1
00:00:00,000 --> 00:00:29,999
This, the <i>kula</i> in <i>yayin nesech</i> is going to come out. But let's just pick it up from the <i>Gemara</i> in <i>Chullin</i>. We were discussing, we'll do this outside quickly, we were discussing <i>lav yayin nesech</i>. So who is it exactly that can <i>pasul</i> your wine? So the <i>Gemara</i> in <i>Chullin</i> in source number four talked about the <i>pesukim</i> by <i>korbanos</i> and mentions that there are different exceptions of people whose, well we said there are people whose <i>kavanah</i> we accept. It talked about a <i>mumar</i> and

2
00:00:30,000 --> 00:00:59,999
eventually the <i>Gemara</i> talked about even those that are <i>poshei Yisrael</i> that do that sin. We're not so such a fan of sin generally, but you could be <i>chozer b'teshuvah</i>, חוץ מן המומר ומנסך היין ומחלל שבת בפרהסיא. But a person who is <i>menasech hayayin</i>, if he really uses his wine for libations, that would be somebody who we would not accept that <i>korban</i> from. We saw the <i>Shulchan Aruch</i> in <i>Kuf Chaf Dalet</i>, <i>Kuf Chaf</i> I'm in the source sorry, in קוף כף דלת

3
00:01:00,000 --> 00:01:30,999
חת that this includes also somebody who is <i>moshech b'orlaso</i>, somebody who conceals his <i>bris milah</i>, that it's basically he's not an <i>eved Hashem</i>, he's not a <i>maamin</i> and therefore he has the status of a non-Jew. So the <i>Shulchan Aruch</i> says מושך בערלתו אינו עושה יין נסך. That person is not ומומר אע\"פ שמל. But a <i>mumar</i> even though he's <i>mal</i> עושה יין נסך במגעו. With touching it. We'll talk tonight about how much you have to touch it, do you have to shake it,

4
00:01:31,000 --> 00:02:00,999
do you have to move it, okay, all these different things. ונאמן לומר ששב בתשובה. Okay, that he repented. So we mentioned the last time, we ended with this and we'll go now to the <i>Shulchan Aruch</i> in source number six. But the <i>Shach</i> in the <i>Nekudos Hakesef</i> as followed up in the <i>Shulchan Aruch</i> quotes from the <i>Rashba</i>. So there is a <i>teshuva</i> of the <i>Rashba</i> at top that we saw, this is a different one, that is a <i>teshuva</i> that a person who is <i>mechallel Shabbos</i> we consider a non-believer. <i>Shabbos</i> is all about our <i>emunah</i>.

5
00:02:01,000 --> 00:02:30,999
If it's all about our <i>emunah</i>, then if you violate <i>Shabbos b'farhesia</i>, like you just don't care, okay, I'm going to drive, I'm going to do all these things because I believe it's not important. That is, that person is considered an <i>oved avodah zarah</i>. So somebody who publicly transgresses <i>Shabbos</i>, that is an issue. The <i>Shulchan Aruch</i> in source number six tells us: 'Right, so if a guy's <i>mechallel Shabbos</i> I mean really <i>mechallel Shabbos</i> he says 'I'm going to drive on <i>Shabbos</i> and I don't care' and he comes to your house on

6
00:02:31,000 --> 00:03:03,999
<i>Shabbos</i> and he goes through all of your non-<i>mevushal</i> wine and he's just having a field day. He says 'where is it?' and he touches them all and he shakes them all and he drinks some of it and he pours it all he just tripped up all your wine. In a non-EV? What? In a non-electric vehicle. Right, correct, correct, correct. That's a little bit better. ישראל מומר לעבודת אלילים. A <i>mumar</i> says the <i>Shulchan Aruch</i>. או מחלל שבת בפרהסיא. Or somebody who is <i>mechallel Shabbos b'farhesia</i>. אפילו אינו מחלל אלא באיסור דרבנן. Even it's just an <i>issur d'Rabbanan</i>. הרי הוא כעובד אלילים. Right,

7
00:03:04,000 --> 00:03:34,999
that is somebody who is like an <i>avodah zarah</i>. <i>u'vetzina</i> it's a little bit different, even if it's a <i>d'Oraisa</i> you're still <i>m'klal Yisrael</i>. We therefore, says the <i>Shach</i> in the <i>Nekudos Hakesef</i>, that somebody who publicly violates <i>Shabbos</i>, that person is considered an <i>oved avodah zarah</i> and they would <i>pasul</i> your wine. They would <i>pasul</i> your wine. So the question we have to ask today, while we saw this a little bit last week, let's look at the <i>Teshuvos Vehanhagos</i> for a second before we get to what we left off with

8
00:03:35,000 --> 00:04:04,999
in the <i>Binyan Tzion</i>. But the <i>Teshuvos Vehanhagos</i> says a <i>mechallel Shabbos b'farhesia</i> is worse than an actual non-Jew. Right? It's worse. That <i>Chazal</i> really were nervous about somebody who violates publicly <i>avodah</i>, you know, <i>Shabbos</i>, and that is really considered an <i>oved avodah zarah</i>. That's the <i>Teshuvos Vehanhagos</i>. He says <i>chamur m'akum stam</i>. It's worse. קבעו חז\"ל שמחלל שבת דינו כעובד עבודה זרה. ואפילו דאע\"ג שבינינו האידנא אינם עובדי עבודה זרה. Ay, today's <i>goyim</i> are not really <i>ovdei avodah zarah</i>. מכל מקום

