1
00:00:01,220 --> 00:00:03,399
Good evening. We're going to discuss a very

2
00:00:03,399 --> 00:00:08,060
contemporary halachic shaila that is contemporary because it

3
00:00:08,060 --> 00:00:10,679
applies nowadays, but it only applied now, it

4
00:00:10,679 --> 00:00:12,720
only has been a shaila for a number

5
00:00:12,720 --> 00:00:17,199
of years. The shaila is an ancient shaila,

6
00:00:17,199 --> 00:00:22,079
but the application is exceptional and has to

7
00:00:22,079 --> 00:00:24,420
do possibly or maybe possibly not with the

8
00:00:24,420 --> 00:00:26,320
fact that we are zocha to have Baruch

9
00:00:26,320 --> 00:00:29,160
Hashem Eretz Yisrael with shlita on Eretz Yisrael.

10
00:00:29,320 --> 00:00:31,361
We'll see how that might bear a nafka

11
00:00:31,361 --> 00:00:33,640
mina to the fact that there is a

12
00:00:33,640 --> 00:00:36,950
government that might be in control of Eretz

13
00:00:36,950 --> 00:00:38,766
Yisrael. We'll see that's quoted where Rav Shlomo

14
00:00:38,766 --> 00:00:41,079
Zalman will apply that svara, which we'll see

15
00:00:41,079 --> 00:00:46,380
soon. So the question is, Eilat is known

16
00:00:46,380 --> 00:00:49,500
for its beautiful coral reef. I've gone snorkeling

17
00:00:49,500 --> 00:00:52,659
there. Menachem, you went snorkeling there? No, you

18
00:00:52,659 --> 00:00:53,780
never went? Okay, I'll have to take my

19
00:00:53,780 --> 00:00:57,159
son snorkeling there. It's a beautiful, beautiful place.

20
00:00:57,659 --> 00:00:59,640
But you're not allowed to snorkel, you're not

21
00:00:59,640 --> 00:01:01,000
allowed to swim on Yom Tov, so the

22
00:01:01,000 --> 00:01:03,619
question is, if you go to Eilat for

23
00:01:03,619 --> 00:01:05,980
Sukkot, for Pesach, for Shavuot, are you going

24
00:01:05,980 --> 00:01:07,140
to be keeping one day of Yom Tov

25
00:01:07,140 --> 00:01:08,620
or are you going to be keeping two

26
00:01:08,620 --> 00:01:10,140
days of Yom Tov? nafka mina, could you

27
00:01:10,140 --> 00:01:13,439
go snorkeling on second day Yom Tov? Is

28
00:01:13,439 --> 00:01:14,819
there a second day Yom Tov, meaning what's

29
00:01:14,819 --> 00:01:16,289
the shaila? The shaila is, is it Eretz

30
00:01:16,289 --> 00:01:17,680
Yisrael, is it Chutz La'aretz? That's really our

31
00:01:17,680 --> 00:01:20,531
question. It's a question only for those who

32
00:01:20,531 --> 00:01:22,200
are bnei Chutz La'aretz. That is correct. For

33
00:01:22,200 --> 00:01:24,340
those who are bnei America who are visiting

34
00:01:24,340 --> 00:01:27,142
Eretz Yisrael and follow the minhag of Klal

35
00:01:27,142 --> 00:01:28,599
Yisrael that has—the minhag that Klal Yisrael has

36
00:01:28,599 --> 00:01:30,780
had for the past few thousand years, then

37
00:01:30,780 --> 00:01:33,200
we would keep two days wherever we would

38
00:01:33,200 --> 00:01:34,799
go. But yes, it's a question for Israelis

39
00:01:34,799 --> 00:01:37,079
who very much do like to go to

40
00:01:37,079 --> 00:01:42,239
Eilat. I actually drove Berel Wein home this

41
00:01:42,239 --> 00:01:44,400
afternoon from YU, he spoke at YU. I

42
00:01:44,400 --> 00:01:45,700
told him I was speaking about this tonight.

43
00:01:45,799 --> 00:01:48,900
He said—he had a good line. He said

44
00:01:48,900 --> 00:01:56,640
something about the reason why there's not such

45
00:01:56,640 --> 00:01:58,700
a big shaila of going to—something, he had

46
00:01:58,700 --> 00:02:00,359
some funny joke about the fact that there

47
00:02:00,359 --> 00:02:02,739
are no yamim tovim in the winter. The

48
00:02:02,920 --> 00:02:04,079
winter's when everybody likes to go, all the

49
00:02:04,079 --> 00:02:05,420
Israelis go to Eilat in the winter, but

50
00:02:05,420 --> 00:02:07,099
there's no Yom Tov in Eilat in the

51
00:02:07,099 --> 00:02:09,340
winter, so it's not such a shaila. Okay,

52
00:02:09,759 --> 00:02:11,599
so let's start, we'll begin—we have to begin

53
00:02:11,599 --> 00:02:13,719
really with the discussion of what are taka

54
00:02:13,719 --> 00:02:16,060
the gvulot of Eretz Yisrael. If it's included

55
00:02:16,060 --> 00:02:17,659
in Eretz Yisrael, good; if it's not included

56
00:02:17,659 --> 00:02:19,240
in Eretz Yisrael, then that probably is our

57
00:02:19,240 --> 00:02:20,860
answer. It's Chutz La'aretz or Eretz Yisrael, one

58
00:02:20,860 --> 00:02:22,539
of the other, right? We will see it

59
00:02:22,539 --> 00:02:24,979
is not so simple, but what will be

60
00:02:24,979 --> 00:02:27,759
simple is whether it's in Eretz Yisrael. Let's

61
00:02:27,759 --> 00:02:30,393
look at some pesukim Bamidbar, Parshat Masei, Perek

62
00:02:30,393 --> 00:02:33,060
Lamed Daled. Zot Ha'aretz, HaKadosh Baruch Hu says,

63
00:02:33,120 --> 00:02:35,340
asher tipol lachem l'nachala. Why does the Torah

64
00:02:35,340 --> 00:02:37,419
have to tell us where the aretz is?

65
00:02:37,500 --> 00:02:40,870
Zogt Rashi, sheharbeh mitzvot nohagot ba'aretz v'einan nohagot

66
00:02:40,870 --> 00:02:43,240
b'chutz la'aretz. So therefore the Torah has to

67
00:02:43,240 --> 00:02:45,780
tell you which are the borders of Eretz

68
00:02:45,780 --> 00:02:49,099
Yisrael so you know whether the mitzvot hatluyot

69
00:02:49,099 --> 00:02:52,699
ba'aretz apply or don't apply. So let's get

70
00:02:52,699 --> 00:02:54,340
into some of the borders in pasuk gimmel.

71
00:02:55,099 --> 00:02:58,864
v'haya lachem p'at negev, the southern border, mimidbar

72
00:02:58,864 --> 00:03:02,620
tzin al yedei edom, it's on the bottom,

73
00:03:02,620 --> 00:03:07,479
the southeast corner. v'haya lachem gvul negev, this

74
00:03:07,479 --> 00:03:09,745
will be your southern border, miketzeh yam hamelach

75
00:03:09,745 --> 00:03:12,650
kedma, starting from the southern tip of yam

76
00:03:12,650 --> 00:03:14,580
hamelach. That's going to be the bottom of

77
00:03:14,580 --> 00:03:18,159
Eretz Yisrael according to the Torah. And then

78
00:03:18,159 --> 00:03:21,319
it's going to head—that will be the eastern

79
00:03:21,319 --> 00:03:27,080
border. That will be the eastern edge of

80
00:03:27,080 --> 00:03:33,099
the southern border, correct. As Rashi

81
00:03:33,099 --> 00:03:35,800
explains, ruach dromis min hamizrach, now we're going

82
00:03:35,800 --> 00:03:39,379
to outline going from east from the—from the

83
00:03:39,379 --> 00:03:41,960
bottom tip of the yam hamelach going towards—if

84
00:03:41,960 --> 00:03:44,560
you're facing a map, going leftwards towards Egypt,

85
00:03:44,800 --> 00:03:46,939
towards the Mediterranean. So what does the Torah

86
00:03:46,939 --> 00:03:50,030
say? This is where the border goes: venasav

87
00:03:50,030 --> 00:03:54,080
lachem hagvul minegev l'ma'aleh akrabim, that the border

88
00:03:54,080 --> 00:04:00,120
will go just around ma'aleh akrabim. Now,

89
00:04:00,539 --> 00:04:03,560
without knowing, without having a map in front

90
00:04:03,560 --> 00:04:05,919
of us, I will tell you what the

91
00:04:05,919 --> 00:04:10,180
potential possibilities of this pasuk is telling us.

92
00:04:10,680 --> 00:04:11,879
I don't know if it's this pasuk or

93
00:04:11,879 --> 00:04:16,600
another pasuk, there's a wadi that had become

94
00:04:16,600 --> 00:04:21,730
famous, I believe, in 1967, Wadi el-Arish. Wadi

95
00:04:21,730 --> 00:04:24,959
el-Arish is a natural geological phenomenon, meaning it's

96
00:04:24,959 --> 00:04:28,560
been there for thousands of years. It's not

97
00:04:28,560 --> 00:04:35,699
a new thing. That's one opinion,

98
00:04:35,699 --> 00:04:39,319
there's Nachal Mitzrayim, which might be Wadi el-Arish.

99
00:04:39,819 --> 00:04:41,439
If you have a picture of Eretz Yisrael,

100
00:04:41,639 --> 00:04:44,879
sort of draw a line, a crooked line

101
00:04:45,040 --> 00:04:47,289
just around from the bottom tip of yam

102
00:04:47,289 --> 00:04:49,259
hamelach, of the Dead Sea, maybe a little

103
00:04:49,259 --> 00:04:51,620
bit more south, and then draw a line

104
00:04:51,740 --> 00:04:54,160
basically a little crooked that goes towards Egypt.

105
00:04:55,220 --> 00:04:57,699
The line would be well, well, well above

106
00:04:57,699 --> 00:05:01,699
Eilat. Eilat is well below. this border according

107
00:05:01,699 --> 00:05:04,120
to just about all opinions, if not every

108
00:05:04,120 --> 00:05:07,620
opinion. There is no opinion that assumes that

109
00:05:07,620 --> 00:05:11,040
Eilat, that Eretz Yisrael does Baruch Hashem own

110
00:05:11,040 --> 00:05:13,860
now, nobody holds that it was part of

111
00:05:13,860 --> 00:05:18,220
what we'll call biblical or Eretz Yisrael that's

112
00:05:18,220 --> 00:05:24,379
described in the Chumash. Did in the time

113
00:05:24,379 --> 00:05:27,300
of Shlomo HaMelech, did Shlomo HaMelech or in

114
00:05:27,300 --> 00:05:28,493
the time of David, did they, did Klal

115
00:05:28,493 --> 00:05:31,660
Yisrael annex as far south as Eilat? There

116
00:05:31,660 --> 00:05:34,720
are interesting Psukim in all kinds of places

117
00:05:34,920 --> 00:05:37,639
as explained by different Rishonim and Meforshim that

118
00:05:37,639 --> 00:05:40,220
may indicate some things yes, some things no,

119
00:05:40,519 --> 00:05:42,819
but it's certainly not a clear point. There's

120
00:05:42,819 --> 00:05:46,160
no definitive indication that Eilat should be in

121
00:05:46,160 --> 00:05:48,079
the borders of Eretz Yisrael. So at this

122
00:05:48,079 --> 00:05:51,019
point let's assume that Eilat is not in

123
00:05:51,019 --> 00:05:53,060
the borders of any version of Eretz Yisrael

124
00:05:53,339 --> 00:05:56,160
other than the modern state of Israel. So

125
00:05:56,160 --> 00:05:58,180
therefore with that in mind we're going to

126
00:05:58,180 --> 00:06:01,779
have to work with the famous Gemara that

127
00:06:01,779 --> 00:06:03,831
teaches us the foundations of Yom Tov Sheini

128
00:06:03,831 --> 00:06:12,019
shel Galuyos, which is source number 2. Of

129
00:06:12,019 --> 00:06:15,519
course the Yom Tov Sheini shel Galuyos question,

130
00:06:15,720 --> 00:06:16,819
whether Yom Tov should be one day or

131
00:06:16,819 --> 00:06:19,740
two days, starts with the fact that in

132
00:06:19,740 --> 00:06:21,339
the olden days in the time of the

133
00:06:21,339 --> 00:06:25,339
Sanhedrin the Rosh Chodesh was determined by eidus

134
00:06:25,339 --> 00:06:27,939
that would be testified in the Beis HaMikdash

135
00:06:28,160 --> 00:06:30,379
and then messages would be sent out from

136
00:06:30,379 --> 00:06:32,500
the Beis HaMikdash to the rest of Klal

137
00:06:32,500 --> 00:06:34,660
Yisrael in Eretz Yisrael and then outside of

138
00:06:34,660 --> 00:06:36,420
Eretz Yisrael as well and that would tell

139
00:06:36,420 --> 00:06:40,279
them when they should make Yom Tov ten

140
00:06:40,279 --> 00:06:42,139
days later for Yom Kippur, 15 days later

141
00:06:42,139 --> 00:06:44,040
for Sukkos and Pesach, six days later for

142
00:06:44,040 --> 00:06:47,079
Shavuos. Let's look at the Gemara inside because

143
00:06:47,079 --> 00:06:48,000
the end of the Gemara will be very

144
00:06:48,000 --> 00:06:51,948
important in our analysis. Yom Tov Sheini shel

145
00:06:51,948 --> 00:06:53,560
Galuyos, where do they come from? Why is

146
00:06:53,560 --> 00:06:58,360
there Yom Tov Sheini shel Galuyos? Detnan, there's

147
00:06:58,360 --> 00:07:00,139
the Gemara in Beitzah daled amud bais, source

148
00:07:00,139 --> 00:07:03,120
number 2. Barishona originally hayu masian masu'os, they

149
00:07:03,120 --> 00:07:06,680
would lift up fires on the hilltops. My

150
00:07:06,680 --> 00:07:08,339
son and I are familiar with the drive

151
00:07:08,339 --> 00:07:11,740
through from Yerushalayim to Tveria on kvish 90.

152
00:07:11,740 --> 00:07:15,240
90. Thank you, towards kvish 90. 90. We

153
00:07:15,240 --> 00:07:17,800
pass the big mountaintops, the very high mountaintops

154
00:07:17,800 --> 00:07:21,959
below Yericho where that mountaintop, what was it

155
00:07:21,959 --> 00:07:28,420
called? Not Yotvata, Sartava. Sartava and

156
00:07:28,420 --> 00:07:29,920
other such mountains that are mentioned in the

157
00:07:29,920 --> 00:07:32,160
mishnayos in Rosh Hashanah. But we know where

158
00:07:32,160 --> 00:07:33,939
some of these mountains, they're the tallest mountains

159
00:07:33,939 --> 00:07:36,100
going that would lead you all the way

160
00:07:36,100 --> 00:07:38,560
from Yerushalayim till Bavel. On the mountaintops they

161
00:07:38,560 --> 00:07:42,600
would raise these, light the fires to indicate

162
00:07:42,600 --> 00:07:44,500
that the Beis Din had decided that it

163
00:07:44,500 --> 00:07:47,480
was a new month. Mishekilklu HaKusim, right the

164
00:07:47,480 --> 00:07:49,040
Kusim played games with us and they started

165
00:07:49,040 --> 00:07:50,819
lighting fires on mountaintops even when it was

166
00:07:50,819 --> 00:07:53,540
not Rosh Chodesh. Hishkinu sheyislochim yotzin, they sent

167
00:07:53,540 --> 00:07:56,019
out messengers with secret codes and based on

168
00:07:56,019 --> 00:07:57,800
these messages when the messenger with the secret

169
00:07:57,800 --> 00:08:00,699
code would arrive from Yerushalayim they'd know that

170
00:08:00,699 --> 00:08:03,379
Yerushalayim was taka mekudash at whatever given day.

