1
00:00:00,000 --> 00:00:29,999
<i>yayin nesech</i> so we'll see tonight some more of the applications of <i>yayin nesech</i> as well as hopefully we'll get to the little bit about <i>bishul</i>. Okay so first just a few more examples that they have here and then we'll once we get to source 23 the <i>Gemara</i> tonight is about <i>bishul</i>. So let's just go to source 16. Okay this is a <i>sheila</i> of the of the <i>Chuvous Hanhagos</i> of <i>Rav Sternbuch</i>. No, we did this one, second. No we didn't, okay.

2
00:00:30,000 --> 00:00:59,999
Yeah. So the question is can you buy kosher wine from Jewish-owned stores that also sell non-kosher wine. That's the <i>sheila</i>. So we mentioned that you really can't benefit from <i>stam yeinam</i>. So the issue is can you can you do this. So says the <i>Chuvous Hanhagos</i> מעכשיו כשהיהודי קונה בחנות זאת אפילו יין כשר או שאר דברים ומקבל עודף בחזרה לא הכשילו בכסף של איסור סתם יינם. But says the <i>Chuvous Hanhagos</i> it's probable the money that's coming to you from the cash register is prohibited because if

3
00:01:00,000 --> 00:01:29,999
that cash register had money that was used for purchase of you know non-kosher wine that would be a problem. So he really says the best thing to do probably be not to pay with cash, but you know more of an issue really in <i>Eretz Yisrael</i> than it would be here. You don't really have too many Jewish-owned wine stores here and if they're Jewish-owned wine stores they're most likely not selling non-kosher wine. So okay fine. Next. So we learned before that if you look

4
00:01:30,000 --> 00:01:59,999
in the <i>Rashash</i>... what's the issue there? You're benefiting. You can't benefit from money that was purchased for <i>stam yeinam</i>. So at a store that sells both the money that I get that could be money that was used to purchase non-kosher wine that money's <i>assur</i>. Not just the benefit from the money itself is <i>assur</i>. The money? Yeah. So because somebody else paid for non-kosher? In cash. In cash. In cash. Yeah. Okay. Okay. So the question is can you

5
00:02:00,000 --> 00:02:30,999
buy kosher wine... the <i>inyan</i> is you getting it back. Correct correct correct. So I mean if you had exact change it wouldn't make a difference. Correct, yeah. The <i>Chuvous Hanhagos</i> said <i>odef bachazara</i> so it's just an issue of the... yeah. Okay so we learned earlier we learned earlier that <i>Chazal</i> said that <i>stam yeinam</i>, right, wine owned by a non-Jew was done to prevent intermarriage, okay. So are you allowed to buy kosher wine, okay, with a <i>hechsher</i> from a store that is owned by non-Jews.

6
00:02:31,000 --> 00:03:00,999
Okay so now it's a non-kosher store and I want to buy kosher wine from that store. Okay. What? Turn the air on maybe. Push the button. Done. That one. Button. Okay okay. For example your local non-kosher wine store. Your Walmart, your whatever. Jewel. Jewel, your Binny's, okay, sells kosher wine. Can I buy it... is it owned by a Jew? Can I buy it from there?

7
00:03:01,000 --> 00:03:31,999
So we learned that under certain circumstances a Jew can use non-Jewish wine so if you look in the <i>Rashash</i> if you look in the <i>Rashash</i> the <i>Rashash</i> writes the following. So says the <i>Rashash</i> in source 17. He says ואולי יש לומר כיון דיינם נאסר משום בנותיהם כמו פת עובד כוכבים ואינו כמו דאינו אסור עד שיהיה גמרו על ידי עובד כוכבים. The <i>Rashash</i> says that <i>stam yeinam</i>

8
00:03:32,000 --> 00:04:01,999
is like <i>pas akkum</i> that it's only forbidden really like the entire process is under Jewish ownership but if simply the guy is a middleman for selling it the <i>Rashash</i> is not so concerned that this should be an issue. <i>Rav Nevenzahl</i> does <i>pasken</i> like this that you can buy wine from those that want you can buy your wine from Walmart. I don't I wouldn't promote that. Even non-<i>mevushal</i> because it's sealed? I haven't reached <i>mevushal</i> yet. Haven't reached <i>mevushal</i> yet. Okay next, <i>weiter</i>.

9
00:04:02,000 --> 00:04:33,999
A little bit about the severity of <i>stam yeinam</i>. Some pretty intense stuff here. So first if you look in the <i>Chochmas Adam</i> in source number 18. So says the <i>Chochmas Adam</i> וכן גזרו שאפילו סתם יינם יהיה אסור בהנאה מגזירת י\"ח ואפילו יבוא אליהו לא מהני התר לאיסור זה שכבר קיבלו עליהם כל ישראל ואיסור של סתם יינם אף על פי שהוא קל בעיני העולם ודמה לשאר

10
00:04:34,000 --> 00:05:03,999
איסורי דרבנן באמת הוא איסור חמור מאוד והשותה סתם יינם. This is amazing. If you drink <i>stam yeinam</i> <i>oker nishmaso</i>. מקום שנשרש בו קדושה. You've