9
00:04:05,000 --> 00:04:34,999
לעניין מחלל שבת בפרהסיא. קבעו חז\"ל שדינם כעובד עבודה זרה ממש שחמור יותר. Says the <i>Teshuvos Vehanhagos</i> of Rav Sternbuch <i>shlita</i>, it's <i>mamash</i> the worst of the worst. Okay. The question is what about today? How do we view all the people today in our circles that might not be <i>mechallel Shabbos b'farhesia</i> like the <i>Gemara</i> says? When the <i>Gemara</i> says <i>mechallel Shabbos b'farhesia</i>, it's a guy who knows what he's doing, who learned in school,

10
00:04:35,000 --> 00:05:04,999
he knows the <i>halachos</i> and he goes ahead and he says 'look at everybody, I'm going to eat this salad without <i>borer</i> because I don't really care.' Okay, that would be, I mean that's a real going out with fire and brimstone, you're going to go out one way, do it through <i>borer</i>. Okay. So here comes the <i>Binyan Tzion</i>, very, very important <i>teshuva</i> of the <i>Binyan Tzion</i>. The <i>Binyan Tzion</i> is known also as the <i>Rav Yaakov Ettlinger</i>, also known as the <i>Aruch Laner</i>. So says the... as the Binyan Tziyon or sometimes the people say that the Aruch LaNer is known as the Binyan Tziyon. So says the Aruch LaNer. <i>Tshuvah</i> was written over

11
00:05:05,000 --> 00:05:34,999
150 years ago. So he's discussing the status of Jews who on the one hand they're going to go to <i>shul</i>, they're going to go to <i>shul</i> for whatever they want to go to <i>shul</i> for, they might say <i>kaddish</i>, they're whatever, they want to go hear <i>kiddush</i> and then they're going to go violate <i>Shabbos</i>. We have people like this even today. If you go to certain parts of the Syrian community for example, you have people who are fire and brimstone about <i>davening</i> on <i>Shabbos</i> and will <i>daven</i> more than people in our circles and they'll daven harder and then they will go do whatever they want. And they... so where

12
00:05:35,000 --> 00:06:05,999
are we gonna tell them? This is <i>mechalel Shabbos be'farhesya</i>? They're coming to <i>shul</i>. So says the Binyan Tziyon: פושעי ישראל שבזמננו we in the notes they call traditional Jews. It's a little bit tricky if you want to use that title and I don't want to get into history of traditional <i>shuls</i> in Chicago because that will lead us down a rabbit hole that we will not come out of. פושעי ישראל שבזמננו לא ידענו מה אדון בהם says the Aruch LaNer. I don't know how to view them. אחר שבעוונותינו פשטה הבהרת

13
00:06:06,000 --> 00:06:36,999
לרוב שרובם חילול שבת נעשה להם כהיתר ויש בהם שמתפללים תפילת שבת. They come to <i>shul</i>, they <i>daven</i>, <i>mekadeshim kiddush hayom</i>, ואחר כך מחללים שבת במלאכות דאורייתא ודרבנן. So what am I gonna do? They come to <i>shul</i>, they say <i>nishmas</i>, they say <i>shochen ad</i>, they hear <i>krias hatorah</i> and then they drive to work. So what are you

14
00:06:37,000 --> 00:07:08,999
gonna... what are you gonna view them? So says the Binyan Tziyon, I don't know. I don't know what to say. So that's not <i>tinok shenishba</i>. Oh, hold on, hold on. So the Binyan Tziyon's pointing out this is definitely not <i>tinok shenishba</i>. <i>Tinok shenishba</i> which the Aruch LaNer will talk about also, <i>tinok shenishba</i> is <i>mamesh k'das mamesh</i> who doesn't know anything. He grew up, he didn't know he was Jewish. There's 15 million Jews today. The number is probably way way way more. You know in one year on <i>Tisha B'Av</i> I presented there's a story, there's a book called The Case of Edgardo Mortara,

15
00:07:09,000 --> 00:07:38,999
whatever it is. Story in the 1800s about a <i>mamesh</i> Jew who was taken by a... well whole story, <i>mamesh</i> was a Jewish boy taken into a monastery and never returned back. For every story you hear of this <i>Tisha B'Av</i>, Rav Leizer Silver and they went and they said <i>Shema</i> and they wrote the Shwekey song about it and it's beautiful, for every Jew that heard <i>Shema</i> and came out there are countless Jews that were taken into the monasteries and didn't give them back. So you have Jews today, the number

16
00:07:39,000 --> 00:08:10,999
could be 25 million for all we know. Right? You're talking about... you're talking about tens of thousands of Jews who at this point I spoke in the class made a few weeks ago about Nicholas Winton who saved 669 people, that number became over 6,000 descendants. So that's not the Binyan Tziyon. Binyan Tziyon's talking about a guy, he goes to <i>shul</i>, he just violates <i>Shabbos</i> afterwards. I know this is a side topic, but when the whole craziness of <i>half-Shabbos</i> came about, you remember this... the drama of <i>half-Shabbos</i>? So one

17
00:08:11,000 --> 00:08:40,999
of my <i>rabbeim</i>, one of my mentors in Teaneck, Rabbi Baum, so he got up... first of all, <i>half-Shabbos</i> was a term coined by adults, not by the kids. That the adults were like look at these guys they're only keeping <i>half-Shabbos</i> because they're on their phones, which a lot of it had to do with a certain sense of technology and FOMO and all these different things fine. So he got up in <i>shul</i> on <i>Shabbos</i> and he said for every single person here who doesn't know all the <i>39 melachos de'oraisa</i>, you're also a <i>half-Shabbos</i> Jew. Okay? We're probably mostly <i>half-Shabbos</i> Jews at this point. We don't know all these <i>halachos</i>. So a guy does, he goes

