1
00:00:00,000 --> 00:00:02,560
Yes, for the first time, welcome. There

2
00:00:02,560 --> 00:00:03,780
is a WhatsApp group, there is a

3
00:00:03,780 --> 00:00:05,280
Google Drive that will have all of

4
00:00:05,280 --> 00:00:06,860
the shiurim and all of the folders

5
00:00:06,860 --> 00:00:08,980
and all of the notes and everything

6
00:00:09,199 --> 00:00:11,000
including chazarah notes later in this zman.

7
00:00:12,359 --> 00:00:15,300
I apologize in advance for any jokes

8
00:00:15,300 --> 00:00:19,320
that I say, any food that I

9
00:00:19,320 --> 00:00:22,980
make fun of. Okay. So as I

10
00:00:22,980 --> 00:00:24,879
mentioned this zman, we just finished zman

11
00:00:24,879 --> 00:00:27,760
of basar b'chalav. So we're really just

12
00:00:27,760 --> 00:00:30,199
continuing, which I think actually is good.

13
00:00:30,679 --> 00:00:32,380
While the information is fresh and the

14
00:00:32,380 --> 00:00:33,840
terms and the ideas and the lomdus

15
00:00:33,840 --> 00:00:35,219
that we learned in the last zman

16
00:00:35,219 --> 00:00:37,119
about basar b'chalav and ta'aroves and things

17
00:00:37,119 --> 00:00:39,560
like that, chaticha na'ases neveila and things

18
00:00:39,560 --> 00:00:41,100
like that, that is very very much

19
00:00:41,100 --> 00:00:42,259
relevant for what we are going to

20
00:00:42,259 --> 00:00:44,840
be doing this zman. So this zman

21
00:00:44,840 --> 00:00:46,886
will take us through if you see

22
00:00:46,886 --> 00:00:48,700
the, if you see in the booklet,

23
00:00:48,700 --> 00:00:50,899
so you have siman tzadi hey which

24
00:00:50,899 --> 00:00:51,759
we're going to do over the next

25
00:00:51,759 --> 00:00:53,640
a number of weeks. Siman tzadi hey

26
00:00:53,640 --> 00:00:55,979
is mostly focused on issues of nat

27
00:00:55,979 --> 00:00:57,716
bar nat, which we'll talk about tonight,

28
00:00:57,716 --> 00:01:01,359
נותן טעם בר נותן טעם. That's so

29
00:01:01,359 --> 00:01:02,679
you can keep the regular. And then

30
00:01:02,679 --> 00:01:03,996
you'll have to get a new Shulchan

31
00:01:03,996 --> 00:01:05,739
Aruch for kuf kaf gimmel which we're

32
00:01:05,739 --> 00:01:08,980
going to talk eventually about yayin nesech

33
00:01:08,980 --> 00:01:12,000
and stam yeinam, yayin mevushal, you know

34
00:01:12,079 --> 00:01:13,640
basically things that if you drink other

35
00:01:13,640 --> 00:01:16,480
wines than just Moscato will affect you.

36
00:01:16,480 --> 00:01:18,060
So in my house we'll be alright,

37
00:01:18,459 --> 00:01:19,920
but maybe your house you'll have to

38
00:01:19,920 --> 00:01:22,480
figure this out. So let's go if

39
00:01:22,480 --> 00:01:24,219
you take the, open up the Shulchan

40
00:01:24,219 --> 00:01:27,340
Aruch to siman tzadi hey and the

41
00:01:27,340 --> 00:01:30,799
booklet to page number one. Let's review

42
00:01:30,799 --> 00:01:33,060
something very quickly. We mentioned that the

43
00:01:33,060 --> 00:01:35,480
Torah in three places says that you

44
00:01:35,480 --> 00:01:38,180
cannot cook meat and milk together and

45
00:01:38,180 --> 00:01:39,760
that teaches me three issurim. What are

46
00:01:39,760 --> 00:01:46,336
those three issurim? Hana'ah, achilah, and bishul.

47
00:01:46,336 --> 00:01:49,299
And bishul. That sounds like that sounds

48
00:01:49,299 --> 00:01:52,659
right. There are three things the Halacha

49
00:01:52,659 --> 00:01:54,180
tells us. Now we also learned that

50
00:01:54,180 --> 00:01:56,620
when we create an issur of basar

51
00:01:56,620 --> 00:01:59,019
b'chalav, that is because a ta'am is

52
00:01:59,019 --> 00:02:02,260
created in the pot itself. So again,

53
00:02:02,359 --> 00:02:04,219
I'll make it easy. There is going

54
00:02:04,219 --> 00:02:05,260
to be a lot of terms over

55
00:02:05,260 --> 00:02:07,000
the next few weeks that are very

56
00:02:07,099 --> 00:02:09,956
like parve, dairy, eino ben yomo, so

57
00:02:09,956 --> 00:02:12,680
you just have to like hold kop

58
00:02:12,680 --> 00:02:13,699
as they say for a little bit.

59
00:02:14,419 --> 00:02:16,120
But we mentioned that there's this idea

60
00:02:16,120 --> 00:02:18,539
of nosein ta'am, okay? That means that

61
00:02:18,539 --> 00:02:19,759
if I have a pot and I

62
00:02:19,759 --> 00:02:22,120
make meatballs in that pot, within the

63
00:02:22,120 --> 00:02:24,300
walls of the pot there is nesinas

64
00:02:24,300 --> 00:02:27,599
ta'am, the pot, the meat gave flavor

65
00:02:27,599 --> 00:02:28,759
into the walls of the pot. That

66
00:02:28,759 --> 00:02:29,900
is true for the walls of a

67
00:02:29,900 --> 00:02:31,319
pot, that is true for anything. If

68
00:02:31,319 --> 00:02:32,740
you take a pot of meatballs and

69
00:02:32,740 --> 00:02:34,439
you throw something parve in that pot

70
00:02:34,439 --> 00:02:35,460
of meatballs and then you pull out

71
00:02:35,460 --> 00:02:37,560
that parve thing, okay, you pull out

72
00:02:37,560 --> 00:02:39,219
a potato, even though we did talk

73
00:02:39,219 --> 00:02:40,520
about a Rema that maybe is meikel,

74
00:02:40,680 --> 00:02:42,879
that if you cooked it together, there

75
00:02:42,879 --> 00:02:45,699
is meat flavor in that potato. If

76
00:02:45,699 --> 00:02:47,939
I ate that potato, what am I?

77
00:02:48,479 --> 00:02:51,000
I am fleishig. Now if I take

78
00:02:51,000 --> 00:02:52,639
a ben yomo pot, that means I

79
00:02:52,639 --> 00:02:54,259
cooked this morning meatballs and I cleaned

80
00:02:54,259 --> 00:02:56,780
it out then I cooked something else

81
00:02:56,780 --> 00:02:59,180
in that pot, I cooked something parve

82
00:02:59,180 --> 00:03:00,879
in that pot, could I eat those

83
00:03:00,879 --> 00:03:03,060
noodles? Sure. Of course you could. Thank

84
00:03:03,060 --> 00:03:04,300
you Eddie. Of course you could eat

85
00:03:04,300 --> 00:03:06,099
those noodles, but would those noodles make

86
00:03:06,099 --> 00:03:08,039
you fleishig? No. Could you eat those

87
00:03:08,039 --> 00:03:10,139
noodles with milchig? That's what we're going

88
00:03:10,139 --> 00:03:12,699
to discuss right now. We believe probably

89
00:03:12,699 --> 00:03:14,039
not, but we are going to discuss

90
00:03:14,039 --> 00:03:17,120
very relevant shaylos of what happened, I

91
00:03:17,120 --> 00:03:18,796
just had this shayla in my house

92
00:03:18,796 --> 00:03:21,152
erev pesach, erev the last days, no

93
00:03:21,152 --> 00:03:24,080
sorry, erev Shabbos. One of my boys

94
00:03:24,080 --> 00:03:27,419
was making something and he tasted an

95
00:03:27,419 --> 00:03:29,336
onion that was cut up with a

96
00:03:29,336 --> 00:03:31,659
fleishig knife. And there was a shayla

97
00:03:31,659 --> 00:03:33,479
of now he wants to eat something

98
00:03:33,479 --> 00:03:36,139
milchig. So I told him he'd better

99
00:03:36,139 --> 00:03:39,819
call somebody else. Okay. So the Gemara

100
00:03:39,819 --> 00:03:41,680
in Chullin, the Gemara the first source,

101
00:03:41,780 --> 00:03:42,960
the Gemara in Chullin tells us the

102
00:03:42,960 --> 00:03:45,340
following. The Gemara, we learned this Gemara

103
00:03:45,340 --> 00:03:47,099
last time, but now we didn't spend

104
00:03:47,099 --> 00:03:49,060
as much time on nat bar nat

105
00:03:49,060 --> 00:03:51,479
or נתינת טעם בר נתינת טעם. But

106
00:03:51,479 --> 00:03:53,979
let's go. The following: itmar, דגים שעלו

107
00:03:54,300 --> 00:03:57,080
בקערה. So the Gemara tells us that

108
00:03:57,080 --> 00:04:00,819
if I had fish, okay if I

109
00:04:00,819 --> 00:04:03,400
had fish, let's take one step back.

110
00:04:03,699 --> 00:04:05,360
Just to flush out the rest of

111
00:04:05,360 --> 00:04:08,460
this, there is nesinas ta'am, but after

112
00:04:08,460 --> 00:04:11,000
twenty-four hours we call that nosein ta'am

113
00:04:11,000 --> 00:04:13,479
lifgam. That means that after twenty-four hours,

114
00:04:13,699 --> 00:04:16,360
I'm not as concerned anymore because whatever

115
00:04:16,360 --> 00:04:18,639
flavor is actually there is no longer

116
00:04:18,639 --> 00:04:22,120
a positive flavor but is a negative

117
00:04:22,120 --> 00:04:23,620
flavor. It's going to make the taste

118
00:04:23,620 --> 00:04:26,079
bad. We focus on ta'am. So if

119
00:04:26,079 --> 00:04:28,220
I made meatballs in a fleishig pot

120
00:04:28,220 --> 00:04:31,339
and twenty-eight hours later I made something

121
00:04:31,339 --> 00:04:32,819
in that same pot, I made something

122
00:04:32,819 --> 00:04:35,120
milchig even in that pot, we would

123
00:04:35,120 --> 00:04:36,860
say what's the status of the food?

