1
00:00:01,260 --> 00:00:02,759
You're gonna have to figure out, understand, and

2
00:00:02,759 --> 00:00:06,580
take positions on, either by going to a

3
00:00:06,580 --> 00:00:10,880
posek or by discussing it with the rav.

4
00:00:11,679 --> 00:00:12,699
So what are some of the things which

5
00:00:12,699 --> 00:00:14,679
come up that you just have to know?

6
00:00:15,460 --> 00:00:22,039
So let's start with preparing

7
00:00:22,039 --> 00:00:25,100
for Yom Tov. Even early, the same experience,

8
00:00:25,100 --> 00:00:27,800
once one starts learning the Halachos of the

9
00:00:27,800 --> 00:00:30,920
Yom Tov. So when it comes to Tishrei,

10
00:00:31,260 --> 00:00:34,520
I always start with Hilchos Sukkah because the

11
00:00:34,520 --> 00:00:38,269
seder of the shailas, you first get Hilchos

12
00:00:38,269 --> 00:00:42,240
Sukkah shailas. Right now, you already have the

13
00:00:42,240 --> 00:00:45,646
baalabatim are already thinking, Baruch Hashem mi keamcha

14
00:00:45,646 --> 00:00:47,479
Yisrael, so right now they're thinking about the

15
00:00:47,479 --> 00:00:50,920
pergola, pergola, I don't know how you pronounce

16
00:00:50,920 --> 00:00:53,170
it, so those are the shailas, and already

17
00:00:53,170 --> 00:00:56,619
had, and if you want to have a

18
00:00:56,619 --> 00:01:00,880
tree-free sukkah, so that's a shaila for Sukkos.

19
00:01:00,880 --> 00:01:01,899
You gotta get your tree cut it down,

20
00:01:02,000 --> 00:01:03,881
you can't wait till, wait till erev Yom

21
00:01:03,881 --> 00:01:06,359
Tov, then they know it's erev Yom Tov,

22
00:01:06,459 --> 00:01:07,519
they charge you much more. You have to

23
00:01:07,519 --> 00:01:09,680
get them now. And then if you want

24
00:01:09,680 --> 00:01:12,959
to have, two people are taking off their

25
00:01:12,959 --> 00:01:15,540
roofs off their porches, so they want to

26
00:01:15,540 --> 00:01:18,700
know what's left, have to make sekach. So

27
00:01:18,700 --> 00:01:20,939
I always start with Hilchos Sukkah because that's

28
00:01:20,939 --> 00:01:24,540
usually what comes first. The Hilchos of exactly

29
00:01:24,540 --> 00:01:28,560
how the tekiass sound, that comes usually a

30
00:01:28,620 --> 00:01:30,280
bit later, unless you have to train a

31
00:01:30,280 --> 00:01:34,200
new baal tokeia. So but the issues that

32
00:01:34,200 --> 00:01:38,560
I think, I think the issues that will

33
00:01:38,560 --> 00:01:43,620
come your way on a Yom Tov that

34
00:01:43,620 --> 00:01:47,480
you have to figure out are the issues

35
00:01:47,480 --> 00:01:49,379
of how to deal with some of the

36
00:01:49,379 --> 00:01:53,439
new stoves and the issue which comes up

37
00:01:54,960 --> 00:01:57,079
now that Baruch Hashem more and more people

38
00:01:57,079 --> 00:02:00,359
are in Eretz Yisrael and more and more

39
00:02:00,359 --> 00:02:06,500
people spend Yom Tov in Eretz Yisrael. So

40
00:02:06,500 --> 00:02:10,539
if you're a rav in a Yeshivish community,

41
00:02:10,539 --> 00:02:12,579
you will not get the shaila of Yom

42
00:02:12,579 --> 00:02:14,680
Tov Sheni. If you're a rav in a

43
00:02:14,680 --> 00:02:16,199
Chasidish community, you also won't get the shaila

44
00:02:16,319 --> 00:02:19,919
of Yom Tov Sheni. But for some reason,

45
00:02:19,919 --> 00:02:22,860
if you're a rav in a modern type

46
00:02:22,860 --> 00:02:27,439
community, then you'll get the question of keeping

47
00:02:27,439 --> 00:02:31,780
Yom Tov Sheni. So Yom Tov Sheni in

48
00:02:31,780 --> 00:02:35,030
Eretz Yisrael, person an American goes to Eretz

49
00:02:35,030 --> 00:02:39,004
Yisrael. So the Mishnah Berurah has a davar

50
00:02:39,004 --> 00:02:41,240
pashut ad meod that there is the Halacha

51
00:02:41,240 --> 00:02:44,259
of the when we go to different places,

52
00:02:44,280 --> 00:02:48,203
we keep the minhagim sheyatzu misham. So we

53
00:02:48,203 --> 00:02:50,067
go to Eretz Yisrael, we have a, we're

54
00:02:50,067 --> 00:02:53,560
Bnei Chutz L'aretz, so some will see it

55
00:02:53,560 --> 00:02:58,639
as a detriment of Chutz L'aretz, others see

56
00:02:58,639 --> 00:03:00,419
it as a gevaldige thing, you get two

57
00:03:00,419 --> 00:03:02,900
days of kedusha. However you look at it,

58
00:03:03,080 --> 00:03:05,819
but you come to Eretz Yisrael, you're a

59
00:03:05,819 --> 00:03:08,419
Chutznik, you have two days, kach hadin. And

60
00:03:08,419 --> 00:03:13,020
that is the position of all as far

61
00:03:13,020 --> 00:03:15,060
as I know of all the Gedolei HaPoskim,

62
00:03:16,260 --> 00:03:19,560
Rav Shlomo Zalman beshaato, Rav Elyashiv beshaato, even

63
00:03:19,560 --> 00:03:25,099
further back, Rav Tzvi Pesach. Rav Shlomo Gold,

64
00:03:26,040 --> 00:03:29,439
he wrote a biography, he wrote an autobiography,

65
00:03:30,120 --> 00:03:33,923
he was a rav in Toronto and then

66
00:03:33,923 --> 00:03:35,819
he went to Eretz Yisrael, so he wrote

67
00:03:35,819 --> 00:03:39,743
an autobiography. I was very interested because I

68
00:03:39,743 --> 00:03:41,479
know from when you're a kid you don't

69
00:03:42,120 --> 00:03:44,599
you hear all sorts of different things about

70
00:03:44,599 --> 00:03:48,560
the politics of the community, but you hear

71
00:03:48,560 --> 00:03:50,659
it as a kid. So when I grew

72
00:03:50,659 --> 00:03:52,623
up, I wanted to, I was very excited,

73
00:03:52,623 --> 00:03:54,280
now I'm going to figure out what were

74
00:03:54,280 --> 00:03:56,039
they talking about? What were some of the

75
00:03:56,039 --> 00:03:58,263
things going on behind the scenes? But it

76
00:03:58,263 --> 00:03:59,740
is he didn't write anything, he was such

77
00:03:59,740 --> 00:04:02,219
a sanitized version, I learned nothing of the,

78
00:04:03,219 --> 00:04:05,939
what I wanted to learn. But a lot

79
00:04:05,939 --> 00:04:08,259
of other things. So he writes there that

80
00:04:08,259 --> 00:04:11,659
when he was a, he was a talmid

81
00:04:11,659 --> 00:04:13,759
in Ponevezh when it wasn't people didn't go

82
00:04:13,759 --> 00:04:16,800
to Eretz Yisrael. But he was a talmid

83
00:04:16,800 --> 00:04:20,339
in Torah Vodaath and Ner Yisrael and then

84
00:04:20,339 --> 00:04:22,060
he went to Ponevezh, so he went to

85
00:04:22,060 --> 00:04:25,459
Rav Tzvi Pesach erev Yom Tov and Rav

86
00:04:25,459 --> 00:04:29,360
Tzvi Pesach, the way the conversation went, it

87
00:04:29,360 --> 00:04:32,139
was, does he even ask? Of course you

88
00:04:32,139 --> 00:04:33,819
have to keep two days Yom Tov. Rav

89
00:04:33,819 --> 00:04:37,007
Moshe, Rav Ovadia Yosef, all the Gedolei HaPoskim,

90
00:04:37,007 --> 00:04:40,079
don't have any shaila. And that's what I

91
00:04:40,079 --> 00:04:43,003
said, that in the Yeshivish community and Chasidish

92
00:04:43,003 --> 00:04:46,063
community, it's a davar pashut. We know it's

93
00:04:46,063 --> 00:04:47,480
a davar pashut they have to keep two

94
00:04:47,480 --> 00:04:50,446
days because the Beis Yosef in his Tshuvos

95
00:04:50,446 --> 00:04:54,220
Avkas Rochel, so he says he doesn't understand

96
00:04:54,699 --> 00:04:56,839
how the Chutznikim can have their own minyanim,

97
00:04:57,399 --> 00:04:59,240
he thinks it's a violation of lo tisgodedu.

98
00:05:00,079 --> 00:05:03,579
He didn't wonder why they're davening Yom Tov

99
00:05:03,579 --> 00:05:05,201
on the second day. That was a davar

100
00:05:05,201 --> 00:05:07,639
pashut to daven Yom Tov. But he was

101
00:05:07,639 --> 00:05:10,839
surprised that what's the heter. We have now

102
00:05:10,839 --> 00:05:14,490
teshuvos from the Teshuvos haGeonim that in Teshuvos

103
00:05:14,490 --> 00:05:16,779
haGeonim so Jews would go from Bavel to

104
00:05:16,779 --> 00:05:19,480
Eretz Yisrael and they kept two days in

105
00:05:19,480 --> 00:05:23,540
Eretz Yisrael. So what was the, why is

106
00:05:23,540 --> 00:05:26,120
it even a question? So there are three

107
00:05:26,120 --> 00:05:32,199
sources, the three meshivim. First was the

108
00:05:32,199 --> 00:05:38,279
Chacham Tzvi. Even before the Shaarei Teshuva writes

109
00:05:41,560 --> 00:05:45,139
that Bnei Yeshiva that went to Eretz Yisrael

110
00:05:45,759 --> 00:05:48,120
so they would keep one day Yom Tov.

111
00:05:48,660 --> 00:05:51,447
Somebody told me that years ago a talmid

112
00:05:51,447 --> 00:05:56,100
of Rav Amital asked him, so Rav Amital

113
00:05:56,100 --> 00:05:59,399
said that the minhag in Yerushalayim is that

114
00:05:59,519 --> 00:06:03,540
Bnei Yeshivas keep only one day. So the

115
00:06:03,540 --> 00:06:05,379
Shaarei Teshuva quotes that and then the Shaarei

116
00:06:05,379 --> 00:06:07,759
Teshuva quotes three or four other sefarim that

117
00:06:07,759 --> 00:06:11,620
say otherwise. So the only ha'arah on that

118
00:06:11,620 --> 00:06:14,060
is, it is that some question that there

119
00:06:14,060 --> 00:06:18,180
was a bona fide opinion that Bnei Yeshiva

120
00:06:18,180 --> 00:06:24,220
keep one day Yom Tov. But

121
00:06:24,220 --> 00:06:27,740
l'aniyus da'ati those were Bnei Yeshiva that they

122
00:06:27,740 --> 00:06:31,779
came and didn't have a return ticket in

123
00:06:31,779 --> 00:06:34,240
their pocket. They came with a one-way ticket

124
00:06:34,240 --> 00:06:37,100
and then when it was time to head

125
00:06:37,100 --> 00:06:39,339
back if they're going to head back and

126
00:06:39,339 --> 00:06:41,939
they didn't get married, if they didn't stay

127
00:06:42,139 --> 00:06:47,620
in Eretz Yisrael so then. But nowadays Baruch

128
00:06:47,620 --> 00:06:49,439
Hashem when we send the kid off to

129
00:06:49,439 --> 00:06:51,420
yeshiva first of all he has at least

130
00:06:51,420 --> 00:06:56,600
one return ticket. And then if his sister-in-law's

131
00:06:56,600 --> 00:07:00,899
going to have a l'chaim because she gets

132
00:07:00,899 --> 00:07:03,463
engaged he's also on the next plane back,

133
00:07:03,463 --> 00:07:05,819
right? And then if his parents are going

134
00:07:05,819 --> 00:07:07,120
to get honored at the local shul he's

135
00:07:07,120 --> 00:07:10,959
also on the next plane back. So the,

136
00:07:11,759 --> 00:07:13,920
I would say that that's a different metzius

137
00:07:16,340 --> 00:07:20,620
than the time of when Rav Amital issued

138
00:07:20,620 --> 00:07:23,300
his position and when he referred to the

139
00:07:23,300 --> 00:07:27,420
minhag yeshiva Bnei Yeshiva. That's l'aniyus da'ati. But

140
00:07:27,420 --> 00:07:34,300
the first of the great sefarim that

141
00:07:34,939 --> 00:07:38,419
was moreh otherwise was the Chacham Tzvi. Chacham

142
00:07:38,419 --> 00:07:42,420
Tzvi has a mechudash'dike approach. He says that