18
00:08:41,000 --> 00:09:10,999
to <i>shul</i> then he violates <i>Shabbos</i>. So says the Binyan Tziyon the following <i>psak</i>: וכן נראה לעניות דעתי המזמינים נגיעת יין של פושעים אלו <i>tavo alav beracha</i>. He says really I could make an argument that it's really really fine. You want to be <i>machmir</i> about it, you could be because they're violating <i>Shabbos</i>. אכן יש כאן להמקילין יש להם מה שיסמכו אם לא נתברר לנו שידעו דיני שבת ומעיז פניו וחילל בפני עשרה מישראל. You

19
00:09:11,000 --> 00:09:40,999
could be <i>mekil</i> because you have what to rely on here. People that are showing you they want to be... they're going to <i>shul</i>, they hear the <i>drasha</i> and then they leave and they violate <i>Shabbos</i>. So the Binyan Tziyon says I don't know that all the people today that we would assume are traditional Jews, they come to <i>shul</i> and then they violate <i>Shabbos</i>, I don't know that they touched your wine that would be considered <i>mechallel Shabbos be'farhesya</i>. The Rav Ovadia in <i>Teshuvah</i> number nine quotes this Binyan Tziyon and he says that he accepts the Binyan Tziyon. לשיטת הפוסקים סבירא להו דמומר הוי כגוי אינו אלא מדרבנן וגזירת סתם יינם דרבנן הוה ליה

20
00:09:41,000 --> 00:10:11,999
תרי דרבנן. We have two <i>derabanans</i> here. One <i>derabanan</i> is that a <i>mumar</i> is like a <i>goi</i>. The other <i>derabanan</i> is <i>stam yeinam</i>. מדי דפלוגתא אזלינן לקולא. So I not only do I accept the Binyan Tziyon but it's <i>trei derabanans</i> and therefore he's willing to be <i>meikel</i>. Okay. That is one group of Jews. So if you have a guy who comes comes to *shul* and they violate *Shabbat* and he touched your *stam yeinam*, we would probably be *meikel* on it. What you should be *machmir*, we'd be *meikel* on it. Okay. Next. What about the non-religious

21
00:10:12,000 --> 00:10:41,999
Jews, meaning they are they're not traditional, so they're not coming. They're not angry and they're not spiteful, they just don't do anything. How do we view that? So says the *Mishna Berurah*. How do you get the title *mechallel Shabbat b'farhesya*? Wait, so what if they basically went off the *derech*? Does that consider a *mumar*? That would be considered a *mumar*. Probably. It depends. Meaning you can't paint anything

22
00:10:42,000 --> 00:11:11,999
with a broad brush. Meaning a person who is still respect- if a guy's *mechallel*- if a guy's *mechallel Shabbat* and is outwardly *mechallel Shabbat*, it's one thing. But if he's back at his- he's off the *derech* but he's with his family, he's respectful of them, I think you could be *meikel* on that also. We wouldn't go to a *tinok shenishba*? Probably not, probably not. And if he's not *mechallel Shabbat b'farhesya*, meaning a person who's off the *derech* let's say, which is a not a great term always to use, but a person who's off the *derech* and but they're not like they're not driving down to you on *Shabbat*. They're respectful of the fact

23
00:11:12,000 --> 00:11:41,999
that I might not do this anymore, but people do it. That I think they would probably fall into that category of the *Binyan Tzion*. Rabbi Rees, I'll send it out. Rabbi Rees has a whole article on this topic. You're probably wondering, oh you gave this on *Shavuot* a few years ago. Very good. Yeah. We did. We talked about it. Okay. So how does one get to be the title of *mechallel Shabbat b'farhesya*? So says the *Mishna Berurah*, to get such a status, right, you have to do something, you could violate *Shabbat* in front of ten people. פרהסיא מקרי כשחילל בפני עשרה מישראל או שידע שיתפרסם ביניהם.

24
00:11:42,000 --> 00:12:12,999
If it's *b'tzina* and the *Mishna Berurah* explains אם מתבייש לעשותו בפני אדם גדול, so this is to Allen's point. If a person is embarrassed to do it, I might not do it anymore, but if I saw my *Rebbi*, I'm not doing it in front of my *Rebbi*. Okay? I might go on my phone on *Shabbat*, but I'm not going on my phone in front of my *Rebbi* on *Shabbat*. That's *b'tzina*. That's *b'tzina*. There's a certain element, you know, the *Gemara* says in the in the fourth *perek* of *Berachot*,

25
00:12:13,000 --> 00:12:42,999
Rabbi Yochanan ben Zakkai is dying, so they say to him, *Nu*, like why are you dying? So he tells them his whole beautiful speech. And then they say, you know, why why are you crying? You're Rabbi Yochanan ben Zakkai. So he says, what do you mean? I have two paths in front of me, אחת של גיהנום ואחת של גן עדן, אחת של גיהנום ואחת של גיהנום, ואיני יודע לאיזה מוליכין אותי. Right? So they say, okay fine. So *Nu*, give us one *bracha*. So says Rabbi Yochanan, you should you should when you sin, you should fear God like you fear people. They said, really? That's it? That's your big

