1
00:00:01,139 --> 00:00:03,100
Okay, so again, very exciting topic which I'm

2
00:00:03,100 --> 00:00:05,669
excited to teach about, which is the Yom

3
00:00:05,669 --> 00:00:07,879
Tov tourist, if anyone in this room or

4
00:00:07,879 --> 00:00:10,240
anyone listening might end up in Israel, so

5
00:00:10,240 --> 00:00:12,080
the big question is going to be, not

6
00:00:12,080 --> 00:00:15,960
just Pesach but Shavuos and Succos and Succos,

7
00:00:16,339 --> 00:00:18,660
how many days of Yom Tov are you

8
00:00:18,660 --> 00:00:20,100
keeping? And this is a very, very relevant

9
00:00:20,100 --> 00:00:22,780
question, you know, really all the time it

10
00:00:22,780 --> 00:00:25,460
comes up every single chag, people are asked,

11
00:00:25,600 --> 00:00:27,460
people are asking, people hear something from their

12
00:00:27,460 --> 00:00:29,719
friend. So let's learn the sources together. I'm

13
00:00:29,719 --> 00:00:31,219
going to put a disclaimer right now that

14
00:00:31,219 --> 00:00:32,840
I am not going to be giving, you

15
00:00:32,840 --> 00:00:35,020
know, the official psak, but I will kind

16
00:00:35,020 --> 00:00:37,060
of just let you know what's out there

17
00:00:37,060 --> 00:00:39,200
a little bit. I'll tell you if there

18
00:00:39,200 --> 00:00:40,939
are official psakim, but for the most part,

19
00:00:41,020 --> 00:00:42,700
we're just kind of learning the sugya over

20
00:00:42,700 --> 00:00:46,200
here. Okay, so the starting point with this

21
00:00:46,200 --> 00:00:47,960
sugya, you really have to just we need

22
00:00:47,960 --> 00:00:49,500
a little bit of background. Right, so originally,

23
00:00:49,500 --> 00:00:52,460
originally, before we had a fixed calendar, right

24
00:00:52,460 --> 00:00:53,780
now our calendar is fixed. If you look

25
00:00:53,780 --> 00:00:55,259
on the Ezras Torah luach, you'll figure out

26
00:00:55,259 --> 00:00:57,320
exactly how long each month is, and when

27
00:00:57,320 --> 00:00:59,600
the molad etc. All this stuff is you

28
00:00:59,600 --> 00:01:01,420
can figure out from Google, from your luach.

29
00:01:01,859 --> 00:01:03,000
Way back when it didn't work that way.

30
00:01:03,079 --> 00:01:04,906
Way back when the way it worked al

31
00:01:04,906 --> 00:01:07,840
pi din Torah, they would have two edim

32
00:01:07,840 --> 00:01:09,299
come, two edim would see the new moon,

33
00:01:09,620 --> 00:01:11,560
and if edim saw the new moon, so

34
00:01:11,560 --> 00:01:12,938
they would come to the Beis Din HaGadol,

35
00:01:12,938 --> 00:01:15,140
the Beis Din HaGadol based on their testimony

36
00:01:15,180 --> 00:01:17,180
would say, okay, the new moon has come,

37
00:01:17,239 --> 00:01:18,239
which means that it is a brand new

38
00:01:18,239 --> 00:01:20,299
month, and based on the testimony, or lack

39
00:01:20,299 --> 00:01:22,760
thereof, they would decide that the previous month

40
00:01:22,760 --> 00:01:25,519
had either been 29 days or had been

41
00:01:25,519 --> 00:01:28,180
30 days. But you, if you weren't, you

42
00:01:28,180 --> 00:01:30,939
know, around, if you didn't have basically no

43
00:01:30,939 --> 00:01:32,239
then there was impossible for you to know

44
00:01:32,239 --> 00:01:34,040
how long the previous month was going to

45
00:01:34,040 --> 00:01:35,700
be. So let's say it was Pesach coming

46
00:01:35,700 --> 00:01:39,079
up, so and you lived very, very far

47
00:01:39,079 --> 00:01:41,719
away. So you don't know, is today the

48
00:01:41,719 --> 00:01:43,500
first day of Nissan already? Or are we

49
00:01:43,500 --> 00:01:45,819
on the last day of Adar Sheini? You

50
00:01:45,819 --> 00:01:47,120
wouldn't know, you wouldn't have an idea. So

51
00:01:47,120 --> 00:01:49,060
now, once they figure that out, they then

52
00:01:49,060 --> 00:01:50,980
have to send shluchim, they have to go

53
00:01:50,980 --> 00:01:53,239
and send people across all of Eretz Yisrael

54
00:01:53,640 --> 00:01:54,840
and outside of Eretz Yisrael, tell all the

55
00:01:54,840 --> 00:01:57,239
Jewish communities, hey, look, you know, we made

56
00:01:57,239 --> 00:01:59,379
it X amount of days or we made

57
00:01:59,379 --> 00:02:01,280
it Y amount of days, the month was

58
00:02:01,280 --> 00:02:03,799
either malei or it was chaser. So the

59
00:02:03,799 --> 00:02:05,719
way it worked out is that practically if

60
00:02:05,719 --> 00:02:08,020
people were outside of a certain distance, if

61
00:02:08,020 --> 00:02:09,860
people were outside of let's say a fifteen

62
00:02:09,860 --> 00:02:12,539
days' travel so that they wouldn't have heard

63
00:02:12,539 --> 00:02:15,479
whether which way Nissan worked, which way Nissan

64
00:02:15,699 --> 00:02:17,659
or really the previous month, which way Adar

65
00:02:17,800 --> 00:02:19,560
how long it was, so they would end

66
00:02:19,560 --> 00:02:21,379
up having to keep two days of Pesach

67
00:02:21,379 --> 00:02:23,419
because they weren't sure is today the first

68
00:02:23,419 --> 00:02:26,199
day of Pesach, is it the last day

69
00:02:26,199 --> 00:02:28,860
before Pesach etc. and automatically you'd end up

70
00:02:28,860 --> 00:02:32,199
keeping two days of Yom Tov. So that

71
00:02:32,199 --> 00:02:34,680
makes all a lot of sense. Everything changed

72
00:02:34,680 --> 00:02:38,539
once they once they made a fixed calendar.

73
00:02:38,719 --> 00:02:39,680
Because now that we have a fixed calendar,

74
00:02:40,060 --> 00:02:41,193
again you can look at your Ezras Torah

75
00:02:41,193 --> 00:02:43,180
luach, you can see exactly how long is

76
00:02:43,180 --> 00:02:44,240
this month and how long is the next

77
00:02:44,240 --> 00:02:46,360
month, so I know with certainty that the

78
00:02:46,360 --> 00:02:48,000
15th of Nissan is the 15th of Nissan.

79
00:02:48,300 --> 00:02:49,539
So why do I have to go and

80
00:02:49,539 --> 00:02:51,139
keep two days? I know the only in

81
00:02:51,139 --> 00:02:52,860
the Torah the only there's only one day

82
00:02:52,860 --> 00:02:54,039
of Yom Tov at the beginning of Pesach,

83
00:02:54,139 --> 00:02:55,479
there's only one day of Yom Tov at

84
00:02:55,479 --> 00:02:56,500
the end of Pesach, I should only have

85
00:02:56,500 --> 00:02:57,400
to keep one day, why do I have

86
00:02:57,400 --> 00:02:58,960
to keep more than that? So the Gemara

87
00:02:58,960 --> 00:03:01,620
in Beitzah addresses all this. It first tells

88
00:03:01,620 --> 00:03:04,866
us the background, Barishona in source one, hayu

89
00:03:04,866 --> 00:03:07,099
masi'in masu'os. So they used to, this is

90
00:03:07,099 --> 00:03:09,080
Barishona Barishona, a quicker way to get the

91
00:03:09,080 --> 00:03:11,419
information out. Originally what they would do instead

92
00:03:11,419 --> 00:03:13,080
of actually sending runners to go and tell

93
00:03:13,080 --> 00:03:14,819
people, hey, you know, we made the chodesh

94
00:03:14,819 --> 00:03:16,319
a certain way, is they would light bonfires.

95
00:03:16,319 --> 00:03:19,199
The bonfires would tell would be a signal

96
00:03:19,199 --> 00:03:21,360
for how long the month was and that

97
00:03:21,360 --> 00:03:22,740
was a much more efficient system. You could

98
00:03:22,740 --> 00:03:24,539
go from mountain to mountain to mountain and

99
00:03:24,539 --> 00:03:26,280
spread word very, very fast all in the

100
00:03:26,280 --> 00:03:30,080
course of one night. However, mishekilkelu haKusim, then

101
00:03:30,080 --> 00:03:32,099
the Kusim came along, the Samaritans, they made

102
00:03:32,099 --> 00:03:34,979
trouble for the rabbinic Jews and they wanted

103
00:03:34,979 --> 00:03:36,620
to mess with our calendar. So they would

104
00:03:36,620 --> 00:03:37,979
go ahead and light the bonfires when we

105
00:03:37,979 --> 00:03:39,439
weren't supposed to light the bonfires and they

106
00:03:39,439 --> 00:03:41,699
threw the entire calendar into whack. So they

107
00:03:41,699 --> 00:03:43,780
had to stop doing this whole fire lighting

108
00:03:43,780 --> 00:03:46,159
thing. hiskinu sheyehu shluchim yotzin. They said, okay,

109
00:03:46,240 --> 00:03:48,159
so we have to go and send shluchim,

110
00:03:48,379 --> 00:03:51,240
fine. v'ilu batlu Kutim avidnan chad yoma, okay

111
00:03:51,319 --> 00:03:54,360
etc. I'm going to just skip to the

112
00:03:54,360 --> 00:03:57,139
next line, v'hashta d'yad'inan b'kvi'a d'yarcha, but nowadays

113
00:03:57,139 --> 00:03:59,699
that we actually know exactly when the calendar

114
00:03:59,699 --> 00:04:01,460
how long it is, that happened around the

115
00:04:01,460 --> 00:04:03,479
4th century CE when the calendar was set

116
00:04:03,479 --> 00:04:06,195
by Hillel HaSheini, so mai ta'ama avidnan try

117
00:04:06,195 --> 00:04:07,580
yomei. So why do we do two days

118
00:04:07,580 --> 00:04:10,379
nowadays? And the answer is mishum d'shalchu m'tam

119
00:04:10,740 --> 00:04:13,209
because it was sent from there. Ironically, shalchu

120
00:04:13,209 --> 00:04:14,580
m'tam means it was sent from Eretz Yisrael.

121
00:04:15,039 --> 00:04:16,259
So the people who were sending this psak

122
00:04:16,259 --> 00:04:18,000
were from Eretz Yisrael. I think the Gemara

123
00:04:18,000 --> 00:04:19,500
in Sanhedrin says it might be Rabbi Eliezer,

124
00:04:19,980 --> 00:04:24,029
one of the Tannaim or Amoraim there in

125
00:04:24,029 --> 00:04:27,680
in Israel, hizaharu b'minhag avoteichem b'yadeichem. You have

126
00:04:27,680 --> 00:04:30,500
to be careful about the minhag of your

127
00:04:30,500 --> 00:04:32,438
fathers in your hands, keep the minhagim of

128
00:04:32,438 --> 00:04:34,199
your of your parents. Your parents used to

129
00:04:34,199 --> 00:04:37,339
keep two days outside of Eretz Yisrael, so

130
00:04:37,339 --> 00:04:39,830
you too also keep two days of Yom

131
00:04:39,830 --> 00:04:42,480
Tov outside of Eretz Yisrael. zimnin d'gazru shmad

132
00:04:42,480 --> 00:04:44,379
v'ati l'kilkulei. Why do you have to keep

133
00:04:44,379 --> 00:04:46,459
the minhag? Because what's going to happen? Maybe

134
00:04:46,459 --> 00:04:47,639
one day there's going to be a shmad,

135
00:04:47,740 --> 00:04:48,680
there's going to be they're going to prevent

136
00:04:48,680 --> 00:04:50,300
the Jews from keeping Torah properly, they're going

137
00:04:50,300 --> 00:04:52,779
to prevent people from learning Torah properly and

138
00:04:52,779 --> 00:04:53,600
you're not going to be able to figure

139
00:04:53,600 --> 00:04:55,399
out exactly when is how long is the

140
00:04:55,399 --> 00:04:57,199
month. Right, meaning let's say they got rid

141
00:04:57,199 --> 00:04:58,920
of all the Ezras Torah luchos, so how

142
00:04:58,920 --> 00:05:00,800
would you know how long... The luach is.

143
00:05:00,899 --> 00:05:02,699
So there's all these calculations, there's a whole

144
00:05:02,699 --> 00:05:04,399
siman in Shulchan Aruch about how to figure

145
00:05:04,399 --> 00:05:06,819
out how the calendar works. It's not so

146
00:05:06,819 --> 00:05:10,980
simple. I'm seeing Davida has... What? You call

147
00:05:10,980 --> 00:05:12,639
up Sam. Right. So Sam knows it. So

148
00:05:12,639 --> 00:05:13,879
Rav Moshe Feinstein, this might seem like a

149
00:05:13,879 --> 00:05:15,819
little crazy, like, are we really worried about

150
00:05:15,819 --> 00:05:16,839
a shmad and people aren't going to know

151
00:05:16,839 --> 00:05:18,819
how to calculate? So Rav Moshe Feinstein, he

152
00:05:18,819 --> 00:05:21,019
lived in Luban in Russia and he was

153
00:05:21,019 --> 00:05:27,360
under the communist regime, they were attacking Judaism

154
00:05:27,360 --> 00:05:28,600
as a whole, they were trying to get

155
00:05:28,600 --> 00:05:30,240
us to stop learning Torah. So Rav Moshe

156
00:05:30,240 --> 00:05:32,259
was basically kicked out of Russia and his

157
00:05:32,259 --> 00:05:35,079
last act before he left Russia was to

158
00:05:35,079 --> 00:05:36,879
write out the next couple decades of the

159
00:05:36,879 --> 00:05:38,639
Hebrew calendar because he knew that no one

160
00:05:38,639 --> 00:05:40,519
in Luban would have any clue what the

161
00:05:40,519 --> 00:05:41,860
calendar was going to look like without him.

