1
00:00:00,000 --> 00:00:01,560
I was recently asked a shailoh that someone

2
00:00:01,560 --> 00:00:03,799
who's going to Eretz Yisrael for Pesach with

3
00:00:03,799 --> 00:00:05,980
a bunch of family, and the family is

4
00:00:05,980 --> 00:00:08,359
keeping only one day of Yom Tov, and

5
00:00:08,359 --> 00:00:09,939
he wanted to know what the halacha is,

6
00:00:10,339 --> 00:00:11,574
should he keep two days of Yom Tov

7
00:00:11,574 --> 00:00:12,640
or should he keep one day of Yom

8
00:00:12,640 --> 00:00:16,679
Tov? So, this is a significantly complicated and

9
00:00:16,679 --> 00:00:18,879
controversial area of halacha. I just want to

10
00:00:18,879 --> 00:00:22,500
go through the basics with you and hopefully

11
00:00:22,500 --> 00:00:25,760
we'll come to some clear decision, but again,

12
00:00:25,879 --> 00:00:28,519
obviously halacha l'maise, every shailoh has so many

13
00:00:28,519 --> 00:00:31,500
little nuances of difference that you need to

14
00:00:31,500 --> 00:00:34,659
ask a shailoh each time. You can't, not

15
00:00:34,659 --> 00:00:36,000
necessarily each time, but you need to ask

16
00:00:36,000 --> 00:00:38,439
a shailoh. Each individual case needs to ask

17
00:00:38,439 --> 00:00:40,500
a shailoh. You can't always assume that two

18
00:00:40,500 --> 00:00:43,119
cases are the same. Obviously, the history of

19
00:00:43,119 --> 00:00:45,000
it is that bizman that they used to

20
00:00:45,000 --> 00:00:47,659
be mekadesh hachodesh al pi r'ia, word didn't

21
00:00:47,659 --> 00:00:49,780
get out to everybody quickly enough to know

22
00:00:49,780 --> 00:00:51,520
exactly when Rosh Chodesh is, and therefore there

23
00:00:51,520 --> 00:00:53,140
was a sfeika d'yoma. They weren't sure which

24
00:00:53,140 --> 00:00:55,159
day to keep Yom Tov, so in galus,

25
00:00:55,240 --> 00:00:57,039
they kept two days of Yom Tov to

26
00:00:57,039 --> 00:01:01,460
be sure. Even after the zman Amoraim, at

27
00:01:01,460 --> 00:01:03,379
the time when they were no longer mekadesh

28
00:01:03,379 --> 00:01:05,537
al pi r'ia, the Gemara Masechet Beitzah Daf

29
00:01:05,537 --> 00:01:07,560
daled amud bais tells us that they still

30
00:01:07,560 --> 00:01:09,359
continued to do Yom Tov Sheini shel Galuyos

31
00:01:09,439 --> 00:01:11,359
even though there's a set calendar and we

32
00:01:11,359 --> 00:01:12,859
know which day is the first day of

33
00:01:12,859 --> 00:01:15,459
Yom Tov, but still minhag avoseinu b'yadeihem, we

34
00:01:15,459 --> 00:01:17,714
continue to keep two days of Yom Tov.

35
00:01:17,714 --> 00:01:20,319
That's the very basic background to two days

36
00:01:20,319 --> 00:01:22,019
of Yom Tov. Now, there is a major

37
00:01:22,019 --> 00:01:26,326
machlokes Rishonim whether that issue of minhag avoseinu

38
00:01:26,326 --> 00:01:28,560
b'yadeihem is just a minhag or it's a

39
00:01:28,560 --> 00:01:31,099
din d'rabbanan, it's a takana mi-d'rabbanan. But whatever

40
00:01:31,099 --> 00:01:32,540
it is, it has to be kept. However

41
00:01:32,540 --> 00:01:34,260
you want to understand the details of it,

42
00:01:34,540 --> 00:01:36,180
Yom Tov Sheini shel Galuyos we don't question

43
00:01:36,180 --> 00:01:37,500
anymore. The fact that we keep two days

44
00:01:37,500 --> 00:01:40,219
of Yom Tov here in galus is a

45
00:01:40,219 --> 00:01:43,980
davar pashut. The interesting issue becomes when someone