143
00:07:42,699 --> 00:07:47,379
when do we say that a person is

144
00:07:48,039 --> 00:07:53,160
noheig k'chumras sheyatza misham? So that's when if

145
00:07:53,160 --> 00:07:55,139
they would end up staying they would be

146
00:07:55,139 --> 00:07:58,740
allowed to keep that hanhaga, that practice. But

147
00:07:58,740 --> 00:08:03,680
if when they would end up staying they

148
00:08:03,680 --> 00:08:05,500
would not be allowed to keep that practice

149
00:08:05,500 --> 00:08:11,120
so then even before they decide to stay

150
00:08:11,640 --> 00:08:14,579
they cannot maintain their practice. So here he

151
00:08:14,579 --> 00:08:19,040
says a Jew comes from Chutz La'aretz and

152
00:08:19,040 --> 00:08:21,439
let's say he decides to stay, he's making

153
00:08:21,439 --> 00:08:23,620
aliyah and then he would keep second day

154
00:08:23,620 --> 00:08:27,100
Yom Tov, he over Bal Tosif. Right? An

155
00:08:27,100 --> 00:08:29,759
Eretz Yisroeldiker who wants to keep a second

156
00:08:29,759 --> 00:08:32,620
day, he wants to sit in the Sukkah

157
00:08:32,620 --> 00:08:35,946
on Shmini Atzeres, it's a machlokes between Rav

158
00:08:35,946 --> 00:08:39,120
Shlomo Zalman and Rav Elyashiv when an American

159
00:08:39,120 --> 00:08:44,820
Jew is visiting Eretz Yisrael whether he's allowed

160
00:08:44,820 --> 00:08:46,870
to sit in the Sukkah Shmini Atzeres. Rav

161
00:08:46,870 --> 00:08:48,539
Elyashiv says of course he can sit in

162
00:08:48,539 --> 00:08:51,539
the Sukkah, not Bal Tosif, he's an American,

163
00:08:51,679 --> 00:08:53,413
he takes second day Yom Tov. Rav Shlomo

164
00:08:53,413 --> 00:08:55,159
Zalman said he's an American Jew keep second

165
00:08:55,159 --> 00:08:58,539
day Yom Tov, but he can't sit in

166
00:08:58,539 --> 00:08:59,740
the Sukkah because sitting in the Sukkah is

167
00:08:59,740 --> 00:09:03,980
Bal Tosif. So the Chacham Tzvi took the

168
00:09:03,980 --> 00:09:09,139
approach that hoyil that if I would end

169
00:09:09,139 --> 00:09:13,980
up staying so then I'm obligated to keep

170
00:09:13,980 --> 00:09:18,259
the chumras hamakom sheyatza misham, that's correct, but

171
00:09:18,259 --> 00:09:20,220
if I end up staying I couldn't keep

172
00:09:20,220 --> 00:09:23,419
the chumra sheyatza misham, it'd be assur. So

173
00:09:23,419 --> 00:09:27,279
therefore even b'sha'as that I'm not living there,

174
00:09:27,279 --> 00:09:29,939
so the din of keeping the chumra sheyatza

175
00:09:29,939 --> 00:09:33,320
misham doesn't apply. So that's the mechudash'dike mehalech

176
00:09:33,320 --> 00:09:37,279
of the Chacham Tzvi. One can understand there's

177
00:09:37,279 --> 00:09:41,720
a distinction, to understand why the distinction should

178
00:09:42,700 --> 00:09:46,580
make a compelling difference l'maiseh I don't understand.

179
00:09:49,199 --> 00:09:52,279
And I guess if a person follows all

180
00:09:52,279 --> 00:09:55,549
the hanhagos of the Chacham Tzvi then he'd

181
00:09:55,549 --> 00:09:56,490
be a candidate, he could follow this as

182
00:09:56,490 --> 00:10:10,090
well. Although Rav Ovadia Yosef is very progeny

183
00:10:10,090 --> 00:10:12,649
were not mekabel his position. Rav Yaakov Emden

184
00:10:12,649 --> 00:10:14,889
was not mekabel the position. So you see

185
00:10:14,889 --> 00:10:18,509
that it wasn't mekubal even the family wasn't

186
00:10:18,509 --> 00:10:23,029
mekabel. So then lechoreh and what we don't

187
00:10:23,029 --> 00:10:26,389
understand the Chacham Tzvi is that it's true

188
00:10:26,389 --> 00:10:28,730
that if a person would sit in the

189
00:10:28,730 --> 00:10:31,091
Sukkah on Shmini Atzeres he'd be over Bal

190
00:10:31,091 --> 00:10:33,250
Tosef. But if he would relax and not

191
00:10:33,250 --> 00:10:35,690
do Melacha is there Bal Tosef over there?

192
00:10:36,090 --> 00:10:37,570
Why would there be Bal Tosef in thing

193
00:10:37,570 --> 00:10:43,049
Melacha? So on the issur Melacha even I

194
00:10:43,049 --> 00:10:45,269
can't say, I don't think the Chacham Tzvi

195
00:10:45,269 --> 00:10:48,490
spells it out, but af hasvarah hard to

196
00:10:48,490 --> 00:10:52,429
apply the Chacham Tzvi svara to the inyan

197
00:10:52,429 --> 00:10:56,750
of Melacha. Then the Alter Rebbe, Alter Rebbe

198
00:10:56,750 --> 00:11:00,330
has a mechudashdik approach that Yom Tov Sheini

199
00:11:00,330 --> 00:11:03,929
is not doesn't attach itself to the person

200
00:11:04,370 --> 00:11:06,529
but it attaches itself to the place. It's

201
00:11:06,529 --> 00:11:09,200
a geographical bin. And if you're in Eretz

202
00:11:09,200 --> 00:11:11,470
Yisroel so then it's one day Yom Tov.

203
00:11:11,669 --> 00:11:13,129
If you're in Chutz La'aretz it's two days

204
00:11:13,129 --> 00:11:16,029
Yom Tov. And if I understood the Alter

205
00:11:16,029 --> 00:11:19,549
Rebbe correctly it has to do with the

206
00:11:19,549 --> 00:11:22,409
hashpa'os and the oros of the Yom Tov.

207
00:11:22,649 --> 00:11:24,710
That in Eretz Yisroel the oros of the

208
00:11:24,710 --> 00:11:26,830
Yom Tov are so strong and so powerful

209
00:11:26,830 --> 00:11:30,149
and compelling that once when they've spent one

210
00:11:30,149 --> 00:11:32,950
day of a Yom Tov in Eretz Yisroel

211
00:11:33,409 --> 00:11:36,149
so then all the hashpa'os that are supposed

212
00:11:36,149 --> 00:11:38,789
to happen have happened. In Chutz La'aretz the

213
00:11:38,789 --> 00:11:41,470
hashpa'os and the oros are somewhat different. And

214
00:11:41,470 --> 00:11:43,750
you can't compare the oros of Pesach in

215
00:11:43,750 --> 00:11:45,029
Eretz Yisroel the oros of Pesach Chutz La'aretz.

216
00:11:45,090 --> 00:11:46,450
Of course you can't compare them, we know

217
00:11:46,450 --> 00:11:49,460
that there's a Medrash that says Havu Atzivnu

218
00:11:49,460 --> 00:11:53,330
Lacha Tziyunim that the mitzvos in Eretz Yisroel

219
00:11:53,910 --> 00:11:57,049
are there the mitzvos in Chutz La'aretz the

220
00:11:57,590 --> 00:12:00,450
Medrash, a peledike Medrash, Rashi, Ramban both quote

221
00:12:00,450 --> 00:12:02,450
it, that in order that we get back

222
00:12:02,450 --> 00:12:03,889
to Eretz Yisroel to keep all the mitzvos.

223
00:12:04,370 --> 00:12:06,830
So exactly what it means we don't know

224
00:12:06,830 --> 00:12:10,070
but it means something along the lines that

225
00:12:10,070 --> 00:12:12,870
the mitzvos in Eretz Yisroel every mitzvah in

226
00:12:12,870 --> 00:12:15,330
Eretz Yisroel that the hashpa'os and the oros

227
00:12:15,330 --> 00:12:18,269
of the mitzvah are overwhelming and there and

228
00:12:18,269 --> 00:12:22,210
the hashpao of the same mitzvah will be

229
00:12:22,210 --> 00:12:24,769
different in Chutz La'aretz. Something along those lines.

230
00:12:25,269 --> 00:12:26,870
So the Alter Rebbe said so you want

231
00:12:26,870 --> 00:12:29,473
to get the hashpa'os of Pesach in Chutz

232
00:12:29,473 --> 00:12:30,970
La'aretz you're going to need a two days.

233
00:12:32,570 --> 00:12:35,190
So again I believe it's the Alter Rebbe

234
00:12:35,190 --> 00:12:38,289
I assume that Chabad that all Chabad Shluchim

235
00:12:38,289 --> 00:12:40,937
follow this and I assume and inna hachi

236
00:12:40,937 --> 00:12:44,570
nami if a person follows the Alter Rebbe

237
00:12:44,570 --> 00:12:47,549
in all hanhagos so then ya'aleh lo then

238
00:12:47,549 --> 00:12:49,610
he has to follow this as well lechoreh.

239
00:12:49,610 --> 00:12:53,929
Doesn't have to but probably that's appropriate. And

240
00:12:53,929 --> 00:12:57,990
then the third was Rav Shmuel Salant who

241
00:12:57,990 --> 00:13:04,236
raised it in a speculative fashion and Rav

242
00:13:04,236 --> 00:13:08,950
Shmuel Salant approach Rav Shmuel Salant was the

243
00:13:08,950 --> 00:13:13,230
sgan no he was the Rav HaRashi of

244
00:13:13,230 --> 00:13:15,850
Yerushalayim at the turn of the previous century.

245
00:13:17,629 --> 00:13:21,350
And one of the one of the gedolei

246
00:13:21,350 --> 00:13:26,470
haolam at that point. The Aderes became went

247
00:13:26,470 --> 00:13:28,796
to Yerushalayim to become the assistant to Rav

248
00:13:28,796 --> 00:13:30,330
Shmuel Salant but I think Rav Shmuel Salant

249
00:13:30,330 --> 00:13:35,250
outlived the Aderes. The senior rabbi outlived the

250
00:13:35,250 --> 00:13:39,769
assistant rabbi. So the so Rav Shmuel Salant

251
00:13:40,769 --> 00:13:46,850
is quoted as saying in the footnotes of

252
00:13:46,850 --> 00:13:49,293
the Luach in Eretz Yisroel so the Luach

253
00:13:49,293 --> 00:13:53,029
in Eretz Yisroel was put together primarily by

254
00:13:53,029 --> 00:13:55,710
Rav Yechiel Michel Tukachinsky. The Luach in America

255
00:13:55,710 --> 00:13:59,409
was put together primarily by Rav Henkin. And

256
00:13:59,409 --> 00:14:04,490
then it was upgraded by Rav Margolis and

257
00:14:04,490 --> 00:14:08,519
upgraded by Rav Henkin son together with Rav

258
00:14:08,519 --> 00:14:10,929
Riff who was the son-in-law. Rav Henkin was

259
00:14:10,929 --> 00:14:15,789
one of the ziknei gedolei haposkim besha'ato so

260
00:14:15,789 --> 00:14:17,990
there was amongst the rabbanim in America so

261
00:14:17,990 --> 00:14:20,669
some would bring their shailos to Rav Moshe

262
00:14:20,669 --> 00:14:22,789
and some would bring their shailos to Rav

263
00:14:22,789 --> 00:14:29,190
Henkin. And then Rav Moshe

264
00:14:30,750 --> 00:14:34,769
lived after Rav Henkin. Our Rav Henkin established

265
00:14:35,410 --> 00:14:38,909
a lot of protocols in America. All of

266
00:14:38,909 --> 00:14:41,690
the sheimos how to how to write Harry

267
00:14:41,690 --> 00:14:43,909
in a get how to write Edward in

268
00:14:43,909 --> 00:14:46,740
a get how to write Mary Aleph. Rav

269
00:14:46,740 --> 00:14:49,029
Henkin was one who came from Europe and

270
00:14:49,029 --> 00:14:50,909
he sat down he was a rav in

271
00:14:50,909 --> 00:14:52,669
Europe and a rav over here Lower East

272
00:14:52,669 --> 00:14:57,049
Side and he established protocols for ksivas hagittin

273
00:14:57,049 --> 00:15:00,789
and he created the transliteration. between Hebrew and

274
00:15:00,789 --> 00:15:03,629
English and then it's been tweaked, but the

275
00:15:03,629 --> 00:15:06,433
yesodos are still from Rav Henkin. And the

276
00:15:06,433 --> 00:15:11,149
Mesadri Gittin all came to Rav Henkin for

277
00:15:11,149 --> 00:15:14,269
questions about how to spell. He came to

278
00:15:14,409 --> 00:15:16,669
Rav Moshe also, he chose Rav Moshe also.