124
00:04:37,860 --> 00:04:39,779
You could eat it. It's nesinas ta'am,

125
00:04:39,839 --> 00:04:41,379
it's nosein. Now if you didn't clean

126
00:04:41,379 --> 00:04:43,579
it, it's gross. That would be an

127
00:04:43,579 --> 00:04:45,680
issue. But nosein ta'am lifgam means after

128
00:04:45,680 --> 00:04:48,259
twenty-four hours, that's when we're definitely more

129
00:04:48,259 --> 00:04:50,399
lenient. So the first shayla the rabbi's

130
00:04:50,399 --> 00:04:51,339
going to ask when you call, the

131
00:04:51,339 --> 00:04:53,180
first shayla's going to be, was it

132
00:04:53,180 --> 00:04:55,180
cold? Then it's going to be, when

133
00:04:55,180 --> 00:04:56,259
was the last time the thing was

134
00:04:56,259 --> 00:04:58,079
used? So now let's get into this

135
00:04:58,079 --> 00:04:59,593
concept. So the Gemara... The Gemara tells

136
00:04:59,593 --> 00:05:02,459
us that a machlokes between Rav and

137
00:05:02,459 --> 00:05:04,920
Shmuel regarding the status of hot pareve

138
00:05:05,120 --> 00:05:09,399
fish, okay, דגים שעלו בקערה. That means

139
00:05:09,399 --> 00:05:12,160
I cooked fish. רב אמר אסור לאכלן

140
00:05:12,480 --> 00:05:14,993
בכותח. So Rav says you can't, that

141
00:05:14,993 --> 00:05:18,420
fish cannot be eaten with dairy. Why

142
00:05:18,420 --> 00:05:19,939
not? What is the reason according to

143
00:05:19,939 --> 00:05:22,480
Rav? Because there is no way that

144
00:05:22,560 --> 00:05:24,680
well here the k'arah is a fleishig

145
00:05:24,680 --> 00:05:28,160
ben yomo. So according to Rav why

146
00:05:28,160 --> 00:05:31,279
can't I eat that fish with dairy

147
00:05:31,420 --> 00:05:34,639
with milchig? Because the fish absorbed taam

148
00:05:34,639 --> 00:05:36,876
from the meat. It was a ben

149
00:05:36,876 --> 00:05:38,120
yomo. I made meatballs in the morning,

150
00:05:38,639 --> 00:05:40,220
I cleaned it out, I made fish

151
00:05:40,220 --> 00:05:42,060
later in the afternoon, completely pareve fish,

152
00:05:42,399 --> 00:05:44,259
but the taam of the meatballs is

153
00:05:44,259 --> 00:05:45,336
still in the walls of the pot

154
00:05:45,336 --> 00:05:47,560
and there that when I heat it

155
00:05:47,560 --> 00:05:49,399
up the taam comes into the fish,

156
00:05:49,480 --> 00:05:50,759
the fish is now fleishig. Why would

157
00:05:50,759 --> 00:05:52,273
that be a question? Hold on a

158
00:05:52,273 --> 00:05:52,946
sec, hold on a sec, hold on

159
00:05:52,946 --> 00:05:55,220
a sec. שמואל אמר מותר לאכלן בכותח.

160
00:05:55,680 --> 00:05:58,279
Shmuel says you can eat it with

161
00:05:58,279 --> 00:06:01,040
the some kutach is a dairy kind

162
00:06:01,040 --> 00:06:02,399
of thing you could eat it with

163
00:06:02,399 --> 00:06:06,639
that because רב אמר נותן טעם הוא.

164
00:06:07,000 --> 00:06:08,639
Rav says it's noten taam. What do

165
00:06:08,639 --> 00:06:11,079
you mean? The meat was noten taam

166
00:06:11,079 --> 00:06:13,339
from the wall into the fish. Shmuel

167
00:06:13,339 --> 00:06:16,980
amar muttar because נותן טעם בר נותן

168
00:06:16,980 --> 00:06:19,120
טעם הוא. There's a concept called for

169
00:06:19,120 --> 00:06:20,379
the rest of the zman we're going

170
00:06:20,379 --> 00:06:21,899
to call it nat bar nat, not

171
00:06:21,899 --> 00:06:24,000
נותן טעם בר נותן טעם. You know

172
00:06:24,120 --> 00:06:26,279
for example in the Gemara the Gemara

173
00:06:26,279 --> 00:06:27,639
is in Gittin, we're learning Gittin in

174
00:06:27,639 --> 00:06:28,879
the yeshiva this year. So the Gemara

175
00:06:28,879 --> 00:06:31,339
in Gittin the first eight blatt is

176
00:06:31,339 --> 00:06:33,139
בפני נכתב ובפני נחתם. When you sign

177
00:06:33,139 --> 00:06:34,079
a get you have to say בפני

178
00:06:34,240 --> 00:06:35,759
נכתב ובפני נחתם but you learn Gittin

179
00:06:36,180 --> 00:06:38,459
no one ever says בפני נכתב ובפני

180
00:06:38,879 --> 00:06:40,879
נחתם you say בפני נכתב ובפני נחתם.

181
00:06:41,040 --> 00:06:42,399
You say like that. Say very fast.

182
00:06:42,819 --> 00:06:44,060
So we told our seniors when the

183
00:06:44,060 --> 00:06:45,560
Roshei Yeshiva come to interview you for

184
00:06:45,560 --> 00:06:47,079
the yeshivas and they say what are

185
00:06:47,079 --> 00:06:48,199
you learning in Gittin they don't say

186
00:06:48,199 --> 00:06:49,959
בפני נכתב ובפני נחתם you have to

187
00:06:49,959 --> 00:06:51,773
speed through it so you know it

188
00:06:51,773 --> 00:06:52,300
sounds like you know what you're talking

189
00:06:52,300 --> 00:06:54,256
about, okay? So nat bar nat, okay?

190
00:06:54,600 --> 00:06:55,680
They do know what they're talking about

191
00:06:55,740 --> 00:06:56,759
but it's always good to help them.

192
00:06:56,759 --> 00:06:59,300
Okay? There's a concept called nat bar

193
00:06:59,300 --> 00:07:01,160
nat. Nat bar nat means according to

194
00:07:01,160 --> 00:07:04,699
Shmuel the meatballs were noten taam into

195
00:07:04,699 --> 00:07:06,959
the walls of the pot. The walls

196
00:07:06,959 --> 00:07:09,060
of the pot are noten taam into

197
00:07:09,060 --> 00:07:11,259
the fish. That is a very very

198
00:07:11,259 --> 00:07:13,800
weak taste. That is not strong enough

199
00:07:14,339 --> 00:07:16,040
and נותן טעם בר נותן טעם we

200
00:07:16,040 --> 00:07:18,040
think is according to Shmuel which the

201
00:07:18,040 --> 00:07:19,420
Gemara paskens like is going to be

202
00:07:19,420 --> 00:07:21,160
okay. The Gemara the Tosafos in Zevachim

203
00:07:21,699 --> 00:07:24,579
in source number two explains that we

204
00:07:24,579 --> 00:07:27,040
saw a little bit of this Tosafos.

205
00:07:27,040 --> 00:07:29,009
Says the Tosafos in Zevachim ואם לא

206
00:07:29,009 --> 00:07:32,500
הביא ראיה לדבריו מקדירה שבישלו בה בשר

207
00:07:32,620 --> 00:07:34,500
לא יבשלו בה חלב בשביל דנותן טעם

208
00:07:35,000 --> 00:07:36,660
when I if I cooked meat, don't

209
00:07:36,660 --> 00:07:38,220
cook in it milk because it's noten

210
00:07:38,300 --> 00:07:39,399
taam. דהתם לאו נותן טעם בר נותן

211
00:07:39,399 --> 00:07:40,600
טעם הוא that's not נותן טעם בר

212
00:07:41,220 --> 00:07:44,180
נותן טעם שפעמים שהטעם השני באיסור דהיינו

213
00:07:44,180 --> 00:07:47,160
בשר וחלב sometimes the second taste is

214
00:07:47,339 --> 00:07:50,579
in a prohibition namely basar vechalav takes

215
00:07:50,579 --> 00:07:51,980
effect when the meat and the milk

216
00:07:51,980 --> 00:07:54,240
are fused together okay like when I

217
00:07:54,240 --> 00:07:56,500
cook milk in a fleishig pot that's

218
00:07:56,500 --> 00:07:59,939
an issue אבל כאן הטעם השני בהיתר

219
00:07:59,939 --> 00:08:03,980
וקודם שיבא לידי איסור נתבטל הטעם בדגים

220
00:08:04,379 --> 00:08:09,000
לפי שהוא שני meaning when the fish

221
00:08:09,000 --> 00:08:11,680
is muttar by itself the meatballs are

222
00:08:11,680 --> 00:08:13,699
muttar by themselves so what happens? I

223
00:08:13,699 --> 00:08:15,860
have two muttar items in that situation

224
00:08:16,079 --> 00:08:18,519
I didn't fuse any issur together. When

225
00:08:18,519 --> 00:08:20,420
I made mamash basar vechalav and I

226
00:08:20,420 --> 00:08:22,240
created an entity a cheftza shel issur

227
00:08:22,439 --> 00:08:24,199
that's a problem and that's going to

228
00:08:24,199 --> 00:08:25,800
be noten taam. But you're telling me

229
00:08:25,879 --> 00:08:27,519
according to Shmuel I have fish the

230
00:08:27,519 --> 00:08:29,959
fish is pareve. The meat's fleishig. They're

231
00:08:29,959 --> 00:08:31,679
both noten taam into other things by

232
00:08:31,679 --> 00:08:33,539
the time they meet together it's a

233
00:08:33,539 --> 00:08:35,340
weak noten taam and therefore we do

234
00:08:35,340 --> 00:08:37,360
not imply that it's already inherently forbidden

235
00:08:37,580 --> 00:08:39,700
and noten taam is going to be

236
00:08:39,700 --> 00:08:42,419
okay. Halacha lemaaseh this how we pasken

237
00:08:42,440 --> 00:08:43,240
if you look in the Beis Yosef.

238
00:08:43,399 --> 00:08:45,879
Says the Beis Yosef in source number

239
00:08:45,879 --> 00:08:48,019
three. The Beis Yosef says you're right

240
00:08:48,559 --> 00:08:52,440
we pasken like Shmuel nat bar nat

241
00:08:52,679 --> 00:08:55,419
not a problem. However says the Beis

242
00:08:55,419 --> 00:08:57,720
Yosef it is a three way machlokes

243
00:08:57,919 --> 00:08:59,700
how to understand what it means דגים

244
00:08:59,700 --> 00:09:02,320
שעלו בקערה. So before we even see

245
00:09:02,320 --> 00:09:04,559
these three Rishonim, the Rivan, the Sefer

246
00:09:04,559 --> 00:09:05,820
HaTerumah, and the Rambam and there's a

247
00:09:05,820 --> 00:09:08,759
fourth what does it sound like? I

248
00:09:08,759 --> 00:09:10,679
gave you a lot of information I

249
00:09:10,679 --> 00:09:13,460
said that דגים שעלו בקערה fish that

250
00:09:13,460 --> 00:09:15,519
is in a plate is fish that

251
00:09:15,519 --> 00:09:17,159
was cooked in a fish cooked in

252
00:09:17,159 --> 00:09:19,440
a ben yomo fleishig pot. What does

253
00:09:19,440 --> 00:09:23,239
it sound like דגים שעלו בקערה? It

254
00:09:23,239 --> 00:09:26,226
was no water. Otherwise it was touching.

255
00:09:26,919 --> 00:09:30,399
So where was the fish was cooked

256
00:09:30,399 --> 00:09:32,679
where? Up against the metal. Some fish.

257
00:09:32,679 --> 00:09:35,580
Right. It doesn't even sound like... so

258
00:09:35,639 --> 00:09:37,000
okay that's a machlokes. It could be

259
00:09:37,000 --> 00:09:38,059
that it was cooked in that pot

260
00:09:38,139 --> 00:09:39,016
or it could be as Joel is

261
00:09:39,016 --> 00:09:40,360
saying it was cooked in another pot

262
00:09:40,440 --> 00:09:41,899
and then it came onto a pot

263
00:09:41,940 --> 00:09:43,039
maybe that is fleishig. So let's see

264
00:09:43,039 --> 00:09:48,480
three machlokes Rishonim. So the Rivan chosno

265
00:09:48,639 --> 00:09:58,559
the father in law of the Rivan

266
00:09:58,559 --> 00:09:59,480
was. The *Rivan chasno*, *Rashi*, *kasav mishmo*,

267
00:09:59,480 --> 00:10:08,019
אלו אין נתבשלו לו. Says the *Rivan*

268
00:10:08,620 --> 00:10:11,019
that *Shmuel* only allows eating the fish

269
00:10:11,019 --> 00:10:13,919
when the, okay, again, eating the fish

270
00:10:13,919 --> 00:10:17,340
with *milkchik* when the hot fish was

271
00:10:17,340 --> 00:10:19,993
placed on a *fleishig* dish. Okay, אף

272
00:10:19,993 --> 00:10:22,348
על גב דבאלו נמי קבלו כדי קליפה,

273
00:10:22,348 --> 00:10:24,704
טעמן בשר בבליעה מועטת התיר נותן טעם

274
00:10:24,704 --> 00:10:25,919
בר נותן טעם. אבל נתבשלו ונבלעו כל

275
00:10:25,919 --> 00:10:38,659
טעם הבשר שבלוע בקדירה, but if you're

276
00:10:38,659 --> 00:10:40,919
telling me that I *mamish* did what?