26
00:12:43,000 --> 00:13:12,999
*bracha* on your deathbed Rabbi Yochanan ben Zakkai? Says, yeah, because when people sin the first thing they ask is, does anybody see me? They don't care about *Hakadosh Baruch Hu*. So person has element of *busha*, element of *busha*. This year *Shabbat Shuva* we're talking about *busha*. That's going to be the topic. So we're talking about *busha*. So says *Mishna Berurah*, ואם נתבייש לעשותו בפני אדם גדול אף שעושהו בפני הרבים גם לצינעא יחשב. Okay. Now. So that's those kind of Jews. Next kind of Jews. What about the completely completely unaffiliated? *Mamash* no idea,

27
00:13:13,000 --> 00:13:43,999
not involved, no nothing. Says the *Tshuvot VeHanhagot*. נראה דתלי בטעם פסול מחלל שבת כעובד כוכבים. So he says it depends on why. Really says it depends on why *Chazal* gave this reason. Why why *Chazal* said a *mechallel Shabbat b'farhesya* has the status of an *oved kochavim*. אם עשו אותו כעכו\"ם בגדר קנס שידעו חומר איסור. If it says we're *knassing* you, we're fining you, we're penalizing

28
00:13:44,000 --> 00:14:14,999
you. You did something wrong so you should know what the real thing is. כן כשבגדר אונס כמנינו של קיבוץ חנוך לתורה שסביבותם מקולקל אינו ראוי לקונסו מחלל שבת בפרהסיא. If you're telling me we fine people, we're like we're giving them a *knas*, okay, so then that wouldn't apply to people who don't know anything. Why? Why would a *knas* help? It's not going to help anything. It's like when the students are like, we didn't do anything wrong, why are you giving me a consequence? אבל אם טעם הדין שנאסר פיתו ויינו כדי שיתרחק ממנו. But if it's

29
00:14:15,000 --> 00:14:44,999
that we don't want other people to learn from them. Meaning they do it, it's wrong, I get it. You know what Rabbi Elchanan Wasserman- we're way off topic on this *shiur* thing, it's fine- Rabbi Elchanan Wasserman in the *Kovetz Maamarim* writes about- the *Rambam* says that if you don't believe in certain things, you don't believe in certain *ikarei emuna*, you don't get *Olam HaBa*. So Rabbi Elchanan writes in the *Kovetz Maamarim* because a *nebech an apikores* is also an *apikores*. I don't care why you became an *apikores*, it doesn't matter. He calls it a *nebech an apikores*. It doesn't matter

30
00:14:45,000 --> 00:15:14,999
why you believe that *Hakadosh Baruch Hu* isn't- if you believe it, you're not a *maamin*, you don't get *Olam HaBa*. So says says Rav Sternbuch, if the reason that he doesn't keep *Shabbat*, I don't know why he doesn't keep *Shabbat*, we want you to distance yourself from him, you should do- you should do all the <i>kiruv</i> in the world, you should invite him for <i>Shabbos</i>, you should welcome him into your home. But אם כן אפילו אינו אשם יש לאסור, then he says we would <i>aser</i> it completely, right? That's the reason <i>Chazal</i> said it. So if you look on the left side: לפי דרכינו כמחלל שבת בזמן הזה קשה להקל ביינו מטעם

31
00:15:15,000 --> 00:15:45,999
שהם כאנוסים, says it's a little bit hard to give the status. דאדרבה ראוי להחמיר שיותר עלול מטוס להתערב וללמוד מהם. Right, we really maybe should distance ourselves from them so we shouldn't learn from them. נראה דיש לחלק דעניין לדון בחצר דרחוקי כאילו במי שנתבייש מאדם גדול. If somebody potentially would be embarrassed, it might be one thing when the <i>Mishna Berurah</i> says this whole <i>halacha</i> that a person is going to be embarrassed, that maybe only applies he says to <i>Eiruvei Chatzeros</i>. But

32
00:15:46,000 --> 00:16:15,999
in generally if the irreligious Jew would not transgress <i>Shabbos</i> in front of a <i>Rav</i>, then <i>Chazal</i> write this <i>halacha</i> would we include you in <i>Eiruvei Chatzeros</i>. So everybody has a <i>chatzer</i>, we're all part of a <i>chatzer</i>, and if we want to carry into the <i>chatzer</i>, to the <i>movoi</i> into the <i>chatzer</i>, so we all live there together. How can we all carry? Through <i>Eiruvei Chatzeros</i>. You give, I give, we all give it together. What happens if a person in that courtyard is not a religious Jew? He might not be able to be included. So

33
00:16:16,000 --> 00:16:45,999
can you be <i>mafkir</i> his <i>reshuss</i>, could you not be <i>mafkir</i> his <i>reshuss</i>? So if he's embarrassed, \"I don't keep <i>Shabbos</i>, but I wouldn't do it in front of an <i>Adam Gadol</i>.\" All right, so we can include him in those things. But in generally drinking though, says <i>Rav</i> Sternbuch, that's only by <i>Eiruvei Chatzeros</i> the <i>Mishna Berurah</i>'s point is. You're talking about making an <i>eiruv</i>. That's a big deal, you want to be able to carry on <i>Shabbos</i>, you want to carry into the <i>eiruv</i>. Let's be <i>meikel</i> that if he was a little bit embarrassed in front of an <i>Adam Gadol</i>, all right, we'll be <i>meikel</i> that guy we can still

34
00:16:46,000 --> 00:17:15,999
use, we can count him in the <i>eiruv</i>. But I'm not going to be <i>meikel</i> like that to drink with him. That person you should distance yourself from, you shouldn't join together with that person. So says <i>Rav</i> Sternbuch, really it's best to keep away from such people and maybe we would keep this <i>halacha</i> <i>aval le'inyan yeinom</i>, the last four lines. But with their wine, <i>de'shema kiruv</i>. When you give your <i>eiruv</i>, you give your little <i>challah</i> for the <i>Eiruvei Chatzeros</i>, you could sleep all <i>Shabbos</i>, I don't want to hang out with you. Get away from me. The point

