1
00:00:00,000 --> 00:00:29,999
We are on page 18 in the booklet. Okay, so the next <i>sugya</i> that we are going to learn which will take us a few weeks is the topic of <i>stam yeinam</i>. Okay, so we know that we'll just start. If you look at source number one, okay, we'll just get right into it. A lot of very relevant things we're going to talk about: non-Jewish housekeepers and maids and cleaning services that might touch your wine, non-religious people, gifts, things like that.

2
00:00:30,000 --> 00:00:59,999
So the <i>pasuk</i> tells us in <i>Sefer Devarim</i>, the <i>pasuk</i> says: פסילי אלוהיהם תשרפון באש. Okay, you're supposed to, you gotta burn and destroy all <i>avoda zara</i>. לא תחמוד כסף וזהב עליהם. Right, so you can't benefit or get any use out of things that were done for <i>avoda zara</i>. Okay, that is clear. The <i>Gemara</i> in <i>Avoda Zara</i> in source number two, the <i>Gemara</i> tells us: <i>yayin minalan</i>. So, not only is... so where do we know this? אמר רבה בר אבוה אמר

3
00:01:00,000 --> 00:01:29,999
קרא אשר חלב זבחימו יאכלו ישתו יין נסיכם. מה זבח אסור בהנאה, just like something that was really done for <i>avoda zara</i> is <i>assur behana'ah</i>, אף יין נמי אסור בהנאה. So too there is an <i>issur d'oraisa</i> from benefiting from wine that was used as for, now there's a term called, which we're going to learn about, <i>yayin nesech</i>. So what's <i>yayin nesech</i>? What was that used for?

4
00:01:30,000 --> 00:01:59,999
For libations. For real <i>avoda zara</i>. So the <i>Gemara</i> says if there was wine used for <i>avoda zara</i>, and you took that wine and you cooked with it or you drank it or you benefited from it, that would be an <i>issur d'oraisa</i>. Okay. Now this is what's called <i>yayin nesech</i>. Okay, this is what's called <i>yayin nesech</i>. The <i>Rambam</i> in source number three, the <i>Rambam</i> says the following: <i>yayin sheninsach l'akum</i>, wine that was really used for <i>avoda zara</i> is <i>assur behaniya</i>. You cannot benefit from it. והשותה ממנו

5
00:02:00,000 --> 00:02:30,999
כל שהוא and as long as you drank even a little bit. <i>Malkot</i>? לוקה מן התורה. Okay, you get <i>malkos</i> for benefiting or drinking even a small amount of this. The <i>Rambam</i> in source number and <i>halacha beis</i>: יין שננסך כזבח שקרב לו וכיון שאיסור זה משום עכו\"ם <i>ein lo shiur</i>. There is no amount that one would be... sometimes there's a <i>kezayis</i>

6
00:02:31,000 --> 00:03:00,999
and a <i>kabeitza</i>. The end of the day, one is not able... this is very clear. This is <i>yayin nesech</i>. So if there was... now we're going to see later there really isn't <i>avoda zara</i> anymore. We don't have people that are using wine for <i>avoda zara</i>. A Christian coworker has a bottle of wine at his house, he's not using that for libations, okay? If he is, it's very strange, it doesn't really have that happening anymore. So now what do we do with that? Okay, but that's <i>yayin nesech</i>. That's topic number one: <i>yayin nesech</i>, wine used for

7
00:03:01,000 --> 00:03:30,999
actual <i>avoda zara</i> purposes. If you use that wine, you drink that wine, you benefit from that wine, <i>assur d'oraisa</i> and you get <i>malkos</i>. Fine. Now, the <i>Gemara</i> in <i>Avoda Zara</i> says: What happens if the wine just belongs to the non-Jew? Meaning he's not there sitting there and pouring it out for <i>avoda zara</i> purposes, but he owns it. So the <i>Gemara</i> in <i>Avoda Zara</i> in source number four says the following: אתא רב אחא בר אדא אמר רבי יצחק גזרו על פיתן

8
00:03:31,000 --> 00:04:01,999
משום שמנן. So they <i>gozer</i> there... there's a number of things that we do to prevent intermarriage, okay? What are those things? So we have... what are those things? Their bread. We have <i>pas akum</i>. Okay, we have <i>bishul akum</i>. And we have wine. So the <i>Gemara</i> says we are <i>gozer</i> on their bread because of the oil. מאי אלמיה דשמנא מפת אלא על פיתן ושמנן

9
00:04:02,000 --> 00:04:31,999
משום יינן. Because of the wine. And the <i>Gemara</i> says in <i>Avoda Zara</i>, the idea sometimes in <i>Chazal</i> of like a slippery slope is a real thing. So the <i>Gemara</i> says: Why am I really worried about wine? I'm worried about wine because what might happen? ועל יינם משום בנותיהם. So what's going to happen? Wine owned by a non-Jew, not <i>avoda zara</i> wine, not <i>avoda zara</i> wine, but wine owned by a non-Jew which what do we call in <i>halacha</i>? That's called <i>stam yeinam</i>.

10
00:04:32,000 --> 00:05:02,999
<i>Stam yeinam</i> means it's not wine that was really done for <i>avoda zara</i> purposes, but it's wine that's owned by a non-Jew. That wine, says the <i>Gemara</i>, is <i>assur</i>. <i>Mishum bnoteihem</i> because we are concerned that it might come to mix together. Now, one more <i>Mishnah</i>, just as background. Okay, so it seems though that maybe this should be... only I can't drink it. I won't drink your wine.

