Halacha LeMa'aseh
Yom Tov Sheini Shel Galuyot
The Second Day of Yom Tov: A Study in Halachic Debate
The origins and contemporary relevance of the second day of Yom Tov
In the time of the Sanhedrin, the Jewish calendar was determined by the testimony of witnesses who observed the new moon in Jerusalem. Messengers would then travel to Jewish communities in the diaspora to announce the date of Rosh Chodesh — but those communities far from Jerusalem might not receive the news before Yom Tov arrived. To avoid any doubt about which day was the correct one, diaspora communities began observing two days of each Yom Tov (except Yom Kippur).
Even after the calendar was fixed mathematically by Hillel II (c. 359 CE), eliminating all uncertainty, the Rabbis decreed that diaspora Jews should continue observing Yom Tov Sheini — minhag avoteinu b'yadeinu, "the custom of our ancestors is in our hands." This became the defining practice separating diaspora Jewry from their brethren in Eretz Yisrael.
With mass aliyah to the modern State of Israel and unprecedented global travel, the ancient distinctions have become pressing contemporary questions: What does an Israeli visiting New York do on the second day of Sukkos? What does a New Yorker visiting family in Jerusalem do? Can you board a flight from Tel Aviv on Yom Tov Sheini? These questions — once theoretical — are now everyday halachic reality.
One beautiful insight from the shiurim: in Eretz Yisrael, where God's presence is more accessible, one day suffices to fully experience the spiritual power of a Yom Tov. In galus, where that presence is more hidden, two days are needed to reach the same spiritual depth. Yom Tov Sheini is not merely a calendrical compromise — it reflects the existential reality of life outside the Holy Land.
The most contested issue in contemporary Yom Tov Sheini halacha
The Question
An Israeli — someone who lives in Eretz Yisrael and has no intention of relocating — visits a diaspora community over Yom Tov. Must he observe Yom Tov Sheini?
The Chacham Tzvi (R. Tzvi Ashkenazi, 1660–1718) holds that an Israeli visiting abroad need not keep Yom Tov Sheini — and more than that, he must not keep it, due to the prohibition of bal tosif (adding to the Torah's commandments).
His logic: the rule of "keep the stringencies of where you came from" applies only to practices you could legitimately continue if you settled permanently. Since an Israeli who permanently moved to Israel may not keep a second day (bal tosif), he cannot keep it even as a visitor. The practice is place-based, not person-based.
The majority of Acharonim — including the Peri Chadash, the Nodah BiYehudah, and the Mishna Berura — hold that an Israeli visiting abroad must keep two days privately (b'tzina). The Beit Yosef himself (R. Yosef Karo) in his Teshuvos Avkas Rochel considered it a violation of lo tisgodedu for Chutz L'Aretz visitors to form their own minyanim in Israel.
The Gemara in Pesachim derives from the Mishnah that one observes the stringencies of both the place they left and the place they arrived — and since the obligation of Yom Tov Sheini travels with the person, it applies even in Israel.
Majority: Full Two Days
Daven Yom Tov twice, say Kiddush both nights, do not do melacha even privately. The second day is fully Yom Tov. Rav Schachter: add tefillin without a bracha and listen to havdalah after day one.
Rav Soloveitchik: "Day and a Half"
Me'ikar hadin follows Chacham Tzvi (one day), but respect for the majority → no melacha on day two. Daven tefillas chol, put on tefillin with a bracha on day two, but refrain from melacha.
Chacham Tzvi: One Day
The Chacham Tzvi holds not only that one day is permitted — it is required (due to bal tosif). Melacha is fully permitted on day two. This is the practice of many Israelis and Sephardim.
Note: lo tisgodedu (divisive practices) is a concern in all approaches — an Israeli in a diaspora community who openly does melacha while others observe Yom Tov Sheini may violate this prohibition, regardless of their personal psak.
B'Yishuv vs. B'Tzina
Doing melacha in public within a Jewish community (b'yishuv) is universally agreed to be forbidden due to lo tisgodedu. Doing so privately at home (b'tzina) is disputed: Tosafot forbids it; the Ran, Rosh, and Rambam permit it. The Mishnah Berura rules stringently — even b'tzina is forbidden.