279
00:15:16,929 --> 00:15:21,596
And then Rav Henkin also was omed al

280
00:15:21,596 --> 00:15:25,370
hamishmar many many things and he was a

281
00:15:25,370 --> 00:15:29,710
one-man Torah observer to give hora'os to schools

282
00:15:29,710 --> 00:15:33,230
and hora'os to communities. So the Luach was

283
00:15:33,230 --> 00:15:38,409
primarily Rav Henkin's project and Rav Henkin was...

284
00:15:38,409 --> 00:15:41,669
his parnassah came from Ezras Torah. He ran

285
00:15:41,669 --> 00:15:44,970
Ezras Torah. That was the... he ran the

286
00:15:44,970 --> 00:15:52,309
funding for the Talmidei Chachamim survivors who didn't

287
00:15:52,309 --> 00:15:57,769
have means to support themselves. And Rav Henkin

288
00:15:58,970 --> 00:16:01,710
when he... he was answering shailos all the

289
00:16:01,710 --> 00:16:04,809
time but he held that he was being

290
00:16:04,809 --> 00:16:07,070
supported by... he had a job to be

291
00:16:07,070 --> 00:16:10,710
the maskir for Ezras Torah. So whenever he

292
00:16:10,710 --> 00:16:14,450
would answer a phone call, he would he

293
00:16:14,450 --> 00:16:15,809
would make a note of it so he

294
00:16:15,809 --> 00:16:17,269
could make up the time to Ezras Torah.

295
00:16:17,269 --> 00:16:18,970
And they found a notebook in his desk

296
00:16:19,389 --> 00:16:20,830
where he had all the times he had

297
00:16:20,830 --> 00:16:23,830
to make up Ezras Torah because his poskening

298
00:16:23,830 --> 00:16:26,350
shailos for America wasn't an Ezras Torah job.

299
00:16:27,689 --> 00:16:31,830
So he writes, so that's the American Luach.

300
00:16:31,830 --> 00:16:34,473
So the Luach in Eretz Yisrael was Rav

301
00:16:36,450 --> 00:16:39,769
Michal Tucazinsky. Rav Rav Michal Tucazinsky was one

302
00:16:39,769 --> 00:16:45,350
of the Gedolei Yerushalayim and he was also

303
00:16:45,350 --> 00:16:50,230
a phenomenal person. He was that knowledgeable about

304
00:16:51,930 --> 00:16:55,350
astronomy that he became a member of the

305
00:16:55,350 --> 00:16:59,830
Royal Astronomers of London. And so he had

306
00:16:59,830 --> 00:17:04,069
a phenomenal set yedi'os. And Rav Michal Tucazinsky

307
00:17:04,069 --> 00:17:07,349
is, he wrote the guide for Avelos, Gesher

308
00:17:07,349 --> 00:17:12,390
HaChayim. Gesher HaChayim was like the, was the

309
00:17:12,390 --> 00:17:14,750
first as far as I know the first

310
00:17:15,529 --> 00:17:20,950
sefer that brought together halachos of Avelos in

311
00:17:20,950 --> 00:17:23,009
a how-to and a manual form. All the

312
00:17:23,009 --> 00:17:26,250
seforim we have nowadays on Avelos, they all

313
00:17:26,250 --> 00:17:28,589
start with the Gesher HaChayim. And then now

314
00:17:28,589 --> 00:17:31,849
some would disagree but every sefer the Gesher

315
00:17:31,849 --> 00:17:35,630
HaChayim was the code, was the gold, what's

316
00:17:35,630 --> 00:17:38,509
it called, the gold bar of Hilchos Avelos,

317
00:17:38,509 --> 00:17:40,869
was that the gold standard of Hilchos Avelos

318
00:17:40,869 --> 00:17:43,890
till many other seforim came out. But the...

319
00:17:45,029 --> 00:17:47,430
that's the Gesher HaChayim that's known to most

320
00:17:47,430 --> 00:17:50,630
people. And then he wrote the Luach and

321
00:17:50,630 --> 00:17:52,230
then he has and then he wrote a

322
00:17:52,230 --> 00:17:55,549
sefer called Sefer Ir HaKodesh. I think it

323
00:17:55,549 --> 00:17:57,329
was primarily put together by his son Rav

324
00:17:57,329 --> 00:18:00,150
Nissan from his notes I think. And that's

325
00:18:00,789 --> 00:18:05,589
hilchos hamitzvos hatluyos ba'aretz and hilchos Yerushalayim and

326
00:18:06,890 --> 00:18:11,329
hilchos Beis Hamikdash. So there he also wrote

327
00:18:11,329 --> 00:18:15,309
the he'aros to his Luach. So there he

328
00:18:15,309 --> 00:18:18,730
has it, Rav Shmuel Salant wrote that he

329
00:18:18,730 --> 00:18:21,440
thinks that when a chutznik coming to Eretz

330
00:18:21,440 --> 00:18:25,309
Yisrael should be careful not to say, not

331
00:18:25,309 --> 00:18:28,796
to davven shel chol but should davven shel

332
00:18:28,796 --> 00:18:31,269
Eretz Yisrael. And to be careful not to

333
00:18:31,269 --> 00:18:36,743
make the brachos that belong to Yom Tov

334
00:18:36,743 --> 00:18:40,089
Sheni. Should do, he has to do melachos

335
00:18:40,089 --> 00:18:42,910
and has to do the mitzvos but he

336
00:18:42,910 --> 00:18:44,829
should be careful not to make the brachos

337
00:18:44,829 --> 00:18:48,230
which introduced a certain safeik in the Yom

338
00:18:48,230 --> 00:18:50,589
Tov Sheni in Eretz Yisrael. So he has

339
00:18:50,589 --> 00:18:54,710
a detailed approach of how a chutznik davvens

340
00:18:54,710 --> 00:18:57,210
and how he says brachos. And he writes

341
00:18:57,210 --> 00:18:59,633
at the end that if the other Gedolei

342
00:18:59,633 --> 00:19:02,990
Hador would mekabbel this hora'ah then people should

343
00:19:02,990 --> 00:19:06,109
keep it. And the assumption is but they

344
00:19:06,109 --> 00:19:10,349
weren't mekabbel so then they shouldn't follow. Exactly

345
00:19:10,349 --> 00:19:11,491
where was Rav Shmuel Salant coming from? So

346
00:19:11,491 --> 00:19:12,319
here's the mahalach of Rav Shmuel Salant which

347
00:19:12,319 --> 00:19:18,393
Rav Chaim also apparently taught,

348
00:19:18,393 --> 00:19:20,670
he heard this from the Rav And that

349
00:19:20,670 --> 00:19:23,910
is that when the Gemara says in Beitzah,

350
00:19:25,190 --> 00:19:28,440
shilchu misam, they sent from Bavel to Eretz

351
00:19:28,440 --> 00:19:31,549
Yisrael nowadays that we know that we are

352
00:19:31,549 --> 00:19:37,589
baki, we are baki now in

353
00:19:37,589 --> 00:19:41,369
the establishing the calendar that we no longer

354
00:19:41,369 --> 00:19:42,767
have to worry about the shluchim coming, bekiei

355
00:19:42,767 --> 00:19:43,596
b'kavia d'yarcha... could we go down to one

356
00:19:43,596 --> 00:19:44,424
day? So shilchu misam, hizaharu beminhag avoseichem beyadeichem,

357
00:19:44,424 --> 00:19:45,253
keep the old minhag, shema yachzeir hakilkul. So

358
00:19:45,253 --> 00:19:46,081
the way they wrote... We would expect shema

359
00:19:46,081 --> 00:19:46,910
yachzor kilkul. We would expect keep two days

360
00:19:46,910 --> 00:19:47,738
Yom Tov. The lashon of hizaharu beminhag avoseichem

361
00:19:47,738 --> 00:19:48,567
beyadeichem, keep the old minhag, that would raise

362
00:19:48,567 --> 00:19:49,395
the question of what was the old minhag

363
00:19:49,395 --> 00:19:50,224
when a chutznik came to Eretz Yisroel. Right,

364
00:19:50,224 --> 00:19:51,052
a person from Bavel came to Eretz Yisroel

365
00:19:51,052 --> 00:19:51,880
at the time of when they would send

366
00:19:51,880 --> 00:19:52,709
out shluchim. So if he stayed and his

367
00:19:52,709 --> 00:19:53,537
family in Bavel was keeping two days because

368
00:19:53,537 --> 00:19:54,366
the shluchim didn't get there, but he's in

369
00:19:54,366 --> 00:19:55,194
Eretz Yisroel, so the shluchim he knows what

370
00:19:55,194 --> 00:19:56,023
the shluchim are saying. So Rav Chaim had

371
00:19:56,023 --> 00:19:56,851
understood that when a chutznik came to Eretz

372
00:19:56,851 --> 00:19:57,680
Yisroel at the time of Kiddush haChodesh before

373
00:19:57,680 --> 00:19:58,508
it became a takana minhag, when it was

374
00:19:58,508 --> 00:19:59,337
a response to not knowing what the shluchim

375
00:19:59,337 --> 00:20:00,165
were going to tell you, but if you're

376
00:20:00,165 --> 00:20:00,994
in Eretz Yisroel, you know, so you only

377
00:20:00,994 --> 00:20:01,822
kept the one day. So Rav Chaim said

378
00:20:01,822 --> 00:20:02,651
the lashon of hizaharu beminhag avoseichem beyadeichem raises

379
00:20:02,651 --> 00:20:03,479
the question of whether a person from chutz

380
00:20:03,479 --> 00:20:04,307
la’aretz had come to Eretz Yisroel he should

381
00:20:04,307 --> 00:20:05,136
keep that old minhag. The old minhag was

382
00:20:05,136 --> 00:20:05,964
when he came to Eretz Yisroel he only

383
00:20:05,964 --> 00:20:06,793
kept one day. So when the Rav. presented

384
00:20:06,793 --> 00:20:07,621
Rav Chaim's he'ara it was a safek. It

385
00:20:07,621 --> 00:20:08,450
was a chumra. It wasn't Rav Chaim was

386
00:20:08,450 --> 00:20:09,278
not saying a person should only keep one

387
00:20:09,278 --> 00:20:10,107
day. Rav Chaim was saying heyos that the

388
00:20:10,107 --> 00:20:10,935
lashon is an interesting lashon, heyos that I

389
00:20:10,935 --> 00:20:11,764
have this safek. So then I don't know

390
00:20:11,764 --> 00:20:12,592
if Rav Chaim said this or the Rav

391
00:20:12,592 --> 00:20:13,421
said it because of Rav Chaim's he'ara, but

392
00:20:13,421 --> 00:20:14,249
basically it came out to something along the

393
00:20:14,249 --> 00:20:15,078
lines of Rav Moshe Soloveitchik. But the Rav

394
00:20:15,078 --> 00:20:15,906
said that maybe one should put on tefillin

395
00:20:15,906 --> 00:20:16,734
on the last day of Simchas Torah and

396
00:20:16,734 --> 00:20:17,563
the last day of Yom Tov and the

397
00:20:17,563 --> 00:20:18,391
last day of Pesach. Maybe if one puts

398
00:20:18,391 --> 00:20:19,220
on tefillin during Chol haMoed one should put

399
00:20:19,220 --> 00:20:20,048
on tefillin without a bracha on the second

400
00:20:20,048 --> 00:20:20,877
day Yom Tov. And that I know he

401
00:20:20,877 --> 00:20:21,705
was moreh hora'ah sometimes that if a person

402
00:20:21,705 --> 00:20:22,534
went to Eretz Yisroel for Yom Tov, if

403
00:20:22,534 --> 00:20:23,362
they asked the Rav he would say to

404
00:20:23,362 --> 00:20:24,191
put on tefillin on the last day of

405
00:20:24,191 --> 00:20:25,019
Yom Tov privately obviously without a bracha. The

406
00:20:25,019 --> 00:20:25,848
more intricate hora'os like Rav Moshe Soloveitchik I

407
00:20:25,848 --> 00:20:26,676
don't know. I remember the Rav discussing it

408
00:20:26,676 --> 00:20:27,505
in shiur. But lema'aseh the Rav Moshe Soloveitchik's

409
00:20:27,505 --> 00:20:28,333
hora'os and the chashash for Rav Chaim's safek

410
00:20:28,333 --> 00:20:29,161
had not become well practiced. And when I

411
00:20:29,161 --> 00:20:29,990
was younger and more courageous so people asked

412
00:20:29,990 --> 00:20:30,818
me and if I thought a person was

413
00:20:30,818 --> 00:20:31,647
holding so I would suggest this approach until

414
00:20:31,647 --> 00:20:32,475
somebody came back from Eretz Yisroel who was

415
00:20:32,475 --> 00:20:33,304
a serious serious Jew and said that Rebbi

416
00:20:33,304 --> 00:20:34,132
it's you called it a day and a

417
00:20:34,132 --> 00:20:34,961
half, it's not, it's twenty-two and a half

418
00:20:34,961 --> 00:20:35,789
days. He said it was very very hard.