277
00:10:41,600 --> 00:10:44,676
I cooked the fish in that *fleishig

278
00:10:44,676 --> 00:10:46,695
ben yomo* pot, *asur le'ochlo bekutach*. According

279
00:10:46,695 --> 00:10:54,179
to, good, the *Rivan*, *Rashi*, and *Rabbi*

280
00:10:54,179 --> 00:10:56,879
Doug say the following: if you cook

281
00:10:56,879 --> 00:10:59,393
fish in a *fleishig* pot, that is

282
00:10:59,393 --> 00:11:02,559
not, that is not נותן טעם בר

283
00:11:02,559 --> 00:11:04,980
נותן טעם. That is *mamish* cooking it

284
00:11:05,320 --> 00:11:07,580
and therefore the only time that *Shmuel*

285
00:11:07,580 --> 00:11:10,480
really held that it's okay is when

286
00:11:10,480 --> 00:11:12,879
I cooked it by, I cooked the

287
00:11:12,879 --> 00:11:14,620
fish, I took the fish that was

288
00:11:14,620 --> 00:11:16,759
cooked in a *parve* pot, on a

289
00:11:16,759 --> 00:11:18,639
whatever pot, it doesn't matter, and then

290
00:11:18,639 --> 00:11:20,059
I took that fish and I put

291
00:11:20,059 --> 00:11:23,340
it on a *ben yomo fleishig* plate.

292
00:11:24,019 --> 00:11:26,379
Okay, that's נותן טעם בר נותן טעם.

293
00:11:26,720 --> 00:11:30,320
Why? Because the meat, the whatever, the

294
00:11:30,320 --> 00:11:32,980
meatballs were the *nosein ta'am*, then I

295
00:11:32,980 --> 00:11:34,860
took it onto the plate, that plate's

296
00:11:34,860 --> 00:11:37,179
not a real *fleishig* plate, the *fleishig*

297
00:11:37,179 --> 00:11:38,399
plate is a נותן טעם בר נותן

298
00:11:38,399 --> 00:11:39,580
טעם plate, it's a *nab bar nab*

299
00:11:39,580 --> 00:11:42,213
plate. What? We're gonna talk, we're gonna

300
00:11:42,213 --> 00:11:42,720
talk about all those things in a

301
00:11:42,720 --> 00:11:44,960
second. Okay, so says the *Rivan* in

302
00:11:44,960 --> 00:11:46,679
the name of *Rashi*, that's the only

303
00:11:46,679 --> 00:11:49,379
time he's going to be *meikel*. In

304
00:11:49,379 --> 00:11:52,059
comes the *Sefer HaTruma* and the *Rosh*

305
00:11:52,059 --> 00:11:54,559
and others and the *Tur*, וכתב הראש

306
00:11:54,559 --> 00:11:59,529
וספר התרומה the other way, התיר ירקות

307
00:11:59,529 --> 00:12:03,759
וקטניות שנתבשלו בקדירה בת יומא חלבת, the

308
00:12:03,759 --> 00:12:08,240
other way around. They allow the fish

309
00:12:08,240 --> 00:12:10,240
that was cooked in a *fleishig ben

310
00:12:10,240 --> 00:12:13,916
yomo* pot to be eaten with *milkchik*,

311
00:12:13,916 --> 00:12:15,935
רק שמנקה מחלב לאכל בתבשיל של בשר,

312
00:12:17,899 --> 00:12:22,460
so long as obviously it's been cleaned

313
00:12:22,460 --> 00:12:24,526
out, because they believe אפילו נאמר אלו

314
00:12:24,526 --> 00:12:26,881
אין נצלו לו כשנתבשלו שרי, משום דאיכא

315
00:12:26,881 --> 00:12:31,879
שלשה נותן טעם. They actually say it

316
00:12:31,879 --> 00:12:35,019
was weakened three times. Forget *nosein ta'am*,

317
00:12:35,259 --> 00:12:36,600
forget *nat bar nat*, actually weakened, one

318
00:12:36,600 --> 00:12:39,639
sec, hold on, hold on, *nat bar

319
00:12:39,639 --> 00:12:42,120
nat* to the third degree. The meat

320
00:12:42,120 --> 00:12:44,960
to the pot is one, what's next?

321
00:12:44,960 --> 00:12:50,920
The pot קדירה במים והמים בירק. So

322
00:12:50,920 --> 00:12:53,159
don't view the water as everything. I

323
00:12:53,159 --> 00:12:55,320
cooked meatballs this morning, meatballs went into

324
00:12:55,320 --> 00:12:57,720
my pot. That is *nosein ta'am* one.

325
00:12:58,220 --> 00:13:00,179
The meatballs went into the water, *nosein

326
00:13:00,179 --> 00:13:02,440
ta'am* two. The water was *nosein ta'am*

327
00:13:02,440 --> 00:13:05,196
into the fish, that's crazy. That's נותן

328
00:13:05,196 --> 00:13:06,542
טעם בר נותן טעם בר נותן טעם,

329
00:13:06,542 --> 00:13:07,966
that's *mutar*. That's what's the logic though,

330
00:13:07,966 --> 00:13:10,321
that the water cooks before the item

331
00:13:10,321 --> 00:13:12,159
in the water? Yes, because you need

332
00:13:12,159 --> 00:13:14,879
a medium to transfer heat. I need

333
00:13:14,879 --> 00:13:16,033
a medium to transfer *ta'am*. We don't,

334
00:13:16,259 --> 00:13:17,919
it's not just a magic potion, something

335
00:13:17,919 --> 00:13:19,500
has to transfer heat, transfer the taste.

336
00:13:19,879 --> 00:13:20,899
So the water transfers the taste, but

337
00:13:20,899 --> 00:13:21,840
it doesn't happen at the same time.

338
00:13:22,139 --> 00:13:23,940
The water absorbs from the thing and

339
00:13:23,940 --> 00:13:24,879
then it puts it in, it's floating

340
00:13:24,879 --> 00:13:26,336
in the pot, so the water is,

341
00:13:26,336 --> 00:13:27,600
is being is transferred even if it

342
00:13:27,600 --> 00:13:29,860
happens in a split second. But the

343
00:13:29,860 --> 00:13:31,093
*Tur*, the *Sefer HaTruma*, and the *Rosh*

344
00:13:31,093 --> 00:13:33,200
say that's enough and therefore if I

345
00:13:33,200 --> 00:13:35,299
made meatballs this morning and I cooked

346
00:13:35,299 --> 00:13:37,700
fish this afternoon, do not leave here

347
00:13:37,700 --> 00:13:40,220
before we do *halacha lema'aseh* and go

348
00:13:40,220 --> 00:13:42,120
home, but according to the *Tur* and

349
00:13:42,120 --> 00:13:43,539
the *Rosh* and the *Sefer HaTruma* I

350
00:13:43,539 --> 00:13:45,559
could go ahead and eat that fish

351
00:13:45,559 --> 00:13:48,340
with whatever *milkchik* you wanted to eat

352
00:13:48,340 --> 00:13:50,326
it with. Hold on, hold on, hold

353
00:13:50,326 --> 00:13:52,039
on, hold on, there's a lot of

354
00:13:52,039 --> 00:13:53,659
details. I want to get through a

355
00:13:53,659 --> 00:13:55,379
number more *mekomos* unless it's I don't

356
00:13:55,379 --> 00:13:57,500
understand what that source was, because that's

357
00:13:57,500 --> 00:13:59,855
fine, but according to the *Rosh*, how

358
00:13:59,855 --> 00:14:02,211
you're translating this, he says the *yerakos*

359
00:14:02,211 --> 00:14:04,567
that were cooked in a *ben yomo

360
00:14:04,567 --> 00:14:06,922
chalavas*. *Chalavas*? Where are you getting this

361
00:14:06,922 --> 00:14:09,278
was cooked in a *fleishig* pot to

362
00:14:09,278 --> 00:14:11,634
start with? The fish was cooked in

363
00:14:11,634 --> 00:14:13,989
the *Rosh* pot. But the vegetables, *yerakos*,

364
00:14:13,989 --> 00:14:15,672
*ben yomos*, *shenisbashlu bak*... He's saying the

365
00:14:15,672 --> 00:14:23,120
other way I just said the other

366
00:14:23,120 --> 00:14:24,220
way around. If I cooked it in

367
00:14:24,220 --> 00:14:25,309
a *milkchik* pot it's a *fleishig*, other

368
00:14:25,309 --> 00:14:27,320
just do the other way around. If

369
00:14:27,320 --> 00:14:29,639
I cooked them all in a, he

370
00:14:29,639 --> 00:14:30,899
says, if I cooked it all in

371
00:14:30,899 --> 00:14:33,000
a *bas yoma chalavas*, as long as

372
00:14:33,000 --> 00:14:35,039
it's clean, I could, if I later

373
00:14:35,039 --> 00:14:36,559
cooked something *betavshil shel basar* I can

374
00:14:36,559 --> 00:14:38,580
eat it. I made macaroni and cheese

375
00:14:38,580 --> 00:14:40,159
this morning, I cleaned it out, I

376
00:14:40,159 --> 00:14:42,539
made something *fleishig* in there, I can

377
00:14:42,539 --> 00:14:43,212
eat it together, I can eat it.

378
00:14:43,212 --> 00:14:44,419
Meaning whatever is as long as it's

379
00:14:44,419 --> 00:14:45,679
been cleaned out, whatever I put in

380
00:14:45,679 --> 00:14:47,240
that pot afterwards doesn't have the status

381
00:14:47,240 --> 00:14:51,080
of what it was this morning. No,

382
00:14:51,139 --> 00:14:52,600
no, then he continues in the underline,

383
00:14:53,139 --> 00:14:54,989
he continues in the underline, חלב בקדירה

384
00:14:54,989 --> 00:14:56,335
קדירה במים ומים בירק, even though if

385
00:14:56,335 --> 00:14:59,379
it's it's. 24 hours? That's what he's

386
00:14:59,379 --> 00:15:02,182
saying, yeah. According to the Rashi he's

387
00:15:02,182 --> 00:15:04,538
talking about boiling vegetables, but he equates

388
00:15:04,538 --> 00:15:06,894
boiling vegetables where you have a full

389
00:15:06,894 --> 00:15:13,080
pot of a liquid medium as opposed

390
00:15:13,080 --> 00:15:15,559
to if you were frying a piece

391
00:15:15,559 --> 00:15:17,914
of meat that had lachluchit on it.

392
00:15:17,914 --> 00:15:18,587
So we're talking about that, potentially but

393
00:15:18,587 --> 00:15:18,700
depends on how much oil you have.

394
00:15:18,960 --> 00:15:20,679
Yeah, that might, that might be. We're

395
00:15:20,679 --> 00:15:22,139
going to talk about that. And then

396
00:15:22,139 --> 00:15:23,296
he quotes the third is the Rambam.