46
00:01:43,980 --> 00:01:47,040
from Chutz La'aretz travels to Eretz Yisrael, or

47
00:01:47,040 --> 00:01:50,200
really vice versa, someone from Eretz Yisrael comes

48
00:01:50,200 --> 00:01:52,212
to Chutz La'aretz. There is a Mishna Masechet

49
00:01:52,212 --> 00:01:54,719
Pesachim Daf nun where the Mishna tells us

50
00:01:54,719 --> 00:01:56,620
that someone who goes from a makom that

51
00:01:56,620 --> 00:01:58,959
has certain minhagim to a makom that has

52
00:01:58,959 --> 00:02:01,400
different minhagim is supposed to keep the chumros

53
00:02:01,400 --> 00:02:03,819
of the makom that he came from as

54
00:02:03,819 --> 00:02:05,459
well as the chumros of the makom that

55
00:02:05,459 --> 00:02:07,159
he went to. He should keep the chumros

56
00:02:07,159 --> 00:02:10,560
of both places. The particulars of that Mishna

57
00:02:10,560 --> 00:02:12,900
is talking about doing melacha in erev Pesach,

58
00:02:12,900 --> 00:02:14,580
that there were some places that a minhag

59
00:02:14,580 --> 00:02:16,620
they didn't do melacha in erev Pesach, other

60
00:02:16,620 --> 00:02:18,199
places that had a minhag that they did

61
00:02:18,199 --> 00:02:20,240
do melacha in erev Pesach. You go from

62
00:02:20,240 --> 00:02:22,180
one makom to the other, you keep the

63
00:02:22,180 --> 00:02:24,500
chumros. You go, you keep the chumros of

64
00:02:24,500 --> 00:02:26,840
the place of both places. However, the Gemara

65
00:02:26,840 --> 00:02:29,020
over there in daf nun aleph says that

66
00:02:29,020 --> 00:02:31,680
if a person plans on staying where he

67
00:02:31,680 --> 00:02:37,340
is, the Gemara says that someone is still

68
00:02:37,340 --> 00:02:39,620
limited to all the issurim of the place

69
00:02:39,620 --> 00:02:41,960
that he left only if he plans on

70
00:02:41,960 --> 00:02:43,780
going back. But if he plans on staying

71
00:02:43,780 --> 00:02:45,439
where he is, the new makom that he

72
00:02:45,439 --> 00:02:47,900
came, so then he becomes a ben makom

73
00:02:47,900 --> 00:02:50,219
of the makom that he went to and

74
00:02:50,219 --> 00:02:52,520
he now has all the halachos of that

75
00:02:52,520 --> 00:02:54,060
makom and all the minhagim of that makom.

76
00:02:54,219 --> 00:02:56,270
So if someone went, let's say, from Chutz

77
00:02:56,270 --> 00:02:58,280
La'aretz to Eretz Yisrael, just because he was

78
00:02:58,280 --> 00:02:59,960
born in Chutz La'aretz doesn't mean that he's

79
00:02:59,960 --> 00:03:02,699
forever limited or bound by the Chutz La'aretz

80
00:03:02,699 --> 00:03:05,280
chumros, let's say. So he would keep whatever

81
00:03:05,280 --> 00:03:06,900
they keep in Eretz Yisrael if he plans

82
00:03:06,900 --> 00:03:08,719
on making aliya, he plans on staying there.