In the "Midbar"
The Gemara distinguishes: if a Ben Eretz Yisrael is in chutz l'aretz but not in a Jewish community (e.g., at a hospital far from any Jewish neighborhood), even the stringent opinion permits melacha. The prohibition is about appearance within the community.
Intent to Return
The Ran reads the Mishnah: it only applies to one whose da'ato lachzor — who plans to return to their home community. A clear visitor who plans to go back to Israel does not automatically become bound by the full diaspora obligations, according to some views.
The diaspora Jew visiting Eretz Yisrael over Yom Tov
The Mishna Berura and most Ashkenazic poskim rule that a diaspora Jew visiting Israel keeps his full two-day Yom Tov — including private observance of melacha restrictions on the second day. He should not perform melacha publicly. The reasoning: his Yom Tov Sheini obligations travel with him and are not suspended simply because he is visiting Israel temporarily.
Following the same logic as his ruling for Israelis abroad, the Chacham Tzvi would allow visitors to adopt the local Israeli minhag of one day. Since they are present in a makom where only one day is observed, and Yom Tov Sheini is a custom, the local practice governs. This position is held by some Sephardic poskim.
A nuanced approach discussed in several shiurim: the visitor keeps the second day privately (refrains from melacha) but does not repeat the Yom Tov davening, does not make Kiddush, and does not engage in the full Yom Tov experience. The practical question — whether to join locals for a Yom Tov seudah on what is their regular weekday — is a common real-world scenario addressed by multiple poskim.
A fascinating practical ruling: if a person is part of a group and the majority of that group is following one shittah, even those with a different personal psak should conform to avoid violating lo tisgodedu. A group that is mostly keeping one day should all keep one day; a group mostly keeping two days should all keep two days. The crucial caveat: this only applies if everyone in the group is truly in the same halachic circumstance. Mixed groups (e.g., some who own apartments in Israel, some first-time tourists) may have enough divergence that lo tisgodedu doesn't require uniformity.
Analyzed by: Rabbi Aryeh Lebowitz ("Visitors Keeping Two Days of Yom Tov in Israel"; "Flying Back From Israel on Yom Tov Sheini")
Modern aviation creates complex Yom Tov Sheini questions that classical sources did not anticipate
Can a diaspora Jew board a flight from Ben Gurion Airport on what is — for him — Yom Tov Sheini? The question involves multiple issues: is boarding itself an act of melacha? What if the flight was booked before Yom Tov? Does it matter where the flight lands?
One shiur analyzes this in depth from the perspective that a person keeping one day in Israel (following the Chacham Tzvi) may board a flight — but there is a concern: the moment one leaves Israeli airspace, one arguably should be treating the day as Yom Tov. How does one handle the transition mid-flight?
Rabbi Aryeh Lebowitz was prompted to address this when he took attendance in his 11th-grade class on Isru Chag: two boys had gone to Israel for Yom Tov yet were present. One landed at 5 AM; the other at 9 PM — having flown out of Israel on Yom Tov Sheini. "He said the whole plane was full of Jews from the Five Towns, from Teaneck, from Queens... who keep one day in Israel and flew back on Yom Tov Sheni because for them it wasn't Yom Tov."
R. Lebowitz's analysis: those following the Chacham Tzvi are technically permitted to fly, but there are serious concerns — most prominently, that one is engaging in uvda d'chol (weekday-type activity on a day that is still Yom Tov for most people around them) and undermining the sanctity of the day.
A compelling argument from the transcripts: Yom Tov Sheini is territorial, not personal. Just as Shabbos begins earlier in Tzfat than in Teveria based on geography, Yom Tov Sheini depends entirely on one's location. The moment a person leaves Israeli airspace, they are in Chutz L'Aretz — and it is immediately Yom Tov Sheini. There is no personal "carrying" of the status.
Under this view, someone who boards a plane from Israel on the second day of Yom Tov should expect to be observing Yom Tov conditions mid-flight — including the obligations of v'samachta b'chagecha. "How are you enjoying the chag sitting on a plane? Even with a comfortable seat, more legroom — that's not simchat Yom Tov." The ruling: one should simply not put oneself in this situation.