397
00:15:23,296 --> 00:15:25,840
וכן נראה דעת הרמבם. Then he quotes

398
00:15:25,840 --> 00:15:28,613
the Rambam to, you know, just like

399
00:15:28,613 --> 00:15:29,962
to your point, שכתבו בפרק ט מהלכות

400
00:15:29,962 --> 00:15:32,318
מאכלות אסורות, קערה שאכלו בה בשר, if

401
00:15:32,318 --> 00:15:34,674
I have a plate that I was

402
00:15:34,674 --> 00:15:37,029
eating meat, ובשלו בה דגים אותם דגים

403
00:15:37,029 --> 00:15:42,600
מותר לאוכלן בכותח. So according to the

404
00:15:42,600 --> 00:15:45,042
Rambam, he says ולא חילק בין צליה

405
00:15:45,042 --> 00:15:47,820
לבישול כלל. According to the Rambam, even

406
00:15:47,820 --> 00:15:49,460
if the fish I allowed, I can

407
00:15:49,460 --> 00:15:52,039
eat the fish with dairy if it

408
00:15:52,039 --> 00:15:53,679
was cooked in a fleishig ben yomo

409
00:15:53,679 --> 00:15:55,740
pot, even if it was fried. Again

410
00:15:55,840 --> 00:15:57,960
because of nat bar nat. He quotes

411
00:15:57,960 --> 00:15:59,039
here in the footnote, by the way,

412
00:16:00,179 --> 00:16:03,019
a comment of the Issur v'Hetter that

413
00:16:03,019 --> 00:16:04,899
you can eat it like the Rivash,

414
00:16:04,980 --> 00:16:06,236
a little bit of like a, we'll

415
00:16:06,236 --> 00:16:07,320
call it a fourth opinion or a

416
00:16:07,320 --> 00:16:08,919
three-eighths, or B, but anyway, these are

417
00:16:08,919 --> 00:16:10,379
the three opinions. So according to the

418
00:16:10,379 --> 00:16:12,829
Rambam, the plate, it says אכלו בה

419
00:16:12,829 --> 00:16:17,220
בשר ובשלו בה דגים. So is he

420
00:16:17,220 --> 00:16:19,676
saying that you cooked meat in that,

421
00:16:19,676 --> 00:16:22,032
but it says אכלו? That's not just

422
00:16:22,032 --> 00:16:23,059
you cooked? Yeah, yeah, yeah. Yeah, we'll

423
00:16:23,059 --> 00:16:24,200
see, we'll see a little bit later

424
00:16:24,200 --> 00:16:26,320
in the Rema about plates and stuff

425
00:16:26,320 --> 00:16:28,000
like that. Okay. So now go to

426
00:16:28,000 --> 00:16:29,426
the Shulchan Aruch in Tzadi-Hei. Is this

427
00:16:29,426 --> 00:16:33,059
davar charif? A little bit later. Yeah,

428
00:16:33,100 --> 00:16:35,519
a little bit, a little bit. Okay,

429
00:16:35,519 --> 00:16:37,720
so if you go into Siman Tzadi-Hei

430
00:16:37,799 --> 00:16:40,082
the following. Shulchan Aruch in Seif Aleph

431
00:16:40,082 --> 00:16:41,092
says דגים שנתבשלו או שנתצלו בקדירה של

432
00:16:41,480 --> 00:16:48,516
בשר. The fish that I cooked in

433
00:16:48,516 --> 00:16:50,559
a meat, in a meat pot. rechuza

434
00:16:52,960 --> 00:16:55,000
yafeh. All I gotta do is clean

435
00:16:55,000 --> 00:16:57,480
it out really, really well. Right? If

436
00:16:57,480 --> 00:16:58,636
I clean it out really, really well

437
00:16:58,636 --> 00:17:01,960
שאין שום שומן דבוק בה. As long

438
00:17:01,960 --> 00:17:03,859
as there's really nothing that's left there,

439
00:17:03,859 --> 00:17:07,519
then mutar l'ochlan b'kutach. Right? Like the

440
00:17:07,519 --> 00:17:10,220
Rambam, I can eat it with the

441
00:17:10,220 --> 00:17:12,759
dairy thing. Why? Exactly as we just

442
00:17:12,759 --> 00:17:15,115
said. משום דהוי נותן טעם בר נותן

443
00:17:15,115 --> 00:17:19,759
טעם דהיתרא. It's why d'heteira? Because there

444
00:17:19,759 --> 00:17:21,306
is נט בר נט דאיסורא. Right? Certain

445
00:17:21,306 --> 00:17:24,000
things that become an issur just because

446
00:17:24,000 --> 00:17:26,799
the ta'am is weakened doesn't matter. If

447
00:17:26,799 --> 00:17:28,980
I took treifus tonight and cooked it

448
00:17:28,980 --> 00:17:30,680
in my pot and then I said,

449
00:17:30,759 --> 00:17:32,480
\"Oh, I cooked treifus in this morning

450
00:17:32,480 --> 00:17:34,259
and now I had other treifus\". I

451
00:17:34,259 --> 00:17:35,519
don't care that you have other treifus

452
00:17:35,519 --> 00:17:36,480
in there. I don't care that it's

453
00:17:36,480 --> 00:17:37,599
later. I don't care that you cleaned

454
00:17:37,599 --> 00:17:39,519
it out. It's treifus. Treifus is an

455
00:17:39,519 --> 00:17:41,779
issur no matter what. Doesn't matter. But

456
00:17:41,980 --> 00:17:44,099
נותן טעם בר נותן טעם דהיתרא of

457
00:17:44,099 --> 00:17:45,700
meat in a pot and milk in

458
00:17:45,700 --> 00:17:47,599
a pot that later are because of

459
00:17:47,759 --> 00:17:49,319
נותן טעם בר נותן טעם joined together,

460
00:17:49,799 --> 00:17:51,573
that's what we're talking about. ואם לא

461
00:17:51,573 --> 00:17:54,079
היה רחוצה יפה, and if you didn't

462
00:17:54,079 --> 00:17:56,173
wash it out so nicely, אם יש

463
00:17:56,173 --> 00:17:59,220
ממש על פני הקדירה יוצא ממנו בשישים

464
00:17:59,220 --> 00:18:01,299
מהדגים אסור לאוכלן בכותח. All right, then

465
00:18:01,299 --> 00:18:02,259
you have to figure out if you

466
00:18:02,259 --> 00:18:04,519
had shishim or not. Okay, exactly we

467
00:18:04,519 --> 00:18:06,519
just saw in the Gemara and then

468
00:18:06,519 --> 00:18:10,259
in the Rambam. Seif Beis. Okay, now

469
00:18:10,259 --> 00:18:11,859
the Shulchan Aruch is going to clarify

470
00:18:11,859 --> 00:18:13,619
what exactly is this halacha of nat

471
00:18:13,619 --> 00:18:16,233
bar nat. So let's follow. ביצה שנתבשלה

472
00:18:16,233 --> 00:18:21,240
במים בקדירה חולבת. I take an egg,

473
00:18:21,240 --> 00:18:23,740
okay, and I cooked it in a

474
00:18:23,740 --> 00:18:26,480
milchig pot. I want to take that

475
00:18:26,480 --> 00:18:29,156
egg. An egg is parve or fleishig?

476
00:18:29,156 --> 00:18:31,949
Parve. There we go. מותר לתת אותה

477
00:18:31,949 --> 00:18:35,299
בתוך התרנגולת. If you're thinking, \"What does

478
00:18:35,299 --> 00:18:37,319
that mean?\" That is exactly what that

479
00:18:37,319 --> 00:18:40,779
sounds like. It's Thanksgiving morning and you

480
00:18:40,779 --> 00:18:42,160
take that egg and you shove it

481
00:18:42,160 --> 00:18:43,966
in the turkey. Afilu l'chatchila says the,

482
00:18:45,400 --> 00:18:48,633
now why? All right, now I took

483
00:18:48,633 --> 00:18:50,660
the, I had a milchig pot. ביצה

484
00:18:50,660 --> 00:18:52,759
שנתבשלה במים בקדירה חולבת, a milchig pot.

485
00:18:52,859 --> 00:18:54,059
I cooked an egg in a milchig

486
00:18:54,059 --> 00:18:55,859
pot. I could stick that egg in

487
00:18:55,859 --> 00:18:58,240
a turkey, or hen, chicken, whichever you

488
00:18:58,240 --> 00:19:01,799
like. Afilu l'chatchila I could even do

489
00:19:01,799 --> 00:19:05,119
it l'chatchila. Why is that okay? Because

490
00:19:05,119 --> 00:19:10,079
אבל אם נתבשלה בקדירה עם בשר, that's

491
00:19:10,079 --> 00:19:13,680
different. If I had a milchig pot,

492
00:19:14,180 --> 00:19:15,819
that means that maybe this morning I

493
00:19:15,819 --> 00:19:17,579
made macaroni and cheese. I cleaned it

494
00:19:17,579 --> 00:19:19,299
out. It is a milchig pot. For

495
00:19:19,299 --> 00:19:20,720
the next 24 hours that pot is

496
00:19:20,720 --> 00:19:22,400
a milchig pot. But when I cooked

497
00:19:22,400 --> 00:19:25,000
the eggs alone, what was milchig inside

498
00:19:25,000 --> 00:19:27,140
the pot? Nothing. The only thing that

499
00:19:27,140 --> 00:19:29,319
was milchig inside the pot was the

500
00:19:29,319 --> 00:19:30,880
ta'am from this morning of the macaroni

501
00:19:30,880 --> 00:19:32,440
and cheese that was back into, but

502
00:19:32,440 --> 00:19:34,279
the egg isn't a milchig egg. So

503
00:19:34,279 --> 00:19:35,099
if I took that egg and I

504
00:19:35,099 --> 00:19:36,579
put it in a turkey, that's not

505
00:19:36,579 --> 00:19:37,740
going to do anything, that's not a

506
00:19:37,740 --> 00:19:41,420
problem. But if I had meat sauce

507
00:19:41,420 --> 00:19:42,660
and I threw an egg in there,

508
00:19:43,019 --> 00:19:44,996
and then I took that egg, right,

509
00:19:44,996 --> 00:19:46,779
and I took that egg, that, I'm

510
00:19:46,779 --> 00:19:48,960
sorry, what's a macaroni and cheese and

511
00:19:48,960 --> 00:19:50,279
I took that egg, that egg is

512
00:19:50,279 --> 00:19:54,319
now what? Milchig. נתבשלה בקדירה עם בשר.

513
00:19:54,599 --> 00:19:56,099
He says it by the meat. But

514
00:19:56,099 --> 00:19:57,660
if the parve item is cooked together

515
00:19:57,660 --> 00:20:00,500
with meat, afilu b'klippa... Asur le'ochlo bechutach.

516
00:20:00,960 --> 00:20:05,299
Okay, an egg cooked with meat or

517
00:20:05,299 --> 00:20:06,920
cooked with dairy could not be eaten,

518
00:20:07,380 --> 00:20:08,339
you can't use it for the other

519
00:20:08,339 --> 00:20:12,880
one. Okay. Good. Fershteis? Veiter. Says the

520
00:20:24,880 --> 00:20:29,720
Rema: Veyesh machmirim. So the Rema says,

521
00:20:29,819 --> 00:20:32,220
there are those that are machmir בצליה

522
00:20:32,220 --> 00:20:37,000
ובשול לאסור נותן טעם בר נותן טעם.

523
00:20:37,220 --> 00:20:40,579
Oh, so close. Says the Rema, like

524
00:20:40,579 --> 00:20:43,200
the Rivan, quoting Rashi, and the Aruch,

525
00:20:43,500 --> 00:20:45,859
and the Mordechai, there are those that

526
00:20:45,859 --> 00:20:48,380
are machmir even if it's נותן טעם

527
00:20:48,839 --> 00:20:50,500
בר נותן טעם, even if it's not

528
00:20:50,500 --> 00:20:52,779
bar nat, to be machmir not to

529
00:20:52,779 --> 00:20:54,837
use it. The Rema says, let's continue,

530
00:20:54,837 --> 00:20:58,039
right? The Rema actually a little bit

531
00:20:58,039 --> 00:20:59,460
later, we'll put him back to that

532
00:20:59,460 --> 00:21:01,896
Issur Veheter, but let's continue. Vehaminhag le'asor

533
00:21:02,440 --> 00:21:06,279
lechatchila, and the Rema says, and the

534
00:21:06,279 --> 00:21:09,519
minhag is to be to assur this.

535
00:21:09,819 --> 00:21:11,900
That means that what? The fish that

536
00:21:11,900 --> 00:21:14,660
was cooked in a fleishig ben yomo

537
00:21:14,660 --> 00:21:17,480
pot, not with fleishig, a fleishig ben

538
00:21:17,480 --> 00:21:20,299
yomo pot, that fish the Rema says

539
00:21:20,420 --> 00:21:24,240
lechatchila should not be eaten together with

540
00:21:24,240 --> 00:21:27,599
dairy. Okay. What about bedieved? Excellent. We're

541
00:21:27,599 --> 00:21:28,500
going to come back to that next

542
00:21:28,500 --> 00:21:30,559
time. Okay. But this is how the

543
00:21:30,559 --> 00:21:35,519
Rema paskens. So, but ובדיעבד מותר בכל

544
00:21:35,519 --> 00:21:38,839
ענין דדוקא לאכלם עם חלב ובשר עצמו.

