1
00:00:00,000 --> 00:00:02,194
All right, so let's just start, we'll

2
00:00:02,194 --> 00:00:29,980
start by recapping a little bit from

3
00:00:29,980 --> 00:00:32,539
what we ended with two weeks ago

4
00:00:32,539 --> 00:00:35,099
and then we'll get into tonight. So

5
00:00:35,099 --> 00:00:37,659
we discussed the we are discussing within

6
00:00:37,659 --> 00:00:40,219
the world of Yayin Nesach what actually

7
00:00:40,219 --> 00:00:42,779
makes the wine aser what what do

8
00:00:42,779 --> 00:00:45,339
you have to do to make it

9
00:00:45,339 --> 00:00:47,899
aser. We discussed already some of the

10
00:00:47,899 --> 00:00:50,459
criteria for who is considered a goy

11
00:00:50,459 --> 00:00:53,019
who is not considered the Muslims the

12
00:00:53,019 --> 00:00:55,579
Christians things like that. Oh, sorry, yeah.

13
00:00:55,579 --> 00:00:58,139
So sponsoring the learning tonight is being

14
00:00:58,139 --> 00:01:00,699
sponsored by Dovid Yaakov and Leah Liba

15
00:01:00,699 --> 00:01:03,259
Elka, Rabbi Dovid Radinsky, who is having

16
00:01:03,259 --> 00:01:05,819
had a surgery this afternoon so all

17
00:01:05,819 --> 00:01:08,379
the learning should be a refuah sheleimah.

18
00:01:08,379 --> 00:01:10,939
Okay, so we mentioned in the Shulchan

19
00:01:10,939 --> 00:01:13,498
Aruch, we won't go back through it,

20
00:01:13,498 --> 00:01:15,384
but we mentioned in in Sif Yud

21
00:01:15,384 --> 00:01:15,784
and in Yud Aleph in Kuf Chaf

22
00:01:15,784 --> 00:01:16,184
Daled. Again, this is just a review

23
00:01:16,184 --> 00:01:16,584
from a few weeks ago because it's

24
00:01:16,584 --> 00:01:16,984
important to have some review. That the

25
00:01:16,984 --> 00:01:17,384
non-Jew has to intend to want to

26
00:01:17,384 --> 00:01:17,784
touch the wine, that was condition number

27
00:01:17,784 --> 00:01:18,184
one. He has to know that he

28
00:01:18,184 --> 00:01:18,584
is touching wine, that is number two.

29
00:01:18,584 --> 00:01:18,984
He has to not be distracted, has

30
00:01:18,984 --> 00:01:20,093
to be focused on the fact that

31
00:01:20,093 --> 00:01:22,653
he's touching wine, and he has to

32
00:01:22,653 --> 00:01:25,213
actually shake the wine. Those are the

33
00:01:25,213 --> 00:01:27,773
four criteria in Yud Aleph says it

34
00:01:27,773 --> 00:01:30,333
as well, so intent to touch the

35
00:01:30,333 --> 00:01:32,893
wine, knowledge that it's wine, focus, and

36
00:01:32,893 --> 00:01:35,453
the fact that he's actually shaking it.

37
00:01:35,453 --> 00:01:38,013
We learned this chidush of the Rema

38
00:01:38,013 --> 00:01:40,573
in... yeah, we learned the chidush of

39
00:01:40,573 --> 00:01:43,133
the Rema that the Rema basically says

40
00:01:43,133 --> 00:01:45,693
that... hold on. Yeah, so if we

41
00:01:45,693 --> 00:01:48,253
go to Sif Yud Ches again, this

42
00:01:48,253 --> 00:01:50,813
is still chazarah. If you go to

43
00:01:50,813 --> 00:01:53,373
Sif Yud Ches. Okay, if you go

44
00:01:53,373 --> 00:01:55,932
to Sif Yud Ches, the Shulchan Aruch

45
00:01:55,932 --> 00:01:58,492
here, based on a Gemara in Avodah

46
00:01:58,492 --> 00:02:01,052
Zarah that talks about pouring the wine

47
00:02:01,052 --> 00:02:03,612
without even shaking the wine, would be

48
00:02:03,612 --> 00:02:06,172
potentially a problem. Here the Rema in

49
00:02:06,172 --> 00:02:08,732
Yud Tes, which we saw last time...

50
00:02:08,732 --> 00:02:11,052
just thinking if we should do inside/outside...

51
00:02:11,052 --> 00:02:11,452
no. Okay, so the... hold on, let

52
00:02:11,452 --> 00:02:11,852
me go to one more Shulchan Aruch.

53
00:02:11,852 --> 00:02:12,252
Yeah, go to Kuf Chaf Daled, this

54
00:02:12,252 --> 00:02:12,652
is where we ended with the Rema.

55
00:02:12,652 --> 00:02:13,052
So the Rema here, according to a

56
00:02:13,052 --> 00:02:13,452
number of Rishonim, has this big, big

57
00:02:13,452 --> 00:02:13,852
chidush. The Rema in Kuf Chaf Daled

58
00:02:13,852 --> 00:02:14,252
tells us that in the end of

59
00:02:14,252 --> 00:02:14,652
the day le-ma'aseh really it's not such

60
00:02:14,652 --> 00:02:15,052
a problem. All of this that we

61
00:02:15,052 --> 00:02:15,452
discussed, not such a problem. Why? Because

62
00:02:15,452 --> 00:02:15,852
the Rema says הוא הדין אם הכניס,

63
00:02:15,852 --> 00:02:16,252
I'm sorry, in the middle... אם נגע

64
00:02:16,252 --> 00:02:16,652
ביין על ידי דבר אחר. So if

65
00:02:16,652 --> 00:02:17,052
you do it unintentionally, you're, you know,

66
00:02:17,052 --> 00:02:17,452
like the waiter and the stick that

67
00:02:17,452 --> 00:02:17,852
goes in, he wasn't focused and things

68
00:02:17,852 --> 00:02:18,252
like that. Since everything dumbs down a

69
00:02:18,252 --> 00:02:18,652
level, so it's not such a big

70
00:02:18,652 --> 00:02:19,052
deal. And the Rema then says that's

71
00:02:19,052 --> 00:02:19,452
really the situation today. That that if

72
00:02:19,452 --> 00:02:19,852
a... the Rema says that even if

73
00:02:19,852 --> 00:02:20,252
the non-Jew really directly touches the wine,

74
00:02:20,252 --> 00:02:20,652
that's not really going to be such

75
00:02:20,652 --> 00:02:21,052
a problem today. However, we don't really

76
00:02:21,052 --> 00:02:21,452
want to be mefarsem, he says at

77
00:02:21,452 --> 00:02:21,852
the end, we don't really want to

78
00:02:21,852 --> 00:02:22,252
tell the non-Jews about this big chidush

79
00:02:22,252 --> 00:02:22,652
that we have, but it does seem

80
00:02:22,652 --> 00:02:23,052
that a very, very big chidush that

81
00:02:23,052 --> 00:02:23,452
if a Christian were to pour out

82
00:02:23,452 --> 00:02:23,852
a glass of kosher wine without directly

83
00:02:23,852 --> 00:02:24,252
touching the wine, you would be allowed

84
00:02:24,252 --> 00:02:24,652
to drink it. That's what the Rema

85
00:02:24,652 --> 00:02:25,052
says. That's a big, big chidush. We

86
00:02:25,052 --> 00:02:25,452
just went through three weeks telling you

87
00:02:25,452 --> 00:02:25,852
that it should be aser, that a

88
00:02:25,852 --> 00:02:26,252
non-Jew, a Christian, that's avodah zarah if

89
00:02:26,252 --> 00:02:26,652
there's ever avodah zarah. And yet the

90
00:02:26,652 --> 00:02:28,506
Rema says really today everybody's really not

91
00:02:28,506 --> 00:02:31,066
it's not they're not so bad. And

92
00:02:31,066 --> 00:02:33,626
if they... since we know that indirectly

93
00:02:33,626 --> 00:02:36,186
is okay, so today basically everything should

94
00:02:36,186 --> 00:02:38,746
be not a problem at all, but

95
00:02:38,746 --> 00:02:41,306
ואין לפרסם הדבר בפני עמי הארץ. Don't

96
00:02:41,306 --> 00:02:43,866
let everybody know about this. Yet today

97
00:02:43,866 --> 00:02:46,426
we're pretty machmir about this. We do

98
00:02:46,426 --> 00:02:48,986
not seem to follow this leniency of

99
00:02:48,986 --> 00:02:51,545
the Rema. So tonight is going to

100
00:02:51,545 --> 00:02:54,105
figure out a little bit about the

101
00:02:54,105 --> 00:02:56,148
rest of this topic. Why are we

102
00:02:56,148 --> 00:02:56,548
machmir? Who are we machmir about? When

103
00:02:56,548 --> 00:02:56,948
are we machmir? So let's review the

104
00:02:56,948 --> 00:02:57,348
following. Okay, if you look at קכ\"ה

105
00:02:57,348 --> 00:02:57,748
א. Okay, that is the next siman,

106
00:02:57,748 --> 00:02:58,148
קכ\"ה א. There the Rema says... I'm

107
00:02:58,148 --> 00:02:58,548
sorry, the Shulchan Aruch says that wine

108
00:02:58,548 --> 00:02:58,948
that is poured by a non-Jew, okay,

109
00:02:58,948 --> 00:02:59,348
that is aser to drink. It could

110
00:02:59,348 --> 00:02:59,748
benefit, but it says נטל עובד כוכבים

111
00:02:59,748 --> 00:03:00,148
כלי שיש בו יין והגביהו והציק יין.

112
00:03:00,148 --> 00:03:00,548
If he takes it, אף על פי

113
00:03:00,548 --> 00:03:00,948
שלא שכשו, ne'esar bi-shtiyah. You cannot drink

114
00:03:00,948 --> 00:03:01,348
that wine שהרי היין בא מכחו. We'll

115
00:03:01,348 --> 00:03:01,748
come back to this later about nitzok

116
00:03:01,748 --> 00:03:02,148
in a second. You could benefit from

117
00:03:02,148 --> 00:03:02,548
it, but whatever is left in the

118
00:03:02,548 --> 00:03:02,948
kli is going to be a... you

119
00:03:02,948 --> 00:03:03,348
can't drink it, but at least you

120
00:03:03,348 --> 00:03:03,748
can benefit from it. Says the Rema...

121
00:03:03,748 --> 00:03:04,148
ויש אומרים דלא אסרינן ניצוק בכח עובד

122
00:03:04,148 --> 00:03:04,548
כוכבים. The Rema disagrees as he does

123
00:03:04,548 --> 00:03:04,948
earlier and the Rema says it's fine.

