it a few times. We talked about the soaps and things like that, <i>Nosen Ta'am Lifgam</i>, not being <i>Nosen Ta'am Lifgam</i> necessarily <i>lechatchila</i>. Okay, if you look in the <i>Shulchan Aruch</i> in <i>Tzadi Hei Dalet</i>, if you look in the <i>Shulchan Aruch Tzadi Hei Dalet</i>, I'm going to try to go fast and see if we can get through the end of <i>Tzadi Hei</i>. If not, we'll have to wrap it up next week. It's some straightforward

2
00:00:30,000 --> 00:00:59,999
stuff. Okay, so the <i>Shulchan Aruch</i> says in <i>Tzadi Hei Dalet</i>, <i>Yeira Li</i>, which is always an interesting thing when the <i>Shulchan Aruch</i> says ירא לי שנתן אפר במים if a person puts ash into the vat of water, במים חמין שביורה קודם שהניח הקדרות בתוכו before he puts anything in, אף על פי שהשומן דבוק בהן even if, so he puts ash into a vat of

3
00:01:00,000 --> 00:01:29,999
water before washing let's say dirty <i>milchig</i> and <i>fleishig</i> dishes together, even if there's stuff on top, <i>mutar</i> says the <i>Shulchan Aruch</i>, that would be <i>mutar</i>, דעל ידי האפר הוי נותן טעם לפגם. The ash is <i>Nosen Ta'am Lifgam</i> so I put something in that is some kind of, you know, of, okay, some kind of detergent and it makes it bad so it's <i>lifgam</i> and everything would be <i>mutar</i> even if there was stuff on top of the

4
00:01:30,000 --> 00:02:00,999
plates. Why... why... hold on one second, one second, one second, let me just let's get through a little bit. If you go to the <i>Shach</i>, so the <i>Shach</i> says where in the world did you get this from? This is not a <i>Gemara</i>, there's not a <i>Gemara</i> in <i>Chulin</i>, there's not a <i>Gemara</i> anywhere. Where did you get this from? So the <i>Shach</i> in <i>Sif</i>... this is why by the way now you have to realize that the <i>Shach</i>, the <i>Shach</i> does not live that much after the <i>Shulchan Aruch</i>. The <i>Shulchan Aruch</i> is the 14th, the 1500s. The <i>Shach</i> is the 1500s. The <i>Shach</i>, you know, is 1600s,

5
00:02:01,000 --> 00:02:30,999
I'm sorry. The <i>Shach</i> is not רב שלמה זלמן אויערבאך in the 2000s or the 1900s, but nonetheless the <i>Shach</i>, his level that he would argue with the <i>Shulchan Aruch</i> because he was that level. Rabbi <i>Kinach</i> would tell us that there are certain <i>Gedolim</i>, certain <i>Acharonim</i> that could argue with <i>Rishonim</i>, <i>Akiva Eiger</i>, the <i>Shach</i>, certainly things like that. So if you look in the <i>Shach</i>, the <i>Shach</i> says where's this come from? Where's it come from? Says דין זה לא נמצא בשום פוסק. Okay, this is not found anywhere. ולא שום אחד מהאחרונים הזכירו גם

6
00:02:31,000 --> 00:03:01,999
בבית יוסף לא הזכירו, not only that, you <i>Shulchan Aruch</i> didn't mention this in the <i>Beis Yosef</i>. So not only that, he goes through, if you go to the next line, he quotes a <i>Tosafos</i> that not only that, but there's a <i>Tosafos</i> in <i>Chulin</i> that seems to go against this <i>Gemara</i>, that essentially it goes against this <i>Gemara</i> because he quotes a <i>Tosafos</i> and he quotes a <i>Rosh</i>, we'll say it outside, but והרא\"ש ופירוש רבינו אפרים דאמרינן דנתעסקו בו אלא רק בשר וחלב הניחו מה שצוותה התורה

7
00:03:02,000 --> 00:03:31,999
להגעיל כלי מדין. We know that in <i>Parshas Matos</i> we learn about all the ideas of <i>hagala</i>. So the <i>Tosafos</i>, the <i>Gemara</i> says היכי הכשירו יורה גדולה, I'm sorry, the <i>Shach</i>, היכי הכשירו יורה גדולה, one second, says the <i>Shach</i>. Whenever <i>hagala</i> is needed, so <i>hagala</i> performed on a, right? We perform <i>hagala</i>, everything seems to be clean. <i>Tosafos</i> says how

8
00:03:32,000 --> 00:04:01,999
could <i>hagala</i> ever be effective? Why? He says היכי הכשירו יורה גדולה והלא המים שישם כנגד והמים נותנים טעם פירוש הניחו כי לא נעשו המים כולו נבילה. What happens? You could only perform <i>hagala</i> on <i>keilim</i> that did not have <i>shishim</i> in them. Meaning, anytime I put hot water in a <i>kli</i> to do <i>hagala</i>, it re-awakens anything that was inside there. So it would always be a problem. So, says the

9
00:04:02,000 --> 00:04:31,999
<i>Tosafos</i>, if you keep reading, if you look up this <i>Tosafos</i> in <i>Chulin</i>, so <i>Tosafos</i> says that it must be that they were only, that if the <i>kli</i> was large enough, there wasn't <i>shishim</i> that it would be okay. So the <i>Shach</i> says at the last line ואם איתא הלא התורה לא בא ללמוד אלא להגעיל כל אחד כדינו ומשום מים יוסר היאך תקנת הדבר. All they had to do in <i>Klei Midyan</i> was to do what? Throw some ash in. The Torah never mentions this idea.