11
00:05:04,000 --> 00:05:33,999
uprooted your soul from its very source. Yeah, <i>hashomer be'einavav</i> אין לו חלק לעולם הבא. This is not like this is not some rabbi out of <i>Bnei Brak</i>. This is the <i>Chachmas Adam</i>. והחמירו מאוד בעונש המקובל ונתחבר על זה ספר מיוחד נקרא יין משומר והקורא בו תסמר שערות ראשו מגודל העונש. Right, meaning like this is this is bad. Okay, the <i>Rema paskens</i> you've got to like fast five different times. So, now, the question is why? I mean, why is

12
00:05:34,000 --> 00:06:03,999
it that we're so <i>chamur</i> about <i>yayin nesech</i>? So I mean there's a lot of reasons, but we discussed last week, one, there is the בל מן עבודה זרה. Two, anything that's going to, you know, we can make jokes that this and this leads to intermarriage and yet when the intermarriage rate rises to what it is today we're like oh my gosh, how did that happen? Well there was rules in place. Well we're talking about <i>stam</i>, now. Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, but it's <i>gezeira ata</i>. Correct. That's why it's a <i>gezeira</i>. Right. So the <i>Ben Ish Chai</i>, the <i>Ben Ish Chai</i> in the 19th

13
00:06:04,000 --> 00:06:34,999
century, the <i>Ben Ish Chai</i> writes the following. He says המה ראו ברוח קודשם טעם סתר ונעלם באיסור זה שגזרו עליו. The <i>Ben Ish Chai</i> says there's a certain thing that maybe <i>Chazal</i> didn't want to reveal to us. They don't want to let us know ודרך חכמים שלא לגלות טעם הסודי. You should know that they didn't reveal it to us, ורק אומרים טעם הפשטי. The <i>Ben Ish Chai</i> in his <i>halacha</i>, they they told us these <i>pshat</i>. But you should realize that there's a deeper there's a deeper <i>pshat</i>, לכן אפילו מסתלק טעם

14
00:06:35,000 --> 00:07:04,999
הפשטי באיזה זמן. And maybe you'll find a time where that regular <i>pshat</i> sort of doesn't apply. הרי איסור זה אין לו היתר לעולם בשום זמן ובשום מקום. There is no escaping this concept even if one of those reasons no longer applies. The idea of <i>stam yeinam</i> is going to apply forever, not forever, but applies and you should be very, very, very careful about this, okay? And if you continue a little bit more, if you go to the <i>Shelah</i> in source 20, okay? If you go to the

15
00:07:05,000 --> 00:07:34,999
<i>Shelah</i> in source 20, a wild <i>Shelah</i>, okay? The <i>Shelah</i> writes ומצאתי בספר טעמי מצות שחיבר רב מנחם הבבלי. So quoted by <i>Rav Menachem HaBavli</i> שכתב בלאו שלא לשתות יין נסך וזה לשונו ובימי חורפי ראיתי אנשי מעשה. I saw people, <i>anshei ma'aseh</i>, usually, you know, <i>heiligeh Yidden</i>. <i>Shemachmirim al atzmam</i>, they were more <i>machmir</i>, שאפילו בראיית הגוי היין. Even if the <i>goy</i> looked at your wine,

16
00:07:35,000 --> 00:08:04,999
לא היה רוצה לשתותו אף על פי שלא נגע בו גוי. Even if he didn't actually see it, you know, okay? And if you have <i>mevushal</i> wine? I mean, just read the <i>Shelah</i>. It's a big deal. Big deal. And Noam didn't get to that yet. Hold on to that. We're talking about we're talking about <i>stam yeinam</i>. So he says, כיוון שנעשה אינו בו סימן ברכה. It's not going to be good, it's not <i>asur</i>, but it's not going to be good. כיוון שהגוי רואה גביע יין ביד ישראל כמו צרה בעין

17
00:08:05,000 --> 00:08:34,999
שכלו. And and he says ואל תסמך לדקדק חומרה כחוט השערה וכל השונה. Don't laugh. השמר ממנו זוכה ליין המשומר בענביו. You'll you'll find a lot of <i>bracha</i>. And and he says at the end, ותמה אני על המקילים. Why so many are <i>meikel</i> on this. He says להחמיר על כל החומרות ועל זה נאמר קדש עצמך במותר לך. Okay, so he's pretty intense. What's he saying what's he saying they're <i>meikel</i> on? Drinking <i>stam yeinam</i>? Drinking it? Like <i>mamash</i>.

18
00:08:35,000 --> 00:09:04,999
And finally, the <i>Ohel Yaakov</i> does come in and says tells us, first in source 21 and then source 22, what exactly does this does this idea of the <i>Shelah</i> mean that you've got to look at it? I mean, we cool out the <i>Shelah</i>, so how do I know this is the <i>Shelah</i> we've got to we have to follow? So in the <i>Ohel Yaakov</i> he says ויש מחמירים שהגוי לא יסתכל ביין ויש אומרים שאין קפידה במקום שהגוי הסתכל ביין דרך בקבוק זכוכית וכדומה. What do you mean through the bottle? That he says that he doesn't have special powers. מיהו חסידים ואנשי מעשה מקפידים גם בזה. But there are some

19
00:09:05,000 --> 00:09:34,999
people that even if he's looked at it through the bottle, וכן יש שהקפידו שלא יראה הגוי את היין אפילו דרך בקבוק זכוכית. <i>Goy</i> comes to your house, you don't just hide the, you know, whatever, you don't hide the silverware, you hide the wine. But in source 22, they quote in the name of <i>Rav Elyashiv</i>, <i>me'ikar hadin</i>, okay, everybody calm down. <i>Re'iyas goy yayin</i>, if the <i>goy</i> sees your wine, מדינה מותר בשתייה מותר לקדש עליו. Only if he's <i>nogaya bo hagoy</i>. Okay, fine. Now, I'll tell you one other application they talk about here which is a very interesting thing which,