419
00:20:35,789 --> 00:20:36,618
I mean finding somebody who was going to

420
00:20:36,618 --> 00:20:37,446
make the bracha of borei pri hagafen for

421
00:20:37,446 --> 00:20:38,275
the second time during the Seder and finding

422
00:20:38,275 --> 00:20:39,103
somebody who's going to make a bracha of

423
00:20:39,103 --> 00:20:39,932
achilas matzah and then HaMotzi. So when this

424
00:20:39,932 --> 00:20:40,760
serious Jew said it was so difficult I

425
00:20:40,760 --> 00:20:41,588
said okay, why should I be a yotze

426
00:20:41,588 --> 00:20:42,417
min haklal? All the gedolei olam said it's

427
00:20:42,417 --> 00:20:43,245
two days, bring the two days with the

428
00:20:43,245 --> 00:20:44,074
brachos of two days with the davening of

429
00:20:44,074 --> 00:20:44,902
two days. Rav Moshe Soloveitchik though wasn't accepted.

430
00:20:44,902 --> 00:20:45,731
I don't know how much the Rav said

431
00:20:45,731 --> 00:20:46,559
it lema'aseh. So, but there's because of the

432
00:20:46,559 --> 00:20:47,388
misunderstanding what the Rav was saying so that

433
00:20:47,388 --> 00:20:48,216
generated an approach in some of our circles

434
00:20:48,216 --> 00:20:49,045
that a person when they go to Eretz,

435
00:20:49,045 --> 00:20:49,873
then American living in Eretz Yisroel, American going

436
00:20:49,873 --> 00:20:50,702
to Eretz Yisroel should keep only one day.

437
00:20:50,702 --> 00:20:51,530
So that's a misunderstanding. The Rav did not

438
00:20:51,530 --> 00:20:52,359
say that, that was not what I was

439
00:20:52,359 --> 00:20:53,187
in shiur. The Rav was pointing out that

440
00:20:53,187 --> 00:20:54,015
Rav Chaim, was machmir, was machmir that on

441
00:20:54,015 --> 00:20:54,844
the second day Yom Tov when a Jew

442
00:20:54,844 --> 00:20:55,672
from America comes to Eretz Yisroel he should

443
00:20:55,672 --> 00:20:56,501
be concerned about the mitzvah d’Oraita of tefillin,

444
00:20:56,501 --> 00:20:57,329
he should be concerned about the issur d’Oraita

445
00:20:57,329 --> 00:20:58,158
of being mazkir shem shamayim levatala. It was

446
00:20:58,158 --> 00:20:58,986
all mitoch chumra and pachad not mitoch being

447
00:20:58,986 --> 00:20:59,815
mekel on anything. That approach though it seems

448
00:20:59,815 --> 00:21:00,643
to me has become misunderstood and and and

449
00:21:00,643 --> 00:21:01,472
and has bred many many people who come

450
00:21:01,472 --> 00:21:02,300
to Eretz Yisroel and they live in America.

451
00:21:02,300 --> 00:21:03,129
There are hora'os lekula, for example Rav Shlomo

452
00:21:03,129 --> 00:21:03,957
Zalman said of a person, I was told

453
00:21:03,957 --> 00:21:04,785
that he said of a person. So Shlomo

454
00:21:04,785 --> 00:21:05,614
Zalman's mahalach as explained to me is that

455
00:21:05,614 --> 00:21:06,442
he's an Eretz Yisrael guy if you're there

456
00:21:06,442 --> 00:21:07,271
for Yom Tov. He has two homes. He's

457
00:21:07,271 --> 00:21:08,099
a ben Chutz La'aretz and he's a ben

458
00:21:08,099 --> 00:21:08,928
Eretz Yisrael for Yom Tov. So that's a

459
00:21:08,928 --> 00:21:09,756
big chiddush to say such a thing. That

460
00:21:09,756 --> 00:21:10,585
there is such a thing. It's not a

461
00:21:10,585 --> 00:21:11,413
deah peshutah. But Shlomo Zalman is ashlei ravrevei.

462
00:21:11,413 --> 00:21:12,242
When I asked Rav Schachter what is the

463
00:21:12,242 --> 00:21:13,070
tipping point, so he said a rov, a

464
00:21:13,070 --> 00:21:13,899
person in Eretz Yisrael for more than six

465
00:21:13,899 --> 00:21:14,727
months. So then they're an Eretz Yisrael-diker. Less

466
00:21:14,727 --> 00:21:15,556
than six months, they're a Chutznik. Right. And

467
00:21:15,556 --> 00:21:16,384
for tax reasons people know exactly how many

468
00:21:16,384 --> 00:21:17,212
days they're Eretz Yisrael or Chutz La'aretz, so

469
00:21:17,212 --> 00:21:18,041
they keep a close cheshbon. So but again,

470
00:21:18,041 --> 00:21:18,869
Shlomo Zalman is ashlei ravrevei. A person exactly

471
00:21:18,869 --> 00:21:19,698
what he meant I don't know. Does he

472
00:21:19,698 --> 00:21:20,526
mean every Yom Tov? Does he mean davka

473
00:21:20,526 --> 00:21:21,355
the Regalim? Does he mean that the first

474
00:21:21,355 --> 00:21:22,183
Yom Tov of a planned stay? I'm not

475
00:21:22,183 --> 00:21:23,012
exactly sure of the details of Shlomo Zalman's

476
00:21:23,012 --> 00:21:23,840
pshat. But that's a mahalach. Sometimes you'll have

477
00:21:23,840 --> 00:21:24,669
people go to Gedolei Yisrael and they'll say

478
00:21:24,669 --> 00:21:25,497
and the Gadol will have said what's the

479
00:21:25,497 --> 00:21:26,326
plan? I'll say I plan to live here.

480
00:21:26,326 --> 00:21:27,154
They'll say well if you find a if

481
00:21:27,154 --> 00:21:27,983
you start dating, say I'll be dating over

482
00:21:27,983 --> 00:21:28,811
here. And if you end up dating a

483
00:21:28,811 --> 00:21:29,639
girl who wants to stay, will you stay?

484
00:21:29,639 --> 00:21:30,468
Yeah. And if you end up, yeah, stay.

485
00:21:30,468 --> 00:21:31,296
And if you end up getting a job

486
00:21:31,296 --> 00:21:32,125
here, you'll say I'll stay. And if you

487
00:21:32,125 --> 00:21:32,953
end up finding a shver who will support

488
00:21:32,953 --> 00:21:33,782
you, sure stay. So some Gedolei Yisrael apparently

489
00:21:33,782 --> 00:21:34,610
have said if that's the case and you're

490
00:21:34,610 --> 00:21:35,439
dating, so maybe you'll end up staying and

491
00:21:35,439 --> 00:21:36,267
that was enough to stay. I'm not sure,

492
00:21:36,267 --> 00:21:37,096
I'm not sure. But those are all judgment

493
00:21:37,096 --> 00:21:37,924
calls. Me’ikar hadavar, so le’aniyut da’ati what's happened

494
00:21:37,924 --> 00:21:38,753
is that in our community there are many,

495
00:21:38,753 --> 00:21:39,581
many more people who are spend Yom Tov

496
00:21:39,581 --> 00:21:40,410
in Eretz Yisrael and they're spending Yom Tov

497
00:21:40,410 --> 00:21:41,238
there because they have children there, they have

498
00:21:41,238 --> 00:21:42,066
parents there, grandchildren there. So it becomes very,

499
00:21:42,066 --> 00:21:42,895
very difficult. Going to Eretz Yisrael to spend

500
00:21:42,895 --> 00:21:43,723
time with your children and they're going on

501
00:21:43,723 --> 00:21:44,552
a tiyul and you can't join the tiyul

502
00:21:44,552 --> 00:21:45,380
with your children and grandchildren and you may

503
00:21:45,380 --> 00:21:46,209
have to take a car and they can't

504
00:21:46,209 --> 00:21:47,037
jump with you at some point. So it

505
00:21:47,037 --> 00:21:47,866
is and some people find it very, very

506
00:21:47,866 --> 00:21:48,694
difficult, tircha. Some people find it as an

507
00:21:48,694 --> 00:21:49,523
almost a political statement which is not in

508
00:21:49,523 --> 00:21:50,351
our circles. But it does become difficult. And

509
00:21:50,351 --> 00:21:51,180
that's why it's an important nekudah. In other

510
00:21:51,180 --> 00:21:52,008
words, when something becomes challenging and inconvenient, it

511
00:21:52,008 --> 00:21:52,837
is a reason to make sure that you've

512
00:21:52,837 --> 00:21:53,665
got the halacha right. A person's inconvenience, a

513
00:21:53,665 --> 00:21:54,493
person's tircha is a reason to go back

514
00:21:54,493 --> 00:21:55,322
to the sefarim, learn through the sugya and

515
00:21:55,322 --> 00:21:56,150
make sure. It's not a reason to take

516
00:21:56,150 --> 00:21:56,979
a position though. Very sometimes tircha is a

517
00:21:56,979 --> 00:21:57,807
reason. But because a person finds a particular

518
00:21:57,807 --> 00:21:58,636
din inconvenient and difficult, that's not a reason

519
00:21:58,636 --> 00:21:59,464
to say that we're going to follow Rabbanim

520
00:21:59,464 --> 00:22:00,293
who say certain things or it's not a

521
00:22:00,293 --> 00:22:01,121
reason to machria. It's a reason to go

522
00:22:01,121 --> 00:22:01,950
through the sugya 100 percent. And the person

523
00:22:01,950 --> 00:22:02,778
goes through the sugya and finds a chacham

524
00:22:02,778 --> 00:22:03,607
to be compelling, nu, okay. Still, tzarich iyun

525
00:22:03,607 --> 00:22:04,435
because you're going against a binyan of the

526
00:22:04,435 --> 00:22:05,264
posek. Whatever it is, that's the sugya, that's

527
00:22:05,264 --> 00:22:06,092
the parsha and these questions come up and

528
00:22:06,092 --> 00:22:06,920
they come up with a very strong feeling

529
00:22:06,920 --> 00:22:07,749
sometimes because there are many Jews in our

530
00:22:07,749 --> 00:22:08,577
circles who have received hora’os that allow them

531
00:22:08,577 --> 00:22:09,406
to only keep one day or they have

532
00:22:09,406 --> 00:22:10,234
friends, whatever it is. So you have to

533
00:22:10,234 --> 00:22:11,063
know the sugya. Yeah, go ahead. I'd also

534
00:22:11,063 --> 00:22:11,891
heard of Rav Asher Weiss pasken like Rav

535
00:22:11,891 --> 00:22:12,720
Shlomo Zalman publicly regarding Yom Tov. Bedi’avad? L’chatchilah.

536
00:22:12,720 --> 00:22:13,548
In Eretz Yisrael for the Yom Tov? So

537
00:22:13,548 --> 00:22:14,377
he can be mitztaref. Go ahead. And also

538
00:22:14,377 --> 00:22:15,205
Rav Schachter says that there's a problem of

539
00:22:15,205 --> 00:22:16,034
lo titgodedu if you're going to go with

540
00:22:16,034 --> 00:22:16,862
a group, you're going to be in a

541
00:22:16,862 --> 00:22:17,691
family where everyone's keeping one day, you're going

542
00:22:17,691 --> 00:22:18,519
to keep two days. Sometimes it's also just

543
00:22:18,519 --> 00:22:19,347
like very challenging. You're a yeshiva guy in

544
00:22:19,347 --> 00:22:20,176
a Chol HaMoed-diker shvitz, you may not be

545
00:22:20,176 --> 00:22:21,004
able to find anything to do. So what

546
00:22:21,004 --> 00:22:21,833
does Rebbe think about that? Challenging is challenging,

547
00:22:21,833 --> 00:22:22,661
okay. Challenging means that it's a... it's a...

548
00:22:22,661 --> 00:22:23,490
challenge for one day. What about the Lo

549
00:22:23,490 --> 00:22:24,318
Tisgodidu thing? The Lo Tisgodidu thing, Rav Schechter

550
00:22:24,318 --> 00:22:25,147
said it in very, very limited situations. So,

551
00:22:25,147 --> 00:22:25,975
I again, Rav Schechter just looks at the

552
00:22:25,975 --> 00:22:26,804
situation and says... have to speak for him.

