1
00:00:00,959 --> 00:00:03,580
When it comes to Yayin Nesach, S'tam

2
00:00:03,580 --> 00:00:07,160
Yeinam, can we have protective seals so

3
00:00:07,600 --> 00:00:09,860
that we're not concerned somebody touched it

4
00:00:09,860 --> 00:00:11,120
or did something else to it? So

5
00:00:11,120 --> 00:00:13,300
we ended off last time with a

6
00:00:13,300 --> 00:00:19,420
discussion about in source the double seal,

7
00:00:19,420 --> 00:00:20,620
which we saw in the Shulchan Aruch

8
00:00:20,620 --> 00:00:22,580
Igros Moshe, the double seal is not

9
00:00:22,580 --> 00:00:23,920
a din in the double seal, it's

10
00:00:23,920 --> 00:00:24,960
more of a din in the effort

11
00:00:24,960 --> 00:00:25,900
that is going to have to be

12
00:00:25,900 --> 00:00:29,340
put in to actually taking it up.

13
00:00:29,780 --> 00:00:33,640
We finished with in source 40 about

14
00:00:33,640 --> 00:00:36,260
the same idea, Torech Rav, it's going

15
00:00:36,260 --> 00:00:36,740
to be a lot, a lot of

16
00:00:36,740 --> 00:00:39,008
work. Okay. Is there enough in let's

17
00:00:39,008 --> 00:00:41,399
say I have a single seal that's

18
00:00:41,399 --> 00:00:43,740
just like airplane food, you cannot get

19
00:00:43,740 --> 00:00:44,140
it off. Correct, yes, so we're going

20
00:00:44,140 --> 00:00:45,040
to talk about that, yeah, yeah. We're

21
00:00:45,040 --> 00:00:47,540
going to talk about doing... it would

22
00:00:47,540 --> 00:00:48,701
need something else. I mean the tin

23
00:00:48,701 --> 00:00:50,020
foil and then that and then that

24
00:00:50,020 --> 00:00:51,727
plastic thing. I mean the plastic is

25
00:00:51,727 --> 00:00:54,960
nearly impossible. Correct, correct. It would still

26
00:00:54,960 --> 00:00:57,320
need two. It would still need two

27
00:00:57,320 --> 00:01:00,460
as long as, unless the one is

28
00:01:00,460 --> 00:01:03,300
really, really, really amazing. It seems like

29
00:01:03,300 --> 00:01:04,680
it would still, Rav Moshe would probably

30
00:01:04,680 --> 00:01:05,900
say one. Could be that it's one.

31
00:01:05,900 --> 00:01:07,580
Could be that it's one. So we'll

32
00:01:07,580 --> 00:01:10,360
see in a little bit about on

33
00:01:10,360 --> 00:01:11,840
this idea. So let's go to source

34
00:01:11,840 --> 00:01:15,580
41. So when it comes to a

35
00:01:15,580 --> 00:01:17,700
cork, okay? So when it comes to

36
00:01:17,700 --> 00:01:20,060
a cork, if you look in source,

37
00:01:20,780 --> 00:01:23,320
so again, most wine bottles today have

38
00:01:23,320 --> 00:01:24,580
the cork and then they also have

39
00:01:24,580 --> 00:01:26,280
some kind of aluminum foil, I don't

40
00:01:26,280 --> 00:01:28,341
know the wines that I buy, some

41
00:01:28,341 --> 00:01:32,620
of them have the twist off. Yeah,

42
00:01:32,620 --> 00:01:37,540
yeah, yeah. So it's a corked bottle,

43
00:01:37,700 --> 00:01:38,901
so to Howard's point, you would still

44
00:01:38,901 --> 00:01:40,740
need the foil wrapping. So in source

45
00:01:40,740 --> 00:01:51,020
41 he paskens the following: בקבוקים שלנו

46
00:01:51,020 --> 00:01:54,600
שבקק של שעוה או מתכת מהודק ועל

47
00:01:54,600 --> 00:01:57,940
יש כיסוי ניילון af she'eino mudpas הרי

48
00:01:57,940 --> 00:02:00,300
הוא כשני חותמות. So again, you would

49
00:02:00,300 --> 00:02:02,040
need two, but it would seem that

50
00:02:02,040 --> 00:02:04,840
if the foil was already removed, potentially

51
00:02:06,140 --> 00:02:08,180
it would be a problem. But if

52
00:02:08,180 --> 00:02:13,000
you go to source... and you twist

53
00:02:13,000 --> 00:02:15,740
off please? So we saw we said

54
00:02:15,740 --> 00:02:19,320
last week with a twist-off lid, so

55
00:02:19,320 --> 00:02:21,080
it's if you twist off that cap,

56
00:02:21,220 --> 00:02:23,000
it's very, almost impossible for you to

57
00:02:23,000 --> 00:02:24,620
put the cap, to reseal the cap

58
00:02:24,620 --> 00:02:26,860
back to the ring. So that would

59
00:02:26,860 --> 00:02:28,960
be a double, as long as so

60
00:02:28,960 --> 00:02:30,340
there you probably would paskin one would

61
00:02:30,340 --> 00:02:31,640
be enough because no way to get

62
00:02:31,640 --> 00:02:35,580
it back. So okay. So if you

63
00:02:35,580 --> 00:02:36,780
look in source 42, just to get

64
00:02:36,780 --> 00:02:38,141
back to corks for a second. בקבוק

65
00:02:38,141 --> 00:02:42,320
יין שבקק שם שאי אפשר לפותחו אלא

66
00:02:42,320 --> 00:02:45,500
על ידי פותחן המקלקל את הפקק, the

67
00:02:45,500 --> 00:02:48,520
way that you do it is that

68
00:02:48,520 --> 00:02:51,600
you destroy the cork. Okay? I don't

69
00:02:51,600 --> 00:02:54,000
know about how fancy people open their

70
00:02:54,000 --> 00:02:55,540
wine bottles, but when I finish with

71
00:02:55,640 --> 00:02:58,040
a corkscrew, that thing is not going

72
00:02:58,040 --> 00:03:02,820
to have... probably seen the bottle at

73
00:03:02,820 --> 00:03:05,300
that point. So he says that's chashuv

74
00:03:05,300 --> 00:03:08,620
k'veis chosamos. He says that would be.

75
00:03:08,620 --> 00:03:10,080
Since the normal way to remove it

76
00:03:10,080 --> 00:03:11,280
is by pulling out with the corkscrew,

77
00:03:11,400 --> 00:03:14,460
which would damage it, the intact cork

78
00:03:14,460 --> 00:03:16,620
would be potentially that would be enough

79
00:03:17,120 --> 00:03:19,840
to ensure that it's a double seal.

80
00:03:19,940 --> 00:03:22,000
So he explains in the footnote. He

81
00:03:22,000 --> 00:03:23,200
says in the footnote he quotes the

82
00:03:23,200 --> 00:03:25,720
Sefer Yayin Malchos. I don't know who

83
00:03:25,720 --> 00:03:27,580
the Sefer Yayin Malchos is, but he

84
00:03:27,580 --> 00:03:29,426
quotes in the Sefer Yayin Malchos שקיבל

85
00:03:29,426 --> 00:03:32,440
ושמע מרבותיו שם שהכל תלוי בטרחא, that

86
00:03:32,440 --> 00:03:34,860
once again, that we're a little bit

87
00:03:34,860 --> 00:03:36,840
nervous because sometimes you could remove a

88
00:03:36,840 --> 00:03:38,460
cork without really destroying the cork. So

89
00:03:38,460 --> 00:03:40,680
what's my concern? My concern is that

90
00:03:40,680 --> 00:03:42,020
if it's not a lot of work

91
00:03:42,020 --> 00:03:43,880
to take out the cork, then maybe

92
00:03:43,880 --> 00:03:46,920
somebody took out the cork, drank some

93
00:03:46,920 --> 00:03:48,200
of the wine, and then just put

94
00:03:48,200 --> 00:03:49,520
the cork back in. I wouldn't know

95
00:03:49,520 --> 00:03:51,140
when I came back. It looks like

96
00:03:51,140 --> 00:03:53,387
they had just... yeah, but in my

97
00:03:53,387 --> 00:03:55,777
limited experience, you can put the cork

98
00:03:55,777 --> 00:03:58,168
back in, but you can't put it

99
00:03:58,168 --> 00:03:59,817
in all the way. Correct, correct. So

100
00:03:59,817 --> 00:04:00,217
he... Correct. If you use the corkscrew,

101
00:04:00,217 --> 00:04:01,617
then it's got a hole in it.

102
00:04:01,617 --> 00:04:02,642
You can see the hole in the

103
00:04:06,179 --> 00:04:09,480
cork. Right, right, right. Right. So again,

104
00:04:09,680 --> 00:04:11,541
I agree. He's quoting this what... but

105
00:04:11,541 --> 00:04:12,660
if you look in the left side,

106
00:04:12,700 --> 00:04:14,961
it's very interesting that he quotes in

107
00:04:14,961 --> 00:04:16,720
the on the left side that this

108
00:04:16,720 --> 00:04:18,440
would not be the same thing when

109
00:04:18,440 --> 00:04:22,440
it comes to champagne, which is why?

110
00:04:22,440 --> 00:04:24,830
Because it pops out, you're not going

111
00:04:24,830 --> 00:04:27,320
to... Right, because the moment it's removed,

112
00:04:27,860 --> 00:04:29,400
you can't get it back in. Okay,

113
00:04:29,560 --> 00:04:31,220
good. Fine. So that's when it comes

114
00:04:32,020 --> 00:04:33,520
to that's when it comes to corks.