124
00:03:04,948 --> 00:03:05,348
Why is it fine? Because מכל מקום

125
00:03:05,348 --> 00:03:05,748
יש להחמיר אם לא הפסד מרובה. It's

126
00:03:05,748 --> 00:03:06,148
better to be machmir if you don't

127
00:03:06,148 --> 00:03:06,548
if you don't need to, but in

128
00:03:06,548 --> 00:03:06,948
the end it seems to be that

129
00:03:06,948 --> 00:03:07,348
you could be meikel about it as

130
00:03:07,348 --> 00:03:07,748
well. The Shach right here in se'if

131
00:03:07,748 --> 00:03:08,148
katan alef on the right side, so

132
00:03:08,148 --> 00:03:08,548
the Shach has a question. The Shach

133
00:03:08,548 --> 00:03:08,948
says: Hold on a second. Earlier the

134
00:03:08,948 --> 00:03:09,348
Rema says it seems to be permitted.

135
00:03:09,348 --> 00:03:09,748
Here he's saying really only if it's

136
00:03:09,748 --> 00:03:10,148
a case of significant loss. So the

137
00:03:10,148 --> 00:03:10,548
Rema explains the following: קשיא דלעיל סימן

138
00:03:10,548 --> 00:03:10,948
קכ\"ד סעיף י\"ד פסק דמה שנשאר בפנים

139
00:03:10,948 --> 00:03:11,348
מותר. Earlier we learned the Rema's like:

140
00:03:11,348 --> 00:03:11,748
Ah, everything's fine! Even what's left in

141
00:03:11,748 --> 00:03:12,148
the bottle! והיינו משום דלא חמירו כמו

142
00:03:12,148 --> 00:03:12,548
בניצוק. Nitzok is a concept we'll come

143
00:03:12,548 --> 00:03:12,948
back to tonight of pouring. So since

144
00:03:12,948 --> 00:03:13,348
the kli is assur, whatever came out

145
00:03:13,348 --> 00:03:13,748
of the kli connects what's out of

146
00:03:13,748 --> 00:03:14,148
the kli and in the kli, so

147
00:03:14,148 --> 00:03:14,548
whatever is left in the kli is

148
00:03:14,548 --> 00:03:14,948
assur. The Rema said before it's muttar.

149
00:03:14,948 --> 00:03:15,348
I don't understand! וכן לקמן סימן קכ\"ח

150
00:03:15,348 --> 00:03:15,748
העתיק לשון הטור דיוצא אסור בשתייה משמע

151
00:03:15,748 --> 00:03:16,148
דמה שבפנים מותר. I don't understand! And

152
00:03:16,148 --> 00:03:16,548
now we're saying unless it's a real

153
00:03:16,548 --> 00:03:16,948
case of loss you should be machmir.

154
00:03:16,948 --> 00:03:17,348
ve-kashya de-nitzok. He has another question. So

155
00:03:17,348 --> 00:03:17,748
he says in the few lines below:

156
00:03:17,748 --> 00:03:18,148
ולדידן הכל שרי במקום הפסד. He explains

157
00:03:18,148 --> 00:03:18,548
that the Rema is only leaning when

158
00:03:18,548 --> 00:03:18,948
there's a great loss of money because

159
00:03:18,948 --> 00:03:19,348
either he says דכל מה שאסור מן

160
00:03:19,348 --> 00:03:19,748
הדין בשתייה. When we say that you

161
00:03:19,748 --> 00:03:20,148
can't drink it, לדידן דעובד כוכבים בזמן

162
00:03:20,148 --> 00:03:20,548
הזה, but today since I hold, says

163
00:03:20,548 --> 00:03:20,948
the Shach for the Rema, that all

164
00:03:20,948 --> 00:03:21,348
the Goyim today are לאו עובדי כוכבים

165
00:03:21,348 --> 00:03:21,748
הם שרי אף בשתייה. So really, really

166
00:03:21,748 --> 00:03:22,148
the Shach is saying: No, the Rema

167
00:03:22,148 --> 00:03:22,548
meant what he said. The Rema meant

168
00:03:22,548 --> 00:03:22,948
what he said. It's okay to be

169
00:03:22,948 --> 00:03:23,348
machmir if one wants to but really

170
00:03:23,348 --> 00:03:23,748
in the end of the day the

171
00:03:23,748 --> 00:03:24,148
Shach is saying what the Rema holds

172
00:03:24,148 --> 00:03:24,548
and this is why coming back to

173
00:03:24,548 --> 00:03:24,948
what we ended with last week, two

174
00:03:24,948 --> 00:03:25,348
weeks ago, that according to the Rema

175
00:03:25,348 --> 00:03:25,748
really it should be okay but we're

176
00:03:25,748 --> 00:03:26,148
machmir when it seems if there's not

177
00:03:26,148 --> 00:03:26,548
a big loss. Okay. Now go back

178
00:03:26,548 --> 00:03:26,948
to the end of yod-chet. Okay. Go

179
00:03:26,948 --> 00:03:27,348
back to the end of yod-chet. So

180
00:03:27,348 --> 00:03:27,748
the Rema—the Shulchan Aruch here says the

181
00:03:27,748 --> 00:03:28,148
following: נטל עובד כוכבים כלי של יין.

182
00:03:28,148 --> 00:03:28,548
If a Goy takes a bottle of

183
00:03:28,548 --> 00:03:28,948
wine ve-higbiho ve-yatzak ha-yayin. He lifts it

184
00:03:28,948 --> 00:03:29,348
and he pours it. He doesn't shake

185
00:03:29,348 --> 00:03:29,748
it. Okay? He's very careful. נאסר שהרי

186
00:03:29,748 --> 00:03:30,148
יין מכחו. הגביהו ולא שכסכו ולא נגע

187
00:03:30,148 --> 00:03:30,548
מותר. So the Shulchan Aruch says that

188
00:03:30,548 --> 00:03:30,948
if he merely lifts it without shaking

189
00:03:30,948 --> 00:03:31,348
or pouring it nothing's assur. Okay? הגביהו

190
00:03:31,348 --> 00:03:31,748
ולא שכסכו ולא נגע מותר. The Rema

191
00:03:31,748 --> 00:03:32,148
says וכל שכן שאינו אוסר בנגיעת הכלי

192
00:03:32,148 --> 00:03:32,548
לחוד. So just meaning because we're meikel

193
00:03:32,548 --> 00:03:32,948
about these Goyim if I pick it

194
00:03:32,948 --> 00:03:33,348
up, the Goy picks it up, doesn't

195
00:03:33,348 --> 00:03:33,748
move it, doesn't touch, doesn't touch the

196
00:03:33,748 --> 00:03:34,148
wine, doesn't shake it, doesn't pour, he

197
00:03:34,148 --> 00:03:34,548
just lifts it up, that would be

198
00:03:34,548 --> 00:03:34,948
okay, number one. Number two, the Rema

199
00:03:34,948 --> 00:03:35,348
adds that just touching the bottle of

200
00:03:35,348 --> 00:03:35,748
wine is going to be okay. Right?

201
00:03:35,748 --> 00:03:36,148
It's going to be okay. The Shach—there's

202
00:03:36,148 --> 00:03:36,548
a very short Shach here in siman

203
00:03:36,548 --> 00:03:36,948
mem-gimmel right on the left side. So

204
00:03:36,948 --> 00:03:37,348
the Shach wants in the—the Shach says:

205
00:03:37,348 --> 00:03:37,748
Hold on a second. ולכן אני תמה

206
00:03:37,748 --> 00:03:38,148
על קצת המחמירים ומפסידים ממון של ישראל

207
00:03:38,148 --> 00:03:38,548
לאסור יין שנגע בו עובד כוכבים. I

208
00:03:38,548 --> 00:03:38,948
don't understand! Why is everybody machmir about

209
00:03:38,948 --> 00:03:39,348
it? The Rema's seemingly meikel about it.

210
00:03:39,348 --> 00:03:39,748
So he says ולכן נראה דאין לחוש

211
00:03:39,748 --> 00:03:40,148
כלל. Really we should say that it

212
00:03:40,148 --> 00:03:41,976
should be muttar completely. Let's just finish

213
00:03:41,976 --> 00:03:42,376
a little bit of this. If you

214
00:03:42,376 --> 00:03:42,776
go to siman yod-zayin—we're going backwards—go to

215
00:03:42,776 --> 00:03:43,176
siman yod-zayin, I'm sorry. Says the Shulchan

216
00:03:43,176 --> 00:03:44,394
Aruch in siman yod-zayin if he shakes

217
00:03:44,394 --> 00:03:46,953
the wine without lifting it: היה שם

218
00:03:46,953 --> 00:03:49,513
ואחז עובד כוכבים בכלי פתוח של יין

219
00:03:49,513 --> 00:03:52,073
ושכסכו ואף על פי שלא הגביהו. He—it's

220
00:03:52,073 --> 00:03:54,633
there on the counter. He shakes it

221
00:03:54,633 --> 00:03:57,193
but he doesn't lift it ולא נגע

222
00:03:57,193 --> 00:03:58,656
ביין אסור. Then it would be assur.

223
00:03:58,656 --> 00:04:04,094
The Rema says ve-yesh harbe cholkim. And

224
00:04:04,094 --> 00:04:06,654
many, many are—argue that, you know, without

225
00:04:06,654 --> 00:04:09,214
lifting the glass is not really a

226
00:04:09,214 --> 00:04:11,774
problem. Why? Because the whole issue of

227
00:04:11,774 --> 00:04:14,333
lifting and pouring is that's how they

228
00:04:14,333 --> 00:04:16,893
did Avoda Zara. They didn't do the

229
00:04:16,893 --> 00:04:19,453
Avoda Zara with it being on the

230
00:04:19,453 --> 00:04:22,013
counter. Okay. How big of a difference

231
00:04:22,013 --> 00:04:24,573
does that make? Ah, okay. So then

232
00:04:24,573 --> 00:04:27,133
says the Shulchan Aruch and this is

233
00:04:27,133 --> 00:04:29,693
just—this will wrap up until we get

234
00:04:29,693 --> 00:04:32,253
into some more practical stuff. If you

235
00:04:32,253 --> 00:04:34,813
go to kuf-kaf-hey-tet. Okay? kuf-kaf-hey-tet. We're going

236
00:04:34,813 --> 00:04:37,373
to talk about clothes also a little

237
00:04:37,373 --> 00:04:39,933
bit later. So the Shulchan Aruch here...

