1
00:00:00,000 --> 00:00:02,700
I usually for the Mishmars we've usually been

2
00:00:02,700 --> 00:00:05,339
doing things in Shabbos, but because this Mishmar

3
00:00:05,339 --> 00:00:10,179
was a Shavuos Mishmar, and it was supposed

4
00:00:10,179 --> 00:00:13,560
to connect with the Chabura, so I figured

5
00:00:13,560 --> 00:00:16,620
I would speak about the Masechta that we're

6
00:00:16,620 --> 00:00:19,899
learning, Maseches Beitzah and Shavuos. And we'll have

7
00:00:19,899 --> 00:00:20,980
to do a little bit with Shabbos also,

8
00:00:21,160 --> 00:00:22,940
but I didn't have time to connect everything

9
00:00:22,940 --> 00:00:24,960
together in terms of Shabbos. So I figured

10
00:00:24,960 --> 00:00:26,199
I would just speak about an interesting topic

11
00:00:26,199 --> 00:00:27,530
that comes up at the beginning of Maseches

12
00:00:27,530 --> 00:00:30,239
Beitzah that the entire Jewish world is constantly

13
00:00:30,239 --> 00:00:34,500
curious about. But we'll start in Hilchos Shavuos.

14
00:00:34,679 --> 00:00:36,780
The Shiur will be a little, usually it's

15
00:00:36,780 --> 00:00:38,899
a lot more Halakhic oriented, this may also

16
00:00:38,899 --> 00:00:45,619
be a little more Lomdus oriented, but I

17
00:00:45,619 --> 00:00:48,240
think it's an interesting discussion, interesting topic, interesting

18
00:00:48,240 --> 00:00:51,949
thought. So the Magen Avraham opens up Siman

19
00:00:51,949 --> 00:00:54,560
Taf Tzadik Daled and tells us that on

20
00:00:54,560 --> 00:00:56,420
the first night of Shavuos, one has to

21
00:00:56,420 --> 00:01:00,600
wait to make Kiddush until Tzeis Hakochavim, because

22
00:01:00,600 --> 00:01:03,213
you need Temimos, the Pasuk tells us Sheva

23
00:01:03,213 --> 00:01:06,780
Shabbatos Temimos, you need seven full weeks of

24
00:01:06,780 --> 00:01:08,980
Sefiras HaOmer, seven full weeks have to be

25
00:01:08,980 --> 00:01:11,480
completed until the end of the last day.

26
00:01:11,939 --> 00:01:12,900
So you have to wait until the day

27
00:01:12,900 --> 00:01:14,819
is completely done before you make Kiddush at

28
00:01:15,019 --> 00:01:16,579
Tzeis Hakochavim. That's what the Magen Avraham tells

29
00:01:16,579 --> 00:01:18,730
us at the very beginning of Siman Taf

30
00:01:18,730 --> 00:01:21,310
Tzadik Daled. The Pri Megadim and the Mishna

31
00:01:21,310 --> 00:01:23,219
Berurah there in Sif Katan Alef points out

32
00:01:23,219 --> 00:01:26,099
that just like the Magen Avraham says that

33
00:01:26,099 --> 00:01:28,819
this applies to Kiddush, so too the Taz

34
00:01:28,819 --> 00:01:30,739
in Sif Katan Alef says it applies to

35
00:01:30,739 --> 00:01:33,359
Tefillah, and also you should wait to daven

36
00:01:33,359 --> 00:01:36,310
Maariv until Tzeis Hakochavim. That's what the Pri

37
00:01:36,310 --> 00:01:38,280
Megadim points out. Then the Pri Megadim continues

38
00:01:38,280 --> 00:01:40,099
and at the end he comments and he

39
00:01:40,099 --> 00:01:44,040
says that the Knesses HaGedolah, the Knesses HaGedolah

40
00:01:44,040 --> 00:01:47,111
was one of the 17th century Turkish Achronim,

41
00:01:47,111 --> 00:01:48,819
he's one of the great he was a

42
00:01:48,819 --> 00:01:51,349
commentary on the Tur. So in the Knesses

43
00:01:51,349 --> 00:01:53,659
HaGedolah that the Pri Megadim quotes, he writes

44
00:01:53,659 --> 00:01:56,760
that not only is this true that you

45
00:01:56,760 --> 00:01:58,219
should wait to make Kiddush, you should wait

46
00:01:58,219 --> 00:01:59,920
for davenning until Tzeis Hakochavim on the first

47
00:01:59,920 --> 00:02:01,819
night of Shavuos, but it is also true

48
00:02:01,819 --> 00:02:04,060
that you should wait to make Kiddush and

49
00:02:04,060 --> 00:02:06,260
wait for davenning on the second night of

50
00:02:06,260 --> 00:02:09,219
Shavuos. That's what the Knesses HaGedolah says. The

51
00:02:09,219 --> 00:02:12,039
Pri Megadim disagrees with the Knesses HaGedolah when

52
00:02:12,039 --> 00:02:13,259
he quotes him and the Pri Megadim says

53
00:02:13,259 --> 00:02:15,219
it doesn't make sense. The whole reason why

54
00:02:15,219 --> 00:02:19,340
we wait until Tzeis Hakochavim is because we

55
00:02:19,340 --> 00:02:21,979
need Sheva Shabbatos Temimos. We need seven complete

56
00:02:21,979 --> 00:02:25,099
weeks. Once the first day of Shavuos hit,

57
00:02:25,500 --> 00:02:27,419
so you have seven complete weeks. Who cares,

58
00:02:27,879 --> 00:02:30,159
the Knesses HaGedolah, who cares whether it's the

59
00:02:30,159 --> 00:02:34,219
second day is a Safeika DeYoma, but you

60
00:02:34,219 --> 00:02:35,919
already had the seven complete weeks. So it

61
00:02:35,919 --> 00:02:37,300
just doesn't make sense why you would need

62
00:02:37,300 --> 00:02:40,620
a wait on the second day even though

63
00:02:40,620 --> 00:02:42,039
you would need a wait on the first

64
00:02:42,039 --> 00:02:45,139
night. This is what the Knesses HaGedolah says,

65
00:02:45,159 --> 00:02:46,740
this is what the Pri Megadim says. That's

66
00:02:46,900 --> 00:02:48,740
Machlokes between them. So the Pri Megadim is

67
00:02:48,740 --> 00:02:50,900
a lot more convincing. Yeah. Go back to

68
00:02:50,900 --> 00:02:52,620
a shiur you gave a few weeks ago.

69
00:02:53,039 --> 00:02:55,491
Did the Knesses HaGedolah count every night, tonight

70
00:02:55,491 --> 00:02:57,746
are one or two? So the Baal HaMaor

71
00:02:57,746 --> 00:03:00,080
question at the end of Pesachim. Yeah, the

72
00:03:00,080 --> 00:03:02,414
Baal HaMaor asks whether he should do both.

73
00:03:02,414 --> 00:03:04,748
So l'chora he did. But yet he still

74
00:03:04,748 --> 00:03:07,082
said again the Safeika DeYoma of Shavuos tells

75
00:03:07,082 --> 00:03:09,416
you that the second day should be like

76
00:03:09,416 --> 00:03:11,750
the first day for some reason. But again

77
00:03:11,750 --> 00:03:14,084
this is a question. So the first night,

78
00:03:14,084 --> 00:03:16,418
the chidush is we usually have a thing

79
00:03:16,418 --> 00:03:21,719
called Tosefes, Tosefes Shabbos, Tosefes Yom Tov. As

80
00:03:21,719 --> 00:03:24,259
we pointed out in the past, Rov HaRishonim

81
00:03:24,259 --> 00:03:26,159
explain that Tosefes Shabbos is DeOraisa. The Rambam,

82
00:03:27,640 --> 00:03:29,759
but Rov say that. So it's a real

83
00:03:29,759 --> 00:03:31,740
thing, and yet on Shavuos because the Pasuk

84
00:03:31,740 --> 00:03:35,120
says Temimos we don't have Tosefes of Yom

85
00:03:35,120 --> 00:03:38,479
Tov. Says the Knesses HaGedolah we even don't

86
00:03:38,479 --> 00:03:39,960
have Tosefes Yom Tov on the second night.