35
00:17:16,000 --> 00:17:46,999
of this <i>gezeirah</i> is actually though with wine is different. The whole point here is mingling. So לענין יינם דשמא קירוב אזאי ברשע מחלל שבת בפרהסיא אף אם נתבייש, I don't care if he's embarrassed, מכל מקום כיוון שמחלל בפרהסיא עשו כעכו\"ם להתרחק ממנו. So <i>Rav</i> Sternbuch says very strongly, it's the opinion of others including certain of the <i>Chassidishe poskim</i> that we don't want you learning from bad behavior. So we have to sort of say that this kind of Jew his wine would be a problem.

36
00:17:47,000 --> 00:18:16,999
If he touched your wine it would be a problem. Does that mean that they're focusing on the mingling and not the fact that it was <i>avodah zarah</i>? Correct, because we agree on that, we don't think they're doing it for <i>avodah zarah</i> purposes. Now, if you go however, if you look in source number 12, the <i>Sefer Hakashrus</i> <i>paskens</i> that to what we were saying earlier: <i>tinok shenishbah</i>. Okay. היינו אלו שלא קיבלו כל חינוך מסורתי ואינם מחללי שבת מתוך ידיעה. They have no idea. במזיד וביד רמה להכעיס אינם נחשבים כמחללי שבת בפרהסיא ואין מגעם

37
00:18:17,000 --> 00:18:46,999
ביין אסור. No, he says they would not be the case of <i>tinok shenishbah</i>, they don't know anything. And that's really what are we worried about? They're not doing <i>avodah zarah</i> for sure. They don't know better. We're not going to learn from their issues because they don't know anything. If you look in the footnote he says though this is a problem. How do you know who's a <i>tinok shenishbah</i> today? It's a very hard thing to assess. If you're telling me back in the day, okay,

38
00:18:47,000 --> 00:19:16,999
there was no internet and there was no <i>Chabad</i> and there was no <i>kiruv</i> and there's a guy living out in the middle of Wyoming who <i>mamash</i> never knew that he was a Jew and he came to your house and he touched your wine, okay. You're tell me your coworker is a <i>tinok shenishbah</i>? The guy who grew up in the suburbs, who grew up in Chicago over there? Maybe forget Conservative, forget Reform. He knows, he's surrounded by Jews. You tell me he's a <i>tinok shenishbah</i>? I don't know. It's a hard call. It's a hard

39
00:19:17,000 --> 00:19:47,999
thing. It's a hard thing to assess. Yeah. I thought part of the calculation was whether or not they had proper education in the first place. So even if they understand it's out there, if they were never taught... again, no one's saying you're wrong. But we're not talking about a guy who doesn't know anything. Meaning, a person who might not have gone to a day school, but sees plenty of Conservative Reform <i>shuls</i> around. Has Jewish friends. Knows <i>Rosh Hashanah</i>. Knows <i>Yom Kippur</i>. Is that

40
00:19:48,000 --> 00:20:20,999
a <i>tinok shenishbah</i>? So says the <i>Sefer Hakashrus</i>, look at what it says the footnote. אכן יש לציין שיש סוברים שבזמנינו שיש הסברה דתית קשורה ורצינית יתכן בסתם יהודי נקרא חילוני. You're going to tell me that a <i>Chiloni</i> guy that lives on my parents' block in <i>Modi'in</i> is a <i>tinok shenishba</i>? Come on. Isn't Israel somewhat different in this? Whatever, okay, yes, maybe. But maybe not. Why is it different than a guy living in Highland Park? Because

41
00:20:21,000 --> 00:20:50,999
they're not supposed to... like they see other Jews, but the other Jews aren't keeping <i>Shabbos</i> saying... I'm not arguing. I'm not saying yes or no. It is very hard to have a metric for who's a <i>tinok shenishba</i> or not. That's his point. What about people who go through high school, go through <i>Base Yaakov</i> and have no idea? 100 percent. Yeah. I know many of them. I taught many of those kids. Proudly. Okay. He laughing at I taught your kids. That's why I laugh. Yeah. Okay. <i>Weiter</i>, good. So let's go now to the next topic. And that is,

42
00:20:51,000 --> 00:21:20,999
okay, all this is great. All this is fine, we now know something about something. When this guy who let's say is <i>mechallel Shabbos befarhesya</i>, you know him, he went through the system, he's anti-religious, he hates <i>Shabbos</i>, he drives around with a thing, <i>vehaya machanecha kadosh</i>, about driving... Most people don't hate <i>Shabbos</i>, they go off to... I taught a bunch of students. Right. Right. Who aren't <i>frum</i> anymore. Right. Right. They don't hate <i>Shabbos</i>, they don't hate Jews. Do you remember when... you saying what's the status with those kids?

43
00:21:21,000 --> 00:21:50,999
It's very hard. So if you remember when David Bashevkin came for <i>Shabbos</i> a few years ago. So he made a point that I thought about a lot since because I think it has a lot of <i>emes</i> to it. When... I'm about the same age, David Bashevkin and I. When I was a kid, the friends that I had that went off the <i>derech</i>, you went off fireworks. Meaning like drugs, whatever. Whatever, work at the pizza store, drop out of high school, like, you went out.