11
00:05:03,000 --> 00:05:32,999
The <i>Gemara</i> says in <i>Avodah Zarah</i> in source number five, אלו דברים שעובדי כוכבים אסורין. What are the things of a guy that are <i>assur</i> and <i>issurei issurei hana'ah</i>? But also are benefited from. One of those is wine. וחומץ של עובדי כוכבים שמתחילתו יין. So what is very clear from these few first sources, for those that just joined us, we read through five quick sources. There is an very straight <i>issur</i> in the Torah, you

12
00:05:33,000 --> 00:06:02,999
cannot benefit from something that is done for <i>avodah zarah</i> purposes. So if some guy gives you a bottle of wine and said I just used half this bottle of Moscato for <i>avodah zarah</i> purposes and you drink the rest of that bottle, that's an <i>issur d'oraissa</i>. That's number one. The <i>Gemara</i> says and that's the <i>Rambam</i> says is even if you drank a little bit, <i>assur mi'doraissa</i>, you get <i>makkos</i>. The <i>Gemara</i> in <i>Avodah Zarah</i> in source number four, number five says even <i>stam yeinam</i>, was not used for <i>avodah zarah</i>, that is also <i>assur</i> because of a <i>gezeira</i> you might come to mix with

13
00:06:03,000 --> 00:06:32,999
people together. Not for <i>hana'ah</i>, right? One second, hold on. So the, if it's no, that's the, the <i>Gemara</i> just said that. You cannot benefit from it. <i>Issurei issurei hana'ah</i>. So why did I get a <i>psak</i> that someone, Rabbi Doug, Rabbi Doug. You joined this <i>shiur</i> forty-two seconds ago. We are starting four weeks of <i>stam yeinam</i>. So we're going to learn through the <i>marei mekomos</i> and then we're going to get to your <i>psak</i>. What, what is the

14
00:06:33,000 --> 00:07:02,999
<i>psak</i>? So the <i>psak</i> was if someone gave you a bottle of non-kosher wine, you could give it to somebody else. We didn't get to that yet. Give me a minute. We're going to get there. We're not actually going to get there. Oh we are going to get there. Okay. So there's three things. There's <i>stam yeinam</i>, I'm sorry, there's <i>yayin nesech</i>, that's <i>assur mi'doraissa</i>. There's <i>stam yeinam</i> that is ordinary non-like non-<i>avodah zarah</i> wine owned by a non-Jew, that is <i>assur</i> for drinking and for benefit. And then there

15
00:07:03,000 --> 00:07:32,999
is Jewish owned wine which we haven't really talked about yet. Okay. Now, if we go to source number six, so why would <i>Chazal</i> forbid us from <i>stam yeinam</i>? I understand <i>yayin nesech</i>, that's used for <i>avodah zarah</i>. Why can't I benefit from <i>stam yeinam</i>? So there is a very, very important <i>machlokes</i> here, the three-way <i>machlokes</i> about the the root of why it's <i>assur</i>. So let's begin in the <i>Beit Yosef</i>. Okay, very, very important three-way

16
00:07:33,000 --> 00:08:03,999
<i>machlokes</i>. So the <i>Beit Yosef</i> says the following, quoting first the <i>Piskei Rid</i> and the <i>Beit Yosef</i> himself, <i>Peirush</i>, אע\"פ שבשאר דברים שגזרו עליהם, there are three things: <i>bishul akum</i>, <i>pas akum</i>, and <i>stam yeinam</i>. The other things like <i>pithan v'shamnam</i>, like their bread and their oil, and certain things like that, לא אסרו אלא באכילה, <i>v'lo b'hana'ah</i>. If somebody gives you, if a guy gives you,

17
00:08:04,000 --> 00:08:33,999
we're <i>meikel</i> today on <i>pas palter</i>. Okay, sorry, on <i>pas akum</i>. We're <i>meikel</i> on <i>pas akum</i>, right? All of us that don't eat <i>pas yisrael</i>, maybe some of you that are <i>makpid</i> on it, but those of us that don't, it's a big <i>kula</i>, but we rely on it. We rely on it. So but if a guy came over to you and said, listen, I have this unbelievable bread, it's <i>kosher</i> with but I baked it, you could use that to fuel your, I don't know, your what? Feed the dog, right, whatever you want, you can

18
00:08:34,000 --> 00:09:04,999
benefit from it. We wouldn't be upset about it. Same is true, but why is it when it comes to the wine, I don't know if dogs drink wine or not, probably we don't know. Right, but if I gave you the bottle of wine, that that would be a problem. So why, so the <i>Beit Yosef</i> asks, why are we more <i>machmir</i> on wine than everything else? ובסתם יינם גזרו לא אסרו אף בהנאה. Here we're more <i>machmir</i>. <i>V'hata'am</i>, and he explains, משום דכיון דיין נסך אסור בהנאה מדאורייתא. Because here

19
00:09:05,000 --> 00:09:35,999
and this is a very, very important rule in <i>halacha</i>, there is already a context that exists. When it comes to <i>pas akum</i>, when it comes to <i>bishul akum</i>, there isn't a context that exists in the Torah <i>mi'doraissa</i>. Here there is a <i>mi'doraissa</i> concept, you cannot benefit from a wine that was used in <i>avodah zarah</i>, it's called <i>yayin nesech</i>. So if I'm basing my things off of that, so says the <i>Beit Yosef</i>, כשבאו חכמים לגזור על סתם יינם,

20
00:09:36,000 --> 00:10:05,999
when the <i>chachamim</i> are going to come and now be <i>gozer</i> and make certain decrees, שכאילו נתנסך וודאי ממילא הוא אסור בהנאה. So if I am <i>Chazal</i>, bread and oil, they have no comparison in the <i>d'oraissa</i> level. Okay, so they only <i>gozer</i> you can't eat from them, but you could benefit from them. But I have But I have a concept in the <i>Torah</i> and I have a concept in <i>Halacha</i> called <i>yayin nesech</i>. So if I'm going to base my <i>d'Rabanan</i> on my <i>d'Oraisa</i>,

21
00:10:06,000 --> 00:10:35,999
I'm going to base it on the same thing and I'm going to make this <i>asur</i> even on a <i>d'Oraisa</i>, I'm sorry, on a <i>d'Rabanan</i> level but still benefiting from <i>hana'ah</i>. That's <i>Beis Yosef</i>. Then he quotes the <i>Ran</i>. <i>v'haRan kasav sham</i>. So the <i>Ran</i> says hold on. כי אם בשתייה היו אוסרים סבורים לומר שמשום ניסוך נאסר because what might happen if they forbade <i>stam yeinam</i> out of