10
00:04:32,000 --> 00:05:01,999
<i>Shach</i> says it can't be that this is a real thing. This is a real thing. <i>Tosafos</i> says, based on the <i>Shach</i>, that really you should be able to <i>kasher</i> large <i>ben yomo keilim</i>. That means they were used for <i>treifus</i> today and I throw something in there. Obviously we don't do that, and therefore this <i>halacha</i> is made up. So there are other <i>poskim</i> that agree with the <i>Shach</i>, that this <i>halacha</i> is not found anywhere. You're telling me that I could take a massive, a massive pot, I could throw soap in there, then I could put in <i>keilim</i> and put in milk and put in <i>fleishig</i>. It doesn't, it doesn't make sense, how could you do that? So that's what the <i>Shach</i>

11
00:05:02,000 --> 00:05:33,999
says. So the question is, who's right? <i>Shulchan Aruch</i> says it <i>meforash</i>. The <i>Shach</i> says it's not true. Hold on one second, hold on one second. No, no. <i>Yireh li</i> means you could do it. <i>Yireh li</i> doesn't mean like I think it's a good idea. <i>Yireh li</i> means you could do it. <i>Yireh li</i> probably means that it's not brought down anywhere, but I think you could do it. So when does he say <i>yireh li</i>? It's a very... it's a strange <i>lashon</i>. <i>Yireh li</i> usually comes from the fact that it's not a <i>meforash Gemara</i>, it's not a <i>meforash</i>. The <i>sevara</i> makes good sense. The <i>sevara</i> makes good sense. So now, if you look in the <i>Chacham Tzvi</i>, there's

12
00:05:34,000 --> 00:06:03,999
a... there's a <i>Taz</i>. There is a <i>Taz</i> in <i>se'if katan tet-vav</i>, we're not going to do... there is a <i>Taz</i> here that quotes a <i>Maharshal</i> that also says it's a problem. There is a <i>Gra</i> here. If you look in the <i>Be'ur HaGra</i>, right below the <i>Shach</i>, below the <i>Nekudas HaKesef</i>, there's a <i>Gra</i>. The <i>Gra</i> on <i>yireh li</i> says עיין ט\"ז וש\"ך שחולקים על זה. So the <i>Gra</i> also seems... the <i>Gra</i> is not like telling you, \"Hey, you should look at the <i>Shach</i>, and if you figure out the <i>Shach</i>, this is what he says.\" The <i>Gra</i>'s saying that because

13
00:06:04,000 --> 00:06:33,999
the <i>Gra</i> says that I hold like the <i>Shach</i> and <i>Taz</i>. Okay. So if you look in the <i>Chachmas Tzvi</i>... the <i>Chacham Tzvi</i>, depends on how you like to pronounce it. If you look in the <i>Chacham Tzvi</i>, the following: says מה שכתב הש\"ך דין זה לא נמצא בשום פוסק ואינו כלום ומה צורך לכתבו כמבואר בגמרא ובכל הפוסקים שכל נותן טעם לפגם מותר. He explains that what does it mean that no one ever <i>paskened</i> this way? דין זה

14
00:06:34,000 --> 00:07:03,999
לא נמצא בשום פוסק. That we know that that applies. We have this concept. What's that concept called? <i>Nosen ta'am l'fgam</i>. So it doesn't mean <i>nosen ta'am l'fgam</i> doesn't apply. What does the <i>Shach</i> mean that this <i>halacha</i> doesn't apply? The ash. Meaning, that's <i>yireh li</i>. <i>Yireh li</i>... so what's the <i>makor</i>? So he continues, and he explains that the <i>machlokes</i> really here is arguing is that

15
00:07:04,000 --> 00:07:33,999
the... he says ואפילו אינו פגום גדול דומיא דקדירה שאינה בת יומה שאינו פגום אלא מעט יותר מבת יומה. The <i>Gemara</i> says that after 24 hours, what happens with the taste? The absorbed flavor is <i>pagum</i>, and it can no longer forbid things. The <i>Shulchan Aruch</i> takes that <i>halacha</i> and he extrapolates that <i>halacha</i> and he says that's even true if it was a <i>ben yomo</i>. Because I know that <i>eino ben yomo</i> works and after 24 hours something becomes <i>pagum</i> and it becomes bad. So therefore, <i>yireh li</i> that if I could take a <i>ben yomo kli</i>,

16
00:07:34,000 --> 00:08:04,999
I could throw ash inside and poof, I got a situation of <i>ta'am l'fgam</i>. I don't care that there's <i>ta'am</i> in the walls of the pot because when the <i>ta'am</i> comes out from the walls of the pot, it has a fight with ash and everybody, everybody should be okay. Okay? So hold on one second. And therefore, don't bring me this whole <i>Tosafos</i> because even <i>Tosafos</i> would agree that you can <i>kasher</i> <i>ben yomo</i> by being <i>pogem</i> the pot. <i>Tosafos</i>, in fact, if you look at the end of the <i>Chachmas Tzvi</i>,

17
00:08:05,000 --> 00:08:34,999
he says all <i>Tosafos</i> was saying... don't bring me a <i>raya</i> from <i>Tosafos</i> that <i>Tosafos</i> doesn't bring this issue what they did in the <i>midbar</i> in against Midian. Why? <i>Tosafos</i> was quoting you one thing that they did. That doesn't mean you couldn't do other things. It wasn't an exhaustive list. <i>Tosafos</i> wasn't telling you all the ways to <i>kasher</i> the <i>kelim</i>. <i>Tosafos</i> was saying when you have big pots it wouldn't work אלא חדא מתרתי או תלת נקט. <i>Tosafos</i> was presenting one method of <i>kashering kelim</i>, that smaller <i>kelim</i> and things like that, but there'd be no reason,

18
00:08:35,000 --> 00:09:06,999
says the <i>Chachmas Tzvi</i>, that you would not be able to <i>kasher</i> a <i>kli</i> by putting in <i>afar</i>. Now, the <i>Chazon Ish</i> in source 54... so that's the <i>Chachmas Tzvi</i> that seems to say that the <i>Shach</i> is actually not arguing... the <i>Shach</i> is not arguing against the <i>Shulchan Aruch</i>, they're really just arguing on ash. Okay? Okay. So if you look in source 54 in the <i>Chazon Ish</i>. Says the <i>Chazon Ish</i>: מהוכיח הש\"ך שאין העפר פוגם את המים. When you told... when you

19
00:09:07,000 --> 00:09:37,999
mentioned that they agree that, you know, it's... that it's <i>pogem</i> the water... that the <i>afar</i>'s not <i>pogem</i> the water אלא מים נעכרים בעירוב העפר. That's when the adding substances are genuinely <i>pogem</i> something. But they disagree really just about ash. They're just arguing about ash. ומה היש בדורותינו מיני חמצן. But today when we have real bleach and things that are <i>mamash pogem</i>, they're not arguing. They would agree.