162
00:05:42,060 --> 00:05:43,120
That was his last act. So you can

163
00:05:43,120 --> 00:05:45,600
see if you weren't in Rav Moshe's Luban,

164
00:05:45,639 --> 00:05:47,420
I don't know what the other areas did,

165
00:05:47,439 --> 00:05:48,959
but people really there wasn't such a clear

166
00:05:48,959 --> 00:05:51,459
way of knowing the calendar. Now it's true

167
00:05:51,459 --> 00:05:53,199
we have Google, so Google kind of changes

168
00:05:53,199 --> 00:05:55,540
things, but it's not like it's such a

169
00:05:55,540 --> 00:05:57,800
far-fetched takkanah that we keep two days of

170
00:05:57,800 --> 00:05:59,279
Yom Tov. Okay, so that's the background to

171
00:05:59,279 --> 00:06:00,439
why we keep two days of Yom Tov

172
00:06:00,439 --> 00:06:03,560
in Chutz La'aretz. The question now becomes: okay,

173
00:06:03,620 --> 00:06:04,879
so I'm a Ben Chutz La'aretz. I'm going

174
00:06:04,879 --> 00:06:06,519
to use that term sometimes, Ben Chutz La'aretz,

175
00:06:06,680 --> 00:06:08,800
someone from Chutz La'aretz, maybe I'll just say

176
00:06:08,800 --> 00:06:10,519
an American, that's a little simpler. I'm an

177
00:06:10,519 --> 00:06:12,839
American. I come to Israel. So in Israel

178
00:06:13,139 --> 00:06:15,699
they keep one day, this takkanah was never

179
00:06:15,699 --> 00:06:17,519
ever created that you have to keep two

180
00:06:17,519 --> 00:06:19,660
days of Yom Tov. In Chutz La'aretz there's

181
00:06:19,660 --> 00:06:24,826
a takkanah that Americans and other Bnei Chutz

182
00:06:24,826 --> 00:06:26,230
La'aretz have to keep two days of Yom

183
00:06:26,230 --> 00:06:27,680
Tov. So what do you do then? That's

184
00:06:27,680 --> 00:06:30,959
the big question. So if the, I guess

185
00:06:30,959 --> 00:06:33,120
the starting point is that it seems like

186
00:06:33,120 --> 00:06:35,120
it's not so complicated. It seems like if

187
00:06:35,120 --> 00:06:37,000
you learn one Gemara the answer should be

188
00:06:37,000 --> 00:06:39,180
pretty straightforward. The Gemara goes as follows: this

189
00:06:39,180 --> 00:06:41,139
Gemara in the fourth perek of Pesachim, it's

190
00:06:41,139 --> 00:06:43,606
a Mishnah really. It says makom shenahagu la'asot

191
00:06:43,606 --> 00:06:47,360
melacha be'arvei Pesachim ad chatzot osin. If you

192
00:06:47,360 --> 00:06:49,399
have a place, this is not talking about

193
00:06:49,399 --> 00:06:52,160
Yom Tov, it's talking about a minhag which

194
00:06:52,160 --> 00:06:54,180
some had not to do any melacha on

195
00:06:54,180 --> 00:06:55,939
the day on Erev Pesach in the morning

196
00:06:55,939 --> 00:06:58,259
before Pesach actually started. So it's talking about

197
00:06:58,259 --> 00:07:00,345
minhagim in general. But makom shenahagu la'asot melacha

198
00:07:00,345 --> 00:07:03,100
be'arvei Pesachim ad chatzot osin. If you have

199
00:07:03,100 --> 00:07:04,879
a minhag to go and do melacha Erev

200
00:07:04,879 --> 00:07:07,598
Pesach up until chatzot, no problem. makom shenahagu

201
00:07:07,598 --> 00:07:10,399
shelo la'asot ein osin. But if you're in

202
00:07:10,399 --> 00:07:12,259
a place which has a minhag not to

203
00:07:12,259 --> 00:07:14,680
go and do melacha on Erev Pesach, so

204
00:07:14,680 --> 00:07:16,300
you should join that minhag and you should

205
00:07:16,300 --> 00:07:18,980
not be doing... you're part of those people

206
00:07:19,060 --> 00:07:21,019
so you should not be doing melacha. What

207
00:07:21,019 --> 00:07:22,676
if I'm a traveler? haholech mimakom she'osin lemakom

208
00:07:22,676 --> 00:07:26,720
she'ein osin. Let's say I am going from

209
00:07:26,720 --> 00:07:28,000
a place where they do melacha to a

210
00:07:28,000 --> 00:07:29,417
place where they don't do melacha. o mimakom

211
00:07:29,417 --> 00:07:32,120
she'ein osin lemakom she'osin, or I'm doing the

212
00:07:32,120 --> 00:07:33,600
reverse, I'm going from a place where they

213
00:07:33,600 --> 00:07:34,600
don't do melacha and I'm coming to a

214
00:07:34,600 --> 00:07:36,959
place where they do do melacha. So what's

215
00:07:36,959 --> 00:07:38,863
the halacha? The halacha is notnin alav chumrei

216
00:07:38,863 --> 00:07:40,840
makom sheyatza misham vechumrei makom shehalach lesham. The

217
00:07:40,840 --> 00:07:45,319
rule is that you give the chumros of

218
00:07:45,319 --> 00:07:47,399
both places on the person. So if you

219
00:07:47,399 --> 00:07:49,959
were machmir over there you have to still

220
00:07:49,959 --> 00:07:51,860
be machmir, if they're machmir over here you

221
00:07:51,860 --> 00:07:54,259
have to still be machmir. If that's all

222
00:07:54,259 --> 00:07:56,034
you had, and ve'al yeshaneh adam mipnei hamachlokes.

223
00:07:56,034 --> 00:08:00,439
And don't change anything because of machlokes, meaning

224
00:08:00,439 --> 00:08:02,379
don't do differently than where you're at because

225
00:08:02,379 --> 00:08:04,379
of machlokes. So if I only had that

226
00:08:04,379 --> 00:08:06,199
Mishnah before I saw the Rishonim, so it

227
00:08:06,199 --> 00:08:07,639
would sound like okay I just have to

228
00:08:07,639 --> 00:08:09,660
be machmir in all directions. So what would

229
00:08:09,660 --> 00:08:11,439
being machmir in all directions even look like

230
00:08:11,439 --> 00:08:13,878
in Israel? Let's say I get creative... ve'al

231
00:08:13,878 --> 00:08:18,040
yeshaneh adam mipnei hamachlokes, right? If you're coming

232
00:08:18,040 --> 00:08:21,879
from a place where they don't do melacha

233
00:08:22,879 --> 00:08:25,060
and you don't do melacha, then you're creating

234
00:08:25,060 --> 00:08:27,699
machlokes, because there... there it stands out. Right.

235
00:08:27,879 --> 00:08:29,680
Right. So the whole Mishnah is very hard

236
00:08:29,680 --> 00:08:31,899
to understand. Meaning the Mishnah says don't change

237
00:08:31,899 --> 00:08:34,919
from what's being done because of machlokes. Okay,

238
00:08:34,940 --> 00:08:36,419
but I thought you also told me I

239
00:08:36,419 --> 00:08:38,000
have to be machmir for... for whatever I

240
00:08:38,000 --> 00:08:40,620
was machmir from beforehand. So that's that's the

241
00:08:40,620 --> 00:08:42,179
issue with this Mishnah. Maybe we won't get

242
00:08:42,179 --> 00:08:45,259
into exactly what this theoretical perspective would be

243
00:08:45,259 --> 00:08:46,860
if you're machmir for everything. The Rishonim say

244
00:08:46,860 --> 00:08:48,080
it doesn't mean what it sounds like. It

245
00:08:48,080 --> 00:08:50,379
does not mean that all chumros just automatically

246
00:08:50,379 --> 00:08:52,179
apply in all directions. If you look at

247
00:08:52,179 --> 00:08:54,059
the Ran, source three, he says there's a

248
00:08:54,059 --> 00:08:55,500
very... you have to read this Mishnah very

249
00:08:55,500 --> 00:08:57,220
carefully. It means something very specific. So he

250
00:08:57,220 --> 00:08:59,379
says, he quotes the whole Mishnah, jump to

251
00:08:59,379 --> 00:09:03,320
the second line. peirush mishnatenu besheda'ato lachazor limekomo.

252
00:09:03,720 --> 00:09:06,080
The whole Mishnah is talking specifically about a

253
00:09:06,080 --> 00:09:08,120
person who plans on going back to their

254
00:09:08,120 --> 00:09:11,360
original place. That's his very, very fundamental yesod.

255
00:09:11,559 --> 00:09:13,529
It's not just him, other Rishonim say it

256
00:09:13,529 --> 00:09:14,919
also, it's based on the Gemara. But he

257
00:09:14,919 --> 00:09:16,279
says the entire Mishnah is talking about where

258
00:09:16,279 --> 00:09:17,799
I'm going somewhere and I'm planning on returning

259
00:09:17,799 --> 00:09:20,187
back to my original place. umishum hachi katani

260
00:09:20,187 --> 00:09:24,500
haholech mimakom she'ein osin lemakom she'osin. Therefore it

261
00:09:24,500 --> 00:09:25,740
says, now now he tells you how to

262
00:09:25,740 --> 00:09:27,000
read the Mishnah. When I go from a

263
00:09:27,000 --> 00:09:28,759
place where they don't do melacha and I

264
00:09:28,759 --> 00:09:29,659
go to a place where they do do

265
00:09:29,659 --> 00:09:30,989
melacha. So what do I... what's the halacha?

266
00:09:30,989 --> 00:09:32,927
keivan sheda'ato lachazor notnin alav chumrei hamakom sheyatza

267
00:09:32,927 --> 00:09:35,000
misham midina. Since I plan on going back

268
00:09:35,000 --> 00:09:36,720
to the place where they do not do

269
00:09:36,720 --> 00:09:42,720
melacha, the halacha is, this is a halacha,

270
00:09:42,840 --> 00:09:44,720
he's saying midina, the actual halacha for him

271
00:09:44,720 --> 00:09:46,899
is that this person has a requirement to

272
00:09:46,899 --> 00:09:49,019
keep the halachos of the place which he

273
00:09:49,019 --> 00:09:51,320
originally lived in and which he plans on

274
00:09:51,320 --> 00:09:54,715
returning to. That's a halacha. umimakom she'osin lemakom

275
00:09:54,715 --> 00:09:57,379
she'ein osin. What about the reverse? Where I

276
00:09:57,379 --> 00:09:58,899
am from a place where they're more meikel,

277
00:09:59,159 --> 00:10:00,580
we do melacha... and I go to a

278
00:10:00,580 --> 00:10:01,899
place where they're more machmir, they don't do

279
00:10:01,899 --> 00:10:04,899
melacha. af al gav de-mi-dina oseh, even though

280
00:10:04,899 --> 00:10:06,980
really the halacha is you're allowed to do

281
00:10:06,980 --> 00:10:09,600
melacha, you're a person from the first type

282
00:10:09,600 --> 00:10:14,659
of minhag, nonetheless, keivan she-daato lachazor because you

283
00:10:14,659 --> 00:10:16,665
plan on returning, afilu hachi al yeshane mipnei

284
00:10:16,665 --> 00:10:18,779
ha-machlokes. The Mishna at the end tells you

285
00:10:19,159 --> 00:10:21,259
when you're in Rome, act like the Romans

286
00:10:21,259 --> 00:10:24,679
and be machmir. But that machmir is only

287
00:10:24,679 --> 00:10:28,460
to avoid acting out, to avoid looking different

288
00:10:28,460 --> 00:10:29,820
from the rest of the population. So he

289
00:10:29,820 --> 00:10:31,704
adds ve-keivan de-mipnei ha-machlokes hu ve-lav mi-dina, since

290
00:10:33,240 --> 00:10:35,500
this when you're in Rome and you're doing

291
00:10:35,500 --> 00:10:37,460
like the Romans, that's not really the halacha

292
00:10:37,580 --> 00:10:39,227
but that's just to avoid machlokes, yesh lomar

293
00:10:39,227 --> 00:10:42,740
davka bifneihem hu de-metzar ha be-tzina shari. So

294
00:10:42,740 --> 00:10:44,519
then the issur is only when you're in

295
00:10:44,519 --> 00:10:47,039
public that you shouldn't be acting differently in

296
00:10:47,039 --> 00:10:49,259
public, but when you're be-tzina, when you are

297
00:10:49,259 --> 00:10:50,779
alone in your home, so you can do

298
00:10:50,779 --> 00:10:52,940
what you want. So this shiur is not

299
00:10:52,940 --> 00:10:55,600
about the following case, but in theory let's

300
00:10:55,600 --> 00:10:57,299
just talk about an Israeli coming to Chutz

301
00:10:57,299 --> 00:10:59,320
La'aretz because this is the easier case. So

302
00:10:59,320 --> 00:11:01,259
what the Shulchan Aruch, the Shulchan Aruch talks

303
00:11:01,259 --> 00:11:03,059
about this case explicitly. Shulchan Aruch says if

304
00:11:03,059 --> 00:11:05,460
I'm an Eretz Yisrael Yid and I come

305
00:11:05,460 --> 00:11:08,419
to Chutz La'aretz, so when I'm in public

306
00:11:08,639 --> 00:11:11,500
because of machlokes I have to keep two

307
00:11:11,500 --> 00:11:12,879
days of Yom Tov, I can't do melacha

308
00:11:12,879 --> 00:11:16,139
in front of other Chutznikim, if we'll use

309
00:11:16,139 --> 00:11:17,879
that word. But when I'm at my home

310
00:11:18,139 --> 00:11:19,059
and no one can tell if I'm doing

311
00:11:19,059 --> 00:11:21,340
melacha or not, so then I would be

312
00:11:21,340 --> 00:11:23,449
allowed to go and do melacha. That's the

313
00:11:23,449 --> 00:11:25,919
basic the basic halacha. Yeah, Shan. So when

314
00:11:25,919 --> 00:11:27,200
you say you make it look like you're

315
00:11:27,200 --> 00:11:28,779
keeping two days of Yom Tov, if you're

316
00:11:28,779 --> 00:11:31,139
with somebody the whole day, they'll also realize

317
00:11:31,139 --> 00:11:32,899
they're not doing the mitzvos asay which they're

318
00:11:32,899 --> 00:11:35,620
not doing the day. That's a good question.