22
00:10:36,000 --> 00:11:06,999
a concern they might be confused ויבואו להתיר יין נסך ואפילו בהנאה. They're not going to know what wine. Wine looks like wine. What you're going to see in the next few weeks, I'm not a wine person, but the really great wines and the really cheap wines and the really medium wines they all look like wine. So I don't know what wine you're drinking. I don't know that that's <i>yayin nesech</i> versus <i>stam yeinam</i>. I have no idea. So I might think they're all <i>mutar</i>. They're all allowed. So therefore <i>Chazal</i> extended the thing and said we don't want anybody to make an assumption

23
00:11:07,000 --> 00:11:36,999
that <i>yayin nesech</i> is <i>mutar be'hana'ah</i>. So <i>Chazal</i> said it's just easier. It's easier sometimes to just make what we call a <i>lo plug</i>. It's too confusing. It's too confusing. You're going to drink. I'm going to ask you every time was that <i>yayin nesech</i>? Was that <i>stam yeinam</i>? You can't benefit from any wine that is owned by a <i>goy</i>. They might mix it anyway so you wouldn't know the difference. Correct, they might mix it anyway. It's easier. Stay away. It's not like the <i>Beis Yosef</i>. The <i>Beis Yosef</i> has its roots in a <i>d'Oraisa</i> but that's the, that is the <i>Ran</i>. Okay, that's the <i>Ran</i>. So that's the <i>Beis Yosef</i> and

24
00:11:37,000 --> 00:12:07,999
that's the <i>Ran</i>. In comes the <i>Rashba</i> in source number seven. Says the <i>Rashba</i> אבל הרשבא כתב בתורת הבית שגזרו על סתם יינם משום בנותיהם לא אסרוה אלא בשתייה. One second, says the <i>Rashba</i>. What's the reason? <i>yayin nesech</i> I get. <i>avodah zarah</i> I can't benefit it. The <i>pasuk</i> says פסילי אלוהיהם תשרפון

25
00:12:08,000 --> 00:12:37,999
באש. Fine. If a <i>goy</i> owns a bottle of wine and that wine is not used for <i>avodah zarah</i> what's the reason I can't drink his wine? What did the <i>Gemorah</i> say? Because of intermarriage. Okay. So then what should be <i>asur</i>? Drinking the wine. So that, the <i>Rashba</i> says that is. This is a fascinating <i>Rashba</i> because sometimes you have to understand the progression of <i>Halacha</i>. The <i>Beis Yosef</i> and the <i>Ran</i>. The <i>Beis Yosef</i> says no, no, no. The <i>d'Oraisa</i> is here. So even though the <i>d'Rabanan</i> is lower level

26
00:12:38,000 --> 00:13:07,999
because it can't be on a <i>d'Oraisa</i>, it is patterned after the <i>d'Oraisa</i> and if the <i>d'Oraisa</i> is <i>asur be'hana'ah</i>, the <i>d'Rabanan</i> is <i>asur be'hana'ah</i>. Fine. The <i>Ran</i> says no, no, no. Really it's just drinking but people are going to just benefit for <i>yayin nesech</i> but because we're going to get confused we made them parallel. The <i>Rashba</i> says no, no, no. Here's the progression. When <i>Chazal</i> came in they said intermarriage, we're very worried. Therefore stay away from drinking. We're not going to sit at a bar together if I'm

27
00:13:08,000 --> 00:13:38,999
just holding your bottle of wine. We're not going to mingle too much. So therefore the <i>Rashba</i>, but then the <i>Rashba</i>, right. But that's just it. Wouldn't I think that the drinking also, my first thought would be drinking with you as well. Hold on, give me a second. שגזרו על סתם יינם משום בנותיהם לא אסרוה אלא בשתייה. Okay. Now, <i>v'Beis Din she'lachareihem</i>. Okay, to <i>Shai's</i> point you're right. Later, so it's a fascinating <i>Rashba</i>. Later, okay, however by the time of the <i>Gemorah</i> ראו שהורגלו הרבה לנסך.

28
00:13:39,000 --> 00:14:09,999
They saw that people were actually getting lax with <i>yayin nesech</i>. ולפיכך הוסיפו באיסור היין. So they decided we're going to now make a decree to say וגזרו על סתם יינם שאסור בהנאה. This is very indicative. There is a <i>Rashba</i> when it comes, I think we might have covered this <i>Rashba</i>. There's an opinion of the <i>Rashba</i> when it comes to <i>Taharas Hamishpacha</i> when it comes to <i>harchakos</i>. So the <i>Rambam</i> very famously holds all <i>harchakos</i> are <i>d'Oraisa</i>.

29
00:14:10,000 --> 00:14:39,999
Most <i>Rishonim</i> don't hold like that <i>Rambam</i>. The <i>Rashba</i> says that really like <i>negi'ah</i> is <i>asur</i> because it might lead. So the <i>Rashba</i> is saying you're right. Really it's just drinking because that's the decree. However, similar issue to the <i>Ran</i>, we saw what was happening. So <i>Chazal</i>, everything is <i>asur</i>. Everything is <i>asur</i>. We don't want you getting mixed up with <i>yayin nesech</i> and therefore everything is going to be <i>asur</i>. So according to the <i>Beis Yosef</i>, <i>Chazal</i> gave the status of

30
00:14:40,000 --> 00:15:09,999
<i>stam yeinam</i> like <i>yayin nesech</i>. That's the <i>Beis Yosef</i> at the top. According to the <i>Ran</i>, really it was to prevent intermarriage but it's getting confusing to know which one so they said it's <i>asur</i> to both. And the <i>Rashba</i> really agrees with the <i>Ran</i> but understands a little bit the progression a little bit differently. Okay. What's the difference between the <i>Ran</i>? Not much. Not much. Just for context. According to the—yeah. According to the—the only difference is, there's not a difference in practice. The only difference is that according to the <i>Rashba</i> it was stage one and stage two, and according to the <i>Ran</i> it was stage one.