553
00:22:26,804 --> 00:22:27,632
But but Rav Schechter has said it in

554
00:22:27,632 --> 00:22:28,461
very limited situations. Tzaricha Iyun Gadol exactly why

555
00:22:28,461 --> 00:22:29,289
mnyat melacha would be Lo Tisgodidu. I to

556
00:22:29,289 --> 00:22:30,118
not to take a Lulav and Esrog they

557
00:22:30,118 --> 00:22:30,946
wouldn't come up anyways because Hoshanah Rabbah. Not

558
00:22:30,946 --> 00:22:31,774
to sit in the Sukkah I understand. Not

559
00:22:31,774 --> 00:22:32,603
to join if you're in a program and

560
00:22:32,603 --> 00:22:33,431
they're all davening chol so to have a

561
00:22:33,431 --> 00:22:34,260
to daven in a visible way that it's

562
00:22:34,260 --> 00:22:35,088
Yom Tov, I understand that situation. I don't

563
00:22:35,088 --> 00:22:35,917
understand zu keneged mnyat melacha. But whatever it

564
00:22:35,917 --> 00:22:36,745
is, it's in the Shu\"t Rav Schechter said

565
00:22:36,745 --> 00:22:37,574
it, but very, very precise situations. I once

566
00:22:37,574 --> 00:22:38,402
had a talmid whose family made Aliyah and

567
00:22:38,402 --> 00:22:39,231
he was here, and he gets here. So

568
00:22:39,231 --> 00:22:40,059
he went so he wanted to know about

569
00:22:40,059 --> 00:22:40,888
one day, two days Yom Tov. And and

570
00:22:40,888 --> 00:22:41,716
that's what you're describing that it's a that

571
00:22:41,716 --> 00:22:42,545
it's a difficult thing. No question here. So

572
00:22:42,545 --> 00:22:43,373
he asked me in the Beis Medrash, I

573
00:22:43,373 --> 00:22:44,201
said Rav Schechter is five tables away, and

574
00:22:44,201 --> 00:22:45,030
he's the ba'al Lo Tisgodidu shita. So so

575
00:22:45,030 --> 00:22:45,858
he went to Rav Schechter, he said, but

576
00:22:45,858 --> 00:22:46,687
you're in Beis Shemesh and Beis Shemesh there

577
00:22:46,687 --> 00:22:47,515
are going to be a lot of Jews

578
00:22:47,515 --> 00:22:48,344
who are going to keep second day Yom

579
00:22:48,344 --> 00:22:49,172
Tov. So my point is that it's a

580
00:22:49,172 --> 00:22:50,001
very tightly nuanced position. So one has to

581
00:22:50,001 --> 00:22:50,829
ask him exactly does your situation fit his

582
00:22:50,829 --> 00:22:51,554
his mahalach. I also once asked him about

583
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
this, and he also told me it's only

584
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
if it's within the same family, the same

585
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
nuclear family. It's not as if you're your

586
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
uncle and your aunt and your cousins that

587
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
are all keeping one and you're the one

588
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
who should be keeping two. It's only if

589
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
a son and his parents are there, the

590
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
wife and her spouse or the daughter, you

591
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
know, it's only within a nuclear family, not

592
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
in general people. In other words, if I'm

593
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
visiting my uncle, it wouldn't apply. Correct. Different

594
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
family, one does this, one does that, that's

595
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
not... But it sounds like also, but it's

596
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
also in the context where like like you're

597
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
in a lone shut situation where you're not

598
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
going to find... Yeah, so again, Baruch Hashem

599
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
if we can raise these questions Rav Schechter.

600
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
But then what you're saying is correct that

601
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
that is accurate, obviously, that that's another mahalach

602
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
that's sometimes available. Yeah. Good, so that sugya

603
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
of Yom Tov Sheini when an Eretz Yisroeldiker

604
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
comes to America, so then our our mahalach

605
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
in America is much more I always hope

606
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
that they ask the sha'alos in Eretz Yisrael

607
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
because Eretz Yisroeldiker is there much more easygoing

608
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
on an Eretz Yisroeldiker who comes to America.

609
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
Reb Moshe held that when you're part of

610
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
a community over here, so one has to

611
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
keep Yom Tov Sheini because of maris ayin.

612
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
And Reb Moshe paskened afilu b'chadrei chadarim. So

613
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
that seems to be the mahalach of American

614
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
poskim. Ela im kein an Eretz Yisroeldiker will

615
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
take get out of the Jewish community b'heter

616
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
and find themselves into a place where there

617
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
aren't any way beyond the techum of a

618
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
Jewish community. So then I think Reb Moshe

619
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
would say for them they can they can

620
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
function as an Eretz Yisroeldiker and and do

621
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
melachos. The Eretz Yisroeldiker poskim are much more

622
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
easygoing. I'm not sure I'm not sure if

623
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
it's because they don't know the metzius over

624
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
here or they hold in principle that there's

625
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
no problem of maris ayin for Eretz Yisroeldiker

626
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
in America. And the emes is it could

627
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
be that we should be mekil to allow

628
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
melacha if there are many, many more Israelis

629
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
around. You're in a community where there are

630
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
a lot of Israeli visitors, maybe. Okay, tzaricha

631
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
iyun. Good. So then the next question, let's

632
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
discuss the question of showering on Yom Tov.

633
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
Showering on Yom Tov is also something that

634
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
has shifted. Go ahead. A guy in Eretz

635
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
Yisrael who is safek or a guy from

636
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
Eretz Yisrael visiting America, but should he put

637
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
on tefillin when he's if he's if he

638
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
has to stay home, should he go to

639
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
shul, should he...? An Eretz Yisroeldiker who comes

640
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
to America so they should put on tefillin

641
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
privately at home and they and they can

642
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
chap a lot of davening but they can

643
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
chap tefillah b'tzibbur still and they can chap

644
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
krias haTorah. Or or parts of the davening

645
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
should they do b'tzibbur? In the ideal world,

646
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
so they would, the ideal world they would

647
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
come, come a little bit late so they'd

648
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
have a short Tefilla B'tzibur, chapp the Krias

649
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
Shma and then, and then from then on

650
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
they can daven with the Tzibur. They probably,

651
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
one of the pshatim is that they should

652
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
chapp a Hashkama minyan or something, but, but

653
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
al pi ideally, why not? They can, they

654
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
can daven with the Tzibur. Is it, is

655
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
it considered Tefilla B'tzibur if it's a different

656
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
Shemonah Esrei? Yeah, I think, I think it

657
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
would be. I think it is Tefilla B'tzibur.

658
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
You're not, you're not doing the same Shemonah

659
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
Esrei. You're together. That comes under the general

660
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
question of what's their shaila. The shaila is

661
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
that they would much rather head into some

662
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
other community and then they take an Uber

663
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
from there. So that's the chilluk of how

664
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
strong they have to what they have to

665
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
give up to do Tefilla B'tzibur. And then

666
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
what we're really saying is that maybe to

667
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
those poskim who say that it's not Tefilla

668
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
B'tzibur, because there's more reason to have less

669
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
adifus for Tefilla B'tzibur. But if they can,

670
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
then they can marviach, yeah. Rebbe would generally

671
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
give the psak from Rav Moshe? They have

672
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
to keep fully Yom Tov or go with...?

673
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
I mean they wouldn't be saying the brachos

674
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
and they wouldn't be saying... so like a

675
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
half day. They wouldn't, they would do melachos.

676
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
They would do melachos, yeah. Question the posek

677
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
would say, can they be a Shabbos goy

678
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
for their American cousins? So Rav Moshe would

679
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
say no, because that's mishum maris ayin. But

680
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
to be honest, it's most correctly ask Eretz

681
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
Yisrael, the rabbonim of Eretz Yisrael. They should

682
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
ask the rabbonim there. And my experience has

683
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
been that most of the rabbonim of Eretz

684
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
Yisrael will tell them that they, they don't

685
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
have to keep the Yom Tov Sheni. And

686
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
again, that's the issue of maris ayin. And

687
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
again it could be that, I don't know,

688
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
I don't know if the difference of, I

689
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
never looked into it, of the difference of

690
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
metzius of whether it's al pi din nowadays,

691
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
I don't know. Good. So now when it

692
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
comes, yeah. When there are poskim in Eretz

693
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
Yisrael even if they were a person who's

694
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
a ben Chutz La'aretz keeping one day in

695
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
Eretz Yisrael flying back, they would even be

696
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
meikel for him, or just Bnei Eretz Yisrael

697
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
coming back? Bnei Eretz Yisrael, Bnei Eretz Yisrael,

698
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
yeah. When a ben Chutz La'aretz kept one

699
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
day then they would agree with Rav Moshe's

700
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
tzad that it's the maris ayin issue. No,

701
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
a ben Chutz La'aretz goes to Eretz Yisrael

702
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
for Pesach and on the last day he

703
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
only keeps seven days as Bnei Eretz Yisrael

704
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
and flies back and then that morning he's

705
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
in the airport so the poskim in Eretz

706
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
Yisrael would say he can go home? I

707
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
don't think so. I think they, I think

708
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
there was a Kol Korei recently about that

709
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
nekuda that even should not be landing in

710
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
Chutz La'aretz while it's still Yom Tov. Right,

711
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
so that's one issue. Then the second, then

712
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
you're saying that a person let's say he's

713
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
in Eretz Yisrael for every Yom Tov. So

714
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
he's following Rav Shlomo Zalman, Rav Chaim Rav

715
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
Asher, and he's keeping one day Yom Tov.

716
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
So then, then I think that we would

717
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
tell him he should not be getting on

718
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
a plane that would bring him to Chutz

719
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
La'aretz on Yom Tov. Okay, but you're saying

720
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
but something happened, he didn't read the Kol

721
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
Korei, so he went to the airport, now

722
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
he lands in America so I think then

723
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
we would not say. So I'm not sure.

724
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
In other words how far do we take

725
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
that he's a ben Eretz Yisrael for Yom

726
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
Tov? I don't know, I don't know. I

727
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
mean, what you're asking is, you're asking a

728
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
question that I can't answer. You're asking if

729
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
somebody paskens for him that he keep one

730
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
day in Eretz Yisrael and he ends up

731
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
in Chutz La'aretz on Yom Tov, so that's

732
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
hard to answer because I have a bias

733
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
that he should have, that it's Yom Tov

734
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
for him. So I can't answer that question.

735
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
The question that you're asking about if he's

736
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
a ben Eretz Yisrael for Yom Tov, does

737
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
Rav Shlomo Zalman or Rav Asher say that

738
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
changes? So again, we should follow, should ask

739
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
Rav Asher what he would say, Baruch Hashem,

740
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
we'll find out. On Friday we'll take the

741
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
idea that he's in Ben Eretz Yisroel, does

742
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
that switch? There are seforim that discuss, that

743
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
discuss if he's a Ben Eretz Yisroel, but

744
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
if he every Yom Tov is in Eretz

745
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
Yisroel, let's say. And now this Yom Tov

746
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
he happens to be here, I think the

747
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
poskim, the Chazon Ish would say that then

748
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
he has to keep two days. I don't

749
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
understand it well enough to explain the cheshbon.

750
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
But yours is a little more nuanced. Okay,

751
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
to figure out the question. For some reason,

752
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
Kol Koreis that I don't know which rabbanim,

753
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
I don't know who put it out, but

754
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
they strongly, the Kol Koreis strongly discourage, the

755
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
Kol Koreis usually prohibit. So they're prohibiting Jews

756
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
from Eretz Yisroel from getting on the plane

757
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
such that they will land in America once

758
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
Yom Tov has begun, or land in Europe

759
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
also Yom Tov. Anyways, so let's go on

760
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
to a more cheerful, but a topic where

761
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
I think it'll be easier to be meikel,

762
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
that of showering on Yom Tov. So what's

763
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
the issue of showering? Showering is that the

764
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
person draws water from their hot water boiler,

765
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
so new hot, new water, cold water comes

766
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
in. So when you draw your hot water

767
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
off, so that there's no issur d'oraisa there

768
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
per se, but when you bring new water

769
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
into your hot water boiler, so then that

770
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
is an issur of bishul. And if you

771
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
bring a lot of cold water in, then

772
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
you might light up the fire again. And

773
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
the question is, is that muttar on Yom

774
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
Tov because I'm boiling up the water, but

775
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
the water for my boiler I don't use

776
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
for cooking. So I'm boiling up the water

777
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
either for no reason or for another shower.

778
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
Mishna in Beitzah says that ponei yadav veraglav,

779
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
that one can use hot water according to

780
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
Beis Hillel for ponei yadav veraglav, but a

781
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
person cannot use hot water for a shower

782
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
because that's more than ponei yadav veraglav. So

783
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
the question is, is there any flexibility on

784
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
that din from the mishna? So l'chora we

785
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
have to analyze it. L'chora the issue of

786
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
havuarah is and the issue of bishul. Right?

787
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
Havuarah and bishul. If you end up putting

788
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
the fire on or you end up cooking

789
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
the water. So the halacha is that one's

790
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
allowed to do havuarah and bishul l'tzorech ochel

791
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
nefesh. And the halacha is that if there's

792
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
tzorchei haguf which are which have the same

793
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
din as ochel nefesh, similar to shaveh l'chol

794
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
nefesh, so l'chora they should have the same

795
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
din as ochel nefesh. And why was Beis

796
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
Hillel meikel, why did Beis Hillel say that

797
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
ponei yadav veraglav is muttar? Because that's shaveh

798
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
l'chol nefesh. Shaveh l'chol nefesh is a hano'ah

799
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
which is like achilah. So you have a

800
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
hano'ah, and if you have a hano'ah and

801
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
it's not shaveh l'chol nefesh like Tosfos says,

802
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
so one cannot do a melacha for that

803
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
kind of hano'ah. But if a person has

804
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
a hano'ah which is like, which is shaveh

805
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
l'chol nefesh, so maybe that should have the

806
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
same din as ponei yadav veraglav. So the

807
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
question is whether bizmaneinu anu that a full

808
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
body shower is that in the same category

809
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
as ponei yadav veraglav bizman hamishna? So l'aniyus

810
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
da'ati, I would say that if it's a

811
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
situation where you have a Shabbos and two

812
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
days Yom Tov, and sakh ha-kol a person

813
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
will not shower for three days, so I

814
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
could see that somebody could argue that showering

815
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
in that situation is on the same category

816
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
as achilah. So why would I say that?