171
00:08:04,060 --> 00:08:09,203
Says the Gemara, Ve'ilu batlu Kusim avdinan chad

172
00:08:09,203 --> 00:08:14,660
yoma veHeicha de'matu shlochim avdinan chad yoma. Wherever

173
00:08:14,660 --> 00:08:17,800
the shlochim would arrive they knew exactly when

174
00:08:17,800 --> 00:08:19,519
Rosh Chodesh was, therefore they knew exactly when

175
00:08:19,519 --> 00:08:21,180
Yom Tov was. If you know exactly when

176
00:08:21,180 --> 00:08:22,959
Yom Tov is then you don't have to

177
00:08:22,959 --> 00:08:24,273
keep a second day. You know when Yom

178
00:08:24,273 --> 00:08:26,814
Tov is. Asks the Gemara, vehashtah deyad'inan bikvia

179
00:08:26,814 --> 00:08:30,180
deyarcha, the third line vehashtah deyad'inan bikvia deyarcha,

180
00:08:30,540 --> 00:08:32,120
we know when the kvius of the yerach

181
00:08:32,120 --> 00:08:35,899
is, we know when the new months are

182
00:08:36,139 --> 00:08:38,560
nowadays, we have a calendar. mai ta'ama avdinan

183
00:08:38,560 --> 00:08:42,620
trei yomei? Why do we have to still

184
00:08:42,620 --> 00:08:46,240
keep two days? I want to give you

185
00:08:46,240 --> 00:08:50,120
a little bit of history that the Ritva

186
00:08:50,120 --> 00:08:52,179
shared with us. If you look at page

187
00:08:52,179 --> 00:08:54,960
2, the Ritva in Beitzah, I'm sorry the

188
00:08:55,019 --> 00:08:56,259
Ritva in Rosh Hashanah yud ches amud aleph,

189
00:08:56,360 --> 00:08:57,620
I have it on towards the bottom of

190
00:08:57,620 --> 00:09:00,320
page 2 in the middle of source number

191
00:09:00,320 --> 00:09:03,980
7 in the italics. The Ritva explains this

192
00:09:03,980 --> 00:09:08,240
line of the Gemara in the italics. What

193
00:09:08,240 --> 00:09:12,659
happened? Aval achshav, you see the Ritva's lashon

194
00:09:12,659 --> 00:09:15,425
italics on the bottom of page 2, achshav

195
00:09:15,425 --> 00:09:17,879
bazman hazeh anu yodei bikvia deyarcha. He's explained

196
00:09:17,879 --> 00:09:19,259
the Gemara that we just mentioned and nowadays

197
00:09:19,259 --> 00:09:21,379
we do know when Rosh Chodesh is, we

198
00:09:21,379 --> 00:09:24,960
have a calendar. Why? sheharei amad Hillel HaZaken.

199
00:09:25,440 --> 00:09:28,000
Who and when was Hillel HaZaken? Says the

200
00:09:28,000 --> 00:09:31,380
Ritva, Hillel HaZaken was the Nasi acharon shehaya

201
00:09:31,380 --> 00:09:35,120
beYisrael. He was the final Nasi in that

202
00:09:35,120 --> 00:09:37,840
position of nesius of Klal Yisrael. He was

203
00:09:37,840 --> 00:09:40,815
beno shel Rebbi Yehuda Nasi ben beno shel

204
00:09:40,815 --> 00:09:43,220
Rabbeinu HaKadosh. So there's two Rebbi Yehuda HaNasi's.

205
00:09:43,600 --> 00:09:45,320
There's Rebbi Yehuda HaNasi Rabbeinu HaKadosh who wrote

206
00:09:45,320 --> 00:09:48,079
the mishnayos, his grandson was also Rebbi Yehuda

207
00:09:48,079 --> 00:09:51,471
HaNasi and his that son meaning Rebbi Yehuda

208
00:09:51,471 --> 00:09:55,259
HaNasi Rabbeinu HaKadosh great-grandson was Hillel HaZaken. Hillel

209
00:09:55,259 --> 00:09:58,059
HaZaken, so that's three generations after the mishnayos

210
00:09:58,059 --> 00:10:05,639
were written. So we're talking

211
00:10:08,460 --> 00:10:13,200
350 of the Common Era. Around 350 of

212
00:10:13,200 --> 00:10:14,659
the Common Era, give or take 20, 30

213
00:10:14,659 --> 00:10:20,980
years, what happened then? kesherah hasmichus

214
00:10:20,980 --> 00:10:24,187
mismatet, he realized that the people who are

215
00:10:24,187 --> 00:10:26,320
have smicha in order to be on the

216
00:10:26,320 --> 00:10:28,220
Beis Din to pasken the Rosh Chodesh you

217
00:10:28,220 --> 00:10:29,860
have to have smicha. If you have a

218
00:10:29,860 --> 00:10:31,019
Beis Din that doesn't, if you don't have

219
00:10:31,019 --> 00:10:33,740
a Beis Din of smuchim of official people

220
00:10:33,740 --> 00:10:36,480
with official smicha from Moshe Rabbenu, you can't

221
00:10:36,480 --> 00:10:39,240
do Kiddush HaChodesh. Once he saw that that

222
00:10:39,240 --> 00:10:42,019
institution of smicha was starting to weaken, there

223
00:10:42,019 --> 00:10:44,779
weren't as many people who had smicha, probably

224
00:10:44,779 --> 00:10:48,680
because of Roman persecution, v'shelo yiheyeh l'Yisrael Beis

225
00:10:48,680 --> 00:10:51,000
Din and therefore if that happens Bnei Yisrael

226
00:10:51,000 --> 00:10:52,179
won't have a Beis Din that could do

227
00:10:52,179 --> 00:10:54,750
Kiddush HaChodesh anymore. So keep in mind, Bnei

228
00:10:54,750 --> 00:10:57,240
Yisrael were mekadesh the Chodesh after Churban HaBayis

229
00:10:57,259 --> 00:11:01,289
for another nearly 300 years, right? The Churban

230
00:11:01,289 --> 00:11:02,480
HaBayis was in 70 of the Common Era,

231
00:11:02,519 --> 00:11:04,019
we're talking now 350 of the Common Era,

232
00:11:04,360 --> 00:11:06,720
so 280 years later they still were doing

233
00:11:06,720 --> 00:11:09,419
Kiddush HaChodesh al pi re'iya after Churban HaBayis

234
00:11:09,519 --> 00:11:13,174
for 280 years or so. So he realized,

235
00:11:13,174 --> 00:11:15,259
but it's going to, you know, he realized

236
00:11:15,259 --> 00:11:16,000
that it might not be able to continue

237
00:11:16,000 --> 00:11:18,067
too much longer. What did he do? amad

238
00:11:18,067 --> 00:11:22,419
v'iber kol hashanim he calculated all of the

239
00:11:22,419 --> 00:11:25,403
future years, al pi cheshbon, v'kidesh kol hachodashim

240
00:11:25,403 --> 00:11:29,000
v'kol hamoados. There at that time in the

241
00:11:29,000 --> 00:11:32,080
year whatever 350 of the Common Era, he

242
00:11:32,080 --> 00:11:34,259
sat down and figured out all the future

243
00:11:34,259 --> 00:11:36,639
months and all the future Yom Tovim and

244
00:11:36,639 --> 00:11:43,080
he was mekadesh all of them. This

245
00:11:43,080 --> 00:11:45,507
is what the Ritva says, what he says,

246
00:11:45,507 --> 00:11:49,019
ki mipnei hadochak rashai likboa kodem zmanim. Gemara

247
00:11:49,179 --> 00:11:52,220
in Sanhedrin 12b says you're allowed to be

248
00:11:52,980 --> 00:11:55,989
mekadesh a Chodesh before the Chodesh comes, v'gam

249
00:11:55,989 --> 00:11:58,534
shelo al pi re'iya. And the Gemara in

250
00:11:58,534 --> 00:12:01,053
Sanhedrin says you can also do it shelo

251
00:12:01,053 --> 00:12:10,139
al pi re'iya. So

252
00:12:10,139 --> 00:12:12,860
he took advantage of both those leniencies and

253
00:12:12,860 --> 00:12:18,960
to save the institution of our calendar, and

254
00:12:18,960 --> 00:12:20,759
the Ritva continues in the dot-dot-dot that I

255
00:12:20,759 --> 00:12:22,279
cut out, he says, and if not for

256
00:12:22,279 --> 00:12:23,659
him, who knows what would be with Klal

257
00:12:23,659 --> 00:12:25,480
Yisrael. So we all owe him a great

258
00:12:25,480 --> 00:12:27,580
deal of gratitude, says the Ritva, for doing

259
00:12:27,580 --> 00:12:29,120
that. Okay, so coming back to our shiur.

260
00:12:29,639 --> 00:12:33,460
Let's finish up source number two. So now

261
00:12:33,460 --> 00:12:37,299
that we know based on Hillel HaZaken calculations

262
00:12:37,299 --> 00:12:40,720
and established calendar, asks the Gemara in the

263
00:12:40,720 --> 00:12:43,123
third line: Hashta d'is lan b'keviya d'yarcha mai

264
00:12:43,123 --> 00:12:44,700
ta'ama avdinan trei yomei. If the whole reason

265
00:12:44,700 --> 00:12:46,331
for the two days of Yom Tov, Yom

266
00:12:46,331 --> 00:12:48,279
Tov Sheni shel Galuyos, is that people didn't

267
00:12:48,279 --> 00:12:50,799
know when Rosh Chodesh was, and therefore if

268
00:12:50,799 --> 00:12:53,340
they didn't get the message in time, they

269
00:12:53,340 --> 00:12:54,559
didn't know when Yom Tov should be, so

270
00:12:54,559 --> 00:12:55,580
they had to be on the safe, they

271
00:12:55,580 --> 00:12:57,580
had to practice two days Yom Tov out

272
00:12:57,580 --> 00:13:00,720
of safek. So if we don't have a

273
00:13:00,720 --> 00:13:02,779
safek anymore, we have a set calendar, why

274
00:13:02,779 --> 00:13:05,080
do we have Yom Tov Sheni? Answers the

275
00:13:05,080 --> 00:13:06,259
Gemara, this is the line that we're going

276
00:13:06,259 --> 00:13:08,700
to talk about tonight: mishum d'shalchu misam, they

277
00:13:08,700 --> 00:13:10,962
sent a message from Eretz Yisrael: hizaharu b'minhag

278
00:13:10,962 --> 00:13:16,139
avoseichem biyadeichem. You guys in chutz la'aretz better

279
00:13:16,139 --> 00:13:18,940
be careful with your minhag of your cities.

280
00:13:19,919 --> 00:13:22,759
Why? Why do you have to carry on

281
00:13:22,759 --> 00:13:25,940
your minhag? zimnin d'gazri shmada v'asi l'kilkulei. Because

282
00:13:25,940 --> 00:13:27,740
maybe you're going to be in galus, maybe

283
00:13:27,740 --> 00:13:33,019
in galus there'll be a shmad, and presumably

284
00:13:33,019 --> 00:13:36,600
that means you will forget the calculation, you'll

285
00:13:36,600 --> 00:13:39,980
forget the calendar that Hillel HaZaken established, and

286
00:13:39,980 --> 00:13:41,500
if you'll forget it, you're going to be

287
00:13:41,500 --> 00:13:43,000
in trouble, you're not going to know when

288
00:13:43,000 --> 00:13:46,360
Yom Tovim are. Just look at this line

289
00:13:46,360 --> 00:13:49,659
I underlined. What is he saying in this

290
00:13:49,659 --> 00:13:50,940
line? Are there two things or one thing

291
00:13:50,940 --> 00:13:56,028
here in this line that I underlined: hizaharu

292
00:13:56,028 --> 00:13:59,940
b'minhag avoseichem biyadeichem zimnin d'gazri shmada v'asi l'kilkulei.

293
00:14:01,039 --> 00:14:03,200
It sounds like there's one point. The one

294
00:14:03,200 --> 00:14:05,059
point is you better continue what your minhag

295
00:14:05,059 --> 00:14:06,320
is. Why do you have to continue your

296
00:14:06,320 --> 00:14:10,700
minhag? Because there's a concern that you might

297
00:14:10,700 --> 00:14:13,220
forget about the real way to figure out

298
00:14:13,460 --> 00:14:15,879
Yom Tovim, and therefore just keep on keeping

299
00:14:15,879 --> 00:14:21,120
two days just to protect yourselves. Okay, that's

300
00:14:21,120 --> 00:14:23,100
the Gemara. What I'd like to do now,

301
00:14:23,179 --> 00:14:24,139
we're going to do, it's going to be

302
00:14:24,139 --> 00:14:25,019
a little bit of a different kind of

303
00:14:25,019 --> 00:14:26,500
shiur tonight. I really just want to do

304
00:14:26,500 --> 00:14:28,539
two sources. We're going to have a Rambam,

305
00:14:28,820 --> 00:14:30,379
a bunch of halachos from the Rambam, and

306
00:14:30,379 --> 00:14:33,399
a Ritva. And that limud of the Rambam

307
00:14:33,399 --> 00:14:36,220
and the Ritva will yield two very different

308
00:14:36,220 --> 00:14:40,220
applications of what to do with the city

309
00:14:40,220 --> 00:14:44,460
of Eilat. We're going to come with very

310
00:14:44,460 --> 00:14:47,159
different conclusions. The Rambam gives us a very

311
00:14:47,159 --> 00:14:50,460
clear picture. This Rambam is very ma'arich, and

312
00:14:50,460 --> 00:14:52,179
he's very clear about giving you the whole

313
00:14:52,179 --> 00:14:55,679
history and the whole procedure how we should

314
00:14:55,679 --> 00:14:58,340
figure out how many days Yom Tov should

315
00:14:58,340 --> 00:15:00,879
be in each city. Based on different locations.

316
00:15:01,019 --> 00:15:02,379
And let's see, join me, source number three.

317
00:15:03,039 --> 00:15:04,220
We're going to go through a whole bunch

318
00:15:04,220 --> 00:15:06,200
of Rambams and point out things as we

319
00:15:06,200 --> 00:15:08,120
go through the Rambams and we'll see what

320
00:15:08,299 --> 00:15:10,440
Shittat Rambam will be. And after that we'll

321
00:15:10,440 --> 00:15:12,120
look at the Ritva in depth and we'll

322
00:15:12,120 --> 00:15:13,779
see what the Shittat HaRitva will be. And

323
00:15:13,779 --> 00:15:16,500
then you'll see that they're too they're they're

324
00:15:16,500 --> 00:15:21,147
totally they're totally different one from another. Kach

325
00:15:21,147 --> 00:15:23,926
sach Rambam behilchos kiddush hachodesh perek hey. K'shehaysa

326
00:15:23,926 --> 00:15:25,663
Sanhedrin kayemes vekov'in al har'iyah. When we had

327
00:15:25,663 --> 00:15:31,516
a Sanhedrin, hayu bnei Eretz Yisrael vechol hamakomos

328
00:15:31,516 --> 00:15:36,740
shemagi'in aleihem shluchei Tishrei. You're going to see

329
00:15:36,740 --> 00:15:38,940
that when we talk about messengers that are

330
00:15:38,940 --> 00:15:40,440
sent from Yerushalayim, the Rambam going to say

331
00:15:40,440 --> 00:15:42,720
anyone who could be reached within ten days

332
00:15:42,720 --> 00:15:47,379
was a city that would keep one day

333
00:15:47,379 --> 00:15:49,820
of Yom Tov. Anybody that would be reached

334
00:15:49,820 --> 00:15:52,039
in more than ten days would have to

335
00:15:52,039 --> 00:15:54,320
keep two days of Yom Tov. Where did

336
00:15:54,320 --> 00:15:56,700
these ten days come from? Ten days is

337
00:15:56,700 --> 00:15:58,279
the amount of travel days that you have

338
00:15:58,279 --> 00:16:02,899
during Tishrei because you can't travel to alert

339
00:16:02,899 --> 00:16:04,919
the rest of the golah, the rest of

340
00:16:04,919 --> 00:16:07,240
Klal Yisrael that it's Rosh Chodesh on one

341
00:16:07,240 --> 00:16:13,779
day of Rosh Hashanah, on a Shabbos, on

342
00:16:13,779 --> 00:16:15,480
a day of two days Rosh Hashanah maybe,

343
00:16:15,639 --> 00:16:18,120
two days Rosh Hashanah, a Shabbos, and Yom

344
00:16:18,120 --> 00:16:20,700
Kippur. So how many days do you have

345
00:16:20,700 --> 00:16:24,759
to travel before Pesach, before Succos? You have

346
00:16:24,759 --> 00:16:27,480
ten days because the 15th is already Succos,

347
00:16:27,580 --> 00:16:28,919
so you have 14 days before that. Four

348
00:16:28,919 --> 00:16:30,139
of them were used up for holidays there,

349
00:16:30,399 --> 00:16:31,740
for Shabbos Yom Tov that you're not allowed

350
00:16:31,740 --> 00:16:34,440
to travel. So there were ten travel days.