Complex questions about amirah l'Yisrael and lifnei iver on Yom Tov Sheini
On Yom Tov Sheini, the Israeli is acting on a regular weekday — melacha is completely permitted for him. Yet the diaspora Jew who is keeping Yom Tov Sheini cannot do it himself. Can he ask the Israeli to act on his behalf?
Majority: Forbidden (Amira l'Yisrael)
The prohibition is analogous to amira l'nochri on Shabbos: just as you may not instruct a non-Jew to do work you cannot do, you may not instruct a Jew. The Chacham Shlomo argues it is actually worse — a Jew acts as your shaliach, making you effectively responsible for the act. Authorities: Dover Meisharim, Rav Moshe Feinstein (Igros Moshe OC 3:73), Dayan Weiss (Minchas Yitzchak).
Rav Shlomo Zalman: Lenient Rationales Noted
Rav Shlomo Zalman Auerbach was choshesh for the stringent view but acknowledged various rationales why people are lenient. He declined to explicitly forbid asking, yet was concerned about the stringent position. The practical result is that one should not rely on the leniency without a compelling need.
What is permitted: Hinting & Israeli Initiative
Two categories are permitted: (1) A vague hint that is not in the manner of a command (beremez she'eino derech tzivui) — e.g., "It's pretty dark in here" is permitted; pointing at a light switch is forbidden. (2) If the Israeli himself offers to help and asks if the visitor wants something done, the visitor may accept — since the initiation came from the Israeli, not the diaspora Jew.
Key prohibition also applies if the instruction was given before Yom Tov — even pre-Yom Tov instructions to do work on Yom Tov Sheini are forbidden.
A diaspora Jew visiting Israel — keeping Yom Tov Sheini privately — wants to ask a local Israeli to perform a melacha. An interesting case from one of the shiurim: a woman from chutz l'aretz who is in Israel for Pesach asks a bas Eretz Yisrael to apply makeup on her face on Yom Tov Sheini. Two questions arise: (1) Is amira l'Yisrael permitted at all? (2) Does the fact that the melacha is performed on the body of the person keeping Yom Tov Sheini make a difference?
Rav Moshe Feinstein (Igros Moshe OC 3:73) addresses whether a Ben Chutz L'Aretz in Israel may ask a Ben Eretz Yisrael to do melacha. The analysis touches on whether the forbidden act is the asking or the resulting melacha, and whether it matters that the doer is acting on behalf of the person keeping Yom Tov. Rabbi Lebowitz's shiur concludes that both questions are interconnected and require careful analysis.
Mrs. Michal Horowitz's shiur addresses a broader range of amirah l'Yisrael scenarios: asking a Jew to do a forbidden act during Tosefes Shabbos (the extension of Shabbos before nightfall), carrying in an eiruv that the asker personally does not use, and opening bottles that the asker does not usually open. These cases explore the limits of the prohibition and whether the benefit accrues to the one asking.
Eilat, apartments, movers, milah, and more
A very contemporary question with ancient roots: is Eilat part of Eretz Yisrael for the purposes of Yom Tov Sheini? The practical stakes: "If you go to Eilat for Sukkot, Pesach, or Shavuot — are you keeping one day or two? The nafka mina: could you go snorkeling on Yom Tov Sheini?"
Eilat lies south of the borders of Eretz Yisrael as defined by many halachic authorities. If it is technically chutz la'aretz, then Israeli residents of Eilat would be obligated in Yom Tov Sheini, and diaspora visitors could not consider themselves in the Eretz Yisrael framework at all.
Rav Shlomo Zalman Auerbach develops an interesting svara: the relevant factor may be whether a Jewish government actually controls the territory. Since the State of Israel has sovereign control over Eilat, there is an argument that it is legally treated as part of Eretz Yisrael for these purposes — even if it's outside the biblical borders. The shiur works through the geographic, political, and halachic dimensions of this question.
A growing contemporary question: many diaspora Jews own apartments in Israel, visiting regularly but maintaining their primary lives elsewhere. Rabbi Lebowitz was motivated to address this by his own parents' situation — they purchased an apartment in Israel, "and that opened up a whole new series of shailos."
The fundamental question: does owning an apartment make one a ben Eretz Yisrael? The shiur builds on a teshuvah by Rav Asher Weiss (published in Yeshurun journal / Minchas Asher), who traces the question through a surprising source: the Teshuvos Maharit Tzalon (Siman 52), which discusses a man with two wives — one in Eretz Yisrael and one in chutz l'aretz — asking which Yom Tov schedule he follows. The answer: it depends on where his primary residence is.