20
00:09:35,000 --> 00:10:04,999
you know, we might not have thought about and that is could somebody... We have lots of times in <i>Halacha</i> when the <i>Halacha</i> says X, but sometimes there's <i>pikuach nefesh</i>, there's <i>refuah</i>, okay? How do you know when when to be <i>meikel</i>, when not to be <i>meikel</i>? So the <i>Gemara</i> in <i>Sanhedrin</i> tells us, well it's very simple. You have different levels. I mean the <i>Gemara</i> in <i>Sanhedrin</i> is the well-known <i>Gemara</i> that they said כל עבירה שבתורה אם אומרים לאדם עבור ואל תהרג. <i>yaavor v'al yeihareg</i>. That do them or get killed, <i>yaavor v'al yeihareg</i>, you should

21
00:10:05,000 --> 00:10:34,999
do the <i>aveira</i> חוץ מעבודה כוכבים גילוי עריות ושפיכות דמים. The big three. However, we have many times where a person is sick, so there's a <i>shaila</i>, should I go to the hospital or not go to the hospital? You got to ask professionals, you got to ask doctors, something on <i>Shabbos</i> came up to me, what about a broken toe? I had a <i>shaila</i> a few weeks ago, you like this, doctor. A kid had a piece of metal stuck in his

22
00:10:35,000 --> 00:11:04,999
hand <i>erev Shabbos</i>, and it was in their palm somewhere. So they asked me what they should do <i>erev</i> for <i>Shabbos</i>. Obviously with my deep medical knowledge, I called two doctors, I called a pediatrician and he gave me one answer, I called another pediatrician and he gave me a different answer. In the end, I told them it's better to go because you don't want it to get infected and that was the doctor's word. They're <i>meikil</i>, we're <i>meikil</i> in certain things. I am a big fan of <i>Hatzalah</i>. But I always like when people say, I'm not sure if

23
00:11:05,000 --> 00:11:35,999
I should go to the hospital, but I'll call <i>Hatzalah</i>. <i>Hatzalah</i> takes you, it's good because you get in quicker, but you being <i>m'chalel Shabbos</i> is no better than me being <i>m'chalel Shabbos</i>. We're <i>m'chalel Shabbos</i> when we have to be. So the <i>shaila</i> is, if a doctor says you need to drink this wine, the only wine out there is the wine and it's not a kosher wine. Could you drink it? We just saw these <i>chumros</i> that you shouldn't, what should you do? The <i>Gemara</i> in <i>Sanhedrin</i> says obviously the only three big <i>aveiros</i>. But look in the <i>Beis Yosef</i>.

24
00:11:36,000 --> 00:12:06,999
The <i>Beis Yosef</i> writes in source... Was it <i>yayin nesech</i> that would be <i>aveira</i> of <i>avoda kochavim</i>? Is <i>yayin nesech</i> included in <i>yeihareg v'al yaavor</i>? It's part of <i>ovdei kochavim</i>. Hold on a second, I'm talking about <i>yayin nesech</i>. If a guy says bow down to this idol or I'll kill you, then you get killed. If a person says drink this wine that was used for <i>avoda zara</i> or get killed... So you're saying it's a step further. That's the question, that's the question. Says <i>azoy zugt</i> the <i>Beis Yosef</i>. So first

25
00:12:07,000 --> 00:12:37,999
there is an earlier <i>Beis Yosef</i> that they do not quote here. There's an earlier <i>Beis Yosef</i> in <i>kuf-chaf-gimmel</i>. If you have the <i>Shulchan Aruch</i> we'll be able to look in it inside, that a sick person should not use <i>yayin nesech</i>. That's what the <i>Beis Yosef</i> says. If you're a sick person you should not use <i>yayin nesech</i>, but it does not seem that the <i>Shulchan Aruch</i> seems to follow that way. But this is the big question. The big question would be number one, what do I do about

26
00:12:38,000 --> 00:13:08,999
<i>yayin nesech</i>? Number two is... is this <i>stam yeinam</i>? That's <i>yayin nesech</i>. The <i>Beis Yosef</i> says earlier in <i>kuf-chaf-gimmel</i>, if it's use <i>yayin nesech</i> or die, you die. Now, could you use <i>stam yeinam</i> for medicinal purposes? So the <i>Shach</i> later, not the <i>Shach</i> here, says you absolutely could drink <i>stam yeinam</i>. Person says you got to drink this wine, living is important, the

27
00:13:09,000 --> 00:13:38,999
<i>stam yeinam</i> is very important, but <i>stam yeinam</i> is an <i>issur d'rabbanan</i>. Violate the <i>d'rabbanan</i> so you can stay alive. What about somebody whose life is not really in danger? Maybe it's helpful. So look at the <i>Beis Yosef</i>. The <i>Beis Yosef</i> here in source 24 quotes the <i>Rashba</i>. <i>Kosav haRashba</i>. This <i>Beis Yosef</i>? It's here, <i>kuf-chaf-gimmel</i>. I have to look