319
00:11:35,740 --> 00:11:37,279
So the question was if you're with someone

320
00:11:37,279 --> 00:11:38,580
the whole day, they'll be able to tell

321
00:11:38,580 --> 00:11:41,559
you're not doing the mitzvos asay. I'm understanding

322
00:11:41,559 --> 00:11:43,179
the issur melacha part. Right. Do they have

323
00:11:43,179 --> 00:11:44,538
to do a seder? When an Israeli's in

324
00:11:44,538 --> 00:11:47,379
in America, do they have to do a

325
00:11:47,379 --> 00:11:49,100
seder? is basically a second seder is your

326
00:11:49,100 --> 00:11:51,720
question. So good question. The answer is I

327
00:11:51,720 --> 00:11:53,259
didn't look into that enough to give you

328
00:11:53,259 --> 00:11:55,639
a proper answer. My guess is that we'll

329
00:11:55,639 --> 00:11:56,779
just say stay in a different room and

330
00:11:56,779 --> 00:11:58,639
as long as you're not publicly desecrating it's

331
00:11:58,639 --> 00:12:00,299
not going to lead to machlokes, but I'm

332
00:12:00,299 --> 00:12:01,980
not certain about that. But it's just one

333
00:12:01,980 --> 00:12:04,759
other person. They probably know this is primarily

334
00:12:04,759 --> 00:12:07,440
a larger public like mara d'asra where the

335
00:12:07,440 --> 00:12:09,240
person that could be walking past and doesn't

336
00:12:09,240 --> 00:12:12,399
know you from from Adam doesn't know that

337
00:12:12,399 --> 00:12:14,580
you're an Israeli. Right, so how to apply

338
00:12:14,580 --> 00:12:15,740
this, you know, who it applies to, your

339
00:12:15,740 --> 00:12:17,318
family might be different. I don't know and

340
00:12:17,318 --> 00:12:20,879
ask the people who are getting asked those

341
00:12:20,879 --> 00:12:23,039
questions aren't the American poskim, they're the Israeli

342
00:12:23,039 --> 00:12:24,889
poskim because the Israelis are speaking to their

343
00:12:24,889 --> 00:12:28,240
their Israeli poskim. Okay, so what does that

344
00:12:28,240 --> 00:12:30,019
mean practically for our American who goes to

345
00:12:30,019 --> 00:12:32,639
Yisrael? Let's just any guesses just so far

346
00:12:32,720 --> 00:12:33,960
what does this mean? You're an American who

347
00:12:33,960 --> 00:12:35,480
goes to Yisrael, what what should the halacha

348
00:12:35,480 --> 00:12:37,444
be? They only have one day. They have

349
00:12:37,444 --> 00:12:38,159
to keep two days in Yisrael. Right. Okay,

350
00:12:38,159 --> 00:12:42,240
so so let's what would you say when

351
00:12:44,620 --> 00:12:48,059
in Rome? So that was part of it,

352
00:12:48,120 --> 00:12:51,200
meaning you shouldn't do differently. If they have

353
00:12:51,200 --> 00:12:53,460
a chumra, you shouldn't do differently than that

354
00:12:53,460 --> 00:12:54,879
chumra which they have because it would lead

355
00:12:54,879 --> 00:12:57,919
to machlokes. But when you're from the place

356
00:12:57,919 --> 00:12:59,340
which is more machmir, when you're from the

357
00:12:59,340 --> 00:13:00,759
place which doesn't do melacha and you're in

358
00:13:00,759 --> 00:13:02,200
a place where they do do melacha, the

359
00:13:02,200 --> 00:13:04,080
halacha is mi-dina, says the Ran and other

360
00:13:04,080 --> 00:13:06,679
Rishonim, that you are required to keep that

361
00:13:06,679 --> 00:13:09,320
which you were the place where you're from,

362
00:13:09,580 --> 00:13:11,360
as long as daato lachazor. As long as

363
00:13:11,360 --> 00:13:13,679
you plan on going back, so the halacha

364
00:13:13,679 --> 00:13:15,566
is you're required. It's you're still a Ben

365
00:13:15,566 --> 00:13:17,100
Chutz La'aretz, you're still an American, and an

366
00:13:17,100 --> 00:13:20,820
American keeps American halacha. Yes, good, just before

367
00:13:20,820 --> 00:13:23,860
we we get to the dissenters. So far

368
00:13:23,919 --> 00:13:25,158
so good. Okay, so the big, the big

369
00:13:25,158 --> 00:13:27,100
name over here is the Chacham Tzvi. Who's

370
00:13:27,100 --> 00:13:29,534
the Chacham Tzvi? So his name is Rav

371
00:13:29,534 --> 00:13:31,399
Tzvi Hirsch Ashkenazi. I'll tell you what I

372
00:13:31,399 --> 00:13:33,100
found on Wikipedia just a little bit. He

373
00:13:33,100 --> 00:13:35,240
lives in the late 1600s, early 1700s. He

374
00:13:35,240 --> 00:13:36,860
has a few, more than a few, but

375
00:13:36,860 --> 00:13:38,620
he has a bunch of famous teshuvos. One

376
00:13:38,620 --> 00:13:41,059
of them is in this topic. He's got

377
00:13:41,059 --> 00:13:43,039
a very ironic name because his name is

378
00:13:43,039 --> 00:13:46,399
Rav Tzvi Ashkenazi and we call him the

379
00:13:46,399 --> 00:13:48,799
Chacham Tzvi. Chacham is regular name which we

380
00:13:48,799 --> 00:13:51,779
reserve for Sefardi poskim, like Chacham Ovadia. So

381
00:13:51,779 --> 00:13:52,860
how did that happen? So he was a

382
00:13:52,860 --> 00:13:55,440
big traveler. He ended up in, depends on

383
00:13:55,440 --> 00:13:57,779
which exactly place you look, either he ended

384
00:13:57,779 --> 00:14:01,059
up somewhere Constantinople or Salonika somewhere, he learned

385
00:14:01,059 --> 00:14:02,879
in a Sefardi yeshiva and they really really

386
00:14:02,879 --> 00:14:04,210
liked him. They started calling him the Chacham

387
00:14:04,210 --> 00:14:06,419
Tzvi. So we said, you know what, let's

388
00:14:06,419 --> 00:14:07,500
call him the Chacham Tzvi, and that's how

389
00:14:07,500 --> 00:14:10,019
he published his teshuva sefer. The teshuvos were

390
00:14:10,019 --> 00:14:11,879
the that of the Chacham Tzvi. But he

391
00:14:11,879 --> 00:14:14,279
got around. He fought against the Shabtai Tzvi

392
00:14:14,279 --> 00:14:17,679
movement and he was certainly he was known

393
00:14:17,679 --> 00:14:19,940
for being his teshuvos are nice and easy

394
00:14:19,940 --> 00:14:20,960
to read in a certain sense because he

395
00:14:20,960 --> 00:14:22,559
stays to the topic. Sometimes teshuvos go all

396
00:14:22,559 --> 00:14:24,100
over the place and like, oh, I actually

397
00:14:24,100 --> 00:14:25,240
had a chidush so I want to tell

398
00:14:25,240 --> 00:14:26,879
you something and they go off on tangents.

399
00:14:26,980 --> 00:14:28,238
The Chacham Tzvi stays nice and nice and

400
00:14:28,238 --> 00:14:32,539
focused. So he has he disagrees with what

401
00:14:32,539 --> 00:14:33,849
you would have expected. He says as follows:

402
00:14:33,849 --> 00:14:35,379
Nir'eh li ani da'ati. So he was asked

403
00:14:35,379 --> 00:14:41,559
this exact same question. He says:

404
00:14:41,559 --> 00:14:43,906
nireh li de-tzrichim hem le-hisnaheg be-inyanei ha-moadim ke-echad

405
00:14:43,906 --> 00:14:46,820
mi-benei Eretz Yisrael ha-toshavim, those who actually live

406
00:14:46,820 --> 00:14:48,944
there. ve-ein ze bichlal chomrei makom she-yatza mi-sham,

407
00:14:48,944 --> 00:14:50,620
and don't worry that this is part of

408
00:14:50,620 --> 00:14:52,299
the rule that you have to follow the

409
00:14:52,299 --> 00:14:54,879
minhagim of your original place. Why? So he

410
00:14:54,879 --> 00:14:56,609
has this very very interesting idea. He says:

411
00:14:56,609 --> 00:14:58,523
she-ilu hayu kol anshei ha-makom she-yatzu mi-sham kan

412
00:14:58,523 --> 00:15:03,220
bi-keviyusa Let’s say the entire, I don’t know,

413
00:15:03,360 --> 00:15:06,080
the entire Washington Heights community were to uproot

414
00:15:06,080 --> 00:15:08,539
itself and move to Israel. So you’re from

415
00:15:08,539 --> 00:15:10,259
a Washington Heights community, you’re from an American

416
00:15:10,259 --> 00:15:12,379
community, and you as a whole community were

417
00:15:12,379 --> 00:15:14,259
to uproot yourself and move to Israel. So

418
00:15:14,259 --> 00:15:15,976
what would they do? pshita she’asurim hayu la’asot

419
00:15:15,976 --> 00:15:19,000
yoter miyom echad. They can’t start keeping to

420
00:15:19,000 --> 00:15:20,779
do, they can’t continue doing two days if

421
00:15:20,779 --> 00:15:23,038
they uproot themselves and move to Eretz Yisroel

422
00:15:23,038 --> 00:15:25,191
mishum bal tosif. Says it’ll be a problem

423
00:15:25,191 --> 00:15:26,200
bal tosif. In Israel, you have a mitzvah

424
00:15:26,200 --> 00:15:27,958
to keep only one day. If you were

425
00:15:27,958 --> 00:15:28,899
to, the whole community were to move to

426
00:15:28,899 --> 00:15:30,700
Eretz Yisroel, so of course they moved, so

427
00:15:30,700 --> 00:15:31,700
they have to keep one day, they can’t

428
00:15:31,700 --> 00:15:33,585
keep two days. sheharei hayoshev bishmini basukkot lokei.

429
00:15:33,585 --> 00:15:36,419
Okay, he brings proofs to the idea of

430
00:15:36,419 --> 00:15:38,573
bal tosif ve’khen bepesach ushavuot ha’osei yom echad

431
00:15:38,573 --> 00:15:40,726
mo’ed yoter min hamitzvah over al bal tosif.

432
00:15:41,500 --> 00:15:45,047
So very, very interesting idea. v’lo amru notnin

433
00:15:45,047 --> 00:15:47,200
alav chumrei makom sheyatza misham. When does this

434
00:15:47,200 --> 00:15:49,353
whole rule apply that you have to keep

435
00:15:49,353 --> 00:15:51,506
your original minhagim? ela bechumrah sheshar bnei hamakom

436
00:15:51,506 --> 00:15:53,660
sheyatza ze misham nohagim chumratam bemakom hanohagim kulam.

437
00:15:55,600 --> 00:15:58,200
Only if were your whole community to uproot

438
00:15:58,200 --> 00:15:59,840
itself and move to the second place where

439
00:15:59,840 --> 00:16:01,940
you’re visiting, you’d be able to continue keeping

440
00:16:01,940 --> 00:16:04,600
that minhag. So like erev Pesach. So if

441
00:16:04,600 --> 00:16:05,759
you had a minhag to not work on

442
00:16:05,759 --> 00:16:08,299
erev Pesach and you lived in Salonica and

443
00:16:08,299 --> 00:16:09,919
you moved to Washington Heights, you could keep

444
00:16:09,919 --> 00:16:11,720
doing that minhag. There’s nothing wrong with not

445
00:16:11,720 --> 00:16:14,179
doing melacha on erev Pesach. But if you

446
00:16:14,179 --> 00:16:16,820
live in Washington Heights and you move as

447
00:16:16,820 --> 00:16:18,440
a community to Eretz Yisroel, you are not

448
00:16:18,440 --> 00:16:20,320
allowed to keep two days of Yom Tov.