351
00:16:34,559 --> 00:16:38,159
So therefore, whenever you had ten travel, as

352
00:16:38,159 --> 00:16:39,279
far as you could get for ten travel

353
00:16:39,279 --> 00:16:41,379
days, that was the area that would be

354
00:16:41,379 --> 00:16:42,919
reached, that would know when to make Succos.

355
00:16:44,120 --> 00:16:46,182
That's what he says here. So that distance

356
00:16:46,182 --> 00:16:48,961
really doesn't necessarily tie into whether it's a

357
00:16:48,961 --> 00:16:53,700
part of Eretz Yisrael or not? That's what

358
00:16:53,700 --> 00:16:54,840
we're going to discuss. You'll see what the

359
00:16:54,840 --> 00:16:56,567
Rambam going to say about that. That's that's

360
00:16:56,567 --> 00:16:59,679
exactly where we're going. That will be part

361
00:16:59,679 --> 00:17:00,940
of, that will be a small part of

362
00:17:00,940 --> 00:17:03,117
where we're going. K'shehaysa Sanhedrin kayemes vekov'in al

363
00:17:03,117 --> 00:17:05,896
har'iyah hayu bnei Eretz Yisrael vechol makom shemagi'in

364
00:17:05,896 --> 00:17:08,119
aleihem shluchei Tishrei. That's why he says the

365
00:17:08,119 --> 00:17:11,267
word shluchei Tishrei not shluchei Nissan, because Nissan

366
00:17:11,267 --> 00:17:13,220
you have we only have whatever is in

367
00:17:13,220 --> 00:17:16,019
ten days. Osin Yom Tov yom echad bilvad,

368
00:17:16,019 --> 00:17:18,599
only one day of Yom Tov. However, shear

369
00:17:18,599 --> 00:17:26,559
hamakomos harachokos she'ein shluchei Tishrei magi'in aleihem but

370
00:17:26,559 --> 00:17:30,319
the further locations like in Persia, the Jews

371
00:17:30,319 --> 00:17:34,059
in Iran, right, the Jews in Iran are

372
00:17:34,059 --> 00:17:35,839
there since how long, how long have they

373
00:17:35,839 --> 00:17:40,980
been there? The Iranians, the Persian Jews have

374
00:17:40,980 --> 00:17:43,066
been there since Bayis Rishon, since galus Bayis

375
00:17:43,066 --> 00:17:45,220
Rishon. They've been there for, you know, they've

376
00:17:45,220 --> 00:17:49,019
been there for 800 years before, before Hillel

377
00:17:49,019 --> 00:17:50,700
sat down to figure out what to do.

378
00:17:50,819 --> 00:17:53,920
So they were mamash getting there the entirety,

379
00:17:54,400 --> 00:17:57,359
the entire 800 years of, I'm sorry, the

380
00:17:57,359 --> 00:17:59,640
400 years of Bayis Sheni and another 200

381
00:17:59,640 --> 00:18:03,599
years, another 300 years after Bayis Sheni. Those

382
00:18:03,599 --> 00:18:07,590
700 years they were getting messengers from Eretz

383
00:18:07,590 --> 00:18:11,039
Yisrael when Rosh Chodesh should be. And Iran,

384
00:18:11,420 --> 00:18:13,059
I mean everyone knows the map now because

385
00:18:13,059 --> 00:18:14,500
it's in the news all day long for

386
00:18:14,500 --> 00:18:17,759
the past week. You have Israel, then you

387
00:18:17,759 --> 00:18:20,819
have Syria, then you have Iraq, and then

388
00:18:20,819 --> 00:18:22,940
you get to Iran. And then where the

389
00:18:22,940 --> 00:18:24,400
Jews lived was a little bit, Iran is

390
00:18:24,400 --> 00:18:26,559
gigantic. So you have to pass through all

391
00:18:26,559 --> 00:18:29,180
of Syria, whatever, part of Eretz Yisrael, all

392
00:18:29,180 --> 00:18:30,720
of Syria, all of Iraq which is much

393
00:18:30,720 --> 00:18:32,380
bigger than Syria, and a good part of

394
00:18:32,380 --> 00:18:34,640
Iran which is much bigger than Syria and

395
00:18:34,640 --> 00:18:36,980
Iraq. So that's more than ten days. So

396
00:18:36,980 --> 00:18:39,640
the Persians weren't getting, all those Jews from

397
00:18:39,640 --> 00:18:44,019
Tehran and all those Jews from Mashhad and

398
00:18:44,019 --> 00:18:48,740
Isfahan, Hamadan where Mordechai ve'Esther are buried. They

399
00:18:48,740 --> 00:18:51,779
didn't get their messengers till could be weeks

400
00:18:51,779 --> 00:18:54,511
later. So they would have to keep two

401
00:18:54,511 --> 00:18:57,291
days because even though the shluchin were not

402
00:18:57,291 --> 00:18:58,333
sent over there? The shluchin were sent out

403
00:18:58,333 --> 00:19:04,582
every month. But the amount of... on Pesach

404
00:19:04,582 --> 00:19:09,444
because of... Rosh Chodesh you could travel, you

405
00:19:09,444 --> 00:19:10,834
had no Yom Kippur. Nevertheless the cutoff was

406
00:19:10,834 --> 00:19:14,819
ten days, correct. Okay, so the people that

407
00:19:14,819 --> 00:19:16,720
were like in Iran for example, in Bavel,

408
00:19:16,960 --> 00:19:18,680
would make two days misafek because they didn't

409
00:19:18,680 --> 00:19:20,900
know when Rosh Chodesh was. Let's look at

410
00:19:20,900 --> 00:19:23,559
Halacha Hey. Bizman hazeh she'ein sham Sanhedrin. We

411
00:19:23,559 --> 00:19:26,099
don't have Sanhedrin nowadays. So we would think

412
00:19:26,099 --> 00:19:28,047
that everybody should just follow the calendar. Haya

413
00:19:28,047 --> 00:19:30,826
min hadin sheyihyu bechol hamakomos osin yom tov

414
00:19:30,826 --> 00:19:33,119
echad. Aval. The next word is very important.

415
00:19:34,180 --> 00:19:35,859
Right, somebody asked me this week, somebody sent

416
00:19:35,859 --> 00:19:37,559
me a text message this week, he's a

417
00:19:37,559 --> 00:19:41,240
rebbe, a very chashuver rebbe of chashuve talmidim,

418
00:19:41,519 --> 00:19:42,880
and he said I got a question from

419
00:19:42,880 --> 00:19:45,579
a talmid, could you please send me in

420
00:19:45,579 --> 00:19:47,779
text form in just a few lines why

421
00:19:47,779 --> 00:19:51,319
do we keep Yom Tov Sheini? Everybody says

422
00:19:51,319 --> 00:19:53,613
it's minhag, right? Minhag avoseichem beyadeichem. Minhag avoseichem

423
00:19:53,613 --> 00:19:55,319
beyadeichem. Minhag avoseichem beyadeichem. Sounds like it's a

424
00:19:55,319 --> 00:19:59,182
din minhag, right? What is the lashon of

425
00:19:59,182 --> 00:19:59,559
the next word of the Rambam which I

426
00:19:59,559 --> 00:20:04,237
underlined for you? takonas chachamim hee sheyizharu beminhag

427
00:20:04,237 --> 00:20:08,099
avoseichem beyadeichem. Do you realize the gymnastics the

428
00:20:08,099 --> 00:20:10,220
Rambam just did? He just did a backwards

429
00:20:10,220 --> 00:20:12,919
flip. He took the gemara that says minhag

430
00:20:12,919 --> 00:20:15,400
avoseichem beyadeichem, he says that it's a takana

431
00:20:15,400 --> 00:20:18,460
to follow your minhag. Isn't that funny? It's

432
00:20:18,460 --> 00:20:20,779
a takana to follow your minhag. That changes

433
00:20:20,779 --> 00:20:22,740
things a little bit. That makes that ups

434
00:20:22,740 --> 00:20:23,839
the ante a little bit, it's not just

435
00:20:23,839 --> 00:20:26,720
a minhag, it's a takana that you have

436
00:20:26,720 --> 00:20:30,619
to follow the minhag. Okay, lefikach says the

437
00:20:30,619 --> 00:20:33,440
Rambam in halacha vav: kol makom shelo hayu

438
00:20:33,440 --> 00:20:36,480
shluchei tishrei magiin lo, any place that in

439
00:20:36,660 --> 00:20:39,079
the ten-day trip couldn't be reached by the

440
00:20:39,079 --> 00:20:41,079
shluchim, let's say let's talk about, you know,

441
00:20:41,140 --> 00:20:44,153
the Iranian the people in Tehran, yaasu shenei

442
00:20:44,153 --> 00:20:50,442
yamim afilu bazman hazeh. Certainly America. kemo

443
00:20:50,442 --> 00:20:53,657
shehayu osim bazman shebenei eretz yisrael kovein al

444
00:20:53,657 --> 00:20:55,119
hareiah just like they used to do when

445
00:20:55,119 --> 00:20:57,259
they had the Beis Hamikdash, they should do

446
00:20:57,259 --> 00:21:01,490
now because of this takana. However, uvenei eretz

447
00:21:01,490 --> 00:21:04,819
yisrael bazman hazeh osim yom echad, and the

448
00:21:04,819 --> 00:21:08,539
Israelis, you see what lashon he uses? Says

449
00:21:08,539 --> 00:21:11,079
that he's talking about Eretz Yisrael. Anybody in

450
00:21:11,079 --> 00:21:14,000
Eretz Yisrael bazman hazeh osim yom echad will

451
00:21:14,000 --> 00:21:17,471
do one day, kemin hagam shemeolam lo asu

452
00:21:17,471 --> 00:21:19,359
shenei yamim because Israelis only kept one day,

453
00:21:19,740 --> 00:21:22,880
so they'll continue to keep one day. Fine.

454
00:21:22,960 --> 00:21:24,440
Let's look at halacha tes. Now he's going

455
00:21:24,440 --> 00:21:30,359
to introduce something new. Until now we've been

456
00:21:30,359 --> 00:21:32,559
talking about how far are you from Yerushalayim?

457
00:21:32,619 --> 00:21:35,240
Are you a ten-days distance or more? Now

458
00:21:35,240 --> 00:21:36,955
he's going to introduce something new. ein asiyas

459
00:21:36,955 --> 00:21:39,579
yom tov echad that this idea of doing

460
00:21:39,579 --> 00:21:42,519
one Yom Tov or two days Yom Tov,

461
00:21:42,519 --> 00:21:45,839
teluya bikravas hamakom on closeness on geometric on

462
00:21:45,839 --> 00:21:52,039
on geographical proximity, the ten-day distance.

463
00:21:52,940 --> 00:21:54,940
Okay, so how so? I thought we've been

464
00:21:54,940 --> 00:21:58,627
saying whatever's within ten-days radius keeps one day

465
00:21:58,627 --> 00:22:00,059
and anything past the ten-days radius has to

466
00:22:00,059 --> 00:22:03,773
keep two days. I'll tell you. im yiheyeh

467
00:22:03,773 --> 00:22:07,359
makom beino uvein yerushalayim mahalach chamishah yamim, let's

468
00:22:07,359 --> 00:22:09,900
say there's a place five days away, ufachos

469
00:22:09,900 --> 00:22:13,900
shebevadai efshar sheyagiu lahem hashlichim, a place that's

470
00:22:13,900 --> 00:22:15,519
five days, you and I would say five

471
00:22:15,519 --> 00:22:16,759
days away is definitely going to keep one

472
00:22:16,759 --> 00:22:19,200
day, right? Because they are reached by the

473
00:22:20,759 --> 00:22:22,873
shluchim. Uh-uh. ein omrim sheanshei makom zeh osim

474
00:22:22,873 --> 00:22:24,740
yom tov echad. We're not necessarily going to

475
00:22:24,740 --> 00:22:26,920
say they should keep one day because look

476
00:22:26,920 --> 00:22:32,660
at this new wrinkle that the Rambam introduces.

477
00:22:32,859 --> 00:22:36,157
I underlined it for you. shema lo hayu

478
00:22:36,157 --> 00:22:40,579
hashlichim yotzin lemakom zeh. Maybe the shluchim didn't

479
00:22:40,579 --> 00:22:44,554
go to that city. Why not? mipnei shelo

480
00:22:44,554 --> 00:22:45,597
hayu sham yisrael because there were no Jews

481
00:22:45,597 --> 00:22:52,279
there. veachar shechazru likboa al hacheshbon, maybe

482
00:22:52,279 --> 00:22:56,208
only later yashvu sham yisraelim shechayavim laasos shenei

483
00:22:56,208 --> 00:22:58,359
yamim. And if you know that there were,

484
00:22:58,359 --> 00:23:02,720
if that's Alexandria, if that's clear, if you

485
00:23:02,720 --> 00:23:04,759
know it's within ten days and there were

486
00:23:04,759 --> 00:23:06,779
Jews there, then it's only keep one day.

487
00:23:06,779 --> 00:23:08,079
So when the Rambam was in Egypt, he

488
00:23:08,079 --> 00:23:15,400
kept only one day. Correct. Correct. 100%

489
00:23:15,400 --> 00:23:18,559
correct. And he'll say that soon, I believe.

490
00:23:19,180 --> 00:23:23,220
He'll say that soon explicitly. If Alexandria is

491
00:23:23,220 --> 00:23:27,619
indeed 10-day walk from Yerushalayim. We'll see. Okay,

492
00:23:27,640 --> 00:23:28,480
but he's going to talk about it more

493
00:23:28,480 --> 00:23:30,619
explicitly. What he just said is something incredible.

494
00:23:30,700 --> 00:23:32,859
He just said that the 10- the 10-day

495
00:23:33,359 --> 00:23:35,180
travel is not that you have to be

496
00:23:35,180 --> 00:23:37,220
10 days away in order to keep only

497
00:23:37,220 --> 00:23:39,519
one day of Yom Tov, it's the fact

498
00:23:39,519 --> 00:23:42,200
that the shluchim actually came to your city.