115
00:04:33,520 --> 00:04:38,660
So lema'aseh lema'aseh, how do we... here

116
00:04:38,660 --> 00:04:40,600
I am in my... this is all

117
00:04:40,600 --> 00:04:41,860
about what comes to a closed bottle.

118
00:04:42,000 --> 00:04:43,720
Is there any way to keep an

119
00:04:43,720 --> 00:04:46,340
open bottle of wine on my counter

120
00:04:46,340 --> 00:04:48,140
knowing that there might be non-Jewish people

121
00:04:48,140 --> 00:04:49,300
in my house, cleaning up in my

122
00:04:49,300 --> 00:04:50,720
house, or somebody might be present who

123
00:04:50,720 --> 00:04:53,360
might touch the wine? So there are

124
00:04:53,360 --> 00:04:54,340
going to be a number of solutions.

125
00:04:54,540 --> 00:04:56,120
Solution number one is going to be

126
00:04:56,120 --> 00:05:00,160
just create your own double seal, meaning...

127
00:05:00,160 --> 00:05:02,160
I'll figure it out. Take a bag,

128
00:05:02,160 --> 00:05:04,000
wrap some tape around it, make some

129
00:05:04,000 --> 00:05:05,720
fancy I don't know notes and you'll

130
00:05:05,720 --> 00:05:06,940
know that if they ripped it apart,

131
00:05:07,360 --> 00:05:08,420
they ripped it apart, so that would

132
00:05:08,420 --> 00:05:11,160
be fine. If you look in source

133
00:05:11,160 --> 00:05:14,280
43, says the Aruch Hashulchan in source

134
00:05:14,280 --> 00:05:19,200
43 that if you fastened a cap

135
00:05:19,200 --> 00:05:21,807
so tightly, צרירה בחזק פי השק מותר,

136
00:05:22,840 --> 00:05:24,380
if you fastened the cap so tightly

137
00:05:24,380 --> 00:05:26,480
that in order to remove that cap,

138
00:05:26,920 --> 00:05:28,880
I would need some kind of tool.

139
00:05:28,880 --> 00:05:30,700
If you need some kind of tool,

140
00:05:30,920 --> 00:05:33,040
that's considered a chosum acher, דצרירה בעצמה

141
00:05:33,040 --> 00:05:35,500
הוי חותם, and we're going to see

142
00:05:35,500 --> 00:05:37,720
a little bit later, specifically when it

143
00:05:37,720 --> 00:05:39,660
comes to workers, they're not going to

144
00:05:39,660 --> 00:05:42,080
do something that would also threaten their

145
00:05:42,080 --> 00:05:45,560
employment, which we'll get to. So he

146
00:05:45,560 --> 00:05:48,360
explains that same thing, the Aruch Hashulchan

147
00:05:48,360 --> 00:05:49,680
says, that if you fasten it really,

148
00:05:49,720 --> 00:05:51,460
really, really tightly, so if I had

149
00:05:52,060 --> 00:05:53,460
a bag and I tied it really

150
00:05:53,460 --> 00:05:54,740
tight around this thing and the only

151
00:05:54,740 --> 00:05:55,661
way to get the bag off was

152
00:05:55,661 --> 00:05:57,040
to cut it with something, that would

153
00:05:57,040 --> 00:05:59,220
be considered one way to get around

154
00:05:59,220 --> 00:06:02,962
it. Fine. Next, if you go, oh

155
00:06:02,962 --> 00:06:04,761
very interesting, go to source 44. I

156
00:06:04,761 --> 00:06:05,786
don't know if you've ever seen these

157
00:06:05,786 --> 00:06:06,900
in Eretz Yisroel, they have in Israel

158
00:06:06,900 --> 00:06:11,080
these days a bottle cap that has

159
00:06:11,080 --> 00:06:14,460
a numerical code. You see these? So

160
00:06:14,460 --> 00:06:15,620
actually I've seen them, they have the

161
00:06:15,620 --> 00:06:16,940
picture of them in the notes. It's

162
00:06:16,940 --> 00:06:18,660
a cap you put on top and

163
00:06:18,660 --> 00:06:20,180
just like a Shabbos code for your

164
00:06:20,180 --> 00:06:22,540
house, it's a code to get into

165
00:06:22,540 --> 00:06:26,500
the bottle of wine. Okay? Yeah. Get

166
00:06:26,500 --> 00:06:27,980
off my Moscato, you know what I'm

167
00:06:27,980 --> 00:06:32,960
saying? You gotta protect it. Now, so

168
00:06:32,960 --> 00:06:35,140
the shaila is, and you see it

169
00:06:35,140 --> 00:06:38,220
here in source 44, okay, so if

170
00:06:38,220 --> 00:06:40,004
they can only remove it if they

171
00:06:40,004 --> 00:06:42,180
knew the numerical code, now what, this

172
00:06:42,180 --> 00:06:45,161
was created not for drinking, they were

173
00:06:45,161 --> 00:06:47,940
really created to hopefully children don't get

174
00:06:47,940 --> 00:06:49,885
into wine bottles. Right? ובשנים האחרונות נכנס

175
00:06:49,885 --> 00:06:56,120
לשוק דבר הקרוי פקק עם קוד. So

176
00:06:56,120 --> 00:06:59,000
there's bottles that now have a code

177
00:06:59,000 --> 00:07:01,100
with it. And he says now, it's

178
00:07:01,100 --> 00:07:03,400
interesting, it might actually depend on whether

179
00:07:03,400 --> 00:07:04,680
it is a, this is just an

180
00:07:04,680 --> 00:07:05,940
interesting thing, you can say what you

181
00:07:05,940 --> 00:07:08,140
can disagree with either this, whether it's

182
00:07:08,140 --> 00:07:11,380
a three-digit numerical code or a four-digit,

183
00:07:11,460 --> 00:07:12,920
now not to get into Terumos u'Maaseros

184
00:07:12,920 --> 00:07:15,180
yet for next zman, but in order

185
00:07:15,800 --> 00:07:18,120
numerically for me to try all codes

186
00:07:18,120 --> 00:07:19,420
with three digits, how long would it

187
00:07:19,420 --> 00:07:24,100
take me? Very little time. It's not

188
00:07:24,100 --> 00:07:25,660
a ton of time, I don't know.

189
00:07:26,240 --> 00:07:28,782
So he says the following. Shoteh b'shichivah?

190
00:07:28,782 --> 00:07:31,173
It says no. Well, an hour? It's

191
00:07:31,173 --> 00:07:35,420
less than, no, five minutes. Not for

192
00:07:35,420 --> 00:07:37,363
Rain Man. I'm saying like, why would

193
00:07:37,363 --> 00:07:39,753
you need to be troubled? What? You

194
00:07:39,753 --> 00:07:42,144
don't need to know the code for

195
00:07:42,144 --> 00:07:42,827
the front door. The bottle caps say

196
00:07:42,827 --> 00:07:44,581
Luchos, Imos, you know, it's like Shul.

197
00:07:44,581 --> 00:07:50,980
So lemaiseh he says the following. So

198
00:07:51,060 --> 00:07:53,108
he says פקק זה שיכול אדם להסגיר

199
00:07:53,108 --> 00:07:55,499
את הבקבוק באופן שאף אחד לא ישתה

200
00:07:55,499 --> 00:07:56,182
מן הבקבוק ויש לעיין אם נחשב הדבר

201
00:07:56,182 --> 00:07:57,340
כבקבוק חתום אשר לא נחשש למגע יין

202
00:07:57,340 --> 00:08:03,760
נסך. Okay, so now I have this

203
00:08:03,760 --> 00:08:05,340
thing that let's say a guy comes

204
00:08:05,340 --> 00:08:07,281
along and touches the bottle, moves the

205
00:08:07,281 --> 00:08:08,501
bottle, but there's no way that it

206
00:08:08,501 --> 00:08:10,920
affected the wine. So he says that

207
00:08:10,920 --> 00:08:12,580
it seems that it should be okay.

208
00:08:12,580 --> 00:08:14,970
Shulchan Aruch nakat l'dina כיצד היה חותם

209
00:08:14,970 --> 00:08:17,600
בתוך חותם, so the Shulchan Aruch paskens

210
00:08:18,020 --> 00:08:19,900
what is considered a double seal, שהחבית

211
00:08:19,900 --> 00:08:24,240
בכלי שאינו מהודק כדרך שחוסמים כל אדם,

212
00:08:26,219 --> 00:08:29,000
I close it regularly, and then I

213
00:08:29,000 --> 00:08:30,441
put it with some kind of sealant,

214
00:08:30,441 --> 00:08:32,490
that's chosum echad, הכלי מהודק וטוחנו מלמעלה,

215
00:08:32,490 --> 00:08:34,960
if I close it and then I

216
00:08:34,960 --> 00:08:37,288
sealed it, okay, so that's chosum b'toch

217
00:08:37,288 --> 00:08:39,565
chosum. So he says לפי זה היה

218
00:08:39,565 --> 00:08:41,614
מקום לומר שסגירת הפקק תחשב לחותם הראשון,

219
00:08:41,614 --> 00:08:44,560
the bottle is one, and the code

220
00:08:44,560 --> 00:08:46,861
is number two. That's what he holds,

221
00:08:46,861 --> 00:08:47,900
that's what he says, I could make

222
00:08:47,900 --> 00:08:49,740
an argument. The cap, even though it

223
00:08:49,740 --> 00:08:51,160
looks at the same, the same thing,

224
00:08:51,340 --> 00:08:53,060
the cap itself is one, doesn't have

225
00:08:53,060 --> 00:08:54,360
to, as long as it goes on,

226
00:08:54,420 --> 00:08:56,640
doesn't have to seal, and the code

227
00:08:56,640 --> 00:08:58,905
is the seal. Because it's two steps.