31
00:15:10,000 --> 00:15:39,999
There was never a stage two, but that's how the <i>Rashba</i> understands it. Fine. Now. So, how do we <i>pasken</i>, you know, why was this, you know, made this decree? So if you look now in the מדרש פרקי דרבי אליעזר. So on the one hand, you find the following source. After the story of the episode with the women of Midian, in the end, <i>Balak</i> and <i>Parshas Pinchas</i>, אלעזר המודעי אומר עמד פנחס והחרים על ישראל. So, you know, after all of this terrible, <i>Bilaam</i>

32
00:15:40,000 --> 00:16:10,999
tries to curse the Jews and it doesn't work. Eventually gets them to be seduced by the women of Midian. So the—afterwards, after <i>Pinchas</i> gets up, after all the Jews had illicit relationships that they should not have had, culminating in <i>Cozbi</i> and <i>Zimri</i>, so <i>Pinchas</i> enacts a specific decree when it comes to wine. <i>Ubesod Shem Hamiforesh</i> he makes a decree in the name of God עם הקדוש ברוך הוא בכתב שנכתב על הלוחות ובחרם בית דין העליון ובחרם בית דין התחתון. He says makes a

33
00:16:11,000 --> 00:16:40,999
decree שלא ישתה אדם ישראל מיינם של גוים <i>kemarpish raglam</i>. This is very very very bad and therefore we need to stay far away from this. So <i>Pinchas</i> makes a decree that we are staying, you know, as far away from <i>stam yeinam</i> as possible. So there was interesting timelines as to when exactly this whole decree happened, but if you look in the <i>Ramban</i>, the <i>Ramban</i> says there are contradictory sources, like <i>pesukim</i> in <i>Daniel</i> that made it seem as though it was already applicable at the time of <i>Daniel</i>, maybe later than <i>Pinchas</i>, so says the <i>Ramban</i>.

34
00:16:41,000 --> 00:17:11,999
The <i>Ramban</i> says וכיון דתניא פרק דרבי אליעזר הגדול שאליהו גזר על היין ועל דבר פעור. <i>Ve'ika lemeimar</i>, <i>gazar ihu shtiya</i>, <i>Pinchas</i> really decreed you cannot drink it, ואתו אינהו גזרו אפילו בהנאה. And later they came and they were <i>gozer</i> on all the other things. Or he says, לא פשט תקנו אליהו

35
00:17:12,000 --> 00:17:43,999
ודניאל חוזר והורה עליו. Either way, there's a little bit of a debate as to when exactly this whole decree happened, but nonetheless this is the decree, we do not benefit from <i>stam yeinam</i>. Okay. If you have those little packets right here, if you need one they're on the table, this is the <i>Shulchan Aruch</i>. We just need a little bit for tonight. So, if you look in the <i>Shulchan Aruch</i> in <i>Kuf-Chaf-Gimmel</i>, <i>Se'if Aleph</i>. <i>Kuf-Chaf-Gimmel</i>, <i>Se'if Aleph</i>.

36
00:17:44,000 --> 00:18:14,999
Says the <i>Shulchan Aruch</i>. סתם יינם של עמים עובדי כוכבים אסור בהנאה. You cannot benefit from the wine no matter what. והוא הדין במגע ביין שלנו, and similarly if it was touched, they touched our wine which we'll get to in a minute. I know it's hard to see this <i>Rama</i>, but the <i>Rama</i> adds the following. The <i>Rama</i> says,

37
00:18:15,000 --> 00:18:44,999
משום גזירת יין שנתנסך לאלילים, the <i>Rama</i> adds this was, you know, we were concerned about benefiting from <i>yayin nesech</i>. Now, he goes on to say, we'll come back to this in a second, בזמן הזה שאינו שכיח שאומות מנסכין לעבודת כוכבים, alright we'll come back to this, you know, even today, <i>lema'aseh</i> it does not seem like there's—what—once <i>Chazal</i> eliminated the the the <i>avoda

38
00:18:45,000 --> 00:19:14,999
zara</i> as the <i>Gemara</i> says, shouldn't this become not as big a concern and we have to have <i>chumra</i> on top of <i>chumra</i> on top of <i>chumra</i>? So, yes and no. Meaning there might not be a drive for <i>avoda zara</i> but there are certain things that still qualify as <i>avoda zara</i>. I mean, we don't have <i>avoda zara</i> like it was in the times of <i>Mitzrayim</i> and the times of the <i>Gemara</i>, but we do have <i>avoda zara</i> that exists today. We do have people that are, I mean you if you consider like the major major <i>machlokes</i>, <i>Ran</i> and all the <i>Rishonim</i> whether or not you consider Christianity <i>avoda

39
00:19:15,000 --> 00:19:44,999
zara</i>. So most do. I mean, most will consider Christianity <i>avoda zara</i>, maybe not <i>avoda zara</i> like paganism, there's not as much paganism, but it might be <i>avoda zara</i>. איסלם אינמי עבודה זרה. But you're right. On the other hand also, once you have a <i>gezeira</i>, you know, a <i>Beis Din</i> cannot be <i>mafkia</i>, you can't just say this doesn't apply anymore. So once you have a decree in place, you have a decree. On top of the fact that there is

40
00:19:45,000 --> 00:20:14,999
an intermarriage concern which which clearly we have a problem about. Right? So that would still apply. I mean the <i>de-rabbanan</i> of <i>stam yeinam</i> would still apply. So we'll talk about that. We'll talk about that. Okay. So now, so but you go to the <i>Shulchan Aruch</i>... Wait for a second and let's go to now source number ten. Okay? Source number ten. So if I cannot benefit from <i>stam yeinam</i>, so what do I do? Can I give a non-kosher

41
00:20:15,000 --> 00:20:44,999
wine to somebody else? If I was gifted a non-kosher bottle of wine, like Rabbi Doug is saying, could I re-gift it to somebody else? Okay? So we said obviously you can't drink <i>stam yeinam</i> and we saw the different <i>rishonim</i>. So now let's see the <i>Tur</i> in source number ten. So the <i>Tur</i> quotes the <i>Rashbam</i> in certain <i>ge'onim</i> ורשב''ם כתב בשם רש''י שכתב להשיב להגאונים דבזמן הזה אין איסור הנאה במגע של

42
00:20:45,000 --> 00:21:14,999
גוי ביין שלנו that we are <i>meikel</i>, there is no <i>issur hana'ah</i> of wine that was touched by a <i>goy</i>, that you can benefit from wine owned by a non-Jew. Okay? Why? To Shaya's point דגויים בזמן הזה אינן רגילים לנסך לעבודה זרה והוה ליה אינן איסה כי לא אינם יודעים מטיב עבודה זרה ומשמשו והוה כתינוק שעושה יין נסך לאסור בשתייה ולא בהנאה. So

43
00:21:15,000 --> 00:21:44,999
Rashi says you can for sure benefit from wine that was owned by a non-Jew. How do I know that? Because <i>Chazal</i> never said if you have a non-Jewish neighbor and a little the one day the two-year-old comes over to gift you a bottle of wine. Okay? We're going to say oh my gosh. First of all, there's a lot of other problems. Okay? But <i>etzem</i> the fact that he was someone managed to hold a bottle and it didn't break, okay?