545
00:21:38,900 --> 00:21:41,519
The Rema says, but if dairy was

546
00:21:41,519 --> 00:21:43,253
added to it, meaning I made, I

547
00:21:43,253 --> 00:21:45,799
made meatballs in the morning, I cleaned

548
00:21:45,799 --> 00:21:47,579
it out, I have, I made fish

549
00:21:47,579 --> 00:21:49,099
in there in the afternoon, I didn't

550
00:21:49,099 --> 00:21:50,779
realize the pot was, I took the

551
00:21:50,779 --> 00:21:53,019
fish and I, I added milk and

552
00:21:53,019 --> 00:21:54,440
I add all this other stuff, says

553
00:21:54,440 --> 00:21:56,559
the Rema, you could eat that fish.

554
00:21:57,079 --> 00:21:58,880
You could eat that fish. The shaila

555
00:21:59,059 --> 00:22:00,339
we're going to talk about soon is

556
00:22:00,339 --> 00:22:02,880
can I do that lechatchila? Okay. We

557
00:22:02,880 --> 00:22:04,226
have the shaila, we have the shaila

558
00:22:04,226 --> 00:22:05,700
a lot. The shaila comes up a

559
00:22:05,700 --> 00:22:07,839
lot. I'm running out of pots. It's

560
00:22:07,839 --> 00:22:09,599
Friday afternoon. I only have a milchig

561
00:22:09,599 --> 00:22:10,960
pot. Can I use, these are going

562
00:22:10,960 --> 00:22:12,200
to come up. So the Rema says,

563
00:22:12,980 --> 00:22:16,339
bedieved it's going to be mutar. Meaning,

564
00:22:16,579 --> 00:22:18,079
in essence, why does the Rema say

565
00:22:18,079 --> 00:22:20,599
that? Let's understand how the Rema comes

566
00:22:20,599 --> 00:22:22,759
to this. The Rema's not, if it's

567
00:22:22,759 --> 00:22:23,819
mutar it's mutar, if it's assur it's

568
00:22:23,819 --> 00:22:26,759
assur. The Rema says, yes, really we

569
00:22:26,759 --> 00:22:29,720
don't, we don't in essence pasken like

570
00:22:29,720 --> 00:22:31,859
the Rivan. I, we pasken like how

571
00:22:31,859 --> 00:22:34,019
the Shulchan Aruch paskens, like the Rambam,

572
00:22:34,019 --> 00:22:35,256
that it's nosein ta'am it's not bar

573
00:22:35,256 --> 00:22:36,980
nat. However, we're going to be machmir

574
00:22:36,980 --> 00:22:38,900
about it, but in any situation it's

575
00:22:38,900 --> 00:22:40,336
a, this is a good reminder of

576
00:22:40,336 --> 00:22:42,819
what machmir generally means. Machmir is a

577
00:22:42,819 --> 00:22:44,700
good thing. Machmir is not a bad

578
00:22:44,700 --> 00:22:46,380
thing. Machmir is not a person who's

579
00:22:46,380 --> 00:22:48,779
a religious fanatic. A chumra means there

580
00:22:48,779 --> 00:22:50,200
is basis in halacha for such a

581
00:22:50,200 --> 00:22:52,160
thing. Right? So the Rema says, this

582
00:22:52,160 --> 00:22:52,900
is what it means to be machmir.

583
00:22:53,420 --> 00:22:55,119
Yes, the Rivan, yes, the Shulchan Aruch

584
00:22:55,119 --> 00:22:56,799
says this, we follow the Rivan. However,

585
00:22:57,039 --> 00:22:58,900
in cases of need, a bedieved, it's

586
00:22:58,900 --> 00:23:00,799
mutar because it's only a chumra. Right?

587
00:23:01,240 --> 00:23:02,680
A person who keeps 72 minutes after

588
00:23:02,680 --> 00:23:05,059
Shabbos is a chumra, right? That's the

589
00:23:05,059 --> 00:23:07,396
Rabbeinu Tam, and in case of need

590
00:23:07,396 --> 00:23:07,960
if they keep it as a chumra,

591
00:23:08,059 --> 00:23:09,960
they're able to be meikel on certain

592
00:23:09,960 --> 00:23:11,900
things because it's a chumra. Okay. Fine.

593
00:23:12,440 --> 00:23:19,480
That's the Rema. Okay. Yeah. The Rema

594
00:23:19,480 --> 00:23:21,256
adds, okay, so now if you look

595
00:23:21,256 --> 00:23:22,266
ואפילו אם ליתן בה כלי שלהם מותר

596
00:23:22,266 --> 00:23:27,140
לכתחילה. Okay. Vechein nahagu. So we pasken

597
00:23:27,140 --> 00:23:28,599
like this. This is how we pasken

598
00:23:28,599 --> 00:23:30,660
as Ashkenazim. This is how we pasken.

599
00:23:31,160 --> 00:23:33,180
Then the Rema begins to add four

600
00:23:33,180 --> 00:23:35,220
different halachos. We're going to talk about

601
00:23:35,220 --> 00:23:36,079
a few of them right now. So

602
00:23:36,079 --> 00:23:39,740
let's go one by one. Okay. He

603
00:23:39,740 --> 00:23:42,442
says first, וכן אם לא נתבשלו או

604
00:23:42,442 --> 00:23:49,200
נצלו תחילה. Let's say that I actually

605
00:23:49,200 --> 00:23:51,200
didn't cook them at all together. Rather

606
00:23:51,279 --> 00:23:53,700
what did I do? רק עלו בכלי

607
00:23:53,700 --> 00:23:57,319
של בשר מותר לאכלן עם חלב עצמו

608
00:23:57,319 --> 00:24:03,476
וכן להיפך. Fish cooked in a ben

609
00:24:03,476 --> 00:24:07,773
yomo pot, okay, in a fleishig ben

610
00:24:07,773 --> 00:24:10,420
yomo pot, got that? Fish cooked in

611
00:24:10,420 --> 00:24:12,775
a fleishig ben yomo pot can be

612
00:24:12,775 --> 00:24:13,785
put lechatchila on a dairy ben yomo

613
00:24:13,785 --> 00:24:17,000
plate. Okay? Clean plate, not like full

614
00:24:17,000 --> 00:24:19,819
of yogurt. Okay? Next. That's number one.

615
00:24:22,720 --> 00:24:23,960
I'll tell you where the shaila comes

616
00:24:23,960 --> 00:24:25,880
up. Shaila comes up that a person

617
00:24:25,880 --> 00:24:28,220
makes pasta in a fleishig ben yomo

618
00:24:28,220 --> 00:24:30,740
pot. Okay? They make pasta in a

619
00:24:30,740 --> 00:24:32,140
fleishig ben yomo pot and they want

620
00:24:32,140 --> 00:24:33,059
to know if they could add cheese

621
00:24:33,059 --> 00:24:35,079
or not to it. Shulchan Aruch would

622
00:24:35,079 --> 00:24:38,960
say yes. The Rema would say no.

623
00:24:39,380 --> 00:24:41,019
That's how we pasken. That's how we

624
00:24:41,019 --> 00:24:42,940
pasken. That the noodles aren't, the spaghetti

625
00:24:42,940 --> 00:24:44,660
will not make you fleishig, you cannot

626
00:24:44,660 --> 00:24:46,900
eat that spaghetti. If you by accident

627
00:24:46,900 --> 00:24:48,420
did it and you didn't realize, the

628
00:24:48,420 --> 00:24:50,839
Rema would say it's fine. Okay? That's

629
00:24:50,839 --> 00:24:53,900
number one. But what would the Rema

630
00:24:53,900 --> 00:24:54,976
say if it was an eino ben

631
00:24:54,976 --> 00:24:59,319
yomo pot? I made... I'm just telling

632
00:24:59,319 --> 00:25:01,220
you, do not share this halacha in

633
00:25:01,220 --> 00:25:02,660
your house. You will get yelled at.

634
00:25:03,240 --> 00:25:05,960
Okay? This is a regular halacha, it's

635
00:25:05,960 --> 00:25:08,019
the Rema paskins, I could take the.

636
00:25:08,019 --> 00:25:10,460
The reason is you find this in

637
00:25:10,460 --> 00:25:11,579
a lot of the in the Rishonim,

638
00:25:12,380 --> 00:25:14,519
that's why we have multiple sets of

639
00:25:14,519 --> 00:25:17,059
pots. If yes, you could have one

640
00:25:17,059 --> 00:25:19,519
pot and every other day make something

641
00:25:19,519 --> 00:25:21,500
in it, it gets confusing. But if

642
00:25:21,500 --> 00:25:23,779
you had an eino ben yomo fleishig

643
00:25:23,779 --> 00:25:25,319
pot, you made spaghetti in there and

644
00:25:25,319 --> 00:25:26,339
you wanted to add cheese lechatchila the

645
00:25:26,339 --> 00:25:30,180
Rema would say go ahead. Okay? You'd

646
00:25:30,180 --> 00:25:31,619
feel weird doing it. You took that

647
00:25:31,619 --> 00:25:32,599
pot that it came out of the

648
00:25:32,599 --> 00:25:34,400
fleishig dishwasher and then you'd feel weird

649
00:25:34,400 --> 00:25:36,000
doing it, but that's how the Rema

650
00:25:36,359 --> 00:25:40,559
paskins. Next. היה הכלי שנתבשלו או נצלו

651
00:25:40,559 --> 00:25:46,460
בו לפגם. Before we get to the

652
00:25:46,460 --> 00:25:48,519
second halacha, okay, go to the source

653
00:25:48,519 --> 00:25:49,720
for one second to source number four

654
00:25:49,720 --> 00:25:51,880
to the Bedek HaBayis. Say the question

655
00:25:51,880 --> 00:25:53,599
is as we just mentioned can I

656
00:25:53,599 --> 00:25:55,619
do this or not lechatchila? Just I

657
00:25:55,619 --> 00:25:56,559
know we said this outside but let's

658
00:25:56,559 --> 00:25:58,660
look at it inside. Bedek HaBayis is

659
00:25:58,660 --> 00:26:01,359
Rabbi Yosef Karo. So if I made

660
00:26:01,359 --> 00:26:03,920
vegetables שנתבשלו בקדרה חולבת אפילו בת יומא,

661
00:26:03,920 --> 00:26:05,733
even if it's that day, מותר לאכלו

662
00:26:05,733 --> 00:26:08,319
בתבשיל של בשר, ונראה דדוקא בדיעבד אבל

663
00:26:08,319 --> 00:26:10,980
לכתחילה אין לו לבשל בכלי של חלב.

664
00:26:10,980 --> 00:26:12,980
So the Bedek HaBayis quotes, here it's

665
00:26:12,980 --> 00:26:15,720
actually quoting the Rabbeinu Yerucham, that actually

666
00:26:15,720 --> 00:26:17,579
the Rabbeinu Yerucham says no, you shouldn't

667
00:26:17,579 --> 00:26:19,380
do it lechatchila, bedieved like the Rema

668
00:26:19,380 --> 00:26:21,779
says. Says the Bedek HaBayis, says Rabbi

669
00:26:21,779 --> 00:26:25,279
Yosef Karo, ein devarav nirim. No. לכתחילה

670
00:26:25,279 --> 00:26:27,480
נמי מותר לבשל בכלי של חלב. That's

671
00:26:27,480 --> 00:26:29,680
fine. You could do it even like

672
00:26:29,680 --> 00:26:31,319
we just said, it would be fine

673
00:26:31,319 --> 00:26:34,740
to intentionally do this kind of thing.