499
00:23:42,839 --> 00:23:44,380
Which means two things: A, that they have

500
00:23:44,380 --> 00:23:45,299
to be able to get there within 10

501
00:23:45,299 --> 00:23:47,779
days, and B, that there were Jews there,

502
00:23:47,779 --> 00:23:49,539
there was a Jewish population at the time

503
00:23:49,539 --> 00:23:52,240
of the Beis Hamikdash. So let's pause for

504
00:23:52,240 --> 00:23:54,960
a second. Let's say you have a city

505
00:23:54,960 --> 00:24:00,099
like Tel Aviv. No, it's not talking about

506
00:24:00,099 --> 00:24:01,700
Tel Aviv yet. We'll talk about that in

507
00:24:01,700 --> 00:24:05,962
like a minute. Some city in Syria, Sidon,

508
00:24:05,962 --> 00:24:09,799
in Lebanon. And let's say there were no

509
00:24:09,799 --> 00:24:12,140
Jews there. What? I want to say that

510
00:24:12,140 --> 00:24:14,839
there were no Jews. No Jews but still

511
00:24:14,839 --> 00:24:17,759
within a 10-day walk. What? Petra. Petra, great,

512
00:24:18,039 --> 00:24:22,680
Petra, fine. Petra's a gambling place, nobody they

513
00:24:22,680 --> 00:24:25,407
gamble in Petra, right? There's gambling in Jordan,

514
00:24:25,407 --> 00:24:27,440
people all the Israelis go to Jordan to

515
00:24:27,440 --> 00:24:29,740
gamble now, right? There's Petra, a casino, yeah,

516
00:24:29,819 --> 00:24:31,279
yeah, yeah. Okay, so it's not a place

517
00:24:31,279 --> 00:24:34,079
for Jewish boys, right? Just like Las Vegas

518
00:24:34,079 --> 00:24:36,480
isn't, even though there's a burgeoning Jewish community

519
00:24:36,480 --> 00:24:40,700
in Las Vegas. So Petra. Petra is within

520
00:24:40,799 --> 00:24:46,400
10-day walk from Yerushalayim, let's assume. But it's

521
00:24:46,400 --> 00:24:48,640
there are no Jews there. So according to

522
00:24:48,640 --> 00:24:51,240
the Rambam, how many days would you have

523
00:24:51,240 --> 00:24:54,779
to keep in Petra? Well, shluchim didn't come,

524
00:24:54,880 --> 00:24:57,259
so you keep two days. So the point

525
00:24:57,259 --> 00:24:58,940
is not the distance. The point is that

526
00:24:58,940 --> 00:25:00,654
shluchim got there. In order for In order

527
00:25:00,654 --> 00:25:00,839
shluchim to get there, it has to be

528
00:25:00,839 --> 00:25:02,500
within the distance, but it also has to

529
00:25:02,500 --> 00:25:05,400
be a Jewish community. Ah, I wrote here

530
00:25:05,400 --> 00:25:06,740
Brisk. I heard on a tape, who was

531
00:25:06,740 --> 00:25:08,359
I listening to? A lot of times what

532
00:25:08,359 --> 00:25:10,319
I do when I'm preparing a shiur for

533
00:25:10,319 --> 00:25:11,500
Thursday night and I work through the sugya

534
00:25:11,500 --> 00:25:13,240
myself, during the course of the week while

535
00:25:13,240 --> 00:25:15,019
I'm driving, I try to listen to shiurim

536
00:25:15,019 --> 00:25:17,660
on the topic also to sort of hear

537
00:25:17,660 --> 00:25:20,440
what other people said. I heard, I think

538
00:25:20,440 --> 00:25:23,059
from Rabbi Rakafet has a tape on this,

539
00:25:23,099 --> 00:25:25,140
he comes here every July to speak every

540
00:25:25,140 --> 00:25:27,909
summer. He quoted, he worked through the sugya

541
00:25:27,909 --> 00:25:30,259
b'iyun and he quotes a minhag from the

542
00:25:30,259 --> 00:25:33,420
Brisker Rav. The Brisker Rav was machmir in

543
00:25:33,420 --> 00:25:37,127
Geula. How far is Geula from the Beit

544
00:25:37,127 --> 00:25:40,980
HaMikdash? Pretty far? 15 minutes? 15 minutes walk?

545
00:25:43,160 --> 00:25:45,839
Geula. Geula, you know like Meah Shearim and

546
00:25:45,839 --> 00:25:49,259
Geula. It's about a 14-minute walk, an 18-minute

547
00:25:49,339 --> 00:25:52,720
walk. He was makpid to not do melacha

548
00:25:52,720 --> 00:25:54,740
on Yom Tov Sheni shel Galuyot. He was

549
00:25:54,740 --> 00:25:56,039
makpid for Yom Tov Sheni shel Galuyot in

550
00:25:56,039 --> 00:25:58,279
Geula. Why? Because of this Rambam we just

551
00:25:58,279 --> 00:26:00,079
read. He said how do we know that

552
00:26:00,079 --> 00:26:03,000
Jews lived right over here in Geula? We

553
00:26:03,000 --> 00:26:04,920
know they lived in the Old City. Good.

554
00:26:05,959 --> 00:26:08,000
Maybe they lived in some other place in

555
00:26:08,000 --> 00:26:09,039
Jerusalem? How do you know that they lived

556
00:26:09,039 --> 00:26:11,460
in Geula? How do you know they lived

557
00:26:11,460 --> 00:26:14,740
in Meah Shearim? Meah Shearim is just like

558
00:26:14,740 --> 00:26:18,599
far away. It's just like Lawrence. It's just

559
00:26:18,599 --> 00:26:23,339
like Moscow. How do you know Jews lived

560
00:26:23,339 --> 00:26:26,279
there? Is that wild? Is that a wild

561
00:26:26,279 --> 00:26:28,380
chumra? Who said the Rambam is talking about

562
00:26:29,519 --> 00:26:31,559
in Eretz Yisrael? The Rambam specifically is not

563
00:26:31,559 --> 00:26:34,427
talking about in Eretz Yisrael. We'll get to

564
00:26:34,427 --> 00:26:36,180
it. Okay, fine, so he'll say it explicitly.

565
00:26:36,500 --> 00:26:40,728
He'll say it explicitly about Eretz Yisrael. aval

566
00:26:40,728 --> 00:26:43,194
b'Eretz Yisrael bizman hazeh osim yom echad afilu

567
00:26:43,194 --> 00:26:49,359
bimkomot she'asu shenayim. But maybe,

568
00:26:49,400 --> 00:26:50,559
no, no, that's not clear because that could

569
00:26:50,559 --> 00:26:51,900
be the part of Eretz Yisrael where Jews

570
00:26:51,900 --> 00:26:55,259
lived. So that's not clear. The communities that

571
00:26:55,259 --> 00:26:58,480
did not exist in the time of Beit

572
00:26:58,480 --> 00:27:01,900
HaMikdash? Even though they're two minutes away from

573
00:27:01,900 --> 00:27:04,442
or ten minutes away from? That is correct.

574
00:27:04,442 --> 00:27:06,940
That seems to be shitat HaRambam. That seems

575
00:27:06,940 --> 00:27:08,819
to be shitat HaRambam. The point that the

576
00:27:09,019 --> 00:27:11,099
Brisker Rav was mechadesh that I think Rav

577
00:27:11,099 --> 00:27:12,960
Shlomo Zalman and I think everybody else would

578
00:27:12,960 --> 00:27:16,380
assume not like that is: you think the

579
00:27:16,380 --> 00:27:19,819
Beit HaMikdash was there and in Geula area

580
00:27:19,819 --> 00:27:23,960
you don't think Jews lived there? It's like,

581
00:27:26,680 --> 00:27:28,640
it's like Wall Street is, whatever, I mean

582
00:27:28,839 --> 00:27:30,539
I don't have to think of examples. The

583
00:27:30,539 --> 00:27:33,019
Beit HaMikdash is there, operational, functional, Jews are

584
00:27:33,019 --> 00:27:34,900
in control of Eretz Yisrael, and 15 minutes

585
00:27:34,900 --> 00:27:36,694
away you don't think real estate is, you

586
00:27:36,694 --> 00:27:39,127
know, is, you know? You go to Jackson

587
00:27:39,127 --> 00:27:43,474
or. Right, in Lakewood, they're already out, they're

588
00:27:43,474 --> 00:27:46,839
already in Jackson township. Fine, those who have

589
00:27:46,839 --> 00:27:55,259
Lakewood connections understand that. Continues the Rambam. This

590
00:27:55,259 --> 00:27:58,339
relates to your question about the Rambam living

591
00:27:58,339 --> 00:28:01,004
in Alexandria. v'ilu haya hadavar talui b'kiruv hamakom,

592
00:28:01,004 --> 00:28:02,839
if it was just a matter of geographic

593
00:28:02,839 --> 00:28:06,151
proximity, hayu kol bnei Mitzrayim osim yom echad,

594
00:28:06,539 --> 00:28:09,619
all of Egypt would do one day. Why?

595
00:28:09,619 --> 00:28:12,839
sheharei efshar sheyagio lahem shluchei Tishrei, because all

596
00:28:12,839 --> 00:28:15,107
of Egypt is accessible within ten days. shebein

597
00:28:15,107 --> 00:28:18,220
Yerushalayim u'Mitzrayim derech Ashkelon. If you travel through

598
00:28:18,220 --> 00:28:21,279
the Ashkelon route from Jerusalem, which actually works,

599
00:28:21,279 --> 00:28:22,319
by the way, if you know Ashkelon is

600
00:28:22,319 --> 00:28:23,799
on the border a little bit south, south,

601
00:28:24,480 --> 00:28:27,119
so you just go straight down to Ashkelon,

602
00:28:27,160 --> 00:28:29,640
down to Gaza. That's the fastest way to

603
00:28:29,640 --> 00:28:32,079
get to Mitzrayim pretty much, it's almost the

604
00:28:32,079 --> 00:28:34,784
fastest way. ela mahalach shmona yamim o pachos,

605
00:28:34,839 --> 00:28:37,319
it's eight days max to get to Egypt.

606
00:28:38,299 --> 00:28:40,500
So therefore why in Egypt would we only

607
00:28:40,500 --> 00:28:43,119
do, why if we sit in Egypt do

608
00:28:43,119 --> 00:28:44,640
we do two days? Maybe they keep two

609
00:28:44,640 --> 00:28:48,279
days? Why? Not because it's too far away,

610
00:28:48,279 --> 00:28:51,767
but because maybe in the time of the

611
00:28:51,767 --> 00:28:53,400
Beit HaMikdash there were no Jews in Alexandria.

612
00:28:53,400 --> 00:28:55,353
But there were. In the time of Beit

613
00:28:55,353 --> 00:28:57,279
HaMikdash? Yeah. Okay, so maybe he did keep

614
00:28:57,279 --> 00:28:59,779
one day. Now he's coming to that. That

615
00:28:59,779 --> 00:29:01,099
was in the time of the Gemara. Was

616
00:29:01,220 --> 00:29:02,849
it the time of the Beit HaMikdash? Yeah,

617
00:29:02,849 --> 00:29:03,891
Bayit Sheni is brought down. Yeah, Bayit Sheni.

618
00:29:04,220 --> 00:29:06,400
Okay, fine. Right. The flag that they waved

619
00:29:06,400 --> 00:29:08,880
was a Mishna or a Gemara? It's a

620
00:29:08,880 --> 00:29:13,700
Braisa. It's in Gemara. Okay, great. ushnayim. And

621
00:29:13,700 --> 00:29:15,240
then he says: v'chen rov Surya, the majority

622
00:29:15,240 --> 00:29:17,900
of Syria. Also, again, Syria is not so

623
00:29:17,900 --> 00:29:20,009
big and Syria is right adjacent, you know,

624
00:29:20,009 --> 00:29:21,259
it's also within a ten-day. So again, if

625
00:29:21,259 --> 00:29:22,720
people didn't live there, so you're not going

626
00:29:22,720 --> 00:29:25,599
to be able to have one-day Yom Tov.

627
00:29:27,560 --> 00:29:32,259
Nimtza. Fine. Let's go now to, I broke

628
00:29:32,259 --> 00:29:34,079
this Rambam into pieces. Let's go to source

629
00:29:34,079 --> 00:29:35,480
number five in this Rambam, which is the

630
00:29:35,480 --> 00:29:37,437
middle of Halacha Yud Alef. v'chol makom shebeino

631
00:29:37,437 --> 00:29:40,216
uvein Yerushalayim, any place between there and Yerushalayim,

632
00:29:40,216 --> 00:29:42,995
mahalach asara yamim beshava o pachos, ten days

633
00:29:42,995 --> 00:29:45,774
or less, she'efshar shehashluchim yagio elav, where it's

634
00:29:45,774 --> 00:29:48,554
possible if that's the distance, so people might

635
00:29:48,554 --> 00:29:58,799
be able, the shaliach might be

636
00:29:58,799 --> 00:30:01,244
able to arrive there, ro'im. Now this is

637
00:30:01,244 --> 00:30:04,023
where the words get a little bit difficult.

638
00:30:08,192 --> 00:30:10,971
*Im oto makom me'eretz yisrael shehayu bo yisrael

639
00:30:10,971 --> 00:30:11,319
besha'at hayerushah bekibush sheini* if it's in Israel

640
00:30:11,319 --> 00:30:11,319
and there were Jewish people living there, *kegon*

641
00:30:11,319 --> 00:30:13,909
he gives some cities like Lod *Lod*, *Yavne*,

642
00:30:14,257 --> 00:30:15,994
*Tveria*, then osim yom echad *osim yom echad*.

643
00:30:15,994 --> 00:30:18,371
If it's within ten days and, sorry, if

644
00:30:18,371 --> 00:30:20,079
it's within ten days and Jews are living

645
00:30:20,079 --> 00:30:23,791
there, then it's one day. *Veim oto makom

646
00:30:23,791 --> 00:30:30,380
miSuria* *kegon Tzor* *veDamesek* *Ashkelon*... what? *Ashkelon*'s

647
00:30:30,380 --> 00:30:33,027
in *Suria*? Didn't he just say three halachos,

648
00:30:33,027 --> 00:30:34,660
*halachos* ago *Ashkelon*'s on the way to *Mitzrayim*?

649
00:30:36,080 --> 00:30:37,539
Maybe there were two *Ashkelon*s, that's what some

650
00:30:37,539 --> 00:30:41,539
of the *acharonim* say, yeah. Chutz LaAretz *O

651
00:30:41,539 --> 00:30:45,708
michutz la'aretz o betoch chutz la'aretz* *osim keminhag

652
00:30:45,708 --> 00:30:51,961
avoseihem beyadeihem* *im yom echad yom echad* *im

653
00:30:51,961 --> 00:30:53,351
shenei yamim shenei yamim*. You know what the

654
00:30:53,351 --> 00:30:53,351
Rambam *Rambam* just said? That there are going

655
00:30:53,351 --> 00:30:55,079
to be parts of Chutz LaAretz. *chutz la'aretz*

656
00:30:57,900 --> 00:30:59,539
that will, some places will keep one day,

657
00:30:59,619 --> 00:31:03,307
some places will keep two days. That would

658
00:31:03,307 --> 00:31:05,044
be very strange. That, that we're going to

659
00:31:05,044 --> 00:31:05,200
get in a minute. Yeah, he's going to

660
00:31:05,200 --> 00:31:06,880
say it explicitly in the next line. So

661
00:31:06,880 --> 00:31:10,160
I pointed out in the English that there

662
00:31:10,160 --> 00:31:12,380
are going to be cities in *Suria*, Damascus,

663
00:31:12,380 --> 00:31:14,440
I assume where Jews were living in Damascus,

664
00:31:15,640 --> 00:31:18,444
should keep B'zman hazeh. *bazman hazeh* one day

665
00:31:18,444 --> 00:31:24,660
of *Pesach*, one day of *yom tov*.

666
00:31:24,980 --> 00:31:26,579
We have to ask, we have to go

667
00:31:26,579 --> 00:31:29,980
to Ocean Parkway and Avenue S and ask

668
00:31:29,980 --> 00:31:33,559
the Syrians there because their grandparents came from

669
00:31:33,559 --> 00:31:36,019
Damascus I'm assuming, and ask them if they

670
00:31:36,019 --> 00:31:37,494
kept one day or two days *yom tov*,

671
00:31:37,494 --> 00:31:39,359
you know just the, you know forty years

672
00:31:39,359 --> 00:31:44,380
ago before they moved onto Ocean Parkway. Let's

673
00:31:44,380 --> 00:31:46,640
see number six, *Halacha yud-bet* in the *Rambam*.

674
00:31:47,419 --> 00:31:51,666
What about a place Yerushalayim *shebeino uvein Yerushalayim

675
00:31:51,666 --> 00:31:51,847
asara yamim o pachos me'asara* less than ten

676
00:31:51,847 --> 00:31:54,974
days, chutz la'aretz, minhag? *vehu Suria o chutz

677
00:31:54,974 --> 00:31:54,974
la'aretz ve'ein lahem minhag* if it's a place

678
00:31:54,974 --> 00:31:57,000
that doesn't have a minhag. *minhag*, so it's

679
00:31:57,000 --> 00:31:57,660
not going to be able to follow minhag.

680
00:31:57,660 --> 00:31:59,740
*minhag*. Oh, and this is the punchline, think

681
00:31:59,900 --> 00:32:04,174
Eilat *Eilat* right now, think Eilat *Eilat*. Eretz

682
00:32:04,174 --> 00:32:05,911
Yisrael? *O shehi ir shenitchadsha bemidbar eretz yisrael*

683
00:32:05,911 --> 00:32:07,947
a new city in the desert of Eretz

684
00:32:07,947 --> 00:32:12,811
Yisrael *Eretz Yisrael* aka Eilat. *Eilat*, *o makom

685
00:32:12,811 --> 00:32:14,480
sheshachnu bo yisrael ata* or a place that

686
00:32:14,480 --> 00:32:18,939
Jews just began settling more recently, rov. *osim

687
00:32:18,939 --> 00:32:20,674
shenei yamim keminhag rov ha'olam*. In Eretz Yisrael

688
00:32:20,674 --> 00:32:23,514
*Eretz Yisrael*? *Ma'aleh Adumim* maybe, yeah, yeah, yeah,

689
00:32:25,720 --> 00:32:27,880
*Ma'aleh Adumim* is probably had a settlement. They

690
00:32:27,880 --> 00:32:31,099
didn't have a settlement there? No. Yeah, they

691
00:32:31,099 --> 00:32:32,407
didn't have a settlement. It's a good strategic

692
00:32:32,407 --> 00:32:34,819
location, it's not a mountaintop. Okay. *Osim shenei*...