44
00:21:51,000 --> 00:22:21,999
Today's, we don't find that as much. You find it, you find it. You find it sometimes in the very, very <i>Yeshivishe</i> world when it's like a lot of pressure. But today what do we find? We find a lot of this. I'm not angry, I'm not upset, I'm just apathetic. I don't really care. And by the way, that kind of guy also might not view himself as not religious. He might do some of these things, but he also might do a lot of... and he's just... he's just very apathetic. It's a good <i>shayla</i>. It's a good <i>shayla</i>. He would not be considered this. He would not be considered like a <i>mechallel Shabbos befarhesya</i>, probably because

45
00:22:22,000 --> 00:22:51,999
first of all there's still a respect... a lot of those. But like they're not... they're not angry. A <i>mumer's</i> angry and he's upset and he's rebellious. That's what it means to be a <i>mumer</i>. And you could be a <i>mumer leteiavon</i> or a <i>mumer</i>... a <i>mumer ledavar echad</i>. Okay. It's why in both <i>tochachos</i>... both <i>tochachos</i> focus what's the fix to apathy? What's the fix to apathy? The fix to apathy is not passion.

46
00:22:52,000 --> 00:23:21,999
That if... so if I'm apathetic towards <i>tfila</i>, but if I <i>shookled</i> more then like it would be better. The fix to apathy is relationship. Both <i>tochachos</i> in the Torah focus on this issue. The <i>tochacha</i> in <i>Bechukosai</i> is all about <i>vehalachti imi keri</i>. You didn't care enough. You just like whenever you wanted God, God was there for you, but you didn't want God, you didn't care. So <i>Hashem</i> says, <i>vehalachti imi keri</i>, I'll act like that with you. That's <i>tochacha</i> in <i>Bechukos</i>. <i>Tochacha</i> in <i>Ki Savo</i> is all about <i>besimcha uvetuv levav</i>. All I asked you was to worship me with like a little bit of

47
00:23:22,000 --> 00:23:51,999
<i>bren</i>, a little bit of excitement because we have this relationship together. So all of the <i>tochachas</i> focus on... is focused on passion. <i>Rav</i> Aharon Lichtenstein has an unbelievable article called... something. But anyway, in the piece on <i>Teshuva</i>, he talks about that I... my <i>Teshuva</i> is on that I don't care enough. I don't care enough. Like my <i>Teshuva</i> is that I need

48
00:23:52,000 --> 00:24:22,999
to fix that relationship, not that I whatever, I could be better at <i>Shabbos</i>, <i>lashon hara</i>, <i>tfila</i>, <i>brachos</i>, learning, whatever. I just don't care enough. And that's where we unfortunately find that a lot today. Okay, I could talk for a long time about this, so I won't. But what we find today among students and among teenagers and among young adults is a certain indifference. Like when you have a kid who will, you know, eat something not <i>kosher</i>, it's not because he's angry, it's not because he's rebellious, he just has a lot of access and a lot of things and

49
00:24:23,000 --> 00:24:53,999
like... but it would not make him a <i>mumer</i>, would not make him a <i>mumer</i>. Okay, anyway. Says the <i>Tur</i>. So what does this guy... what does he have to do to the wine? Does he have to shake it, move it, turn it upside down? What actually <i>passuls</i> this wine? So the <i>Gemara</i> gives different situations and the <i>Tur</i> says the following: לא כל מגע הגוים שוה לאסור. It's not all the same. <i>Yesh assur behana'ah</i>,

50
00:24:54,000 --> 00:25:24,999
sometimes it's going to be <i>assur behana'ah</i>, like, you know, I don't know, he's... we're going to see. A non-Jew touches a wine that in a way that's used for libations for <i>Avodah Zarah</i>, he's going to shake it, he's going to do something, it's going to be <i>assur behana'ah</i>. <i>veyesh</i> is going to be <i>muttar behana'ah</i>, okay, it he's going to touch in a wine that he's going to touch the wine, but it was not in a way done for <i>Avodah Zarah</i>, so it's <i>muttar behana'ah</i> <i>ve'assur bishtiya</i> ויש שמותר אפילו בשתייה. So you're going to have three categories.

51
00:25:25,000 --> 00:25:55,999
Sometimes completely <i>assur</i>, sometimes only <i>assur</i> in to drink but <i>muttar</i> to have benefit and then sometimes completely even <i>muttar</i> to drink. It's talking about <i>Stam Yeinam</i>, <i>Stam Yeinam</i>. Okay, so what's the <i>sugya</i>? So look at the <i>Gemara</i> in <i>Avodah Zarah</i> in source 14. The <i>Gemara</i> here is discussing that if a non-Jew <i>hoshet yado lachavis</i>, he puts his hand. We're going to learn like four criteria, okay? Criterion number one, if you want to write as a header. This is <i>Gemara</i> number one. You have to have intent that

52
00:25:56,000 --> 00:26:26,999
I do want to touch the wine. Okay, it's a good lawyer term, <i>shelo</i> intent to touch, okay? Sounds bad. <i>savar shel shemen</i>. He, the <i>Gemara</i> says he sticks in the barrel but he thinks it's oil. <i>venimtza shel yayin</i> עשו מעשה ואמרו ימכר. So the <i>Gemara</i> says you can't drink it, but what can you do with it? You can sell it. Why says the <i>Rashi</i>? דהואיל דסבר של שמן ליכא למיגזר שנתכוין לנסך. Alright, the guy