238
00:04:39,933 --> 00:04:42,493
it says which we'll do it outside

239
00:04:42,493 --> 00:04:45,053
that a closed bottle right if you

240
00:04:45,053 --> 00:04:47,613
look in the Shach the Shach talks

241
00:04:47,613 --> 00:04:50,173
about sosum. So a closed bottle does

242
00:04:50,173 --> 00:04:51,818
not become forbidden even if it's shaken

243
00:04:51,818 --> 00:04:52,218
by a goy. Okay so a closed

244
00:04:52,218 --> 00:04:52,618
bottle does not become assur even if

245
00:04:52,618 --> 00:04:53,018
it's shaken by a goy. העובד כוכבים

246
00:04:53,018 --> 00:04:53,418
שנטל של יין what? The Shulchan Aruch

247
00:04:53,418 --> 00:04:53,818
says ונטלו ממקום למקום שאוחז פי הנוד

248
00:04:53,818 --> 00:04:54,218
בידו בין שהיה מלא או חסר מותר

249
00:04:54,218 --> 00:04:54,618
even though it's moving around. He schlepped

250
00:04:54,618 --> 00:04:55,018
it around. So he says why? Says

251
00:04:55,018 --> 00:04:55,418
the Shach explains because it's closed. דאם

252
00:04:55,418 --> 00:04:55,818
לא כן אסור משום שכשוך it can't

253
00:04:55,818 --> 00:04:56,218
be assur because of shikhshukh only. Since

254
00:04:56,218 --> 00:04:56,618
it's closed we are we're more lenient

255
00:04:56,618 --> 00:04:57,018
about it. And that means re-closed also

256
00:04:57,018 --> 00:04:57,418
right? Hold on hold on hold on.

257
00:04:57,418 --> 00:04:57,818
So fine. So let's let's review. So

258
00:04:57,818 --> 00:04:58,218
again we had four criteria. You had

259
00:04:58,218 --> 00:05:00,630
to have intent to touch the wine

260
00:05:00,630 --> 00:05:03,190
that a person is touching. So therefore

261
00:05:03,190 --> 00:05:05,750
if somebody accidentally you know touched the

262
00:05:05,750 --> 00:05:08,310
wine would it be a problem? Number

263
00:05:08,310 --> 00:05:10,870
two was that I have to have

264
00:05:10,870 --> 00:05:13,430
knowledge that I know that I'm touching

265
00:05:13,430 --> 00:05:15,990
this wine that you know again a

266
00:05:15,990 --> 00:05:18,550
person thinks they're pouring you know I

267
00:05:18,550 --> 00:05:21,110
don't know honey and it's wine it

268
00:05:21,110 --> 00:05:23,670
would be a problem. They had to

269
00:05:23,670 --> 00:05:25,429
have focus the whole time and they

270
00:05:25,429 --> 00:05:25,829
have to be able to to shake

271
00:05:25,829 --> 00:05:26,229
it. Okay. Fine. You can go through

272
00:05:26,229 --> 00:05:26,629
in the notes later all these different

273
00:05:26,629 --> 00:05:27,029
things about you know they have a

274
00:05:27,029 --> 00:05:27,429
good chart. Okay. Fine. Go to the

275
00:05:27,429 --> 00:05:27,829
booklet for a second. Okay so the

276
00:05:27,829 --> 00:05:28,229
Chazon Ish here in source seventeen says

277
00:05:28,229 --> 00:05:28,629
that he's not so sure about the

278
00:05:28,629 --> 00:05:29,029
kullah of the Rema. So the Chazon

279
00:05:29,029 --> 00:05:29,429
Ish he's quoting the Taz. The Taz

280
00:05:29,429 --> 00:05:29,829
will become a very important Taz as

281
00:05:29,829 --> 00:05:30,229
we move on tonight because the Taz

282
00:05:30,229 --> 00:05:30,629
based on the Rambam holds that whenever

283
00:05:30,629 --> 00:05:31,029
a non-Jew I don't care if the

284
00:05:31,029 --> 00:05:31,429
non-Jew is a law-abiding Christian Protestant Catholic

285
00:05:31,429 --> 00:05:31,829
doesn't matter Buddhist Muslim a non-Jew that

286
00:05:31,829 --> 00:05:32,229
touches the wine says the Taz is

287
00:05:32,229 --> 00:05:32,629
assur. Says the Chazon Ish כתב דכוחו

288
00:05:32,629 --> 00:05:33,029
אף על גב דקיימא לן דמותר בהנאה

289
00:05:33,029 --> 00:05:33,429
מכל מקום לא נסמיכין חד דרגא לדידן

290
00:05:33,429 --> 00:05:33,829
להתיר בשתיה. He says it can't be

291
00:05:33,829 --> 00:05:34,229
that we even though we might reduce

292
00:05:34,229 --> 00:05:34,629
it by a level it can't be

293
00:05:34,629 --> 00:05:35,029
that it's reduced to a level that

294
00:05:35,029 --> 00:05:35,429
it's mutar to drink. And he quotes

295
00:05:35,429 --> 00:05:35,829
from the Rebbi Akiva Eiger הסכים עם

296
00:05:35,829 --> 00:05:36,229
השך דלדידן מותר בשתיה he writes that

297
00:05:36,229 --> 00:05:36,629
the Rebbi Akiva Eiger and quoting the

298
00:05:36,629 --> 00:05:37,029
Dugul Mervava and the Shach all disagree

299
00:05:37,029 --> 00:05:37,429
with this Taz and they allow drinking

300
00:05:37,429 --> 00:05:37,829
מכל מקום לדידן מותר בשתיה כיון דאז

301
00:05:37,829 --> 00:05:38,229
מלאה של כוונת ניסוך כמורא של בלי

302
00:05:38,229 --> 00:05:38,629
כוונה דמותר בשתיה. So he says the

303
00:05:38,629 --> 00:05:39,029
Taz we're going to see tonight you're

304
00:05:39,029 --> 00:05:40,893
right the Taz is going to argue

305
00:05:40,893 --> 00:05:43,453
on the Rema. This is going to

306
00:05:43,453 --> 00:05:46,013
be a huge Taz because even though

307
00:05:46,013 --> 00:05:48,573
generally we follow a Shach and everybody

308
00:05:48,573 --> 00:05:51,133
else one of the reasons we are

309
00:05:51,133 --> 00:05:53,693
going to find that we are more

310
00:05:53,693 --> 00:05:56,253
machmir for some of these things even

311
00:05:56,253 --> 00:05:58,813
though Shach Rebbi Akiva Eiger Dugul Mervava

312
00:05:58,813 --> 00:06:01,373
the Shach himself said I don't know

313
00:06:01,373 --> 00:06:03,933
why everybody's being meikel about this. We're

314
00:06:03,933 --> 00:06:06,493
going to find reasons that that more

315
00:06:06,493 --> 00:06:09,053
contemporary poskim are machmir about it. So

316
00:06:09,053 --> 00:06:11,612
in the end of the day sof

317
00:06:11,612 --> 00:06:14,172
kol sof if you stopped here it

318
00:06:14,172 --> 00:06:16,732
would seem that everybody that the Rema

319
00:06:16,732 --> 00:06:19,292
is meikel. If the Rema is meikel

320
00:06:19,292 --> 00:06:21,852
Rebbi Akiva Eiger is meikel Dugul Mervava

321
00:06:21,852 --> 00:06:24,412
is meikel the except the Taz. So

322
00:06:24,412 --> 00:06:26,972
that a non-Jew today it would dumb

323
00:06:26,972 --> 00:06:29,532
it down a level that basically every

324
00:06:29,532 --> 00:06:32,092
time a non-Jew would touch your wine

325
00:06:32,092 --> 00:06:34,652
it's the level of like no no

326
00:06:34,652 --> 00:06:37,212
intention to it and therefore it would

327
00:06:37,212 --> 00:06:39,772
it would be potentially for sure mutar

328
00:06:39,772 --> 00:06:42,332
be-hana'ah and potentially even mutar be-shtiya. Okay?

329
00:06:42,332 --> 00:06:44,892
That's that's what the halacha says. You

330
00:06:44,892 --> 00:06:47,452
don't find that many areas of halacha

331
00:06:47,452 --> 00:06:50,012
where like it's pretty clear that it's

332
00:06:50,012 --> 00:06:52,572
one way and yet we're going to

333
00:06:52,572 --> 00:06:55,131
find like we're machmir about this. We're

334
00:06:55,131 --> 00:06:57,691
machmir about this. No we we don't

335
00:06:57,691 --> 00:07:00,251
find like a kashrut agency out there

336
00:07:00,251 --> 00:07:02,811
that will you know in Israel this

337
00:07:02,811 --> 00:07:05,371
is a big shaila with waiters and

338
00:07:05,371 --> 00:07:07,931
things like that. Who can be a

339
00:07:07,931 --> 00:07:10,491
waiter? We don't find kashrut agencies that

340
00:07:10,491 --> 00:07:13,051
are like oh it's fine he's a

341
00:07:13,051 --> 00:07:15,611
Christian that's fine he can touch wine.

342
00:07:15,611 --> 00:07:18,171
We're pretty machmir about it. So let's

343
00:07:18,171 --> 00:07:20,731
see. Okay. Now. So again the Shulchan

344
00:07:20,731 --> 00:07:23,291
Aruch would hold that everybody could at

345
00:07:23,291 --> 00:07:25,851
least benefit the Rema would seem to

346
00:07:25,851 --> 00:07:28,411
hold that everybody could at least drink

347
00:07:28,411 --> 00:07:29,194
it. So there's three levels. Shulchan Aruch

348
00:07:29,194 --> 00:07:29,594
says מותר בהנאה אסור בשתיה the Rema

349
00:07:29,594 --> 00:07:29,994
says mutar be-shtiya and the Shach says

350
00:07:29,994 --> 00:07:30,394
that the Rema's mutar in drinking is

351
00:07:30,394 --> 00:07:30,794
only makom hefsed. It's fine but like

352
00:07:30,794 --> 00:07:31,194
don't always rely on it. Okay. That

353
00:07:31,194 --> 00:07:31,594
would be when it comes to a

354
00:07:31,594 --> 00:07:31,994
Christian. When it comes to a Muslim

355
00:07:31,994 --> 00:07:32,394
leaving out the Taz for a second

356
00:07:32,394 --> 00:07:32,794
when it comes to a Muslim the

357
00:07:32,794 --> 00:07:33,194
Shulchan Aruch would say what? What would

358
00:07:33,194 --> 00:07:33,594
Shulchan Aruch say about a Muslim? You

359
00:07:33,594 --> 00:07:33,994
could drink it. He's not a goy

360
00:07:33,994 --> 00:07:34,394
right? The Dugul Mervava and the Shach

361
00:07:34,394 --> 00:07:34,794
everybody else would seem to everybody else

362
00:07:34,794 --> 00:07:35,194
would seemingly agree. So the question is:

363
00:07:35,194 --> 00:07:35,594
Why are we machmir by the Muslims

364
00:07:35,594 --> 00:07:35,994
more than we would have based on

365
00:07:35,994 --> 00:07:36,394
these halachos? Okay. Fine. Good. Versteh'st. Let's

366
00:07:36,394 --> 00:07:36,794
go. So look at Rav Moshe Feinstein.