693
00:32:35,660 --> 00:32:41,904
ah, that's correct. *Hasair hamishtaleach* was over

694
00:32:41,904 --> 00:32:43,641
there right at *eretz gezeira* you're saying. Right.

695
00:32:43,641 --> 00:32:46,839
Ah, interesting, yeah. You there, we did ATVs

696
00:32:46,839 --> 00:32:49,640
in there. We went, when I went with

697
00:32:49,640 --> 00:32:52,500
our group, our summer program, we went ATVing

698
00:32:52,500 --> 00:32:56,240
in the desert and they actually identified right

699
00:32:56,240 --> 00:32:59,400
outside of *Ma'aleh Adumim* and they identified what

700
00:32:59,400 --> 00:33:01,140
they believe, it was probably based on the

701
00:33:01,140 --> 00:33:03,440
measurements from Yerushalayim *Yerushalayim* in the right direction,

702
00:33:04,039 --> 00:33:06,539
a configuration that would make sense, what they

703
00:33:06,539 --> 00:33:10,940
assume would be the *Azazel* hill, *Azazel* cliff.

704
00:33:10,940 --> 00:33:13,339
It was either that or they just wanted

705
00:33:13,339 --> 00:33:15,900
to get money from Americans to go on

706
00:33:15,900 --> 00:33:20,900
their ATV expedition, one of the two. So

707
00:33:20,900 --> 00:33:22,079
what do you see from here? You see

708
00:33:22,079 --> 00:33:24,140
that according to the *shitas HaRambam*, it sounds

709
00:33:24,140 --> 00:33:26,559
certainly from this very last *halacha*, a new

710
00:33:26,559 --> 00:33:29,440
city in the desert. Even if it is

711
00:33:29,440 --> 00:33:31,920
Eretz Yisrael *Eretz Yisrael*. We said before it's

712
00:33:31,920 --> 00:33:33,539
probably not Eretz Yisrael. *Eretz Yisrael*. But even

713
00:33:33,539 --> 00:33:34,954
if it would be in Eretz Yisrael *Eretz

714
00:33:34,954 --> 00:33:35,680
Yisrael*, if you have a new city in

715
00:33:35,680 --> 00:33:37,700
the desert that Jews never lived there, so

716
00:33:37,700 --> 00:33:38,819
that means the shluchim *shluchim* in the time

717
00:33:38,819 --> 00:33:39,799
of the Beis HaMikdash? *Beis HaMikdash* didn't go

718
00:33:39,799 --> 00:33:41,740
there not because they couldn't get there, but

719
00:33:41,740 --> 00:33:43,259
because there was no reason to go there

720
00:33:43,259 --> 00:33:44,980
in the time of the *Beis HaMikdash*, they

721
00:33:44,980 --> 00:33:49,079
would follow, they would not have this one

722
00:33:49,079 --> 00:33:51,420
day leniency, they would keep two days. The

723
00:33:51,420 --> 00:33:53,367
shluchim *shluchim* never got there. According to *shitas

724
00:33:53,367 --> 00:33:56,000
HaRambam* it seems to be eminently clear that

725
00:33:56,000 --> 00:33:58,299
Eilat. *Eilat* should be according to *shitas HaRambam*

726
00:33:58,299 --> 00:34:45,420
two days of

727
00:34:55,260 --> 00:34:57,940
Yom Tov Sheni Shel Galuyot. *yom tov sheni

728
00:34:57,940 --> 00:35:01,099
shel galuyos*. needs Yom Tov Sheni Shel Galuyot?

729
00:35:01,659 --> 00:35:04,360
That's where things are right now. Now, we

730
00:35:04,360 --> 00:35:07,079
finished the Rambam. Wait, there's one day that

731
00:35:07,079 --> 00:35:08,747
Jews did live in a place there. Would

732
00:35:08,747 --> 00:35:10,929
that work? Don't know, don't know, probably not.

733
00:35:10,929 --> 00:35:14,179
Okay, let's see source number seven. Source number

734
00:35:14,179 --> 00:35:15,900
seven is the Ritva. The Ritva is going

735
00:35:15,900 --> 00:35:20,099
to ask a very simple question and we'll

736
00:35:20,099 --> 00:35:21,480
see his answer and we're going to come

737
00:35:21,480 --> 00:35:23,474
out with something very different than the Rambam.

738
00:35:23,474 --> 00:35:24,883
Says the Ritva on Rosh Hashanah daf yud

739
00:35:24,883 --> 00:35:34,880
ches amud alef, ve-yesh od she'eilah gedolah. What

740
00:35:34,880 --> 00:35:36,260
bothers me about the Ritva is the Ritva

741
00:35:36,260 --> 00:35:39,179
assumes something that we who know what the

742
00:35:39,179 --> 00:35:41,599
map of Israel looks like might be bothered

743
00:35:41,599 --> 00:35:44,047
by. Chazal say that how big is Eretz

744
00:35:44,047 --> 00:35:48,320
Yisrael 400 parsaos. 400 parsaos times 400 parsaos.

745
00:35:50,360 --> 00:35:55,659
A parsa is how much is that? 400

746
00:35:55,659 --> 00:36:00,688
parsaos is 400 parsaos. He says it's mahalach

747
00:36:00,688 --> 00:36:06,775
esrim yom le-adam beinoni

748
00:36:06,775 --> 00:36:12,880
she-zeh asarah parsaos. Either way, it's

749
00:36:12,880 --> 00:36:14,619
a very large area. First of all, it's

750
00:36:14,619 --> 00:36:16,179
a square area and Eretz Yisrael as we

751
00:36:16,179 --> 00:36:17,780
know it today is not square, unless the

752
00:36:17,780 --> 00:36:21,820
shape was different then. Secondly, meaning it includes

753
00:36:21,820 --> 00:36:24,679
more areas, but we know, I mean the

754
00:36:24,679 --> 00:36:28,780
Torah says that the Jordan River is the

755
00:36:28,780 --> 00:36:31,619
easternmost border, so you can't get... it's between

756
00:36:31,619 --> 00:36:32,900
the Mediterranean and the Jordan, there ain't no

757
00:36:32,900 --> 00:36:35,380
400 parsaos there. So he's going to be

758
00:36:35,380 --> 00:36:38,159
using this as a calculation, and we know

759
00:36:38,159 --> 00:36:40,280
the numbers don't work for the map that

760
00:36:40,280 --> 00:36:41,219
we know, so it's going to be a

761
00:36:41,219 --> 00:36:42,460
little bit difficult, but you'll see the lomdus,

762
00:36:42,460 --> 00:36:45,219
and the lomdus will perhaps still apply. Asks

763
00:36:45,219 --> 00:36:49,699
the Ritva something very simple. He says it's

764
00:36:49,699 --> 00:36:51,840
impossible that all of Eretz Yisrael could be

765
00:36:51,840 --> 00:36:54,460
reached within 10 days. Funny, because the Rambam

766
00:36:54,460 --> 00:36:57,440
said the opposite, right? Actually true because we

767
00:36:57,440 --> 00:37:02,460
go ahead and... you're right, because the Rambam

768
00:37:02,460 --> 00:37:07,059
said explicitly not that way. Oh you're right,

769
00:37:07,820 --> 00:37:09,360
yes, the Ritva brings that proof. He says

770
00:37:09,360 --> 00:37:11,340
15 days for people to go back home.

771
00:37:11,340 --> 00:37:14,119
Yep. 15 days for the... Motzaei Sukkos 15

772
00:37:14,119 --> 00:37:17,000
days after the... could be, yes, yes, yes,

773
00:37:17,019 --> 00:37:19,559
15 days to go back home, right. 15

774
00:37:19,559 --> 00:37:21,800
days after the regel, you want to give

775
00:37:21,800 --> 00:37:23,320
people up to 15 days to go back

776
00:37:23,320 --> 00:37:26,099
home, right. So that's even more of a

777
00:37:26,099 --> 00:37:28,878
kashya, because it could be a person could

778
00:37:28,878 --> 00:37:31,657
do it in 10 days but he's with

779
00:37:31,657 --> 00:37:31,657
his kids like the scenic... like when you're

780
00:37:31,657 --> 00:37:32,460
driving away from vacation you stop at the

781
00:37:32,460 --> 00:37:37,139
scenic overlook. Bathroom every... I hear. Okay, I'm

782
00:37:37,139 --> 00:37:40,219
not getting into that. Asks the Ritva a

783
00:37:40,219 --> 00:37:46,579
she'eilah gedolah. He says why are you... wherever

784
00:37:46,579 --> 00:37:49,260
the shluchim got, that's as far as you

785
00:37:49,260 --> 00:37:50,880
would only have to keep one day, because

786
00:37:50,880 --> 00:37:52,710
the shluchim. informed the people exactly when Rosh

787
00:37:52,710 --> 00:37:55,260
Chodesh was. The problem was, even Eretz Yisrael

788
00:37:55,260 --> 00:37:56,619
they were not able... they should not have

789
00:37:56,619 --> 00:37:57,900
been able to reach all of Eretz Yisrael

790
00:37:57,900 --> 00:38:00,679
Because if Eretz Yisrael is 400 parsa by

791
00:38:00,679 --> 00:38:03,219
400 parsa, that means let's say Yerushalayim is

792
00:38:03,219 --> 00:38:05,179
smack in the middle, let's say. Let's imagine

793
00:38:05,460 --> 00:38:06,679
is smack in the middle. That means there's

794
00:38:06,679 --> 00:38:11,139
a 200 parsa radius. How long does it

795
00:38:11,139 --> 00:38:14,059
take to walk 200 parsaos? Says the Ritva,

796
00:38:15,019 --> 00:38:17,347
I'm sorry, 400 parsaos, so there's a 200...

797
00:38:17,347 --> 00:38:20,854
right, 200 parsa radius and she-mahalach esrim yom

798
00:38:20,854 --> 00:38:25,199
le-adam, which would be a 20-day walk. A

799
00:38:25,199 --> 00:38:27,440
person, normal person walks Chazal say 10 parsaos

800
00:38:27,440 --> 00:38:30,199
a day, so 200 parsa radius would be

801
00:38:30,199 --> 00:38:35,000
a 20-day walk. And that means to go

802
00:38:35,000 --> 00:38:36,960
from to the edges, to the corners of

803
00:38:36,960 --> 00:38:39,239
Eretz Yisrael should take 20 days. That means

804
00:38:39,239 --> 00:38:41,590
there should be a good half of Eretz

805
00:38:41,590 --> 00:38:44,749
Yisrael that's not reached. Why did they walk?

806
00:38:44,749 --> 00:38:47,528
Why didn't they go by fast horse? I

807
00:38:47,528 --> 00:38:50,308
mean, they walk. Pony Express back then. You

808
00:38:50,308 --> 00:38:54,719
sent shluchim on foot. So that's a good

809
00:38:54,719 --> 00:38:58,420
question. I hear that. Two things. First of

810
00:38:58,420 --> 00:39:01,639
all, horses also have to sleep, as do

811
00:39:01,639 --> 00:39:06,239
shluchim Second of all, a horse doesn't race

812
00:39:06,239 --> 00:39:10,619
continually for a 10-hour day. Meaning horses know

813
00:39:10,619 --> 00:39:12,980
how to run and they could run races,

814
00:39:12,980 --> 00:39:19,400
but they don't run like that continually. Right.

815
00:39:21,219 --> 00:39:26,760
So asks the Ritva, asks the Ritva, you

816
00:39:26,760 --> 00:39:28,900
and I know that Eretz Yisrael keeps one

817
00:39:28,900 --> 00:39:32,119
day, and chutz la'aretz. keeps two days. But

818
00:39:32,119 --> 00:39:34,960
according to my calculations, it seems that there

819
00:39:34,960 --> 00:39:37,320
are many parts of Eretz Yisrael that shluchim

820
00:39:37,320 --> 00:39:39,380
did not arrive at by the end of

821
00:39:39,380 --> 00:39:42,239
10 days. And therefore why do those further

822
00:39:42,739 --> 00:39:46,900
parts of Eretz Yisrael not... why do those

823
00:39:46,900 --> 00:39:48,219
further parts of Eretz Yisrael only keep one

824
00:39:48,219 --> 00:39:50,659
day? They are Eretz Yisrael but the shluchim

825
00:39:50,659 --> 00:39:52,599
didn't reach that far, so why do they

826
00:39:52,599 --> 00:39:54,480
only keep one day? Now the Rambam told

827
00:39:54,480 --> 00:39:57,539
us, addressed this point, and he said whoever

828
00:39:57,539 --> 00:39:59,699
said that Eretz Yisrael keeps one day and

829
00:40:00,179 --> 00:40:02,360
chutz la'aretz Wherever shluchim got, and if there

830
00:40:02,360 --> 00:40:03,800
were Jews there, kept one day. I don't

831
00:40:03,800 --> 00:40:05,719
care where you are, Israel, chutz la'aretz it

832
00:40:05,719 --> 00:40:08,340
doesn't matter. It's nothing to do with Eretz

833
00:40:08,340 --> 00:40:10,579
Yisrael... per se, says the Rambam. It has

834
00:40:10,579 --> 00:40:12,067
to do with how far you are and

835
00:40:12,067 --> 00:40:13,420
where there were Jews there. The Ritva says

836
00:40:13,420 --> 00:40:15,400
no, no, no. We know that Eretz Yisroel

837
00:40:15,400 --> 00:40:17,679
versus chutz la'aretz In fact, you know what

838
00:40:17,679 --> 00:40:22,480
the poskim quote? Yom Tov Sheini Shel Galuyos.

839
00:40:22,480 --> 00:40:24,840
There, the lashon Chazal itself tells you there's

840
00:40:24,840 --> 00:40:29,519
a difference between diaspora versus Israel. The Ritva,

841
00:40:29,519 --> 00:40:32,679
I think, makes that point. So why does

842
00:40:32,679 --> 00:40:33,973
chutz la'aretz all keep two days and Eretz

843
00:40:33,973 --> 00:40:36,119
Yisroel only keep one day? So he says

844
00:40:36,119 --> 00:40:41,579
something interesting. I'll ask you one more question.

845
00:40:44,900 --> 00:40:47,067
Do we make a bracha on a minhag.

846
00:40:47,067 --> 00:40:51,199
Yeah, some do. I spoke about this to

847
00:40:51,199 --> 00:40:53,859
Mincha Maariv this week regarding Rosh Chodesh. Ashkenazim

848
00:40:55,199 --> 00:40:58,739
do, Sephardim don't. The Shulchan Aruch says you

849
00:40:58,739 --> 00:41:01,179
don't make a bracha on a minhag The

850
00:41:01,179 --> 00:41:04,000
Ritva was certainly me’chachmei Sefard. He assumes that

851
00:41:04,000 --> 00:41:06,059
you don't make brachot on a minhag. If

852
00:41:06,059 --> 00:41:07,820
that's the case, he's also bothered by how

853
00:41:07,820 --> 00:41:09,159
in the world do you make brachot on

854
00:41:09,159 --> 00:41:12,093
all of Yom Tov Sheini Shel Galuyos, minhag

855
00:41:12,093 --> 00:41:15,119
avoteichem beyadeichem, right? It's a minhag. I told

856
00:41:15,119 --> 00:41:17,019
you that the Rambam wheedles his way out

857
00:41:17,019 --> 00:41:17,820
of it because the Rambam said it's a

858
00:41:17,820 --> 00:41:21,800
takana to follow the minhag? of your location.

859
00:41:21,800 --> 00:41:27,780
ulai d’Oraita? That doesn't, that's called takana. That's

860
00:41:27,780 --> 00:41:29,679
a takana. But I'm asking about a minhag.