449
00:16:20,360 --> 00:16:21,834
You have to keep one day of Yom

450
00:16:21,834 --> 00:16:23,639
Tov. He has a line at the end

451
00:16:23,679 --> 00:16:24,759
which I think is really what he’s saying

452
00:16:24,860 --> 00:16:26,679
in a simpler way. What he says at

453
00:16:26,679 --> 00:16:28,378
the end is just the bolded last line.

454
00:16:28,378 --> 00:16:31,159
keivan shehamakom goreim. At the end of the

455
00:16:31,159 --> 00:16:33,200
day, this is not just a minhag which

456
00:16:33,200 --> 00:16:35,299
is up to oh, what was my minhag,

457
00:16:35,379 --> 00:16:37,059
what was your minhag. This is based on

458
00:16:37,059 --> 00:16:38,519
the place. The place is if you’re in

459
00:16:38,519 --> 00:16:41,360
Israel, so you keep one day. If you’re

460
00:16:41,360 --> 00:16:43,860
in chutz la’aretz, chutz la’aretz people keep two

461
00:16:43,860 --> 00:16:46,080
days. So it’s not shayakh to the general

462
00:16:46,080 --> 00:16:47,940
rule of keep the minhagim of from where

463
00:16:47,940 --> 00:16:50,259
you came from, because those minhagim are specific

464
00:16:50,259 --> 00:16:54,559
to places by definition, not just by happenstance.

465
00:16:54,559 --> 00:16:57,879
That’s that’s his first main argument. And then

466
00:16:57,879 --> 00:16:59,159
he has a second argument. His second argument’s

467
00:16:59,159 --> 00:17:02,740
very hard to understand. He says, excuse me,

468
00:17:03,419 --> 00:17:06,279
he says, ve-af, if you jump to the

469
00:17:06,279 --> 00:17:08,279
end of the to the end of the

470
00:17:08,279 --> 00:17:11,119
big bold, ve-af d’shalchu mitam hizaharu beminhag avoteichem.

471
00:17:11,119 --> 00:17:12,839
Ay, didn’t they say in the Gemara you

472
00:17:12,839 --> 00:17:14,745
have to keep to your minhagim? dilma gazru

473
00:17:14,745 --> 00:17:17,519
shmada ve-ati l’kalkulei. Well, isn’t the whole concern

474
00:17:17,859 --> 00:17:19,319
that someone’s going to have a shmad and

475
00:17:19,319 --> 00:17:20,000
you’re not going to be able to keep

476
00:17:20,000 --> 00:17:21,299
the mitzvot and you’re going to lose the

477
00:17:21,299 --> 00:17:24,476
calendar? hakha kalkalah gufah lo shayakha ela keshehem

478
00:17:24,476 --> 00:17:26,599
bimkomam bechutz la’aretz. When would you ever have

479
00:17:26,599 --> 00:17:28,019
a problem of this shmad of losing the

480
00:17:28,019 --> 00:17:30,440
calendar? If you’re in chutz la’aretz. aval biheyotam

481
00:17:30,440 --> 00:17:33,039
be’eretz yisroel lo shayakh. If everyone were to

482
00:17:33,039 --> 00:17:35,059
get up and move to Eretz Yisroel and

483
00:17:35,059 --> 00:17:37,440
there were a shmad, so he says it’s

484
00:17:37,440 --> 00:17:39,240
not shayakh that you’d have such a problem

485
00:17:39,240 --> 00:17:41,400
that people would lose the calendar. He doesn’t

486
00:17:41,400 --> 00:17:42,740
explain why that is. He just says if

487
00:17:42,740 --> 00:17:44,019
you were to move to Israel, what, you

488
00:17:44,019 --> 00:17:45,740
think a shmad would really cause problems? It

489
00:17:45,740 --> 00:17:47,259
can’t be. Wait, but they don’t say in

490
00:17:47,259 --> 00:17:48,779
Israel like because if he said that then

491
00:17:48,779 --> 00:17:50,000
he would have said in Israel too they

492
00:17:50,000 --> 00:17:51,559
should be keeping two days. Right, so we

493
00:17:51,559 --> 00:17:52,900
don’t say in Israel keep two days because

494
00:17:52,900 --> 00:17:55,240
that wasn’t the minhag of avoteihem. Meaning there’s

495
00:17:55,240 --> 00:17:57,019
two parts here. The first part is keep

496
00:17:57,019 --> 00:17:58,880
your minhag which was in chutz la’aretz they

497
00:17:58,880 --> 00:18:00,599
would keep two days and why are we

498
00:18:00,599 --> 00:18:02,019
telling you to keep that minhag because it

499
00:18:02,019 --> 00:18:04,359
could lead to a problem down the line.

500
00:18:04,420 --> 00:18:05,559
But in Israel they never even made that

501
00:18:05,559 --> 00:18:07,720
takanah because they were always keeping one day,

502
00:18:07,740 --> 00:18:09,500
so they didn’t feel the need to force

503
00:18:09,500 --> 00:18:11,799
the two days upon them. So already his

504
00:18:11,799 --> 00:18:13,339
son Rabbi Yaakov Emden says I’m not exactly

505
00:18:13,339 --> 00:18:15,018
sure why he thinks that the that the

506
00:18:15,018 --> 00:18:18,680
shmad couldn’t be an issue in Eretz Yisroel,

507
00:18:19,079 --> 00:18:20,480
but okay, at least that first, that first

508
00:18:20,480 --> 00:18:23,110
sevara is very interesting that it’s a makom

509
00:18:23,110 --> 00:18:25,480
goreim, it’s a minhag which is specifically dependent

510
00:18:25,480 --> 00:18:27,259
on a place. So maybe this whole rule

511
00:18:27,259 --> 00:18:29,685
doesn’t apply. If you look, can I just

512
00:18:29,685 --> 00:18:31,838
say this is also going back to what

513
00:18:31,838 --> 00:18:33,992
you were saying before about keeping the population

514
00:18:33,992 --> 00:18:36,145
of Jews in other places. I mean, we

515
00:18:36,145 --> 00:18:38,298
don’t look at it from Europe more or

516
00:18:38,298 --> 00:18:40,451
less because there’s such a huge community, but

517
00:18:40,451 --> 00:18:42,604
a Jewish community that’s very small off in

518
00:18:42,604 --> 00:18:44,758
chutz la’aretz and to find a minyan is

519
00:18:44,758 --> 00:18:45,565
difficult and if you go anywhere like outside

520
00:18:45,565 --> 00:18:45,565
of a city, the community’s so much smaller

521
00:18:45,565 --> 00:18:56,819
so shmad is much easier. Okay,

522
00:18:56,980 --> 00:18:58,900
okay, so Yosef saying that maybe what he

523
00:18:58,900 --> 00:19:00,640
meant is that the communities in Israel were

524
00:19:00,640 --> 00:19:02,599
historically larger and it would be harder for

525
00:19:02,599 --> 00:19:05,180
them all to lose. I think the Ramban

526
00:19:05,180 --> 00:19:06,319
in one of his letters talks about how

527
00:19:06,319 --> 00:19:07,539
like he couldn’t find a minyan except for

528
00:19:07,539 --> 00:19:10,160
in Yerushalayim. Like there wasn’t, wasn’t always the

529
00:19:10,160 --> 00:19:11,519
case that there were such large Jewish communities

530
00:19:11,519 --> 00:19:13,845
in in Israel. But also something else, it

531
00:19:13,845 --> 00:19:15,998
was because Yerushalayim at the time of the

532
00:19:15,998 --> 00:19:18,152
Ramban was sacked by Mongols and all the

533
00:19:18,152 --> 00:19:19,766
Jews either fled or were killed. Right, but

534
00:19:22,620 --> 00:19:24,007
I’m saying you could have, you could have

535
00:19:24,007 --> 00:19:25,460
something like that again if there was a

536
00:19:25,460 --> 00:19:26,819
shmad, so they they could do the same

537
00:19:26,819 --> 00:19:29,004
thing. Yeah, but it’s not a it’s not

538
00:19:29,004 --> 00:19:31,157
a shmad. shmad means that they try to

539
00:19:31,157 --> 00:19:33,480
uproot. Right, right. shmad regularly is more of

540
00:19:33,480 --> 00:19:35,839
an attacking our mitzvot more than the people.

541
00:19:35,900 --> 00:19:37,149
I hear what you’re saying. Okay, so maybe

542
00:19:37,149 --> 00:19:39,680
maybe that’s what what’s going on. If you

543
00:19:39,680 --> 00:19:42,960
look the Shulchan Aruch HaRav, the Ba’al HaTanya,

544
00:19:43,500 --> 00:19:47,720
the first Lubavitcher Rebbe, so he he was

545
00:19:47,720 --> 00:19:49,759
he thought the Chacham Tzvi was correct. He

546
00:19:49,759 --> 00:19:52,139
says bnei chutz la’aretz sheba’u l’eretz yisroel. If

547
00:19:52,139 --> 00:19:54,220
you have bnei chutz la’aretz who come to

548
00:19:54,220 --> 00:19:56,319
Eretz Yisroel, af al pi sheda’atam lachazor, even

549
00:19:56,319 --> 00:19:57,969
though you plan on returning back home, ein

550
00:19:57,969 --> 00:20:00,122
osin ela yom echad k’vnei eretz yisroel. Israel.

551
00:20:00,259 --> 00:20:01,958
You should just do like the bnei eretz

552
00:20:01,958 --> 00:20:04,619
yisrael vyesh cholkin. He says, yes, some people

553
00:20:04,619 --> 00:20:07,226
disagree, but he says, says the Shulchan Aruch

554
00:20:07,226 --> 00:20:09,980
Harav that the standard halacha he thinks should

555
00:20:09,980 --> 00:20:12,039
be like the chacham tzvi. Okay. So that's,

556
00:20:12,039 --> 00:20:15,660
that's where the one day opinion comes from.

557
00:20:16,299 --> 00:20:17,749
So what's, what's the problem with the one

558
00:20:17,749 --> 00:20:21,039
day opinion? So the problem is that it

559
00:20:21,039 --> 00:20:25,039
went against probably a thousand years of minhag.

560
00:20:25,759 --> 00:20:26,858
If you look at the Avkat Rochel, if

561
00:20:26,858 --> 00:20:28,599
you turn the page, so again, the chacham

562
00:20:28,599 --> 00:20:31,400
tzvi was written, was published at the beginning

563
00:20:31,400 --> 00:20:33,720
of the 1700s. The Avkat Rochel is written

564
00:20:33,720 --> 00:20:35,529
by, is the teshuva sefer of the Beis

565
00:20:35,529 --> 00:20:37,339
Yosef. So Beis Yosef he writes the Shulchan

566
00:20:37,339 --> 00:20:38,940
Aruch, he writes the Kesef Mishneh. He also

567
00:20:38,940 --> 00:20:40,640
has this teshuva sefer which doesn't get quite

568
00:20:40,640 --> 00:20:42,740
as much press, the Avkat Rochel, but he

569
00:20:42,740 --> 00:20:44,960
was asked this same question. The Avkat Rochel's

570
00:20:44,960 --> 00:20:47,119
interesting though because it wasn't published until 200

571
00:20:47,119 --> 00:20:49,180
years after the Beis Yosef died. We had

572
00:20:49,180 --> 00:20:50,599
it in parts and we had a bunch

573
00:20:50,599 --> 00:20:52,519
of scattered teshuvos, some people published these and

574
00:20:52,519 --> 00:20:54,339
some published those, and someone finally put it

575
00:20:54,339 --> 00:20:56,259
together 200 years later called the Avkat Rochel.

576
00:20:56,359 --> 00:20:58,259
So the chacham tzvi did not have this

577
00:20:58,259 --> 00:20:59,880
teshuva most likely in front of him when

578
00:20:59,880 --> 00:21:01,779
he wrote his teshuva, but the Beis Yosef

579
00:21:01,779 --> 00:21:04,099
writes as follows. He says in, he's got

580
00:21:04,099 --> 00:21:05,988
strong language here. He says Teshuva. Davar pashut

581
00:21:05,988 --> 00:21:07,711
hu dechol shedaato lachazor noheg kemakom sheyatza misham.

582
00:21:09,859 --> 00:21:11,960
Anytime you're planning on returning somewhere, you have

583
00:21:11,960 --> 00:21:13,799
to keep the chumros of the place from

584
00:21:13,799 --> 00:21:16,099
which you left afilu lehakel. That would be

585
00:21:16,099 --> 00:21:18,330
true even lekula ubilvad shelo yaase bifnei bnei

586
00:21:18,330 --> 00:21:20,799
hamakom. Okay, he goes through the whole thing.