367
00:07:36,794 --> 00:07:37,194
So there's a tshuva of Rav Moshe.

368
00:07:37,194 --> 00:07:37,594
Okay, again, the Shulchan Aruch would never

369
00:07:37,594 --> 00:07:37,994
allow drinking of wine poured by Christians,

370
00:07:37,994 --> 00:07:38,394
okay? That would be assur, assur, assur.

371
00:07:38,394 --> 00:07:38,794
You cannot drink that wine. If the

372
00:07:38,794 --> 00:07:39,194
guy, your workmate, Christensen, very good, what

373
00:07:39,194 --> 00:07:39,594
are we going to do with that,

374
00:07:39,594 --> 00:07:39,994
okay, if he comes to your party

375
00:07:39,994 --> 00:07:40,394
and pours your bottle of wine, you

376
00:07:40,394 --> 00:07:40,794
cannot drink that wine. So the question

377
00:07:40,794 --> 00:07:41,194
was asked to Rav Moshe, can a

378
00:07:41,194 --> 00:07:41,594
catering company hire non-Jewish waiters, non-Jewish workers,

379
00:07:41,594 --> 00:07:41,994
okay, and have them pouring wine using

380
00:07:41,994 --> 00:07:42,394
gloves? Ah, if I wear gloves, everything's

381
00:07:42,394 --> 00:07:42,794
fine. The Christian didn't touch your wine,

382
00:07:42,794 --> 00:07:43,194
the gloves touched your wine. Okay. So

383
00:07:43,194 --> 00:07:43,594
Rav Moshe writes, now number one he

384
00:07:43,594 --> 00:07:43,994
says in the first paragraph, gloves don't

385
00:07:43,994 --> 00:07:44,394
help. Okay, so let's forget about that.

386
00:07:44,394 --> 00:07:44,794
Gloves don't really help because it's actually

387
00:07:44,794 --> 00:07:45,194
considered touching and it wouldn't really help.

388
00:07:45,194 --> 00:07:45,594
He says there in that second paragraph

389
00:07:45,594 --> 00:07:45,994
negi'ah beyado mamash, that's like exactly touching

390
00:07:45,994 --> 00:07:46,394
with your hands. Okay. So then he

391
00:07:46,394 --> 00:07:46,794
writes in the next paragraph, he says,

392
00:07:46,794 --> 00:07:47,194
let's go to the bottom. הא דאיתא

393
00:07:47,194 --> 00:07:47,594
בריש סימן קכ\"ד בעכו\"ם שהגביה כלי של

394
00:07:47,594 --> 00:07:47,994
יין ויצא יין שזהו שצריך לאסור בשתייה

395
00:07:47,994 --> 00:07:48,394
ואם הוא שלא בכוונה מותר שכן איתא

396
00:07:48,394 --> 00:07:48,794
בש\"ך. Like we just saw, דבזמן הזה

397
00:07:48,794 --> 00:07:49,194
שרי אפילו שלא במקום הפסד ממון לא

398
00:07:49,194 --> 00:07:49,594
הוי כהאי דנחשב נגיעה בזמן הזה שלא

399
00:07:49,594 --> 00:07:49,994
בכוונה. That's the Rema. The Rema says

400
00:07:49,994 --> 00:07:50,394
that touching the wine today is like

401
00:07:50,394 --> 00:07:50,794
it didn't have intention, which means that

402
00:07:50,794 --> 00:07:51,194
it should be mutar. לעניין נגיעה על

403
00:07:51,194 --> 00:07:51,594
ידי דבר אחר יש מקום להתיר אף

404
00:07:51,594 --> 00:07:51,994
בלא בדיעבד. If you hold like the

405
00:07:51,994 --> 00:07:52,394
Rema, well then I don't need gloves.

406
00:07:52,394 --> 00:07:52,794
דאיתא בש\"ך דוקא במקום הפסד יש לסמוך

407
00:07:52,794 --> 00:07:53,194
על זה. So Rav Moshe says really

408
00:07:53,194 --> 00:07:53,594
only in a place of loss. In

409
00:07:53,594 --> 00:07:53,994
the end of the day, though, Rav

410
00:07:53,994 --> 00:07:54,394
Moshe says, I don't think you should

411
00:07:54,394 --> 00:07:54,794
do this, and let's see why. ואם

412
00:07:54,794 --> 00:07:55,194
כן שייך זה רק שאירע דרך מקרה.

413
00:07:55,194 --> 00:07:55,594
This is all assuming like things are

414
00:07:55,594 --> 00:07:55,994
happening randomly so to speak, or not

415
00:07:55,994 --> 00:07:56,394
so frequently. But the Shach and the

416
00:07:56,394 --> 00:07:56,794
Rema don't mean that I can hire

417
00:07:56,794 --> 00:07:57,194
a non-Jew on a permanent basis to

418
00:07:57,194 --> 00:07:57,594
be the guy pouring wine. You want

419
00:07:57,594 --> 00:07:57,994
to say that once in a while

420
00:07:57,994 --> 00:07:58,394
it happened, we can use that Rema.

421
00:07:58,394 --> 00:07:58,794
That's number one, says Rav Moshe. אבל

422
00:07:58,794 --> 00:07:59,194
לכתחילה לא שייך להתיר אף להרמ\"א שאסור

423
00:07:59,194 --> 00:07:59,594
לכתחילה. The Rema wouldn't say that. The

424
00:07:59,594 --> 00:07:59,994
Rema wouldn't say that. Second of all,

425
00:07:59,994 --> 00:08:00,394
he says, וגם הכא יש לאסור אף

426
00:08:00,394 --> 00:08:00,794
בדיעבד מדינא אף להרמ\"א שצריך להשגיח בכל

427
00:08:00,794 --> 00:08:01,194
עת ממש. Forget anything, you have a

428
00:08:01,194 --> 00:08:01,594
problem when you have unattended wine bottles.

429
00:08:01,594 --> 00:08:01,994
That's a problem in kashrus. Okay, if

430
00:08:01,994 --> 00:08:02,394
you, you know, you left the room

431
00:08:02,394 --> 00:08:02,794
and all of a sudden you came

432
00:08:02,794 --> 00:08:03,194
back and all your workers were there,

433
00:08:03,194 --> 00:08:03,594
so he says, Rav Moshe, it's not

434
00:08:03,594 --> 00:08:03,994
such a good idea, not such a

435
00:08:03,994 --> 00:08:04,394
good idea. Okay, again, the Rema's not

436
00:08:04,394 --> 00:08:04,794
wrong. We hold by that Rema, but

437
00:08:04,794 --> 00:08:05,194
we're not really going to rely on

438
00:08:05,194 --> 00:08:05,594
it for sure on a permanent lechatchila

439
00:08:05,594 --> 00:08:05,994
basis to hire, you know, Arab workers

440
00:08:05,994 --> 00:08:06,394
let's say. Okay. It doesn't matter. It

441
00:08:06,394 --> 00:08:06,794
doesn't matter. Well they can't pour closed

442
00:08:06,794 --> 00:08:07,194
bottles. It's the gravity. What if it's—they

443
00:08:07,194 --> 00:08:07,594
didn't open it, it's just in the

444
00:08:07,594 --> 00:08:07,994
office and they didn't open it till—what

445
00:08:07,994 --> 00:08:08,394
are you hiring them for? They're not

446
00:08:08,394 --> 00:08:08,794
waiters. They're carrying around—Schleppers. Yeah, you could

447
00:08:08,794 --> 00:08:09,194
hire them to schlep. So how does

448
00:08:09,194 --> 00:08:09,594
this impact, I mean, maybe we'll get

449
00:08:09,594 --> 00:08:09,994
there, bedi'eved keilim? Okay, good. Good. Hold

450
00:08:09,994 --> 00:08:10,394
on. So bedi'eved there's what to meikel

451
00:08:10,394 --> 00:08:10,794
on. There's what to meikel on. Especially

452
00:08:10,794 --> 00:08:11,194
in a place of loss. But we'll

453
00:08:11,194 --> 00:08:11,594
see, we'll see. Again, how hard is

454
00:08:11,594 --> 00:08:11,994
it to kasher a thing? It's probably

455
00:08:11,994 --> 00:08:12,394
not so hard. Sometimes it's annoying to

456
00:08:12,394 --> 00:08:12,794
kasher, but it's not a hefsed merubeh.

457
00:08:12,794 --> 00:08:13,194
Okay, fine. Yeah. So we'll see, we'll

458
00:08:13,194 --> 00:08:13,594
see in a second. Okay, so if

459
00:08:13,594 --> 00:08:13,994
you remember, if you go back to

460
00:08:13,994 --> 00:08:14,394
קכ\"ד ז. We're not going to see

461
00:08:14,394 --> 00:08:14,794
it inside, just a reminder if you

462
00:08:14,794 --> 00:08:15,194
want to see it, you go to

463
00:08:15,194 --> 00:08:15,594
קכ\"ד ז. The Shulchan Aruch here in

464
00:08:15,594 --> 00:08:15,994
קכ\"ד ז mentioned the following: He said

465
00:08:15,994 --> 00:08:16,394
that יש אוסרים בכל מקום שאסרו ביין

466
00:08:16,394 --> 00:08:16,794
שלנו שמותר בהנאה. That whenever there is

467
00:08:16,794 --> 00:08:17,194
contact by a non-Jew when it comes

468
00:08:17,194 --> 00:08:17,594
to these issues of wine... Muslim, it

469
00:08:17,594 --> 00:08:17,994
should really be okay and certainly a

470
00:08:17,994 --> 00:08:18,394
mechallel Shabbos befarhesia should be okay. So

471
00:08:18,394 --> 00:08:18,794
the question is, where does it come

472
00:08:18,794 --> 00:08:19,194
today that we're machmir about these? And

473
00:08:19,194 --> 00:08:19,594
we are machmir about mechallel Shabbos befarhesia

474
00:08:19,594 --> 00:08:19,994
also. Now, maybe not to the point

475
00:08:19,994 --> 00:08:20,394
as we'll see to embarrass somebody, but

476
00:08:20,394 --> 00:08:20,794
we are machmir that if a person

477
00:08:20,794 --> 00:08:21,194
came to your home who is a

478
00:08:21,194 --> 00:08:21,594
straight mechallel Shabbos befarhesia—not they didn't forget

479
00:08:21,594 --> 00:08:21,994
tinok shenishba, they knew what they were

480
00:08:21,994 --> 00:08:22,394
doing, they drove to your house on

481
00:08:22,394 --> 00:08:22,794
Shabbos, they honked the horn, they promoted

482
00:08:22,794 --> 00:08:23,194
it haya machanecha kadosh and they got

483
00:08:23,194 --> 00:08:23,594
to your house and they take your

484
00:08:23,594 --> 00:08:23,994
bottle of wine and they pour it,

485
00:08:23,994 --> 00:08:24,394
we're machmir. And the question is why?