87
00:03:40,580 --> 00:03:41,695
But the Pri Megadim says no you can

88
00:03:41,695 --> 00:03:43,360
start you can start early on the second

89
00:03:43,360 --> 00:03:48,199
night of Shavuos. Pri Megadim is Meikel. Yes.

90
00:03:48,639 --> 00:03:50,439
So Pri Megadim is also much more convincing.

91
00:03:50,759 --> 00:03:53,639
We understand you need Sheva Shabbatos Temimos Tiheyena,

92
00:03:53,639 --> 00:03:55,080
but how should that impact the second night

93
00:03:55,080 --> 00:03:57,599
at all? So different ways to answer that

94
00:03:57,599 --> 00:03:59,919
question. One Rav Schachter has in a Teshuvah

95
00:03:59,919 --> 00:04:02,460
that he wrote during Covid on this topic,

96
00:04:02,599 --> 00:04:04,120
so he points out that the Netziv, the

97
00:04:04,120 --> 00:04:05,583
Binyan Shlomo also has it, Rav Shlomo MiVilna,

98
00:04:05,583 --> 00:04:07,063
but the Netziv has in the HaEmek Davar

99
00:04:07,063 --> 00:04:09,911
in Parshas Emor that the Pasuk tells us

100
00:04:09,911 --> 00:04:11,953
Ukrasem Be'etzem HaYom Hazeh Mikra Kodesh Yihiyeh Lachem,

101
00:04:13,619 --> 00:04:15,963
I think it's something along those lines in

102
00:04:15,963 --> 00:04:19,740
Perek Kaf Gimmel in Parshas Emor. So the

103
00:04:19,740 --> 00:04:21,306
fact that it says Ukrasem Be'etzem HaYom Hazeh,

104
00:04:22,900 --> 00:04:25,120
that is coming Lemiyutei, Be'etzem means in the

105
00:04:25,120 --> 00:04:27,259
middle of the day, that's Lemiyutei that comes

106
00:04:27,259 --> 00:04:30,360
to exclude the night before, or the day

107
00:04:30,360 --> 00:04:33,920
before. Meaning this is telling you that even

108
00:04:33,920 --> 00:04:36,483
though there's generally a rule, a Mitzvah called

109
00:04:36,483 --> 00:04:39,480
Tosefes Shabbos, Tosefes Yom Tov, Shavuos has a

110
00:04:39,480 --> 00:04:41,455
Gezeras Hakasuv that tells you Be'etzem HaYom Hazeh,

111
00:04:41,455 --> 00:04:44,620
that no, Shavuos starts at the day or

112
00:04:44,620 --> 00:04:46,779
when Tzeis Hakochavim hits, but you can't start

113
00:04:46,779 --> 00:04:49,459
beforehand. That's the Drasha that the Netziv has.

114
00:04:49,839 --> 00:04:51,800
So if that's true, what the Knesses HaGedolah

115
00:04:51,800 --> 00:04:54,779
would say is that it's not about Temimos,

116
00:04:54,920 --> 00:04:56,100
it's not about this idea that we need

117
00:04:56,100 --> 00:04:59,240
completeness. No, the idea is that Shavuos is

118
00:04:59,240 --> 00:05:01,300
unique in that You need be'etzem hayom hazeh,

119
00:05:01,639 --> 00:05:02,699
you need it to start on the day.

120
00:05:02,699 --> 00:05:04,399
So the idea of two days of Yom

121
00:05:04,399 --> 00:05:06,386
Tov, as we'll see bli neder be'ezras Hashem

122
00:05:06,386 --> 00:05:07,090
soon, in our perek he spoke about during

123
00:05:07,090 --> 00:05:09,424
the week with the korbanos of Shavuos, with

124
00:05:09,424 --> 00:05:10,299
the eating the dairy the night before? No,

125
00:05:11,879 --> 00:05:15,459
no, no, no, no. Yeah, no, yeah. Is

126
00:05:15,459 --> 00:05:16,980
this all this is is that what it's

127
00:05:16,980 --> 00:05:19,130
talking about? No, this is You mean something

128
00:05:19,130 --> 00:05:21,464
else you mentioned earlier in the week about

129
00:05:21,464 --> 00:05:23,798
Shavuos being unique and that, you know, the

130
00:05:23,798 --> 00:05:26,132
Yom Tov started by the day and not...

131
00:05:26,132 --> 00:05:28,180
Yeah, so that's not Shavuos. Rav Schachter writes

132
00:05:28,180 --> 00:05:30,420
this in Ginas Egoz that the idea of

133
00:05:30,420 --> 00:05:33,271
simchas Yom Tov is depend is like kodashim

134
00:05:33,271 --> 00:05:35,022
in that the day follows the night? Yeah,

135
00:05:35,360 --> 00:05:37,480
exactly. That's why the Steipler and others would

136
00:05:37,480 --> 00:05:39,660
do such a thing. No, but this is

137
00:05:39,920 --> 00:05:41,639
that meaning be'etzem doesn't mean the day. It

138
00:05:41,639 --> 00:05:42,839
also means the night, but it means when

139
00:05:42,839 --> 00:05:45,579
the day starts which is at night. So

140
00:05:45,579 --> 00:05:46,959
if that's true, the Knesset HaGedolah would say,

141
00:05:47,060 --> 00:05:47,980
you're going to tell me it's all about

142
00:05:47,980 --> 00:05:49,439
temimos. You're right. That only makes sense on

143
00:05:49,439 --> 00:05:51,250
the first night because we only count Sefiras

144
00:05:51,250 --> 00:05:53,019
HaOmer till the first day. But if it's

145
00:05:53,019 --> 00:05:54,480
not about that, it's about that there's something

146
00:05:54,480 --> 00:05:56,790
unique to Shavuos, a gzeiras hakasuv by Shavuos

147
00:05:56,790 --> 00:06:00,819
that excludes tosefes. So what that tells you,

148
00:06:01,079 --> 00:06:02,379
just like the first day you have to

149
00:06:02,379 --> 00:06:04,060
wait, so too the second day because that's

150
00:06:04,060 --> 00:06:05,519
how two days of Yom Tov work. Whatever

151
00:06:05,519 --> 00:06:06,519
you do the first, you do the second.

152
00:06:06,800 --> 00:06:08,319
If it's all about temimos, it just doesn't

153
00:06:08,319 --> 00:06:10,019
make sense on the second day because we

154
00:06:10,019 --> 00:06:12,213
already completed it. But if it's a gzeiras

155
00:06:12,213 --> 00:06:14,100
hakasuv in the Yom Tov of Shavuos, so

156
00:06:14,100 --> 00:06:15,639
once we have Yom Tov sheini shel galuyos,

157
00:06:15,720 --> 00:06:18,060
that's what we would do. That's what The

158
00:06:18,060 --> 00:06:19,759
problem is and Rav Schachter quotes this all

159
00:06:19,759 --> 00:06:20,879
the time. I think he may even have

160
00:06:20,879 --> 00:06:21,920
that in the tshuva. I just didn't get

161
00:06:21,920 --> 00:06:23,839
a chance to look beforehand. He quotes all

162
00:06:23,839 --> 00:06:25,340
the time that he heard from the Chofetz

163
00:06:25,340 --> 00:06:26,971
Chaim. The Chofetz Chaim didn't like when the

164
00:06:26,971 --> 00:06:28,660
Netziv would what he called made up drashos.

165
00:06:29,580 --> 00:06:31,779
We have drashos that Chazal make up, but

166
00:06:31,779 --> 00:06:34,660
nowhere in Chazal does nowhere do we find

167
00:06:34,660 --> 00:06:36,195
in the Gemara that it says be'etzem hayom

168
00:06:36,195 --> 00:06:38,529
hazeh le'miyuta that you can't do tosefes to

169
00:06:38,529 --> 00:06:41,420
exclude tosefes. So it's kind of like a

170
00:06:41,600 --> 00:06:43,420
made-up drasha. So the Chofetz Chaim wasn't so

171
00:06:43,420 --> 00:06:45,959
fond of that. So the question is, is

172
00:06:45,959 --> 00:06:47,620
there another way to understand this Knesset HaGedolah?