20
00:09:38,000 --> 00:10:07,999
They would agree if I threw in something that's very, very bad. Why... what's the issue with ash? Why would ash be different? It's not bad enough. It's not bad enough. And he says potentially also the ash floats to the top, it's not as <i>me'urav</i> and everything. Okay, so they're arguing about ash itself but they're not really arguing... Maybe that's what they used back in those days. Is the...

21
00:10:08,000 --> 00:10:37,999
Correct, right. So they're arguing whether or not that works or not. That's what the <i>Chazon Ish</i> says. Okay. So the <i>l'maise</i> we should never really what what should we do? So if you look in source fifty-five, if you look in source fifty-five, okay, all we should really do today when you call the rabbi and you say, \"Rabbi, was this did I kosher did I <i>traif</i> up this pot?\" The rabbi says \"yes\" because we get a kickback from the <i>hagala</i>, okay. Why do we need all of this? Why do we need all

22
00:10:38,000 --> 00:11:09,999
of this? What should I do? Put in soap. Put in just take take a plate, pour some bleach on top of it, <i>shain</i>, everything's good, we're good to go, okay. So the <i>Badei Hashulchan</i> in source fifty-five says the following: אבל אם לא נתן האפר במים אלא אחר שנתן בו הקדירה that the leniency of <i>nosein taam lifgam</i> is only when the <i>pogem</i> substance is added before.

23
00:11:10,000 --> 00:11:39,999
שנתן בו אחר שכבר נבלע בשר בחלב בדופני הכלים לא מהני אפר לפגום מה שבלוע בכלי That only works if I add the thing in and then what? That things get mixed together. But once the forbidden flavor has been absorbed, adding bleach isn't going to do anything, right? Adding bleach won't do anything. So <i>l'maise</i>, potentially you could fill up a massive vat, huge pot, dump tons of bleach in, and wash your <i>milchig</i> and <i>flaishig</i> dishes together, okay. If you... What? Well so this means you cannot

24
00:11:40,000 --> 00:12:10,999
have you cannot just have one dishwasher. Oh, hold on wait wait we're not at dishwashers yet, hold on a second, hold on a second. So now if you go to one more source on this topic, if you go to source fifty-six, <i>l'maise</i> how do we <i>pasken</i>? So in the end we seem to we don't really know that ash will ruin it, but in source fifty-six the <i>Chachmas Adam</i> says כל זה שכתבנו בהדחה שעושה דוקא במדיח מים נקיים אבל נתנו אפר במים חמים but he

25
00:12:11,000 --> 00:12:40,999
says if you put it in hot water, קודם שידיח הכלים אף על פי שהשומן דבוק מותר דהאפר נותן טעם לפגם the <i>Chachmas Adam</i> seems to <i>pasken</i> that it would be good to go. I can throw things I can throw some kind of bad detergent in, some kind of bleach in, wash all my <i>keilim</i> and everything should be fine. The the <i>Badei Hashulchan</i> though, I'm sorry, yes, in source fifty-seven, that you really shouldn't just <i>lechatchila</i>. והני מילי בדיעבד שכבר נתנו

26
00:12:41,000 --> 00:13:10,999
הקדירות בתוכו אבל לכתחילה אין להניח במים דלכתחילה נגמר ההיתר דנותן טעם לפגם You have to realize that to do this is essentially saying that I'm relying <i>lechatchila</i> <i>nosein taam lifgam</i>, that I'm throwing in tons of bleach, I'm putting <i>milchig</i> dishes and <i>flaishig</i> dishes while it might be okay <i>bidieved</i> it would not be the best idea <i>lechatchila</i> and therefore that is really how we <i>pasken</i>. So if you take one takeaway from tonight it should not be that you go home and say we don't need dishwashers, we can throw tons of bleach and put everything together. We're going to talk about soon in a second dishwashers

27
00:13:11,000 --> 00:13:41,999
where <i>Rav Ovadia</i> is like wildly lenient on things, but don't worry, <i>Ashkenazim</i> we got it, we got it, we got it. Yeah. What about the <i>Badei Hashulchan</i>? Yeah. And he doesn't like putting in <i>efer</i> once it's already mixed in. But why? If I put whatever <i>pogem</i> substance, bleach, soap, whatever it is, into the pot and then I boil the water with that, why wouldn't that draw out whatever <i>taam</i> that's in the walls of the pot, mix that, make it <i>pogum</i>, whatever goes back in

28
00:13:42,000 --> 00:14:11,999
is <i>pogum</i>? I lost you Jules halfway through. One more time? Sorry. Okay, the <i>Badei Hashulchan</i> says that if it's already mixed in the walls of the pot... One second. A bleach is not <i>mivla</i> from the walls of the pot. No, no, no, I'm saying. That's what... So when if I make a if I have a <i>traif</i> pot, I <i>traifed</i> it up, meatballs. Fine. It's <i>mamash</i> <i>traif</i>. <i>Mamash</i> <i>traif</i>. The <i>Badei Hashulchan</i> says if you put the <i>pogum</i> stuff in, you're not doing anything. Correct.

29
00:14:12,000 --> 00:14:41,999
According to the <i>Badei Hashulchan</i>, what if I put a bunch of <i>pogum</i> stuff in and boil the water, whatever that stuff, together? Why doesn't that why doesn't that go into the walls of the pot and counteract the stuff that's in the pot? No, I'm saying, it seems to me it would either draw it out like a reverse a reverse <i>hagala</i>. Well, it's I'm saying it's part of that. Like if you do that first, it would seem to make it <i>pogum</i>. That sounds super <i>bidieved</i>. I can say it wasn't <i>bidieved</i>, I'm saying even according to the <i>Badei Hashulchan</i>... One second, that's how we kosher in general though, why are you making it so complicated? That's

30
00:14:42,000 --> 00:15:11,999
how we kosher. Of course, but it's not a <i>ben yomo</i>. I'm saying why wouldn't it... Oh, a <i>ben yomo</i>. Well on a <i>ben yomo</i>, boiling it with something <i>pogum</i> in it, I don't know, it seems to make everything <i>pogum</i> in the walls of the pot even if you like the <i>Badei Hashulchan</i>. No, correct, no, you're yeah, you've dealt with a different you've dealt with a different <i>shaila</i>. One second, it's different it's different if... But it’s going to make it all <i>pogum</i>, isn’t that the point? Why we wait, it’s going to

31
00:15:12,000 --> 00:15:41,999
make it all <i>pogum</i>, but I first of all it would be אין מבטלין איסור לכתחילה because it’s real <i>traifus</i>. Here with milk or meat, it’s <i>chad b’heteira</i> and <i>chad b’heteira</i>, but <i>traifus</i> in the pot is אין מבטלין איסור לכתחילה because it’s an <i>issur</i> inside the pot. The question is if it’s because if it’s <i>traifus</i> and it’s an <i>issur</i>, then an <i>issur</i> you couldn’t you couldn’t do this. You wait <i>ad de’pugal</i> because then it’s not there’s no <i>ta’am</i> anymore, because then it’s <i>pugal</i>. No, you still have to <i>kasher</i> it. Right, I’m saying that’s...