The parallel: an apartment owner who visits Israel periodically but lives mainly in America has their primary residence in chutz l'aretz and remains a full ben chutz l'aretz. Ownership alone does not confer a change in status — it depends on where one genuinely lives.
The Rama in Yoreh De'ah 115:3 discusses how customs — including dairy-related practices — change when a person moves to a new community. Rabbi Yaacov Thaler's shiur applies this framework specifically to Yom Tov Sheini: when someone moves from Israel to the diaspora (or vice versa), at what point do their Yom Tov Sheini obligations change?
The Rama's principle is that one adopts stringencies of both the old and new location during the period of transition — which has significant implications for someone in the process of making aliyah or leaving Israel.
A Mila b'zmanah (on the eighth day) overrides Shabbat and Yom Tov. But what about mila shelo bizmana — a bris scheduled for after the eighth day due to illness or other delay — when it falls on Yom Tov Sheini?
A fundamental machlokes: The Rambam holds that mila shelo bizmana is docha Yom Tov Sheini (overrides it). The Rosh disagrees — it does not override Yom Tov Sheini. This is described in Rabbi Thaler's shiur as "a major-league machlokes Rambam-Rosh."
The underlying question reflects the fundamental debate about Yom Tov Sheini's status: if it is treated as a full rabbinic Yom Tov, then mila shelo bizmana — which does not override the Torah's own Yom Tov — should not override a rabbinic one either (Rosh). But the Rambam's view suggests Yom Tov Sheini has a softer status that a deferred mila can override.
A fascinating edge case: On Shavuos, the Magen Avraham rules that one must wait until tzeis hakochavim (nightfall) to make Kiddush, because the Torah requires temimos — seven complete weeks of Sefiras HaOmer. If Shavuos is accepted early, before the full seven weeks are technically complete, is the acceptance valid? And if someone accepts Yom Tov before nightfall, does this affect when Yom Tov Sheini begins?
The shiur explores how Tosefes Yom Tov — the voluntary extension of Yom Tov into the preceding night — interacts with the calendar-based structure of Yom Tov Sheini. If accepting Shabbos early makes a personal difference in when Shabbos "starts" for an individual, does the same mechanism apply to a communal or individual acceptance of Yom Tov on Shavuos?
The deeper issue is whether Yom Tov Sheini is purely calendar-determined (and thus cannot be shifted by personal acceptance) or whether there is an element of kabbalah that could affect its timing.
From the Talmudic period through contemporary poskim
The Sanhedrin codifies the mathematical calendar, eliminating uncertainty about Rosh Chodesh. The doubt that originally gave rise to Yom Tov Sheini is removed — yet the practice continues by rabbinic decree.
Medieval authorities debate whether Yom Tov Sheini is a Torah-level decree (d'oraisa), a full rabbinic law (d'rabbanan), or a mere custom (minhag). The Rashba, Ritva, and others explore the implications for travelers.
R. Tzvi Ashkenazi (Chacham Tzvi) rules that an Israeli visiting abroad need not keep Yom Tov Sheini, treating it as a localized minhag rather than a portable personal obligation. This becomes the touchstone of the lenient position.
The Peri Chadash, Nodah BiYehudah, Chasam Sofer, and R. Akiva Eiger generally reject the Chacham Tzvi's ruling for practical purposes, citing lo tisgodedu and the risk of public Chillul Yom Tov.
R. Yisrael Meir Kagan (Chofetz Chaim) codifies in Mishna Berura that visitors to Israel keep two days privately, and that Israelis abroad must also keep two days privately. He acknowledges the complexity and multiple opinions.
With millions of Israeli-born Jews traveling globally and millions of diaspora Jews visiting Israel, the theoretical question becomes intensely practical. Contemporary poskim including R. Ovadia Yosef, R. Shlomo Zalman Auerbach, and others develop detailed rulings for specific scenarios.
Selected moments from the transcripts — actual words from the shiurim
He's a legitimate Ben Eretz Yisrael — not one of these people that have been living in America for 15 years, but still talks on the phone on Yom Tov Sheini because they're talking in Hebrew.