173
00:06:47,620 --> 00:06:48,819
And that's what I want to explore. Is

174
00:06:48,819 --> 00:06:51,120
there another way to understand why the Knesset

175
00:06:51,120 --> 00:06:53,360
HaGedolah is machmir to say even on the

176
00:06:53,360 --> 00:06:55,300
second night of Shavuos you should wait until

177
00:06:55,300 --> 00:06:57,939
tzeit hakochavim? That's what Do we hold that

178
00:06:57,939 --> 00:07:00,339
way? We probably a lot of them do

179
00:07:00,339 --> 00:07:02,079
mikveh and vasikin but that's what I want

180
00:07:02,079 --> 00:07:04,720
to explore regardless. Okay, so in general in

181
00:07:04,720 --> 00:07:06,100
terms of the second night of Yom Tov

182
00:07:06,180 --> 00:07:10,259
outside of Shavuos, on Pesach, on Succos. So

183
00:07:10,259 --> 00:07:13,779
is there an allowance, do we do tosefes

184
00:07:13,779 --> 00:07:15,120
on the second night? Do we take on

185
00:07:15,120 --> 00:07:16,920
Yom Tov early on that second night on

186
00:07:16,920 --> 00:07:18,220
a typical Yom Tov? I'm not talking about

187
00:07:18,220 --> 00:07:20,040
Shabbos when Shabbos is the second night, but

188
00:07:20,040 --> 00:07:21,620
on a typical Yom Tov. You have Succos

189
00:07:21,620 --> 00:07:24,379
on a Monday and Tuesday. So on Monday

190
00:07:24,379 --> 00:07:26,680
night, Tuesday night. So on Tuesday night can

191
00:07:26,680 --> 00:07:29,300
I take in Succos at 4:30? after plag,

192
00:07:29,300 --> 00:07:31,199
whenever plag is. Am I allowed to do

193
00:07:31,199 --> 00:07:35,000
that? So the Maharil is quoted, the achronim

194
00:07:35,000 --> 00:07:36,639
all quote this Maharil and they say their

195
00:07:36,639 --> 00:07:40,560
tefilla. So he writes that the minhag of

196
00:07:40,560 --> 00:07:43,720
the yekkes, the minhag of yotzei Germania, of

197
00:07:43,720 --> 00:07:46,680
the Germans, was that they would not start

198
00:07:46,680 --> 00:07:48,509
the second night of Yom Tov, the leil

199
00:07:48,509 --> 00:07:50,720
beis of a Yom Tov early because of

200
00:07:50,720 --> 00:07:52,920
a chshash. They were worried that what's going

201
00:07:52,920 --> 00:07:54,540
to happen is people they're going to finish

202
00:07:54,540 --> 00:07:56,860
davening, they're going to come home. Everyone's wives

203
00:07:56,860 --> 00:07:57,860
are going to see them they came home

204
00:07:57,860 --> 00:07:59,300
from shul and they're going to start cooking

205
00:07:59,300 --> 00:08:01,180
and preparing the meal. And that's a problem

206
00:08:01,259 --> 00:08:02,379
because you can't cook from one day of

207
00:08:02,379 --> 00:08:03,560
Yom Tov to another day of Yom Tov.

208
00:08:03,660 --> 00:08:07,529
What's that called? Hachana de-Rabbah? Right. That's Hachana

209
00:08:07,529 --> 00:08:08,579
de-Rabbah. You can't cook from one to the

210
00:08:08,579 --> 00:08:10,899
other. Right. That's Gemara in Beitzah. It's almost

211
00:08:10,899 --> 00:08:13,839
the Yom Tov bringing it in for you

212
00:08:14,160 --> 00:08:16,120
for the second day. Okay. So Dave's really

213
00:08:16,120 --> 00:08:18,095
missing out on a lot of a lot

214
00:08:18,095 --> 00:08:20,060
of shiurim. You see. Yeah. So there's a

215
00:08:20,060 --> 00:08:21,579
big discussion. It seems to be hitting the

216
00:08:21,579 --> 00:08:22,939
point that you guys have been doing something.

217
00:08:22,939 --> 00:08:24,398
We've been around picking the right topic. Every

218
00:08:24,398 --> 00:08:27,600
time picking the right topic. So yeah, so

219
00:08:27,600 --> 00:08:29,300
there is a big discussion. It seems to

220
00:08:29,300 --> 00:08:30,879
be a machlokes at the very least in

221
00:08:30,879 --> 00:08:33,259
the achronim but as we pointed out, the

222
00:08:33,259 --> 00:08:36,659
rishonim also about whether what tosefes does is

223
00:08:36,659 --> 00:08:38,500
it changes the day into the next day

224
00:08:38,700 --> 00:08:40,620
or it's just in terms of the issur

225
00:08:40,620 --> 00:08:43,120
melacha. It comes up with Tosafos at the

226
00:08:43,120 --> 00:08:44,860
very beginning of Arvei Pesachim and then many

227
00:08:44,860 --> 00:08:48,320
other places. But that is a big discussion.

228
00:08:48,679 --> 00:08:52,240
But regardless, the question here you're still you're

229
00:08:52,240 --> 00:08:54,139
not allowed to cook from day one to

230
00:08:54,139 --> 00:08:57,439
day two. So until you make Kiddush, it's

231
00:08:57,439 --> 00:09:00,039
probably still day one. So there's still because

232
00:09:00,039 --> 00:09:01,639
even when we take in early, what we'll

233
00:09:01,639 --> 00:09:03,100
say is you can make Kiddush and just

234
00:09:03,100 --> 00:09:04,779
make sure... That's what you mentioned recently with

235
00:09:05,840 --> 00:09:07,720
Sefira. You can still count even though it's

236
00:09:07,720 --> 00:09:10,519
still day of. So that's kind of what

237
00:09:10,519 --> 00:09:12,091
you were... Yeah, yeah, very interesting. Yes, yes.

238
00:09:12,091 --> 00:09:16,566
Yeah, yeah. But this is so but that's

239
00:09:16,566 --> 00:09:17,259
what the Maharil again that was the chshash

240
00:09:17,259 --> 00:09:19,299
that the Maharil had that the minhag of

241
00:09:19,299 --> 00:09:21,899
Germans were they wouldn't take in early on

242
00:09:21,899 --> 00:09:23,279
the second night because they were worried that

243
00:09:23,279 --> 00:09:24,860
then they were going to start preparing too

244
00:09:24,860 --> 00:09:28,240
early. Many places don't are meikel and they

245
00:09:28,240 --> 00:09:30,500
don't worry about such a chshash but that's

246
00:09:30,500 --> 00:09:31,960
what those people did and there are places

247
00:09:31,960 --> 00:09:33,580
that still do that that will wait on

248
00:09:33,580 --> 00:09:34,580
the second night of Yom Tov because we're

249
00:09:34,580 --> 00:09:36,740
worried about that. So for example in our

250
00:09:36,740 --> 00:09:39,960
shul, so we'll daven Maariv before tzeit hakochavim

251
00:09:40,000 --> 00:09:42,440
on a typical second night, but pretty close

252
00:09:42,440 --> 00:09:44,960
to tzeit hakochavim enough that hopefully by the

253
00:09:44,960 --> 00:09:46,600
time you walk back so it'll be about

254
00:09:46,600 --> 00:09:48,720
the time that, you know, your wife lit

255
00:09:48,720 --> 00:09:50,320
candles or something along those lines and then

256
00:09:50,320 --> 00:09:51,879
you can start preparing because if you came

257
00:09:51,879 --> 00:09:53,259
in ten minutes early and the person forgot

258
00:09:53,379 --> 00:09:55,500
and they started setting up his table, so

259
00:09:55,500 --> 00:09:57,083
that's going to be a problem, Hachana de-Rabbah.