674
00:26:35,619 --> 00:26:39,160
That's how the Sephardim might give a

675
00:26:39,160 --> 00:26:41,619
psak. We obviously do not follow that

676
00:26:41,619 --> 00:26:44,400
psak. If you turn the page, because

677
00:26:44,400 --> 00:26:45,700
from the language of the Shulchan Aruch

678
00:26:45,700 --> 00:26:48,319
it sounds like shenisbashlu or shenitzlu. It

679
00:26:48,319 --> 00:26:50,000
sounds like they already did it. Can

680
00:26:50,000 --> 00:26:51,359
I do it lechatchila? So here you

681
00:26:51,359 --> 00:26:52,729
have in Halichot Olam, Rav Ovadia. So

682
00:26:52,729 --> 00:26:55,353
Rav Ovadia writes ולא עוד אלא אפילו

683
00:26:55,353 --> 00:26:58,636
הוא יודע מראש. I know, says Rav

684
00:26:58,636 --> 00:27:01,480
Ovadia. I am cooking with intention that

685
00:27:01,480 --> 00:27:04,220
later I'm going to eat this with

686
00:27:04,220 --> 00:27:09,900
dairy, that's fine. שעתיד לעשות לבן או

687
00:27:09,900 --> 00:27:12,799
חמאה באורז מותר לבשל האורז בקדירה בשר

688
00:27:12,799 --> 00:27:17,400
בת יומא. Says Rabbi Yosef Karo, I

689
00:27:17,400 --> 00:27:20,380
took a pot, it's a fleishig pot,

690
00:27:20,809 --> 00:27:22,359
it's ben yomo, and it's clean. I'm

691
00:27:22,359 --> 00:27:24,099
going to cook rice in there and

692
00:27:24,099 --> 00:27:25,240
later I am going to eat that

693
00:27:25,240 --> 00:27:28,279
rice with butter. Says Rav Ovadia, that

694
00:27:28,279 --> 00:27:31,240
is going to be okay. Even cooking

695
00:27:31,240 --> 00:27:33,380
it lechatchila to do it is going

696
00:27:33,380 --> 00:27:35,633
to be okay. That's what I mean.

697
00:27:35,633 --> 00:27:37,180
But the Rema's lechatchila is that adding

698
00:27:37,180 --> 00:27:39,799
the cheese lechatchila? Yeah. No, or cooking,

699
00:27:40,140 --> 00:27:41,689
meaning is the lechatchila or the Rema

700
00:27:41,689 --> 00:27:44,019
says it's a problem is you when

701
00:27:44,019 --> 00:27:45,596
you decide to cook it in the

702
00:27:45,596 --> 00:27:47,953
fleishig pot or when you decide to

703
00:27:47,953 --> 00:27:48,290
put the cheese on? So no, so

704
00:27:48,290 --> 00:27:50,059
the Rema says we don't do it.

705
00:27:50,059 --> 00:27:50,059
Rema says we don't do it. But

706
00:27:50,059 --> 00:27:52,619
I'm saying what where are we measuring?

707
00:27:52,660 --> 00:27:53,559
Oh, if you want to eat a

708
00:27:53,559 --> 00:27:54,756
pareve, no one's going to care. No,

709
00:27:54,756 --> 00:27:55,960
no, I'm saying you cooked in the

710
00:27:55,960 --> 00:27:58,700
fleishig pot. That's fine. No, and then

711
00:27:58,700 --> 00:27:59,993
you want to add cheese on. That's

712
00:27:59,993 --> 00:28:02,240
the lechatchila. For the Rema, that's a

713
00:28:02,240 --> 00:28:03,220
problem still. For the Rema it's a

714
00:28:03,220 --> 00:28:07,299
problem. Yeah, yeah, yeah. Okay, so that's

715
00:28:07,299 --> 00:28:08,809
how the Rav Ovadia paskins. If you

716
00:28:08,809 --> 00:28:15,279
look in, okay so let's go now

717
00:28:15,279 --> 00:28:17,119
to source number six to the Badai

718
00:28:17,119 --> 00:28:20,700
HaShulchan, Shagapo Cohen? 508? The great Sephardic

719
00:28:20,700 --> 00:28:22,036
that he put out all on Yoreh

720
00:28:22,036 --> 00:28:24,859
Deah. So he says the following. He

721
00:28:24,859 --> 00:28:28,180
says the opinion of the Rema, he

722
00:28:28,180 --> 00:28:30,900
quotes the Gra. Ube'er HaGra da'ato. This

723
00:28:31,400 --> 00:28:33,279
we're going to see a machlokes here,

724
00:28:33,279 --> 00:28:35,940
a very, very fundamental machlokes right now,

725
00:28:35,940 --> 00:28:38,000
the Gra in this source and the

726
00:28:38,000 --> 00:28:39,859
Chachmat Adam in the next source. Okay.

727
00:28:40,639 --> 00:28:42,819
So by the opinion of the Rema,

728
00:28:42,819 --> 00:28:43,960
which we just said we don't do

729
00:28:43,960 --> 00:28:47,440
this, we don't cook there lechatchila, באר

730
00:28:47,440 --> 00:28:50,559
הגר''א דעתו דמותר אף לכתחילה. He quotes

731
00:28:50,559 --> 00:28:53,759
the Gra that says the Rema allows

732
00:28:53,759 --> 00:28:56,880
cooking pareve food in only an eino

733
00:28:56,880 --> 00:29:01,000
ben yomo pot. Okay? That's okay lechatchila.

734
00:29:01,000 --> 00:29:03,160
That means that if I have a

735
00:29:03,160 --> 00:29:04,960
pot over twenty-four hours and I want

736
00:29:04,960 --> 00:29:06,380
to use it, that would be okay

737
00:29:07,819 --> 00:29:10,599
lechatchila. ואף בקדירה אין אסור לכתחילה שאינו

738
00:29:10,599 --> 00:29:14,339
בן יומא אלא משום גזירה אטו בן

739
00:29:14,339 --> 00:29:18,299
יומא. Okay, so okay, a gezeira atu.

740
00:29:18,299 --> 00:29:19,700
We have this concept a lot of

741
00:29:19,700 --> 00:29:21,240
times, we have a gezeira atu, which

742
00:29:21,240 --> 00:29:23,039
means we're doing this because we don't

743
00:29:23,039 --> 00:29:25,119
want you to come to do something

744
00:29:25,119 --> 00:29:26,220
else, right? We don't want you to

745
00:29:26,220 --> 00:29:27,279
come to cook in a ben yomo

746
00:29:27,279 --> 00:29:29,440
and therefore we asser in eino ben

747
00:29:29,440 --> 00:29:30,700
yomo. But an eino ben yomo by

748
00:29:30,700 --> 00:29:33,319
itself is not really going to be

749
00:29:33,319 --> 00:29:35,940
a problem. But he continues מה שאין

750
00:29:35,940 --> 00:29:41,000
כן כאן. However, דאף בן יומו מותר

751
00:29:41,000 --> 00:29:44,220
מדינא כנזכר לעיל. However, a ben yomo

752
00:29:44,220 --> 00:29:47,000
pot really he says should be allowed

753
00:29:47,000 --> 00:29:49,339
if you cooked pareve. Meaning Chazal are

754
00:29:49,339 --> 00:29:51,980
concerned that I might come to use

755
00:29:51,980 --> 00:29:54,099
a ben yomo pot. You're not going

756
00:29:54,099 --> 00:29:55,519
to cook in it? So what the

757
00:29:55,519 --> 00:29:57,059
Gra is saying is that even if

758
00:29:57,059 --> 00:30:01,039
I cook pareve... I cooked *pareve* in

759
00:30:01,039 --> 00:30:03,660
a dairy *Ben yomo* pot. Okay, I

760
00:30:03,660 --> 00:30:05,019
cooked *pareve* in a dairy *Ben yomo*

761
00:30:05,019 --> 00:30:10,460
pot, the *Rama* really holds that that's

762
00:30:10,460 --> 00:30:14,039
okay. Okay, if I cooked dairy in

763
00:30:14,039 --> 00:30:15,880
a *pareve Ben yomo* pot, that would

764
00:30:15,880 --> 00:30:17,660
be okay to eat it with something

765
00:30:17,660 --> 00:30:19,319
else because that's really how he holds.

766
00:30:19,319 --> 00:30:20,660
And he continues and he says in

767
00:30:20,660 --> 00:30:27,220
the underline: חזינן דבדיעבד מותר בזה רק

768
00:30:27,220 --> 00:30:29,960
לכתחילה נוהגים להחמיר. This whole thing that

769
00:30:29,960 --> 00:30:32,380
we just mentioned that on *lechatchila* we're

770
00:30:32,380 --> 00:30:35,180
*machmir*, אין חומרא זו אלא בבן יומו.

771
00:30:35,180 --> 00:30:37,259
That's when it comes to a *Ben

772
00:30:37,259 --> 00:30:40,319
yomo*. אבל באינו בן יומו הדרינן לעיקר

773
00:30:40,319 --> 00:30:44,359
הדין דנת בר נת שרי אף בישול

774
00:30:44,359 --> 00:30:46,700
לכתחילה באינו בן יומו מותר אף לכתחילה.

775
00:30:46,700 --> 00:30:50,019
What the *Gra* holds is that the

776
00:30:50,019 --> 00:30:52,680
whole this whole thing is only about

777
00:30:52,680 --> 00:30:54,680
a *Ben yomo*. I don't want you

778
00:30:54,680 --> 00:30:55,900
to use a *Ben yomo* and therefore

779
00:30:55,900 --> 00:30:57,339
we're going to be *machmir*. But if

780
00:30:57,339 --> 00:30:59,940
I use an *eino Ben yomo* even

781
00:30:59,940 --> 00:31:01,559
with intention to do it with the

782
00:31:01,559 --> 00:31:04,339
other food, the *Rama* would say not

783
00:31:04,339 --> 00:31:06,099
a problem. So if I had an

784
00:31:06,099 --> 00:31:08,380
*eino Ben yomo* pot and I cooked

785
00:31:08,380 --> 00:31:10,426
spaghetti in that *eino Ben yomo* pot,

786
00:31:10,426 --> 00:31:11,000
it doesn't matter. I cook fish, doesn't

787
00:31:11,000 --> 00:31:14,180
matter. Even *lechatchila* if I called it

788
00:31:14,180 --> 00:31:16,759
a *fleishig eino Ben yomo* pot, that

789
00:31:16,759 --> 00:31:19,039
means I made meatballs thirty-six hours ago,

790
00:31:19,039 --> 00:31:20,819
I take it out tonight, I make

791
00:31:20,819 --> 00:31:21,960
fish and I know I'm going to

792
00:31:21,960 --> 00:31:24,099
eat that fish with dairy, the *Rama*

793
00:31:24,099 --> 00:31:26,000
according to the *Gra* says it's not

794
00:31:26,000 --> 00:31:28,140
a problem. The *Chazal* were not *machmir*

795
00:31:28,140 --> 00:31:30,519
about that, that's not *gezeira atu*, we're

796
00:31:30,519 --> 00:31:33,480
only *gezeira atu* a *Ben yomo*. Okay,

797
00:31:33,480 --> 00:31:37,200
the *Chachmas Adam* argues. *Chachmas Adam* argues

798
00:31:37,200 --> 00:31:39,039
and he says the *Rama* only allows

799
00:31:39,039 --> 00:31:41,880
eating fish with dairy if it was

800
00:31:41,880 --> 00:31:43,279
already cooked in an *eino Ben yomo*

801
00:31:43,279 --> 00:31:47,079
pot, but not *lechatchila*. And he says:

802
00:31:47,079 --> 00:31:50,019
אם היה הכלי שנתבשל בו אינו בן

803
00:31:50,019 --> 00:31:51,500
יומו. If I have a *kli* that

804
00:31:51,500 --> 00:31:53,299
I cooked in that was an *eino

805
00:32:00,840 --> 00:32:02,380
Ben yomo*, okay, מותר לאכלו בחלב אפילו

806
00:32:02,380 --> 00:32:02,980
לדידן אבל אסור לכתחילה. Says the *Chachmas

807
00:32:02,980 --> 00:32:05,500
Adam*, I can't do it *lechatchila*, לבשל

808
00:32:05,500 --> 00:32:08,259
בכלי שאינו בן יומו כדי לאכלו בחלב,

809
00:32:08,259 --> 00:32:13,220
okay, because that's *assur lechatchila*. The *noten

810
00:32:13,220 --> 00:32:15,400
ta'am lifgam assur lechatchila*. What does that

811
00:32:15,400 --> 00:32:18,220
mean? Means like this: so this is

812
00:32:18,220 --> 00:32:21,500
a very, very fundamental *machlokes*, *Gra* and

813
00:32:21,500 --> 00:32:24,119
*Chachmas Adam*. If we follow the *Gra*

814
00:32:24,119 --> 00:32:25,759
we'd be in a better spot, but

815
00:32:25,759 --> 00:32:27,099
we actually don't in this situation, we

816
00:32:27,099 --> 00:32:29,180
follow the *Chachmas Adam*. The *Chachmas Adam*

817
00:32:29,180 --> 00:32:33,519
says again if I took an *eino

818
00:32:33,519 --> 00:32:35,519
Ben yomo fleishig* pot and I made

819
00:32:35,519 --> 00:32:38,319
fish and then by accident I mixed

820
00:32:38,319 --> 00:32:42,140
milk into it, totally fine. The *Chachmas

821
00:32:42,140 --> 00:32:43,339
Adam* says but to take an *eino

822
00:32:43,339 --> 00:32:45,740
Ben yomo fleishig* pot, cook spaghetti in

823
00:32:45,740 --> 00:32:47,000
there with the intention that I'm going

824
00:32:47,000 --> 00:32:48,799
to melt cheese onto those spaghetti noodles,

825
00:32:48,799 --> 00:32:53,579
says the *Chachmas Adam*, that's *assur*. Why?

826
00:32:54,000 --> 00:32:55,240
Because even though you're going to throw

827
00:32:55,240 --> 00:32:58,359
at me *noten ta'am lifgam*, that's all

828
00:32:58,359 --> 00:33:01,059
good and dandy if it was by

829
00:33:01,059 --> 00:33:05,000
accident. But this is *lechatchila*. We don't

830
00:33:05,000 --> 00:33:07,180
do it *lechatchila*. I don't utilize anything

831
00:33:07,180 --> 00:33:09,220
*lechatchila* when it's an *issur*. So says

832
00:33:09,220 --> 00:33:11,636
the *Chachmas Adam*, we are therefore *machmir*.

833
00:33:12,420 --> 00:33:14,660
Most of the modern day *poskim* including

834
00:33:14,660 --> 00:33:16,880
Rav Elyashiv and including if you look

835
00:33:16,880 --> 00:33:18,880
in the *kashrus* books, follow this *Chachmas

836
00:33:18,880 --> 00:33:21,460
Adam*. So therefore, you can't really have

837
00:33:21,460 --> 00:33:23,200
one pot in your house. Because that

838
00:33:23,200 --> 00:33:24,539
one pot is always going to be

839
00:33:24,539 --> 00:33:26,940
an *eino Ben yomo* of something. *Lechatchila*...

840
00:33:26,940 --> 00:33:30,259
*bediavad* it would be okay. Or maybe

841
00:33:30,259 --> 00:33:31,259
*bediavad* means I only have one pot,

842
00:33:31,400 --> 00:33:33,019
but to rely that I'm going to

843
00:33:33,019 --> 00:33:34,259
use it to make pasta to eat

844
00:33:34,259 --> 00:33:35,819
with cheese when it was *fleishig* thirty-six

845
00:33:35,819 --> 00:33:38,219
hours ago, that we're *machmir* about. Okay.

846
00:33:38,219 --> 00:33:38,892
But the *Chachmas Adam's* whole point is

847
00:33:38,892 --> 00:33:48,813
saying for *lechatchila* here is still to

848
00:33:48,813 --> 00:33:51,168
say *eino Ben yomo*. It's to cook

849
00:33:51,168 --> 00:33:53,524
it with intention to use. Correct. Add

850
00:33:53,524 --> 00:33:55,880
cheese if you... No, you could cooking's

851
00:33:55,880 --> 00:33:55,880
never a problem. No no no, I'm

852
00:33:55,880 --> 00:33:55,880
saying there's diff... No, one second. But

853
00:33:56,279 --> 00:34:00,276
if I have a thirty-six hour pot,

854
00:34:00,276 --> 00:34:02,859
okay? I'm gonna make... it was *fleishig*

855
00:34:02,859 --> 00:34:05,220
yesterday morning. Tonight, I'm gonna make spaghetti

856
00:34:05,220 --> 00:34:06,519
in this pot and I know that

857
00:34:06,519 --> 00:34:08,033
afterwards I'm gonna put cheese in. Right,

858
00:34:08,033 --> 00:34:10,280
that's *lechatchila* for sure. Right, but I

859
00:34:10,280 --> 00:34:11,519
can make spaghetti in that pot, it's

860
00:34:11,519 --> 00:34:13,422
not a problem. No but if I

861
00:34:13,422 --> 00:34:15,778
already... let's say I make spaghetti in

862
00:34:15,778 --> 00:34:18,134
this *eino Ben yomo* pot yesterday and

863
00:34:18,134 --> 00:34:20,489
today I decide I want to put

864
00:34:20,489 --> 00:34:22,509
cheese on. Is that *lechatchila* or *bediavad*?

865
00:34:22,509 --> 00:34:22,509
So that seems to be okay, correct.

866
00:34:22,509 --> 00:34:23,249
Meaning, if I... now you can't you

867
00:34:23,249 --> 00:34:26,019
can't *harama* it, yeah yeah. I don't

868
00:34:26,019 --> 00:34:26,920
know what I want to make it

869
00:34:26,920 --> 00:34:28,460
for and your whole fridge is full

870
00:34:28,460 --> 00:34:30,460
of cheese. Yeah yeah, correct, correct. Doesn't...

871
00:34:31,579 --> 00:34:33,039
I don't have to know my intention

872
00:34:33,039 --> 00:34:34,199
but as long as my intention is

873
00:34:34,199 --> 00:34:35,849
not to do that thing, so long

874
00:34:35,849 --> 00:34:37,360
that that would be okay. Now if

875
00:34:37,360 --> 00:34:38,440
a person's like, well I didn't really

876
00:34:38,440 --> 00:34:39,929
know what I wanted yesterday. Right. Okay,

877
00:34:39,929 --> 00:34:42,559
but that's the point because you're not

878
00:34:42,559 --> 00:34:45,036
creating an *issur*. Right. You're cooking *pareve*

879
00:34:45,036 --> 00:34:47,739
pasta. That's fine. But if your intention

880
00:34:47,739 --> 00:34:48,679
was that I'm going to cook it

881
00:34:48,679 --> 00:34:50,079
and then put cheese to it so

882
00:34:50,079 --> 00:34:51,833
it's a problem. They have in the

883
00:34:51,833 --> 00:34:52,460
in the notes I'll send that later

884
00:34:52,460 --> 00:34:53,780
a whole chart of everything that you

885
00:34:53,780 --> 00:34:54,860
can go over and you can review,

886
00:34:54,860 --> 00:34:57,360
it's really wonderful and amazing for... you

887
00:34:57,360 --> 00:34:58,336
can look at that on your own.

888
00:34:58,336 --> 00:35:01,320
Okay. So a few examples. You go

889
00:35:01,320 --> 00:35:06,019
to source number eight. Okay. So we

890
00:35:06,019 --> 00:35:08,099
just mentioned the Rema paskens that parve

891
00:35:08,099 --> 00:35:09,440
food in an eino ben yomo pot

892
00:35:09,440 --> 00:35:11,119
could be eaten with fleishig. There's a

893
00:35:11,119 --> 00:35:12,699
machlokes could I do it lechatchila? So

894
00:35:12,699 --> 00:35:15,599
they quote here something very fascinating. So

895
00:35:15,599 --> 00:35:17,960
in many many kosher ice cream places,

896
00:35:18,639 --> 00:35:22,400
they make both lines of parve and

897
00:35:22,400 --> 00:35:26,440
dairy, they're not necessarily like, they could

898
00:35:26,440 --> 00:35:28,159
be on the same line. So you

899
00:35:28,159 --> 00:35:33,079
look in Dayan Weiss, the Minchas Yitzchak,

900
00:35:33,079 --> 00:35:35,900
they're making parve ice cream in eino

901
00:35:36,399 --> 00:35:39,980
ben yomo dairy utensils. Okay? It's an

902
00:35:39,980 --> 00:35:42,199
eino ben yomo dairy pot and they're

903
00:35:42,199 --> 00:35:45,420
calling that ice cream parve. So Dayan

904
00:35:45,420 --> 00:35:47,260
Weiss, Dayan Weiss was one of the

905
00:35:47,260 --> 00:35:49,159
great great poskim in Eretz Yisrael, was

906
00:35:49,159 --> 00:35:50,800
the dayan of the Edah Hachareidis and

907
00:35:50,800 --> 00:35:54,199
the Bedatz, massive massive talmid chacham. So

908
00:35:54,199 --> 00:35:59,280
it says Dayan Weiss: מה שנשאלתי בענין

909
00:35:59,280 --> 00:36:01,519
גלידה פרוה שנעשה שביום שלפניו נעשה באותו

910
00:36:01,519 --> 00:36:04,260
כלי גלידה חלבי yesterday or it just

911
00:36:04,260 --> 00:36:05,800
means eino ben yomo, it was in

912
00:36:05,800 --> 00:36:08,800
a milchig pot. ואוכלים אותה עם בשר.

913
00:36:08,800 --> 00:36:10,679
Now, did they really eat it with

914
00:36:10,679 --> 00:36:12,440
meat? Not but they're calling it parve.

915
00:36:12,440 --> 00:36:14,159
If I call something parve, I could

916
00:36:14,159 --> 00:36:17,340
eat it with meat. והעליתי שם לאסור

917
00:36:17,340 --> 00:36:19,619
לעשות כן לכתחילה. And I thought that

918
00:36:19,619 --> 00:36:22,000
this should be assur, right? Because when

919
00:36:22,000 --> 00:36:24,860
you label it parve, that's implying that

920
00:36:24,860 --> 00:36:26,340
if something is parve, it could be

921
00:36:26,340 --> 00:36:32,159
eaten with parve or meat or dairy,

922
00:36:32,159 --> 00:36:35,300
'cause it's parve. He's- he don't hold

923
00:36:35,300 --> 00:36:38,260
anything yet. וכתבתי לדחות הצד להיתר. So

924
00:36:38,260 --> 00:36:41,002
he says ובנידון דהוי נט בר נט

925
00:36:41,002 --> 00:36:43,358
כתבתי וזה הלשון אחר מעת לעת אבד

926
00:36:43,358 --> 00:36:45,714
כחו יפה ונותן טעם לפגם מכל מקום

927
00:36:45,714 --> 00:36:50,539
יש להחמיר לכתחילה. How- it doesn't matter.

928
00:36:50,539 --> 00:36:52,416
Even if you clean it well, that-

929
00:36:52,416 --> 00:36:55,159
that we should be machmir. The Rema

930
00:36:55,159 --> 00:36:57,179
does not really allow us to do

931
00:36:57,179 --> 00:36:59,280
that. If you go to the next

932
00:36:59,280 --> 00:37:01,076
source though- There's no cooking involved. Right,

933
00:37:01,076 --> 00:37:03,780
there's no- there's no heat involved in

934
00:37:03,780 --> 00:37:05,780
making ice cream. So how is it

935
00:37:05,780 --> 00:37:08,769
right or wrong? There's cold. Right, it's

936
00:37:08,769 --> 00:37:11,099
all cold. It's all cold ingredients. I

937
00:37:11,099 --> 00:37:13,420
have no idea. I'm just going to

938
00:37:13,420 --> 00:37:15,659
trust Dayan Weiss. I don't- Okay, so

939
00:37:15,659 --> 00:37:17,005
in other words he's- I get it,

940
00:37:17,005 --> 00:37:17,159
I don't know. I don't know. I

941
00:37:17,159 --> 00:37:20,199
don't know. In other words, he's holding

942
00:37:20,199 --> 00:37:23,019
that that should be labeled not parve

943
00:37:23,019 --> 00:37:25,380
but dairy equipment. We're not at dairy

944
00:37:25,380 --> 00:37:27,262
equipment yet. Not dairy equipment. Hold on.