83
00:03:09,000 --> 00:03:10,360
If you plan on staying, you don't have

84
00:03:10,360 --> 00:03:15,099
da'as lachzor, so then your halacha changes. So

85
00:03:15,099 --> 00:03:16,539
the question over here is how does this

86
00:03:16,539 --> 00:03:17,840
apply to Yom Tov Sheini or does it

87
00:03:17,840 --> 00:03:19,659
apply to Yom Tov Sheini? Meaning, maybe we

88
00:03:19,659 --> 00:03:21,280
should say the same thing. You have someone

89
00:03:21,280 --> 00:03:23,419
who goes from Chutz La'aretz to Eretz Yisrael,

90
00:03:23,580 --> 00:03:26,620
plans on coming back, so just apply that

91
00:03:26,620 --> 00:03:28,419
Gemara, and therefore the halacha should be he

92
00:03:28,419 --> 00:03:30,400
keeps the chumros of both places, keeps the

93
00:03:30,400 --> 00:03:31,719
chumros of Eretz Yisrael and the chumros of

94
00:03:31,719 --> 00:03:33,439
Chutz La'aretz. Or do you say, maybe no,

95
00:03:33,520 --> 00:03:35,500
maybe there's reason to say that we shouldn't

96
00:03:35,500 --> 00:03:38,106
apply this Gemara? So, in the Teshuvos Avkas

97
00:03:38,106 --> 00:03:40,060
Rochel, which was written by Rav Yosef Karo

98
00:03:40,060 --> 00:03:43,759
in Siman Chaf Vov, he paskens that we

99
00:03:43,759 --> 00:03:46,960
do apply the concepts in the Gemara in

100
00:03:46,960 --> 00:03:48,800
Pesachim, the Mishna in Pesachim of applying the

101
00:03:48,800 --> 00:03:51,259
chumros of both places, and therefore he says

102
00:03:51,259 --> 00:03:52,889
when a ben Chutz La'aretz goes to Eretz

103
00:03:52,889 --> 00:03:55,300
Yisrael and plans on returning, he does need

104
00:03:55,300 --> 00:03:56,680
to keep all the chumros and he's got

105
00:03:56,680 --> 00:03:58,860
to keep two days of Yom Tov. That's

106
00:03:58,860 --> 00:04:00,500
meforash in the teshuva of the Bais Yosef

107
00:04:00,500 --> 00:04:02,400
in Avkas Rochel. And he even goes so

108
00:04:02,400 --> 00:04:03,919
far as to say that it was a

109
00:04:03,919 --> 00:04:05,740
minhag that that's what everyone did, that the

110
00:04:05,740 --> 00:04:07,300
minhag used to always be that people would

111
00:04:07,300 --> 00:04:10,039
gather and have Yom Tov Sheini minyanim where

112
00:04:10,039 --> 00:04:12,519
they davened tefillos of Yom Tov in Eretz

113
00:04:12,519 --> 00:04:14,800
Yisrael. So that's what people always did, that's

114
00:04:14,800 --> 00:04:16,579
not a chiddush. He didn't view that as

115
00:04:16,579 --> 00:04:18,759
like something that's against the minhag. He said

116
00:04:18,759 --> 00:04:20,360
that's what people always did when they went

117
00:04:20,360 --> 00:04:24,800
from Chutz La'aretz to Eretz Yisrael. And in

118
00:04:24,800 --> 00:04:26,399
fact, that's the way most of the poskim

119
00:04:26,399 --> 00:04:28,691
seem to say. Mishnah Berurah in Taf Tzaddik

120
00:04:28,691 --> 00:04:30,180
Vav Sif Kattan yud gimmel, Rav Moshe in

121
00:04:30,180 --> 00:04:31,937
a couple of teshuvos in Orach Chaim Chelek

122
00:04:31,937 --> 00:04:33,812
Gimmel Siman Ayin daled and Chelek daled Siman

123
00:04:33,812 --> 00:04:36,100
chaf ches. This is something that seems to

124
00:04:36,100 --> 00:04:39,600
be widely accepted among the poskim. However, there

125
00:04:39,600 --> 00:04:42,920
is a significant shitta, which interestingly when you

126
00:04:42,920 --> 00:04:44,339
look at Rav Moshe's teshuvos, he doesn't even

127
00:04:44,339 --> 00:04:45,959
quote this shitta, it's like he's not even

128
00:04:45,959 --> 00:04:47,850
gores it, but the shitta of the Chacham

129
00:04:47,850 --> 00:04:49,720
Tzvi, which is a very well-known shitta and

130
00:04:49,720 --> 00:04:52,779
has pretty cogent logic. The Chacham Tzvi in

131
00:04:53,220 --> 00:04:55,434
Siman kuf samech zayin was asked this question,

132
00:04:55,434 --> 00:04:57,399
and he says no, you can't apply the

133
00:04:57,399 --> 00:04:59,180
Gemara in Pesachim at all. The Gemara in

134
00:04:59,180 --> 00:05:03,354
Pesachim is talking about minhagim that theoretically could