260
00:09:57,519 --> 00:09:59,500
That's going to be an issue. So that's

261
00:09:59,500 --> 00:10:00,799
what the Maharil says. says. Then the question

262
00:10:00,799 --> 00:10:02,980
that it begs is whether there is a

263
00:10:02,980 --> 00:10:04,580
din of tosefet by Yom Tov Sheni in

264
00:10:04,580 --> 00:10:06,340
general. Mean is it that you're just allowed

265
00:10:06,340 --> 00:10:07,659
to take it in early, or is there

266
00:10:07,659 --> 00:10:09,340
is there such a din that there's tosefet

267
00:10:09,340 --> 00:10:10,879
Yom Tov on Yom Tov Sheni on the

268
00:10:10,879 --> 00:10:12,919
second day of Yom Tov the second night

269
00:10:12,919 --> 00:10:14,840
of Yom Tov? So what I wanted to

270
00:10:14,840 --> 00:10:17,100
explore just for a little bit is the

271
00:10:17,100 --> 00:10:20,960
concept of Yom Tov Sheni, a concept which

272
00:10:20,960 --> 00:10:24,820
you know caused much controversy in our world.

273
00:10:25,580 --> 00:10:29,679
I remember I was once in Houston, one

274
00:10:29,679 --> 00:10:31,259
of my first years in college. I had

275
00:10:31,259 --> 00:10:32,480
a friend in Houston so I was there

276
00:10:32,480 --> 00:10:34,399
for Yom Tov and I was there as

277
00:10:34,399 --> 00:10:36,983
like so what's the why you think called

278
00:10:36,983 --> 00:10:40,360
Torah Tours? Yes, yes. So I did that

279
00:10:40,360 --> 00:10:43,860
with my me and my friend basically called

280
00:10:43,860 --> 00:10:44,720
Torah Tours and we're like do you have

281
00:10:44,720 --> 00:10:46,500
a friend in Houston can we go? So

282
00:10:46,500 --> 00:10:47,299
it was the three of us and we

283
00:10:47,299 --> 00:10:49,360
did Torah Tours in his shul and I

284
00:10:49,360 --> 00:10:51,379
remember yeah I don't know if I should

285
00:10:51,379 --> 00:10:53,120
say Houston but whatever it was a community.

286
00:10:53,679 --> 00:10:55,600
And I remember walking into shul on the

287
00:10:55,600 --> 00:10:57,720
second day and some guy some older man

288
00:10:57,720 --> 00:10:58,740
comes to me he says Rabbi I have

289
00:10:58,740 --> 00:10:59,779
a question. I was not a rabbi, I

290
00:10:59,779 --> 00:11:02,080
was first year college student. Rabbi I have

291
00:11:02,080 --> 00:11:03,960
a question. And he brings over his friend

292
00:11:04,019 --> 00:11:06,080
he said so his friend starts telling me

293
00:11:06,240 --> 00:11:07,980
that he really wants to make aliyah, really

294
00:11:07,980 --> 00:11:10,120
wants to. So he doesn't keep second day

295
00:11:10,120 --> 00:11:12,291
Yom Tov anymore. And I was like what?

296
00:11:12,291 --> 00:11:14,759
So maybe that's a question for your rabbi,

297
00:11:15,019 --> 00:11:17,820
not for me. People have a hard time

298
00:11:17,820 --> 00:11:19,500
understanding the concept of a second day Yom

299
00:11:19,500 --> 00:11:21,600
Tov. So the concept begins from the Gemara

300
00:11:21,700 --> 00:11:24,220
in Beitzah 4b. The Gemara tells us it

301
00:11:24,220 --> 00:11:27,059
describes how the the way Rosh Chodesh was

302
00:11:27,059 --> 00:11:30,940
originally made, the way that the Beit Din

303
00:11:30,980 --> 00:11:32,659
was mekadesh hachodesh, that they would have the

304
00:11:32,659 --> 00:11:34,631
edim come and then they would tell them

305
00:11:34,679 --> 00:11:37,299
and then Beit Din would basically put out

306
00:11:37,580 --> 00:11:39,039
and tell everyone that it's Rosh Chodesh and

307
00:11:39,159 --> 00:11:41,460
and that's how everything would be. So because

308
00:11:41,460 --> 00:11:43,220
of that obviously caused a lot of issues

309
00:11:43,440 --> 00:11:46,205
because what happened was is if in Beit

310
00:11:46,205 --> 00:11:48,759
Din in Yerushalayim gets the word that today's

311
00:11:48,759 --> 00:11:50,279
Rosh Chodesh, so if you live in America

312
00:11:50,460 --> 00:11:51,799
so you don't know that it's Rosh Chodesh.

313
00:11:51,799 --> 00:11:53,559
So you may not be able to get

314
00:11:53,559 --> 00:11:57,000
till two weeks later. So because of that

315
00:11:57,059 --> 00:11:59,120
once let's say Nisan, Rosh Chodesh Nisan, so

316
00:11:59,120 --> 00:12:01,539
you know it's around the same time so

317
00:12:01,539 --> 00:12:04,179
once a day hits it's either going to

318
00:12:04,179 --> 00:12:06,720
be Tes Vav or Yud Daled. Next day

319
00:12:06,720 --> 00:12:08,200
will be Tes Vav Tes Zayin. So if

320
00:12:08,200 --> 00:12:09,740
you lived in America you weren't sure if

321
00:12:09,740 --> 00:12:11,820
it was today's the fifteenth or tomorrow's the

322
00:12:11,820 --> 00:12:14,240
fifteenth. So they kept two days. Right? Because

323
00:12:14,240 --> 00:12:16,440
again they were able they knew the days

324
00:12:16,440 --> 00:12:17,759
of the month but each month they weren't

325
00:12:17,759 --> 00:12:19,580
sure if it was me'ubar or not. They

326
00:12:19,580 --> 00:12:20,639
weren't sure if it was 29 or 30.

327
00:12:20,639 --> 00:12:23,019
So they knew that either today or tomorrow

328
00:12:23,159 --> 00:12:24,259
was going to be the fifteenth of Nisan

329
00:12:24,259 --> 00:12:25,200
the first day of Pesach but they didn't

330
00:12:25,200 --> 00:12:27,179
know which one. So because of that safek

331
00:12:27,220 --> 00:12:28,419
they were in doubt they had to keep

332
00:12:28,419 --> 00:12:30,109
both days. That's the what we call sfeika

333
00:12:30,109 --> 00:12:31,740
deyoma, that's why there's a second day of

334
00:12:31,740 --> 00:12:34,779
Yom Tov. That's what it is. Originally they

335
00:12:34,779 --> 00:12:37,159
weren't sure, they needed to do both. Again

336
00:12:37,220 --> 00:12:39,559
if you lived in HaMikdash in that area

337
00:12:39,860 --> 00:12:41,419
so obviously you only kept one day because

338
00:12:41,419 --> 00:12:43,279
you knew when Rosh Chodesh was, there was

339
00:12:43,279 --> 00:12:45,111
no reason to ever keep two days. Shoyn.

340
00:12:47,139 --> 00:12:50,279
The the Gemara then tells us: Vehashta and

341
00:12:50,279 --> 00:12:53,659
now, deyadinan bikvia deyarcha, nowadays we know the

342
00:12:53,659 --> 00:12:55,559
calendar. We know what when's the fifteenth of

343
00:12:55,559 --> 00:12:56,860
Nisan we know when's the sixteenth of Nisan.