32
00:15:42,000 --> 00:16:11,999
right, I’m saying you don’t have to <i>kasher</i> it, I’m saying I just don’t know I don’t know that you’d be able to, I don’t know, I don’t know, I’d have to think about it. Okay, I’m going to skip source 28, there’s a <i>Shevet HaLevi</i> about these different steam-jacketed kettles that I’m sure you can look in the notes and find all about later, it’s very fascinating, but let’s go to dishwashers. Okay. So very very common <i>shaila</i> regarding <i>basar b’chalav</i> and <i>kashrus</i> and things like that is dishwashers. So if you really want, they give

33
00:16:12,000 --> 00:16:43,999
you a whole description in the notes about how dishwashers work, you know, you could also just plug in a GoPro and then from the inside of your own dishwasher. They also give you a video you can watch. There’s lots of good things. So what’s the <i>shaila</i> with the dishwasher? So is the dishwasher like your big vat of water in that what can I do? I could well let’s go opposite extremes. Could I put <i>milchigs</i> and <i>fleishigs</i> in there together because why?

34
00:16:44,000 --> 00:17:13,999
Because it’s not <i>mevatel issur lechatchila</i> because there’s no <i>issur</i>. Do can we can we do that? Is the water that comes out first, is it cold, is it hot? What happens if there’s leftover food, if there’s not leftover food? We’re not going to talk here tonight about how well you clean off your dishes before you load the dishwasher, but that also might be something we’re going to mention. So let’s go to source 59, okay? It’s me or is it very hot in here? It’s me. It’s hot in here. Do we need

35
00:17:14,000 --> 00:17:43,999
to does that work we have to like call Captain Z? Okay, fine. <i>Veiter</i>. Source 59, the <i>Avnei Yashpei</i> Rabbi Feinhandler says the following about a dishwasher. So he <i>paskens</i> that it’s <i>assur</i> to use a dishwasher for meat and then dairy. Okay, we’re not even talking about together, which we’ll talk about in a little bit. That for sure not together, but I cannot do <i>milchigs</i>, wait, and then do <i>fleishigs</i>. Why? ונראה פשוט שאם יש בהן ואינו בטל בשישים, if there’s <i>mammash</i>

36
00:17:44,000 --> 00:18:13,999
food on there, הרי דאף נותן לו טעם. Everything is going to stick. כגון שכח בהן ונמצא שמדיח ומסיר חלבי that if it washed off my mac and cheese, ומבשל בו בשר אחר כך. That’s a problem. נמצא שהכלים והדפנות בלועים בשר וחלב. So if I did <i>fleishig</i> wash and I get meatballs in the walls of the pot, then I do my mac and cheese in there and then noodles and cheese went in there, now what do I have in the walls of the pot?

37
00:18:14,000 --> 00:18:44,999
Now I have an <i>issur</i>. And then if I add more dishes later, I <i>traif</i> up all those dishes. Okay. So the <i>Avnei Yashpei</i> says that not only can you not do them together but for sure you can’t even do them one after the other. So if I ran a, you know, <i>assur</i> if I ran a <i>fleishig</i> wash and there’s no <i>shishim</i>, the dishwasher is going to be <i>fleishig</i>. He says <i>emes</i>. ממש רק מסוג אחר יש איסור כגון שממש של בשר בכלים שהדיח, if I washed off the meat <i>keilim</i>, and <i>lo haya shishim</i>, but there wasn't <i>shishim</i>,

38
00:18:45,000 --> 00:19:14,999
there wasn't enough water to get all the food that I left on my plate, ושוב הדיח כלים חלביים נקיים and then I do <i>ben yomo</i> <i>keilim</i> after that. <i>Ha-keilim v’ha-defanos</i>, everything is <i>assur</i> <i>mishum basar b’chalav</i>. That’s <i>mammash</i> <i>meforash</i> <i>lashon ha-Shulchan Aruch</i> like the plate כקערה של בשר שהדיחה ביורה חלבית מותר. Okay, and he quotes the <i>Rama</i> that this is <i>assur</i>. We know the <i>Rama</i> forbids doing this, placing clean dairy dishes, right, clean dairy dishes in a <i>fleishig</i> pot with water.

39
00:19:15,000 --> 00:19:44,999
Okay. If you go to the end, he says <i>v’chen l’ma’aseh</i>, so he concludes, לא נראה להתיר להשתמש במדיח אחד לבשרי ולחלבי. You cannot use it one for the other, it would be a problem, and therefore it would be <i>assur</i>. Okay. Fine, that is the consensus of many many <i>poskim</i>. In comes <i>Rav Moshe</i>. Is there some way to <i>kasher</i> a dishwasher? Ah, right. <i>Kashering</i> a dishwasher we’re going to talk about in a little bit. <i>Kashering</i> a dishwasher is a <i>kashering</i> <i>shaila</i>. You find different <i>kashrus</i> organizations have different opinions

40
00:19:45,000 --> 00:20:15,999
about it. The general first of all not for <i>Pesach</i> because it’s almost impossible. There is there is like usually what happens if people move into a new place, if you can get new racks, if you get new if it’s metal inside you run it... once, but you should get new racks. If the racks are <i>mamish</i> new and they're metal, you can <i>kasher</i> them, but if not, you should try to get new racks. Okay. Are there other questions? There are times we allow, the OU allows <i>kashering</i> of the dishwashers, the CRC, there are times you have to be <i>meikel</i> because people they might need