28
00:13:39,000 --> 00:14:09,999
it up in mine. I forgot my actual... I think it's <i>beis</i> or <i>gimmel</i> or <i>daled</i> maybe. <i>Kosav haRashba</i> תשובה אמרה אם מותר לעשות מרחץ מסתם יינם או לא זו ודאי צריכה עיון מכל מקום נראה לי שאסור בחולה שאין בו סכנה. The <i>Rashba</i> says there is never <i>hetter</i> to consume rabbinically forbidden things for non-dangerous

29
00:14:10,000 --> 00:14:39,999
illnesses. You have on <i>Shabbos</i> you have חולה שיש בו סכנה, that's life is <i>mamash</i> in danger, we violate <i>Shabbos</i>. You have חולה שאין בו סכנה. And you have what's called a <i>meichush</i>. There are three levels on <i>Shabbos</i>. A <i>meichush</i> is the least, you know the example, there are a lot of people that don't take any medicine on <i>Shabbos</i> because you shouldn't take medicine on <i>Shabbos</i>. But if I take... if I have to take medicine you're going to be worse then you do take medicine on <i>Shabbos</i>. If I don't take the medicine I'm going to get a terrible migraine and I don't

30
00:14:40,000 --> 00:15:09,999
take Advil, it's going to get worse, so you take Advil. But that's a <i>meichush</i>. חולה שאין בו סכנה we're a little bit more <i>machmir</i> for, and חולה שאין בו סכנה... חולה שיש בו סכנה we're not <i>machmir</i> at all. So the <i>Rashba</i> says there is no <i>hetter</i> to do any of this for a חולה שאין בו סכנה. so to drink <i>stam yeinam</i> just because it's going to help me would be <i>assur</i>. The <i>Rashba</i> says obviously too now. Here's the next question.

31
00:15:10,000 --> 00:15:39,999
He says, ואומר אני שיש לאסור מפני שלא מצאתי היתר לאכילה ולשתייה אפילו באיסורי דרבנן בחולה שאין בו סכנה. Can't drink it. So the doctor recommends, listen, I think you could you're you're pretty healthy, but I think you could go for a good round of some <i>stam yeinam</i>. You'd have to say doctor, listen, thank you very much, but it's not going to work for me. אלא בבישולי גוים לבד. Fine. Then he writes at the last line: וכן כיוצא בזה מעתה יש לדון ולאסור לרחוץ בסתם יינם, even to bathe in that wine would be a problem, not

32
00:15:40,000 --> 00:16:10,999
just bathing in it, what else would be considered bathing? Like anointing oneself with it. Why? דרחיצה הרי הוא כשתיה. So there the <i>Rashba paskens</i>, this is what's called in the <i>halacha sicha k'shtiya</i>, anointing myself with it is like drinking it. So if I can't drink <i>stam yeinam</i>, then I also can't anoint myself with <i>stam yeinam</i>. You get <i>hana'ah</i> from <i>stam yeinam</i>? Okay. So this would seem to suggest no. Right. It has to be drinking it

33
00:16:11,000 --> 00:16:40,999
as opposed to <i>hana'ah</i>. Now, you're saying could I could I use it and sell to somebody and make some money out of it? I don't know, whatever, just get <i>hana'ah</i> from it. <i>Stam yeinam</i>, yes. We saw the <i>Shulchan Aruch</i> no, the <i>Rema</i> yes. You know, like could I put it in my what are those things called in the vents with the purifiers whatever you know? Yeah the air freshener, yeah humidifier. Yeah, what's the new fancy ones you know, whatever. Could you use a <i>stam yeinam</i> one? Okay maybe they're having a <i>stam yeinam</i> one. So now, if you look

34
00:16:41,000 --> 00:17:10,999
in the <i>Shulchan Aruch</i>, I don't know if anybody has those packets, I forgot to bring them back but you should have them. You have one? I have I have I have it. Thank you. Okay, so if you look in the <i>Shulchan Aruch</i> in <i>kuf chaf gimmel</i>, קכ\"ג ב. So here the <i>Shulchan Aruch</i> says, אסור לעשות מרחץ מסתם יינם לחולה שאין בו סכנה. Very straightforward. You cannot make a bath from wine from non-Jews for somebody who is a חולה שאין בו

35
00:17:11,000 --> 00:17:44,999
סכנה. The <i>Rema</i>, the the <i>Rema</i> here just says look, עיין לקמן סוף סימן קנה. So if you went to סימן קנה, that's where the <i>Rema paskens</i> himself that you can do it you can bathe in it, you just can't drink it. That's the <i>Rema</i>. That's the <i>Rema</i>. Now, let me see if I can find it here. The <i>Gra</i>, the <i>Be'er HaGolah</i>, no... one second...

36
00:17:45,000 --> 00:18:14,999
<i>yud zayin</i>. Hold on a second. One second. All right, there is a <i>Gra</i>, I wrote the wrong thing here. Okay, fine. So we'll go to a few a few applications here. One of the applications is something called resveratrol. Dr. Jackman? You

37
00:18:15,000 --> 00:18:45,999
don't know? All right, I believe it's a they have a picture of it here. It's an antioxidant found in red wine, commonly marketed as being beneficial for the heart and anti-aging anti-inflammatory purposes but actually its effectiveness is debated. Okay, so could you take these because their derivatives are from from <i>stam yeinam</i>? <i>Shulchan Aruch</i>, <i>Rema</i> would probably agree that it is <i>assur</i> because you're not this is not like life and death quickly grab the anti-aging

38
00:18:46,000 --> 00:19:15,999
wine pill and save your life. There's also a cream, okay? The <i>Rema</i> would probably be <i>meikel</i> on the cream. The <i>Shulchan Aruch</i> would be <i>machmir</i> on the cream. Although they write here in the notes that the cream is most likely has only one percent of actual resveratrol. Yeah. Is that right? It's a natural compound found in red grape skin. Yeah, ah, very good. Exactly. Okay, good. Now, if you go if you go now back to the <i>Shulchan Aruch</i> to <i>yud dalet</i>. Go to <i>seif yud dalet</i>.