861
00:41:29,679 --> 00:41:32,380
If the reason why we keep two days

862
00:41:32,380 --> 00:41:33,820
in chutz la'aretz is because of minhag avoteichem

863
00:41:33,820 --> 00:41:35,099
beyadeichem, you don't make brachot on a minhag.

864
00:41:35,159 --> 00:41:36,900
How can you make all those brachot on

865
00:41:36,900 --> 00:41:38,780
second day Yom Tov if you're not going

866
00:41:38,780 --> 00:41:40,519
to make a bracha on a minhag. I'm

867
00:41:40,519 --> 00:41:42,817
not familiar with the Ran. Says that at

868
00:41:42,817 --> 00:41:45,596
least if you don't daven, if you don't

869
00:41:45,596 --> 00:41:48,375
make all the brachot, then there'll be a

870
00:41:48,375 --> 00:41:51,154
complete zilzul of Yom Tov. It'll be a

871
00:41:51,154 --> 00:41:52,196
yom chol in the middle of Yom Tov.

872
00:41:52,196 --> 00:41:52,196
I hear. I hear. I guess the Ritva

873
00:41:52,196 --> 00:41:52,689
doesn't hold from that. Why? It's a minhag

874
00:41:54,940 --> 00:41:57,420
Okay, so what does the Ritva say? He

875
00:41:57,420 --> 00:42:02,119
says something. I bolded it. He says when

876
00:42:02,119 --> 00:42:06,480
Hillel ha-Zaken established the calendar, he did two

877
00:42:06,480 --> 00:42:09,219
things. He established the calendar for Eretz Yisroel

878
00:42:09,880 --> 00:42:14,949
and he set a takana that in chutz

879
00:42:14,949 --> 00:42:17,579
la'aretz they should act as though they have

880
00:42:17,579 --> 00:42:20,119
no idea when the Rosh Chodesh is. Let

881
00:42:20,119 --> 00:42:24,059
me say that again. When he made his

882
00:42:24,059 --> 00:42:27,659
takana and he told us when the cheshbon

883
00:42:27,659 --> 00:42:30,239
was for the rest of history, when all

884
00:42:30,239 --> 00:42:31,800
the rashei chodashim is, when the yamim tovim

885
00:42:31,800 --> 00:42:34,190
should be, part of his takana was also

886
00:42:35,460 --> 00:42:41,760
that in chutz la'aretz, you should act as

887
00:42:41,760 --> 00:42:43,690
though you have no idea when the Rosh

888
00:42:43,690 --> 00:42:45,219
Chodesh is. You have no idea when the

889
00:42:45,219 --> 00:42:47,894
calculation is. That's what it means. hitkinu minhag

890
00:42:47,894 --> 00:42:52,239
avoteichem beyadeichem meaning act as though, continue doing

891
00:42:52,239 --> 00:42:53,500
what you've been doing until now, act as

892
00:42:53,500 --> 00:42:56,559
though you don't know how things really are,

893
00:42:57,119 --> 00:43:00,199
act as though there was no kiddush hachodesh.

894
00:43:01,019 --> 00:43:03,079
What he gains by this, and we'll see

895
00:43:03,079 --> 00:43:06,000
how it'll unfold in a minute, it's not

896
00:43:06,000 --> 00:43:09,320
a minhag It's a takana. The takana was

897
00:43:09,900 --> 00:43:12,559
that you should do what... this is the

898
00:43:12,559 --> 00:43:14,219
same thing that the Rambam tried to do

899
00:43:14,219 --> 00:43:16,099
for us a few minutes before. Remember I

900
00:43:16,099 --> 00:43:17,820
told you that the says it's a takana,

901
00:43:17,860 --> 00:43:21,260
the takana is to keep your minhag So

902
00:43:21,260 --> 00:43:23,400
the Ritva is saying a similar thing. He

903
00:43:23,400 --> 00:43:26,820
says there's a takana, the takana is that

904
00:43:26,820 --> 00:43:28,900
those places outside of Eretz Yisroel should act

905
00:43:28,900 --> 00:43:31,531
as though... it's a synthetic minhag of some

906
00:43:31,531 --> 00:43:36,599
kind. The takana is for Eretz Yisroel, one

907
00:43:36,599 --> 00:43:38,159
way and takana is for chutz la'aretz to

908
00:43:38,159 --> 00:43:44,340
ignore this calendar, this clarity that Hillel ha-Zaken

909
00:43:44,340 --> 00:43:48,599
brought to us. That means that that takana

910
00:43:48,599 --> 00:43:50,460
in chutz la'aretz is a real takana and

911
00:43:50,460 --> 00:43:52,231
therefore you can make a bracha on Yom

912
00:43:52,231 --> 00:43:55,940
Tov Sheni. Okay, now with that, look at

913
00:43:55,940 --> 00:43:57,227
what he's going to do now. And this

914
00:43:57,227 --> 00:43:59,320
is the punchline. Source number eight, the last

915
00:43:59,559 --> 00:44:05,231
line, last part of the Ritva. Va'avoteinu hayah

916
00:44:05,231 --> 00:44:08,199
lahem minhagot shonot. There were different minhagim of

917
00:44:08,199 --> 00:44:09,380
how many days to keep, one day or

918
00:44:09,380 --> 00:44:12,269
two days of Yom Tov. veyesh she'osim sheni

919
00:44:12,269 --> 00:44:16,000
yamim veyesh she'osim yom echad. Look at these

920
00:44:16,000 --> 00:44:26,730
four words. Veyesh lanu leilech achar harov. Bechutz

921
00:44:26,730 --> 00:44:30,820
la'aretz ruba hayu osim bet yamim me'olam. In

922
00:44:30,820 --> 00:44:34,239
chutz la'aretz most locations in Chutz La'aretz always

923
00:44:34,239 --> 00:44:36,719
had two days of Yom Tov. So therefore

924
00:44:37,219 --> 00:44:39,699
we're going to follow rov The takana was

925
00:44:39,699 --> 00:44:41,820
that we should follow rov and therefore all

926
00:44:41,820 --> 00:44:46,860
of Chutz La'aretz should keep two days. Why

927
00:44:46,860 --> 00:44:48,380
does the majority of Chutz La'aretz? keep two

928
00:44:48,380 --> 00:44:50,689
days originally? Shelo hayu magiin sham shluchim, lefichach

929
00:44:50,689 --> 00:44:52,820
anu osim kan sheni yamim. That's why we

930
00:44:52,820 --> 00:44:55,780
in Galut keep two days. Bottom line on

931
00:44:55,780 --> 00:44:58,000
page two. Aval berov Eretz Yisrael, the majority

932
00:44:58,000 --> 00:45:00,800
of, vast majority of Eretz Yisroel Israel was

933
00:45:00,800 --> 00:45:06,299
reached by the messengers and therefore ve-osim gam

934
00:45:06,299 --> 00:45:08,900
ken hayom yom echad. Says the Ritba something

935
00:45:08,900 --> 00:45:12,599
incredible. We asked, the Rambam says it depended

936
00:45:12,599 --> 00:45:14,780
on where the shluchim actually got. The Ritba

937
00:45:14,780 --> 00:45:16,739
says I'm going to do something much neater.

938
00:45:17,380 --> 00:45:19,199
I don't care where they actually got or

939
00:45:19,199 --> 00:45:22,659
where they don't get. Since most places outside

940
00:45:22,659 --> 00:45:24,780
of Eretz Yisroel they didn't get that far,

941
00:45:26,619 --> 00:45:28,840
all of Chutz La'aretz. should do two days.

942
00:45:29,199 --> 00:45:32,360
Since most places in Eretz Yisroel they did

943
00:45:32,360 --> 00:45:34,440
get, you should only do one day. But

944
00:45:34,440 --> 00:45:35,760
what do we use as the borders of

945
00:45:35,760 --> 00:45:38,219
Eretz Yisroel, today for this purpose? I mean

946
00:45:38,559 --> 00:45:40,659
sometimes he's also saying two days because at

947
00:45:40,659 --> 00:45:43,099
that time was Chutz La'aretz, but today he's

948
00:45:43,099 --> 00:45:45,440
considered it not like that. That's what we

949
00:45:45,440 --> 00:45:47,239
have to discuss, that's where we're going to

950
00:45:47,239 --> 00:45:49,153
go. What you realize is what Rav Shlomo

951
00:45:49,153 --> 00:45:52,659
Zalman realizes. Let me back up one moment.

952
00:45:52,820 --> 00:45:55,440
According to the Rambam, do I care whether

953
00:45:55,440 --> 00:45:58,000
you're in Israel or in Chutz La'aretz, All

954
00:45:58,000 --> 00:45:59,380
I care is how far away you are

955
00:45:59,380 --> 00:46:00,920
and was there a yishuv at the time

956
00:46:00,920 --> 00:46:03,980
of the Therefore Eilat didn't have a yishuv,

957
00:46:04,739 --> 00:46:06,880
Eilat. is two days. According to this Ritba

958
00:46:06,880 --> 00:46:08,960
we have a whole new world. There's something

959
00:46:08,960 --> 00:46:11,779
called Eretz Yisroel and something else called Chutz

960
00:46:11,779 --> 00:46:13,699
La'aretz Chutz La'aretz I don't care if you

961
00:46:13,699 --> 00:46:15,739
did or didn't have shlichim come to your

962
00:46:15,739 --> 00:46:18,260
town in, let's say Beirut. Beirut is not

963
00:46:18,260 --> 00:46:22,099
far, Alexandria, Alexandria is not far. But you

964
00:46:22,099 --> 00:46:24,460
know what? They're part of an animal called,

965
00:46:24,460 --> 00:46:27,739
a gigantic animal called galus, called Chutz La'aretz

966
00:46:28,179 --> 00:46:30,099
and therefore will follow rov and we'll give

967
00:46:30,099 --> 00:46:32,260
all of those places, including a close place

968
00:46:32,260 --> 00:46:34,940
like Beirut and a close place like Alexandria

969
00:46:35,400 --> 00:46:40,039
in Egypt, will consider them to follow the

970
00:46:40,179 --> 00:46:41,300
and we'll give them a din Chutz La'aretz.

971
00:46:41,380 --> 00:46:43,659
of two days. And Eretz Yisroel. even if

972
00:46:43,659 --> 00:46:45,400
there's some place in Eretz Yisroel that's let's

973
00:46:45,400 --> 00:46:46,900
say very far away, let's say as he

974
00:46:46,900 --> 00:46:48,539
thought in his question that Eretz Yisroel is

975
00:46:48,539 --> 00:46:50,269
so gigantic and there are parts of Eretz

976
00:46:50,269 --> 00:46:53,260
Yisroel you can't reach, if it's part of

977
00:46:53,260 --> 00:46:54,980
Eretz Yisroel most of Eretz Yisroel is reachable

978
00:46:54,980 --> 00:46:57,460
by the and therefore you will have only

979
00:46:57,460 --> 00:46:59,880
one day in Eretz Yisroel So the question

980
00:46:59,880 --> 00:47:01,079
is, how do we define Eretz Yisroel. now?

981
00:47:01,400 --> 00:47:02,860
You wanted it to stay the same as

982
00:47:02,860 --> 00:47:05,420
the original, as the original Eretz Yisroel, boundaries,

983
00:47:05,420 --> 00:47:06,840
whatever the same as what was once. That's

984
00:47:06,840 --> 00:47:08,480
what you're saying and you're entitled to say

985
00:47:08,480 --> 00:47:10,480
that. We'll see that won't help us so

986
00:47:10,480 --> 00:47:12,300
much with Eilat That's why I don't want

987
00:47:12,300 --> 00:47:15,079
Eilat, Okay, we'll get there, we'll get there.

988
00:47:15,079 --> 00:47:15,774
So what we have here is a gigantic

989
00:47:15,774 --> 00:47:17,840
machlokes, by the way, between the Rambam and

990
00:47:17,840 --> 00:47:20,519
the Ritba. The Rambam holds that there are

991
00:47:20,519 --> 00:47:22,539
places in Eretz Yisroel that keep two days,

992
00:47:22,980 --> 00:47:25,219
there are places in Chutz l'Aretz like Beirut

993
00:47:25,219 --> 00:47:28,280
that keep one day. According to the Ritba

994
00:47:28,280 --> 00:47:31,780
it's a clean slice. Which one do we

995
00:47:31,780 --> 00:47:34,539
pasken like? Who do we pasken like? Are

996
00:47:34,539 --> 00:47:36,179
there any places in Eretz Yisroel that keep

997
00:47:36,179 --> 00:47:38,050
two days? Are there any places in Chutz

998
00:47:38,050 --> 00:47:41,940
l'Aretz that keep one day? No. So you'll

999
00:47:41,940 --> 00:47:44,079
tell me what you know, but let's see

1000
00:47:44,079 --> 00:47:47,320
what life was like in the time of

1001
00:47:47,340 --> 00:47:49,693
the 1400s, 1500s, the time of the Sefer

1002
00:47:49,693 --> 00:47:52,900
Kaftor Vaferech. Kaftor Vaferech was a sefer that

1003
00:47:52,900 --> 00:47:54,960
wrote about his travels through Eretz Yisrael and

1004
00:47:54,960 --> 00:47:57,519
he records minhagim of what he saw, what

1005
00:47:57,519 --> 00:48:01,680
he saw as he traveled. ve-im tomar, Sefer

1006
00:48:01,680 --> 00:48:03,599
Kaftor Vaferech is talking about different people having

1007
00:48:03,599 --> 00:48:05,719
different minhagim, maybe you worry about a certain

1008
00:48:05,719 --> 00:48:08,559
thing that's like shtei toros. And he says

1009
00:48:08,699 --> 00:48:10,699
don't be worried about people doing different things.

1010
00:48:11,539 --> 00:48:14,099
vehincha ro'eh be-Eretz Yisrael, look at the minhagim

1011
00:48:14,099 --> 00:48:16,619
that he's recording. He's not telling you he's

1012
00:48:16,619 --> 00:48:19,119
telling you historical observations. You know Marco Polo

1013
00:48:19,119 --> 00:48:21,280
went traveling and wrote down what he saw?

1014
00:48:21,800 --> 00:48:23,273
That's what you have here in the Sefer

1015
00:48:23,273 --> 00:48:26,876
Kaftor Vaferech. Lod top line she'oseh yom echad

1016
00:48:26,876 --> 00:48:29,720
mi-yom tov. The city of Lod? in Eretz

1017
00:48:29,720 --> 00:48:31,300
Yisrael. has one day of yom tov. That

1018
00:48:31,300 --> 00:48:36,572
makes sense. Vegass Gat shelo elef vechamesh me'os

1019
00:48:36,572 --> 00:48:40,420
amah, it's 1500 amah away. It's a kilometer

1020
00:48:40,420 --> 00:48:43,139
away. And guess what? They use two days

1021
00:48:43,139 --> 00:48:45,679
of yom tov. Where's Gat? In the middle

1022
00:48:45,679 --> 00:48:47,597
of Eretz Yisrael. Isn't this Gat Pleshtim? Lod,

1023
00:48:51,000 --> 00:48:52,739
It's Gat next to it's right near the

1024
00:48:52,739 --> 00:48:56,539
airport. Right, it's right near the airport. He

1025
00:48:56,539 --> 00:48:58,380
says two cities in Eretz Yisrael. one has

1026
00:48:58,380 --> 00:49:00,099
a minhag to do one day, one has

1027
00:49:00,099 --> 00:49:02,559
a minhag, to do two days, et cetera,

1028
00:49:02,659 --> 00:49:03,960
et cetera, et cetera. What do you see

1029
00:49:03,960 --> 00:49:05,780
from the Sefer Kaftor Vaferech? What was minhag

1030
00:49:05,780 --> 00:49:08,880
of Klal Yisrael? You see like the Rambam.