344
00:12:57,619 --> 00:12:59,580
So if if that's true, mai ta'ama avdinan

345
00:12:59,580 --> 00:13:01,320
trei yomei? Why do we keep two days

346
00:13:01,320 --> 00:13:03,659
Yom Tov then? Doesn't right this is the

347
00:13:03,659 --> 00:13:05,139
question that everyone asks. I know when the

348
00:13:05,139 --> 00:13:06,299
fifteenth of Nisan is why do I have

349
00:13:06,299 --> 00:13:07,720
to keep Yom Tov on the sixteenth of

350
00:13:07,720 --> 00:13:11,147
Nisan? Says says the Gemara: mishum deshalchu mitam

351
00:13:11,147 --> 00:13:13,335
because they sent from Eretz Yisrael, hizharu beminhag

352
00:13:13,335 --> 00:13:19,740
avoteichem biyedeichem, be careful with

353
00:13:19,740 --> 00:13:22,340
the minhag the custom of your forefathers in

354
00:13:22,340 --> 00:13:26,419
your hands, zimnin degazra malchut gezeira because there

355
00:13:26,419 --> 00:13:29,183
may be a time where as Rashi says

356
00:13:29,183 --> 00:13:32,200
that there the kingdom wherever you live the

357
00:13:32,200 --> 00:13:35,039
government will make some sort of shmad and

358
00:13:35,039 --> 00:13:36,346
won't allow you to learn Torah, ve'asi lekal

359
00:13:36,346 --> 00:13:38,851
kulei and it will cause you to forget

360
00:13:38,851 --> 00:13:40,700
the sod ha-ibbur as Rashi says the way

361
00:13:40,700 --> 00:13:43,320
that it calculates and you're going to forget

362
00:13:43,720 --> 00:13:46,000
the whole calendar system and then suddenly you're

363
00:13:46,000 --> 00:13:47,220
stuck and then you're going to have to

364
00:13:47,220 --> 00:13:48,679
keep and then you're going to forget. So

365
00:13:48,679 --> 00:13:50,159
keep two days just so you always keep

366
00:13:50,159 --> 00:13:51,511
two days so you don't run into into

367
00:13:51,511 --> 00:13:55,639
any issues. But but that's what the Gemara

368
00:13:55,740 --> 00:13:58,259
says: hizharu beminhag avoteichem biyedeichem. That's and that's

369
00:13:58,259 --> 00:14:01,440
why we do it. So now if we

370
00:14:01,440 --> 00:14:03,762
have a... but it wasn't a minhag, it

371
00:14:03,762 --> 00:14:04,700
was a safek. Good, we're we're going to

372
00:14:04,700 --> 00:14:05,860
get there. bli neder we're going to get

373
00:14:05,860 --> 00:14:09,031
there. You're making an excellent point. But again

374
00:14:09,031 --> 00:14:11,377
what good you're making an excellent point bli

375
00:14:11,377 --> 00:14:13,431
neder we're going to get there. So so

376
00:14:13,431 --> 00:14:15,871
what comes out though is the second day

377
00:14:15,871 --> 00:14:17,100
of Yom Tov is called sfeika deyoma. It's

378
00:14:17,100 --> 00:14:18,519
based off of a safek. So if we're

379
00:14:18,519 --> 00:14:20,480
talking about the concept of tosefet Yom Tov

380
00:14:20,480 --> 00:14:22,120
obviously there's a safek whether there should be

381
00:14:22,120 --> 00:14:23,820
tosefet Yom Tov right that's the whole point.

382
00:14:24,320 --> 00:14:25,480
Should there be tosefet Yom Tov or not?

383
00:14:25,899 --> 00:14:28,320
That's the safek. So so what should you

384
00:14:28,320 --> 00:14:33,519
do? So in the Klausenberger Rebbe's teshuvos are

385
00:14:33,519 --> 00:14:36,263
called the Divrei Yatziv. So the Divrei Yatziv

386
00:14:36,263 --> 00:14:37,722
in Orach Chayim siman kuf yud zayin he

387
00:14:37,722 --> 00:14:40,759
has a long teshuva about about tosefet. The

388
00:14:40,759 --> 00:14:44,279
Klausenberger was a he was a survivor of

389
00:14:44,279 --> 00:14:45,603
the Holocaust, he was in Auschwitz, he lost

390
00:14:46,480 --> 00:14:48,279
his wife and all his children. Rabbi’s we...

391
00:14:48,279 --> 00:14:50,379
Yes, his Rebbe yes, yes, yes. Yes, yes.

392
00:14:51,120 --> 00:14:54,679
His Rebbe I think Asher Weiss's father is

393
00:14:54,679 --> 00:14:57,379
second day in Auschwitz was he met him.

394
00:14:57,639 --> 00:14:58,899
I think that's what he says. Second day

395
00:14:58,899 --> 00:15:01,639
in Auschwitz he met him. Yeah. Yeah, yeah,

396
00:15:01,679 --> 00:15:05,360
yeah. But so he was a tremendous gadol,

397
00:15:05,360 --> 00:15:08,539
and so in his teshuva called Divrei Yatzev,

398
00:15:08,600 --> 00:15:10,259
so he writes in kuf yud zayin in

399
00:15:10,259 --> 00:15:12,039
Orach Chaim, he has a long thing about

400
00:15:12,039 --> 00:15:13,720
tosefes, but at the very end he discusses

401
00:15:13,720 --> 00:15:15,639
tosefes from Yom Tov to one Yom Tov

402
00:15:15,639 --> 00:15:17,899
to another. And he comments and he says

403
00:15:18,000 --> 00:15:20,000
so because, you know, the whole thing's a

404
00:15:20,000 --> 00:15:22,200
safek, so what you should do is when

405
00:15:22,200 --> 00:15:24,539
you take Tosefet Yom Tov on the first

406
00:15:24,539 --> 00:15:26,320
night, you should have in mind this is

407
00:15:26,620 --> 00:15:28,899
tosefes for both days. That's what he suggests

408
00:15:28,899 --> 00:15:31,419
to do. The problem is that on Shavuos

409
00:15:31,460 --> 00:15:33,159
we don't have tosefes as we pointed out.

410
00:15:33,320 --> 00:15:34,539
As the Magen Avraham tells us, as the

411
00:15:34,539 --> 00:15:36,120
Taz tells us, the Pri Megadim tells us,

412
00:15:36,340 --> 00:15:38,379
we don't do tosefes It's either gezeirat hakatuv

413
00:15:38,399 --> 00:15:39,820
or it's temimos, whatever you want to say,

414
00:15:39,820 --> 00:15:41,539
but there is no tosefes. so you obviously

415
00:15:41,539 --> 00:15:45,139
can't do that. So we have an issue

416
00:15:45,139 --> 00:15:50,179
with that as well. The problem obviously is

417
00:15:50,299 --> 00:15:51,799
that nowadays if we know the keviya deyarcha,

418
00:15:51,879 --> 00:15:53,580
if we know the set calendar, that we

419
00:15:53,580 --> 00:15:56,899
cannot, it should be that we should not

420
00:15:56,899 --> 00:15:58,860
be allowed to take in the second day

421
00:15:58,860 --> 00:16:00,860
of Yom Tov early. Why? Because we know

422
00:16:00,860 --> 00:16:02,000
that the first day is Yom Tov the

423
00:16:02,000 --> 00:16:03,708
second day is chol. We do because minhag

424
00:16:03,708 --> 00:16:05,559
avoteinu beyadeinu. We do because that's the minhag,