135
00:05:03,354 --> 00:05:06,040
be can apply in any place, but for

136
00:05:06,040 --> 00:05:07,800
whatever reason the bnei hamakom in a certain

137
00:05:07,800 --> 00:05:10,040
place keep a certain minhag and in another

138
00:05:10,040 --> 00:05:11,414
place they don't keep a certain minhag. So

139
00:05:11,459 --> 00:05:13,519
then we say, okay, keep the chumra even

140
00:05:13,519 --> 00:05:15,980
when you go from point A to point

141
00:05:15,980 --> 00:05:18,139
B, keep the chumra of point A even

142
00:05:18,139 --> 00:05:20,060
though you're now in place B. Still you

143
00:05:20,060 --> 00:05:21,639
keep the chumra. That makes sense if it's

144
00:05:21,639 --> 00:05:23,860
a chumra that theoretically could have been observed

145
00:05:23,860 --> 00:05:26,300
anywhere. But over here it's not a chumra

146
00:05:26,300 --> 00:05:28,713
that could have been observed anywhere. Yom Tov

147
00:05:28,713 --> 00:05:31,240
Sheni is a din that's only shayach to

148
00:05:31,240 --> 00:05:33,319
chutz la'aretz. It's something that only makes sense

149
00:05:33,319 --> 00:05:36,100
in chutz la'aretz. And Eretz Yisrael doesn't even

150
00:05:36,100 --> 00:05:37,920
make sense, they never would have kept Yom

151
00:05:37,920 --> 00:05:40,300
Tov Sheni in Eretz Yisrael. So says Rav

152
00:05:40,300 --> 00:05:43,959
Yosef, I'm still in shiur mode, says the

153
00:05:43,959 --> 00:05:46,240
Chacham Tzvi, what we see from there is

154
00:05:46,240 --> 00:05:49,439
that it seems you should not apply this

155
00:05:49,439 --> 00:05:52,259
mishna at all, and therefore he says if

156
00:05:52,259 --> 00:05:54,060
someone is visiting Eretz Yisrael and he's a

157
00:05:54,060 --> 00:05:56,220
ben chutz la'aretz, he only keeps one day

158
00:05:56,220 --> 00:05:59,319
of Yom Tov. This has been accepted by

159
00:05:59,319 --> 00:06:00,959
some of the later acharonim, by some of

160
00:06:00,959 --> 00:06:03,819
the mainstream acharonim. Shulchan Aruch HaRav, I assume

161
00:06:03,819 --> 00:06:05,540
this is what Lubavitchers do, Shulchan Aruch HaRav

162
00:06:05,540 --> 00:06:11,199
writes in siman tav-tzadi-vav os yud-aleph, he writes

163
00:06:11,540 --> 00:06:14,439
bnei chutz la'aretz shebau le'eretz yisrael af al

164
00:06:14,439 --> 00:06:16,160
pi shedaatan lachzor, even though they plan on

165
00:06:16,160 --> 00:06:18,710
going back home to chutz la'aretz to chutz

166
00:06:18,710 --> 00:06:21,460
la'aretz, shouldn't call it ein osin ela yom

167
00:06:21,460 --> 00:06:24,319
echad k'vnei eretz yisrael. They still only keep

168
00:06:24,319 --> 00:06:26,600
one day like bnei eretz yisrael. And then

169
00:06:26,600 --> 00:06:28,800
he writes like an afterthought, v'yeish cholkin, there

170
00:06:28,800 --> 00:06:31,019
are those who disagree. But the stam deiah

171
00:06:31,139 --> 00:06:33,000
that's quoted in Shulchan Aruch HaRav is that

172
00:06:33,000 --> 00:06:35,019
you keep one day. That is the shita

173
00:06:35,019 --> 00:06:37,939
of the Chacham Tzvi, but it's certainly if

174
00:06:37,939 --> 00:06:39,420
you read through poskim, it seems to be

175
00:06:39,420 --> 00:06:42,279
a significant minority shita, does not seem to

176
00:06:42,279 --> 00:06:44,319
be the majority shita. Now then there's a

177
00:06:44,319 --> 00:06:45,800
third shita. Many of you may have heard

178
00:06:45,800 --> 00:06:47,839
of the one and a half, and there

179
00:06:47,839 --> 00:06:49,560
are various variations of what one and a

180
00:06:49,560 --> 00:06:50,720
half means. What one and a half does

181
00:06:50,720 --> 00:06:52,800
not mean is you keep one day and

182
00:06:52,800 --> 00:06:54,634
then the other day till chatzos. That it

183
00:06:54,634 --> 00:06:56,259
certainly does not mean. One and a half

184
00:06:56,259 --> 00:06:57,839
means the following, and this is a shita

185
00:06:57,839 --> 00:07:01,279
that's quoted by Rebbi Yechiel Michel Tukachinsky in