1031
00:49:09,639 --> 00:49:11,000
You see like the Rambam that there are

1032
00:49:11,000 --> 00:49:12,602
some cities in Eretz Yisrael that do only

1033
00:49:13,500 --> 00:49:17,579
that do two days. Nowadays you're right, I

1034
00:49:17,579 --> 00:49:19,480
agreed with what you all called out before

1035
00:49:19,480 --> 00:49:21,019
that nowadays we only know the difference between

1036
00:49:21,019 --> 00:49:23,219
Eretz Yisrael. versus Chutz l'Aretz You see that

1037
00:49:23,219 --> 00:49:25,420
wasn't the minhag. of Kaftor Vaferech. The first

1038
00:49:25,420 --> 00:49:28,510
person to really raise this issue was Rav

1039
00:49:28,510 --> 00:49:31,659
Menachem Mendel Kasher. Rav Menachem Mendel Kasher was

1040
00:49:31,659 --> 00:49:34,340
a Gerrer chassid, Gerrer chassid who was an

1041
00:49:34,340 --> 00:49:37,960
incredible ohev Eretz Yisrael. He wrote the incredible

1042
00:49:38,539 --> 00:49:41,039
encyclopedia Torah Shleimah and he knew kol, he

1043
00:49:41,039 --> 00:49:43,536
knew everything ba'al peh, he knew kol HaTorah

1044
00:49:43,536 --> 00:49:49,199
kullah ba'al peh. I believe he wanted to

1045
00:49:49,199 --> 00:49:52,480
be matir an eruv on Manhattan, not like

1046
00:49:52,480 --> 00:49:58,059
Rav Moshe Feinstein. He was an illui atzum,

1047
00:49:58,059 --> 00:50:02,000
and he raised... He raised this question before

1048
00:50:02,000 --> 00:50:06,840
1948 in a periodical that he was the

1049
00:50:06,840 --> 00:50:09,679
editor of called Degel HaTorah. Volume one of

1050
00:50:09,679 --> 00:50:12,440
this periodical called Degel HaTorah, look at the

1051
00:50:12,440 --> 00:50:16,159
right column. Baruch Hashem or Be'ezrat Hashem Warsaw.

1052
00:50:17,280 --> 00:50:19,780
Sheilah L'Gedolei Torah. He's taking this as a

1053
00:50:19,780 --> 00:50:22,800
shaila, throwing it out in this periodical to

1054
00:50:22,800 --> 00:50:25,619
the Talmidei Chachamim of his generation in this

1055
00:50:25,619 --> 00:50:29,139
periodical. He's just sort of fishing for guys,

1056
00:50:29,360 --> 00:50:31,199
not guys, my dear esteemed rabanim who are

1057
00:50:31,199 --> 00:50:33,039
reading this around the world, let me know

1058
00:50:33,039 --> 00:50:34,539
what you think. There's a shaila that's that

1059
00:50:34,539 --> 00:50:38,480
might come up soon. Look at this shaila.

1060
00:50:39,579 --> 00:50:44,719
Moshavot V'ayarot. This is talking in the 19...

1061
00:50:46,639 --> 00:50:49,880
he brought the Gerer Rebbe to Eretz Yisrael.

1062
00:50:49,880 --> 00:50:52,099
during the war. So this is probably in

1063
00:50:52,099 --> 00:50:54,019
the 20s or 30s when he's still in

1064
00:50:54,019 --> 00:50:56,002
Warsaw before he came to Eretz Yisrael. You

1065
00:50:56,002 --> 00:50:58,781
mean for a visit? No, he never came.

1066
00:50:58,781 --> 00:51:02,440
He never came in 1940. Right. So he

1067
00:51:02,440 --> 00:51:04,862
brought the Gerer Rebbe in. He was one

1068
00:51:04,862 --> 00:51:06,946
of them, he signed on. Okay. I'm not

1069
00:51:06,946 --> 00:51:07,460
saying he did it. I'm saying he was

1070
00:51:07,460 --> 00:51:09,219
one of the people who... he was asked

1071
00:51:09,219 --> 00:51:10,719
by the Gerer Rebbe to establish the Ger...

1072
00:51:10,780 --> 00:51:11,800
he was the Rosh Yeshiva of the first

1073
00:51:11,800 --> 00:51:15,010
Ger Yeshiva of the Ger Yeshiva in Eretz

1074
00:51:15,010 --> 00:51:16,900
Yisrael? And he was involved in bringing the

1075
00:51:16,900 --> 00:51:18,940
Gerer Rebbe somehow involved, I don't know, maybe

1076
00:51:18,940 --> 00:51:20,619
in a rabbinical sense, not in a lay

1077
00:51:20,619 --> 00:51:24,619
sense. I don't know the details. Moshavot V'ayarot

1078
00:51:24,619 --> 00:51:27,000
Shenityasdu Me'chadash B'Eretz Yisrael. There are new cities

1079
00:51:27,000 --> 00:51:30,026
and villages sprouting up in Eretz Yisrael V'gam

1080
00:51:30,026 --> 00:51:32,639
He'atidim B'Karov L'hivased B'Eretz Yisrael. There are going

1081
00:51:32,639 --> 00:51:34,394
to be new cities that will Be'ezrat Hashem

1082
00:51:34,394 --> 00:51:37,867
be established, L'hityashev L'hityashev, that will be established

1083
00:51:37,867 --> 00:51:40,646
B'makom She'ein Sham Yishuv. V'gam Einam B'toch Techum

1084
00:51:40,646 --> 00:51:43,339
Shel Eizeh Yishuv. They're not... you know, they'll

1085
00:51:43,339 --> 00:51:45,594
be sprouting up in new areas. Eich Din

1086
00:51:45,594 --> 00:51:49,460
Anshei Otan HaMoshavot B'Yom Tov Sheni? What should

1087
00:51:49,460 --> 00:51:52,000
be the din for those places? Look on

1088
00:51:52,000 --> 00:51:53,079
the bottom, just jump down to the bottom.

1089
00:51:53,079 --> 00:51:55,859
V'hineni Bazeh L'va'er L'va'er K'fi Aniyut Da'ati Et

1090
00:51:55,859 --> 00:51:58,739
Tochen HaSheilah. I'm going... he then goes on

1091
00:51:58,739 --> 00:52:00,360
for four pages to say what he thinks.

1092
00:52:00,360 --> 00:52:03,960
U'mevakesh Ani Me'et... I'll tell you, it's on

1093
00:52:03,960 --> 00:52:05,519
the top of the next page. I thereby

1094
00:52:05,519 --> 00:52:07,300
request from all the Gedolim and all the

1095
00:52:07,300 --> 00:52:10,079
Rabanim around the world, please write to me

1096
00:52:10,079 --> 00:52:12,320
to tell me what you think. He's throwing

1097
00:52:12,320 --> 00:52:14,460
out a shaila. It's a beautiful, beautiful thing.

1098
00:52:14,539 --> 00:52:15,780
And then he says... goes for four pages

1099
00:52:15,780 --> 00:52:18,719
of what he thinks. One of the things

1100
00:52:18,719 --> 00:52:20,900
that he points out is this machlokes Rambam

1101
00:52:20,900 --> 00:52:24,109
v'Ritva. I want to finish with Eich Rav

1102
00:52:24,109 --> 00:52:25,840
Shlomo Zalman... there are lots of poskim deal

1103
00:52:25,840 --> 00:52:28,639
with this shaila. There's a Tzitz Eliezer, there's

1104
00:52:28,639 --> 00:52:30,699
a talk about Mah Rav Elyashiv holds. We're

1105
00:52:30,699 --> 00:52:32,228
going to go through Rav Elyashiv what Rav

1106
00:52:32,228 --> 00:52:37,739
Shlomo Zalman with one mahalach. But to start

1107
00:52:37,739 --> 00:52:40,579
his teshuva, he really sets himself up for

1108
00:52:40,579 --> 00:52:47,320
success with the first unrelated comment. And

1109
00:52:47,320 --> 00:52:49,920
that is, whenever you have to make a

1110
00:52:49,920 --> 00:52:51,159
decision, you have to know what kind of

1111
00:52:51,159 --> 00:52:52,679
decision you're going to make. When you go

1112
00:52:52,679 --> 00:52:54,260
to law, any lawyers here? We have a

1113
00:52:54,260 --> 00:52:55,500
lawyer. So when I went to... when I

1114
00:52:55,500 --> 00:52:58,599
went to jury duty, one of the questions

1115
00:52:58,599 --> 00:53:00,500
that the lawyer asked to see if I'd

1116
00:53:00,500 --> 00:53:03,719
be a good juror for their case is,

1117
00:53:03,920 --> 00:53:06,460
do I have a problem with the idea

1118
00:53:06,460 --> 00:53:12,820
of beyond a reasonable doubt? Meaning, you

1119
00:53:12,820 --> 00:53:14,519
don't have to prove something in an American

1120
00:53:14,519 --> 00:53:17,119
court. It doesn't have to be true that

1121
00:53:17,119 --> 00:53:19,219
he murdered or that he stole. It just

1122
00:53:19,219 --> 00:53:21,039
has to be true beyond reasonable doubt that

1123
00:53:21,039 --> 00:53:22,934
he murdered or that he stole. Am I...

1124
00:53:22,934 --> 00:53:25,366
help me? Yeah, it's a criminal standard for

1125
00:53:25,366 --> 00:53:27,639
criminal. Criminal law. Fine. I know you don't

1126
00:53:27,639 --> 00:53:30,380
do criminal but you've heard of it. Fine.

1127
00:53:30,500 --> 00:53:32,019
Okay. So you don't have to prove anything,

1128
00:53:32,139 --> 00:53:33,420
it just has to be something that's beyond

1129
00:53:33,420 --> 00:53:34,920
reasonable doubt. Meaning, when you're in a court

1130
00:53:34,920 --> 00:53:37,019
of law in America, the parameters are you

1131
00:53:37,019 --> 00:53:38,199
have to be able to prove something beyond

1132
00:53:38,280 --> 00:53:40,249
reasonable doubt. Okay. Now we have a rabosai,

1133
00:53:40,249 --> 00:53:41,780
we have a shaila. I have to figure

1134
00:53:41,780 --> 00:53:45,079
out if is supposed to have one day

1135
00:53:45,079 --> 00:53:47,260
or two days. Do I have to prove

1136
00:53:47,260 --> 00:53:48,739
that it has to be one day or

1137
00:53:48,739 --> 00:53:51,400
two days? Or is it enough if I

1138
00:53:51,400 --> 00:53:56,119
could make an argument, a logical argument, that

1139
00:53:56,119 --> 00:53:56,860
it would have to be one day or

1140
00:53:56,860 --> 00:54:02,773
two days? We have a rule safek d'rabanan

1141
00:54:02,773 --> 00:54:04,214
l'kula. We have our own rules for resolving

1142
00:54:04,214 --> 00:54:04,562
a doubt. So Rav Shlomo Zalman going to

1143
00:54:04,562 --> 00:54:07,679
take what you just said and he's going...

1144
00:54:07,679 --> 00:54:08,519
Rav Shlomo Zalman going to take what you

1145
00:54:08,519 --> 00:54:11,039
just said and inject some steroids into that

1146
00:54:11,039 --> 00:54:13,019
comment. Okay. Let's see what he says in

1147
00:54:13,019 --> 00:54:16,311
source number 11. Nireh Li L'hakdim D'bechol Yom

1148
00:54:16,311 --> 00:54:21,000
Tov Safek is a halacha d'rabanan... second day

1149
00:54:21,000 --> 00:54:22,699
Yom Tov is clearly only d'rabanan. The Torah

1150
00:54:22,699 --> 00:54:24,599
says only first day Yom Tov is d'oraita.

1151
00:54:24,599 --> 00:54:26,900
Second day is clearly only d'rabanan. Maybe it's

1152
00:54:26,900 --> 00:54:28,119
even less than a d'rabanan, maybe it's only

1153
00:54:28,119 --> 00:54:29,920
a minhag. like the lashon of the Gemara

1154
00:54:29,920 --> 00:54:31,719
is minhag avoteinu b'yadeinu. We saw the Ritva

1155
00:54:31,719 --> 00:54:33,579
and the Rambam said it's a minhag. that

1156
00:54:33,579 --> 00:54:35,820
they... it's a takanah that you have to

1157
00:54:35,820 --> 00:54:38,159
follow the minhag. Right. That was the brilliance

1158
00:54:38,300 --> 00:54:39,860
the Rambam and the Ritva make to do

1159
00:54:39,860 --> 00:54:42,760
that, you know, heebie-jeebie. But let's... look at

1160
00:54:42,760 --> 00:54:45,426
this first introductory comment of the Rav Shlomo

1161
00:54:45,426 --> 00:54:48,070
Zalman in source number 11. Nireh Li L'hakdim

1162
00:54:48,070 --> 00:54:50,179
D'bechol Safek D'minhaga, he's calling it a minhag,

1163
00:54:50,559 --> 00:54:52,639
It's a safek not only in d'oraita, not

1164
00:54:52,639 --> 00:54:53,699
only in d'rabanan, but it's a safek in

1165
00:54:53,699 --> 00:54:57,739
a minhag, So what should you do? You

1166
00:54:57,739 --> 00:54:59,559
should follow the din d'oraita, follow the base

1167
00:54:59,559 --> 00:55:01,913
din. Don't... to that minhag. Hachonami l'inyan safek

1168
00:55:01,913 --> 00:55:04,800
yom tov sheini, which is only then he

1169
00:55:04,800 --> 00:55:06,119
introduced the word that the Rishonim use, is

1170
00:55:06,119 --> 00:55:08,559
only a takana to follow the fine. So

1171
00:55:08,559 --> 00:55:10,980
therefore, if it's a safek if you have

1172
00:55:10,980 --> 00:55:14,619
to do the don't you don't have to

1173
00:55:14,619 --> 00:55:16,360
do the It's a safek on a d'rabonon.

1174
00:55:16,960 --> 00:55:18,300
And then he adds, look at what I

1175
00:55:18,300 --> 00:55:22,880
underlined. Meaning, don't do the Yom Tov Sheini,

1176
00:55:24,260 --> 00:55:26,000
Don't just do what the din Torah is.

1177
00:55:26,139 --> 00:55:28,860
Din Torah is m'deoraisa have one day of

1178
00:55:28,860 --> 00:55:30,760
Yom Tov. And now look what he says,

1179
00:55:30,940 --> 00:55:33,039
especially here by Yom Tov Sheini? because in

1180
00:55:33,039 --> 00:55:35,494
Yom Tov Sheini, who what's being frum? You

1181
00:55:35,494 --> 00:55:37,679
want to be real frum? What's being frum?

1182
00:55:38,079 --> 00:55:40,831
Keeping Yom Tov Sheini Day in half? I'll

1183
00:55:40,831 --> 00:55:43,263
put on tefillin. Day in half? Go ahead

1184
00:55:43,263 --> 00:55:44,445
do both. Let's look. B'frat d'lo shayach klal

1185
00:55:44,445 --> 00:55:47,320
l'hachmir b'zeh misafek, you can't be machmir misafek.

1186
00:55:47,320 --> 00:55:48,519
Sometimes you want to be frum, you'll just

1187
00:55:48,519 --> 00:55:51,000
be machmir. Frum here, being machmir here is

1188
00:55:51,000 --> 00:55:55,231
not frum, it's perhaps the opposite. Why? Keivan

1189
00:55:55,231 --> 00:55:58,980
shek'neged zeh, the opposite, the frumkeit of keeping

1190
00:55:58,980 --> 00:56:01,014
Yom Tov Sheni. yesh chashash shel kama tefillos

1191
00:56:01,014 --> 00:56:05,480
u'brachos l'vatala. You're going to make a Shehecheyanu

1192
00:56:05,480 --> 00:56:06,960
on the second night of the second Seder?

1193
00:56:07,039 --> 00:56:08,949
You're going to say asher kidishanu b'mitzvosav v'tzivanu

1194
00:56:08,949 --> 00:56:11,619
al achilas matzah, al achilas maror? You're going

1195
00:56:11,619 --> 00:56:13,000
to make all those brachos l'vatala, all the

1196
00:56:13,000 --> 00:56:14,300
tefillos, all the shmoneh esrei that you're going

1197
00:56:14,300 --> 00:56:16,880
to daven on the Yom Tov? that are

1198
00:56:16,880 --> 00:56:17,940
a weekday at the end of Yom Tov

1199
00:56:18,000 --> 00:56:19,000
You're going to make it as Yom Tov

1200
00:56:19,000 --> 00:56:22,421
davening? They're all brachos l'vatala. v'gam bitul mitzvas

1201
00:56:22,421 --> 00:56:24,260
tefillin deoraisa, day in half won't help you

1202
00:56:24,260 --> 00:56:27,659
with the tefillos, the brachos, with the tefillos,

1203
00:56:27,659 --> 00:56:30,440
the shmoneh esrei won't help you. So therefore,

1204
00:56:30,440 --> 00:56:32,219
what do we have to, what's the goal,

1205
00:56:32,219 --> 00:56:33,699
says Rav Shlomo Zalman? I don't have to

1206
00:56:33,699 --> 00:56:36,039
convince you that it should be one day

1207
00:56:36,039 --> 00:56:37,159
or two days. All I have to do

1208
00:56:37,159 --> 00:56:40,400
is show you that it's a safek. Once

1209
00:56:40,400 --> 00:56:41,659
I show you that it's a safek whether

1210
00:56:41,659 --> 00:56:42,539
or not you should keep one or two

1211
00:56:42,539 --> 00:56:45,219
days, what's going to be the default position?