53
00:26:27,000 --> 00:26:56,999
thought it was oil. We don't do <i>Avodah Zarah</i> with oil. So clearly he did not intend, he didn't intend to touch and therefore you could be, you can't drink it but you can benefit. Okay, situation number, I'm sorry, yeah, same <i>Gemara</i> for number two. There's another <i>Gemara</i> here that you place your... okay so both <i>Gemara</i> number one and we'll see in a second in source 15 which is <i>madu bekaneh</i> if you're like measuring it out. And what

54
00:26:57,000 --> 00:27:27,999
happens? התיז הרצירא בקנה שהיה מטפיח על פי חבית מרותחת בההוא מעשה ואמרו ימכר. That you were, you're measuring out some, you're measuring out the wine and you unintentionally like touch it, okay? You were with a stick or whatever it was. Again, number one is a <i>davor meru'ach</i>. I have to, I have to want to touch this wine. Number one. Number two I have to know that the liquid that I'm about to touch is wine. Number two. Number three, I am focused on the fact that I'm about to do is to touch said wine.

55
00:27:28,000 --> 00:27:57,999
And finally is the <i>Gemara</i> in source 16. So what happens? Now I know it's wine, I'm intending to touch the wine, my mindset is on the wine. What do I have to do? Says the <i>Gemara</i>. <i>Gemara</i> talks about an <i>esrog</i>. אתרוג דנפל לחביתא דחמרא. So the <i>Gemara</i> says that אתי עובד כוכבים ושקליה.

56
00:27:58,000 --> 00:28:28,999
So what happened? I was in Lakewood this past <i>Shabbos</i> afternoon. I was going to pick up my daughter somewhere and it was in, there's a few like apartments in Lakewood, so I couldn't figure out how to get to the upstairs. So the neighbor, the non-Jewish neighbor, he's like oh and he just rings the doorbell for me. Fine. The daughter comes out and she's like, did you just ring the doorbell? I'm like no no it really wasn't me. So that family's probably not coming to the <i>Yeshiva</i>. So says the <i>Gemara</i> if the guy took it out. So says...

57
00:28:29,000 --> 00:28:58,999
so the <i>Gemara</i> says אמר ליה רב אשי נקטוה לידיה. So <i>Rav Ashi</i> who was standing in your <i>bayis</i> told his students: quickly grab the non-Jewish hands when he takes out, that it shouldn't shake. כי היכי דלא לשכך ביה ובריצועא עד דשיפי. Why? So <i>Rashi</i> explains, so long as non-Jews when they do their libations, it's a lot of shaking. Okay, so when it fell in, intent all these things, but just don't, don't shake. If you don't shake then everything's

58
00:28:59,000 --> 00:29:28,999
going to be okay. Right? This is what <i>Rashi</i> explains on the second line of <i>Rashi</i> ולאסור בהנאה שאין מנסכין אלא על ידי שכשוך. It has to be a real kind of shaking, okay? A real kind of shake, a real kind of shaking and if there's no shaking then potentially it could be okay. Now, let's go to the <i>Shulchan Aruch</i>. Let's go to the <i>Shulchan Aruch</i>. Ah, we're going to see in a second. Okay, go to... we're going to do a few.

59
00:29:29,000 --> 00:29:58,999
Let's start with <i>Yud</i> and <i>Yud Alef</i>. Okay, <i>keitzad</i>... oh sorry, מגע עובד כוכבים קכד י. We're going to mention all four of these criteria. מגע עובד כוכבים לאסור בהנאה צריך שלשה תנאים. You're going to need three conditions. Number one, <i>sheyiskaven liyage'a</i>, you intent to touch it. לאפוקי תינוק שנגע דלאו בר כוונה הוא. Okay, that... there you go as opposed to a baby who does not understand what he's doing. <i>vafukei</i>...

60
00:29:59,000 --> 00:30:29,999
<i>nafal labor ve'ala</i> משאינו שיודע שהוא יין שלישי עוסק בדבר אחד. Number two is that I know that I am what I'm touching, I'm touching wine and I'm not distracted שלא עוסק בדבר אחד. Fine. Keep going. <i>Keitzad ha'negi'ah</i>? What exactly- okay, fine, what does it mean <i>negi'ah</i>? שעובד כוכבים היין בהנאה שיגע בידו או ברגלו that it would be <i>assur</i>, so he says: ויש אומרים אפילו

61
00:30:30,000 --> 00:30:59,999
בפיב ששתה ממנו שמצץ מהנקב and you sucked in a little bit, whatever it was that you did, you touched it enough, even with the stick, you shake it, even with the lips, you cannot benefit, for sure not drink, you cannot <i>assur behana'ah</i>. So long as you did anything like that, you shook it, you tasted it, the <i>goy</i> did anything to it, it would be <i>assur</i> completely. Those are the four: intent, knowledge that it's wine, you are not involved

62
00:31:00,000 --> 00:31:29,999
in anything else and you are absolutely sure that and the wine was shaken. Okay. Now, let's set this up for next time. If you go, skip to <i>yud-ches</i>. Skip to <i>yud-ches</i>. Okay, skip to <i>yud-ches</i>. Here the <i>Shulchan Aruch</i> paskens the following: <i>yud-ches</i>. Okay, before we get to this <i>kula</i> of

63
00:31:30,000 --> 00:31:59,999
the <i>Rema</i>, we gotta set it up. Says the <i>Shulchan Aruch</i> in <i>se'if yud-ches</i>: נטל עובד כוכבים כלי של יין. The guy takes your wine, <i>vehigbi'o</i>, and he lifts it, and he pours the wine, אף על פי שלא שכשך נאסר. He doesn't shake it, all he does is he pours it. <i>Nassar</i>. Why? שהרי יין מכוחו הגביה. Okay, so because at least the <i>Shulchan Aruch</i> says his mere