186
00:07:01,279 --> 00:07:04,220
his Ir HaKodesh VeHaMikdash perek yud-tes, and it's

187
00:07:04,220 --> 00:07:07,534
something that everyone quotes beshem Rav Soloveitchik. Rav

188
00:07:07,699 --> 00:07:09,100
Soloveitchik held this way as well, and he

189
00:07:09,100 --> 00:07:11,060
had to worry about this himself. He only

190
00:07:11,060 --> 00:07:12,360
went to Eretz Yisrael I think one time

191
00:07:12,360 --> 00:07:14,360
in the 1930s when he was trying out

192
00:07:14,360 --> 00:07:18,620
for Chief Rabbi of Tel Aviv. So I

193
00:07:18,620 --> 00:07:21,779
think he was there for a Shavuos. So

194
00:07:21,779 --> 00:07:23,180
he asked his father, he asked Rav Moshe

195
00:07:23,180 --> 00:07:25,459
Soloveitchik what to do. So this is what

196
00:07:25,459 --> 00:07:26,759
he told him to do. He said, look,

197
00:07:27,120 --> 00:07:29,040
Chacham Tzvi is right. He said his logic

198
00:07:29,040 --> 00:07:31,939
is so good, you gotta say that he's

199
00:07:31,939 --> 00:07:34,779
correct. But since the majority of poskim say

200
00:07:34,779 --> 00:07:37,240
against the Chacham Tzvi, you can't just dismiss

201
00:07:37,240 --> 00:07:39,874
the other shitos. And therefore you should pasken

202
00:07:39,874 --> 00:07:41,720
like the Chacham Tzvi but be machmir for

203
00:07:41,720 --> 00:07:45,480
the other deious, which means that take sides

204
00:07:45,699 --> 00:07:47,639
and assume that really there's really only one

205
00:07:47,639 --> 00:07:49,759
day of Yom Tov, but be machmir not

206
00:07:49,759 --> 00:07:52,699
to do melacha on the second day. You

207
00:07:52,699 --> 00:07:55,079
should be machmir in both directions. But whenever

208
00:07:55,079 --> 00:07:57,839
the chumra has to—like every chumra, with every

209
00:07:57,839 --> 00:08:00,860
chumra comes a kula the chumra presents a

210
00:08:00,860 --> 00:08:03,060
conflict between day one and day two, always

211
00:08:03,060 --> 00:08:05,660
lean toward day one because that's the real

212
00:08:05,660 --> 00:08:08,639
halacha. So for instance, after the first night

213
00:08:08,639 --> 00:08:10,459
of Yom Tov you hear havdala from an

214
00:08:10,459 --> 00:08:13,399
Israeli who's making havdala and you don't say

215
00:08:13,399 --> 00:08:14,879
kiddush because you don't want to say a

216
00:08:15,040 --> 00:08:16,180
bracha levatala so you're not going to say

217
00:08:16,180 --> 00:08:18,100
kiddush because you really hold be'etzem it's only

218
00:08:18,100 --> 00:08:20,920
one day. On the day after Yom Tov

219
00:08:20,920 --> 00:08:23,860
rishon you say tfillos shel chol because you

220
00:08:23,860 --> 00:08:25,480
gotta decide which tfillos you're going to say,

221
00:08:25,600 --> 00:08:26,779
so on the second day of Yom Tov

222
00:08:26,779 --> 00:08:28,379
say tfillos shel chol because you pasken like

223
00:08:28,379 --> 00:08:30,500
the Chacham Tzvi. On Shemini Atzeret you don't

224
00:08:30,500 --> 00:08:33,220
eat in the sukka. All these types Pesach

225
00:08:33,220 --> 00:08:35,299
sedarim are a very complicated issue exactly what

226
00:08:35,299 --> 00:08:36,727
you do. He has a whole, Rebbi Yechiel

227
00:08:36,727 --> 00:08:38,980
Michel Tukachinsky gives a whole presentation of all

228
00:08:38,980 --> 00:08:40,854
these details what to do. That's what Rav

229
00:08:40,854 --> 00:08:42,360
Soloveitchik paskened. I once asked Rav Schachter about

230
00:08:42,360 --> 00:08:44,399
this, he said he paskens the exact opposite.