228
00:08:58,905 --> 00:09:00,954
Meaning you have to do, yeah, correct,

229
00:09:01,400 --> 00:09:04,500
correct. Meaning step one is that it

230
00:09:04,500 --> 00:09:05,720
has to be closed with something, I

231
00:09:05,720 --> 00:09:06,340
don't have to seal it, I just

232
00:09:06,340 --> 00:09:07,600
have to close it, and close it

233
00:09:07,600 --> 00:09:08,400
with that I locked it, the way

234
00:09:08,400 --> 00:09:09,580
that I locked it is the numerical

235
00:09:09,580 --> 00:09:12,624
code. Fine. Then he says further, ולעניות

236
00:09:12,624 --> 00:09:15,014
דעתי כיוון שעובד יכול לפתוח את הבקבוק

237
00:09:15,014 --> 00:09:20,600
בלי שיורגש כלל. But what's the problem?

238
00:09:21,380 --> 00:09:24,262
If I, do you ever see, remember

239
00:09:24,262 --> 00:09:27,380
an old movie Sneakers? Anybody? Great movie.

240
00:09:28,140 --> 00:09:31,940
Anyway, separate topic. But they crack the,

241
00:09:31,940 --> 00:09:34,760
okay if I crack the code and

242
00:09:34,760 --> 00:09:36,040
I open the bottle of wine, if

243
00:09:36,040 --> 00:09:38,140
I crack your cork, it's not going

244
00:09:38,140 --> 00:09:39,540
to look the same because I destroyed

245
00:09:39,540 --> 00:09:41,160
it. But if I crack the code

246
00:09:41,160 --> 00:09:43,000
and I drink wine and then I

247
00:09:43,000 --> 00:09:45,900
re-lock the code, you're none the wiser.

248
00:09:46,239 --> 00:09:48,387
So he says ולעניות דעתי כיוון שעובד

249
00:09:48,387 --> 00:09:59,160
יכול לפתוח את הבקבוק בלי שיורגש כלל.

250
00:09:59,160 --> 00:10:00,180
The fact though that I could open

251
00:10:00,180 --> 00:10:01,304
it without really anybody noticing, שהרי אם

252
00:10:01,304 --> 00:10:06,760
משאירו בביתו לבדו פחות מחצי שעה. He's

253
00:10:06,760 --> 00:10:07,940
a very smart guy. He could... Instead

254
00:10:07,940 --> 00:10:11,300
of worrying about the code, we should

255
00:10:11,300 --> 00:10:12,782
worry about real things that are that

256
00:10:12,782 --> 00:10:15,007
are impacting Klal Yisrael. How about the

257
00:10:15,007 --> 00:10:16,461
sticker of the lock itself? Why? Why

258
00:10:16,461 --> 00:10:18,851
can't you make a mark, a notation

259
00:10:18,851 --> 00:10:21,242
on the bottle so you can see

260
00:10:21,242 --> 00:10:23,632
if something was taken out? Wait one

261
00:10:23,632 --> 00:10:26,023
second. That's that's a third seal. We're

262
00:10:26,023 --> 00:10:28,413
assuming that the person here is not

263
00:10:28,413 --> 00:10:30,745
having a tiny little sip and moving

264
00:10:30,745 --> 00:10:31,145
on. How do you know that? First

265
00:10:31,145 --> 00:10:32,340
of all, one second. I I go

266
00:10:32,340 --> 00:10:34,840
over to the Go-Meyer house. So you

267
00:10:34,840 --> 00:10:36,200
you left a bottle, you left it

268
00:10:36,200 --> 00:10:37,760
with a marker. Your wife took a

269
00:10:37,760 --> 00:10:39,480
little bit of wine. So later you're

270
00:10:39,520 --> 00:10:41,140
gonna come be choshed that somebody, that's

271
00:10:41,140 --> 00:10:43,285
impossible to know. But you're choshed it's

272
00:10:43,285 --> 00:10:45,676
just me and my wife, but you're

273
00:10:45,676 --> 00:10:48,066
saying there are workers in the house.

274
00:10:48,066 --> 00:10:50,457
So now I leave, no what I'm

275
00:10:50,457 --> 00:10:51,989
saying but I put a mark on

276
00:10:51,989 --> 00:10:52,389
there so I know. Yeah, but you

277
00:10:52,389 --> 00:10:52,789
could put you could I could add

278
00:10:52,789 --> 00:10:53,189
I could put Dr Pepper in there.

279
00:10:53,189 --> 00:10:53,720
I could fill it up with something.

280
00:10:53,720 --> 00:10:56,110
Then you could take the marker and

281
00:10:56,110 --> 00:10:58,501
move the mark. You'd see it, smell

282
00:10:58,501 --> 00:11:00,891
it or taste it, you're going to

283
00:11:00,891 --> 00:11:01,574
know. How, you could change your mark.

284
00:11:01,574 --> 00:11:01,974
You don't know where your mark was.

285
00:11:01,974 --> 00:11:02,374
That's what I'm saying. Right. I don't

286
00:11:02,374 --> 00:11:03,680
know. I don't know. I'm out on

287
00:11:03,680 --> 00:11:06,020
this with this one. I'm pushing back.

288
00:11:06,020 --> 00:11:09,020
Clearly you're not a drinker. Yeah. Yeah.

289
00:11:09,080 --> 00:11:12,640
We could tell, us drinkers. So he

290
00:11:12,640 --> 00:11:14,181
says, but then he says the following,

291
00:11:14,181 --> 00:11:15,880
he says in the in the third

292
00:11:15,880 --> 00:11:17,825
paragraph at the end, לעניות דעתי לא

293
00:11:17,825 --> 00:11:22,800
חששו בכך כגון דטירחא יתירה says three

294
00:11:22,800 --> 00:11:24,520
digits I I don't think it's that

295
00:11:24,520 --> 00:11:25,920
that's so strong. But then he says

296
00:11:25,920 --> 00:11:28,700
the following. He quotes Rav Eliyahu Schlesinger.

297
00:11:28,700 --> 00:11:31,090
Says נראה לעניות דעתי דאפשר לסמוך על

298
00:11:31,090 --> 00:11:34,161
זה כחותם בתוך חותם, actually no, I

299
00:11:34,161 --> 00:11:35,320
I think this is an excellent double

300
00:11:35,320 --> 00:11:37,967
seal. Why? גם גלוי לפניו דקשה מאד

301
00:11:37,967 --> 00:11:41,580
לפענח המספר. He's not going to try

302
00:11:41,580 --> 00:11:43,620
and sit there and attempt to do

303
00:11:43,620 --> 00:11:45,965
the lock. Why? שרוצה לגנוב מבעל הבית

304
00:11:45,965 --> 00:11:48,356
ולעשות דבר נגד הסכמתו לא ישקיע זמן

305
00:11:48,356 --> 00:11:52,340
רב עבור זה. Let's be honest, this

306
00:11:52,340 --> 00:11:53,460
is going to take you at best

307
00:11:53,460 --> 00:11:55,320
a thirty minutes. We're going to talk

308
00:11:55,640 --> 00:11:57,340
soon what other criteria when for what's

309
00:11:57,340 --> 00:12:00,840
called Yotzei Venichnas. Fine. But this guy's

310
00:12:00,840 --> 00:12:02,060
not going to be doing this thing

311
00:12:02,060 --> 00:12:03,580
and therefore he says I think it's

312
00:12:03,580 --> 00:12:05,860
fine. If he really wanted to steal

313
00:12:05,860 --> 00:12:07,260
with for you, it would be easier

314
00:12:07,260 --> 00:12:08,640
just to go and look for money

315
00:12:08,640 --> 00:12:10,320
in your house than to take some

316
00:12:10,320 --> 00:12:12,265
of this wine. ומשום לשתות יין לא

317
00:12:12,265 --> 00:12:14,656
ישקיע זמן לפתוח בקבוק ויעדיף לחפש כסף

318
00:12:14,656 --> 00:12:18,540
אם באמת רוצה לגנוב מבעל הבית. If

319
00:12:18,540 --> 00:12:20,760
he's a real thief, just go find

320
00:12:20,760 --> 00:12:22,260
the the envelope of cash that they

321
00:12:22,260 --> 00:12:23,980
keep in their drawer upstairs and everything

322
00:12:23,980 --> 00:12:25,600
will be fine. So this is this

323
00:12:25,600 --> 00:12:28,340
interesting idea about this this lock. About

324
00:12:28,340 --> 00:12:30,548
the She'elos Uteshuvos forty five, מנעול עם

325
00:12:30,548 --> 00:12:32,939
מספרים על בקבוק יין נחשב כחותם בתוך

326
00:12:32,939 --> 00:12:35,310
חותם. יש מנעול היום עם מספרים kmo,

327
00:12:35,310 --> 00:12:41,940
I'm sorry, bakbuk yayin. They have these

328
00:12:41,940 --> 00:12:44,920
codes. Is that considered like a double

329
00:12:44,920 --> 00:12:46,420
seal? Because it's a big tircha to

330
00:12:46,420 --> 00:12:48,924
figure it out? Says Rav Nevenzahl, tircha

331
00:12:48,924 --> 00:12:53,440
yes, והנחשב כחותם בתוך חותם. So if

332
00:12:53,440 --> 00:12:54,480
you had an open bottle of wine

333
00:12:54,480 --> 00:12:56,340
and you had this fancy-fancy code lock

334
00:12:56,340 --> 00:12:58,520
thing, your wine would be fine and

335
00:12:58,520 --> 00:13:01,200
you could continue to drink it. Okay.