44
00:21:45,000 --> 00:22:14,999
You'd be like, wow, that's an amazing baby. Okay? After you got over that whole scenario, that's not <i>assur</i>. Why is that not <i>assur</i>? Because a two-year-old baby is not worshipping <i>avodah zarah</i>. You're also not having relations. Right, right. So therefore, the <i>Gemara</i> was clear about that. Since there's no concern that this kid was going to offer this wine as <i>nisuch</i>, therefore it should so therefore since today's <i>goyim</i> are mostly are not all of them are not pouring this wine. Yes, if you lived in India

45
00:22:15,000 --> 00:22:44,999
and you lived right next to some Buddhist temple, I probably would tell you shouldn't benefit shouldn't touch any of their wines. But other than that you're... I'm just wondering though, the church, if they use wine... Oh, okay, okay. <i>In hach nami</i>, if it's <i>avodah zarah</i>. <i>In hach nami</i>, but but... We just said it's <i>avodah zarah</i>. No no no. You said some opinion. One second. One second. One second. One second. One second. There's a lot of ways to answer your question. First,

46
00:22:45,000 --> 00:23:15,999
you'd have to even just that, you'd have to answer if that was considered <i>nisuch</i> or not. Meaning let's assume after mass the priest comes over to your house and gives you this half a bottle. Meaning was that what they did was was <i>avodah zarah</i> or was it like <i>Kiddush</i> at service? I don't know. Okay? That's number one. Number two, granted that happens, but רוב ורובא דרובא דרובא the non-Jew at your at work who says Happy <i>Hanukkah</i> that you he

47
00:23:16,000 --> 00:23:45,999
gives you wine or you give him wine, we're not worried that that was used in his house for <i>avodah zarah</i>. It's also a closed bottle usually. We're going to talk about that. But you're right, you're right, you're right. Yeah. So that's Rashi. That's Rashi. So therefore <i>lemayseh</i> today, since non-Jews don't really perform <i>nisuch</i> or libations, they're the same thing as this baby and therefore you could benefit from that wine. You cannot

48
00:23:46,000 --> 00:24:21,999
drink that wine, but you could benefit from that wine. That means I could take the wine and I could give it as a gift. Okay. Fine. That is the opinion of Rashi. If you look in source number eleven, then the <i>Tur</i> quotes the <i>Rosh</i> and the <i>Rosh</i> is a little bit more, you know, a little bit more restrictive. <i>Va'adoni avi ha'Rosh</i>. So the <i>Rosh</i> says the following.

49
00:24:22,000 --> 00:24:51,999
ואדוני אבי הרא''ש שהאריך בזה בסוף דבריו ודחא כל המביאים להתיר מגע גוי ביין שלנו אבל סתם יינם שחמור משום בנותיהם אין טעם להתירא. Meaning to your point, the <i>Rosh</i> says, \"How do I know that this isn't the bottle from church?\" You want to tell me that he came over to my house and touched my bottle of Moscato? Fine. <i>Nicha</i>. That's fine. He's not

50
00:24:52,000 --> 00:25:22,999
doing anything wrong. But how do I know that the bottle that came from his house he didn't do anything with? And therefore, don't come... don't come to me with with that the bottle was closed or not—hold on a second. Okay, so that is what the <i>Rosh</i> says, <i>ein tam l'atirah</i>. Now, ומיהו יש לומר שמתחילה לא נאסרו סתם יינם אלא בשתייה. In the beginning, like the <i>Rashba</i> said before, it was only <i>assur</i> with drinking, <i>dapas shemen v'shelakos</i>, אלא משנתרגלו לנסך but when they started to use these also for <i>avodah zarah</i>, אסורה

51
00:25:23,000 --> 00:25:53,999
בהנאה כיין שעשה עבודה זרה. <i>V'innah</i>, so the <i>Rosh</i> says today, שאין מנסכין דין שנעשה סתם יינם כפת ושלוקות. Really, really says the <i>Rosh</i> that we should make it like everything else. מכל מקום ראיה ברורה אין לנו להתירה בהנאה והנח להם לישראל מוטב שיהיו שוגגין ואל יהיו מזידין. Really says the <i>Rosh</i>, we really really shouldn't do this. We really should only benefit from wine that is our wine touched by a <i>goy</i>. But their wine, that

52
00:25:54,000 --> 00:26:24,999
should not be <i>meikel</i> on, so the only scenario we're allowed benefit is a non-Jew touched the Jewish wine. Much more restrictive than the opinion of <i>Rashi</i>. Does it matter if it's open or closed? We're going to talk about that. If it's closed? We'll talk about that, we're going to talk about that in a little bit, we're going to talk about that in a little bit. Yeah, and when we come to how all these kind of issues when with <i>stam yaynam</i> and <i>yayin nesech</i> and things like that, which are major problems, they could treif up your kitchen more than we realize if you use...