39
00:19:16,000 --> 00:19:46,999
So the <i>Shulchan Aruch</i> in <i>seif yud dalet</i> has the following <i>halacha</i>. Says the <i>Shulchan Aruch</i>, חרצנים וזגים של עובדי כוכבים. So skins and seeds <i>she'ovdei kochavim</i>, you know skins and seeds that they've used. וכן שמרי היין שלהם תוך יב חודש אסורים בהנאה. Can't benefit. לאחר יב חודש מותרים אפילו באכילה, that you

40
00:19:47,000 --> 00:20:16,999
could have them as long as you wash them off in water. Okay, why why is that? Because what is the assumption that after twelve months there's only really left? Okay. So the <i>shaila</i> is there is something... But I did, so the question is, grape seed oil is made so the <i>shayla</i> would be what would we

41
00:20:17,000 --> 00:20:46,999
<i>paskin</i> about this? So look in the <i>Chatam Sofer</i>. Yes they have an OU, that's what we <i>paskin</i>. So the <i>Chatam Sofer</i> didn't live with the OU, it's very interesting. The <i>Chatam Sofer</i> writes in Source 25. So the <i>shayla</i> is going to be, okay, the seeds are separated from the grape, they're dried. Could you, and then they're made through drying this out, could you permit non-Jewish grape seed oil? Even if the grapes had not been dried for 12 months. After

42
00:20:47,000 --> 00:21:16,999
12 months fine, what about before? So says the <i>Chatam Sofer</i>: כל מקום לא ידעתי שום מקום לאסור. I don't know why we would make this <i>assur</i>. Number one: דכח היין שבחצן מסתבך ונעשה ממנו שמן. What you're discussing here is oil, and what really is produced is a new thing, right? It's a new thing altogether. It's not the wine. Next, then he adds: ואם משום תערובת יין כיון שטעמו כמה פעמים ולא נטעם ונרגש בו

43
00:21:17,000 --> 00:21:46,999
טעם יין אין לחוש. I'm not really so concerned about all of this and therefore it would be okay to have grape seed oil. And then not only that, the <i>Emek Teshuva</i> of <i>Yechezkel Roth</i>, who was a <i>Satmar Dayan</i>, he says not only that, but today the way they do this is they heat it up to 400 degrees and 500 degrees, we're not really so concerned. You can go ahead and purchase as much grape seed oil

44
00:21:47,000 --> 00:22:17,999
from your local non-Jewish neighbor as much as you'd like. What? <i>Shemen Kitniyot</i>? Yeah, yeah, exactly, exactly. Okay fine. Let's go <i>weiter</i> into the topic of, unless you're a <i>Nazir</i>, correct, to the topic of <i>Yayin

45
00:22:18,000 --> 00:22:47,999
Mevushal</i>. Okay. Says the <i>Gemara</i> in <i>Avodah Zarah</i>: אמר רב אילעאי שנינו יין מבושל של עובדי כוכבים. Wine that was cooked, non-Jewish wine that was cooked, <i>shemetchilato yayin assur</i>. So the <i>Gemara</i> says that a non-Jew cooks his wine, it's <i>assur</i>. Why? <i>Peshita</i>! What do you mean <i>assur</i>? משום דאיפשר פקע ליה איסורא? I put it in the oven and now all of a sudden the magic potion the <i>issur</i> went away? So the <i>Gemara</i> says the following: אמר רב אשי הא אתא לאשמועינן. No, no, no, I'm not saying that. יין מבושל שלנו

46
00:22:48,000 --> 00:23:17,999
ביד עובדי כוכבים. If we had wine that we owned in the hands of the non-Jews, אין צריך חותם בתוך חותם, what you would not need a special kind of a seal. משום דאינסוכי לא מנסכי. If it's because of <i>nisuch</i> I'm worried about, well guess what? The <i>Goyim</i> when they see <i>bishul</i> wine they're like, uh-uh, stay away. ואי משום איחלופי

47
00:23:18,000 --> 00:23:47,999
איכא חותם אחד לא טרח ומזייף. Now <i>Rashi</i>, if you look on the left side, <i>Rashi</i> explains: טעמא דעובדי כוכבים בשלו הבישול ישראלי בהיתר שלו לא מיתסר בהנאה וקמשמע לן דלא מנסכי עובדי כוכבים יין מבושל. They will not perform their <i>avodah zarah</i> and their <i>nisuch</i> with cooked wine. The <i>Gemara</i>

48
00:23:48,000 --> 00:24:18,999
even now tells us a story. <i>Shmuel</i> and <i>Ablat</i>, <i>Shmuel</i> and this guy <i>Ablat</i>, he was a <i>Goy</i>, שמואל ואבלט הוו יתבי אייתו לקמייהו חמרא מבשלא. So they brought him cooked wine. <i>Mashcheh lidei</i>. So as a very nice non-Jew he moves his hand back. I don't want to mess this up for you, <i>Shmuel</i>. אמר ליה שמואל הרי אמרו יין מבושל אין בו משום יין נסך. Don't worry about it, join together. Don't worry about it, touch it all you want. You can hold it, you can hug it,