336
00:13:01,260 --> 00:13:06,460
So that's approach number two. If you

337
00:13:06,460 --> 00:13:08,484
go in the Shulchan Aruch, just to

338
00:13:08,484 --> 00:13:10,240
show you, we go to Siman Kuf

339
00:13:10,240 --> 00:13:13,420
Lamed, okay, go to Kuf Lamed Beis.

340
00:13:25,360 --> 00:13:31,484
Okay. Now, says the Shulchan Aruch, המפקיד

341
00:13:31,484 --> 00:13:33,520
ביד עובד כוכבים, if you gave the

342
00:13:33,520 --> 00:13:35,364
guy your bottle of wine, בחותם אחד

343
00:13:35,364 --> 00:13:37,754
אסור בשתיה ומותר בהנאה, you can't drink

344
00:13:37,754 --> 00:13:40,145
it but you can get benefit from

345
00:13:40,145 --> 00:13:44,200
it. ושהניח לו קרן זוית. That's when

346
00:13:44,200 --> 00:13:45,300
he sort of gave you a a

347
00:13:45,300 --> 00:13:46,660
place to put it. And then the

348
00:13:46,660 --> 00:13:48,745
Rema says the following. ויש שכתבו דבדיעבד

349
00:13:48,745 --> 00:13:54,520
יש להתיר אפילו בחותם אחד. Says the

350
00:13:54,520 --> 00:13:56,460
Rema, if one seal we would be

351
00:13:56,460 --> 00:13:58,404
meikal if we needed to. ואין צריך

352
00:13:58,404 --> 00:14:00,794
להכיר חותמו אם לא שראה שהחותם מקולקל

353
00:14:00,794 --> 00:14:05,240
אסור. So says the Rema, potentially we

354
00:14:05,240 --> 00:14:10,240
would be meikal bedieved with one with

355
00:14:10,240 --> 00:14:14,040
one seal, potentially even lechatchila. Why? So

356
00:14:14,040 --> 00:14:16,060
we saw earlier in קוף יוד חית

357
00:14:16,220 --> 00:14:20,680
א. Yes, we should have it here.

358
00:14:21,760 --> 00:14:24,080
Okay, you don't have to look at

359
00:14:24,080 --> 00:14:25,460
this one, but in קוף יוד חית

360
00:14:25,460 --> 00:14:30,600
א says the Shulchan Aruch, קוף יוד

361
00:14:30,600 --> 00:14:32,880
חית א, hold on, it's a long

362
00:14:32,880 --> 00:14:34,940
siman, it's a long sif here, but

363
00:14:34,940 --> 00:14:36,760
the Shulchan Aruch here paskens that a

364
00:14:36,760 --> 00:14:39,540
double seal was needed only if the

365
00:14:39,540 --> 00:14:41,520
violation I am talking about is what

366
00:14:41,520 --> 00:14:46,700
level? De-Oraisa. We today, what we're talking

367
00:14:46,700 --> 00:14:49,660
about, is at best a de-rabanan. So

368
00:14:49,660 --> 00:14:51,260
maybe I would not need to have

369
00:14:51,260 --> 00:14:53,620
a a double seal. So in comes

370
00:14:53,620 --> 00:14:56,860
the Aruch Hashulchan in source forty-six. So

371
00:14:56,860 --> 00:14:58,900
we had a big Rema that said

372
00:14:58,920 --> 00:15:00,860
this whole thing doesn't really apply. So

373
00:15:00,860 --> 00:15:02,360
in comes the Aruch Hashulchan and he

374
00:15:02,360 --> 00:15:04,102
says, hold on a second. כבר נתבאר

375
00:15:04,102 --> 00:15:09,600
דבאיסור דאורייתא צריך שני חותמות. You're right,

376
00:15:09,680 --> 00:15:11,080
I need double covering. If I want

377
00:15:11,080 --> 00:15:13,580
to send you meat, I need to

378
00:15:13,580 --> 00:15:14,740
have a double covering. It's got to

379
00:15:14,740 --> 00:15:17,840
be double sealed. ואיסור דרבנן די בחותם

380
00:15:18,200 --> 00:15:21,405
אחד. One's enough. ויין אף שמי דרבנן

381
00:15:21,405 --> 00:15:25,340
החמירו בו כשל תורה. We might be

382
00:15:25,340 --> 00:15:28,340
machmir. Why are we machmir? We said

383
00:15:28,340 --> 00:15:29,501
earlier at the beginning of this month

384
00:15:29,501 --> 00:15:30,960
why are we machmirin in Yayin Nesach?

385
00:15:31,360 --> 00:15:33,261
Because of what it potentially could be

386
00:15:33,261 --> 00:15:34,700
and it's Avoda Zara and things like

387
00:15:34,700 --> 00:15:36,580
that. That's because we were choshesh for

388
00:15:36,580 --> 00:15:40,501
chibash nisuch. But today he says, ולכן

389
00:15:40,501 --> 00:15:42,891
הסכימו כמה מהגדולים דבזמן הזה לא שייך

390
00:15:42,891 --> 00:15:46,140
זה. There is, if you're telling me

391
00:15:46,140 --> 00:15:48,760
there was still Avoda Zara happening, so

392
00:15:48,760 --> 00:15:50,220
then I have to be worried. There's

393
00:15:50,220 --> 00:15:51,900
no Avoda Zara happening. So now we're

394
00:15:51,900 --> 00:15:53,900
back to d'Rabbanan. I should have one

395
00:15:53,900 --> 00:15:56,290
seal ככל איסורי דרבנן וכן יש להורות.

396
00:15:56,290 --> 00:15:57,900
So says the Aruch Hashulchan, I really

397
00:15:57,900 --> 00:16:00,720
could be meikel. Now, we are not,

398
00:16:00,880 --> 00:16:02,020
we do not pasken this way lechatchila

399
00:16:02,460 --> 00:16:05,240
like the Aruch Hashulchan. But in the

400
00:16:05,240 --> 00:16:07,520
case of a person had, I don't

401
00:16:07,520 --> 00:16:09,421
know, twenty-five wine bottles at home and

402
00:16:09,421 --> 00:16:10,540
and there was a maid who went

403
00:16:10,540 --> 00:16:12,560
through the housekeeper and it's a huge

404
00:16:12,560 --> 00:16:14,600
hefsed merube case, we might be meikel

405
00:16:14,600 --> 00:16:17,040
based on this Aruch Hashulchan that you

406
00:16:17,040 --> 00:16:18,900
know there's room to be lenient. That

407
00:16:18,900 --> 00:16:21,180
plus there's room to be lenient if

408
00:16:21,180 --> 00:16:22,860
I'm worried that the goy, you know,

409
00:16:22,960 --> 00:16:24,760
would never touch it because if they

410
00:16:24,760 --> 00:16:25,860
knew they touched it they would lose

411
00:16:25,860 --> 00:16:27,480
their job or whatever it is that

412
00:16:27,480 --> 00:16:29,600
potentially there is what to be lenient

413
00:16:29,600 --> 00:16:32,760
on. Okay. So lechatchila I can create

414
00:16:32,760 --> 00:16:34,580
my own double seal, I can close

415
00:16:34,580 --> 00:16:36,820
a cork really tight, or maybe even

416
00:16:36,820 --> 00:16:38,120
in case of need I could be

417
00:16:38,120 --> 00:16:41,380
meikel on this Aruch Hashulchan. Okay. The

418
00:16:41,380 --> 00:16:43,760
final way is, well, let's say I

419
00:16:43,760 --> 00:16:45,280
don't have any of those, but I

420
00:16:45,280 --> 00:16:47,780
have something called yotzei v'nichnas. Now what's

421
00:16:47,780 --> 00:16:50,420
yotzei v'nichnas? Says the Gemara the following.

422
00:16:50,540 --> 00:16:52,280
Says the Mishna in Avoda Zara. You

423
00:16:52,280 --> 00:16:53,840
have to understand there's certain criteria for

424
00:16:53,840 --> 00:16:57,180
what it means yotzei v'nichnas. So says

425
00:16:57,180 --> 00:16:59,960
the Mishna that if I want to

426
00:16:59,960 --> 00:17:03,080
leave my produce of kosher wine in

427
00:17:03,080 --> 00:17:05,819
a non-kosher winery, so he says the

428
00:17:05,819 --> 00:17:08,210
following: התיר יינם של עובדי כוכבים ומזלות

429
00:17:08,210 --> 00:17:10,319
ברשותו. And I want to put it

430
00:17:10,319 --> 00:17:11,859
in his, in his reshus, and the

431
00:17:11,859 --> 00:17:14,119
non-Jew's reshus, and that reshus, his property,

432
00:17:14,119 --> 00:17:17,260
is pasuach l'reshus harabbim, and it opens,

433
00:17:17,400 --> 00:17:23,180
everybody's there, ובעיר שיש בה עובדי כוכבים

434
00:17:23,180 --> 00:17:26,040
וישראלים, that is mutar. That is mutar.