53
00:26:25,000 --> 00:26:55,999
Okay, fine. So now, that's the <i>Rosh</i>. If you look at the <i>Rambam</i>, so the <i>Rosh</i> basically ends that he's not compelled enough to allow it and therefore is pretty <i>machmir</i>. The <i>Rambam</i> in source number twelve, the <i>Rambam</i> as understood by the <i>Beis Yosef</i>, שדעת הרמב\"ם שלא לחלק. The <i>Rambam</i> says doesn't matter, doesn't even today, בין גויים שבזמנם לגויים שבזמננו. Doesn't matter, it is forbidden says the <i>Rambam</i> to benefit from <i>stam yaynam</i> or Jewish

54
00:26:56,000 --> 00:27:25,999
wine touched by a non-Jew. Okay? So even though they don't perform any kind of <i>nisuch</i> today, there is no distinction and therefore you have the <i>Rashi</i> who's the most lenient, source number ten, that's <i>Rashi</i>. Then you have the <i>Rosh</i> that's a little bit more lenient, a little less lenient, that they can touch our wine but we cannot benefit from their wine. And the <i>Rambam</i> that says everything should be <i>assur b'hana'ah</i>. Okay. So how do we <i>pasken</i>? So now go back to the

55
00:27:26,000 --> 00:28:01,999
<i>Shulchan Aruch</i>. So we just saw that the <i>Shulchan Aruch</i> <i>paskened</i> like the... one out of three chance... like the <i>Rambam</i>. Like the <i>Rambam</i>. Eddie you got one point. סתם יינם של עובדי כוכבים אסור בהנאה והוא הדין למגעם ביין שלנו. Like the <i>Rambam</i>, like the <i>Rambam</i>. Okay, now the <i>Rema</i> says the

56
00:28:02,000 --> 00:28:31,999
following: משום גזירת יין שנסתייך לעלילים. We're worried maybe they're using it for <i>avodah zarah</i>. ובזמן הזה שאינו שכיח שאומות מנסכים לעבודת כוכבים. Today it is not so common that the <i>goyim</i> are using this for real <i>avodah zarah</i> purposes. יש אומרים דמגע עובד כוכבים ביין שלנו, like the <i>Rosh</i>, if they

57
00:28:32,000 --> 00:29:01,999
do touch our wine, <i>eino assur b'hana'ah</i>. It is not <i>assur b'hana'ah</i>, <i>rak b'shtiyah</i>. וכן בסתם יינם שלהם, their wine, אינו אסור ליהנות ממנו. We really shouldn't benefit from. ולכן מותר לגבות חובו מעובד כוכבים סתם יינם. So therefore if the only thing he could pay back his loan with is with a bottle of his wine then we are going to allow it. And that

58
00:29:02,000 --> 00:29:31,999
really is how the <i>Rema</i> <i>paskens</i>. That although some are buying and selling <i>stam yaynam</i>, you really really should be <i>machmir</i>, but we will be <i>meikel</i> in the case of <i>hefsed</i>. It's very important to understand whenever we have a <i>halacha</i> like this and this is why <i>Smichas Chaver</i> is amazing, the <i>Rema</i> is not being like, listen, <i>halacha</i> is X, but if there's a financial concern we could be lenient. You can only be lenient if there's a reason, if there's a context in <i>halacha</i> to be lenient. So the <i>Rema</i> says we really <i>pasken</i>, the <i>Beis Yosef</i>, the <i>Shulchan Aruch</i> <i>paskens</i> like the <i>Rambam</i>.

59
00:29:32,000 --> 00:30:01,999
We have the <i>Rosh</i>. So says the <i>Rema</i>, we should be <i>machmir</i> about it. But because the <i>Rosh</i>'s opinion exists in case of financial issue you can rely on the <i>Rosh</i>. You can rely on the <i>Rosh</i>. You could hear, listen, I can't pay back but I could pay you back with a bottle of wine. Okay, so you pay back with a bottle of wine because we're not really concerned he's using it for <i>avodah zarah</i>. But it's not something that we should become accustomed to because if we become accustomed to it it's going to be an issue. Yes. So if it's a what if wait. Wait till we get to all the practical examples. If it's a what if,

60
00:30:02,000 --> 00:30:31,999
wait till we get to all the practical examples. If it's a can you, wait till we get to the examples. Can you sell wine to a non-Jew that might use it for <i>Avodah Zarah</i>? Well, you can't, no way! If the guy, if the guy says yeah, listen, I'm short of wine for my <i>nisuch</i> purposes, then yes, that would be <i>assur</i>. The same reason you cannot give, you cannot give a Christmas present, right? The <i>Gemara</i> in <i>Avodah Zarah</i> is very clear that within the few days right around their <i>Yamim Tovim</i> you can't give things.

61
00:30:32,000 --> 00:31:01,999
Today we're a little more lenient about it and you shouldn't say this is a Christmas gift. You can say it's an end-of-year bonus, holiday gift. But if you have a staunch, you know, if you're about to give this guy a bottle of wine and he's like \"oh yes, we need it for church\", you would not be able, you'd have to take it right back. 100%. That would be <i>assur</i>. 100% would be <i>assur</i>. Yeah. Yeah. I told you that story once, no? With the Israeli guy on <i>Erev Pesach</i>? A number of years ago there was a, I was at my in-laws, this was before I was even a rabbi because I was, you know, I had

62
00:31:02,000 --> 00:31:32,999
off-Pesach. How many is he up to? A lot. What? Those were the days. You can take it. What? We're not taking your blood pressure, Daddy. I just going to take the medicine up at the moment. Okay. So, I was at my in-laws and it was ערב פסח שחל להיות בשבת, so <i>Shabbos</i> was <i>Erev Pesach</i>. Yeah, so you did all the early things and, you know, my sisters-in-law were very worried there wasn't going to be enough bread so there was like dozens of rolls. So by the time 10:03 hit, you know, we had to get rid of it. So either you flush it down the toilet, we're not going to flush down 30

63
00:31:33,000 --> 00:32:02,999
rolls down the toilet. So there's, the other option is there's a local dumpster. So my in-laws live across from an apartment complex in Queens. So we were going out there, my brother-in-law and I, and each of us had literally a bag of rolls. And this guy's getting in his car. So we're like \"what, why are we going to throw it out? We'll just give it to... we'll be nice, we'll be nice Jews.\" So we said to this guy \"do you want these rolls?\" He goes \"oh, <i>bishvil Pesach</i>?\" I was like \"yeah, I'm like no, sorry. These are, you can't have these.\" So, you