41
00:20:16,000 --> 00:20:49,999
it. But we try like it's not like you can use it Monday for <i>milchigs</i>, run it Tuesday and use it for <i>fleishigs</i> for Wednesday. But in comes <i>Rav Moshe</i>. <i>Rav Moshe

42
00:20:50,000 --> 00:21:20,999
paskins</i>, no, you actually can use it for both. ודבר החדש לרחוץ את הכלים שנקרא בשם dishwasher אם יכול לרחוץ כלי בשר וכלי חלב זה אחר זה הנה צריך שמה שמניחים הכלים

43
00:21:21,000 --> 00:21:50,999
שהוא לכלי בשר אחרים לכלי חלב אחרים. Says <i>Rav Moshe</i>, you can use the same dishwasher as long as you have separate racks. אבל לא כתבתי שם הטעם <i>pashut</i>, says <i>Rav Moshe</i>, I didn't really give the explanation over there in a different <i>teshuva</i> in חלק ד' יורה דעה דבעצם נט בר נט מותר. This is ממש נט בר נט. He quotes the <i>Rama</i>: דאפילו באותן מים שהודחו בהן כלי בשר, the water that washed <i>fleishig kelim</i>,

44
00:21:51,000 --> 00:22:20,999
מותר להדיח גם כלי חלב. Why? Because it's <i>nat bar nat</i> and therefore, says <i>Rav Moshe</i>, that would be the same situation here. He says <i>vechol shekein bekan</i>. Not only that, it's even better. You're telling me I washed my meat dishes Monday morning. Okay. So the water washed it off and maybe it was <i>nosein ta'am</i> into the walls of the dishwasher. Now I have new water... when it was the same water, the <i>Rama</i>'s

45
00:22:21,000 --> 00:22:50,999
<i>meikel</i>. Now I have new water and new racks, so <i>Rav Moshe</i> says we should be <i>meikel</i>. There is questions on this <i>Rav Moshe</i> in terms of, like, how long? Do you have to wait 24 hours? But let's finish it. אבל מה שהמצאתי שם שמה שמניח הכלים צריך שיהיו אחרים. Why do I need something else? Why do I need racks then? דמטעם שמצוי שישאר דבר בעין. If something actual was <i>mamashus</i>, was actual food, that's going to be a problem. Where is that food? That food is not on the walls

46
00:22:51,000 --> 00:23:20,999
of the dishwasher. Where is that food? It's on the racks. So the racks won't... if there's food, that's not going to help you. And therefore, says <i>Rav Moshe</i>, as long as you would have separate racks, it would potentially be okay. Now, you cannot use it if it was not kosher. If you <i>traifed</i> up or it was a non-kosher, that gets into the <i>kashering shaila</i>, because here though we're just talking about where I'm using it one for <i>milchigs</i> and one for <i>fleishigs</i>. What's the difference between being <i>traif</i>

47
00:23:21,000 --> 00:23:52,999
and <i>milchigs</i> and <i>fleishigs</i> together? Would be <i>traif</i> also. It's not <i>traif</i>. It's not <i>milchigs</i> and... first of all, he didn't say <i>milchigs</i> and <i>fleishigs together</i>. But I'm saying if you're talking about <i>traif</i>, we <i>kashered</i>, the CRC over the years in hotels uses dishwashers in the hotels that are <i>traif</i> by running them, running hot water, running with soap, then running another hot water through the dishwasher, <i>kashered</i> even <i>traif</i> ones. So that's why I'm questioning this. These

48
00:23:53,000 --> 00:24:22,999
are two separate things. You're talking about <i>kashering</i> a dishwasher. That we could talk about. <i>Rav Moshe</i> is saying if you have a non-kosher dishwasher, it doesn't work to just do this system of, like, if there's <i>traifus</i>. A non-kosher dishwasher, not <i>traifed</i> up dishwasher. Correct. <i>Kashering</i> dishwashers we could talk about. And he's saying they were <i>treif</i> because it's <i>nat bar nat</i> so you never have an actual <i>issur hana'ah</i>. Correct, correct. And that's why you need separate racks, because separate racks, the only time it would be a potential issue is when there's <i>mamashus</i>, that's only on the racks, that's not on the walls. How does it only go on the racks and not the walls? I don't get that. It all

49
00:24:23,000 --> 00:24:53,999
mixes, how is it only on the racks and not the walls? No, no, no, no. He's saying the <i>b'ayin</i>. The reason I want racks, says <i>Rav Moshe</i>, is because if there's <i>b'ayin</i>, you have a problem. <i>B'ayin</i> doesn't work in <i>nat bar</i>... <i>b'ayin</i> is not <i>nat bar nat</i>. <i>B'ayin</i> is <i>b'ayin</i>. So therefore, get new racks, so therefore you have no problem with that. But the food literally stays on the racks and doesn't mix up? You're saying once it gets to the walls, it's already like got soap in it? No, no, no, no. If there's food left there, then it's going to become a problem. For... it's

50
00:24:54,000 --> 00:25:26,999
<i>nosein ta'am lifgam</i>, then you're relying on lots of other <i>heterim</i>. Wait a second, one second, one second, one second. First of all, first of all, it's <i>Rav Moshe Feinstein</i>. So, okay, it's <i>Rav Moshe Feinstein</i>. They once brought <i>Rav Shlomo Zalman</i> ketchup and <i>Rav Shlomo Zalman paskened</i> a certain thing about ketchup because they brought him the wrong ketchup. This is <i>Rav Moshe's pasken</i> 50, 60 years ago about

51
00:25:27,000 --> 00:25:56,999
dishwashers. Dishwashers have advanced, they've changed. <i>Rav Moshe's psak</i> in <i>Chelek Alef</i> of <i>Orach Chaim</i> and <i>Chelek Beis</i> of <i>Yoreh Deah</i> is you can use the dishwasher but you need separate racks. Why? Because he felt that

52
00:25:57,000 --> 00:26:26,999
there is still <i>be'ein</i> left there. Even if there is not, it's a dangerous precedent to set. The only time that food might be left is on- I don't know about you, I've seen food in my dishwasher. Maybe I don't have a very good dishwasher. That's fine. You have a very- What? Are you saying that you're concerned that the food is absorbing directly from the walls? From a <i>pagam</i> standpoint? No, he's saying from a- I'm just confused about why- why separate racks and why not the walls or anything? He's concerned that the food, the food is sticking to the walls

53
00:26:27,000 --> 00:26:57,999
with the wash it runs and then the same thing gets to the walls. No, no, no. One second. That's not an issue though. That's not an issue because I'm not using it together. If I was- We're going to talk about <i>Rav Ovadia</i> in a second. That's not an issue because it's then later it's not <i>bar nat</i> still. I ran it once, there might be <i>be'ein</i> in the walls of the pot- but it's fine because when the walls of the dishwasher- and I wash it again and it brings out that's not <i>bar nat</i>. <i>Rav Moshe</i> says it's- You can't apply <i>nat bar nat</i> if there's actual <i>mamashut</i> there. So <i>mamashut</i> he feels would be on the racks so he says to get separate racks.