425
00:16:05,559 --> 00:16:08,720
that's what we do. But we know the

426
00:16:08,720 --> 00:16:10,419
set calendar. So if we take it in

427
00:16:10,419 --> 00:16:11,891
early, that means we're ending real Yom Tov,

428
00:16:11,891 --> 00:16:14,080
early. We can't do that. So it should

429
00:16:14,080 --> 00:16:15,120
be very very and I think the Divrei

430
00:16:15,120 --> 00:16:16,940
Yatzev he points this out, but it should

431
00:16:16,940 --> 00:16:19,779
be very very difficult to do that. So

432
00:16:19,940 --> 00:16:21,639
you do have an issue. In terms of

433
00:16:21,639 --> 00:16:24,679
Yom Tov sheni and I think we're inching

434
00:16:24,679 --> 00:16:27,460
towards what Arye saying, but there's a it

435
00:16:27,460 --> 00:16:29,539
seems to be machlokes in the rishonim as

436
00:16:29,539 --> 00:16:30,919
to whether Yom Tov sheni is what we

437
00:16:30,919 --> 00:16:34,279
call a minhag or a takana. For example,

438
00:16:35,319 --> 00:16:36,559
I mean there are a lot of examples,

439
00:16:36,740 --> 00:16:38,419
but Tosafos in Sukkah mem dalet amud bet

440
00:16:38,639 --> 00:16:39,759
and the haRosh in Kesuvos in the first

441
00:16:39,759 --> 00:16:41,840
perek in siman hey, both say explicitly that

442
00:16:42,559 --> 00:16:44,919
Yom Tov sheni is called a minhag, what

443
00:16:44,919 --> 00:16:46,980
we would refer to as a custom. On

444
00:16:46,980 --> 00:16:48,666
the other hand, Rashi here in Beitzah dalet

445
00:16:48,666 --> 00:16:50,539
amud bet calls it a, I don't remember

446
00:16:50,539 --> 00:16:53,580
what it's called, a chok kavua, as Rashi

447
00:16:53,820 --> 00:16:56,120
says, shem vadai chok kavua. It's a takana,

448
00:16:56,559 --> 00:16:59,519
that it's a real full-fledged takana. The Ran

449
00:16:59,519 --> 00:17:01,039
in Sukkah also on that Tosafos that I

450
00:17:01,039 --> 00:17:02,980
was talking about, so the Ran also says

451
00:17:03,120 --> 00:17:05,670
it's a takana, the Ramban in Shabbos kaf

452
00:17:05,670 --> 00:17:07,359
gimmel, the haRitzba in Hashan daf yud ches,

453
00:17:07,420 --> 00:17:08,960
they all say it's a takana. They have,

454
00:17:09,319 --> 00:17:10,579
but what's a who cares whether it's a

455
00:17:10,579 --> 00:17:12,720
minhag or takana? So there are a few,

456
00:17:13,140 --> 00:17:15,440
just to name maybe one or two. The

457
00:17:15,440 --> 00:17:17,799
haRosh in Kesuvos that I quoted before discusses

458
00:17:17,799 --> 00:17:22,759
avelus. So avelus, obviously avelus has a source

459
00:17:22,759 --> 00:17:25,059
min hatorah, de'oraita. Right, there's obviously something in

460
00:17:25,480 --> 00:17:27,420
avelus that's de'oraita, but most of avelus is

461
00:17:27,420 --> 00:17:29,779
only derabbanan. So which part of avelus is

462
00:17:29,859 --> 00:17:31,839
de'oraita, you're a for an avelus for, you

463
00:17:31,839 --> 00:17:35,859
didn't. Okay. So what part of avelus is

464
00:17:36,000 --> 00:17:37,339
de'oraita? So this is a big machlokes from

465
00:17:37,339 --> 00:17:39,400
the geonim and the rishonim, what exactly is

466
00:17:39,539 --> 00:17:41,299
de'oraita? Is it the first day, is it

467
00:17:41,299 --> 00:17:42,859
the week, is it less than a day?

468
00:17:43,059 --> 00:17:45,480
A big discussion. So the haRosh there, so

469
00:17:45,480 --> 00:17:47,743
what happens before? What happens if avelus falls,

470
00:17:48,680 --> 00:17:52,519
a person rachmana litzlan has someone niftar on

471
00:17:52,859 --> 00:17:55,820
Yom Tov On Yom Tov? yeah, on Yom

472
00:17:55,820 --> 00:17:57,859
Tov, What's the din? So there's no avelus.

473
00:17:57,940 --> 00:17:59,440
You wait until after Yom Tov. Yom Tov.

474
00:17:59,440 --> 00:18:02,470
cancels shiva, but it doesn't allow for, Yom

475
00:18:02,470 --> 00:18:05,059
Tov sorry cancels shiva, but it also doesn't

476
00:18:05,059 --> 00:18:06,880
allow for avelus to begin yet. So you

477
00:18:06,880 --> 00:18:08,779
would begin afterwards. Now what happens if falls

478
00:18:08,779 --> 00:18:11,019
out on Yom Tov sheni? So that's the

479
00:18:11,019 --> 00:18:15,700
question. So Yom Tov sheni is derabbanan, so

480
00:18:15,700 --> 00:18:17,900
if you have avelus de'oraita, so a de'oraita

481
00:18:17,900 --> 00:18:19,500
is always going to be docheh a derabbanan.

482
00:18:20,360 --> 00:18:22,279
Now the problem is there are many geonim

483
00:18:22,339 --> 00:18:24,480
and the haRosh quotes this, that believe that

484
00:18:24,480 --> 00:18:26,740
avelus yom rishon, meaning the first day of

485
00:18:26,740 --> 00:18:29,700
avelus, shiva definitely not de'oraita. There are many

486
00:18:29,700 --> 00:18:31,579
that believe the first day even the first

487
00:18:31,579 --> 00:18:33,339
day of avelus is not de'oraita, the only

488
00:18:33,339 --> 00:18:35,440
thing that's de'oraita according to some is what

489
00:18:35,440 --> 00:18:37,940
we call aninus. It's the period before you

490
00:18:37,940 --> 00:18:40,119
bury the body when you're an onen, that's

491
00:18:40,119 --> 00:18:43,599
what's de'oraita. So the first day of avelus

492
00:18:43,599 --> 00:18:45,319
happens on Yom Tov sheni, what should you

493
00:18:45,319 --> 00:18:49,400
do? We have avelus derabbanan and we have

494
00:18:50,160 --> 00:18:51,940
Yom Tov derabbanan. So which one wins out?

495
00:18:52,720 --> 00:18:54,519
So says the haRosh, well it's not really

496
00:18:54,519 --> 00:18:57,720
the calculation, the calculation is avelus derabbanan and

497
00:18:57,720 --> 00:18:59,559
the minhag because Yom Tov sheni is only

498
00:18:59,559 --> 00:19:01,480
a minhag. So you would be mitabel, you

499
00:19:01,480 --> 00:19:03,440
would have avelus if it was the first

500
00:19:03,440 --> 00:19:04,680
day of avelus, you would have that even

501
00:19:04,680 --> 00:19:06,680
if it's only derabbanan, you would have it

502
00:19:06,680 --> 00:19:07,900
on Yom Tov sheni because it's a minhag.

503
00:19:08,200 --> 00:19:09,579
So that's a nafka mina of whether it's

504
00:19:09,579 --> 00:19:11,859
a minhag when you have Yom Tov avelus

505
00:19:11,859 --> 00:19:14,079
derabbanan falls out on Yom Tov sheni, do

506
00:19:14,079 --> 00:19:16,463
we keep the avelus or the Yom Tov,

507
00:19:16,463 --> 00:19:17,559
Well it depends if Yom Tov sheni is

508
00:19:17,559 --> 00:19:20,900
a minhag. For burial. The burial you tell

509
00:19:20,900 --> 00:19:22,471
me. I'm saying because I know I can't

510
00:19:22,471 --> 00:19:24,805
remember the thing. Yom Tov sheni legabei met

511
00:19:24,805 --> 00:19:25,680
kechol shavyuhu rabbanan. Rav Chanina Masechet Beitzah here.

512
00:19:25,680 --> 00:19:35,679
And they buried someone in. Yeah, and since

513
00:19:35,679 --> 00:19:38,122
we don't have to worry about bizayon and

514
00:19:38,122 --> 00:19:40,164
everything like they said because it was a

515
00:19:40,164 --> 00:19:40,164
burial. Yeah, yeah, so we wait, we wait

516
00:19:40,164 --> 00:19:40,220
nowadays, you are correct. Yes we did, she

517
00:19:40,220 --> 00:19:41,946
was buried on acharon shel Pesach and my

518
00:19:41,946 --> 00:19:43,666
grandparents my grandmother started avelus on acharon shel

519
00:19:43,666 --> 00:19:50,420
Pesach. Yeah, so again it's

520
00:19:50,420 --> 00:19:52,980
because of this haRosh that if you'll this

521
00:19:52,980 --> 00:19:56,119
is only derabbanan so it's a minhag. But

522
00:19:56,119 --> 00:19:58,859
aninus doesn't start, that's de'oraita. Yeah, correct, but

523
00:19:59,059 --> 00:20:00,799
it doesn't. There would be meaning there would

524
00:20:00,799 --> 00:20:04,259
be no Aninos, there would never be Aninos

525
00:20:04,259 --> 00:20:05,920
in such a case. If a person had,

526
00:20:05,960 --> 00:20:07,779
according to this opinion, if a person had

527
00:20:07,779 --> 00:20:11,799
a Meis die on Yom Tov Sheni of

528
00:20:11,799 --> 00:20:14,980
let's call it Shavuos in the morning and

529
00:20:14,980 --> 00:20:16,831
the burial took place two hours later, there

530
00:20:16,831 --> 00:20:19,119
was never, he was never an Onein. Meaning

531
00:20:19,119 --> 00:20:21,160
he goes and davens in the morning, he

532
00:20:21,160 --> 00:20:23,900
has to say Brachos, all that. So that's

533
00:20:23,900 --> 00:20:25,539
not... another Nafka Mina which is what Tosfos

534
00:20:25,539 --> 00:20:27,240
in Sukkah Mem Daled that I quoted is

535
00:20:27,240 --> 00:20:28,740
talking about is whether you make a Bracha

536
00:20:28,740 --> 00:20:30,599
on Minhagim. This is a big Machlokes in

537
00:20:30,599 --> 00:20:33,440
the Rishonim and then eventually between the Shulchan