817
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
Because there's a Ksav Sofer that says that

818
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
to avoid tza'ar is shaveh l'chol nefesh. It's

819
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
hard for us to evaluate going against a

820
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
mishna p'rushah. So how can we go up

821
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
against a mishna p'rushah that says that it's

822
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
only ponei yadav veraglav? So the Ksav Sofer

823
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
says that that what eats has a certain

824
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
level of hano'ah and avoiding Tzar is Hana'ah

825
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
in similar category. So when a person comes

826
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
to showering, so L'chora a person only gets

827
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
to shower once every 24 hours, so L'chora

828
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
that's still within a pretty normal range of

829
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
activity. If it happens to be 48 hours,

830
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
so again after Yom Tov is going to

831
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
end up, it has like an extra day

832
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
of Tzar, so I'm not sure, I'm not

833
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
sure. But when it comes to three days,

834
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
so I think that there are many, many

835
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
Americans who will feel very, they'll feel B'tzar

836
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
that they haven't showered in three days. So

837
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
that's what I would look at. I would

838
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
look at the Matzav if there's a three

839
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
day situation, like three days of Kedusha and

840
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
one of those days is Yom Tov Sheni.

841
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
Apuki if Shabbos is Yom Tov Sheni. But

842
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
one of the three days Yom Tov Sheni,

843
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
L'aniyut Da'ati there'd be room to be Moreh

844
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
that one can take a shower on the

845
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
Yom Tov Sheni. What's the, how can we

846
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
explain such a Hora'ah? So first of all

847
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
we'd be following the Ktav Sofer that says

848
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
that a Melacha which is being done to

849
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
avoid Tzar and we'd be saying that the

850
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
person feels that three days without a shower

851
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
give them Tzar. And again I think that

852
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
there are a lot of people that would

853
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
take that position personally. I'm not saying it's

854
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
such a Davar Pashut that I would advocate

855
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
it, but when a person asks, I say

856
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
look if you're B'tzar, so then on the

857
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
second day of Yom Tov when the Melachos

858
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
are D'rabbanan anyways, so what are we looking

859
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
at? I'm pulling off hot water. So then

860
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
I'm going to do a Psik Reisha. A

861
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
Psik Reisha to bring in more water that'll

862
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
cook. I'm going to do a Psik Reisha

863
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
that will bring more water, that might put

864
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
on the fire to cook this water. What's

865
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
this water going to be used for? Also

866
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
for a shower. So I'm doing a Melacha,

867
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
I'm doing Havarah and Bishul L'tzorech a Davar

868
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
Hashaveh Lechol Nefesh because otherwise it leads to

869
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
Tzar. So L'chora that there'd be room to

870
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
be Mekil on Yom Tov Sheni. So Az

871
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
it's hard to go against a Mishna Meforeshet

872
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
but Yom Tov Sheni, so it's going to

873
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
be a Psik Reisha on a D'rabbanan. There's

874
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
another Mahalach Be'ma Nafshach. If I end up

875
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
using that water for another shower, okay, so

876
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
then I'm using it for Davar Shaveh Lechol

877
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
Nefesh. If I don't end up using the

878
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
water for anything, so then it's a Psik

879
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
Reisha D'lo yichpad lei. So a Psik Reisha

880
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
on a Din D'rabbanan D'lo yichpad lei which

881
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
is L'tzorech Mitzva, L'tzorech Simchas Yom Tov, so

882
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
that's many many Poskim I think that it

883
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
would be possible to be Mekil on that.

884
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
Most hot water heaters I believe, I'd have

885
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
to check out, I believe that most hot

886
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
water heaters still have a pilot light. So

887
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
therefore there's no issue of Molid Esh. I

888
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
believe that's correct. So if it doesn't have

889
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
a pilot but has an electrically ignited, which

890
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
might be the way things are going, so

891
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
then that would be Issur D'rabbanan of Molid.

892
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
So that's Tzaricha Iyuna, but again it'd be

893
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
a Psik Reisha on an Issur D'rabbanan of

894
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
being Molid. It wouldn't be Molid or to

895
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
do Bishul even though it's an Issur D'rabbanan.

896
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
But this would be a Psik Reisha, it

897
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
might even be a Safek Psik Reisha because

898
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
it could be that the temperature has gone

899
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
down and that the lights are on anyways.

900
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
That we wouldn't be Samech on as we'll

901
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
discuss often. But it would be a Psik

902
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
Reisha D'rabbanan and again Be'ma Nafshach either you're

903
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
going to use the water and it's a

904
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
Davar Shaveh Lechol Nefesh or you're not going

905
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
to use water and then it's Psik Reisha

906
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
D'lo nicha lei on a Din D'rabbanan. However,

907
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
what has to still be figured out is

908
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
Gzeiras Habalanim. Hagemara in Shabbos says that there

909
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
was a time where people, one of the

910
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
ways in which people enjoyed Oneg Shabbos is

911
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
that they would have a Shvitz on Shabbos.

912
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
So there were Balanim, there were people who

913
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
ran Shvitzim and they would advertise Shomer Shabbos

914
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
Shvitz, right? And we boiled up all the

915
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
water Lifnei Shabbos, we have a system where

916
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
we keep all the hot water. in pipes

917
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
to create steam, so it's gevaldig, you get

918
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
all the hanoyis of a shvitz on Shabbos

919
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
and you had a gevaldig hashgocha that everything

920
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
was taken care of before Shabbos. Only problem

921
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
was that some of the balanim would refill

922
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
their hot water systems on Shabbos. They would

923
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
advertise that it was a Shomer Shabbos shvitz,

924
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
but it wasn't a Shomer Shabbos shvitz. So

925
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
Chazal made a takana was two iterations. Chazal

926
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
made one takana, then the balanim were saying

927
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
that it was—but weren't telling the truth about

928
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
the second takana, until Chazal said that there's

929
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
a gzera mimercatza'os on Shabbos. Gzeras habalanim. Because

930
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
of the balanim, that's why they gave it

931
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
the title and didn't call it gzeras mercatza'os.

932
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
I think they wanted to tell people that

933
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
they made this gzera because of the dishonest

934
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
balanim. So that's why one cannot—it's another issur.

935
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
Now let's say a person would leave their

936
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
shower on from erev Shabbos. So one still

937
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
could not take a shower Friday night. Why

938
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
not? If the shower, the hot water's coming

939
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
on its own? Because there's an issur taking

940
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
a merchatz, apparently included in the issur of

941
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
being in a shvitz is taking, is sitting

942
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
in a situation where hot water is coming

943
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
down. So that'd be an issur derabbanan. So

944
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
how could I take a hot shower on

945
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
Yom Tov? What about gzeras balanim? So le'aniyus

946
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
da'ati, I would argue the following. There is

947
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
a machlokes Rishonim whether gzeras balanim applies to

948
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
Yom Tov or only Shabbos. And there is

949
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
a machlokes Achronim whether the mercatza'os, it was

950
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
only, is only a bath, so even hot

951
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
water coming down from the top. And there

952
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
is a machlokes Achronim whether gzeras balanim applies

953
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
to mayim poshrim, to the water that's not

954
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
hot. So even though we pasken against, we

955
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
pasken le'esor all of these three situations, we

956
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
pasken on Yom Tov we also do not

957
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
go into the shvitz, and we pasken that

958
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
even if it comes from the top it's

959
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
a bath, and we pasken even if it's

960
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
mayim poshrim. However, le'aniyus da'ati, one could argue

961
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
that on a Yom Tov sheini, so it's

962
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
a din derabbanan to begin with, and we

963
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
have these various sfeikos in the Achronim as

964
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
to whether it applies. So I would say

965
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
one could take a mayim poshrim, one can't

966
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
take a full hot shower, but could take

967
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
a warmer shower on a Yom Tov sheini.

968
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
What's the hesber hadavar? From the perspective of

969
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
a de'oraisa, if a person says \"I'm comfortable\"—it's

970
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
a problem, \"I'm comfortable\". It's the guy's neheneh,

971
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
so probably wouldn't be meikil. But if a

972
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
guy says \"no, I'm betza'ar many people, certainly

973
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
younger people, they'll say they feel gross if

974
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
they don't have a shower in three days.

975
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
Okay. So if there's a Yom Tov sheini

976
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
there, so I would say a person who's

977
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
betza'ar. So therefore we can say that there's

978
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
a davar hashaveh lechol nefesh. And we can

979
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
say that either it's a davar hashaveh lechol

980
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
nefesh or it's a psik reisha on an

981
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
issur derabbanan dilo nicha lei. So then we

982
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
could, because Yom Tov sheini, and if we

983
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
say that in addition you take a lukewarm

984
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
shower—not lukewarm but not a very hot shower—so

985
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
we can say that there are several sfeikos

986
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
as to whether the gzeras habalanim apply. So

987
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
even though in and of itself we're machmir

988
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
on the gzeras habalanim, but here where it's

989
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
a gzeras habalanim on a davar derabbanan to

990
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
begin with, and we do have Achronim who

991
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
are meikil in many of these situations, I

992
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
would say that would be muttar on the

993
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
Yom Tov sheini to take a mayim poshrim,

994
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
not mayim chamim. At the same time, you

995
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
have to instruct people not to use bar

996
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
soap and not to use poufs and not

997
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
to lather up because of the various halachos

998
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
that are involved, gzeiros and mishum schita. Velichora,

999
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
that would be a mahalach that would make

1000
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
people more comfortable. What about drying hair? You

1001
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
would pat dry, pat dry should be okay.

1002
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
If you tell a woman, a woman who

1003
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
goes to mikvah on Friday night, so also

1004
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
tell them to use more than one towel

1005
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
so that no towel becomes sopping wet and

1006
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
to pat themselves dry. But they're air drying

1007
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
a little bit. Good. So then the next

1008
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
issue that one has to understand is how

1009
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
one deals with ovens and stoves on Yom

1010
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
Tov. So l'chora, and because there's been significant

1011
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
changes in the last 20 years with the

1012
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
stove and the ranges becoming more electrically controlled

1013
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
rather than just gas controlled. And the teshuvos

1014
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
that are most popular are teshuvos that deal

1015
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
with gas stoves, gas pilot light, but the

1016
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
heights still has them. Right, so you have

1017
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
a gas stove and there's a little light,

1018
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
the ner tamid inside and it's going mamish

1019
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
24/7. And when you turn on your stove,

1020
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
so then the flame shoots from the ner

1021
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
tamid to the where it ever has to

1022
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
be. So that's gvaldik because there you have

1023
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
a there you're not molid or, not creating

1024
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
a new fire on Shabbos, on Yom Tov,

1025
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
on Yom Tov. Shabbos obviously you can't do

1026
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
it, but on Yom Tov where there ha'avara

1027
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
l'tzorech ochel nefesh is mutar and bishul is

1028
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
mutar, so it's gvaldik. Can you lower the

1029
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
flame? So you can only lower the flame

1030
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
if we would assume that lowering the flame

1031
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
is kibui, and kibui can only be done

1032
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
l'tzorech ochel nefesh. So if you have to

1033
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
keep something warm, but you can put it

1034
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
on a high fire so you have a

1035
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
soup and you need to keep it warm

1036
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
for the meal. If you put it, but

1037
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
you only have one high fire there. If

1038
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
you put the soup on high fire it's

1039
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
going to end up boiling and boiling and

1040
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
boil off and become very, very salty. So

1041
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
you have to put it on a lower

1042
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
flame. If you have it on some flame

1043
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
so it'll be, you can't put on high

1044
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
flame because that'll burn off and become too

1045
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
salty. So then you can turn the fire

1046
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
down so then to be able to put

1047
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
the soup on that fire. You have a

1048
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
chicken, and you want to keep the chicken

1049
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
warm. But if you keep the chicken on

1050
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
the flame that you have right now it'll

1051
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
become burnt. So you're allowed to lower the

1052
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
flame so that you won't end up doing

1053
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
a kibui l'tzorech ochel nefesh. So that is,

1054
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
so that's how we would handle old style

1055
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
stoves on Yom Tov, lot of flexibility. However,

1056
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
when you move to electric stoves, so then

1057
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
you run into an issue that when you

1058
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
switch heat in an electric stove, there are

1059
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
different kinds of electric stoves. Sometimes, and it's

1060
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
rare, it's very rare, that you would maintain

1061
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
the same circuitry, but you would introduce, I

1062
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
don't know exactly what it is, some kind

1063
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
of resistance so that either you have more

1064
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
or less electrons going through, and that would

1065
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
raise or lower the fire. Most of the

1066
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
time, what you have is an electric stove

1067
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
and you move from 250 to 350, mostly

1068
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
you're shutting down the 250 circuit and you're

1069
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
opening up the 350 circuit. And if you

1070
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
do that, so you're being mechabeh 250, and

1071
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
that's not l'tzorech ochel nefesh. But more problematic

1072
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
is you're being molid or, you're starting a

1073
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
whole new fire for 360, for the 350.