587
00:21:21,099 --> 00:21:24,700
I'm actually going to skip until the, after

588
00:21:24,700 --> 00:21:26,591
the ellipses, four lines from the bottom v'chen

589
00:21:26,591 --> 00:21:29,380
maasim bechol yom. He says this happens all

590
00:21:29,380 --> 00:21:31,200
the time. People come to Eretz Yisrael. You

591
00:21:31,200 --> 00:21:32,960
have to remember the Beis Yosef, so he

592
00:21:32,960 --> 00:21:34,945
ends up in Tzfat. So v'chen maasim bechol

593
00:21:34,945 --> 00:21:37,098
yom bechol shana v'shana olim lishlosh regalim mchutz

594
00:21:37,098 --> 00:21:39,880
l'aretz to l'aretz. Every one of the three

595
00:21:39,880 --> 00:21:42,070
regalim we have people coming up from chutz

596
00:21:42,070 --> 00:21:43,995
l'aretz to Eretz Yisrael v'osim yom sheni shel

597
00:21:43,995 --> 00:21:48,299
galuyos ketikuno u'chemishpato bechutz l'aretz. They do the

598
00:21:48,299 --> 00:21:51,420
whole two days of Yom Tov like you're

599
00:21:51,420 --> 00:21:53,485
supposed to in chutz l'aretz v'lo od ela

600
00:21:53,485 --> 00:21:55,638
shemitkabtzim minyan mibnei chutz l'aretz and goes into

601
00:21:55,638 --> 00:21:56,715
exactly how you do a minyan and one

602
00:21:56,715 --> 00:21:59,160
thing which he's dealing with over there is

603
00:21:59,160 --> 00:22:00,299
that we said you should try and avoid

604
00:22:00,299 --> 00:22:02,559
machlokes, so he's trying to figure out so

605
00:22:02,559 --> 00:22:04,119
then how come we have public minyanim in

606
00:22:04,119 --> 00:22:06,396
Eretz Yisrael to do Yom Tov Sheni minyanim.

607
00:22:06,396 --> 00:22:07,900
You're they're doing they're acting like Yom Tov

608
00:22:07,900 --> 00:22:10,640
publicly in a certain sense. He's bothered by

609
00:22:10,640 --> 00:22:12,119
that, but you know, we can hold off

610
00:22:12,119 --> 00:22:15,849
on the minyan question for right now. So

611
00:22:15,849 --> 00:22:17,194
the Beis Yosef says the, again Beis Yosef

612
00:22:17,194 --> 00:22:19,960
is a hundred years at least earlier than

613
00:22:19,960 --> 00:22:21,460
the chacham tzvi. He says the minhag everyone

614
00:22:21,460 --> 00:22:23,480
was keeping two days. Rav Ovadia, I didn't

615
00:22:23,480 --> 00:22:25,460
give you the actual quotes, but Rav Ovadia

616
00:22:25,460 --> 00:22:28,619
quotes that in the Teshuvos Geonei Mizrach u-Maarav

617
00:22:28,619 --> 00:22:30,019
and the Maaseh HaGeonim, I think that these

618
00:22:30,019 --> 00:22:31,569
are Geonim sefarim, I don't know if they

619
00:22:31,569 --> 00:22:33,259
were found in the Cairo Geniza, but Rav

620
00:22:33,259 --> 00:22:36,359
Ovadia Yosef knew literally everything. So if, if

621
00:22:36,359 --> 00:22:38,220
anyone ever wrote it, he knows it. So

622
00:22:38,220 --> 00:22:40,500
in the 900s already we have these teshuvos

623
00:22:40,500 --> 00:22:42,180
from the Geonim and the Geonim teshuvos says

624
00:22:42,180 --> 00:22:44,740
Rav Ovadia also say you keep two days.

625
00:22:44,799 --> 00:22:46,920
That's what we're all doing. So this standard,

626
00:22:47,039 --> 00:22:50,460
standard psak is to keep two days. There's

627
00:22:50,460 --> 00:22:52,839
the chacham tzvi, there's this Baal HaTanya the

628
00:22:52,839 --> 00:22:54,779
Shulchan Aruch Harav, there's a Sholom Meshiv who

629
00:22:54,779 --> 00:22:56,819
say you keep one day. But the psak

630
00:22:56,819 --> 00:22:58,539
going back at least a thousand years we

631
00:22:58,539 --> 00:23:00,799
know is that people were keeping two days.

632
00:23:01,220 --> 00:23:02,539
The author of the Beis Yosef, the author

633
00:23:02,539 --> 00:23:04,259
of the Shulchan Aruch says in his teshuva

634
00:23:04,599 --> 00:23:07,480
you keep two days. And I'll just tell

635
00:23:07,480 --> 00:23:10,480
you a short list of, before I get

636
00:23:10,579 --> 00:23:12,160
the short list or I'll say the short

637
00:23:12,160 --> 00:23:14,880
list now anyways, short list of contemporary poskim

638
00:23:14,880 --> 00:23:16,259
who say you keep two days is just

639
00:23:16,259 --> 00:23:19,299
about anyone who ever, who you might have

640
00:23:19,299 --> 00:23:21,240
probably heard of nowadays. So the Mishna Berura

641
00:23:21,339 --> 00:23:22,279
first of all is clear that that's what

642
00:23:22,279 --> 00:23:23,398
you do. If you look in source seven

643
00:23:23,398 --> 00:23:26,097
Uben chutz laretz sheba leretz yisrael im daato

644
00:23:26,097 --> 00:23:30,279
lachazor limkomo tzarich laasos shnei yamim tovim. You

645
00:23:30,279 --> 00:23:32,398
have to keep two days of Yom Tov.

646
00:23:32,398 --> 00:23:36,079
Achen im daato shelo lachazor limkomo leolam yitnaheg

647
00:23:36,079 --> 00:23:39,039
kivnei eretz yisrael uchmo shemevoar. If you plan

648
00:23:39,039 --> 00:23:40,680
on staying there, so then you start acting

649
00:23:40,680 --> 00:23:43,289
like the bnei eretz yisrael. So besides for

650
00:23:43,289 --> 00:23:44,646
the Mishna Berura, I'll just tell you Rav

651
00:23:44,646 --> 00:23:48,059
Moshe Feinstein, Rav Shlomo Zalman Auerbach, the Minchas

652
00:23:48,059 --> 00:23:50,359
Yitzchak, Rav Elyashiv, Rav Wosner, and Rav Ovadia.

653
00:23:50,359 --> 00:23:52,269
They all pasken in a stam case, but

654
00:23:52,269 --> 00:23:53,539
we're going to have to talk about in

655
00:23:53,539 --> 00:23:55,119
a moment what it means that I plan

656
00:23:55,119 --> 00:23:56,619
on returning or don't plan on returning. If

657
00:23:56,619 --> 00:23:59,000
I have nothing going for me in terms

658
00:23:59,000 --> 00:24:00,640
of living in Eretz Yisrael, I am quite

659
00:24:00,640 --> 00:24:02,619
certain I am coming back home after this

660
00:24:02,619 --> 00:24:06,359
chag and let's say other chaggim I'm not

661
00:24:06,359 --> 00:24:07,539
planning on being there for all three regalim.

662
00:24:07,579 --> 00:24:09,720
We'll talk about that shortly. So then almost

663
00:24:09,720 --> 00:24:12,460
all contemporary poskim say you keep two days

664
00:24:12,460 --> 00:24:15,438
of Yom Tov. That's that's just the, yeah.

665
00:24:15,438 --> 00:24:17,591
Isn't that why Chabad says you only keep

666
00:24:17,591 --> 00:24:19,744
one day is because they hold that in

667
00:24:19,744 --> 00:24:21,897
Eretz Yisrael you're not allowed... Also Rav Ovadia

668
00:24:21,897 --> 00:24:22,974
said you're going to like find out. Yeah,

669
00:24:22,974 --> 00:24:26,359
so we'll get to Rav Ovadia shortly. Chabad

670
00:24:26,359 --> 00:24:27,940
is the exception. Chabad is the exception because

671
00:24:27,940 --> 00:24:29,859
of this Shulchan Aruch Harav. Shulchan Aruch Harav

672
00:24:29,859 --> 00:24:32,566
is the big posek for Chabad. The Shulchan

673
00:24:32,566 --> 00:24:34,589
Aruch Harav, he writes also elsewhere that like

674
00:24:34,589 --> 00:24:36,059
there's this idea which I didn't understand of

675
00:24:36,059 --> 00:24:38,200
kedusha, that you know there's a certain like

676
00:24:38,200 --> 00:24:40,380
the place has a certain kedusha which is

677
00:24:40,380 --> 00:24:42,319
only fit for one day, that's Eretz Yisrael,

678
00:24:42,420 --> 00:24:44,079
and outside there's the kedusha needs to be

679
00:24:44,079 --> 00:24:45,859
spread out more. So it's more like about

680
00:24:45,859 --> 00:24:47,619
where you are and the kedusha inherently has

681
00:24:47,619 --> 00:24:48,980
to be one day or two days. So

682
00:24:48,980 --> 00:24:50,279
the Shulchan Aruch Harav, if you're if you're

683
00:24:50,279 --> 00:24:51,839
Chabad, if you have strong Chabad roots or

684
00:24:51,839 --> 00:24:54,059
strong Chabad connections, it makes a lot of

685
00:24:54,059 --> 00:24:56,259
sense, you know I think probably the standard

686
00:24:56,259 --> 00:24:57,700
psak is one day if you have a

687
00:24:57,700 --> 00:24:59,519
Chabad posek, you know ask them to, to.

688
00:24:59,519 --> 00:25:01,920
confirm them. But the vast majority of Poskim

689
00:25:01,920 --> 00:25:04,019
say in a normal case, I confirmed with

690
00:25:04,019 --> 00:25:05,799
Rabbi Taubes, he says the same. Rabbi Taubes

691
00:25:05,799 --> 00:25:07,229
says two days to anyone who asks him

692
00:25:07,229 --> 00:25:08,599
a Stam Shayla. We're going to get again

693
00:25:08,599 --> 00:25:10,099
to all the exceptions, there are a lot

694
00:25:10,099 --> 00:25:12,896
of exceptions. But, yeah. Is there an issue,

695
00:25:12,896 --> 00:25:15,049
is it specifically this is a common question,

696
00:25:15,049 --> 00:25:17,202
of if you're only going for half of

697
00:25:17,202 --> 00:25:22,039
Pesach? Like the first half? Yeah. Like if

698
00:25:22,039 --> 00:25:24,024
you're only there for one, is there an

699
00:25:24,024 --> 00:25:26,177
issue of like keeping one day, but then

700
00:25:26,177 --> 00:25:28,330
like or some or the other way around,

701
00:25:28,330 --> 00:25:30,483
but then like eating Chametz on the last

702
00:25:30,483 --> 00:25:32,636
day if you had two Sedarim or something

703
00:25:32,636 --> 00:25:34,319
like that? Right. Right. So how many Sedarim

704
00:25:34,319 --> 00:25:35,700
do you do? So I haven't seen anyone

705
00:25:35,700 --> 00:25:37,480
saying like there's a Tarti Desatri issue. Like

706
00:25:37,480 --> 00:25:39,680
if you, if you're a Chabad person, whatever,

707
00:25:39,819 --> 00:25:41,339
you follow the Chacham Tzevi and you keep

708
00:25:41,339 --> 00:25:43,859
one day the first days. That's just because

709
00:25:43,859 --> 00:25:45,039
when I'm in Israel, so I only keep

710
00:25:45,039 --> 00:25:46,550
one day. But keep then I leave Eretz

711
00:25:46,550 --> 00:25:48,400
Yisrael, I'm keeping two days. So that would,

712
00:25:48,799 --> 00:25:50,259
I don't think that would be unreasonable. Yeah.

713
00:25:50,259 --> 00:25:52,413
We're talking just practical. I know someone, I'm

714
00:25:52,413 --> 00:25:54,566
not gonna say who, who is Moroccan Israeli

715
00:25:54,566 --> 00:25:56,719
but lives here. So he's been living here

716
00:25:56,719 --> 00:25:58,872
many years. So the first days of Pesach

717
00:25:58,872 --> 00:26:01,025
he's going to be here. He has a

718
00:26:01,025 --> 00:26:03,179
daughter though who made Aliyah who lives in

719
00:26:03,179 --> 00:26:05,332
Israel, who's getting married in Israel and wants

720
00:26:05,332 --> 00:26:07,485
to do a Mimouna. The wedding's going to

721
00:26:07,485 --> 00:26:09,638
be the Mimouna which is the day after

722
00:26:09,638 --> 00:26:11,791
Pesach. So the Mimouna is. So he's going

723
00:26:11,791 --> 00:26:13,945
to Israel Chol HaMoed for the last part

724
00:26:13,945 --> 00:26:16,098
of Pesach and the wedding will be what

725
00:26:16,098 --> 00:26:18,251
would be in Chutz La'Aretz the eighth day

726
00:26:18,251 --> 00:26:20,404
of Pesach. So he's going to be in

727
00:26:20,404 --> 00:26:22,557
Israel for his daughter's wedding which will be

728
00:26:22,557 --> 00:26:29,119
a Mimouna. Complicated. Complicated.

729
00:26:29,780 --> 00:26:31,039
I'll let him deal with that Shayla. What?