538
00:20:33,440 --> 00:20:34,799
Aruch and ha-Rama whether we make a Bracha

539
00:20:34,799 --> 00:20:37,500
on Minhagim. Tosfos there in Sukkah says that

540
00:20:37,500 --> 00:20:39,240
we do make a Bracha, Rabbeinu Tam that

541
00:20:39,240 --> 00:20:40,319
we do make a Bracha on Minhag which

542
00:20:40,380 --> 00:20:42,759
now Ashkenazim pasken, but the Rambam in the

543
00:20:42,759 --> 00:20:44,359
eleventh Perek of Berachos and in the third

544
00:20:44,359 --> 00:20:46,380
Perek of Megillah, there he says no you

545
00:20:46,380 --> 00:20:48,019
don't make a Bracha on Minhagim and that's

546
00:20:48,019 --> 00:20:50,357
how Sephardim pasken. And that's why Hallel Rosh

547
00:20:50,357 --> 00:20:51,720
Chodesh is the classic example. Which means what

548
00:20:51,720 --> 00:20:53,660
though? So now you've got this Minhag of

549
00:20:53,660 --> 00:20:55,859
the second day of Shavuos and you're saying

550
00:20:55,859 --> 00:20:58,579
all these Brachos? No, no, so again we're

551
00:20:58,579 --> 00:20:59,779
trying to figure out what you make a

552
00:20:59,779 --> 00:21:01,480
Bracha on. So this isn't what I'm saying

553
00:21:01,480 --> 00:21:04,359
is in terms of Yom Tov Sheni itself,

554
00:21:05,119 --> 00:21:07,019
it's not clear. The only question would be

555
00:21:07,019 --> 00:21:08,519
in Kiddush. That's the only time you make

556
00:21:08,519 --> 00:21:11,115
a Bracha on the day. You say Mekadesh

557
00:21:11,115 --> 00:21:14,900
Yisrael in this case, Chazarat Hashatz, if you're...

558
00:21:14,900 --> 00:21:16,680
the only thing, well Mekadesh Yisrael, you're saying

559
00:21:16,680 --> 00:21:18,220
Shmoneh Esreh, what Bracha are you making on

560
00:21:18,220 --> 00:21:21,420
the day? You're making a Bracha about the

561
00:21:21,420 --> 00:21:23,400
day, it's Me'ein Hame'ora. It's about the day,

562
00:21:23,400 --> 00:21:25,359
but the Bracha on the day, like for

563
00:21:25,359 --> 00:21:27,619
example, Bracha on Hallel, you're making a Bracha

564
00:21:27,619 --> 00:21:29,400
on the Hallel. So what Bracha do you

565
00:21:29,400 --> 00:21:31,119
make on the... maybe Kiddush. So maybe that's...

566
00:21:31,420 --> 00:21:36,539
but again... but that's on... again they don't

567
00:21:36,539 --> 00:21:38,740
make a Bracha on Hallel. You're saying on

568
00:21:38,740 --> 00:21:40,819
Yom Tov? But that's on Hallel, that's not

569
00:21:40,819 --> 00:21:43,119
on the Yom Tov? Right? That's the difference.

570
00:21:43,119 --> 00:21:45,453
This gets into the things with the burial,

571
00:21:45,453 --> 00:21:47,787
like that says similar over here in Israel

572
00:21:47,787 --> 00:21:50,121
like the day and a half of how

573
00:21:50,121 --> 00:21:52,455
would I not put on Tefillin if you

574
00:21:52,455 --> 00:21:56,839
don't put on Tefillin. Correct. Yeah, yeah, yeah.

575
00:21:57,200 --> 00:22:00,000
Same idea, yes, correct. But okay so anyway

576
00:22:00,119 --> 00:22:01,940
so there are Nafka Mina whether it's Minhag

577
00:22:01,940 --> 00:22:05,180
or Takana, whether Yom Tov Sheni is called

578
00:22:05,180 --> 00:22:07,440
that. Again we have a Machlokes, we have

579
00:22:07,440 --> 00:22:09,359
the Rosh who quotes an opinion at least

580
00:22:10,359 --> 00:22:12,740
and Tosfos in Sukkah that clearly say that

581
00:22:12,740 --> 00:22:14,700
it is a Minhag while we have others

582
00:22:14,700 --> 00:22:16,900
that say that it's not a Minhag. We

583
00:22:16,900 --> 00:22:19,759
have Rashi in our Gemara but also the

584
00:22:19,759 --> 00:22:21,779
Ramban, the Ritva, the Ran, they all say

585
00:22:21,779 --> 00:22:24,259
it's really a Takana. The Shitas ha-Rambam is

586
00:22:24,259 --> 00:22:26,819
a little bit confusing. The Rambam writes in

587
00:22:26,819 --> 00:22:28,732
the sixth Perek of Hilchos Yom Tov, Halacha

588
00:22:28,732 --> 00:22:32,037
Yad Daled, I'll just read: Kol ha-dvarim ha-eleh

589
00:22:32,037 --> 00:22:34,079
she'amarnu haynu bizman shehayu Beis Din shel Eretz

590
00:22:34,079 --> 00:22:37,920
Yisrael mekadeshin al pi hare'iyah. Everything that we've

591
00:22:37,920 --> 00:22:42,420
just spoken about talking about Eruv Tavshilin and

592
00:22:42,420 --> 00:22:46,019
pretty much Eruv Tavshilin. But that was only

593
00:22:46,019 --> 00:22:48,336
when they would be mekadesh hachodesh al pi

594
00:22:48,336 --> 00:22:50,119
hare'iyah, meaning the way that they used to

595
00:22:50,119 --> 00:22:51,903
do it based off their sight. Vehayu bnei

596
00:22:51,903 --> 00:22:54,237
hagolah osim shnei yamim kedei le-histalek min hasafek

597
00:22:54,237 --> 00:22:56,571
liphi shelo hayu yodin yom shekidsbu bo bnei

598
00:22:56,571 --> 00:22:57,446
Eretz Yisrael. And so if you lived in

599
00:22:57,446 --> 00:22:57,446
America, you had two days of Yom Tov.

600
00:22:57,446 --> 00:22:57,940
kedei le-histalek min hasafek because you had a

601
00:22:57,940 --> 00:23:00,069
Safek liphi shelo hayu yodin yom shekidsbu bo

602
00:23:00,069 --> 00:23:01,980
bnei Eretz Yisrael because they didn't know when

603
00:23:01,980 --> 00:23:04,095
Eretz Yisrael were mekadesh hachodesh. Aval hayom shebnei

604
00:23:04,095 --> 00:23:05,845
Eretz Yisrael somchin al hacheshbon umekadeshin alav ein

605
00:23:05,845 --> 00:23:07,596
Yom Tov Sheni le-histalek min hasafek ela minhag

606
00:23:07,596 --> 00:23:09,299
bilvad. But nowadays that Bnei Eretz Yisrael they

607
00:23:09,299 --> 00:23:12,119
rely on the calendar and mekadeshin alav and

608
00:23:12,119 --> 00:23:13,728
that's how they're mekadesh it, ein Yom Tov

609
00:23:13,728 --> 00:23:14,581
Sheni le-histalek min hasafek we don't keep Yom

610
00:23:14,581 --> 00:23:18,015
Tov Sheni because we are Safek, ela minhag

611
00:23:18,015 --> 00:23:22,140
bilvad. It's a minhag. That's what it is.