1074
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
Can't be molid or. That's one problem. Other

1075
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
problem is if you have a gas stove,

1076
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
so gas stoves nowadays, gas stoves don't have

1077
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
pilot lights. Gas stoves nowadays have electric igniters.

1078
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
So if you move the fire from 250

1079
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
to 350, in the heights you just add

1080
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
more fuel, more gas. But in an electric

1081
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
stove you are starting a new flame that

1082
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
will bring the fire up to the point

1083
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
it'll get up to 350. So one of

1084
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
the curiosities of Hilchos Yom Tov is that

1085
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
even though you're allowed to... Even though you're

1086
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
allowed to cook le-tzorech ochel nefesh, but you

1087
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
can't be molid ur le-tzorech ochel nefesh, right?

1088
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
And the issur d'rabbanan, min de'oraisa you can

1089
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
strike a match, min de'oraisa you can do

1090
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
any havara, havara le-tzorech. Chazal made a din

1091
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
that you cannot start a new flame on

1092
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
Shabbos ve-Yom Tov. That's why every Yom Tov

1093
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
people have 24-hour, 48-hour, 72-hour candles. Sometimes they

1094
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
double as Yahrtzeit lights, but they have a

1095
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
function that they they have they're able you're

1096
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
able to transfer fire from them to any

1097
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
other situation where you need fire because you

1098
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
don't have to be molid ur. What's the

1099
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
issur of being molid ur? It's a machlokes

1100
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
Rashi and Rambam. The Rambam says that being

1101
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
molid ur is a melachas ochel nefesh she-efshar

1102
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
la'asosah me-esmol. That since I could have a

1103
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
pilot light going, since I could have a

1104
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
72-hour candle going, so I'm able to have

1105
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
do this kind of havara me-esmol. So a

1106
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
melacha, a melachas ochel nefesh she-efshar la'asosah me-esmol,

1107
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
certainly a melachas machshirei ochel nefesh she-efshar la'asosah

1108
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
me-esmol is assur. So the Rambam writes starting

1109
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
maintaining a fire that I can't do from

1110
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
yesterday because my fuel gets used up, so

1111
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
to add fuel that's a melacha I need

1112
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
to be doing moment by moment on Yom

1113
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
Tov, but to start a fire that I

1114
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
could do erev Yom Tov. So the Rambam

1115
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
says that nekudah, that that ma'aseh havara of

1116
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
being molid ur, so that was efshar la'asosah

1117
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
me-esmol so I can't do it on Yom

1118
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
Tov. And Rashi has a mechudash'dik approach. Rashi

1119
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
says that being molid ur, the idea of

1120
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
being molid, Chazal said that since molid is

1121
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
similar or is a is conceptually connected to

1122
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
melachos Shabbos, so therefore Chazal made it assur.

1123
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
A very mechudash'dik approach. In other words, what

1124
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
Rashi is pointing out to us is that

1125
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
we are very familiar that Chazal will say

1126
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
that I can't put a plant in the

1127
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
ground on Shabbos, seed in the ground, and

1128
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
I can't put a plant in the ground

1129
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
on Shabbos, and I can't water something on

1130
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
Shabbos, but I but I can't even do

1131
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
something which looks like I can't move a

1132
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
plant into the into the light if it's

1133
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
going to give it greater gidul. So it's

1134
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
a specific ma'aseh which looks like a ma'aseh

1135
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
de'oraisa, right? That we understand. Here Rashi said

1136
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
that Chazal when it came to molid they

1137
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
looked at melachos be-klal. They said melachos be-klal

1138
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
are creative activities, so if I do something

1139
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
which looks like it's creative that's an issur

1140
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
of being molid. It's a different way than

1141
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
we normally think of dinim de-rabbanan, that they

1142
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
looked at the conceptualized the melacha of the

1143
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
issur and said if I do something which

1144
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
is conceptually similar to the issur that's also

1145
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
de-rabbanan, being molid, creating a new that's why

1146
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
we have a din on Shabbos ve-Yom Tov

1147
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
one cannot create a new form. One cannot,

1148
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
I mean it's a machlokes exactly, one cannot

1149
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
take a liquid or a gas and make

1150
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
it into a solid. I just had a

1151
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
very interesting sheilah about making slush. Can you

1152
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
have a slush maker on Shabbos? Put a

1153
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
slush maker on a Shabbos clock. And then

1154
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
add it, so my machshavah first was that

1155
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
to make slush you're making ice, so most

1156
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
of the poskim say that one shouldn't make

1157
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
ice on Shabbos. So even though the slush

1158
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
maker is going, but when I put the

1159
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
water in I'm making new ice. So Rav

1160
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
Shlomo Zalman points out that there are there

1161
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
are poskim, I think it's Tzitz Eliezer who

1162
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
is meikel on who holds making ice is

1163
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
not molid. Rav Shlomo Zalman said that his

1164
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
lashon is that one should be machmir, one

1165
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
shouldn't make ice on Shabbos. But then when

1166
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
I looked into the the science of slush,

1167
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
so I thought this was very interesting that

1168
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
a slush maker has two things going on.

1169
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
On one hand it's making ice, the temperature

1170
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
of the water is below freezing point, but

1171
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
then they have two systems that stop the

1172
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
slush from becoming a block of ice. One

1173
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
is they have things moving around all the

1174
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
time so that the it becomes balls of

1175
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
ice, and the other is that they send

1176
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
antifreeze through. through some pipes within the slush

1177
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
maker, so again for the same reason it

1178
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
shouldn't become a block of ice. So microscopically

1179
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
when you look at slush, it's little balls

1180
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
of ice sitting in water. So it never

1181
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
becomes a solid block of ice. Macroscopically, I

1182
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
don't know that's that's our experience, you know,

1183
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
when you go into a 7-Eleven, so you

1184
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
think you're walking out with a with a

1185
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
cup of of little balls of ice. I

1186
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
don't know if you see that you have

1187
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
balls of ice that are sitting in liquid.

1188
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
So tzarich iyun, that's why when this person

1189
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
asked me what to do for his youth

1190
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
group, so I thought that the Shlomo Zalman

1191
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
says you shouldn't make ice and I thought

1192
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
that even though microscopically you're you're making very

1193
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
small balls of ice and keeping them so

1194
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
they shouldn't become this solid, so maybe you

1195
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
could say that I'm just making a a

1196
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
thicker liquid. It's not mamash content of the

1197
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
powder, but I'm not and do I look

1198
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
do I say I'm creating little balls of

1199
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
ice or are you creating a a slow

1200
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
liquid because my ice is free-flowing? So I'm

1201
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
not sure. I thought it would anyways be

1202
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
ovdin dechol and if it makes noise it

1203
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
could be avsha demilta. But then the Rabbi

1204
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
told me that the family in in many

1205
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
shuls, it's it's people are doing it for

1206
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
the youth groups. He gave me certain communities,

1207
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
not not local. So I said I don't

1208
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
know. I said I didn't realize that the

1209
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
psak is out there already, but I'll look

1210
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
at it much more carefully. And if it's

1211
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
being done already, so maybe it's not ovdin

1212
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
dechol. But it has to take a stand

1213
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
what to be ma'ale shulchan melachim, that's the

1214
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
nekuda. Is it considered are you being molid?

1215
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
First of all, there are many poskim who

1216
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
who allow making ice. But let's say you

1217
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
want to take the approach that you can't

1218
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
make ice, so was this called making ice

1219
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
because you you make little balls of ice

1220
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
but you still making it in a in

1221
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
a pourable fashion. Tzarich iyun have to be

1222
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
ma'ale shulchan melachim. So what does it do

1223
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
with us? Molid, right, so that's the issur

1224
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
of molid. So so Rashi says the issur

1225
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
of molid and the Rambam the issur of

1226
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
molid, and therefore being molid or is assur

1227
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
on Yom Tov even letzorech ochel nefesh. So

1228
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
havara and bishul is muttar, but being molid

1229
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
or is assur. kach hadin. So so if

1230
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
you have the if you still live in

1231
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
the Heights and you have and you haven't

1232
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
upgraded your oven and you have a pilot

1233
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
geburning because there's no molid or and you

1234
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
can you can fire up and you're doing

1235
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
bishul. If you have an electric oven, an

1236
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
electric range, electric oven, so then you're in

1237
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
trouble because you have to know how does

1238
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
the circuitry work and it's very very I'm

1239
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
I'm told it's most likely that you're changing

1240
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
circuitry being mechabe and being molid or that

1241
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
you can't do on Yom Tov. And if

1242
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
you have a modern-day gas stove, probably also

1243
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
you're going to end up being molid or

1244
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
because if your oven is sitting at 250,

1245
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
so the only way they're going to get

1246
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
to 350 is probably, probably, or as if

1247
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
your fire is going and you know it's

1248
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
going and you hear the swish of the

1249
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
gas and you open up and you see

1250
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
that the fire is going up to 350

1251
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
won't be a problem at all. But if

1252
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
it's quiet and you look inside and you

1253
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
don't see a fire going, so then you're

1254
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
going to end up being molid or to

1255
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
bring it up to 350, that's a problem.

1256
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
Nu, so what does it so that's so

1257
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
then what so that's why one has to

1258
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
keep the fire on at the highest at

1259
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
the temperature the higher temperature you want. That's

1260
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
why you have to do the cheshbon. Now

1261
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
what about the range? So the modern-day range

1262
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
has an electric clicker. So when you turn

1263
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
on your range the top of the range,

1264
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
so the gas comes out and you hear

1265
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,554
the clicker and the fire goes on. Okay,

1266
00:22:51,554 --> 00:22:51,681
so you're being molid or, it's a problem.

1267
00:22:51,681 --> 00:22:52,509
However, there are different kinds of ranges. Sometimes

1268
00:22:52,509 --> 00:22:53,338
the range has the clicker at the end

1269
00:22:53,338 --> 00:22:54,166
of the at the end of the dial.

1270
00:22:54,166 --> 00:22:54,995
So the gas come when you turn on

1271
00:22:54,995 --> 00:22:55,823
the gas, so you turn the gas on,

1272
00:22:55,823 --> 00:22:56,652
gas is coming out, you have to go

1273
00:22:56,652 --> 00:22:57,480
to high, when you go to high then

1274
00:22:57,480 --> 00:22:58,309
it clicks and then you have to adjust

1275
00:22:58,309 --> 00:22:59,137
it. So if that's the case then what

1276
00:22:59,137 --> 00:22:59,965
you could do is just turn on the

1277
00:22:59,965 --> 00:23:00,794
gas and bring an or from here from

1278
00:23:00,794 --> 00:23:01,622
Sometimes the clickers are not so, are not

1279
00:23:01,622 --> 00:23:02,451
so gevaldig, so you have to go very

1280
00:23:02,451 --> 00:23:03,279
slow if the clickers are at the beginning

1281
00:23:03,279 --> 00:23:04,108
of the dial. So you don't have this

1282
00:23:04,108 --> 00:23:04,936
other eitzah. But sometimes if you go very

1283
00:23:04,936 --> 00:23:05,765
quickly past the clicker, you won't end up

1284
00:23:05,765 --> 00:23:06,593
getting a spark and then you'll get the

1285
00:23:06,593 --> 00:23:07,422
gas and then you can transfer fire. But

1286
00:23:07,422 --> 00:23:08,250
if you have a shpitz range and it

1287
00:23:08,250 --> 00:23:09,079
works every single time, so then you're stuck

1288
00:23:09,079 --> 00:23:09,907
and you have to leave fire on for

1289
00:23:09,907 --> 00:23:10,736
Yom Tov. So now the new thing in

1290
00:23:10,736 --> 00:23:11,564
the market is the Shabbos mode. Just last

1291
00:23:11,564 --> 00:23:12,392
week somebody had a new fridge, a new

1292
00:23:12,392 --> 00:23:13,221
person in the community and they could not

1293
00:23:13,221 --> 00:23:14,049
and every time they opened the door the

1294
00:23:14,049 --> 00:23:14,878
light went on and the lights were hardwired.