486
00:08:24,394 --> 00:08:24,794
We just saw from the Rama that

487
00:08:24,794 --> 00:08:25,194
we shouldn't be machmir about these things.

488
00:08:25,194 --> 00:08:25,594
So why are we machmir? So it

489
00:08:25,594 --> 00:08:25,994
could be one answer is we're like

490
00:08:25,994 --> 00:08:26,394
the Taz, because the Taz is a

491
00:08:26,394 --> 00:08:26,794
machmir. I'm sorry, the Taz is a

492
00:08:26,794 --> 00:08:27,194
meikel, the Taz is machmir. So that's

493
00:08:27,194 --> 00:08:27,594
number one. But so the reason to

494
00:08:27,594 --> 00:08:27,994
be a little bit more machmir is

495
00:08:27,994 --> 00:08:28,394
the following. So now let's go for

496
00:08:28,394 --> 00:08:28,794
a little bit of background, we're gonna

497
00:08:28,794 --> 00:08:29,194
do the following. Okay. Go to source

498
00:08:29,194 --> 00:08:29,594
19. So here's the topic, the concept

499
00:08:29,594 --> 00:08:29,994
of what we said before of nitzuk.

500
00:08:29,994 --> 00:08:30,394
There's another halacha that relates to stam

501
00:08:30,394 --> 00:08:30,794
yeinam and that is the concept of

502
00:08:30,794 --> 00:08:31,194
nitzuk. Nitzuk means a stream that a

503
00:08:31,194 --> 00:08:31,594
stream of wine that is poured has

504
00:08:31,594 --> 00:08:31,994
a halachic connection between the container that

505
00:08:31,994 --> 00:08:32,394
the wine is in and the container

506
00:08:32,394 --> 00:08:32,794
that the cup or whatever the wine

507
00:08:32,794 --> 00:08:33,194
is going into. So the Gemara says

508
00:08:33,194 --> 00:08:35,753
in source 19 that אמר ליה רב

509
00:08:35,753 --> 00:08:38,313
חסדא לאנהו סבותא. So Rav Huna, I'm

510
00:08:38,313 --> 00:08:40,873
sorry, Rav Chisda would instruct his wine

511
00:08:40,873 --> 00:08:43,433
merchants that when they're filling bottles belonging

512
00:08:43,433 --> 00:08:45,993
to non-Jews that they should ensure כי

513
00:08:45,993 --> 00:08:48,553
חליתו חמרא (it's cut off there) אלא

514
00:08:48,553 --> 00:08:51,113
כטיפי כטוף. Really what they should do

515
00:08:51,113 --> 00:08:53,673
is they should pour it in short

516
00:08:53,673 --> 00:08:54,404
bursts. Short bursts from an elevated position

517
00:08:54,404 --> 00:08:54,804
and not to have one long stream.

518
00:08:54,804 --> 00:08:55,204
So if they are filling bottles belonging

519
00:08:55,204 --> 00:08:55,604
to non-Jews, what's Rav Chisda worried about?

520
00:08:55,604 --> 00:08:56,004
Nitzuk. I have my kli of wine,

521
00:08:56,004 --> 00:08:56,404
you have a kli that's a problem.

522
00:08:56,404 --> 00:09:05,480
If I pour from my cup into

523
00:09:05,480 --> 00:09:07,834
from my vat into your cup, well,

524
00:09:07,834 --> 00:09:10,394
it's connecting the two and it's gonna

525
00:09:10,394 --> 00:09:12,954
asser whatever is left in my barrel

526
00:09:12,954 --> 00:09:15,514
or whatever. What's the fancy thing people

527
00:09:15,514 --> 00:09:18,073
put on their tables to pour wine

528
00:09:18,073 --> 00:09:20,633
out of? Decanter. Very good. Very good.

529
00:09:20,633 --> 00:09:23,193
Okay, so Rav Chisda said don't do

530
00:09:23,193 --> 00:09:25,753
that. Rather do like this. If you

531
00:09:25,753 --> 00:09:28,313
do it like this, that's okay, because

532
00:09:28,313 --> 00:09:30,873
that's not really connecting anything. That's why

533
00:09:30,873 --> 00:09:33,433
we tell people when they're kashering, don't

534
00:09:33,433 --> 00:09:35,627
do this. You can't a little bit,

535
00:09:35,627 --> 00:09:36,027
a little bit, a little bit, you

536
00:09:36,027 --> 00:09:36,427
have to kasher again. It has to

537
00:09:36,427 --> 00:09:51,420
be nitzuk, it has to be a

538
00:09:51,420 --> 00:10:06,800
stream because you can only kasher in

539
00:10:06,800 --> 00:10:37,080
a kli rishon. So if I had

540
00:10:37,080 --> 00:11:16,700
a boiling pot of water and I

541
00:11:16,700 --> 00:11:35,400
poured a little bit and then I

542
00:11:35,400 --> 00:12:02,260
stopped and I poured a little bit

543
00:12:02,260 --> 00:12:32,745
and then I stopped, it's a question

544
00:12:32,745 --> 00:12:35,305
of does that consider nitzuk or not.

545
00:12:35,305 --> 00:12:37,865
So Rashi here on the left side,

546
00:12:37,865 --> 00:12:40,425
Rashi says that he explains this concept

547
00:12:40,425 --> 00:12:42,985
with Rav Chisda and Tosafot, I'm sorry,

548
00:12:42,985 --> 00:12:44,448
this Tosafot, Tosafot says that nitzuk is

549
00:12:44,448 --> 00:12:44,848
not really such a problem. Says Rabbeinu

550
00:12:44,848 --> 00:13:15,820
Tam, no, nitzuk is okay. It's not

551
00:13:15,820 --> 00:13:22,214
a problem. How do we pasken? So

552
00:13:22,214 --> 00:13:43,720
go into Kuf Chaf Vav now and

553
00:13:43,720 --> 00:13:49,762
it was a little bit all over

554
00:13:49,762 --> 00:13:52,322
the place tonight. If you go to

555
00:13:52,322 --> 00:13:54,882
קוף כף ו\"ו א\"ל\"ף. Okay. So the

556
00:13:54,882 --> 00:13:57,442
Shulchan Aruch in קוף כף ו\"ו א\"ל\"ף

557
00:13:57,442 --> 00:14:00,002
paskens like that Gemara that if you're

558
00:14:00,002 --> 00:14:02,562
pouring wine העירוי מכלי שיש בו יין

559
00:14:02,562 --> 00:14:05,122
עובד כוכבים אסור בהנאה נאסר כל היין

560
00:14:05,122 --> 00:14:33,220
שבכלי העליון and it would be a

561
00:14:33,220 --> 00:14:35,351
problem. If I'm pouring from my bottle

562
00:14:35,351 --> 00:14:37,911
of Kedem grape juice into your avoda

563
00:14:37,911 --> 00:14:46,780
zara cup, my whole Kedem grape juice

564
00:14:46,780 --> 00:15:06,262
is now a problem. שהעמוד הניצוק מחבר

565
00:15:06,262 --> 00:15:08,822
בין היין שבכלי העליון לבין היין שבכלי

566
00:15:08,822 --> 00:15:11,382
התחתון, that's all mixed together והוי כאילו

567
00:15:11,382 --> 00:15:13,942
יין של איסור מעורב בשל היתר. But

568
00:15:13,942 --> 00:15:16,502
אם אירה בקיטוף שקודם שנגע בשל איסור

569
00:15:16,502 --> 00:15:19,062
הפסיק קילוחו היורד מהיין של היתר מותר.

570
00:15:19,062 --> 00:15:21,622
So we pasken exactly like this, Shulchan

571
00:15:21,622 --> 00:15:24,182
Aruch paskens exactly like the Gemara says.

572
00:15:24,182 --> 00:15:26,742
In seif daled, the Shulchan Aruch explains

573
00:15:26,742 --> 00:15:28,205
הדין ניצוק חיבור הני מילי בהפסד מועט,

574
00:15:28,205 --> 00:15:28,605
that there is a chumra but it

575
00:15:28,605 --> 00:16:02,220
only apply again if it's not a

576
00:16:02,220 --> 00:16:05,030
big loss. If it's a big loss,

577
00:16:05,030 --> 00:16:34,920
we might be a little bit meikel.

578
00:16:34,920 --> 00:16:38,534
The Shach right here in seif katan

579
00:16:38,534 --> 00:16:41,094
aleph, the Shach explains the Shulchan Aruch

580
00:16:41,094 --> 00:16:43,654
is machmir only, says the following, quotes

581
00:16:43,654 --> 00:16:46,214
the Rambam. And he says אלא שהחמיר

582
00:16:46,214 --> 00:16:48,773
המחבר בדבר ואסור בהנאה והוציא היין שאינו

583
00:16:48,773 --> 00:16:51,333
אסור אלא בשתיה לא שייך בו ניצוק.

584
00:16:51,333 --> 00:16:53,893
It's only nitzuk when the actual wine

585
00:16:53,893 --> 00:16:56,453
that is in the bottom cup is

586
00:16:56,453 --> 00:16:59,013
asser. If I want to say that

587
00:16:59,013 --> 00:17:01,573
I'm connecting something that is mutter that's

588
00:17:01,573 --> 00:17:04,133
mine, something asser that's yours, your thing

589
00:17:04,133 --> 00:17:06,693
has to be asser. Well, that's gonna

590
00:17:06,693 --> 00:17:09,253
depend on Who's holding it and what

591
00:17:09,253 --> 00:17:11,813
the status of this cup is and

592
00:17:11,813 --> 00:17:14,007
what kind of religion he professes to

593
00:17:14,007 --> 00:17:14,407
be a part of. See, so it

594
00:17:14,407 --> 00:17:14,807
depends. Now, according to the shita of

595
00:17:14,807 --> 00:17:15,207
the Rama before nitzok? Correct, correct, correct.

596
00:17:15,207 --> 00:17:18,331
Okay, now, now, it's a lot of

597
00:17:18,331 --> 00:17:20,891
background. I'm not sure they have this

598
00:17:20,891 --> 00:17:23,451
way, but either way take out the

599
00:17:23,451 --> 00:17:26,011
book and now go to source twenty-one.