435
00:17:26,460 --> 00:17:28,722
Why is that mutar? So Rashi says

436
00:17:28,722 --> 00:17:31,980
דמירתת ליה עובד כוכבים ולא נגע. Why?

437
00:17:32,700 --> 00:17:35,820
Because the goy, he's he's nervous, not

438
00:17:35,820 --> 00:17:37,484
going to touch it. דאמר דלמא חזי

439
00:17:37,484 --> 00:17:41,180
להנך ישראל דעברי ברשותא ומפסדינא. Maybe something's

440
00:17:41,180 --> 00:17:41,780
going to happen, I'm going to lose

441
00:17:41,780 --> 00:17:42,620
it, I'm not going to touch it.

442
00:17:42,620 --> 00:17:44,580
Because a Jew might come in and

443
00:17:44,580 --> 00:17:46,420
if he he comes in and I

444
00:17:46,420 --> 00:17:48,760
might risk selling all, he's giving me

445
00:17:48,760 --> 00:17:50,060
wine to sell, he knows that I

446
00:17:50,060 --> 00:17:51,820
can't, I'm the middleman, the goy says.

447
00:17:52,220 --> 00:17:53,681
If the if the Jew comes in

448
00:17:53,681 --> 00:17:54,400
and sees him touching his wine, ah,

449
00:17:54,760 --> 00:17:55,660
it's not going to be good for

450
00:17:55,660 --> 00:17:56,760
my business, not going to give me

451
00:17:56,760 --> 00:18:00,340
any more wine. Fine. Okay. Says the

452
00:18:00,340 --> 00:18:04,260
Gemara, the Mishna continues, if עיר שכולה

453
00:18:04,260 --> 00:18:06,682
עובדי כוכבים, then it's assur. However, ad

454
00:18:06,682 --> 00:18:11,320
sheyeishev u'mshamer. However, as long as you

455
00:18:11,320 --> 00:18:13,862
have a shomer, that's okay. And the

456
00:18:13,862 --> 00:18:16,253
shomer doesn't need to be yoshev u'mshamer.

457
00:18:16,253 --> 00:18:16,653
I don't need the guy to be

458
00:18:16,653 --> 00:18:19,480
sitting there twenty-four seven, three-sixty-five watching and

459
00:18:19,580 --> 00:18:21,865
watching watching it. אף על פי שיצא

460
00:18:21,865 --> 00:18:24,861
ונכנס מותר. As long as I'm yotzei

461
00:18:24,861 --> 00:18:29,100
v'nichnas. Okay. Now, the next Mishna in

462
00:18:29,100 --> 00:18:31,680
Avoda Zara in source forty-eight X that

463
00:18:31,680 --> 00:18:34,260
if I if I leave a non-Jew

464
00:18:34,260 --> 00:18:36,247
in my store המניח עובד כוכבים בחנות

465
00:18:36,247 --> 00:18:40,980
אף על פי שיצא ונכנס מותר. So

466
00:18:40,980 --> 00:18:42,102
there's a non-Jew in my, I have

467
00:18:42,102 --> 00:18:44,160
a non-Jewish worker, how am I worried

468
00:18:44,460 --> 00:18:45,540
because he knows that I'm in and

469
00:18:45,540 --> 00:18:49,320
out. ואם הודיעו שהוא מפליג כדי שישתום

470
00:18:49,700 --> 00:18:55,060
ויסתום ויגוב. That he could do what?

471
00:18:55,400 --> 00:18:57,560
So long as the we'll see Rabban

472
00:18:57,560 --> 00:18:59,200
Gamliel in a second. But so long

473
00:18:59,200 --> 00:19:00,380
as he's not going to be for

474
00:19:00,380 --> 00:19:01,780
enough time that he's going to be

475
00:19:01,780 --> 00:19:04,100
able to destroy it, take it out,

476
00:19:04,180 --> 00:19:06,487
refill it. רבן שמעון בן גמליאל אומר

477
00:19:06,487 --> 00:19:08,200
כדי שיפתח את החבית ויגוב. He's got

478
00:19:08,200 --> 00:19:10,620
to open the barrel, and he's got

479
00:19:10,620 --> 00:19:12,760
to, you know, make the new lid,

480
00:19:12,760 --> 00:19:13,880
and then he's got to, you know,

481
00:19:13,920 --> 00:19:15,720
dry it and all these things. But

482
00:19:15,720 --> 00:19:17,180
if I did leave for that long

483
00:19:17,180 --> 00:19:18,480
enough time, says Rashi on the left

484
00:19:18,480 --> 00:19:20,870
side, בשם רבן שמעון בן גמליאל אינו

485
00:19:20,870 --> 00:19:23,260
נאסר אלא עד שישהה כדי שיפתח את

486
00:19:23,260 --> 00:19:24,720
כל מגופת החבית. If I told him

487
00:19:24,800 --> 00:19:26,560
listen, I'm heading out, I'm going to

488
00:19:26,560 --> 00:19:27,840
be on a flight for the next

489
00:19:27,840 --> 00:19:30,020
three hours, that's enough time to open

490
00:19:30,020 --> 00:19:31,600
the barrel, to make a new lid,

491
00:19:31,740 --> 00:19:33,260
to reseal it and everything, then it

492
00:19:33,260 --> 00:19:35,420
would be assur. Okay. This is what

493
00:19:35,420 --> 00:19:38,460
we call yotzei v'nichnas. In comes the

494
00:19:38,460 --> 00:19:39,900
Tur as the Tur explains the following.

495
00:19:40,460 --> 00:19:43,102
So the the Tur says, he quotes

496
00:19:43,102 --> 00:19:48,580
the Rosh but yeah we're going to

497
00:19:48,580 --> 00:19:52,980
see in a second. Now the Gemara

498
00:19:52,980 --> 00:19:55,780
later Rava in the Gemara explains when

499
00:19:55,780 --> 00:19:58,700
רבן שמעון בן גמליאל said this that's

500
00:19:58,700 --> 00:20:00,362
only if there's another criteria. criterion and

501
00:20:00,400 --> 00:20:03,700
that is the Jew the non-Jew can't

502
00:20:03,700 --> 00:20:05,840
see the Jew coming. So like if

503
00:20:05,840 --> 00:20:07,540
the store is open and there's just

504
00:20:07,540 --> 00:20:09,700
one thoroughfare and he's at the end

505
00:20:09,700 --> 00:20:11,340
of it I know he's coming then

506
00:20:11,600 --> 00:20:12,920
that wouldn't work. But if there's many

507
00:20:12,920 --> 00:20:14,480
ways to get in the house there's

508
00:20:14,480 --> 00:20:16,160
many ways that he I the Jew

509
00:20:16,160 --> 00:20:18,160
might just show up that's what רבן

510
00:20:18,160 --> 00:20:19,100
שמעון בן גמליאל's going to be okay

511
00:20:19,100 --> 00:20:21,300
with. So says the Tur using this

512
00:20:21,300 --> 00:20:23,140
opinion of Rava. Says in the in

513
00:20:23,140 --> 00:20:26,385
the bottom right side: מותר בשל זמן

514
00:20:26,385 --> 00:20:28,776
רב שהוא ירא בכל פעם אתא יבא

515
00:20:28,776 --> 00:20:30,980
ויראני We know this that's what we

516
00:20:30,980 --> 00:20:32,740
just said. He's it's always muttar even

517
00:20:32,740 --> 00:20:33,980
if it's a long time because he

518
00:20:33,980 --> 00:20:36,220
doesn't know when the Jew is going

519
00:20:36,220 --> 00:20:38,385
to be coming. ובלבד שלא יסגר הגוי

520
00:20:38,385 --> 00:20:41,360
החנות that he can't be locked in

521
00:20:41,360 --> 00:20:44,004
there by himself right? ולא ירחיק הקרון

522
00:20:44,004 --> 00:20:46,220
והספינה and the sefinah can't be too

523
00:20:46,220 --> 00:20:48,347
far away. במה דברים אמורים שיש שם

524
00:20:48,347 --> 00:20:49,960
דרך עקלקלות where there's some kind of

525
00:20:50,000 --> 00:20:51,985
you know angle שיכול לבא עליו פתאום

526
00:20:53,460 --> 00:20:56,002
like the pasuk says in Malakhi the

527
00:20:56,002 --> 00:20:59,565
ge'ulah will come yavo pit'om. Just comes

528
00:20:59,565 --> 00:21:03,500
suddenly. That's the famous Zionist versus Chasidish

529
00:21:03,500 --> 00:21:07,240
debate about Zionism. The debate about Zionism

530
00:21:07,240 --> 00:21:08,561
is based on that pasuk in Malakhi

531
00:21:08,561 --> 00:21:10,780
pit'om versus whatever. It's a good discussion.

532
00:21:11,700 --> 00:21:13,240
So he says if I'm going to

533
00:21:13,240 --> 00:21:15,360
the beit hamerchatz and I'm going to

534
00:21:15,360 --> 00:21:17,985
go this roundabout way בענין שלא ידע

535
00:21:17,985 --> 00:21:20,376
הגוי שהלך לבית המרחץ like Shaya just

536
00:21:20,376 --> 00:21:21,480
said he doesn't know where I'm going.