54
00:26:58,000 --> 00:27:27,999
Why is- Wait, why is the <i>be'ein</i> still the <i>be'ein</i>? Why is it not אינו ראוי לאכילת כלב? Why between the chemicals and the wash, don't you consider it food anymore? Because it was before the soap? First of all, you have to ask when it was <i>nivlah</i>. You don't know when it was <i>nivlah</i>. By the way, there's a <i>shaileh</i> in dishwashers. Some dishwashers they wash everything off in hot water first and then the soap comes out. So that's what we just said is a problem. We just said I can put <i>afar</i> in only beforehand. In most dishwashers, if you go inside, it's not what happens. Which is why

55
00:27:28,000 --> 00:27:58,999
we're going to see that a lot of <i>poskim</i> are not <i>meikel</i> like this <i>Rav Moshe</i>. Okay. So if you look in <i>Sefer</i>- we're definitely not going to finish that- if you look in Source 61 in the <i>Agur B'halacha</i>, he quotes about- it's a good discussion. He says that <i>Rav Moshe</i> today would say differently. במדיחי כלים יש מקומות שנדבק שם ממשות חמץ או בשר וחלב ואי אפשר לנקותו רק על ידי אומן. There are certain places that they might go back and use it. ואין להביא ראיה מדברי הגאון באגרות משה. He says you cannot bring a <i>raya</i> from <i>Rav Moshe Feinstein</i>. Why? כי ישנם מינים ממינים

56
00:27:59,000 --> 00:28:37,999
שונים ואולי באותו זמן לא היה חשש. This is a <i>mefurash raya</i> that you cannot <i>pasken</i> things just because you saw it in a <i>teshuva</i> of <i>Rav Moshe Feinstein</i>. Now I'm not saying <i>Rav Moshe</i>- we don't follow <i>Rav Moshe</i>, we are <i>meikel</i> like <i>Rav Moshe</i> sometimes, but sometimes a <i>teshuva</i> is what a <i>teshuva</i> is. It was written in whatever the generation, century was. You had to know what the situation was, all these different things. So says the <i>Agur B'halacha</i>, <i>Rav Moshe</i> would not allow it today, he would say <i>assur</i>. However, if you look in Source 62 in the <i>Sheilos u'Tshuvos</i> of the <i>Shavei Tzion</i> of הרב שמואל טוביה שטרן, he says the following. He says that no, actually he would allow a dishwasher for meat and

57
00:28:38,000 --> 00:29:07,999
then dairy, it doesn't matter, and you actually don't have to change the racks in between. And he explains. He says- and the underline- ונת בר נת כזה לא גרע ממה שמשום שאין המים עושים פליטות ובלעיות הללו ובפרט שהמים אינו ככלי ראשון. He says the water being sprayed out is an <i>iruy kli rishon</i>

58
00:29:08,000 --> 00:29:37,999
which can't really even remove anything from the walls of the thing. <i>Iruy kli rishon</i> isn't strong enough to take stuff out of the dishwasher and therefore he writes, לכן אני מסכים להתיר תשמיש מדיחי כלים הללו בזה אחר זה. So again, before we do one more, <i>Dvar Yehoshua</i> that says it's <i>assur</i> because it <i>boley</i> things. <i>Rav Moshe</i> says yes, but you do separate racks, I'm definitely okay with it because of <i>nat bar nat</i>. <i>Agur B'halacha</i> says though <i>Rav Moshe</i>

59
00:29:38,000 --> 00:30:07,999
would not have said that today, <i>Rav Moshe</i> would have been <i>machmir</i> today because there's just so much happening in the dishwasher, it's too dangerous. And <i>Shmuel Tuvia Stern</i> says, what are you talking about? The fact that the water comes out first and it's only <i>iruy kli rishon</i>, I'm not worried about anything. You don't need separate racks. You can't do it together, but you don't need separate racks. In comes <i>Rav Ovadia</i> and <i>Rav Ovadia</i> says don't worry <i>Sefardim</i>. Don't worry <i>Sefardim</i>, I got this. Okay? <i>Rav Ovadia</i> in the <i>Yabia Omer</i> says the following. By the way, this is why I, you

60
00:30:08,000 --> 00:30:38,999
know, you have to know how these things operate. Like for example, you know, whatever people do in their homes they do in their homes. But my <i>Mesora</i> from my Rebbe as much as I would like it not to be, is that not only do we not raise the oven on the <i>Yom Tov</i> on the <i>Shabbos</i> mode oven, but we do not use a warming drawer on <i>Shabbos</i> day. Okay? That's the <i>Mesora</i> I have from Rabbi Neuburger, in fact when he was by us for <i>Shabbos</i>, my wife tried once again. She said, just making sure nothing's changed Rebbe, and he said I

61
00:30:39,000 --> 00:31:08,999
don't think so. But his point to me was you have to know how every warming drawer works. Okay? Everything operates differently and like when you talk to <i>Poskim</i>, you can't just <i>Pasken</i>, you have to like look at things change. How soap gets dispensed, when the water gets dispensed, how hot is the water, all of these things are parts of this. So let's go <i>weiter</i> very fast so we can move on a little bit. We got some interesting examples. The <i>Yabia Omer</i> in source 63 says <i>Rav Ovadia</i> both in 63 says מסקנא דדינא