Rabbi Aryeh Lebowitz, Ten Minute Halacha — A Ben Eretz Yisrael in Chutz L'Aretz
On the challenge of defining who truly qualifies as a Ben Eretz Yisrael with clear halachic implications
The whole plane was full of Jews from the Five Towns, from Teaneck, from Queens — who were in Eretz Yisrael and keep one day of Yom Tov in Eretz Yisrael and flew back on Yom Tov Sheni shel Galuyos because for them it wasn't Yom Tov.
Rabbi Aryeh Lebowitz, Ten Minute Halacha — Flying Back From Israel on Yom Tov Sheini
The real-world phenomenon that prompted the shiur on flying on Yom Tov Sheini
If you're a rav in a Yeshivish community, you will not get the shaila of Yom Tov Sheni. If you're a rav in a Chasidish community, you also won't get the shaila. But for some reason, if you're a rav in a modern type community, then you'll get the question.
RIETS Contemporary Halacha 5786 — Hilchos Yom Tov
On the sociological reality of which communities encounter Yom Tov Sheini debates
You should not be on a plane on Yom Tov. There's an obligation of v'samachta b'chagecha — to enjoy the chag. How are you enjoying the chag sitting on a plane? Even if you have a comfortable seat, more legroom — that's not simchat Yom Tov.
Unidentified — 'One Should Not Board an Airplane on Yom Tov Sheini'
The mashkafic argument against flying on Yom Tov Sheini, beyond the technical halachic debate
So we have a major-league machlokas Rambam-Rosh: is Mila Shelo Bizmana docha Yom Tov Sheni? The Rambam says yes, the Rosh says no.
Rabbi Yaacov Thaler, Yoreh De'ah 266:8 — Milah on Yom Tov Sheini
The fundamental dispute about the status of Yom Tov Sheini, revealed through the milah question
In Eretz Yisrael it takes one day — you get the feelings of the Yom Tov. In Chutz La'aretz, where Hashem's presence is further away, you need two days. After two days, now I'll feel Kabbalas HaTorah on Shavuos. Now I'll feel the cheirus of Pesach.
Unidentified — 'Understanding Yom Tov Sheini In Israel and Out'
A hashkafic approach to the spiritual meaning of needing two days of Yom Tov in the diaspora
17 shiurim from YUTorah · 1 duplicate removed · transcribed via Sofer.AI
Ten Minute Halacha · Beis Haknesses of North Woodmere
Young Israel of Woodmere · Stern College
YUTorah
RIETS · Yeshiva University
Cong. Adath Israel · Elizabeth, NJ
YUTorah · Young Israel of Woodmere
YUTorah · Yoreh De'ah Series
YUTorah · status of Eilat
YUTorah · comprehensive background shiur
YUTorah · 3-part series on amira l'Yisrael
YUTorah · 'Ashrei Raz Teshuvah of the Week'
This is a summary of positions discussed in the shiurim — not a personal psak halacha. Consult your rav.
| Scenario | Stringent View | Lenient View |
|---|---|---|
| Israeli visiting abroad | Keep 2 days (privately) | Keep 1 day |
| Diaspora Jew visiting Israel | Keep 2 days (privately) | Keep 1 day (adopt local) |
| Israeli asking about aliyah — visiting abroad | Keep 2 days | Intent to make aliyah → 1 day |
| Diaspora Jew flying out of Israel on YTS | Do not fly | Permitted (some conditions) |
| Asking an Israeli to do melacha on YTS | Forbidden (amirah l'Yisrael) | Permitted (he is not violating anything) |
| Visiting Eilat (from diaspora) | Keep 2 days (if outside borders) | Keep 1 day (part of Israel practically) |
SRT subtitle files generated by Sofer.AI — download and open in any media player or subtitle viewer
About This Page
This page was created by Matthew Miller as a study resource based on 17 shiurim sourced from YUTorah, transcribed using Sofer.AI (a specialized Jewish audio transcription service), and analyzed thematically. The shiurim were delivered by contemporary poskim including rabbis associated with Yeshiva University / RIETS, Young Israel of Woodmere, and independent educators. Speaker identifications were confirmed via YUTorah.org. This is a summary for educational purposes — all halachic questions should be directed to a qualified posek.