231
00:08:44,559 --> 00:08:46,080
He said, \"That's what Rav Soloveitchik held.\" He

232
00:08:46,080 --> 00:08:48,000
said, \"I hold that really me'ikar hadin it's

233
00:08:48,000 --> 00:08:50,279
two days, but it's kedai to be machmir

234
00:08:50,279 --> 00:08:52,779
for the shitos that it's one day.\" So

235
00:08:52,899 --> 00:08:54,519
you would davven tfillos shel Yom Tov but

236
00:08:54,519 --> 00:08:55,840
you would still have to put on tefillin

237
00:08:56,220 --> 00:08:58,299
just without a bracha. So it would be

238
00:08:58,299 --> 00:09:01,580
a whole separate twist to which direction you

239
00:09:01,580 --> 00:09:04,799
would go. That's the third shita. Now there

240
00:09:04,799 --> 00:09:07,000
are a couple of X-factors over here. X-factor

241
00:09:07,220 --> 00:09:09,279
number one is what does daatan lachzor mean?

242
00:09:09,679 --> 00:09:11,340
The Radbaz writes in a tshuva and this

243
00:09:11,340 --> 00:09:13,004
is accepted by the Mishna Berura in tav-tzadi-vav

244
00:09:13,004 --> 00:09:14,779
seif katan yud-gimmel that if you go with

245
00:09:14,779 --> 00:09:17,539
your entire family then you're not considered daatan

246
00:09:17,539 --> 00:09:19,340
lachzor. Because who's going to go with their

247
00:09:19,340 --> 00:09:21,240
entire family and not fall in love with

248
00:09:21,240 --> 00:09:22,559
Eretz Yisrael and just want to stay there?

249
00:09:22,879 --> 00:09:25,019
Meaning if you go without your family, okay

250
00:09:25,080 --> 00:09:26,759
you have something pulling you back. But you

251
00:09:26,759 --> 00:09:28,279
go with your entire family, then it's not

252
00:09:28,279 --> 00:09:30,399
daatan lachzor. So Rav Moshe writes that that's

253
00:09:30,399 --> 00:09:32,919
ridiculous to apply to our times where you

254
00:09:32,919 --> 00:09:35,039
bought a return ticket and you get home

255
00:09:35,039 --> 00:09:37,820
in ten hours and like very few people

256
00:09:37,820 --> 00:09:39,690
go and then just stay. It's interesting, Rav

257
00:09:39,690 --> 00:09:41,940
Nosson Gestetner writes in a tshuva that when

258
00:09:41,940 --> 00:09:43,899
he went to Eretz Yisrael in whatever it

259
00:09:43,899 --> 00:09:45,929
was, 1950, or whatever it was, when he

260
00:09:45,929 --> 00:09:47,100
went—it was before that, I think it was

261
00:09:47,100 --> 00:09:48,720
even before World War II—when he went to

262
00:09:49,819 --> 00:09:52,519
Eretz Yisrael for a visit, he started learning

263
00:09:52,519 --> 00:09:54,200
in yeshiva there and he loved it so

264
00:09:54,200 --> 00:09:56,220
much he decided right there on the spot

265
00:09:56,399 --> 00:09:57,940
on Yom Tov. It happened to have been

266
00:09:57,940 --> 00:09:59,024
on Yom Tov, it was I think it

267
00:09:59,024 --> 00:10:01,259
was on Shavuos, he... decided I'm staying. Now

268
00:10:01,259 --> 00:10:02,299
he didn't know what to do. When he

269
00:10:02,299 --> 00:10:03,379
started Yom Tov he was going to keep

270
00:10:03,379 --> 00:10:05,039
two days, but he didn't know what to

271
00:10:05,039 --> 00:10:06,220
do: should I keep a second day? Because

272
00:10:06,220 --> 00:10:07,659
he decided right then and there that he's

273
00:10:07,659 --> 00:10:09,179
staying. He went to ask the Chazon Ish.