730
00:26:31,420 --> 00:26:34,000
I'll let him deal with that Shayla. He's

731
00:26:34,000 --> 00:26:36,160
saying what he's doing though is he's not

732
00:26:36,160 --> 00:26:37,589
keep, you know, he's going to be here

733
00:26:37,589 --> 00:26:38,900
the first days and keep two days. He

734
00:26:38,900 --> 00:26:41,400
lives here usually, goes to Israel via aliyah

735
00:26:41,440 --> 00:26:43,599
whatever, but like keeps two days, but the

736
00:26:43,599 --> 00:26:47,680
last days his daughter's getting married on, you

737
00:26:47,680 --> 00:26:50,259
know, Mimouna day. And I think he's not

738
00:26:50,259 --> 00:26:51,819
keep, he said he's not keeping the last

739
00:26:51,819 --> 00:26:53,920
day of Pesach as Pesach. Okay, so again,

740
00:26:53,980 --> 00:26:57,339
I'm not I'm my goal here is not

741
00:26:57,339 --> 00:26:58,500
to tell you about what anyone else is

742
00:26:58,500 --> 00:27:00,539
doing. I'm just telling you what I've seen

743
00:27:00,680 --> 00:27:03,000
and I'd say what I'd say the standard

744
00:27:03,000 --> 00:27:06,680
approach to this topic is. So let me

745
00:27:06,680 --> 00:27:08,299
just there's a few other points. So what

746
00:27:08,299 --> 00:27:09,900
is the response to the Chacham Tzevi? So

747
00:27:09,900 --> 00:27:12,240
Rav Shlomo Zalman Auerbach and others just explain

748
00:27:12,759 --> 00:27:15,640
it's not necessarily true that this rule of

749
00:27:15,640 --> 00:27:17,839
Chumrei Makom Sheyatza Misham that you are basically

750
00:27:17,839 --> 00:27:20,200
where you return to is dependent on whether

751
00:27:20,980 --> 00:27:23,500
it's a Minhag which is dependent on place

752
00:27:23,500 --> 00:27:25,464
or not. Meaning which is specific to Eretz

753
00:27:25,464 --> 00:27:26,700
Yisrael. As long as you are in America

754
00:27:26,700 --> 00:27:27,960
at the end of the day, you keep

755
00:27:27,960 --> 00:27:30,339
the American Shulkhan Arukh and if you are

756
00:27:30,440 --> 00:27:31,700
Israeli at the end of the day, you

757
00:27:31,700 --> 00:27:36,240
keep the Israeli Shulkhan Arukh. Has anyone ever

758
00:27:36,240 --> 00:27:37,819
heard of one and a half days before?

759
00:27:37,819 --> 00:27:39,539
Yeah. Yeah. Everyone's heard of one and a

760
00:27:39,539 --> 00:27:40,740
half days. I hadn't heard of one and

761
00:27:40,740 --> 00:27:41,920
a half days until I went to HaKotel.

762
00:27:41,920 --> 00:27:42,900
That's the first time I ever heard of

763
00:27:42,900 --> 00:27:45,119
it, my Yeshiva for my first year in

764
00:27:45,119 --> 00:27:46,839
Israel. So what is one and a half

765
00:27:46,839 --> 00:27:49,240
days? So one, the second Gemara sounded a

766
00:27:49,240 --> 00:27:51,059
little bit like. Yes. Yes. So the Gemara

767
00:27:51,059 --> 00:27:53,240
sounded like this idea. One what what is

768
00:27:53,240 --> 00:27:54,500
one and a half days? One and a

769
00:27:54,500 --> 00:27:58,619
half days says, you know what, really either

770
00:27:58,619 --> 00:27:59,680
we should be keeping two days or one

771
00:27:59,680 --> 00:28:02,059
day, whichever side you take, but I'm worried

772
00:28:02,059 --> 00:28:03,920
about the other opinion. So I'm going to

773
00:28:03,920 --> 00:28:05,700
try and be Machmir for every single thing

774
00:28:05,700 --> 00:28:07,579
that I can do as if it were

775
00:28:07,579 --> 00:28:09,000
both two days and one day at the

776
00:28:09,000 --> 00:28:10,720
same time. So what does that end up

777
00:28:10,720 --> 00:28:12,460
being? It ends up being a little miserable

778
00:28:12,460 --> 00:28:15,480
in my experience. But you end up not

779
00:28:15,480 --> 00:28:17,059
doing any Melakha, so you can't you can't

780
00:28:17,059 --> 00:28:18,819
like do anything, you know, with all which

781
00:28:18,819 --> 00:28:20,759
all the Israelis are doing. But you also

782
00:28:20,940 --> 00:28:22,319
depending on how you Pasken, depending on whether

783
00:28:22,319 --> 00:28:24,039
you think it's you're really two days is

784
00:28:24,039 --> 00:28:25,099
what you should be keeping or really one

785
00:28:25,099 --> 00:28:26,160
day you should be keeping, but you're going

786
00:28:26,160 --> 00:28:27,220
to let's say you're a man you'll put

787
00:28:27,220 --> 00:28:29,160
on Tefillin and maybe you make a Bracha

788
00:28:29,259 --> 00:28:30,819
maybe you don't make a Bracha depending on

789
00:28:30,859 --> 00:28:33,200
on the case. Or you'll maybe make a

790
00:28:33,200 --> 00:28:36,480
Seder without Brachot, with Brachot, without without Brachot

791
00:28:36,480 --> 00:28:38,960
etc. You'll Daven, how you'll Daven will depend

792
00:28:38,960 --> 00:28:41,339
on exactly where you end on that question.

793
00:28:41,339 --> 00:28:43,119
But you basically try and be Machmir for

794
00:28:43,119 --> 00:28:45,839
everything in all directions as much as possible.

795
00:28:45,839 --> 00:28:47,960
Now why why did that come about? So

796
00:28:47,960 --> 00:28:49,180
the answer is that a lot of Poskim

797
00:28:49,180 --> 00:28:51,079
were very taken by the Chacham Tzevi argument.

798
00:28:51,200 --> 00:28:53,160
They thought, you know, I know it's against

799
00:28:53,160 --> 00:28:55,480
all the Poskim, all the Poskim basically don't

800
00:28:55,480 --> 00:28:59,059
accept, again, most most of the Poskim don't

801
00:28:59,059 --> 00:29:00,859
accept the Chacham Tzevi. But his argument's very

802
00:29:00,859 --> 00:29:02,660
strong. This is something which is dependent on

803
00:29:02,660 --> 00:29:04,259
the place. If it's something which is dependent

804
00:29:04,259 --> 00:29:08,039
on the place, so they're they're at least

805
00:29:08,039 --> 00:29:09,440
saying maybe we should be Machmir for that

806
00:29:09,440 --> 00:29:11,220
idea. There's actually another point which a lot

807
00:29:11,220 --> 00:29:12,779
of them bring up. What were they doing,

808
00:29:13,220 --> 00:29:15,620
let's let's say you were an American who

809
00:29:15,620 --> 00:29:18,500
made Aliyah L'Regel in the times of the

810
00:29:18,500 --> 00:29:20,579
Beit HaMikdash. So how many days did you

811
00:29:20,579 --> 00:29:24,559
keep? You presumably kept one. Meaning there's there

812
00:29:24,559 --> 00:29:26,480
might even be Gemaras I saw someone quoting.

813
00:29:26,599 --> 00:29:28,700
I didn't I they didn't have a source

814
00:29:28,759 --> 00:29:30,680
but they said online that Gemaras say so

815
00:29:30,680 --> 00:29:31,480
I don't know if that's true or not.

816
00:29:31,779 --> 00:29:34,720
But but if you made Aliyah L'Regel, so

817
00:29:35,000 --> 00:29:36,359
you're in Eretz Yisrael, there's no reason for

818
00:29:36,359 --> 00:29:37,599
you to be keeping two. It wasn't like

819
00:29:37,599 --> 00:29:38,859
a Minhag they had. Just when they weren't

820
00:29:38,859 --> 00:29:40,339
sure if it was Yom Tov or not.

821
00:29:40,640 --> 00:29:42,059
So when they came to when they didn't

822
00:29:42,059 --> 00:29:43,700
know they'd keep two days M'Safek and when

823
00:29:43,700 --> 00:29:45,319
they were in Eretz Yisrael, so they'd keep

824
00:29:45,319 --> 00:29:47,539
one day. So if the whole goal is

825
00:29:47,539 --> 00:29:50,420
really Hizaharu Beminhag Avoteichem Beyadeichem, keep the Minhag

826
00:29:50,420 --> 00:29:52,339
of your parents of your grandparents, so how

827
00:29:52,339 --> 00:29:53,640
can it be that you're expecting me to

828
00:29:53,640 --> 00:29:56,019
be more Machmir than my grandparents were when

829
00:29:56,019 --> 00:29:58,519
I was in Israel? It's a very strong

830
00:29:58,519 --> 00:30:02,279
argument. Yeah. There's one exception though, meaning it

831
00:30:02,279 --> 00:30:03,759
sounds like a very strong argument, there's one

832
00:30:03,759 --> 00:30:06,299
very very big exception to the rule of

833
00:30:06,660 --> 00:30:08,680
that we're just copying what our avos did.

834
00:30:09,119 --> 00:30:11,440
There's one time where our avos were certainly

835
00:30:11,440 --> 00:30:13,929
keeping one day, and we keep two days

836
00:30:13,929 --> 00:30:16,799
in Chutz La'aretz. Anyone know? This is like

837
00:30:16,799 --> 00:30:21,799
a sixty thousand dollar question. So Shavuos. Shavuos

838
00:30:22,019 --> 00:30:26,400
in the Torah is always forty-nine days after

839
00:30:26,720 --> 00:30:27,880
we count the Omer and then we have

840
00:30:27,880 --> 00:30:29,680
we have Shavuos. So as long as you

841
00:30:29,680 --> 00:30:32,559
would know what the first day of Nisan

842
00:30:32,559 --> 00:30:35,839
was, so then you're going to be able

843
00:30:35,839 --> 00:30:37,880
to figure out when Shavuos is as long

844
00:30:37,880 --> 00:30:39,420
as by the time Shavuos comes you know

845
00:30:39,420 --> 00:30:40,749
when the first day of Nisan is. Because

846
00:30:40,749 --> 00:30:42,740
when if once you figure out the first

847
00:30:42,740 --> 00:30:44,220
day of Nisan, you'll figure out the first

848
00:30:44,220 --> 00:30:47,749
day of Pesach, and then fifty days later

849
00:30:47,749 --> 00:30:49,400
is going to be Shavuos no matter what.

850
00:30:49,559 --> 00:30:51,319
Outside of it didn't take sixty days to

851
00:30:51,319 --> 00:30:52,759
go in and get the news out to

852
00:30:53,759 --> 00:30:55,619
maybe in America it would have, but but

853
00:30:56,279 --> 00:30:57,859
in Bavel and other areas, they would have

854
00:30:57,859 --> 00:31:00,240
actually known when Shavuos was almost definitely and

855
00:31:00,240 --> 00:31:02,160
they were keeping one day almost always. When

856
00:31:02,160 --> 00:31:03,740
they made this takkanah keep two days, so

857
00:31:03,740 --> 00:31:05,339
they just said you know what, let's make

858
00:31:05,339 --> 00:31:07,579
Shavuos like Pesach and like Sukkos, let's not

859
00:31:07,579 --> 00:31:09,900
confuse everyone. They made it two days even

860
00:31:09,900 --> 00:31:11,839
though that wasn't what the actual minhag of

861
00:31:11,839 --> 00:31:13,460
our forefathers was. So it's not, you know,

862
00:31:13,819 --> 00:31:15,660
this argument is not ironclad that we should

863
00:31:15,660 --> 00:31:17,559
just be keeping what our avos did. There's

864
00:31:17,559 --> 00:31:18,759
a little bit of lo palug, there's a

865
00:31:18,759 --> 00:31:23,140
little bit of you know kind of getting

866
00:31:23,140 --> 00:31:24,799
out the wrinkles in in how it's done.

867
00:31:24,799 --> 00:31:26,953
So but how can you say like keep

868
00:31:26,953 --> 00:31:29,106
two days for Pesach and Sukkos but only

869
00:31:29,106 --> 00:31:31,059
one day for Shavuos? No, so I have

870
00:31:31,059 --> 00:31:32,740
not seen any poskim say keep two days

871
00:31:32,740 --> 00:31:34,779
of X and only one day of Shavuos

872
00:31:34,779 --> 00:31:37,079
though, even though you know you could have

873
00:31:37,119 --> 00:31:39,240
you could have heard such such an argument.

874
00:31:39,339 --> 00:31:40,718
So I'll tell you there were poskim... But

875
00:31:40,718 --> 00:31:42,871
which day is Rosh Chodesh Nisan then you

876
00:31:42,871 --> 00:31:45,024
also would know which day is Pesach so

877
00:31:45,024 --> 00:31:47,299
you also... No but I'm saying you would

878
00:31:47,299 --> 00:31:49,259
figure out when Rosh Chodesh Nisan was let's

879
00:31:49,259 --> 00:31:52,700
say thirty days later. Let's say by Iyar,

880
00:31:52,759 --> 00:31:55,500
thirty days... so Pesach has already passed, and

881
00:31:55,500 --> 00:31:56,680
now I figure out when the first day

882
00:31:56,680 --> 00:31:57,940
of Nisan was, the word gets to me

883
00:31:58,500 --> 00:31:59,779
that when the first day of Nisan was.