64
00:32:03,000 --> 00:32:32,999
know, okay. <i>Weiter</i>. So, if you look, it's, it's hard to see this in here. I know it's hard in this, in this one. There is a <i>Pischei Teshuva</i> in <i>Pischei Teshuva Sif Katan Bais</i> that, could you have a business, could you profit from selling non-kosher wines? Meaning, could I own a wine store that profits from selling non-kosher wine? So what would you say? So the <i>Rema</i> would seem to say

65
00:32:33,000 --> 00:33:02,999
that there are those that are lenient. There are those that are lenient. That's your <i>parnassah</i>, that's your <i>parnassah</i>. So the <i>Pischei Teshuva</i> in <i>Sif Katan Bais</i>, it's very hard to see, but the <i>Pischei Teshuva</i> quotes here a <i>Levushai Srad</i> who's <i>melamed zechus</i>, that they hold like the, like the <i>Rema</i>. It's not ideal, but you should avoid it if you could. But what are you going to do? He says מלמד זכות על מה שנוהגים עכשיו לעשות סחורה מסתמא יינם. But what are you going to do? That, they rely on it and therefore

66
00:33:03,000 --> 00:33:32,999
it would be, it would be okay. Fine. That's, that's next. If the, the <i>Rema paskens</i>, if you go back up to this <i>Rema</i>, that if you accidentally bought or sold a non-kosher bottle of wine, you could benefit. The <i>Shulchan Aruch</i> would be <i>machmir</i>, but the <i>Rema</i> would say if you bought it by accident, you know, you know, again, you can't do things by accident every day, but it would be okay. So if you look in source 13 in the שאלות ותשובות שבט הלוי, <i>Rav Halberstam</i>, he quotes <i>Rav Halberstam</i> the following. He says לדינא שאלתי

67
00:33:33,000 --> 00:34:02,999
פי הגאון רב משה הלברשטאם חבר בית דין של עדה החרדית שאלות ותשובות דברי משה והתיר לי לתת הבקבוק בסתם יינם that I could regift a bottle of wine, a bottle of non-kosher wine לאיזה נכרי מזכיר עכו״ם כדי שיעבוד יותר מהר. What does <i>ya'avod yoser maher</i> mean? You'll work better. Meaning, if I... I have an incentive program. Whoever gets the most sales

68
00:34:03,000 --> 00:34:33,999
gets this bottle of wine. So that is done, as the <i>Rema</i> would say, for what reason? For benefit, for profit. So that would be okay. That would be okay to have some kind of thing where... Now, there is another issue here, that there is an issue of <i>lo tichanem</i>. What's the issue of <i>lo tichanem</i>? What's the <i>issur</i>? You can't give gifts to <i>goyim</i>. To <i>goyim</i>. Okay? So that's another interesting <i>shayla</i> which we can talk about a different time. But you could give a gift to a non-Jew if the goal for that non-Jew is to work better. That's

69
00:34:34,000 --> 00:35:03,999
not considered a gift, it's considered, you know, an incentive or something. You should not send on their holiday. That's what I just mentioned, that's the <i>Rema</i>, I don't have it here, that's the <i>Rema</i> later in <i>kuf mem hey</i> or something. The <i>Rema</i> says you cannot give gifts to the <i>goyim</i> on their holiday. Okay, fine. If you look though in source 14, okay, if you look in source 14, it quotes the <i>Maharam Schick</i>. The <i>Maharam Schick</i> was one of the great <i>talmidim</i>. of the <i>Chasam Sofer</i>, who really took over the

70
00:35:04,000 --> 00:35:33,999
mantle of leadership from the <i>Chasam Sofer</i>, who in the fight against the Reform movement, the <i>Maram Shick</i> is as fire and brimstone as the <i>Chasam Sofer</i> was. So the <i>Maram Shick</i> says, ומכל מקום יראי ה'. Fine, you're right. You have now this non-Jewish, non-kosher bottle of wine. That really, it's fine. If you don't, if it's not such a financial loss and you want to be <i>machmir</i>, <i>medakdek b'mitzvos</i> and <i>ein hefsed</i>,

71
00:35:34,000 --> 00:36:03,999
meaning like it's not such a big deal. You know, you know, like if it's the bottle of wine that has the screw top, all right, whatever. You'll be all right. You know, you'll be all right. כי אם מעט כדאי להחוש להפסידו. To check it out. A <i>Goy</i> gives you a bottle of wine. All right, so it's better if you have an inexpensive bottle of non-kosher wine. Is it <i>mutter</i>? Probably. Is it better to drink it? Probably not. Chuck it out if you really, really don't need to. Can you regift it?

72
00:36:04,000 --> 00:36:34,999
You said you could regift it. If regifting it, if it's definitely for the purpose of a benefit. If not, you're probably not for a cheap bottle of wine. Okay, source 15, says the <i>Darchei Teshuva</i>, sorry. Okay. Now, could I keep <i>stam yeinam</i> in my house? Could I keep <i>stam yeinam</i> in my house? There's obviously like there's obviously getting there are also times that wine could just be <i>traif</i>. I don't think it's not it's rare.

73
00:36:35,000 --> 00:37:04,999
I don't know I don't know about wine, but you know, if you had pig fat wine, that would not be an issue of <i>stam yeinam</i>, that would just be an issue of <i>kashrus</i>. We're not there yet, we're not there yet. Okay, אם כהאי גוונא בהגהות הטור שכתב ומביא מהגהות האשירי דבכל מקום אסור לישראל להשהות יין אצלו כדי ליושנו ואפילו להסיקו. According to the <i>Sephardim</i> who say like the <i>Shulchan Aruch</i>, like the <i>Rambam</i>, based on how the <i>Beis Yosef</i> read the <i>Rambam</i>, that

74
00:37:05,000 --> 00:37:34,999
you cannot benefit at all from this, that if you really were gifted this bottle of wine, you should not, it's <i>assur</i> to leave it in your house. The, yeah, <i>b'beis Goy assur</i>. You really, really gotta leave it out. And he writes in the middle on the line וכל זה הוא נפקא מינא לגבי ספרדים. By the way, we finally got one. Finally got one, guys. <i>Sephardim</i> here more <i>machmir</i> than us. So, win. Okay? They might use one dishwasher, but you