274
00:10:09,240 --> 00:10:10,320
I don't remember what the, what the answer

275
00:10:10,320 --> 00:10:12,200
the Chazon Ish gave him. But that's, you

276
00:10:12,200 --> 00:10:15,679
know, if that, that were a legitimate possibility,

277
00:10:15,980 --> 00:10:17,340
then when you go with your whole family,

278
00:10:17,340 --> 00:10:19,929
that's, that's the shita that holds that, that

279
00:10:20,580 --> 00:10:22,740
that's called already that it's not daato lachzor

280
00:10:22,759 --> 00:10:24,039
and then you would keep only one day.

281
00:10:24,799 --> 00:10:27,740
Aruch HaShulchan writes that if you plan on

282
00:10:27,740 --> 00:10:29,429
staying for at least a year, then it's,

283
00:10:29,429 --> 00:10:31,240
then you would only keep one day, which

284
00:10:31,240 --> 00:10:32,580
would have a big nafka mina for guys

285
00:10:32,580 --> 00:10:33,909
who go to learn for a year. Ella

286
00:10:33,909 --> 00:10:35,340
mai, guys don't really go to learn for

287
00:10:35,340 --> 00:10:37,039
a year anymore. Guys go for a couple

288
00:10:37,039 --> 00:10:38,659
of months, then they come home, you know,

289
00:10:38,740 --> 00:10:40,759
for a wedding, for their cousin's wedding, and

290
00:10:40,759 --> 00:10:42,980
for Chanukah because they need a Chanukah present

291
00:10:42,980 --> 00:10:44,580
and a hug and then they go, you

292
00:10:44,580 --> 00:10:47,234
know, for Pesach again and whatever. So no

293
00:10:47,234 --> 00:10:48,539
one, no one really goes for a full

294
00:10:48,539 --> 00:10:50,399
year anymore. But if you were to literally

295
00:10:50,399 --> 00:10:52,080
go for a full year, Aruch HaShulchan thinks

296
00:10:52,080 --> 00:10:53,620
that you would only keep, you would only

297
00:10:53,620 --> 00:10:56,220
keep one day. Rav Ovadia Yosef thinks that

298
00:10:56,220 --> 00:11:00,139
if you're a bachur of marriageable age who's

299
00:11:00,139 --> 00:11:02,779
single and you're in Eretz Yisrael learning in

300
00:11:02,779 --> 00:11:04,884
yeshiva, Rav Ovadia writes in a teshuva in

301
00:11:04,884 --> 00:11:07,399
Yabia Omer chelek vav Orach Chayim siman mem

302
00:11:07,480 --> 00:11:09,379
and Yechaveh Da'at chelek aleph siman chof vav

303
00:11:09,379 --> 00:11:11,600
you keep one day because even though you're

304
00:11:11,600 --> 00:11:14,019
not dating right now, chances are, not chances

305
00:11:14,019 --> 00:11:15,620
are, but there's a possibility you'll meet a

306
00:11:15,620 --> 00:11:17,340
nice Israeli girl and you're going to want

307
00:11:17,340 --> 00:11:19,600
to stay in Eretz Yisrael. Unless you're absolutely

308
00:11:19,600 --> 00:11:21,580
adamant that under no circumstances are you going

309
00:11:21,580 --> 00:11:24,149
to date an Israeli girl. Then maybe, then

310
00:11:24,149 --> 00:11:26,299
maybe it would be different. I'm not making

311
00:11:26,299 --> 00:11:30,139
this up. So that's X-factor number one. X-factor

312
00:11:30,139 --> 00:11:33,940
number two is Rav Schachter. He told me

313
00:11:33,940 --> 00:11:35,200
a number of years ago that he was

314
00:11:35,200 --> 00:11:37,919
very disturbed that rumors started going around that

315
00:11:37,919 --> 00:11:39,720
Rav Schachter holds that if you go in

316
00:11:39,720 --> 00:11:41,320
a large group, you only keep one day.