884
00:32:00,119 --> 00:32:02,119
So I've already kept two days of Pesach

885
00:32:02,119 --> 00:32:03,359
because it didn't get to me in time,

886
00:32:03,400 --> 00:32:04,559
it didn't get to me within fifteen days,

887
00:32:04,559 --> 00:32:06,779
but it got to me within sixty days,

888
00:32:06,839 --> 00:32:09,559
whatever it was, so so that that would

889
00:32:09,559 --> 00:32:13,589
be all that they need. You're saying a

890
00:32:13,599 --> 00:32:15,309
minhag of keeping the minhag you're saying. No,

891
00:32:15,309 --> 00:32:18,279
the first source of the minhag of the

892
00:32:19,579 --> 00:32:21,079
poskim... Oh yeah yeah yeah yeah, making trouble,

893
00:32:21,180 --> 00:32:23,420
making trouble. Right, right, one hundred percent. So

894
00:32:23,420 --> 00:32:24,680
I'll just tell you some poskim who held

895
00:32:24,680 --> 00:32:27,059
this way. Rav Shmuel Salant held this way,

896
00:32:27,140 --> 00:32:28,799
Rav Kook held this way, and Rav Soloveitchik,

897
00:32:29,180 --> 00:32:30,880
so he also would tell talmidim to be

898
00:32:30,880 --> 00:32:33,500
machmir for one and a half days. He

899
00:32:33,500 --> 00:32:35,220
personally never had to, because the only time

900
00:32:35,220 --> 00:32:36,200
he ever went to Eretz Yisrael he went

901
00:32:36,200 --> 00:32:38,458
to Eretz Yisrael for only one regel, I

902
00:32:38,458 --> 00:32:39,380
forget I think it was Shavuos or whatever

903
00:32:39,380 --> 00:32:40,759
it was, and the way it worked out

904
00:32:40,759 --> 00:32:42,619
was that Friday was the first day of

905
00:32:42,619 --> 00:32:44,099
yom tov, and then what would have been

906
00:32:44,099 --> 00:32:45,819
the second day of yom tov was Shabbos.

907
00:32:45,940 --> 00:32:47,880
So no one was keeping melacha was doing

908
00:32:47,880 --> 00:32:49,494
melacha. Rav Soloveitchik. So he didn't have to

909
00:32:49,494 --> 00:32:52,114
daven? Say again? So he didn't have to

910
00:32:52,114 --> 00:32:54,000
daven? Right, so the way that the Rav

911
00:32:54,000 --> 00:32:55,759
was told to do it was to keep

912
00:32:55,759 --> 00:32:57,983
it like to daven like a ben Eretz

913
00:32:57,983 --> 00:32:59,940
Yisrael, to keep it like the chachamim of

914
00:32:59,940 --> 00:33:02,339
Sefad in terms of davening. So in Israel

915
00:33:02,400 --> 00:33:04,019
they were also davening that way. So it

916
00:33:04,019 --> 00:33:06,000
ended up being that he didn't have to

917
00:33:06,000 --> 00:33:07,519
take a stand on it personally, but that's

918
00:33:07,519 --> 00:33:09,920
what he would apparently tell his talmidim. So

919
00:33:09,920 --> 00:33:12,000
Rav Shechter writes and Rav Willig writes similarly

920
00:33:12,000 --> 00:33:13,480
that like if you're you know if you

921
00:33:13,480 --> 00:33:15,740
follow all of the Rav psakim, so nice

922
00:33:15,740 --> 00:33:18,920
to keep one point five days. It's very

923
00:33:19,099 --> 00:33:20,599
very hard. I'll tell you my... I only

924
00:33:20,599 --> 00:33:23,160
tried it once in Hakotel and it was

925
00:33:23,359 --> 00:33:25,779
I was flipping... I must have been mechalel

926
00:33:25,779 --> 00:33:27,779
yom tov sheini so many times just because

927
00:33:27,779 --> 00:33:29,799
you're like you're just very very confused because

928
00:33:29,799 --> 00:33:31,059
you're treating it as a chol day but

929
00:33:31,059 --> 00:33:32,960
a yom tov day. It's really it's not

930
00:33:32,960 --> 00:33:34,885
fun at all. What does mechalel mean in

931
00:33:34,885 --> 00:33:40,279
that context? melacha? Exactly. You treat it like

932
00:33:40,319 --> 00:33:41,460
chol and then some people say you shouldn't

933
00:33:41,460 --> 00:33:43,079
be wearing your yom tov bigadim if you

934
00:33:43,079 --> 00:33:44,440
think it's really not yom tov, so you're

935
00:33:44,440 --> 00:33:46,720
wearing like your chol clothes. It's like it's

936
00:33:46,720 --> 00:33:49,039
a little bit of a headache. If someone's

937
00:33:49,039 --> 00:33:50,980
really you know wants a challenge, that's an

938
00:33:50,980 --> 00:33:52,579
opinion which you might want to follow. If

939
00:33:52,579 --> 00:33:54,160
you don't want a challenge, so Rav Neuberger

940
00:33:54,160 --> 00:33:55,160
said he used to tell people to do

941
00:33:55,160 --> 00:33:57,500
this and then he got so much response

942
00:33:57,500 --> 00:33:59,579
back that it just it wasn't working. So

943
00:33:59,579 --> 00:34:01,800
he tells people to do two days. Rav

944
00:34:01,800 --> 00:34:05,319
Willig says the same thing. And okay fine.

945
00:34:05,420 --> 00:34:07,059
So so that's all about a stam visitor.

946
00:34:07,940 --> 00:34:09,360
I guess we'll get to what are the

947
00:34:09,360 --> 00:34:12,860
exceptions. So again if you are planning on

948
00:34:12,860 --> 00:34:14,920
living there, so it's open and shut no

949
00:34:14,920 --> 00:34:16,760
question, you're an Israeli now. If I the

950
00:34:16,760 --> 00:34:18,480
moment I make my decision, I get off

951
00:34:18,480 --> 00:34:21,199
the plane, the Nefesh B'Nefesh plane on the

952
00:34:21,199 --> 00:34:23,000
day before Pesach, I'm keeping one day now.

953
00:34:23,639 --> 00:34:25,745
Not a question. There was someone from Belgium

954
00:34:25,745 --> 00:34:27,898
who he had a small group of two-day

955
00:34:27,898 --> 00:34:30,052
and then there was someone from Belgium who

956
00:34:30,052 --> 00:34:32,205
finished up her aliyah paperwork like erev yom

957
00:34:32,205 --> 00:34:34,358
tov. So she like left our second day

958
00:34:34,358 --> 00:34:36,511
of yom tov group on erev yom tov.

959
00:34:38,159 --> 00:34:39,920
That's awesome. Okay. So if you get your

960
00:34:39,920 --> 00:34:41,840
aliyah papers in right before yom tov, so

961
00:34:41,840 --> 00:34:44,119
then then you are good to go. So

962
00:34:44,119 --> 00:34:46,059
what if I'm planning on living there for

963
00:34:46,159 --> 00:34:47,960
I don't know a year, two years, five

964
00:34:47,960 --> 00:34:49,579
years, I have a job with a set

965
00:34:49,579 --> 00:34:50,519
amount of time and then after that I

966
00:34:50,519 --> 00:34:52,900
have no plan. So how exactly long does

967
00:34:52,900 --> 00:34:55,199
it last? So this is the poskim debate

968
00:34:55,199 --> 00:34:56,599
exactly how long, but I think that the

969
00:34:56,599 --> 00:34:58,596
majority view is that of the Aruch HaShulchan,

970
00:34:58,596 --> 00:34:59,134
a lot of poskim the Tzitz Eliezer... A

971
00:34:59,134 --> 00:35:01,000
lot of poskim, the Tzitz Eliezer, Avnei Nezer,

972
00:35:01,000 --> 00:35:02,089
Shevet HaLevi, they all say the same idea:

973
00:35:02,089 --> 00:35:04,115
V'chen yeira'eh li d'afilu ba levado im ein

974
00:35:04,115 --> 00:35:06,142
da'ato lachazor ad achar shanah mikri ein da'ato

975
00:35:06,142 --> 00:35:08,940
lachazor. If you really don't plan on even

976
00:35:08,940 --> 00:35:12,539
getting back on a plane until for one

977
00:35:12,539 --> 00:35:14,019
year and this is talking about when you're

978
00:35:14,019 --> 00:35:16,039
not relying on your parents back home or

979
00:35:16,039 --> 00:35:18,420
something like that, but if you're an independent

980
00:35:18,420 --> 00:35:20,119
person and you plan on living in Israel

981
00:35:20,119 --> 00:35:21,699
for a year, you're not coming back for

982
00:35:21,699 --> 00:35:23,239
a year, so that's good enough says the

983
00:35:23,239 --> 00:35:25,980
Aruch HaShulchan, you are now an Israeli. Okay,

984
00:35:26,119 --> 00:35:28,059
so these are, in a certain sense, the

985
00:35:28,059 --> 00:35:31,539
simpler cases. Anyone ever hear of the three

986
00:35:32,039 --> 00:35:34,440
regalim heter? Right, so this I think is

987
00:35:34,440 --> 00:35:35,440
a famous one, I think I grew up

988
00:35:35,440 --> 00:35:37,155
with this one. This is Rav Shlomo Zalman

989
00:35:37,155 --> 00:35:39,780
Auerbach's big chiddush. Rav Shlomo Zalman Auerbach says

990
00:35:41,480 --> 00:35:44,059
that if you have you know you'll be

991
00:35:44,059 --> 00:35:46,440
in Israel for all three regalim, so this

992
00:35:46,440 --> 00:35:48,059
is a Yom Tov halacha. This whole halacha

993
00:35:48,059 --> 00:35:50,360
is a Yom Tov halacha. With respect to

994
00:35:50,360 --> 00:35:52,639
Yom Tov then, you are an Israeli for

995
00:35:52,639 --> 00:35:55,739
the whole year basically. So it's a very

996
00:35:55,739 --> 00:35:57,920
interesting, it's a little counterintuitive. Does it matter

997
00:35:57,920 --> 00:36:00,340
where it starts? Say again. Does it matter

998
00:36:00,340 --> 00:36:02,480
where it starts? Right, so let's read, I'm

999
00:36:02,480 --> 00:36:03,460
not sure if it's so clear if it

1000
00:36:03,460 --> 00:36:06,427
matters when it starts: Nireh l'aniyut da'ati d'yeish

1001
00:36:06,427 --> 00:36:08,825
ladun bemi sheyeish lo dirah kevuah b'Eretz Yisrael

1002
00:36:08,825 --> 00:36:11,222
v'kavu atzmam lihyot tamid b'diratam sheb'Eretz Yisrael yachad

1003
00:36:11,222 --> 00:36:14,800
im ishto u'vnei beito b'chol shloshet haregalim. So

1004
00:36:15,000 --> 00:36:16,579
maybe he means that you always do that,

1005
00:36:16,639 --> 00:36:17,679
this is the plan for the next ten

1006
00:36:17,679 --> 00:36:18,719
years, I'm not sure, he's not so clear.

1007
00:36:18,800 --> 00:36:20,710
He says you plan on spending the shalosh

1008
00:36:20,710 --> 00:36:22,569
regalim in Eretz Yisrael. V'af sherov hashanah hem

1009
00:36:22,569 --> 00:36:24,219
b'Chutz La'aretz, you're spending all the rest of

1010
00:36:24,219 --> 00:36:25,924
the time b'Chutz La'aretz, m'kol makom l'inyan Yom

1011
00:36:25,924 --> 00:36:28,174
Tov Sheini keivan shehahevdel bein Eretz Yisrael l'Chutz

1012
00:36:28,174 --> 00:36:30,519
La'aretz shayach rak b'gimmel regalim. Since this whole

1013
00:36:30,519 --> 00:36:33,149
distinction is only relevant for the three regalim,

1014
00:36:33,149 --> 00:36:35,445
nireh l'aniyut da'ati d'ein aleihem shem Bnei Chutz

1015
00:36:35,445 --> 00:36:37,719
La'aretz b'yachas l'Yom Tov Sheini. We look at

1016
00:36:37,719 --> 00:36:39,730
you as an Israeli with respect to Yom

1017
00:36:39,730 --> 00:36:41,380
Tov because with respect to Yom Tov you

1018
00:36:41,380 --> 00:36:43,760
are always an Israeli. So I think sometimes

1019
00:36:43,760 --> 00:36:44,780
you get asked this shaila or you hear

1020
00:36:44,780 --> 00:36:46,539
about this shaila. People think oh I'm keeping

1021
00:36:46,539 --> 00:36:50,820
Sukkot and Pesach in Israel so I'm now

1022
00:36:50,820 --> 00:36:53,010
a Ben Eretz Yisrael according to this Minchat

1023
00:36:53,010 --> 00:36:55,179
Shlomo. So the problem is you also have

1024
00:36:55,179 --> 00:36:56,944
to be there for Shavuot. Rav Shlomo Zalman

1025
00:36:56,944 --> 00:36:58,059
Auerbach never said if you're there for two

1026
00:36:58,059 --> 00:36:59,500
out of three that that's going to be

1027
00:36:59,500 --> 00:37:01,000
good enough. This alone is a big chiddush,

1028
00:37:01,559 --> 00:37:02,659
but two out of three, which I think

1029
00:37:02,659 --> 00:37:03,719
a lot of people think is good enough,

1030
00:37:03,980 --> 00:37:04,980
I don't know too many people who fly

1031
00:37:04,980 --> 00:37:06,679
back also for Shavuot, maybe people do, but

1032
00:37:06,679 --> 00:37:08,840
for the most part I don't know how

1033
00:37:08,840 --> 00:37:12,380
often this comes up practically. Where did he

1034
00:37:12,380 --> 00:37:13,960
get such a svara? This is like I

1035
00:37:13,960 --> 00:37:16,639
don't know, it's a little surprising, I'm there

1036
00:37:16,639 --> 00:37:17,900
for all the yamim tovim so now I'm

1037
00:37:17,900 --> 00:37:19,780
an Israeli. So he says I know that

1038
00:37:19,780 --> 00:37:21,079
what I'm saying is a big chiddush, like

1039
00:37:21,079 --> 00:37:22,840
I wouldn't have been so comfortable saying it.