537
00:21:21,480 --> 00:21:24,120
אכן ירא בכל פעם אתא יבא And

538
00:21:24,120 --> 00:21:25,440
he's always worried maybe he's going to

539
00:21:25,440 --> 00:21:28,340
come. So number one is in addition

540
00:21:28,340 --> 00:21:30,260
to all these other things he says

541
00:21:30,260 --> 00:21:31,420
he can't be away for an extended

542
00:21:31,420 --> 00:21:33,680
period of time and he also has

543
00:21:33,680 --> 00:21:35,300
to make sure that he can come

544
00:21:35,300 --> 00:21:37,240
in at any time. So you have

545
00:21:37,240 --> 00:21:39,820
four criteria you have four criteria based

546
00:21:39,820 --> 00:21:42,100
on this Tur. Number one the non-Jew

547
00:21:42,100 --> 00:21:43,380
thinks the Jew could come at any

548
00:21:43,380 --> 00:21:44,840
single time. If he thinks he's going

549
00:21:44,840 --> 00:21:46,160
to come at any single time that's

550
00:21:46,160 --> 00:21:46,940
number one and we're going to see

551
00:21:46,940 --> 00:21:47,900
how many of these we need. Number

552
00:21:47,900 --> 00:21:50,520
two when the Jew comes back he

553
00:21:50,520 --> 00:21:52,240
opens the door and the door has

554
00:21:52,240 --> 00:21:54,760
to be unlocked. If the door is

555
00:21:54,760 --> 00:21:57,640
locked that's a problem. Number two. Number

556
00:21:57,640 --> 00:21:59,060
three that the Jew is able to

557
00:21:59,060 --> 00:22:01,740
show up you know suddenly right? That's

558
00:22:01,740 --> 00:22:04,420
number three the first yotze venichnas not

559
00:22:04,420 --> 00:22:06,520
locked and suddenly. And the fourth is

560
00:22:06,520 --> 00:22:07,680
that I don't know how long he's

561
00:22:07,680 --> 00:22:09,825
leaving for. Okay. The third you said

562
00:22:09,825 --> 00:22:15,681
you're not going to know when he's

563
00:22:15,681 --> 00:22:18,071
coming. If you have a store that

564
00:22:18,071 --> 00:22:20,462
you're leaving with and you got cameras

565
00:22:20,462 --> 00:22:20,862
whatever you can Ooh don't but we'll

566
00:22:20,862 --> 00:22:21,262
get to the cameras in a second.

567
00:22:21,262 --> 00:22:21,662
Ooh. Let's go to source 15 now.

568
00:22:21,662 --> 00:22:22,062
Oh sorry go to the Shulchan Aruch

569
00:22:22,062 --> 00:22:23,240
one second. קכט א and then we're

570
00:22:23,240 --> 00:22:31,620
going to see about cameras. Okay so

571
00:22:31,620 --> 00:22:33,402
the Shulchan Aruch says in קכט א

572
00:22:33,402 --> 00:22:36,180
here המניח עובד כוכבים בחנותו if I

573
00:22:36,180 --> 00:22:39,300
left a goi in my store ויצא

574
00:22:39,300 --> 00:22:41,307
and I left או שהיה לו יין

575
00:22:41,307 --> 00:22:43,220
בספינה or I have it on a

576
00:22:43,220 --> 00:22:45,065
boat on a wagon והניחו עם עובד

577
00:22:45,065 --> 00:22:46,120
כוכבים and I left it with a

578
00:22:46,120 --> 00:22:48,168
goi והלך לבית הכנסת או לבית המרחץ

579
00:22:48,680 --> 00:22:50,120
I went to shul or I went

580
00:22:50,120 --> 00:22:52,007
to the bathhouse שעובד כוכבים עובר לו

581
00:22:52,007 --> 00:22:54,200
חביות or he's traveling with it so

582
00:22:54,200 --> 00:22:55,360
he says it's all going to be

583
00:22:55,360 --> 00:22:58,200
okay אפילו שהה זמן רב even if

584
00:22:58,200 --> 00:22:59,846
it's a long time דהוא ירא בכל

585
00:22:59,846 --> 00:23:01,700
שעה אתא יבא ויראני maybe he's going

586
00:23:01,700 --> 00:23:02,701
to come that's what we said שלא

587
00:23:05,100 --> 00:23:08,101
נודע שסגר עובד כוכבים החנות it's not

588
00:23:08,101 --> 00:23:09,125
locked שהרחיק or that people are unable

589
00:23:09,125 --> 00:23:10,660
to see him. So again and he

590
00:23:10,660 --> 00:23:12,700
continues on the following: according to the

591
00:23:12,700 --> 00:23:14,520
Shulchan Aruch you need how many of

592
00:23:14,520 --> 00:23:17,540
the four conditions? All. If you get

593
00:23:17,540 --> 00:23:18,880
back and the door is locked or

594
00:23:18,880 --> 00:23:20,260
if you get back and the guy

595
00:23:20,260 --> 00:23:23,120
knew that you were coming all bets

596
00:23:23,120 --> 00:23:25,840
are off. Doesn't work. Doesn't work. So

597
00:23:26,140 --> 00:23:27,840
okay so today we have lots of

598
00:23:27,840 --> 00:23:29,020
people in our homes people coming in

599
00:23:29,020 --> 00:23:30,561
and out of our homes. So what

600
00:23:30,561 --> 00:23:32,420
what what's the problem? So look at

601
00:23:32,420 --> 00:23:42,000
source 50. Yeah if you look there's

602
00:23:42,000 --> 00:23:43,620
a good Shach. It's not a big

603
00:23:43,620 --> 00:23:51,620
Shach. If you go to the Shach

604
00:23:51,620 --> 00:23:55,920
in קיח מב. קיח מב. So this

605
00:23:57,260 --> 00:24:01,440
Shach here קיח מב that the Shach

606
00:24:01,440 --> 00:24:03,800
says that we really limit this idea

607
00:24:03,800 --> 00:24:07,221
of yotze venichnas to really be bedi'eved

608
00:24:07,221 --> 00:24:09,320
only if the owner is actually out

609
00:24:09,320 --> 00:24:11,480
for a long time. If he's out

610
00:24:11,480 --> 00:24:12,640
for a long time longer than it

611
00:24:12,640 --> 00:24:13,880
takes to seal everything then we would

612
00:24:13,880 --> 00:24:15,360
need all of these like all these

613
00:24:15,360 --> 00:24:16,680
conditions. If it's a very short time

614
00:24:17,280 --> 00:24:19,920
we're probably not so concerned. If the

615
00:24:19,920 --> 00:24:21,980
guy is actually yotze venichnas in and

616
00:24:21,980 --> 00:24:23,080
out in and out in and out

617
00:24:23,080 --> 00:24:25,720
like every five minutes you don't need

618
00:24:25,720 --> 00:24:27,880
the door locked like if he says

619
00:24:27,880 --> 00:24:30,180
I'm running to my car and he

620
00:24:30,180 --> 00:24:31,420
locks the door and you get right

621
00:24:31,420 --> 00:24:32,940
back we're not worried that in that

622
00:24:32,940 --> 00:24:34,560
30 seconds even though he locked the

623
00:24:34,560 --> 00:24:37,300
door he undid the lid and then

624
00:24:37,300 --> 00:24:38,480
he put the lid back on and

625
00:24:38,480 --> 00:24:40,660
he resealed it. He's not the Flash.

626
00:24:41,080 --> 00:24:44,780
Okay. So now go to source 50.

627
00:24:45,280 --> 00:24:47,500
Okay. So what about cameras? Cameras are

628
00:24:47,500 --> 00:24:49,240
a big big topic in halachah especially

629
00:24:49,240 --> 00:24:51,200
within the world of kashrut of mashgichim

630
00:24:51,200 --> 00:24:54,020
things like that. So the Sefer Hashulchan

631
00:24:54,020 --> 00:24:56,840
K'Hilchato paskens that if I am able

632
00:24:56,840 --> 00:24:59,100
to install cameras in my kitchen then

633
00:24:59,100 --> 00:25:01,020
maybe I could tell the cleaning help

634
00:25:01,080 --> 00:25:03,100
you can't touch because I'm going to

635
00:25:03,100 --> 00:25:04,160
check the cameras. So would that be

636
00:25:04,160 --> 00:25:05,525
yotze venichnas? So he says: במקום שקשה

637
00:25:05,525 --> 00:25:09,220
מאוד לשמור את היין if I can't

638
00:25:09,220 --> 00:25:11,202
really watch the watch the wine, I

639
00:25:11,202 --> 00:25:13,593
don't have a shomer there או עבור

640
00:25:13,593 --> 00:25:15,983
זה עובד זר נכרי קבוע בבית של

641
00:25:15,983 --> 00:25:16,800
אדם מוגבל או זקן and sometimes it

642
00:25:16,800 --> 00:25:18,120
happens, a person has a caretaker, a

643
00:25:18,120 --> 00:25:20,560
person has an aid. They're not they're

644
00:25:20,560 --> 00:25:22,260
not there, you can't have a Jew

645
00:25:22,260 --> 00:25:23,904
there the whole time. אפשר להתקין מצלמות

646
00:25:23,904 --> 00:25:25,760
על היינות ולהודיע לנכרי you could put

647
00:25:25,760 --> 00:25:28,862
a camera and you could say hey,

648
00:25:28,862 --> 00:25:31,820
אפשר בכל רגע לראות I'm always going

649
00:25:31,820 --> 00:25:33,928
to check אם נוגעים ביין שאסור להם

650
00:25:33,928 --> 00:25:36,340
לנגוע ביין. Right? So that would seem

651
00:25:36,340 --> 00:25:38,680
to be okay, that's basically a camera

652
00:25:38,680 --> 00:25:40,664
is taking the place of a yotze

653
00:25:40,664 --> 00:25:44,980
venichnas. Okay. Now, he quotes in the

654
00:25:44,980 --> 00:25:49,220
footnote that potentially we would also seemingly

655
00:25:49,220 --> 00:25:51,589
allow this: יש בזה שני צדי היתר.