62
00:31:09,000 --> 00:31:38,999
יש להורות היתר מדיח כלים לכלי בשר וכלי חלב אפילו ביחד. Go ahead says <i>Rav Ovadia</i>. רק מהיות טוב היכא דאפשר להדיח כלי בשר לחוד וכלי חלב לחוד says <i>Rav Ovadia</i> it is better to use them separately but he would be okay if he used them together and he explains in source 64 in the <i>Yalkut Yosef</i> exactly what he said earlier that when the dishwasher spritzes out that water that's mixed with soap and then another it's all basically

63
00:31:39,000 --> 00:32:08,999
there's nothing there is not enough food in there that would possibly that would trip up anything. So therefore he said it's really we are going you know there's room to be <i>Meikel</i>. But even <i>Rav Ovadia</i>, even the <i>Sefardim</i> they don't really really rely they generally try to do at least one after the other they don't really do milk and meat together. If you really like never cleaned off your plate, you like took your your plate of macaroni and cheese and your plate of meatballs and you put it in there, <i>Rav Ovadia</i> is not <i>Meikel</i> on that. Okay? But if it was washed off, <i>Rav Ovadia</i> would be <i>Meikel</i>.

64
00:32:09,000 --> 00:32:40,999
But <i>lemaisa lemaisa</i> and he quotes that, you know, restaurants and things like that and hotels and things, that if the dishes don't have really large pieces it should be okay. All right. Aren't industrial dishwashers very different though than household ones? It could be, it could be. So you really have to you have to do each one. Okay. So, okay. <i>Lemaisa lemaisa</i> if you really do find like you know <i>Pareve</i> dishes and things like that and

65
00:32:41,000 --> 00:33:10,999
you know a <i>Pareve</i> fork and usually we're <i>Meikel</i> about it, usually <i>Meikel</i> about it because of the soap and the hot water. If you don't really need it, the general <i>Hakpada</i> is to try and do <i>Hagala</i> if you could. You don't have to wait till <i>Pesach</i>. You could take a boiling pot of water, dunk it in, take it right out, obviously not with your hand. What? You wait 24 hours but <i>velemaisa</i> okay fine. And the <i>He'arot</i> in the notes I'll just share with you and because we discussed it in the past and we'll move on to source

66
00:33:11,000 --> 00:33:40,999
65. That they quote here about the whole Dunkin Donuts Starbucks debate because this is where part of this gets played into it. And that we mentioned a while ago maybe a few weeks ago that when they wash everything together at Starbucks, so it's washed all of the things are washed together. So that includes the filters they're going to make your coffee with and that includes the thing they just made the ham and cheese sandwich with and they put it all in a bin and they wash it with boiling hot water and soap. So there that's the <i>Chumra</i>. And there's also a <i>Chazon Ish</i> that that's relied on that your

67
00:33:41,000 --> 00:34:11,999
coffee thing that they're now going to make coffee for you for, you know, and that's why some of the CRC recommendation is the only thing that you can get is what's like free-standing and they it only goes like tea goes straight from the urn to the so it comes back to this issue that at a Starbucks it's a non-kosher restaurant that they're potentially washing all those together. Those that are <i>Meikel</i> on it are <i>Meikel</i> because there's sources to be <i>Meikel</i> on these things because we're not as <i>Machmir</i> when it's, you know, soap and <i>Nosein Ta'am Lifgam</i> and <i>Nat bar Nat</i>. But that is where the <i>Chumra</i> comes

68
00:34:12,000 --> 00:34:41,999
in. As I mentioned they're not as <i>Machmir</i> when it comes to Dunkin Donuts because the dishes are not washed in such hot water. Okay. Gross but easier in <i>Halacha</i>. So anyway you can read it in the notes. It's interesting. If you really want to go down you can read all the CRC articles and Fishbane, all the different things but let's let's move on. Okay. Good we got a few minutes. Source 65. Source 65. Okay. So this is, you know, an interesting source for why we

69
00:34:42,000 --> 00:35:11,999
generally try to leave things on separate parts of our counter. Okay? Even if you don't have a <i>Milchig</i> side and a <i>Fleishig</i> side but that it shouldn't be put down on the same counters together comes from the following <i>Gemara</i>. So the <i>Gemara</i> in <i>Chulin</i> says the following. בעי מיניה רב דימי מרב נחמן מהו להניחי כדא דמילחא could I... If I could if I could take a salt and put it <i>Gabei Kadda De'Kamcha</i>, which is like this <i>kuthach</i>? So could I put a salt, a salt, straight up salt next to this <i>kuthach</i>, this dairy dish? Because some

70
00:35:12,000 --> 00:35:41,999
<i>kuthach</i> might fall in the salt, I might use that salt for meat and it might be a problem. So the <i>Gemara</i> says, <i>Assur</i>. Okay. The <i>Gemara</i> continues, <i>De'Chala Mai</i>? What about vinegar? Could I put <i>kuthach</i> next to vinegar? So the <i>Gemara</i> says, <i>Amar Lei Shari</i>. Yeah, you're okay. <i>U'mai Shna</i>? So why? So the <i>Gemara</i> says: דלמא אקרא דמלחא מאי טעמא, the <i>Gemara</i> has like a line like, figure this out: האי איתיה איסורא בעיניה והאי ליתיה איסורא בעיניה.

71
00:35:42,000 --> 00:36:11,999
So the <i>Gemara</i> says that in vinegar and salt, you it's going to be <i>mivattel</i>, that if a little bit of that salt falls in the vinegar, sorry, a little bit of the vinegar falls in the salt, it's <i>mivattel</i>, but with the <i>kuthach</i> it clumps together and it's still like <i>be'ayin</i> like it's not going to be <i>mivattel</i>. Okay, fine. The what? Okay. The <i>Shulchan Aruch</i> in <i>Siff Hey</i>. So go to the <i>Shulchan Aruch</i> in <i>Siff Hey</i>. <i>Shulchan Aruch</i> in <i>Siff

72
00:36:12,000 --> 00:36:42,999
Hey</i> says exactly what we saw in this <i>Gemara</i>. The <i>Gemara</i> says, the <i>Shulchan Aruch</i> says: אין מניחין כלי שיש בו כותח אצל כלי שיש בו מלח אבל מותר להניחו אצל כלי שיש בו חומץ. Exactly what we just said. The <i>Rema</i> adds: ודווקא עם הכלים מגולים. This is only if what? They're all uncovered. דאילו העביר ונתן ביחד, but if there was mixed dancing, <i>mutter</i>, it's <i>mutter</i>