945
00:37:27,262 --> 00:37:29,199
He's saying that you can't use- that's

946
00:37:29,199 --> 00:37:30,159
a good question, I don't know. I'd

947
00:37:30,159 --> 00:37:31,976
have to find that. But the Ohel

948
00:37:31,976 --> 00:37:37,559
Yaakov here, they quote the following: that

949
00:37:37,559 --> 00:37:41,280
actually don't because what do most people

950
00:37:41,280 --> 00:37:44,840
make- make ice cream for? Dessert. Dessert

951
00:37:44,840 --> 00:37:46,679
is not usually, even if you're a

952
00:37:46,679 --> 00:37:48,599
big meat guy, you don't have meat

953
00:37:48,599 --> 00:37:50,239
for dessert. So when you make it,

954
00:37:50,239 --> 00:37:54,619
says the Ohel Yaakov, גלידה נאכלת ברוב

955
00:37:54,619 --> 00:37:57,199
העולם לקינוח for dessert, שהיו אוכלים לבד

956
00:37:57,199 --> 00:37:58,980
ולכן כשבעלת הבית עושה גלידה נעשה על

957
00:37:58,980 --> 00:38:01,473
דעת they're not making it like, no,

958
00:38:01,473 --> 00:38:03,219
they're making it for parve and therefore

959
00:38:03,219 --> 00:38:06,480
everything is going to be okay. This

960
00:38:06,480 --> 00:38:08,119
leads us to a very common shaila

961
00:38:08,119 --> 00:38:10,780
in source number ten. If I baked

962
00:38:10,780 --> 00:38:12,780
a parve cake, okay, a chocolate cake

963
00:38:12,780 --> 00:38:14,320
for dessert in an eino ben yomo

964
00:38:14,320 --> 00:38:16,659
fleishig pan. This is a very common

965
00:38:16,659 --> 00:38:19,059
shaila. I didn't, right? Most people will

966
00:38:19,059 --> 00:38:21,639
have parve dishes or parve baking sheets,

967
00:38:21,639 --> 00:38:24,260
but I didn't use it. I used

968
00:38:24,260 --> 00:38:26,480
a fleishig eino ben yomo fleishig pan.

969
00:38:26,960 --> 00:38:29,880
And now, so again, I had meatballs,

970
00:38:30,000 --> 00:38:35,019
I made in my pot, Wednesday morning.

971
00:38:35,019 --> 00:38:37,900
Wednesday morning I made meatballs. Thursday night

972
00:38:37,900 --> 00:38:39,840
I make a chocolate cake. I have

973
00:38:39,840 --> 00:38:41,519
that chocolate cake, I finish Shabbos and

974
00:38:41,519 --> 00:38:43,420
now it's Sunday morning and I have

975
00:38:43,420 --> 00:38:45,039
a coffee and I want to know,

976
00:38:45,039 --> 00:38:47,039
could I eat that cake some of

977
00:38:47,039 --> 00:38:49,380
that cake with the coffee? To not

978
00:38:50,420 --> 00:38:52,980
real coffee because we're talking about milchig

979
00:38:52,980 --> 00:38:55,579
coffee here with cream, like normal people.

980
00:38:55,579 --> 00:38:57,519
Good. Let's get back to that zman.

981
00:38:58,439 --> 00:39:04,219
Okay. Says the Megillas Sefer the following:

982
00:39:04,219 --> 00:39:05,300
וכן נראה שמותר לבשל שוקולד וכיוצא בזה

983
00:39:05,300 --> 00:39:06,719
בסיר בשרי שאינו בן יומו כדי לעשותם

984
00:39:06,719 --> 00:39:09,420
בעוגה אף שאוכלים עם כוס קפה שיש

985
00:39:09,420 --> 00:39:11,719
בו חלב. That would be okay. Why

986
00:39:11,719 --> 00:39:14,400
would that be okay? shelo naaseh and

987
00:39:14,400 --> 00:39:15,900
Jules, this gets back to your point,

988
00:39:15,900 --> 00:39:17,760
להדיא רק בשביל זה. This goes even

989
00:39:17,760 --> 00:39:20,139
further. When I made my chocolate cake,

990
00:39:20,880 --> 00:39:23,076
unless you really made it, I'm going

991
00:39:23,076 --> 00:39:24,099
to make this for Sunday morning, if

992
00:39:24,099 --> 00:39:25,099
you want a piece of it on

993
00:39:25,099 --> 00:39:26,559
Shabbos go ahead but that's my- that's

994
00:39:26,559 --> 00:39:28,380
my coffee cake. You're making it dessert

995
00:39:28,380 --> 00:39:30,119
for Shabbos. That's your intention. You don't

996
00:39:30,119 --> 00:39:32,019
have to start like figuring out every

997
00:39:32,019 --> 00:39:34,239
scenario and every like- you made it

998
00:39:34,239 --> 00:39:36,500
for Shabbos, dessert for Shabbos. If you

999
00:39:36,500 --> 00:39:37,800
end up wanting it on Sunday morning,

1000
00:39:37,900 --> 00:39:40,179
okay, so that's Sunday morning and therefore

1001
00:39:40,179 --> 00:39:42,139
it would be okay. This leads us

1002
00:39:42,139 --> 00:39:44,659
to the whole discussion about DE and

1003
00:39:44,659 --> 00:39:45,716
things like that. I'm going to leave

1004
00:39:45,716 --> 00:39:46,840
it to you, you can read it

1005
00:39:46,840 --> 00:39:51,276
partially in the notes. But I'm going

1006
00:39:51,276 --> 00:39:52,139
to skip it 'cause you can read

1007
00:39:53,000 --> 00:39:53,940
it for you but I do want

1008
00:39:53,940 --> 00:39:54,960
to point one thing out and we'll-

1009
00:39:54,960 --> 00:39:56,690
we'll end with this. A very common...

1010
00:39:56,690 --> 00:40:00,320
A very common misconception when it comes

1011
00:40:00,320 --> 00:40:01,500
to DE and these kind of things

1012
00:40:01,699 --> 00:40:04,019
which, okay, the OU stopped doing DE

1013
00:40:04,019 --> 00:40:06,219
a long time ago. Okay? Either it

1014
00:40:06,219 --> 00:40:09,800
got confusing, Kashrus organizations, they, I'm sorry,

1015
00:40:09,860 --> 00:40:11,559
the companies didn't like it, they wanted

1016
00:40:11,559 --> 00:40:12,699
it to be uniform and what was

1017
00:40:12,699 --> 00:40:15,420
actually on like, they didn't like it.

1018
00:40:15,420 --> 00:40:17,739
DE or not DE. Still used for

1019
00:40:17,739 --> 00:40:19,642
a few things. So all of that,

1020
00:40:19,642 --> 00:40:20,599
all of that, all of that. Let

1021
00:40:20,599 --> 00:40:21,900
me just give me this, we'll do

1022
00:40:21,900 --> 00:40:22,940
Ma'ariv and then everybody, we could talk

1023
00:40:23,139 --> 00:40:26,340
afterwards. There are certain things that like,

1024
00:40:26,340 --> 00:40:28,059
like Oreos, there are certain things that

1025
00:40:28,059 --> 00:40:29,460
are, you know, DE, should always check

1026
00:40:29,460 --> 00:40:31,179
back with the OU. I know somebody

1027
00:40:31,179 --> 00:40:33,000
who's like always so nervous because the

1028
00:40:33,000 --> 00:40:34,300
OU says you should check back in

1029
00:40:34,300 --> 00:40:36,059
and every like six months he's always

1030
00:40:36,059 --> 00:40:37,519
like, I don't know, maybe they changed

1031
00:40:37,519 --> 00:40:38,340
it again, so he wouldn't eat them.

1032
00:40:38,340 --> 00:40:40,760
Like Oreos are DE and things like

1033
00:40:40,760 --> 00:40:43,840
that, right? There are certain things that

1034
00:40:43,840 --> 00:40:45,260
you can look at the ingredients and

1035
00:40:45,260 --> 00:40:47,059
you can say, oh, there's no, there's

1036
00:40:47,059 --> 00:40:49,679
no milk in there. Bederech klal, that

1037
00:40:49,679 --> 00:40:51,219
is not a way. There are certain

1038
00:40:51,219 --> 00:40:52,880
things, I think if there's no like,

1039
00:40:52,880 --> 00:40:55,599
no concern of allergy for milk. Looking

1040
00:40:55,599 --> 00:40:57,699
at ingredients, I tell my students all

1041
00:40:57,699 --> 00:41:00,340
the time, looking at ingredients does you

1042
00:41:00,340 --> 00:41:04,019
nothing because what we require as what

1043
00:41:04,019 --> 00:41:06,059
makes something milchig or not is not

1044
00:41:06,059 --> 00:41:07,356
only the line in which it was

1045
00:41:07,356 --> 00:41:08,516
produced and the heat and the ben

1046
00:41:08,516 --> 00:41:09,780
yomo and eino ben yomo. There are

1047
00:41:09,780 --> 00:41:11,219
certain things that the FDA says that

1048
00:41:11,219 --> 00:41:12,940
is so little milk you don't have

1049
00:41:12,940 --> 00:41:14,820
to call that dairy. We don't consider

1050
00:41:14,820 --> 00:41:16,599
that so little milk. So sometimes a

1051
00:41:16,599 --> 00:41:20,739
product might say contains dairy, it's dairy-free.

1052
00:41:21,039 --> 00:41:22,460
It's not what we, and it says

1053
00:41:22,460 --> 00:41:24,519
OUD. So some people are like, ah,

1054
00:41:24,659 --> 00:41:25,820
there's no way it's OUD, I looked

1055
00:41:25,820 --> 00:41:27,719
in the ingredients, there must be DE.

1056
00:41:27,820 --> 00:41:30,340
It's not DE. Sometimes, sometimes things are

1057
00:41:30,340 --> 00:41:31,380
DE, you've got to call the OU

1058
00:41:31,380 --> 00:41:33,340
because email Webby Rabbi, Rabbi Webby at

1059
00:41:33,980 --> 00:41:36,960
ou.org. And sometimes, I mentioned this last

1060
00:41:36,960 --> 00:41:38,800
month, there were these, there are parve

1061
00:41:38,800 --> 00:41:41,699
ice cream brands that have OUD. Talenti

1062
00:41:41,699 --> 00:41:44,159
was one of them. It says OUD,

1063
00:41:44,159 --> 00:41:46,000
but it says dairy-free. People were mamash

1064
00:41:46,000 --> 00:41:48,639
eating it after, after Shabbos meals. It's

1065
00:41:49,119 --> 00:41:50,820
mamash milchig. It has milk in it.

1066
00:41:51,159 --> 00:41:52,960
Ah, it says dairy-free? Yeah, because the

1067
00:41:52,960 --> 00:41:54,596
FDA says that so little milk you

1068
00:41:54,596 --> 00:41:55,780
don't require it, but that doesn't mean,

1069
00:41:55,780 --> 00:41:57,000
forgetting ben yomo and eino ben yomo,

1070
00:41:57,000 --> 00:41:59,179
it doesn't necessarily mean that something's always

1071
00:41:59,179 --> 00:42:01,800
dairy-free. We'll pick it up again next

1072
00:42:01,800 --> 00:42:02,300
week.