49
00:24:19,000 --> 00:24:48,999
it doesn't matter. It's cooked wine. If it's cooked wine it's not going to be a problem. Okay. Now, why is this okay? Now this is going to be the major, major <i>kula</i> for us. I'm not a wine person. I have been told that if you're really a wine person, the non-<i>mevushal</i> wine tastes a lot better. To me the Moscato tastes the same whether it was cooked or not. I haven't yet tried non-<i>mevushal</i> Moscato but if it's

50
00:24:49,000 --> 00:25:18,999
out there let me know. But we know that if you have non-<i>mevushal</i> wine and a <i>Goy</i> touches it there's a problem. So it solves for different <i>kashrus</i> organizations, if you want to bring in non-<i>mevushal</i>... You need a <i>mashgiach</i> just for the wine cart, okay, just for the wine cart. So the <i>Rosh</i> explains the following: Why can you benefit from <i>mevushal</i> wine? Because it's not offered for <i>nissech</i>. Okay, but how can I drink it? So says the <i>Rosh</i> asks a question. He says <i>vedavar tamu

51
00:25:19,000 --> 00:25:49,999
kavan</i>. Why is it <i>assur</i>? It's <i>assur</i> because, okay, if I'm not worried about <i>yayin nesech</i>, fine, but what else am I worried about? Intermarriage. Intermarriage! That didn't go away. If I have a boy and my non-Jewish neighbor has a girl and then what? We're not going to drink together, that's cooked wine. Who said that? The <i>Gemara</i> didn't say that. Because they have good taste, they want good wine. ודבר תמוה כיון שגזרו יינם משום בנותיהם וכי משום שהרתיחו לא שייך הך גזירה?

52
00:25:50,000 --> 00:26:19,999
Because it's cooked, they're going to stop hanging out together? I understand that it's not something of <i>nissech</i>. So he says ואפשר לפי שמבושל אינו מצוי כל כך. Maybe just because finding cooked wine is so uncommon. ומלתא דלא שכיחא לא גזרו בה. The <i>Rosh</i> is almost backed into a corner. According to the <i>Rosh</i>, I don't understand. We have two reasons for this, one is <i>yayin nesech</i> and one is because <i>benoseihen</i>. <i>Yayin nesech</i>, fine. What about drinking? We shouldn't allow it.

53
00:26:20,000 --> 00:26:49,999
Says you're right, but it's so uncommon ומלתא דלא שכיחא לא גזרו בה רבנן, right? We don't make decrees out of these kind of things. Okay, fine. What's so uncommon? <i>Yayin mevushal</i>, <i>yayin mevushal</i>. But now it's common! Hold on a second, that was the <i>Rosh</i> in the 1100s, okay? They didn't have what we have today. So that's the <i>Rosh</i>. Let's keep going. We're going to get to you in a second when we get to <i>Rav Shlomo Zalman</i>. Now, there's a number of other answers as well. For example, the <i>Ritva</i>. The

54
00:26:50,000 --> 00:27:19,999
<i>Ritva</i> in source 29, the <i>Ritva</i> was living a little bit later than the <i>Rosh</i>, and the <i>Ritva</i> explains a little bit similarly that <i>mevushal</i> wine was never included in this <i>gezeirah</i> because it's only drunk occasionally. דהכא לענין איסור יינם של נכרים לא גזרו עליו מפני שאין שותים ממנו על דרך תענוג ודבר מועט ולפרקים. It didn't happen as much, we were not drinking cooked wine all the time. ואינו מצוי אלא אצל המעט לפיכך לא היה בכלל גזירה ועמד בטהרתו. The only reason cooked

55
00:27:20,000 --> 00:27:49,999
wine got a go-around, an end-around was because it didn't happen a lot. But really the <i>Rosh</i> is correct and the <i>Ritva</i> is correct that it should be a problem. Okay, that's another answer. Now, the question would be that today you're going to argue, so Shai's not here but he asked a question last week similarly. So what would the answer be when you say but today it's more common? What would the simple answer be? They don't change it. The <i>gezeirah</i> was made

56
00:27:50,000 --> 00:28:20,999
where the <i>gezeirah</i> was made. You can't just change things because you want to change things. The <i>Rav Shlomo Zalman</i> quotes, not in this <i>Rav Shlomo Zalman</i>, in a number of examples where we see we don't include even if things change, we don't add things to a <i>gezeirah</i> if that was not the original decree of that <i>gezeirah</i>. Okay? One of the examples <i>Shlomo Zalman</i> brings is what we did in this in this <i>simchas chaveirim</i> a <i>kesem</i>, right? When it comes to <i>taharas hamishpacha</i>, a woman sees a <i>kesem</i>, it's the size of a bedbug.