73
00:36:43,000 --> 00:37:12,999
for a minute if it was by accident. ולא חיישינן שמא נפל על המלח. We're not worried that like something happened. But in general, one thing should not be put next to the other thing. Like the <i>Gra</i> explains like it's not <i>machzikin issura</i>, but we're not really worried something happened, but generally keep the salt away from the <i>kuthach</i>, but the vinegar would would be okay. Fine. The <i>Shulchan Aruch</i> in <i>Siff Vav</i> says the following, based on a <i>Tosfos</i> in the <i>Gemara</i> that we just saw: מותר ליתן

74
00:37:13,000 --> 00:37:42,999
בתוך תיבה כד של בשר אצל כד של חלב. What could I do? That I could place a jug of milk next to a jug of meat. Says the <i>Shach</i> in <i>Siff Katan Chaf-Gimel</i>, why is that okay? That sounds like blasphemy. It sounds like, kick that guy out of <i>Semicha</i>, <i>Chaver</i>. He says the <i>Shach</i>, <i>demizar zahiri</i>, I'm going to be very careful, שלא יפול מזה לזה, I'm going to be very careful. מה שאין כן בסיף ה דלא מסיק אדעתיה

75
00:37:43,000 --> 00:38:12,999
שלא יפול מן הכותח, but this I'm going to be very, very, very careful. Okay? And the <i>Shach</i> clarifies in <i>Siff Dalet</i>, <i>megullim</i> only if it's really, really, you know, uncovered, but if it was covered, everything would be okay. So if you look in the <i>Badei HaShulchan</i> in source 66, says the <i>Badei HaShulchan</i>, this is why, this is why we have the following. Or this is also like a good idea like if you if

76
00:38:13,000 --> 00:38:43,999
you have at your house, you know, I don't know, you have guests that are coming. So you make a whole, you know, the rest of the year you don't have a coffee station, but you make a coffee station, and you put coffees out, you put some sugar out in a bowl. Okay? So if that's a real coffee station, you should not take that sugar and then the guests leave, you're like, we're not fancy anymore, take that sugar and put it back in the thing and then use it for, you know, for baking or for cooking or for meat, it's going to be a problem. That has to be a creamer. Because that has to be a creamer after some problem.

77
00:38:44,000 --> 00:39:14,999
I don't understand you. Best friend? I don't I don't yeah, I don't understand you. Yeah but you keep the creamer and the milk in the fridge where it's cold, and not on the counter where it's not. No, but still it potentially could still be an issue. Meaning if people brought creamer out there, it would still be an issue, I would think. I don't understand that either. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Okay. So yeah, and don't don't get me started, did you try the Trader Joe's one? Yeah, I did.

78
00:39:15,000 --> 00:39:44,999
Tastes like every other one. Says the <i>Badei HaShulchan</i>: <i>Vechatav od Maharshal</i>. So the <i>Maharshal</i> explains: שהעולם נזהרים שלא להניח קדירה חולבת במקום שהניחו שם מקודם קדירת בשר. That the, you know, as they say in the <i>Yeshiva</i> world, the <i>Velt</i> is <i>noheig</i> that we don't put down the meat pot where or the <i>milchig</i> pot where the meat pot was. Why? דיש לחוש שנתשפך שם מתחילה ממאכל

79
00:39:45,000 --> 00:40:14,999
של בשר ושוב נבלע לקדירה החולבת. Meaning if we're not so careful, this is not like at oh my gosh, this is a crazy situation, things spill all the time. If you making soup and you have hot soup and a little bit spilled on the counter. and then you bring over your mac and cheese pot and put it down, that's a big issue. That potentially could be a problem. Now, yeah, there might be <i>shishim</i>, there'd be lots of things. But therefore says the <i>Badei Hashulchan</i>, ואף על פי שצונן לא בלע אפילו הכי החמיר בדבר שלפעמים הקדירה חמה ולא אדעתיה ויש ליזהר בזה וכיוצא בזה

80
00:40:15,000 --> 00:40:44,999
נתנו חכמים מקום בתוך המקרר לאחד משל חלב ומקום לעצמו לשל בשר. We should have separate places, separate counters, where, you know, where things are not going to touch one another. And if you have like a <i>parve</i> counter, it is really recommended that if you ever put something on a <i>parve</i> counter that's milk or meat, you should put a towel underneath it. It's just not worth it. You know, it wasn't dirty, I checked. Most of the time it should be fine. You

81
00:40:45,000 --> 00:41:14,999
know, my wife is very <i>makpid</i> about this. I, you know, I try to- I don't want to show her the <i>Badei Hashulchan</i>. But it's something that we should try to be careful for. Fine. That is <i>Sif Dalet</i>, one more minute, perfect. If you look in <i>Sif Zayin</i>, <i>Shulchan Aruch</i> <i>paskens</i> that מלח הנתן בקערה של בשר, if I put meat, I'm sorry, if I had salt that was placed on <i>fleishig</i> dishes, I could actually use that meat- that salt for <i>milchig</i>. But says the <i>Rema</i>, <i>anu machmirim</i>,

82
00:41:15,000 --> 00:41:45,999
<i>tavo alav beracha</i>, כי יש מחמירים לכתחילה. That we should really be <i>machmir</i> on this. The <i>Taz</i> disagrees and says why are you <i>machmir</i> on this? The <i>Badei Hashulchan</i>, <i>Sif Katan</i> 67, defends the <i>Rema</i> and explains the <i>Rema</i> was being <i>machmir</i> only in a situation where that <i>fleishig</i> pot had a little like layer of something, and I'm nervous that like the salt absorbed- like, if you had a <i>fleishig</i> bowl that you hadn't used in three days and was completely clean and not hot, and you accidentally dumped

83
00:41:46,000 --> 00:42:16,000
salt in there, you could take out that salt, put it into milk and drink it. But the <i>Rema</i> is being <i>machmir</i> because if you had a <i>kli</i> that was dirty, you might not realize, it's just better to be <i>machmir</i>, right? Better to be <i>machmir</i>. Alright, good, <i>shkoyach</i>. So next week, the one minute, perfect.