1040
00:37:23,159 --> 00:37:24,039
He says but at the end of the

1041
00:37:24,039 --> 00:37:26,206
day jump to the bold: m'kol makom b'tzeruf

1042
00:37:26,206 --> 00:37:29,400
im shitat haChacham Tzvi asher devarav hem divrei

1043
00:37:29,400 --> 00:37:32,300
svara. Since the Chacham Tzvi also thinks you'll

1044
00:37:32,300 --> 00:37:34,039
always keep one day even without the three

1045
00:37:34,039 --> 00:37:36,099
yamim tovim and what he's saying makes a

1046
00:37:36,099 --> 00:37:37,960
lot of sense, so you put that together

1047
00:37:37,960 --> 00:37:39,440
with this svara and he says now I'm

1048
00:37:39,440 --> 00:37:41,679
comfortable being meikel. This is a theme throughout

1049
00:37:41,679 --> 00:37:43,320
a lot of teshuvot and again if you

1050
00:37:43,320 --> 00:37:46,019
have any specific situations you should ask a

1051
00:37:46,019 --> 00:37:48,139
rabbi. But many many poskim say well if

1052
00:37:48,139 --> 00:37:49,380
we can just push you a little bit

1053
00:37:49,380 --> 00:37:51,570
more into the Eretz Yisrael category, the Chacham

1054
00:37:51,570 --> 00:37:54,039
Tzvi had a nice argument, that should be

1055
00:37:54,039 --> 00:37:56,079
enough to get you into the Eretz Yisrael

1056
00:37:56,079 --> 00:37:58,159
box even though they wouldn't necessarily be comfortable

1057
00:37:58,880 --> 00:38:01,329
based on that svara alone. We mentioned Rav

1058
00:38:01,329 --> 00:38:03,219
Ovadia, I'll summarize him over here. Rav Ovadia

1059
00:38:03,300 --> 00:38:05,659
has a fascinating idea. He says, and this

1060
00:38:05,659 --> 00:38:07,840
is I think what Sefardim do follow l'ma'aseh,

1061
00:38:07,840 --> 00:38:11,219
although they should ask their rabbis. Let's say

1062
00:38:11,219 --> 00:38:12,739
he's talking about a male, so he's talking

1063
00:38:12,739 --> 00:38:15,280
about a bachur, you're in yeshiva and we

1064
00:38:15,280 --> 00:38:17,360
ask the bachur if you were to find

1065
00:38:17,360 --> 00:38:19,739
a nice Israeli girl, yeah you're currently dependent

1066
00:38:19,739 --> 00:38:21,079
on your parents, but you find a nice

1067
00:38:21,079 --> 00:38:23,139
Israeli girl and the way he puts it

1068
00:38:23,139 --> 00:38:24,719
is, and she'd give you a really big

1069
00:38:24,719 --> 00:38:26,920
dowry so that you could survive in Eretz

1070
00:38:26,920 --> 00:38:30,059
Yisrael, would you stay? And if his answer

1071
00:38:30,059 --> 00:38:31,900
is yes, so he says that's good enough.

1072
00:38:31,900 --> 00:38:34,539
Again with the Chacham Tzvi enough that we

1073
00:38:34,539 --> 00:38:36,119
can consider it's possible that you'd be a

1074
00:38:36,119 --> 00:38:37,400
Ben Eretz Yisrael. That's enough that as long

1075
00:38:37,400 --> 00:38:39,519
as you could in theory stay here, that

1076
00:38:39,519 --> 00:38:40,420
would be good enough. Then he has this

1077
00:38:40,420 --> 00:38:41,980
great line at the end, he says what

1078
00:38:41,980 --> 00:38:43,099
if, we won't read it inside, but you

1079
00:38:43,099 --> 00:38:44,800
can read it yourselves. He says what if

1080
00:38:46,619 --> 00:38:50,780
you say no, no I wouldn't, my parents

1081
00:38:50,780 --> 00:38:52,199
would be so upset? So what you should

1082
00:38:52,199 --> 00:38:53,760
do then is you should tell him you

1083
00:38:53,760 --> 00:38:55,619
know living in Eretz Yisrael is a mitzvah,

1084
00:38:56,019 --> 00:38:58,019
the halacha is Pru u'Rvu is a mitzvah

1085
00:38:58,019 --> 00:38:59,840
and the halacha is if your parents ever

1086
00:38:59,840 --> 00:39:01,559
try and tell you to do something against

1087
00:39:01,559 --> 00:39:03,260
a mitzvah, the real halacha is you shouldn't

1088
00:39:03,260 --> 00:39:05,840
listen to your parents. So again if there's

1089
00:39:05,940 --> 00:39:07,760
a l'ma'aseh shaila someone should ask a rabbi

1090
00:39:07,760 --> 00:39:09,539
instead of acting based on this one statement.

1091
00:39:09,539 --> 00:39:10,820
So he says you should try and convince

1092
00:39:10,820 --> 00:39:12,619
him really the halacha is you should stay

1093
00:39:12,619 --> 00:39:14,119
in Eretz Yisrael if you find such a

1094
00:39:14,119 --> 00:39:16,739
wonderful young woman. So if he says I

1095
00:39:16,739 --> 00:39:18,199
guess you know if you put it that

1096
00:39:18,199 --> 00:39:19,699
way maybe I would stay, so he says

1097
00:39:19,699 --> 00:39:20,920
that would be good enough to go and

1098
00:39:20,920 --> 00:39:25,380
consider you a Ben Eretz Yisrael. So if

1099
00:39:25,380 --> 00:39:27,800
I have someone set up on a shidduch

1100
00:39:27,800 --> 00:39:30,619
date who are in Israel that means I

1101
00:39:30,619 --> 00:39:32,480
think keep one day and go on there

1102
00:39:32,480 --> 00:39:35,000
right? So I'm not posek the shaila, you

1103
00:39:35,000 --> 00:39:36,860
would have to ask whoever you normally ask

1104
00:39:36,860 --> 00:39:39,570
your shailot to. Not again, this is Rav

1105
00:39:39,570 --> 00:39:41,219
Ovadia's big chiddush. I'm not sure everyone is,

1106
00:39:41,719 --> 00:39:43,280
is the Israeli staying in Israel is the

1107
00:39:43,280 --> 00:39:45,739
question. But that's according to Rav Ovadia the

1108
00:39:45,739 --> 00:39:47,920
answer would be yes. If you're going on

1109
00:39:47,920 --> 00:39:49,820
a shidduch date in Israel and that person

1110
00:39:49,820 --> 00:39:51,260
is planning on staying in Israel no matter

1111
00:39:51,260 --> 00:39:53,039
what and you would join them, so then

1112
00:39:53,039 --> 00:39:54,519
Rav Ovadia at least would be meikel that

1113
00:39:54,519 --> 00:39:57,019
you could keep one day. Have to make

1114
00:39:57,019 --> 00:39:58,698
sure the dates don't end before Pesach then,

1115
00:39:58,698 --> 00:40:00,044
but. Wait, that's yours right now. Oh, sorry.

1116
00:40:01,920 --> 00:40:05,814
Okay, so we can figure out the specific

1117
00:40:05,814 --> 00:40:07,968
application. I'll just tell you one thing which,

1118
00:40:07,968 --> 00:40:10,121
yeah, when I was at Nishmat, the story

1119
00:40:10,121 --> 00:40:34,780
there was that the rabbi there

1120
00:40:34,780 --> 00:40:36,933
would do the Rav Ovadia thing of like

1121
00:40:36,933 --> 00:40:37,202
if you meet a guy that you'd stay,

1122
00:40:37,202 --> 00:40:38,908
and his story is that there was like

1123
00:40:38,908 --> 00:40:41,061
one year that there was someone who wanted

1124
00:40:41,061 --> 00:40:43,214
to do like Magen David Adom training on

1125
00:40:43,214 --> 00:40:43,752
what would have been Yom Tov Sheni, so

1126
00:40:43,752 --> 00:40:43,752
like they really wanted to find the Hetter

1127
00:40:43,752 --> 00:40:43,752
so they could go and do the Magen

1128
00:40:43,752 --> 00:40:43,752
David Adom training, and she's like, no, I

1129
00:40:43,752 --> 00:40:45,098
would go back, and he's like, no, maybe

1130
00:40:45,098 --> 00:40:47,251
you'd stay, so finally she's like, okay, fine,

1131
00:40:47,251 --> 00:40:49,404
I'll stay. So he's like, okay, great, you

1132
00:40:49,404 --> 00:40:51,558
can keep only one day, and she ended

1133
00:40:51,558 --> 00:40:53,711
up marrying the instructor of the Magen David

1134
00:40:53,711 --> 00:40:55,326
Adom training. Wow, she ended up marrying the

1135
00:40:55,326 --> 00:40:55,326
trainer she got on Yom Tov Sheni, that's

1136
00:40:55,326 --> 00:40:55,894
incredible. That's a great story. That's a great

1137
00:40:55,894 --> 00:40:57,582
story. I'll tell you one Hetter which I

1138
00:40:57,582 --> 00:40:59,735
just there's it's against an explicit Rav Moshe

1139
00:40:59,735 --> 00:41:01,888
Feinstein. Some people I've heard are Meikal as

1140
00:41:01,888 --> 00:41:04,041
long as you have an apartment. If you

1141
00:41:04,041 --> 00:41:05,387
have an apartment in Eretz Yisrael, that's that's

1142
00:41:05,387 --> 00:41:05,387
enough. So Moshe writes explicitly that nowadays that

1143
00:41:05,387 --> 00:41:05,387
means nothing. You can have an apartment in

1144
00:41:05,387 --> 00:41:05,387
a whole bunch of places, you would fly

1145
00:41:05,387 --> 00:41:05,813
back. Back in the day, could be that

1146
00:41:05,813 --> 00:41:06,890
having an apartment, if you had a home

1147
00:41:06,890 --> 00:41:06,890
there, so that would mean you stay, but

1148
00:41:06,890 --> 00:41:07,739
he says that's that's not really such a

1149
00:41:07,739 --> 00:41:10,579
such a real big Inyan. Rav Neuburger, the

1150
00:41:10,579 --> 00:41:12,820
way Rav Neuburger put it is that unfortunately

1151
00:41:12,820 --> 00:41:15,980
in this area whenever someone somewhere says something,

1152
00:41:15,980 --> 00:41:17,800
so everyone else says, oh, so that must

1153
00:41:17,800 --> 00:41:20,099
be the Halakha as long as it's Meikal.

1154
00:41:20,900 --> 00:41:23,099
So that's that's unfortunate. Some people are following

1155
00:41:23,099 --> 00:41:26,000
doing one day I think Shelo Kedin and

1156
00:41:26,000 --> 00:41:27,559
you should ask your local rabbi. I'll just

1157
00:41:27,559 --> 00:41:31,980
end by saying that sometimes we have this

1158
00:41:31,980 --> 00:41:33,519
tension in Chutz La'aretz because people don't really

1159
00:41:33,519 --> 00:41:34,920
like this whole two-day Yom Tov thing, they

1160
00:41:34,920 --> 00:41:36,519
all want to do the one day and

1161
00:41:36,519 --> 00:41:38,460
especially three-day Yom Tov. So one of my

1162
00:41:38,460 --> 00:41:40,239
Rabbanim says we should start calling it three

1163
00:41:40,239 --> 00:41:42,619
days of Kedusha instead of three days of

1164
00:41:42,619 --> 00:41:44,300
Yom Tov, like you should should try and

1165
00:41:44,300 --> 00:41:46,219
like we got to change the the bad

1166
00:41:46,219 --> 00:41:47,760
rap that three days of Yom Tov has.

1167
00:41:47,880 --> 00:41:49,159
Yom Tov is a wonderful thing, we should

1168
00:41:49,159 --> 00:41:51,559
really embrace it. So I don't know, maybe

1169
00:41:51,780 --> 00:41:53,820
that you know fits for some people and

1170
00:41:53,820 --> 00:41:55,619
just happens to not fit so well for

1171
00:41:55,619 --> 00:41:57,460
me. The other approach which I once heard

1172
00:41:57,460 --> 00:41:59,780
from Rav Wosner is, no, it's okay for

1173
00:41:59,780 --> 00:42:01,820
it to be uncomfortable. It's good that you

1174
00:42:01,820 --> 00:42:03,780
don't enjoy three days Yom Tov. The goal

1175
00:42:03,780 --> 00:42:06,139
in the Torah HaKadosh Baruch Hu wants everyone

1176
00:42:06,139 --> 00:42:07,980
in Eretz Yisrael and especially right now we're

1177
00:42:07,980 --> 00:42:09,920
trying to keep the Eretz Yisrael everyone in

1178
00:42:09,920 --> 00:42:11,800
Eretz Yisrael in our mind. If you're keeping

1179
00:42:12,639 --> 00:42:13,980
Yom Tov Sheni even while you're there in

1180
00:42:13,980 --> 00:42:16,400
Eretz Yisrael, reminder to yourself you know the

1181
00:42:16,400 --> 00:42:17,840
real place where we are supposed to be

1182
00:42:17,840 --> 00:42:21,980
you know before Biat Goel and certainly once

1183
00:42:21,980 --> 00:42:24,139
Biat Goel Moshiach, so then we should be

1184
00:42:24,139 --> 00:42:25,119
in Eretz Yisrael and if we're a little

1185
00:42:25,119 --> 00:42:27,300
uncomfortable, so it's a good reminder that hopefully

1186
00:42:27,300 --> 00:42:29,500
one day we'll all end up there Be'karov.

1187
00:42:29,659 --> 00:42:31,320
Okay, everyone should have a fantastic