656
00:25:51,589 --> 00:25:55,080
האחד כיוצא ונכנס בלא זמן רב there's

657
00:25:55,080 --> 00:25:58,000
no there's no zman rav anymore. I'm

658
00:25:58,000 --> 00:26:01,100
always watching you. Therefore afillu l'chatchila and

659
00:26:01,100 --> 00:26:04,020
also they're also always mifached tamid, they're

660
00:26:04,020 --> 00:26:06,307
always worried. והשני שיש נקב בדלת שישראל

661
00:26:06,307 --> 00:26:08,697
יכול לראות את הנכרי ואז היין אינו

662
00:26:08,697 --> 00:26:11,820
נאסר. If there was a hole in

663
00:26:11,820 --> 00:26:12,720
the door that they could always look

664
00:26:12,720 --> 00:26:14,560
through, that would be the same thing.

665
00:26:14,700 --> 00:26:16,340
So why would a camera be any

666
00:26:16,340 --> 00:26:19,060
different? So we pasken like this, or

667
00:26:19,060 --> 00:26:20,080
we pasken like this and we would

668
00:26:20,080 --> 00:26:22,500
be okay with this. However, however, we

669
00:26:22,500 --> 00:26:23,580
don't pasken like this for a lot

670
00:26:23,800 --> 00:26:25,580
there's a big debate amongst kashrus organizations

671
00:26:25,580 --> 00:26:27,940
about doing this for mashgichim. Could you

672
00:26:27,940 --> 00:26:29,680
have a mashgiach that's in the I

673
00:26:29,680 --> 00:26:30,760
don't need a mashgiach anymore, I have

674
00:26:30,760 --> 00:26:32,900
a camera, and someone's always watching you.

675
00:26:32,940 --> 00:26:34,380
So first of all, we're not going

676
00:26:34,380 --> 00:26:35,020
to get into it now but we

677
00:26:35,020 --> 00:26:36,520
can talk about, you know, different different

678
00:26:36,520 --> 00:26:38,940
policies. What would be part of the

679
00:26:38,940 --> 00:26:43,680
problem with that? Technical glitches. What else?

680
00:26:44,300 --> 00:26:46,540
You're not really watching all the time.

681
00:26:46,540 --> 00:26:48,930
But you have be'di'avad playback. Right. Now

682
00:26:48,930 --> 00:26:50,920
you also isn't seeing everything anyway. Yeah,

683
00:26:51,060 --> 00:26:53,140
yet the mashgiach himself might not know

684
00:26:53,140 --> 00:26:54,720
what he's doing, that's a separate conversation

685
00:26:54,720 --> 00:26:56,760
if he's not trained enough. But am

686
00:26:56,760 --> 00:27:00,380
I really checking? So interestingly, if you

687
00:27:00,380 --> 00:27:02,980
look in source number 51 in the

688
00:27:02,980 --> 00:27:05,840
Teshuvos Vehanhagos of Rav Sternbuch, so Rav

689
00:27:05,840 --> 00:27:10,200
Sternbuch says 51, this would not work.

690
00:27:10,240 --> 00:27:12,020
It might work for yayin nesech if

691
00:27:12,020 --> 00:27:13,380
you have put in a camera in

692
00:27:13,380 --> 00:27:15,320
an, you know, in an old age

693
00:27:15,320 --> 00:27:16,561
home for a person who has an

694
00:27:16,561 --> 00:27:18,200
aid, it would not work for cholov

695
00:27:18,200 --> 00:27:20,500
yisroel. Meaning if you want to be

696
00:27:20,580 --> 00:27:21,260
if you want to hold like cholov

697
00:27:21,260 --> 00:27:22,560
yisroel and you want to have a

698
00:27:22,560 --> 00:27:24,420
milk that was watched by a Jew,

699
00:27:25,020 --> 00:27:26,440
it doesn't work. So he says the

700
00:27:26,440 --> 00:27:29,422
following: bi'er b'Teshuvos Vehanhagos the following he

701
00:27:29,422 --> 00:27:31,813
says: אם אפשר לסמוך שאכן המשגיח בודק

702
00:27:31,813 --> 00:27:35,486
תמיד כל היום כל התצלומים ממקום החליבה

703
00:27:35,486 --> 00:27:41,320
why not? The guy, the mashgiach is

704
00:27:41,320 --> 00:27:42,740
going to check every single day the

705
00:27:42,740 --> 00:27:44,804
place where they milked וממילא גם האקום

706
00:27:44,804 --> 00:27:48,161
החולב לא מרתע לאורב and he says

707
00:27:48,161 --> 00:27:49,868
nonetheless, נראה שסומך שלא בודקים התצלומים תמיד.

708
00:27:53,820 --> 00:27:56,200
We know, we know, you're not you're

709
00:27:56,200 --> 00:27:58,407
not watching this וכן אני מפקפק אם

710
00:27:58,407 --> 00:28:01,540
המצלמה קולטת כל הנעשה and in addition,

711
00:28:02,140 --> 00:28:04,120
they don't capture every single thing at

712
00:28:04,120 --> 00:28:06,327
every single moment וכן גם ה like

713
00:28:06,327 --> 00:28:08,141
the the everything else stays the same,

714
00:28:08,141 --> 00:28:10,532
they don't capture everything. Ah, okay. So

715
00:28:10,532 --> 00:28:12,922
CRC does use, CRC does use it

716
00:28:12,922 --> 00:28:22,081
for some aspects like the fish market

717
00:28:22,081 --> 00:28:24,471
is under the hashgacha of their cameras

718
00:28:24,471 --> 00:28:26,862
to see that they don't bring in

719
00:28:26,862 --> 00:28:28,911
any non-kosher fish. Right. So the fish

720
00:28:28,911 --> 00:28:31,801
market is under the hashgacha of the

721
00:28:31,801 --> 00:28:33,882
CRC by camera. I'm saying a lot

722
00:28:33,882 --> 00:28:35,700
of kashrus, he's not one second, hold

723
00:28:35,700 --> 00:28:37,980
on a second. Rav Sternbuch isn't saying

724
00:28:37,980 --> 00:28:40,140
he's he's arguing that potentially for something

725
00:28:40,140 --> 00:28:41,520
cholov yisroel he doesn't know that he

726
00:28:41,520 --> 00:28:42,520
would rely on it. That doesn't mean

727
00:28:42,520 --> 00:28:44,181
that other people could disagree with Rav

728
00:28:44,181 --> 00:28:45,120
Sternbuch. Rav Sternbuch's not talking about all

729
00:28:45,120 --> 00:28:48,360
cameras all the time. We don't we

730
00:28:48,360 --> 00:28:50,220
don't allow cameras for yichud issues, for

731
00:28:50,220 --> 00:28:52,900
example, right? Why not? Ah, you there

732
00:28:52,900 --> 00:28:54,860
should be because there you need people.

733
00:28:55,020 --> 00:28:57,380
Ah, that's just sometimes the presence of

734
00:28:57,380 --> 00:29:00,080
somebody is different. To Shai's point, you're

735
00:29:00,080 --> 00:29:02,960
right, you're right. So you know this

736
00:29:02,960 --> 00:29:04,960
is the very famous machine matzah debate,

737
00:29:05,300 --> 00:29:07,240
okay? So the machine matzah debate was

738
00:29:07,240 --> 00:29:09,640
this very thing, right? The, you know,

739
00:29:09,640 --> 00:29:15,240
the first was only machine and come

740
00:29:15,240 --> 00:29:20,380
on. What about sneakers? I don't know,

741
00:29:20,580 --> 00:29:22,300
it was it was before sneakers. Not

742
00:29:22,300 --> 00:29:28,580
the Melamed Leho'il. Rav Nosson of Hanover.

743
00:29:28,720 --> 00:29:32,020
What was the shailos uteshuvos called? Askeil

744
00:29:32,020 --> 00:29:44,140
Teshuvah? Hold on. In an era of

745
00:29:44,140 --> 00:29:46,120
AI cameras that really can see and

746
00:29:46,120 --> 00:29:47,840
process that level of information, does that

747
00:29:48,300 --> 00:29:50,440
change the Yeven Metzulah. No, sorry, that's

748
00:29:50,440 --> 00:29:51,860
the Tach Vat Tat. I'm I'm off.

749
00:29:51,860 --> 00:29:53,280
Ah, whatever. I'll figure it out later.

750
00:29:54,500 --> 00:29:57,120
Yeah, sorry. In an in an era

751
00:29:57,120 --> 00:29:58,760
of AI where we really try so

752
00:29:58,760 --> 00:30:01,380
that's another question. That's a little bit

753
00:30:01,380 --> 00:30:02,640
closer to a real hashgocha protis. You

754
00:30:03,400 --> 00:30:06,480
could pick up little discrepancies. Yes, but

755
00:30:06,480 --> 00:30:07,641
I could also tell you that in

756
00:30:07,641 --> 00:30:09,340
an age of AI, I could mock

757
00:30:09,340 --> 00:30:12,960
up anything that video. So you're talking

758
00:30:12,960 --> 00:30:16,180
about fancy fancy schmancy security cameras. Yeah.