1212
00:56:46,519 --> 00:56:48,800
You're just going to keep one day. So

1213
00:56:48,800 --> 00:56:51,000
that's all, he's setting himself up for success.

1214
00:56:51,059 --> 00:56:52,699
He doesn't have to prove anything. All he

1215
00:56:52,699 --> 00:56:55,219
has to do is sow seeds of doubt

1216
00:56:56,099 --> 00:56:58,460
and then he wins. All he has to

1217
00:56:58,460 --> 00:56:59,207
do is show that there are going to

1218
00:56:59,207 --> 00:57:01,460
be sfeikos. That means he could tell, he

1219
00:57:01,460 --> 00:57:03,730
could use svaras now that you wouldn't matir

1220
00:57:03,730 --> 00:57:06,639
aguna with. He could say svaras that are

1221
00:57:06,639 --> 00:57:08,880
not ironclad, but if it's enough to raise

1222
00:57:08,880 --> 00:57:10,559
a doubt, he'll be able to be meikel

1223
00:57:10,559 --> 00:57:11,840
and say just keep one day, not two

1224
00:57:11,840 --> 00:57:13,460
days. And that's exactly what he's going to

1225
00:57:13,460 --> 00:57:14,559
do. I want to show you the main

1226
00:57:14,559 --> 00:57:17,079
svara that he says because it's late. Look

1227
00:57:17,079 --> 00:57:20,420
at source number 14. He suggests that we

1228
00:57:20,420 --> 00:57:23,280
don't pasken like the Rambam who says that

1229
00:57:23,280 --> 00:57:25,239
it depends on how far you are, some

1230
00:57:25,239 --> 00:57:27,340
places in Eretz Yisrael should keep two days,

1231
00:57:27,340 --> 00:57:28,900
some places in Chutz l'Aretz should keep one

1232
00:57:28,900 --> 00:57:30,940
day. Nobody does that. I know the Kaf

1233
00:57:30,940 --> 00:57:32,886
Hachayim said they did, but says Rav Shlomo

1234
00:57:32,886 --> 00:57:34,840
Zalman nowadays we all we follow the Ritva,

1235
00:57:37,980 --> 00:57:40,980
and Eretz Yisrael, and Eretz Yisrael That's the

1236
00:57:40,980 --> 00:57:42,980
Ritva opinion. It depends if you're in Eretz

1237
00:57:42,980 --> 00:57:45,260
Yisrael, But what's the definition of Eretz Yisrael,

1238
00:57:45,940 --> 00:57:48,320
Look at this rabosai, if you weren't a

1239
00:57:48,320 --> 00:57:50,280
tzioni until now, now's the time to become

1240
00:57:50,280 --> 00:57:52,500
tzioni. Join Rav Shlomo Zalman and get on

1241
00:57:52,500 --> 00:57:58,780
the bandwagon. Source number 14. Miskeivan she... Okay.

1242
00:57:59,900 --> 00:58:02,846
Second line of source number 14. D'af al

1243
00:58:02,846 --> 00:58:06,900
gav she'kdusha rishona batla, even though we don't

1244
00:58:06,900 --> 00:58:11,039
have kdushas Eretz Yisrael from the time of

1245
00:58:12,740 --> 00:58:17,000
Yehoshua, hainu rak l'inyan hamitzvos hatluyos ba'aretz, that

1246
00:58:17,000 --> 00:58:19,960
just means we don't have kdushas Eretz Yisrael

1247
00:58:19,960 --> 00:58:24,089
as far as the mitzvos. Aval b'yachas l'chashivus

1248
00:58:24,089 --> 00:58:26,833
Eretz Yisrael u'kdushasa harei zeh chashuv vadai Eretz

1249
00:58:26,833 --> 00:58:29,099
Yisrael gamur. You could have, what did he

1250
00:58:29,099 --> 00:58:30,579
just say? He just said you could have

1251
00:58:30,579 --> 00:58:34,079
Eretz Yisrael, without kdushas Eretz Yisrael. You could

1252
00:58:34,079 --> 00:58:37,300
have a place that's special called Eretz Yisrael,

1253
00:58:37,300 --> 00:58:40,500
that doesn't have any mitzvos hatluyos ba'aretz. Wow.

1254
00:58:42,019 --> 00:58:44,119
That doesn't sound so Jewish, that sounds very

1255
00:58:44,119 --> 00:58:49,400
nationalistic though. Yeah, so he's saying there are

1256
00:58:49,400 --> 00:58:52,699
different parts, yeah, Ever Hayarden perhaps, they're considered

1257
00:58:52,699 --> 00:58:55,179
Eretz Yisrael, there are no mitzvos hatluyos ba'aretz

1258
00:58:55,179 --> 00:59:01,427
though, there's no mitzvos. b'zman hazeh efshar

1259
00:59:01,427 --> 00:59:08,139
d'kulu k'vnei Eretz Yisrael chashivei.

1260
00:59:12,460 --> 00:59:16,139
B'zman hazeh, this is the punchline that we'll

1261
00:59:16,139 --> 00:59:19,179
do, Efshar. D'kulu k'vnei Eretz Yisrael chashivei. Everybody

1262
00:59:21,000 --> 00:59:23,099
in the present state of Israel is all

1263
00:59:23,099 --> 00:59:24,880
considered Eretz Yisrael people, even the people in

1264
00:59:25,227 --> 00:59:28,460
Mibli l'hischashev klal regardless im yesh l'osom hamakomos

1265
00:59:28,460 --> 00:59:30,460
din Eretz Yisrael, gam b'yachas l'mitzvos hatluyos ba'aretz.

1266
00:59:30,460 --> 00:59:36,480
Even if there are no mitzvos hatluyos ba'aretz.

1267
00:59:36,480 --> 00:59:37,840
Even if you tell me that has no

1268
00:59:37,840 --> 00:59:40,780
shmita, has no trumos, has no ma'asros, which

1269
00:59:40,780 --> 00:59:42,679
by the way is a gigantic sugya not

1270
00:59:42,679 --> 00:59:44,400
for now. But even if you say there's

1271
00:59:44,400 --> 00:59:48,280
no kdusha, there's no mitzvos in nevertheless, look

1272
00:59:48,280 --> 00:59:50,920
at the last line of source number 14.

1273
00:59:50,920 --> 00:59:55,922
Keivan d'lo mistaber klal sheb'osah hamedina v'tachas oso

1274
00:59:55,922 --> 01:00:00,815
shilton yimatzei chelek mibnei hamedina she'einam nigrarim. achar

1275
01:00:00,815 --> 01:00:03,679
cheshbon osa hamedinah. How could you have one

1276
01:00:03,679 --> 01:00:06,907
governmental authority, one authority that governs one a

1277
01:00:06,907 --> 01:00:09,920
whole region, and say that one is called

1278
01:00:09,920 --> 01:00:11,139
the land and one is not called the

1279
01:00:11,340 --> 01:00:13,074
land? If there's one authority over the land...

1280
01:00:13,074 --> 01:00:15,854
Did you hear Mark's question first? What? Planet

1281
01:00:15,854 --> 01:00:16,548
method is the large customs for it. Hold

1282
01:00:18,340 --> 01:00:22,599
on. Says Rav Shlomo Zalman, it's not mistaber

1283
01:00:23,009 --> 01:00:25,420
that you should have one state and one

1284
01:00:25,420 --> 01:00:28,634
authority and part of them are called are

1285
01:00:28,634 --> 01:00:30,079
called the land and part of them are

1286
01:00:30,079 --> 01:00:32,527
not called the land. And therefore says Rav

1287
01:00:32,527 --> 01:00:34,539
Shlomo Zalman, again, he doesn't have this doesn't

1288
01:00:34,539 --> 01:00:35,960
have to be an ironclad svara which he

1289
01:00:35,960 --> 01:00:37,860
points out later. It's enough of a svara

1290
01:00:38,639 --> 01:00:42,619
that even if there's no kedushas Eretz Yisrael

1291
01:00:42,619 --> 01:00:45,039
in Eilat, but if Eilat is part of...

1292
01:00:46,500 --> 01:00:48,780
how should I finish the sentence? The land

1293
01:00:48,780 --> 01:00:50,039
of Israel. I don't want to say Eretz

1294
01:00:50,039 --> 01:00:51,000
Yisrael. I don't want to say Medinas Yisrael,

1295
01:00:51,000 --> 01:00:53,239
whatever it is. It's part of Israel under

1296
01:00:53,239 --> 01:00:55,239
one authority, whatever you want to call that

1297
01:00:55,239 --> 01:00:57,860
authority. I think between '67 and '82 it

1298
01:00:57,860 --> 01:00:59,460
was the same thing, of course. I didn't

1299
01:00:59,460 --> 01:01:01,139
hear what you said. If that's if that's

1300
01:01:01,139 --> 01:01:04,500
the case, says Rav Shlomo Zalman, then it

1301
01:01:04,500 --> 01:01:08,460
should have a din of Eretz Yisrael? even

1302
01:01:08,460 --> 01:01:10,119
if it doesn't have kedushas Eretz Yisrael, even

1303
01:01:10,119 --> 01:01:11,702
if it doesn't have any mitzvos hateluyos ba'aretz.

1304
01:01:11,702 --> 01:01:13,786
And therefore... how about the other area? How

1305
01:01:13,786 --> 01:01:19,719
about the... yeah. I skipped... I did cut

1306
01:01:19,719 --> 01:01:21,179
and paste... there's a long tshuva, I did

1307
01:01:21,179 --> 01:01:22,960
cut and paste a lot. He he did

1308
01:01:22,960 --> 01:01:24,460
have five steps to build up to this

1309
01:01:24,460 --> 01:01:27,380
which I skipped. Okay, sorry. No no no

1310
01:01:27,380 --> 01:01:29,019
no, it's just I mean this is about

1311
01:01:29,019 --> 01:01:30,940
it, it's late as it is. Based on

1312
01:01:30,940 --> 01:01:32,400
this, what does Rav Shlomo Zalman say? Rav

1313
01:01:32,400 --> 01:01:39,579
Shlomo Zalman says that it's

1314
01:01:39,579 --> 01:01:42,039
not clear. Look at source number sixteen which

1315
01:01:42,039 --> 01:01:44,438
we'll finish: chashvani zeh she'ein zeh kol kach

1316
01:01:44,438 --> 01:01:46,380
barur shechayavim sham Yom Tov Sheni. I'm not

1317
01:01:46,380 --> 01:01:48,575
so clear that you have to have ve'im

1318
01:01:48,575 --> 01:01:51,074
rak safeik hu, and if it's takka only

1319
01:01:51,074 --> 01:01:53,619
a safeik, yeish leilech achar din Torah, you

1320
01:01:53,619 --> 01:01:55,551
should follow only the din d'Oraisa, velinhog rak

1321
01:01:55,551 --> 01:01:58,920
yom echad bilvad. And therefore because of this

1322
01:01:58,920 --> 01:02:00,619
safeik that he has some other speikos which

1323
01:02:00,619 --> 01:02:02,887
we didn't mention and this fabulous svara, the

1324
01:02:02,887 --> 01:02:05,159
fact that if we pasken again, if we

1325
01:02:05,159 --> 01:02:06,719
pasken like the Ritva that it depends not

1326
01:02:06,719 --> 01:02:09,199
on how far the get but what is

1327
01:02:09,199 --> 01:02:11,940
called Eretz Yisrael? well if Eilat is called

1328
01:02:11,940 --> 01:02:15,440
Eretz Yisrael even if there's no kedusha, even

1329
01:02:15,440 --> 01:02:16,480
if there are no mitzvos, but if Eilat

1330
01:02:16,480 --> 01:02:18,960
is called Eretz Yisrael it's going to have

1331
01:02:18,960 --> 01:02:21,289
the din of, like the Ritva says, Eretz

1332
01:02:21,289 --> 01:02:24,719
Yisrael. versus galus. Yom Tov Sheni shel Galuyos.

1333
01:02:24,719 --> 01:02:27,239
Eilat is not galus, it's Eretz Yisrael. And

1334
01:02:27,239 --> 01:02:29,619
therefore says Rav Shlomo Zalman, concludes Rav Shlomo

1335
01:02:29,619 --> 01:02:33,400
Zalman, you only have one day of in

1336
01:02:33,400 --> 01:02:35,920
Eilat, not two days. Even if it's not

1337
01:02:35,920 --> 01:02:37,760
a good svara, it's enough of a safeik

1338
01:02:37,760 --> 01:02:39,559
to be meikel along with the other speikos

1339
01:02:39,559 --> 01:02:40,780
which I didn't have in source number fifteen

1340
01:02:40,780 --> 01:02:43,599
and sixteen. And there is, by the way,

1341
01:02:43,599 --> 01:02:46,187
we could finish with this, a beautiful svara.

1342
01:02:46,187 --> 01:02:47,480
You you could go now, this is just

1343
01:02:47,480 --> 01:02:50,500
a cute thing. The Meshech Chochma asks an

1344
01:02:50,500 --> 01:02:56,719
incredible question. That is a brilliant question. The

1345
01:02:56,719 --> 01:02:58,619
Gemara says, why did Moshe Rabbeinu want to

1346
01:02:58,619 --> 01:03:00,719
go into vechi leechol mipiryah hu hayah rotzeh?

1347
01:03:00,719 --> 01:03:04,340
I'm just going to answer today. What's the

1348
01:03:04,340 --> 01:03:10,193
obvious question? Why did... lekayem es hamitzvos. lekayem

1349
01:03:10,193 --> 01:03:13,027
es hamitzvos. The Gemara said... the Gemara... there's

1350
01:03:13,027 --> 01:03:14,646
more fundamental question. That's the Gemara answer, lekayem

1351
01:03:14,646 --> 01:03:15,800
es hamitzvos. There's a much more simpler answer

1352
01:03:15,800 --> 01:03:17,559
to that question. Why did Moshe Rabbeinu want

1353
01:03:17,559 --> 01:03:21,000
to go to Guess what? Because there's a

1354
01:03:21,000 --> 01:03:23,239
mitzvah to live in like the Ramban says.

1355
01:03:24,039 --> 01:03:26,920
It must be, says the Meshech Chochma, the

1356
01:03:26,920 --> 01:03:29,820
Gemara didn't say that because Moshe Rabbeinu when

1357
01:03:29,820 --> 01:03:32,719
he was in Jordan, he was... that must

1358
01:03:32,719 --> 01:03:34,780
have apparently have been mekayem the mitzvah of

1359
01:03:35,400 --> 01:03:38,019
Yishuv Eretz Yisrael. rabosai, was there trumos umasros

1360
01:03:38,019 --> 01:03:40,239
today in Jordan? No, because the Gemara in

1361
01:03:40,239 --> 01:03:41,300
the next line says he wants to go

1362
01:03:41,300 --> 01:03:43,760
into to do to do trumos umasros. That

1363
01:03:43,760 --> 01:03:45,090
means you have the idea in this Meshech

1364
01:03:45,090 --> 01:03:48,260
Chochma of Moshe Rabbeinu being in Jordan, on

1365
01:03:48,260 --> 01:03:49,739
the on the far side of the Jordan

1366
01:03:49,739 --> 01:03:52,539
River, not in There's no mitzvos but there

1367
01:03:52,539 --> 01:03:56,019
is a din of He's fulfilling the mitzvah

1368
01:03:56,019 --> 01:03:58,519
of Yishuv Eretz Yisrael even there. rabosai, thank

1369
01:03:58,519 --> 01:04:00,607
you very much for joining me and b'ezras

1370
01:04:00,607 --> 01:04:02,019
Hashem next week will be a new topic.

1371
01:04:02,019 --> 01:04:04,619
We should be zocheh to the...