57
00:28:21,000 --> 00:28:51,999
So what was the reason? Because there were so many bedbugs and there was an assumption that maybe it was a bedbug. There aren't bedbugs today and yet nonetheless we use that size to determine a <i>kesem</i>. That's what the <i>gezeirah</i> was. Okay. So those are answers <i>Rosh</i>, <i>Ritva</i>. It's really it was never part of the <i>gezeirah</i>. Ah, it should be? You're right, but we don't add things to <i>gezeiros</i> because that's when the initial decree was. Then you get the next group of answers. Then you have the <i>Ramban</i>. The <i>Ramban</i> in source 30 says,

58
00:28:52,000 --> 00:29:21,999
hold on a second, <i>mevushal</i> wine can be drunk because it's not wine. The whole <i>gezeirah</i> here is wine. ויין מבושל וכיוצא בו לפי שאינו בכלל יין סתם התירו בהם. It's very simple. When the <i>Gemara</i> says <i>mevushal</i> wine is not offered as <i>nissech</i>, they won't do libations for it, that's because it's not wine. It's a great read of the <i>Ramban</i> in the <i>Gemara</i>. Not because well it's wine but it's not the best kind of wine. You have to ask yourself why is it that the <i>goy</i>

59
00:29:22,000 --> 00:29:51,999
says no no no, we're very <i>machmir</i> in our religion that we don't use <i>mevushal</i> wine. He's saying because that's not wine, I'm not going to use that, not because it's a higher status. It's not wine and we always want to use wine. We have this concept a little bit when it comes to the whole <i>shaila</i> of using grape juice on <i>Shabbos</i>, right? Because grape juice cannot be offered on a <i>mizbe'ach</i>, so besides <i>Pesach</i> and the <i>dalet kosos</i> which is its own set of <i>shailas</i> if you can use grape juice or not, there we're probably a little bit more <i>machmir</i>. But can you use grape juice on <i>Shabbos</i>? So there are there are <i>poskim</i> that say you can't use grape juice on <i>Shabbos</i>.

60
00:29:52,000 --> 00:30:21,999
Grape juice can't be used for <i>kiddush</i>. It is a non-alcoholic beverage. Therefore it's not offered on the <i>mizbe'ach</i>, it should be something that has certain status. No no no so according to the <i>Ramban</i>, according to the <i>Ramban</i>, he we'd have to look at the <i>shaila</i> like the <i>sugya</i> there. <i>Kiddush</i> is a little bit different because there's

61
00:30:22,000 --> 00:30:54,999
about <i>Mizbeach</i>. But potentially I'd have to see what the <i>Ramban</i> says. But yeah potentially you'd have the same argument. Have the same argument, it's not wine, it's not wine. I just want to say a theory that I have. Yeah it's really quite simple. When we heat wine now, none of the alcohol comes out because it sits in a sealed situation. In the old days it was a pot, you boiled it, the first thing that came up was the alcohol. Okay good. So hold on a second. So we're going to talk about that in a second when we get to how hot and what happens when it changes. Okay good. So there is a third answer by <i>Rabbi Akiva Eiger</i>

62
00:30:55,000 --> 00:31:24,999
but because I don't have I'm going to wait with this <i>Rabbi Akiva Eiger</i> only because I want to do it see if I can do it a little bit inside. So go to the <i>Shulchan Aruch</i>. Let's go to <i>Siv Gimmel</i>. So go to the <i>Shulchan Aruch</i> <i>Siv Gimmel</i>. <i>Shulchan Aruch</i> says: <i>Yayin mevushal shelanu</i> שנגע בו אק\"ום <i>mutar</i>, it's <i>mutar</i>. וממתי נקרא מבושל משישתיה על גבי האש, when it starts to boil. We'll see, we'll see in a little bit. The <i>Shach</i> here, if you there's a <i>Shach</i>

63
00:31:25,000 --> 00:31:54,999
in <i>Siv Katan Vav</i>, I'm just going to pull it up. Hold on. The <i>Shach</i> in <i>Siv Katan</i> whoops there we go. אפילו בשתיה ואפילו לכתחילה מותר לשתות עם אק\"ום כן המוסכם בפוסקים. So the <i>Shach</i> says that it's <i>l'chatchila</i>, it's permitted for everything. So if a non-Jew takes if a <i>Goy</i> if a non-Jew takes you out to a you know a kosher restaurant, buys a <i>mevushal</i> wine, pours it for

64
00:31:55,000 --> 00:32:25,999
you, everybody's happy, everybody's happy. Okay how hot does the wine have to be? How what what is considered <i>bishul</i>? So the <i>Rosh</i> in source 28 says boiled. Well what does <i>resiyach</i> mean? So like any good Jew, what what would you turn to, what area of <i>halacha</i> would you turn to to know what's considered boiled? <i>Shabbos</i>. What in what in terms of <i>Shabbos</i>? <i>Yad soledes bo</i>, whatever <i>yad soledes bo</i> is. So the <i>Beis Yosef</i> in source 31. I thought you said boiled.