1295
00:23:14,878 --> 00:23:15,706
And they didn't, and they were renting, so

1296
00:23:15,706 --> 00:23:16,535
they didn't buy a Shabbos mode fridge. So

1297
00:23:16,535 --> 00:23:17,363
they asked me what they should do, so

1298
00:23:17,363 --> 00:23:18,192
I came over and looked at it and

1299
00:23:18,192 --> 00:23:19,020
they said that they put a magnet, put

1300
00:23:19,020 --> 00:23:19,849
a magnet in certain place and you can

1301
00:23:19,849 --> 00:23:20,677
turn off. So they, I said use a

1302
00:23:20,677 --> 00:23:21,506
magnet. So I got this look like, you're

1303
00:23:21,506 --> 00:23:22,334
a Rabbi, not an alternative medicine guy, what

1304
00:23:22,334 --> 00:23:23,163
do you mean a magnet? I said, no,

1305
00:23:23,163 --> 00:23:23,991
no. So I happened to have a magnet

1306
00:23:23,991 --> 00:23:24,819
in the car from the thing which holds

1307
00:23:24,819 --> 00:23:25,648
the car to the phone. So I showed

1308
00:23:25,648 --> 00:23:26,476
him that if you put the magnet in

1309
00:23:26,476 --> 00:23:27,305
certain place, you can get the lights to

1310
00:23:27,305 --> 00:23:28,133
knock off. You have to get a magnet,

1311
00:23:28,133 --> 00:23:28,962
you have to, I don't know if there's

1312
00:23:28,962 --> 00:23:29,790
other stuff, I don't think you should keep

1313
00:23:29,790 --> 00:23:30,619
it there 24/7 because I don't know what

1314
00:23:30,619 --> 00:23:31,447
else is cutting off besides, but that's an

1315
00:23:31,447 --> 00:23:32,276
eitzah. So, but in this case you get

1316
00:23:32,276 --> 00:23:33,104
the Shabbos mode. So the Shabbos mode does

1317
00:23:33,104 --> 00:23:33,933
things that are very important and does things

1318
00:23:33,933 --> 00:23:34,761
that are questionable whether they're helpful. One thing

1319
00:23:34,761 --> 00:23:35,590
the Shabbos mode does, which is very, very

1320
00:23:35,590 --> 00:23:36,418
important, is that most ovens nowadays have a

1321
00:23:36,418 --> 00:23:37,246
12-hour cutoff. So if you leave your oven

1322
00:23:37,246 --> 00:23:38,075
on, so most states will not allow an

1323
00:23:38,075 --> 00:23:38,903
oven to be manufactured that doesn't have a

1324
00:23:38,903 --> 00:23:39,732
cutoff because they don't want a person leaving

1325
00:23:39,732 --> 00:23:40,560
their oven on and then going out and

1326
00:23:40,560 --> 00:23:41,389
forgetting about it. So the oven's cutoff is

1327
00:23:41,389 --> 00:23:42,217
12 hours, so that's a terrible thing for

1328
00:23:42,217 --> 00:23:43,046
a guy who wants to keep Yom Tov.

1329
00:23:43,046 --> 00:23:43,874
So you have to buy the Shabbos mode

1330
00:23:43,874 --> 00:23:44,703
because that bypasses, when you put on the

1331
00:23:44,703 --> 00:23:45,531
Shabbos mode, it bypasses the cutoff. Okay, that's

1332
00:23:45,531 --> 00:23:46,360
a good solution. And then the Shabbos mode

1333
00:23:46,360 --> 00:23:47,188
will knock off all the lights, so the

1334
00:23:47,188 --> 00:23:48,017
lights will not go on when you open

1335
00:23:48,017 --> 00:23:48,845
up the door to the oven, gevaldig, you

1336
00:23:48,845 --> 00:23:49,673
need that also. And then the Shabbos mode

1337
00:23:49,673 --> 00:23:50,502
will knock off all the digital readouts, which

1338
00:23:50,502 --> 00:23:51,330
might change when you open the door, also

1339
00:23:51,330 --> 00:23:52,159
very important. Okay, now the real issue that

1340
00:23:52,159 --> 00:23:52,987
has to be figured out is that Rabbi

1341
00:23:52,987 --> 00:23:53,816
Heinemann, who is not only a huge talmid

1342
00:23:53,816 --> 00:23:54,644
chacham and a very, very skilled technically, is

1343
00:23:54,644 --> 00:23:55,473
also a wonderful marketing person because he was

1344
00:23:55,473 --> 00:23:56,301
able to convince major brands to have a

1345
00:23:56,301 --> 00:23:57,130
Sabbath mode. Now the Sabbath mode doesn't do

1346
00:23:57,130 --> 00:23:57,751
anything for Shabbos, but you can't sell a

1347
00:23:57,751 --> 00:23:57,751
Yom Tov mode, so he sells a Shabbos

1348
00:23:57,751 --> 00:23:57,751
mode, sounds better. So that in America Shabbos

1349
00:23:57,751 --> 00:23:57,751
mode is sold. So it doesn't get in

1350
00:23:57,751 --> 00:23:57,751
the way of people Yom Tov mode. So

1351
00:23:57,751 --> 00:23:57,751
he sells a Sabbath, it does nothing for

1352
00:23:57,751 --> 00:23:57,751
Shabbos. It helps you because you can open

1353
00:23:57,751 --> 00:23:57,751
the door after the fire has gone off,

1354
00:23:57,751 --> 00:23:57,751
so it's helpful. So it's good. But for

1355
00:23:57,751 --> 00:23:57,751
Yom Tov, Rabbi Heinemann developed the Shabbos mode

1356
00:23:57,751 --> 00:23:57,751
so that whenever one raises the temperature, there's

1357
00:23:57,751 --> 00:23:57,751
a built-in delay and there's no digital readout.

1358
00:23:57,751 --> 00:23:57,751
So you know that you left your fire

1359
00:23:57,751 --> 00:23:57,751
on at 250, you now want to get

1360
00:23:57,751 --> 00:23:57,751
up to 360. How do you get up

1361
00:23:57,751 --> 00:23:57,751
to 360? You're going to end up putting

1362
00:23:57,751 --> 00:23:57,751
on a circuit, molid or. So what he

1363
00:23:57,751 --> 00:23:57,751
has is, first of all, you don't, there's

1364
00:23:57,751 --> 00:23:57,751
no digital readout. So you have to press

1365
00:23:57,751 --> 00:23:57,751
it once 260, twice 270, three times 280.

1366
00:23:57,751 --> 00:23:57,751
Okay, so you took care of the problem

1367
00:23:57,751 --> 00:23:57,751
of koseiv. How do you take care of

1368
00:23:57,751 --> 00:23:57,751
the problem of molid or and raising the

1369
00:23:57,751 --> 00:23:57,751
fire? So you put in a delay. So

1370
00:23:57,751 --> 00:23:57,751
by putting in the delay, it becomes a

1371
00:23:57,751 --> 00:23:57,751
grama of havarah and a grama of molid.

1372
00:23:57,751 --> 00:23:57,751
So that is highly questionable whether that in

1373
00:23:57,751 --> 00:23:57,751
fact is accurate. Rabbi Heinemann is again ashlei

1374
00:23:57,751 --> 00:23:57,751
ravrevei. Most poskim do not say that a

1375
00:23:57,751 --> 00:23:57,751
predictable delay makes it into a grama. Most

1376
00:23:57,751 --> 00:23:57,751
poskim say the difference between grama and a

1377
00:23:57,751 --> 00:23:57,751
maaseh is are you sure it's going to

1378
00:23:57,751 --> 00:23:57,751
happen. If you're sure it's going to happen,

1379
00:23:57,751 --> 00:23:57,751
then it's a maaseh. If you're not sure

1380
00:23:57,751 --> 00:23:57,751
it's going to happen, then it's grama. If

1381
00:23:57,751 --> 00:23:57,751
you open the door and you're sure that

1382
00:23:57,751 --> 00:23:57,751
the wind is going to blow up the

1383
00:23:57,751 --> 00:23:57,751
fire, that is a maaseh. If you open

1384
00:23:57,751 --> 00:23:57,751
the door and sometimes it doesn't, that's grama.

1385
00:23:57,751 --> 00:23:57,751
Right, if you put your bottles, your barrels

1386
00:23:57,751 --> 00:23:57,751
of water in front of the fire and

1387
00:23:57,751 --> 00:23:57,751
you're not sure whether the fire is going

1388
00:23:57,751 --> 00:23:57,751
to be doused because it'll break the barrels,

1389
00:23:57,751 --> 00:23:57,751
that's grama. So over here, a time delay

1390
00:23:57,751 --> 00:23:57,751
is highly questionable whether a time delay creates

1391
00:23:57,751 --> 00:23:57,751
a grama situation because you know it has

1392
00:23:57,751 --> 00:23:57,751
never failed. It may have taken two and

1393
00:23:57,751 --> 00:23:57,751
a half seconds, or it may have taken

1394
00:23:57,751 --> 00:23:57,751
five and a half seconds, but it's happened.

1395
00:23:57,751 --> 00:23:57,751
So that's highly questionable. There is a strong

1396
00:23:57,751 --> 00:23:57,751
source to say so, there is a Rashba

1397
00:23:57,751 --> 00:23:57,751
who seems to say that, it seems like

1398
00:23:57,751 --> 00:23:57,751
Rav Shlomo Zalman in some writings has accepted

1399
00:23:57,751 --> 00:23:57,751
the idea. But it's a very, very questionable

1400
00:23:57,751 --> 00:23:57,751
mahalach. I think most poskim, and I said

1401
00:23:57,751 --> 00:23:57,751
the Rav was very much against the idea.

1402
00:23:57,751 --> 00:23:57,751
In and he discussed Shabbos mode, he discussed

1403
00:23:57,751 --> 00:23:57,751
the idea of what's called grama. So that's

1404
00:23:57,751 --> 00:23:57,751
highly questionable if that is, if one can

1405
00:23:57,751 --> 00:23:57,751
rely on that nekudah for a Yom Tov.

1406
00:23:57,751 --> 00:23:57,751
You still need to get a Shabbos mode

1407
00:23:57,751 --> 00:23:57,751
oven because you need to have the cut-off

1408
00:23:57,751 --> 00:23:57,751
bypass. And you need the cut-off, the, you

1409
00:23:57,751 --> 00:23:57,751
need the Shabbos mode so you need to

1410
00:23:57,751 --> 00:23:57,751
get that you won't have digital readouts that

1411
00:23:57,751 --> 00:23:57,751
change when you open the door of the

1412
00:23:57,751 --> 00:23:57,751
oven, and that you don't have the lights

1413
00:23:57,751 --> 00:23:57,751
go on. The question is whether this extra

1414
00:23:57,751 --> 00:23:57,751
feature of the Shabbos mode, which Rabbi Heinemann

1415
00:23:57,751 --> 00:23:57,751
promoted as being allowed to change the flame

1416
00:23:57,751 --> 00:23:57,751
because it's only a grama and a grama

1417
00:23:57,751 --> 00:23:57,751
d'grama, so that's highly questionable whether you've accomplished

1418
00:23:57,751 --> 00:23:57,751
that or whether you're stuck with the way

1419
00:23:57,751 --> 00:23:57,751
it was before, that you have to leave

1420
00:23:57,751 --> 00:23:57,751
the oven on 360, whatever your wife decides,

1421
00:23:57,751 --> 00:23:57,751
whatever your mother decides to leave it on,

1422
00:23:57,751 --> 00:23:57,751
and work with it the way you work

1423
00:23:57,751 --> 00:23:57,751
with any other oven that you can't change

1424
00:23:57,751 --> 00:23:57,751
the, so that's again a Shulchan melacha and

1425
00:23:57,751 --> 00:23:57,751
it's a sugya that you have to work

1426
00:23:57,751 --> 00:23:57,751
through and take a position on because sometimes

1427
00:23:57,751 --> 00:23:57,751
you won't get asked, you'll have to teach

1428
00:23:57,751 --> 00:23:57,751
it, but the lashon is sometimes people assume

1429
00:23:57,751 --> 00:23:57,751
things. Good. So those I think are the

1430
00:23:57,751 --> 00:23:57,751
things which in my experience are very, very

1431
00:23:57,751 --> 00:23:57,751
prevalent issues that come up Yom Tov to

1432
00:23:57,751 --> 00:23:57,751
Yom Tov. You know, I'm sure it'll come

1433
00:23:57,751 --> 00:23:57,751
up in different ways as technology advances. Good.

1434
00:23:57,751 --> 00:23:57,751
So for me it was, I always enjoy

1435
00:23:57,751 --> 00:23:57,751
the opportunity to spend time with the guys

1436
00:23:57,751 --> 00:23:57,751
in semicha and at least have the recognition

1437
00:23:57,751 --> 00:23:57,751
and then of course if you're in semicha

1438
00:23:57,751 --> 00:23:57,751
and things come up and I can be

1439
00:23:57,751 --> 00:23:57,751
helpful, so happy to be helpful. Yeah. What's

1440
00:23:57,751 --> 00:23:57,751
the issue with raising the temperature on Yom

1441
00:23:57,751 --> 00:23:57,751
Tov? Well, because in modern day ovens it

1442
00:23:57,751 --> 00:23:57,751
will be molid or because it's an electric,

1443
00:23:57,751 --> 00:23:57,751
you're going to in most you're going to

1444
00:23:57,751 --> 00:23:57,751
shut down certain circuits and then some new

1445
00:23:57,751 --> 00:23:57,751
circuits. That's molid. Now not all, there are

1446
00:23:57,751 --> 00:23:57,751
some electric ovens which don't function that way.

1447
00:23:57,751 --> 00:23:57,751
And most gas, so most gas ovens you're

1448
00:23:57,751 --> 00:23:57,751
going to also, the way things work without

1449
00:23:57,751 --> 00:23:57,751
pilot lights, you're going to be molid a

1450
00:23:57,751 --> 00:23:57,751
new flame. Okay, we'll go make Mincha downstairs,

1451
00:23:57,751 --> 00:23:57,751
okay.