600
00:17:26,011 --> 00:17:28,571
Okay so now go to source twenty-one.

601
00:17:28,571 --> 00:17:31,131
So the, Joel's point is correct. Meaning

602
00:17:31,131 --> 00:17:33,691
what we learned earlier that this should

603
00:17:33,691 --> 00:17:36,250
be bedieved? So here the Ateret Shlomo

604
00:17:36,250 --> 00:17:38,810
quotes the Tiferet Adam and the Beit

605
00:17:38,810 --> 00:17:41,370
Yehuda. דכיוון שרבים אוסרים את היוצא בכוחו

606
00:17:41,370 --> 00:17:43,930
גם בהנאה שיטת הרמב\"ם הוא דמהי. Since

607
00:17:43,930 --> 00:17:44,925
there are those like the Rama and

608
00:17:44,925 --> 00:17:45,325
who else? The Taz. הנה אף על

609
00:17:45,325 --> 00:17:45,725
פי שלעניין הפסד היין פסק מרן להתיר

610
00:17:45,725 --> 00:17:46,125
בהנאה את היוצא. That you're right. We

611
00:17:46,125 --> 00:17:47,562
do accept that opinion of the Rama.

612
00:17:47,562 --> 00:17:50,122
And that opinion of the Rama says

613
00:17:50,122 --> 00:17:52,682
that any non-Jew prohibits that wine to

614
00:17:52,682 --> 00:17:55,242
drink or to benefit from. מכל מקום

615
00:17:55,242 --> 00:17:57,802
לעניין היתר שתייה לא התיר וחשש לאסור

616
00:17:57,802 --> 00:18:00,362
את ההנאה מדין ניצוק. But we are

617
00:18:00,362 --> 00:18:02,922
going to be concerned. If you're telling

618
00:18:02,922 --> 00:18:05,482
me that I know that there are

619
00:18:05,482 --> 00:18:08,042
those that are meikel but the Rama

620
00:18:08,042 --> 00:18:10,602
is machmir, then we are going to

621
00:18:10,602 --> 00:18:13,162
be machmir when it comes to nitzok.

622
00:18:13,162 --> 00:18:15,721
And he says on the left side,

623
00:18:15,721 --> 00:18:16,819
מכל מקום לכאורה יש להקל במה שהוציא

624
00:18:16,819 --> 00:18:17,219
מכוח בשתייה. The Sefer Ataret Shlomo is

625
00:18:17,219 --> 00:18:17,619
explaining the Shulchan Aruch really says this

626
00:18:17,619 --> 00:18:18,019
wine is assur. It's assur. Are there

627
00:18:18,019 --> 00:18:18,419
times that we're lenient? Yeah, we are.

628
00:18:18,419 --> 00:18:18,819
But we're not going to be lenient

629
00:18:18,819 --> 00:18:19,442
when it comes to nitzok. It's the

630
00:18:19,442 --> 00:18:22,002
same thing. So really we're going to

631
00:18:22,002 --> 00:18:24,562
be machmir. So that, that's number one.

632
00:18:24,562 --> 00:18:27,122
That maybe because of nitzok that connects

633
00:18:27,122 --> 00:18:29,682
something that's assur to something that's mutar,

634
00:18:29,682 --> 00:18:32,242
we're going to be machmir. Fine, that's

635
00:18:32,242 --> 00:18:33,705
number one. Number two. How about a

636
00:18:33,705 --> 00:18:35,420
Muslim? Okay, what about a Muslim? We

637
00:18:35,420 --> 00:18:37,162
never had a sichat chavurah context where

638
00:18:37,162 --> 00:18:39,722
we said the word Muslim this many

639
00:18:39,722 --> 00:18:42,282
times. Look in the Yabia Omer. Okay,

640
00:18:42,282 --> 00:18:44,842
so says Rav Ovadia. Says Rav Ovadia.

641
00:18:44,842 --> 00:18:47,402
זכות באר מים מעתה דברים קל וחומר

642
00:18:47,402 --> 00:18:49,962
בקיצור שבוודאי שאינו אוסר מדין ניצוק מה

643
00:18:49,962 --> 00:18:57,080
שנשאר בצלוחית העליונה. No, that you're right.

644
00:19:11,600 --> 00:19:34,231
The wine poured by a Muslim you

645
00:19:34,231 --> 00:19:36,791
can drink. Okay, but there is benefit

646
00:19:36,791 --> 00:19:37,888
that we can get from it and

647
00:19:37,888 --> 00:19:38,288
therefore nitzok does not apply. מותר אפילו

648
00:19:38,288 --> 00:19:40,211
בשתייה ורק שם מה ששפך לכוס יש

649
00:19:40,211 --> 00:19:42,771
להחמיר ולאסור בשתייה. So Rav Ovadia paskens

650
00:19:42,771 --> 00:19:45,331
that no, that it would be okay.

651
00:19:45,331 --> 00:19:47,891
You can drink what's left and nitzok

652
00:19:47,891 --> 00:19:50,451
does not forbid what was left in

653
00:19:50,451 --> 00:19:51,913
the thing, right? So that's Rav Ovadia

654
00:19:51,913 --> 00:19:53,968
about a Muslim. And the same is

655
00:19:53,968 --> 00:19:56,528
true in source twenty-two in the Sefer

656
00:19:56,528 --> 00:20:07,280
Yayin LeNesach. It's a great name of

657
00:20:07,280 --> 00:20:36,314
a Sefer. Okay, Sefer Yayin LeNesach paskens

658
00:20:36,314 --> 00:20:38,874
the same thing in source twenty-two. And

659
00:20:38,874 --> 00:20:41,434
he says that majority of Sephardi poskim

660
00:20:41,434 --> 00:20:43,262
though still say that they allow drinking

661
00:20:43,262 --> 00:21:02,271
of wine poured by a Muslim, but

662
00:21:02,271 --> 00:21:04,831
he writes in the second column it's

663
00:21:04,831 --> 00:21:07,391
just in interest of time, לכתחילה נכון

664
00:21:07,391 --> 00:21:09,951
להחמיר ולהיזהר בכוחו של ישמעאלי. Still be

665
00:21:09,951 --> 00:21:12,511
machmir. ולא יניחו לישמעאלי למזוג יין לכוסם.

666
00:21:12,511 --> 00:21:15,071
You shouldn't have them pour it. דיעבד

667
00:21:15,071 --> 00:21:17,631
שעבר ומזג מותר היין. But if he

668
00:21:17,631 --> 00:21:20,190
poured it, it would be okay. And

669
00:21:20,190 --> 00:21:34,880
the same would be true for a

670
00:21:34,880 --> 00:21:37,439
Mechalel Shabbat. So again we are pretty,

671
00:21:37,439 --> 00:21:44,520
what? Yeah. We go to forty-seven weddings

672
00:21:44,520 --> 00:21:50,914
a year at Ateres Ayala and the

673
00:21:50,914 --> 00:21:53,474
guy pouring the wine, does that affect

674
00:21:53,474 --> 00:21:56,034
this? Correct. Correct. But it's mevuashal? Stam

675
00:21:56,034 --> 00:21:57,862
mevuashal. That wine is mevuashal. Yeah. I

676
00:21:57,862 --> 00:22:32,071
don't think you're bringing a non-mevuashal wine

677
00:22:32,071 --> 00:22:34,631
there. And every caterer has that din?

678
00:22:34,631 --> 00:22:45,820
No. Most kashrus organizations will not allow

679
00:22:45,820 --> 00:23:02,522
to have a non-mevuashal event unless there

680
00:23:02,522 --> 00:23:05,082
are separate mashgiachim. Like you can have

681
00:23:05,082 --> 00:23:07,642
the kashrus are hosting an event catered

682
00:23:07,642 --> 00:23:10,202
by somebody within the cRc hashgacha and

683
00:23:10,202 --> 00:23:12,031
you want to have non-mevuashal wine, you

684
00:23:12,031 --> 00:23:29,711
would need to hire a separate mashgiach

685
00:23:29,711 --> 00:23:32,271
who will pour push the cart himself

686
00:23:32,271 --> 00:23:34,831
and only be the one to pour

687
00:23:34,831 --> 00:23:43,240
the wine. They will not let it

688
00:23:43,240 --> 00:24:05,260
at a bar. For this reason. The

689
00:24:05,260 --> 00:24:07,819
Rama's meikel about it but everybody else

690
00:24:07,819 --> 00:24:10,379
is machmir about it. So again this

691
00:24:10,379 --> 00:24:35,500
comes back to this same issue. The

692
00:24:35,500 --> 00:24:37,660
Rama allows drinking wine poured by a

693
00:24:37,660 --> 00:25:03,880
Muslim. He allows, and he permits wine

694
00:25:09,139 --> 00:25:13,937
that's poured by a Christian. So why

695
00:25:13,937 --> 00:25:16,497
are we machmir? And furthermore, if you

696
00:25:16,497 --> 00:25:19,056
look in source twenty-three, Rav Moshe himself

697
00:25:19,056 --> 00:25:38,180
says it's very, very hard to define

698
00:25:38,180 --> 00:26:05,780
a Mechalel Shabbat Befarhesya. How do you

699
00:26:05,780 --> 00:26:20,102
define such a thing? He says, I'll

700
00:26:20,102 --> 00:26:22,662
know it when you see it. Something

701
00:26:22,662 --> 00:26:45,580
like that. It's hard to give a

702
00:26:45,580 --> 00:26:48,139
metric for something like this. Meaning, the

703
00:26:48,139 --> 00:26:50,699
again, the guy who doesn't know anything,

704
00:26:50,699 --> 00:27:15,371
it's not his fault. The guy who

705
00:27:15,371 --> 00:27:25,602
only knows a certain amount of things,

706
00:27:25,602 --> 00:27:28,162
maybe not his fault. He says in

707
00:27:28,162 --> 00:27:30,722
the middle, he says ובשביל זה בביאורו

708
00:27:30,722 --> 00:27:33,282
hizkir Shulchan Aruch, there is no criteria

709
00:27:33,282 --> 00:27:35,842
listed for this. It's not listed in

710
00:27:35,842 --> 00:27:38,402
the, in the Shach, אם כן משמע

711
00:27:38,402 --> 00:27:40,962
שלא מבואר איסור ממש ועל כל פנים

712
00:27:40,962 --> 00:27:43,522
לדינא נהגו שלא לשתות יין שנהגו בישראל

713
00:27:43,522 --> 00:27:45,316
מומר לחלל שבת בפרהסיא, right? It's not

714
00:27:45,316 --> 00:27:45,716
entirely clear how to define a Mechalel

715
00:27:45,716 --> 00:27:47,645
Shabbos B'Farhesia. It's not codified anywhere. What

716
00:27:47,645 --> 00:27:50,205
about the mumar definition, someone who's l'hachis

717
00:27:50,205 --> 00:27:52,765
as opposed to? Yeah, but I'm saying

718
00:27:52,765 --> 00:27:55,325
that term is very hard to define.