64
00:32:00,000 --> 00:32:29,999
lifting of the bottle and pouring, it's <i>assur</i> even without shaking because it was moved <i>mi'kocho</i> and therefore it is going to be <i>assur</i>. Okay, now look at the <i>Shach</i> up top in <i>mem-beis</i>. <i>Shach</i> has three <i>rashei teivos</i>: <i>Ayin Lamed-Aleph</i>, <i>reish siman kuf-kaf-hei</i>. Go back earlier to where we said to <i>siman kuf-kaf-hei</i>, well, later, <i>siman kuf-kaf-hei</i>. Okay, so if you go there,

65
00:32:30,000 --> 00:33:00,999
what you will find in <i>siman kuf-kaf-hei</i>, we're going to come back to <i>siman kuf-kaf-hei</i> in a second, but if you look in the beginning of <i>siman kuf-kaf-hei</i>, okay, just look in the beginning for a second, we'll come back to this a little bit later. <i>Natal akum</i>. Okay, if

66
00:33:01,000 --> 00:33:30,999
a <i>goy</i> takes your <i>kli shel yayin</i> and he lifts it and wine comes out, אף על פי שלא שכשך, even though he didn't shake it, <i>nassar bishitiya</i>. Why? <i>Yayin ba mi'kocho</i>. Exactly what we just said. ומה שנשאר בכלי אסור גם כן משום ניצוק. Okay, and then also it's connected, we learned this earlier, so therefore, touching or moving wine, I am not doing any

67
00:33:31,000 --> 00:34:01,999
kind of libations, but if I pick it up and I pour it, it's going to be a problem. Okay, one second, hold on, it says what? If it's closed, because you're not able to pour it, does it still count? We're not there yet, we're not there yet. We'll get there in a second. Okay, fine. Before we go back, go back now to <i>kuf-kaf-dalet</i> and go to <i>kaf-dalet</i>.

68
00:34:02,000 --> 00:34:31,999
Okay, go to <i>kaf-dalet</i>. So again, we have said so far that if I touch or move wine but I don't intend to do any kind of libations, I might be- not can't drink it but I could probably benefit from it. But the <i>Shulchan Aruch</i> says in <i>kaf-dalet</i> the following: a few extra minutes, yeah, no one's coming for <i>ma'ariv</i> at nine. A few extra minutes, nine-oh-five. Nine-oh-five. Yeah, that's fine. מגע עובד כוכבים מיין על ידי דבר אחר. So the <i>Shulchan Aruch</i> here says if

69
00:34:32,000 --> 00:35:01,999
wine was accidentally and indirectly touched by a <i>goy</i>, על ידי דבר אחר שלא בכוונה שיורד מהדקל ובידו לולב like example, he's climbing on the tree, he's holding a <i>lulav</i> branch and what happens? ונגע בראש הלולב ביין שלא בכוונה. It's the <i>lulav</i> that he's holding touches the wine. מהלך ונגע בכנף בגדו שלא בכוונה. All these different situations that are touching but through indirect touch or- or without intention. So the <i>Shulchan Aruch</i> says וקהליך

70
00:35:02,000 --> 00:35:32,999
בדרך אחר או שאינו יודע שהוא יין <i>mutar afilu bishtiya</i>. Okay? You can drink it, I mean, I'm sorry, you can benefit from it. Why? Because it's as if nothing happened. Nothing happened. Okay. Let's just read this and then we'll end. Then we'll have to come back to this <i>Rema</i> next week, but we'll leave on a cliffhanger. In comes the <i>Rema</i>. A big <i>chiddush</i> of the <i>Rema</i>. He says: והוא הדין אם נגע בו על ידי דבר אחר או בשל חבל שהוציאו שלא בכוונה. Fine.

71
00:35:33,000 --> 00:36:03,999
Second line. ובזמן הזה דאומות לאו עובדי כוכבים הם. Once we've established that touching wine <i>shelo be-khavana</i> allows me to still benefit from it, potentially to drink it, says the <i>Rema</i>, since today nobody really worships <i>avodah zarah</i>, כל מגע מקרי שלא בכוונה. In comes the <i>Rema</i> and says, therefore,

72
00:36:04,000 --> 00:36:33,999
what? All their touch, everything would be fine! If any Jew, see, he says, ולכן אם נגע ביין על ידי דבר אחר אף על פי שיודע שהוא יין וכיוון ליגע בו מותר אפילו בשתייה דמיקרי מגע על ידי דבר אחר. He basically says everything gets bumped down a level. And therefore, seemingly what emerges from this <i>Rema</i> is a remarkable <i>chiddush</i>, and the remarkable <i>chiddush</i> is that if

73
00:36:34,000 --> 00:37:03,999
a even a Christian, you know, comes to your house and pours your wine, even though and it was without real intent, says the <i>Rema</i>, you should be able to say this is okay. However, let me just end with one line of the <i>Rema</i>. והוא הדין נגע אפילו בידו בלא כוונת מגע או שלא ידע שהוא יין ואין לפרסם הדבר בפני עם הארץ. This should be our secret. We can't have this get out. This gets out, it's going to be problems.

74
00:37:04,000 --> 00:37:34,000
So that's how the <i>Rema</i> holds. We will talk about what this <i>Rema</i> means and how the <i>Shach</i> understands this <i>Rema</i> next in two weeks. We're not actually next week? I don't think so. I think if I do next