75
00:37:35,000 --> 00:38:04,999
could keep that non-kosher bottle of wine in your basement and never drink it. וכל זה הוא נפקא מינא לגבי הספרדים שנוהגין איסור הנאה בסתם יינם because they hold it's <i>assur</i>. אמנם לפי שגבי מרבותינו האשכנזים אין נפקא מינא בכל הדבר ולדינא. Since we really hold like the <i>Rambam</i>, we would be able to keep it in the house, although the <i>Maram Shick</i> would say that really you shouldn't, and ideally you should chuck it away. What's the <i>hana'ah</i> of keeping it in the house? You can't benefit at all from it, so even though,

76
00:38:05,000 --> 00:38:34,999
even though it's there, we're, we're... I would say until you give it to someone... Correct, correct, correct. Meaning according to the, to the <i>Darchei Teshuva</i>, I don't think it's a straight-up <i>issur d'rabbanan</i>, but you should really not have it because we don't hold of things. If it's <i>assur</i>, it's <i>assur</i>. If you're never going to benefit from it, what's having it in my house? So you should get rid of it. So just because it's <i>hana'ah</i>? Yeah, yeah, yeah. You know, there is another interesting <i>shaila</i> here which we're not going into too much, and that is, can you benefit from

77
00:38:35,000 --> 00:39:04,999
schlepping non... like can you transport non-kosher wine? Okay? Could you, you know, I don't know, if you're an Uber driver, or you're a vendor, or the White Sox start selling wine at the games. So and you're going up and down, or the Cubs, with, you know, non-kosher wine. Okay? Could you do that? So the <i>Shulchan Aruch</i> would say, the <i>Shulchan Aruch</i> would say no, because you can't benefit from it. The <i>Rema</i> would seemingly say yes. There is a <i>Shach</i>

78
00:39:05,000 --> 00:39:34,999
in <i>se'if katan daled</i>. So the <i>Rema</i> would say yes because we do allow it, and definitely in this situation it's very indirect benefit. If you look, there is a <i>Shach</i> in <i>se'if katan daled</i>, <i>u'meitshuvas Maram mi'Lublin</i>... <i>nafkaminah b'din kniyah</i>... is this right? I think so. That really you should not be providing these services. Just for clarification, beer and whiskey are not considered...

79
00:39:35,000 --> 00:40:05,999
No, no, no. And why do we not put <i>yeinam</i> on those as well? <i>m'de'rabbanan</i>? Good question about that. Yeah, but if you take the other example, I'm saying <i>m'de'rabbanan</i>, meaning <i>m'de'rabbanan</i> we're taking wine and extending it to all these different levels to avoid contact... It's a great <i>shaila</i>, it's a good <i>shaila</i>. Answer, answer on <i>shaila</i>. Whiskey. Answer it. You know the answer. What's the answer? I don't drink wine. Meaning you're right in theory, but in order to

80
00:40:06,000 --> 00:40:35,999
do that, I'd have to have a <i>beis</i>, meaning I can't <i>asser</i> things just to <i>asser</i> things because of, I mean, I could make a suggestion to you, you shouldn't drink beer with non-Jews, because of <i>mishum bnosayhen</i>. But in terms of establishing an <i>issur</i>, I need a precedent in <i>halacha</i>. You have it with wine. But the precedent is that we've <i>asser-ed</i> drinking with someone else. Because of wine, started with- I understand. Correct. Correct. Correct. Because at the time, people did it with

81
00:40:36,000 --> 00:41:05,999
wine. Correct. No, that's how they would do <i>avoda zara</i>. By the way, we're going to see this, there is a <i>chumra</i>, most people do not hold to this <i>chumra</i>, that you cannot use grape juice for <i>kiddush</i>. Why? Why? Because you can't put grape juice on the <i>mizbeach</i>. Can't put grape juice on the <i>mizbeach</i>. So you have the- you're saying that <i>Chazal</i> could make an extension to say we shouldn't intermingle at all. The hope is that based on <i>yayin</i>, <i>pas</i>, and <i>bishul</i>,

82
00:41:06,000 --> 00:41:36,999
you would make an understanding that like, I don't need <i>Chazal</i> every step of the way to tell me don't be an idiot, right? But in order for me to make a full-fledged <i>issur d'rabbanan</i>, maybe a <i>gezeira</i>, but for sure an <i>issur d'rabbanan</i> without a context of it being within the framework of a <i>d'oreisa</i>. Right? Meaning you have three levels of <i>issurim</i>. You have <i>issur d'oreisa</i>, you have high-level <i>issur d'rabbanan</i>, we'll call it <i>divrei sofrim</i> or <i>mitzvos divrei sofrim</i>. <i>Chol HaMoed</i> is a <i>mitzvah divrei sofrim</i>. It's not <i>d'oreisa</i> but it's <i>d'rabbanan</i>. Then you have a <i>d'rabbanan</i>. Within <i>d'rabbanan</i>s

83
00:41:37,000 --> 00:42:06,999
you have <i>d'rabbanan</i>s and you have <i>gezeros</i> under those <i>d'rabbanan</i>s. So this is not even a <i>gezeira</i> because, you know, <i>ein sof</i>. So you're right, maybe-, but bars also have peanuts. Should we not eat peanuts together? So you could make-, maybe you shouldn't. So yes, you shouldn't intermingle, but I can't establish an <i>issur</i> from a <i>halachic</i> standpoint without some context or some precedent to tell me what I'm basing this off of. And <i>yayin</i>, based on <i>yayin nesech</i>, based on <i>stam yaynam</i>, so there's a progression. But with the beer, there's

84
00:42:07,000 --> 00:42:37,000
no progression. But your theory is 100% accurate, and I think what <i>Chazal</i> intended with this. Would that also apply to eating together, breaking bread? Yeah, yeah, yeah. All right, we'll hold it, we'll stop here for <i>Ma'ariv</i>. Next week <i>im yirtzeh Hashem</i> we're going to have <i>shiur</i> Tuesday night. Tuesday night for those that can make it. I'm not in town Monday night, so you can come Wednesday night, I just won't be here.