759
00:30:16,500 --> 00:30:19,320
Yeah. Potentially, potentially, and then in real

760
00:30:19,320 --> 00:30:21,485
time. In real time, yeah. Then you

761
00:30:21,485 --> 00:30:22,960
could argue that you're watching. Yeah, so

762
00:30:22,960 --> 00:30:24,200
this was the machine matzah debate. The

763
00:30:24,200 --> 00:30:26,460
machine matzah debate was, hey, we this

764
00:30:26,460 --> 00:30:27,400
is actually going to be much better.

765
00:30:27,400 --> 00:30:29,020
The machine matzah debate actually was not

766
00:30:29,020 --> 00:30:30,220
really about that because it was really

767
00:30:30,220 --> 00:30:33,120
about the introduction of technology within the

768
00:30:33,120 --> 00:30:35,780
world of halacha. Like how modern are

769
00:30:35,780 --> 00:30:37,000
we going to get? That was really

770
00:30:37,000 --> 00:30:38,920
what the debate was about. Oh, we've

771
00:30:38,920 --> 00:30:42,120
covered Zionism tonight and machine matzah. What

772
00:30:42,120 --> 00:30:43,120
a way to wrap up the z'man.

773
00:30:43,620 --> 00:30:45,380
So you're right. Reb Shmuel was saying

774
00:30:45,380 --> 00:30:46,540
he doesn't know that he would hold

775
00:30:46,540 --> 00:30:48,121
of it when it comes to a,

776
00:30:48,121 --> 00:30:50,800
but it also requires if you have

777
00:30:50,800 --> 00:30:52,140
real AI cameras that are going to

778
00:30:52,140 --> 00:30:54,040
ding when something happens maybe, but it

779
00:30:54,040 --> 00:30:55,540
really requires that somebody's going to be

780
00:30:55,540 --> 00:30:56,900
sitting there and actually watching the cameras,

781
00:30:57,400 --> 00:31:00,580
right? So, but that would yotzei v'nichnas

782
00:31:00,580 --> 00:31:02,840
would work. So, if you go to

783
00:31:02,840 --> 00:31:07,360
source 52. So many shuls today have

784
00:31:07,360 --> 00:31:09,860
the non-Jewish help so how does that

785
00:31:09,860 --> 00:31:13,320
work? So he explains the following. It's

786
00:31:13,320 --> 00:31:15,340
pretty simple. He says that wine is

787
00:31:15,340 --> 00:31:16,980
mutar that they clean off the tables

788
00:31:16,980 --> 00:31:18,687
wine. נראה להורות הלכה למעשה במקום שמצוי

789
00:31:18,687 --> 00:31:23,300
שיש נכרי לבית הכנסת, right? The non-Jew

790
00:31:23,300 --> 00:31:24,601
is coming to clean the shul. ויש

791
00:31:27,520 --> 00:31:29,840
מפתחות לנקות גם את המטבח של בית

792
00:31:29,840 --> 00:31:31,500
הכנסת. He's got keys to everything, him

793
00:31:31,720 --> 00:31:35,660
and the president. ויכול להיכנס שם מתי

794
00:31:36,900 --> 00:31:42,000
שרוצה. And he can come in whenever

795
00:31:42,000 --> 00:31:44,267
he wants. ופעמים נשאר בתוכם מקורב בקבוקי

796
00:31:44,267 --> 00:31:47,160
יין פתוחים שאינו מבושל. And there are

797
00:31:47,160 --> 00:31:48,380
times he'll come into a shul, he's

798
00:31:48,380 --> 00:31:49,280
going to clean whenever he wants to

799
00:31:49,280 --> 00:31:50,720
clean, there are wine bottles that are

800
00:31:50,720 --> 00:31:53,040
open. נראה שאין לחוש לאסור. He does

801
00:31:53,040 --> 00:31:55,205
not assur them. Mutarim b'shsiya. Why? B'prat

802
00:31:55,205 --> 00:31:57,280
number one, בית הכנסת תמיד נמצאים שם.

803
00:32:00,580 --> 00:32:04,840
Number one is halevai because you have

804
00:32:04,840 --> 00:32:06,240
yotzei v'nichnas. People in the shul all

805
00:32:06,240 --> 00:32:08,344
the time. And he says v'rav b'arichus

806
00:32:08,344 --> 00:32:10,735
b'he'ara. In the he'ara, they don't quote

807
00:32:10,735 --> 00:32:12,120
it here, but the other part is

808
00:32:12,120 --> 00:32:13,460
that he doesn't want to lose his

809
00:32:13,460 --> 00:32:17,540
job. He starts taking wine, it's not

810
00:32:17,540 --> 00:32:19,260
going to go very well for him.

811
00:32:19,600 --> 00:32:21,680
So therefore we would be he doesn't

812
00:32:21,680 --> 00:32:24,540
want to damage that relationship. That's number

813
00:32:24,540 --> 00:32:26,504
one. If you look in source 53

814
00:32:26,504 --> 00:32:27,708
in the שאלות ותשובות קובץ מבית לוי

815
00:32:27,708 --> 00:32:35,880
the following. So what about somebody who

816
00:32:35,880 --> 00:32:37,660
has an aide? So it depends. This

817
00:32:37,820 --> 00:32:40,141
the shaila comes up very frequently. ובנשאר

818
00:32:40,141 --> 00:32:44,560
בבית חולה או זקן שמרתק למיטה. He's

819
00:32:44,560 --> 00:32:47,801
bedridden. אין זה בגדר שמירה. So if

820
00:32:47,801 --> 00:32:48,740
you have a patient let's say, but

821
00:32:48,740 --> 00:32:52,660
really he's not so conscious. He's there,

822
00:32:52,660 --> 00:32:54,020
but he's not really there. That's not

823
00:32:54,020 --> 00:33:02,420
shemira. Correct. V'yesh lizaheir b'zmanenu. Well, it's

824
00:33:02,420 --> 00:33:03,885
bishul akkum's because right, the caregivers are

825
00:33:03,885 --> 00:33:08,640
cooking meals. But even if the guy

826
00:33:08,640 --> 00:33:10,381
was awake and the goy turned on,

827
00:33:10,381 --> 00:33:11,262
it would be a problem. ויש ליזהר

828
00:33:11,262 --> 00:33:14,500
בזמננו שיש לזקנים ולחולים עובדים נכרים. They

829
00:33:14,500 --> 00:33:16,384
have the non-Jewish workers. Shelo yanich bakbuk.

830
00:33:17,020 --> 00:33:18,581
They should not leave them open. וצריך

831
00:33:18,581 --> 00:33:20,630
לסגור את המקום שאינו יכול לפתחו. You

832
00:33:20,630 --> 00:33:23,800
really have to be careful because that

833
00:33:23,800 --> 00:33:26,640
would not be considered shemira. And therefore,

834
00:33:26,640 --> 00:33:28,100
the last piece is what happens if

835
00:33:28,100 --> 00:33:29,200
I put the wine I know my

836
00:33:29,200 --> 00:33:30,780
maid's coming and whatever and I have

837
00:33:30,780 --> 00:33:33,580
these open bottles or maybe there is

838
00:33:33,580 --> 00:33:35,440
a relative who's in an old age

839
00:33:35,440 --> 00:33:37,624
home and there's wine on the table.

840
00:33:37,640 --> 00:33:38,600
Put it in a place they're not

841
00:33:38,600 --> 00:33:39,680
going to find it. If you know

842
00:33:39,680 --> 00:33:40,620
the place they're not going to find

843
00:33:40,620 --> 00:33:42,425
it, so he says in the Ohel

844
00:33:42,425 --> 00:33:44,816
Yaakov, אם הנכרי אינו יודע כלל שיש

845
00:33:44,816 --> 00:33:47,420
יין ואין לחוש כלל לייחודו. If you

846
00:33:47,420 --> 00:33:48,320
really could put it in a place

847
00:33:48,320 --> 00:33:49,240
where they're not going to find it,

848
00:33:49,560 --> 00:33:50,440
you wouldn't have to worry about it.

849
00:33:50,440 --> 00:33:54,100
באופן המוכח היטב דמסתבר שהנכרי לא ימצאנו,

850
00:33:54,100 --> 00:33:56,940
nireh sheyesh l'hakel that they're not really

851
00:33:56,940 --> 00:33:59,180
going to find it. So again, I

852
00:33:59,180 --> 00:34:00,560
can create a double seal, I could

853
00:34:00,560 --> 00:34:02,440
have cameras. You have to also warn

854
00:34:02,440 --> 00:34:04,720
the goy if there are cameras so

855
00:34:04,720 --> 00:34:06,580
that they're afraid of it. I could

856
00:34:06,580 --> 00:34:08,219
use that combination lock, I could have

857
00:34:08,219 --> 00:34:10,699
one seal potentially b'diavad. I could hide

858
00:34:10,699 --> 00:34:12,880
the wine bottle. And even if none

859
00:34:12,880 --> 00:34:14,120
of those, potentially we would still be

860
00:34:14,120 --> 00:34:16,441
meikel if one needed. Shkoyach.