719
00:27:55,325 --> 00:27:57,885
How do you know? You asked last

720
00:27:57,885 --> 00:28:00,445
week about the guy who's off the

721
00:28:00,445 --> 00:28:03,005
derech, is that l'hachis? Maybe you could

722
00:28:03,005 --> 00:28:05,565
argue it's not l'hachis, it's like his

723
00:28:05,565 --> 00:28:08,125
path back, who knows. Strayed away, he

724
00:28:08,125 --> 00:28:10,685
strayed away from. Right, so that's not

725
00:28:10,685 --> 00:28:12,879
l'hachis. Right, right, right. I mean, l'hachis

726
00:28:12,879 --> 00:28:31,300
would, you know, that's not a mumar.

727
00:28:31,300 --> 00:28:47,805
I got a call about a shidduch

728
00:28:47,805 --> 00:28:50,365
for somebody, and the girl called me

729
00:28:50,365 --> 00:29:32,060
about a shidduch for another, like a

730
00:29:32,060 --> 00:29:34,619
friend of hers. And when I reached

731
00:29:34,619 --> 00:29:36,082
out to this guy, I haven't spoken

732
00:29:36,082 --> 00:29:52,437
to him in a very long time,

733
00:29:52,437 --> 00:29:54,997
but I said to him, I said,

734
00:29:54,997 --> 00:29:57,556
she said he doesn't need like the

735
00:29:57,556 --> 00:30:00,116
most religious person, I said he's an

736
00:30:00,116 --> 00:30:04,740
atheist. Like he's mamash, like he went

737
00:30:04,880 --> 00:30:14,677
off. Like maybe a guy who grew

738
00:30:14,677 --> 00:30:17,237
up like mamash frum and like decided

739
00:30:17,237 --> 00:30:19,796
he doesn't believe in anything, maybe, I

740
00:30:19,796 --> 00:30:22,356
don't know, I don't know. So fine,

741
00:30:22,356 --> 00:30:24,916
so again, if the Shach and the

742
00:30:24,916 --> 00:30:27,476
Rema and Rabbi Akiva Eiger and the

743
00:30:27,476 --> 00:30:30,036
Noda B'Yehuda are all meikal, so why

744
00:30:30,036 --> 00:30:32,596
are we machmir? So there are, we'll

745
00:30:32,596 --> 00:30:41,140
see, there's a few others, but there's

746
00:30:41,140 --> 00:30:50,934
a few reasons to be machmir. Let's

747
00:30:50,934 --> 00:30:53,494
go to the Tzitz Eliezer in source

748
00:30:53,494 --> 00:30:56,054
24. How about the Rema, this shitta

749
00:30:56,054 --> 00:30:58,614
of the Rema? Is it davka like

750
00:30:58,614 --> 00:31:01,173
if you made the wine, it was

751
00:31:01,173 --> 00:31:03,733
kosher with Jewish people making the wine,

752
00:31:03,733 --> 00:31:06,293
and then the non-Jew pours it? Or

753
00:31:06,293 --> 00:31:08,853
would it extend, meaning if you take

754
00:31:08,853 --> 00:31:11,413
him l'shito, how does that impact like

755
00:31:11,413 --> 00:31:13,973
the whole sugia of stam yeinam? What

756
00:31:13,973 --> 00:31:15,436
do you mean? Meaning like, if the

757
00:31:15,436 --> 00:31:33,697
wine's made by a non-Jew, there's no

758
00:31:33,697 --> 00:31:58,760
problem according to this Rema? Correct, wouldn't

759
00:31:58,760 --> 00:32:04,248
be a problem. Right. So like there

760
00:32:04,248 --> 00:32:06,808
just wouldn't be the kashrut, it would

761
00:32:06,808 --> 00:32:09,368
just go away. Potentially, potentially, yeah. Okay,

762
00:32:09,368 --> 00:32:27,040
and does anyone bring that as a

763
00:32:27,040 --> 00:32:29,599
snif hakol for our task? No, not

764
00:32:29,599 --> 00:32:32,159
really, not really. Okay, so again, reason

765
00:32:32,159 --> 00:32:34,719
number one is you have the Taz.

766
00:32:34,719 --> 00:32:37,279
You have the Taz and the Rambam

767
00:32:37,279 --> 00:32:39,839
that are machmir by every single non-Jew.

768
00:32:39,839 --> 00:32:42,399
Okay, that's number one. Says the Tzitz

769
00:32:42,399 --> 00:32:44,959
Eliezer in source 24, he brings some

770
00:32:44,959 --> 00:32:47,519
reasons to defend the custom that we're

771
00:32:47,519 --> 00:32:50,079
machmir about it. He says הכל מדובר

772
00:32:50,079 --> 00:32:52,639
כששכשך שלא בכוונה. This whole institution, this

773
00:32:52,639 --> 00:32:55,199
whole idea we're discussing is when because

774
00:32:55,199 --> 00:32:55,599
the Rema's basically saying that any time

775
00:32:55,599 --> 00:32:55,999
a non-Jew touches your wine, it's shelo

776
00:32:55,999 --> 00:32:56,399
b'kavana. Says the Tzitz Eliezer אבל כשהגביה

777
00:32:56,399 --> 00:33:16,145
משכשך בכוונה כדי לשתות יין. The guy's

778
00:33:16,145 --> 00:33:18,705
job was hired as to pour the

779
00:33:18,705 --> 00:33:21,265
wine דבזה אין מי שהתיר אפילו במקום

780
00:33:21,265 --> 00:33:23,825
פסידא. He says that, that doesn't make

781
00:33:23,825 --> 00:33:24,888
sense. Meaning, if he deliberately pours a

782
00:33:24,888 --> 00:33:25,288
glass of wine, that's not shelo b'kavana,

783
00:33:25,288 --> 00:33:26,474
that's pouring wine, and therefore we should

784
00:33:26,474 --> 00:33:48,740
be machmir. The Rema wasn't talking about

785
00:33:48,740 --> 00:34:07,057
any of that. The Rema's saying it

786
00:34:07,057 --> 00:34:09,617
happens to be that he touches it,

787
00:34:09,617 --> 00:34:12,176
it's not so bad. But if I

788
00:34:12,176 --> 00:34:14,736
hire the Muslim to pour the wine,

789
00:34:14,736 --> 00:34:17,296
that is the definition of, you know,

790
00:34:17,296 --> 00:34:19,856
yayin nesech, that's how they did the

791
00:34:19,856 --> 00:34:22,416
libations, was they poured it, so we

792
00:34:22,416 --> 00:34:24,976
should be machmir. That's says, that's the

793
00:34:24,976 --> 00:34:27,536
Tzitz Eliezer. Fine. And what about the

794
00:34:27,536 --> 00:34:30,096
remaining wine in the bottle? So what

795
00:34:30,096 --> 00:34:32,656
would we say about the remaining wine

796
00:34:32,656 --> 00:34:35,216
in the bottle? So says Rav Shlomo

797
00:34:35,216 --> 00:34:37,776
Zalman. Okay, if you go to Rav

798
00:34:37,776 --> 00:34:40,336
Shlomo Zalman, now it seemed to be

799
00:34:40,336 --> 00:34:42,896
that we should say it should be

800
00:34:42,896 --> 00:34:45,456
fine the rest of the wine in

801
00:34:45,456 --> 00:34:48,016
the bottle. However, if you look in

802
00:34:48,016 --> 00:34:50,576
Rav Shlomo Zalman in source 25, Rav

803
00:34:50,576 --> 00:34:53,136
Shlomo Zalman says no. Says הנה כתב

804
00:34:53,136 --> 00:34:55,695
דאין ניצוק חיבור שייך בישמעאל אף שאינו

805
00:34:55,695 --> 00:34:58,255
עובד אלילים. So first he says this

806
00:34:58,255 --> 00:35:00,815
whole idea of nitzok is not part

807
00:35:00,815 --> 00:35:03,375
of the Arabs, she'eino oveid elilim, they

808
00:35:03,375 --> 00:35:04,689
don't worship avoda zara. לכן הסיק שמה

809
00:35:04,689 --> 00:35:05,089
שבתוך הבקבוק מותר אף בשתייה. So if

810
00:35:05,089 --> 00:35:05,489
he poured it, you're right, it should

811
00:35:05,489 --> 00:35:05,889
be a problem but not what's left

812
00:35:05,889 --> 00:35:06,289
in the bottle ורק מה שנשפך לתוך

813
00:35:06,289 --> 00:35:06,689
הכוס אסור בשתייה אולם מרן חולק עליו.

814
00:35:06,689 --> 00:35:07,089
The Sefer Rav Shlomo Zalman was machmir

815
00:35:07,089 --> 00:35:07,489
שנהגו להחמיר בנכרי אף שאינו עובד עבודה

816
00:35:07,489 --> 00:35:07,889
זרה, that he is, Rav Shlomo Zalman

817
00:35:07,889 --> 00:35:08,289
is machmir and says that if it

818
00:35:08,289 --> 00:35:08,689
was poured by a Muslim, whatever remained

819
00:35:08,689 --> 00:35:09,089
in the bottle is assur. Assur. If

820
00:35:09,089 --> 00:35:09,489
you go to the next page, they

821
00:35:09,489 --> 00:35:09,889
quote from Rav Elyashiv. Same thing. They

822
00:35:09,889 --> 00:35:10,289
quote Rav Elyashiv, not only that, he

823
00:35:10,289 --> 00:35:10,689
says he goes one step further. Mechalel

824
00:35:10,689 --> 00:35:11,416
Shabbos shavar yayin bakbuk, so the guy

825
00:35:11,416 --> 00:35:20,482
comes, he's a mechalel shabbos, he takes

826
00:35:20,482 --> 00:35:23,042
the wine, he pours it, אי אפשר

827
00:35:23,042 --> 00:35:25,602
לסמוך על הש\"ך. Don't rely on the

828
00:35:25,602 --> 00:35:28,162
Shach ולהתיר מה שנשאר בבקבוק ואסור לשתות

829
00:35:28,162 --> 00:35:33,880
את זה אם כן מחלל שבת הוא

830
00:35:34,880 --> 00:35:46,871
בפרהסיא. If he's a Mechalel Shabbos B'Farhesia,

831
00:35:46,871 --> 00:36:34,985
it is going to be a problem.