317
00:11:41,720 --> 00:11:42,799
He said that's not at all what I

318
00:11:42,799 --> 00:11:44,360
hold. Let me tell you what happened. A

319
00:11:44,360 --> 00:11:46,220
large group of people were going from California.

320
00:11:46,360 --> 00:11:48,059
A group of 250 people. The rabbi called

321
00:11:48,059 --> 00:11:50,620
me up and he said 200 of these

322
00:11:50,620 --> 00:11:52,279
250 people are not going to ask me

323
00:11:52,279 --> 00:11:53,360
what to do. They're going to keep one

324
00:11:53,360 --> 00:11:55,379
day no matter what. What should I tell

325
00:11:55,379 --> 00:11:57,220
the other 50 to do? And they're going

326
00:11:57,220 --> 00:11:58,659
as a group, they're doing everything together. So

327
00:11:58,659 --> 00:12:00,059
Rav Schachter said he thought in that situation

328
00:12:00,059 --> 00:12:02,000
where 200 of them are anyway going to

329
00:12:02,000 --> 00:12:03,879
keep one day, it would be a violation

330
00:12:03,879 --> 00:12:06,259
of Lo Titgodedu to have different people doing

331
00:12:06,259 --> 00:12:08,159
different things. They're all in the same situation,

332
00:12:08,159 --> 00:12:09,899
they should all do the same thing. So

333
00:12:09,899 --> 00:12:11,740
he said l'halacha they should all keep two

334
00:12:11,740 --> 00:12:13,720
days, l'chumra, two days and then one day

335
00:12:13,720 --> 00:12:17,399
l'chumra. But they're not. So if you're in

336
00:12:17,399 --> 00:12:19,120
a group where the large majority are keeping

337
00:12:19,120 --> 00:12:20,940
one day, so he thought that because of

338
00:12:21,159 --> 00:12:23,259
Lo Titgodedu that you should, you should conform

339
00:12:23,919 --> 00:12:25,820
to what everybody, to what everybody else is

340
00:12:25,820 --> 00:12:27,854
doing. But it's a very tricky thing. I

341
00:12:27,854 --> 00:12:29,000
had a balebos, for instance, who was going

342
00:12:29,000 --> 00:12:30,419
with his parents. His parents own an apartment

343
00:12:30,419 --> 00:12:32,259
in Eretz Yisrael and they keep one day,

344
00:12:32,259 --> 00:12:33,620
they got a psak from whoever they got

345
00:12:33,620 --> 00:12:36,340
it from, and he went to Eretz Yisrael

346
00:12:36,340 --> 00:12:39,039
for Shavuos. So he asked Rav Schachter, \"What

347
00:12:39,039 --> 00:12:40,314
do you think in this situation? Lo Titgodedu?

348
00:12:40,500 --> 00:12:42,500
No, he's going with his whole family, they're

349
00:12:42,500 --> 00:12:44,779
all keeping one day. He said no, the

350
00:12:44,779 --> 00:12:46,899
parents own an apartment in Eretz Yisrael, he

351
00:12:46,899 --> 00:12:49,759
doesn't. So they're in a different situation. When

352
00:12:49,759 --> 00:12:51,600
there's a different matzav for different members of

353
00:12:51,600 --> 00:12:54,014
the family, so then you wouldn't say Lo

354
00:12:54,014 --> 00:12:56,820
Titgodedu. Lo Titgodedu is everyone in the same

355
00:12:56,820 --> 00:12:58,600
boat should do the same thing, but they're

356
00:12:58,600 --> 00:13:00,340
in two different boats over here. I'm just

357
00:13:00,340 --> 00:13:02,519
mentioning this because you have to realize that

358
00:13:02,519 --> 00:13:04,559
there are so many little nuances in each

359
00:13:04,559 --> 00:13:06,460
case that a shayla has to be asked

360
00:13:06,460 --> 00:13:08,299
in each and every situation. In terms of

361
00:13:08,299 --> 00:13:10,340
the shayla that was asked recently to me,

362
00:13:10,340 --> 00:13:11,980
I'll deal with that personally. But these are

363
00:13:11,980 --> 00:13:14,919
just some of the basic, the basic overview.