65
00:32:26,000 --> 00:32:55,999
He said boiled. Okay hold on a second, hold on. So the <i>Beis Yosef</i> in a source 31 says no, that really it's about when things begin to evaporate. <i>V'haRan katav</i> <i>v'haRan</i> and quotes the <i>Ra'avad</i>. והרמב\"ן כתב שבחסר על גבי האור, when it begins to like evaporate, <i>midaso na'aseh mevushal</i>, that's when it's considered you know real real cooking. Not just when it begins to boil a little bit, a little bit different than the <i>Rosh</i>. There has

66
00:32:56,000 --> 00:33:25,999
to be some kind of evaporating. Wine that is defined as <i>yayin mevushal</i>, it's really really began to evaporate. The <i>Rashba</i> doesn't seem to say that. The <i>Rashba</i> others might say that it gets very very hot. And that's what the <i>Shulchan Aruch</i> said we just saw that once it is heated. And the <i>Shach</i> if you go to that same place, the <i>Shach</i> in <i>Siv Katan Zayin</i> right after <i>Vav</i>, a short <i>Shach</i>, he says היינו שיתמעט ממדתו על ידי רתיחה, quoting the <i>Rashba</i> and the <i>Ran</i>, that

67
00:33:26,000 --> 00:33:55,999
wine must evaporate a little bit. There's a big <i>nafka mina</i> for example if you're on a high mountain. Yeah. You will boil before you get to a hot temperature because it's related to the air pressure. There's a formula PV equals nRT right. So you say it will boil but it won't evaporate. It will boil off at a low temperature, you can touch it with your finger. But it won't be too hot. That's right. But status-wise it has to because the air pressure is low so you lose the alcohol. One second. Close up shop. One second. One second. It'll bubble. It'll look

68
00:33:56,000 --> 00:34:25,999
like it's bubbling. But is it does it have the same status as like if they say boil your water because it's dangerous and you're in the the top of mountains, that's not it's not going to work. It's not going to work. Okay fine fine fine fine fine. So I don't think he means that right? I don't think he means that. Because it's got to be it's got to be. But it's bubbling and the alcohol will go off. Right. But he's saying it's evaporating because of the boiling. It's evaporating at a lower temperature because of the boiling. Right. At what temperature it evaporates has to be

69
00:34:26,000 --> 00:34:55,999
hot. Okay. Okay. Let me just. Back to captures. PTSD. Okay if you go to the <i>Minchas Shlomo</i>. If you see Rav <i>Shlomo Zalman</i> in source 32, Rav <i>Shlomo Zalman</i> says the following based on a <i>Gra</i>. He says <i>Bi'ur HaGra</i> that on <i>Shabbos</i> <i>afshira u'bishulo</i> אבל כשרתיחה לדברי הכל הוא מבושל. If something boils it's considered cooking. He quotes the <i>Rashba</i> and the <i>Rosh</i> and the <i>poskim</i>. משמע קצת מזה דסגי בשיעור שיד סולדת בו

70
00:34:56,000 --> 00:35:26,999
דחשוב לכולי עלמא. גם מבושל גמור לענין שבת. <i>Yad soledes bo</i>. <i>Mimeila gam mashma</i> דבשיעור זה שהיד סולדת בו הרי זה גם חשוב כנתחממו ידיו that it might also be when it evaporated, but it has to be <i>yad soledes bo</i>. Rav Moshe Feinstein in source 33 similarly says that once it reaches <i>yad soledes bo</i>, which is what Rav Shlomo Zalman says, גם למה שאמרו בשלו אין בו משום יין נסך

71
00:35:27,000 --> 00:35:56,999
נמי ודאי מידה זו יד סולדת. But Rav Abandjan in source 34 says no, it really has to boil to the point that its reduction <i>mismai mimidaso</i> is noticeable, that it's evaporating because that shows you that it's causing a change in its flavor. So I would imagine that Rav Abandjan might say that if you're in the mountains, flavor's going to change. Right? Right. Okay, <i>l'maise</i>, what's the actual temperature of <i>yad soledes bo</i>? So you have a whole <i>machlokes</i>, we know we discussed this in the past. If you look at source

72
00:35:57,000 --> 00:36:26,999
35 in the <i>Shulchan Halevi</i>, Rav Belsky. So we have a number of <i>poskim</i> when it comes to <i>yad soledes bo</i>. You have anywhere from low 100 degrees to 104, 112, that's Rav Shlomo Zalman, that's probably Rav Moshe Feinstein. You have 115 to like 120, that's like Rav Aaron Kotler was a little bit more. Then you have even those that go a little bit higher. Here Rav Belsky says

73
00:36:27,000 --> 00:36:57,999
the following. He writes מה שיחמם יין או מיץ ענבים שיחשב כמבושל להצילו ממגע נכרי. Right, you're not a <i>kashrus</i> organization. You have some wine, you want to know how hot do I have to boil it so I don't have to worry about my maid's going to touch it and going to mess it up for us? Right? So he writes כבר נהגו בצירוף שאין צריך לבשל יין ומיץ ענבים פחות ממאה שבעים, really ideally 175. Rav Belsky explained that really it should be 175, it's one of

74
00:36:58,000 --> 00:37:27,999
the highest opinions in terms of <i>yad soledes bo</i>. We'll probably wrap it up here, but the next few sources, it's not that many, is about pasteurizing because pasteurizing obviously for those that don't know the process, which I understand not all of us are so knowledgeable on these things, is done differently. And it's short and the question is does it have enough heat to be considered? But you'll find that this, we'll see next time next week,

75
00:37:28,000 --> 00:37:58,000
there's a lot of <i>kashrus</i> organizations that might rely on this, but it is a <i>kula</i>. So sometimes like the Chief Rabbinate is going to rely on this for certain things and that's one of the things where people are like oh what's so bad sometimes relying on the Chief Rabbinate for <i>kashrus</i>? There are certain <i>kulas</i> that they rely on that in America you wouldn't rely on this <i>kula</i>, but in <i>Eretz Yisroel</i> you want everybody to keep a certain level of <i>kashrus</i> you have to rely on it. But we'll talk about that next week.