832
00:36:34,985 --> 00:36:37,545
So again, even though the Rema and

833
00:36:37,545 --> 00:36:40,105
the Shach and the Noda B'Yehuda and

834
00:36:40,105 --> 00:36:42,665
Rabbi Akiva Eiger are meikal, we are

835
00:36:42,665 --> 00:36:45,225
machmir. about this halacha. We are machmir

836
00:36:45,225 --> 00:36:47,785
about this halacha. Why would we machmir

837
00:36:47,785 --> 00:36:50,345
about this halacha? So in source 27,

838
00:36:50,345 --> 00:36:52,905
they quote in the name of Rav

839
00:36:52,905 --> 00:36:55,465
Shlomo Zalman the following. We only seem

840
00:36:55,465 --> 00:36:58,025
to assur the stuff that comes out

841
00:36:58,025 --> 00:37:00,585
of the bottle. Now we're saying what's

842
00:37:00,585 --> 00:37:03,145
in the bottle? כותב שם הגאון רב

843
00:37:03,145 --> 00:37:05,704
שלמה זלמן אוירבך שנוהגים להחמיר אף בנוכרי

844
00:37:05,704 --> 00:37:07,899
שאינו בעובד עבודה זרה. He's machmir about

845
00:37:07,899 --> 00:37:08,299
a goy who's not even a terrible

846
00:37:08,299 --> 00:37:08,699
avoda zara. וכגון ישמעאל שיין הבא מכוחו

847
00:37:08,699 --> 00:37:09,099
נאסר. So therefore they would assur the

848
00:37:09,099 --> 00:37:14,225
wine that was poured by a Muslim.

849
00:37:14,225 --> 00:37:16,785
ולכן אם מזג מבקבוק לכוס מה שבכוס

850
00:37:16,785 --> 00:37:19,345
נאסר ואף מה שבבקבוק אסור. And he

851
00:37:19,345 --> 00:37:21,905
says even what's inside is assur. וכן

852
00:37:21,905 --> 00:37:24,465
נראה דעת הציץ אליעזר. But he says

853
00:37:24,465 --> 00:37:27,025
v'divreihem tzrichim iyun. Now whenever you have

854
00:37:27,025 --> 00:37:48,340
somebody who ends v'divreihem tzrichim iyun, it's

855
00:37:48,340 --> 00:37:50,534
a big question. And apparently it's shared

856
00:37:50,534 --> 00:37:53,094
that they're not sure that Rav Elyashiv

857
00:37:53,094 --> 00:37:55,654
actually said this. They don't know and

858
00:37:55,654 --> 00:37:58,214
it's not, it's been reported in his

859
00:37:58,214 --> 00:38:00,773
name but maybe not being so accurate.

860
00:38:00,773 --> 00:38:03,333
Okay. Either way, let's finish off with

861
00:38:03,333 --> 00:38:05,893
one more. And that is the Avnei

862
00:38:05,893 --> 00:38:08,453
Nezer in source 28. Okay? So whether

863
00:38:08,453 --> 00:38:11,013
or not Rav Elyashiv did say it,

864
00:38:11,013 --> 00:38:13,573
he didn't say it, we'll have to

865
00:38:13,573 --> 00:38:16,133
figure that out. Okay. Somebody spoke about

866
00:38:16,133 --> 00:38:18,693
that right, right. Okay. Says the Avnei

867
00:38:18,693 --> 00:38:21,253
Nezer the following. אומנם מחלל שבת אין

868
00:38:21,253 --> 00:38:23,813
בו קולא שלא בכוונה. First he says

869
00:38:23,813 --> 00:38:26,373
that, you know, when it comes to

870
00:38:26,373 --> 00:38:28,933
m'challel shabbos they don't have that kula.

871
00:38:28,933 --> 00:38:31,493
אם כן חזר דינו כיוון שאסר יין

872
00:38:31,493 --> 00:38:34,053
במגעו. Since it's assur for him to

873
00:38:34,053 --> 00:38:36,613
touch it. אם כן גם מה שנשפך

874
00:38:36,613 --> 00:38:39,173
לכוס נאסר משום כוחו וגם מה שנמצא

875
00:38:39,173 --> 00:38:41,733
בתוך הבקבוק אין להתיר רק בהפסד מרובה.

876
00:38:41,733 --> 00:38:44,292
Whatever he poured in is going to

877
00:38:44,292 --> 00:38:46,852
be assur and whatever's left inside, אין

878
00:38:46,852 --> 00:38:49,412
להתיר רק בהפסד מרובה. Why? Because when

879
00:38:49,412 --> 00:38:51,972
the Rema said this, וכן זה לא

880
00:38:51,972 --> 00:38:54,532
אם לא הרים המחלל שבת את הבקבוק,

881
00:38:54,532 --> 00:38:57,092
the Rema was when things were done

882
00:38:57,092 --> 00:38:59,652
without intention. But this is done with

883
00:38:59,652 --> 00:39:00,384
intention. So even though there might not

884
00:39:00,384 --> 00:39:00,784
be a problem of real nisuch, of

885
00:39:00,784 --> 00:39:01,184
real like whatever avoda zara things that

886
00:39:01,184 --> 00:39:01,584
they're doing with the wine, says the

887
00:39:01,584 --> 00:39:01,984
Avnei Nezer and others that we are

888
00:39:01,984 --> 00:39:02,384
going to be machmir. So in the

889
00:39:02,384 --> 00:39:02,784
end of the day, there are reasons

890
00:39:02,784 --> 00:39:03,184
to be meikel. Reasons to be meikel,

891
00:39:03,184 --> 00:39:03,584
wine poured by non-religious Jew, we said

892
00:39:03,584 --> 00:39:03,984
many poskim, Shach, Rabbi Akiva Eiger, that

893
00:39:03,984 --> 00:39:04,384
take one second back. Binyan Tzion and

894
00:39:04,384 --> 00:39:04,784
everybody else, all those people are considered

895
00:39:04,784 --> 00:39:05,184
tinok shenishba let's say. That's idea number

896
00:39:05,184 --> 00:39:05,607
one. That maybe today most non-religious, you

897
00:39:05,607 --> 00:39:08,167
know, non-religious Jews, most non-religious Jews probably

898
00:39:08,167 --> 00:39:09,264
should be okay. Rav Moshe says it's

899
00:39:09,264 --> 00:39:09,664
unclear what a m'challel shabbos befarhesia is

900
00:39:09,664 --> 00:39:10,064
in its definition. Number two. Number three

901
00:39:10,064 --> 00:39:11,282
that for sure that the Rema is

902
00:39:11,282 --> 00:39:13,842
going to be meikel about, you know,

903
00:39:13,842 --> 00:39:16,402
not drinking it if it was poured

904
00:39:16,402 --> 00:39:18,962
but for sure he's not if there's

905
00:39:18,962 --> 00:39:21,522
no intention it's going to be allowed.

906
00:39:21,522 --> 00:39:24,082
But the end of the day what

907
00:39:24,082 --> 00:39:26,642
does seem to be is that we

908
00:39:26,642 --> 00:39:29,202
do, we are machmir about this. Rav

909
00:39:29,202 --> 00:39:31,762
Shlomo Zalman, Rav Elyashiv are machmir about

910
00:39:31,762 --> 00:39:34,322
it. But it seems that there is

911
00:39:34,322 --> 00:39:36,882
what to rely on in these situations

912
00:39:36,882 --> 00:39:38,344
and definitely not to embarrass somebody. To

913
00:39:38,344 --> 00:39:38,744
a goy, to a non-religious Jew. So

914
00:39:38,744 --> 00:39:39,144
if the non-religious Jew comes to your

915
00:39:39,144 --> 00:39:40,956
house and he's taking and pouring the

916
00:39:40,956 --> 00:39:43,516
wine you're like oh gosh you just

917
00:39:43,516 --> 00:39:46,076
traifed up my kitchen you non-religious Jew,

918
00:39:46,076 --> 00:39:48,300
that would be embarrassment. Embarrassment is a

919
00:39:48,300 --> 00:39:50,859
d'oraysa, we're worried about dinei d'rabbanan. There

920
00:39:50,859 --> 00:39:53,419
are times you can embarrass people if

921
00:39:53,419 --> 00:39:55,979
they're doing there's the whole context of

922
00:39:55,979 --> 00:39:58,539
tochacha but not when it's going to

923
00:39:58,539 --> 00:40:01,099
come in the face of embarrassment. So

924
00:40:01,099 --> 00:40:03,659
you have to you know you have

925
00:40:03,659 --> 00:40:06,219
to realize that we are machmir about

926
00:40:06,219 --> 00:40:08,779
it. Rav Shlomo Zalman, Rav Elyashiv are

927
00:40:08,779 --> 00:40:11,339
machmir about it. But it seems that

928
00:40:11,339 --> 00:40:13,899
there is what to rely on in

929
00:40:13,899 --> 00:40:16,459
these situations and definitely not to embarrass

930
00:40:16,459 --> 00:40:19,019
somebody. So next week we'll look at

931
00:40:19,019 --> 00:40:21,579
some of these more practical examples, but

932
00:40:21,579 --> 00:40:22,600
that wraps up some of the more

933
00:40:22,600 --> 00:40:23,000
lamdus behind this topic. All right, we'll

934
00:40:23,000 --> 00:40:23,400
davven maariv. It is very hot in

935
00:40:23,400 --> 00:40:23,800
here. Holy shit. What's the plan? If

936
00:40:23,800 --> 00:40:24,200
there's going to be no air conditioning

937
00:40:24,200 --> 00:40:24,600
anywhere, you know what? Just the mold.

938
00:40:24,600 --> 00:40:25,000
I thought the mold is a nice

939
00:40:25,000 --> 00:40:25,400
added touch. I know next week. Next

940
00:40:25,400 --> 00:40:25,800
week. Next week. Oh I'm in Maine

941
00:40:25,800 --> 00:40:26,200
this week so better be fixed. Fixed.

942
00:40:26,200 --> 00:40:26,600
Bravo! Bravo! בריך שמה דמארי עלמא. ברכו

943
00:40:26,600 --> 00:40:27,000
את ה' המברך. ברוך ה' המברך לעולם

944
00:40:27,000 --> 00:40:27,400
ועד. ברוך ה' המברך לעולם ועד. Amen.

945
00:40:27,400 --> 00:40:27,800
ברוך אתה ה' אלהינו מלך העולם אשר

946
00:40:27,800 --> 00:40:28,200
בדברו מעריב ערבים. והוא חי וקים תמיד

947
00:40:28,200 --> 00:40:28,600
ימלוך עלינו לעולם ועד. ברוך אתה ה'

948
00:40:28,600 --> 00:40:29,000
המעריב ערבים. Amen.