612
00:23:22,259 --> 00:23:24,119
So the Rambam clearly holds Yom Tov Sheni

613
00:23:24,119 --> 00:23:28,819
is a minhag. Right? However, the Rambam in

614
00:23:28,819 --> 00:23:31,498
Kiddush Hachodesh in Perek Hey Halacha Hey writes:

615
00:23:31,498 --> 00:23:33,332
Bizman hazeh she'ein sham Sanhedrin u-Beis Din shel

616
00:23:33,332 --> 00:23:37,720
Eretz Yisrael kovin al cheshbon zeh. Nowadays where

617
00:23:37,720 --> 00:23:39,551
we go based off calendar: Hayah min hadin

618
00:23:39,551 --> 00:23:41,792
sheyihyu be-chol hamakomos osin yom echad bilvad afilu

619
00:23:41,792 --> 00:23:44,033
hamakomos harichokim shebe-chutz la'aretz kemo bnei Eretz Yisrael

620
00:23:44,033 --> 00:23:45,713
she-hakol al cheshbon echad somchin ve-kovin. Really everyone

621
00:23:45,713 --> 00:23:46,660
should keep one day bilvad even if you're

622
00:23:46,660 --> 00:23:48,839
in America, kemo bnei Eretz Yisrael. That would

623
00:23:48,839 --> 00:23:50,755
make sense, keep one day. She-hakol al cheshbon

624
00:23:50,755 --> 00:23:53,640
echad somchin ve-kovin because we're all based off

625
00:23:53,640 --> 00:23:56,278
the calendar anyway. Aval takanas chachamim hu sheyizharu

626
00:23:56,278 --> 00:24:02,259
beminhag avoseihem she-beyadeihem. To be careful what our

627
00:24:02,259 --> 00:24:04,579
forefathers did. So here he calls it a

628
00:24:04,579 --> 00:24:06,880
takanas chachamim. A takana on a minhag? Oh,

629
00:24:07,400 --> 00:24:10,000
so that's clearly something. What exactly does that

630
00:24:10,000 --> 00:24:12,039
mean? I'll give you one more mareh makom

631
00:24:12,140 --> 00:24:16,119
which is the Rambam in Perek Aleph of

632
00:24:16,119 --> 00:24:18,555
Hilchos Yom Tov in Halacha Kaf Beis writes:

633
00:24:18,555 --> 00:24:20,629
Yom Tov Sheni af al pi she-hu mi-divrei

634
00:24:20,629 --> 00:24:24,686
sofrim. Yom Tov Sheni, af al pi she-hu

635
00:24:24,686 --> 00:24:28,963
mi-divrei sofrim even though it is mi-divrei sofrim,

636
00:24:28,963 --> 00:24:30,980
kol davar she-assur ba-rishon assur ba-sheni. Everything that's

637
00:24:30,980 --> 00:24:33,460
assur on the first day is assur on

638
00:24:33,460 --> 00:24:35,201
the second day. Vechol hamechalel Yom Tov Sheni

639
00:24:35,201 --> 00:24:37,091
ve-afilu shel Rosh Hashanah bein bedavar shehu mishum

640
00:24:37,091 --> 00:24:38,180
shevus bein bemelacha etc. Apologize, Halacha Kaf Aleph.

641
00:24:38,619 --> 00:24:41,783
Zeh she-anu osim be-chutz la'aretz kol yom tov

642
00:24:41,783 --> 00:24:44,947
me-elu shnei yamim minhag hu ve-Yom Tov Sheni

643
00:24:44,947 --> 00:24:48,539
mi-divrei sofrim hu u-me-hadvarim she-nis-chadshu ba-galus. Nowadays that

644
00:24:48,539 --> 00:24:50,015
we keep two days of Yom Tov minhag

645
00:24:50,015 --> 00:24:52,550
hu. It's a minhag. Ve-Yom Tov Sheni mi-divrei

646
00:24:52,550 --> 00:24:54,992
sofrim hu. And it's mi-divrei sofrim. And mi-hadvarim

647
00:24:54,992 --> 00:24:58,680
she-nis-chadshu ba-galus. So those are two very different

648
00:24:58,680 --> 00:25:01,900
things: minhag and mi-divrei sofrim. So which one

649
00:25:01,900 --> 00:25:05,160
is it? It's a whole thing is very

650
00:25:05,319 --> 00:25:07,420
very strange. So the Rambam does hold, and

651
00:25:07,420 --> 00:25:08,799
this is how the maskana of the Gemara

652
00:25:08,799 --> 00:25:10,539
in Beitzah is, that there's a difference between

653
00:25:10,539 --> 00:25:15,420
the Yom Tov, of Rosh Hashanah and all

654
00:25:15,420 --> 00:25:17,359
other Yamim Tovim. Rosh Hashanah is what we

655
00:25:17,359 --> 00:25:21,319
call kdusha achas and yoma arichta, exactly. And

656
00:25:21,319 --> 00:25:23,075
the Yom Tov a regular Yom Tov, is

657
00:25:23,075 --> 00:25:24,819
shtei kdushos. That's what the Rambam writes in

658
00:25:25,059 --> 00:25:26,680
halakha chof dalet here in Perek Aleph. So

659
00:25:26,779 --> 00:25:33,019
what's a nafka mina? Potential? Well

660
00:25:33,059 --> 00:25:35,259
I guess we'll get there, but what's a

661
00:25:35,259 --> 00:25:39,046
nafka mina? I mean, Eretz Yisrael. What's a

662
00:25:39,046 --> 00:25:40,559
nafka mina halakha l'maiseh? Beitzah. A beitzah shenolada

663
00:25:40,559 --> 00:25:43,460
b'shabbos or be'yom tov. So a beitzah that's

664
00:25:43,460 --> 00:25:45,000
laid on Yom Tov do we say it's

665
00:25:45,000 --> 00:25:46,099
assur on the next day or not? If

666
00:25:46,099 --> 00:25:47,503
it's Rosh Hashanah, it's a problem because any

667
00:25:47,503 --> 00:25:48,980
time you have an egg that's laid that

668
00:25:49,279 --> 00:25:52,019
day is assur. So if it's kdusha achas

669
00:25:52,039 --> 00:25:53,839
like Rosh Hashanah, so I can't eat it

670
00:25:53,839 --> 00:25:54,859
the next day because it's as if it

671
00:25:54,859 --> 00:25:56,929
was laid that day. But if it's Yom

672
00:25:56,929 --> 00:26:00,000
Tov sheni shel galuyos and it's shtei kdushos,

673
00:26:00,400 --> 00:26:02,519
so then one of them is chol. Right?

674
00:26:02,859 --> 00:26:04,279
So either the day you're eating it is

675
00:26:04,279 --> 00:26:05,740
a weekday which isn't a problem, or the

676
00:26:05,740 --> 00:26:06,680
day it was laid was a weekday which

677
00:26:06,680 --> 00:26:09,140
isn't a problem. There's also in terms of

678
00:26:09,140 --> 00:26:11,319
Eruvin that there're two or three nafka minas.

679
00:26:11,619 --> 00:26:15,819
I was just trying to test the beitzah

680
00:26:15,819 --> 00:26:19,180
guys. Don't you just have to wait because

681
00:26:19,180 --> 00:26:25,099
it'll become muttar the next day anyways? No,

682
00:26:25,160 --> 00:26:26,500
that would be a reason why there would

683
00:26:26,500 --> 00:26:29,480
be no bitul. Right. davar sheyeish lo matirin,

684
00:26:29,539 --> 00:26:31,440
which is what you're saying, that's something that

685
00:26:31,440 --> 00:26:34,839
there's no bitul. Meaning it's if it's muttar,

686
00:26:34,900 --> 00:26:36,859
it's muttar. I don't need bitul. Meaning, again.

687
00:26:36,900 --> 00:26:38,180
You're saying it's muttar on one of those

688
00:26:38,180 --> 00:26:39,371
days but you don't know which one. But

689
00:26:39,371 --> 00:26:40,420
it doesn't no no, it's muttar for me

690
00:26:40,420 --> 00:26:41,299
to eat on the second day all the

691
00:26:41,299 --> 00:26:42,559
time because either it was laid on the

692
00:26:42,559 --> 00:26:44,091
day that was chol or today is chol.

693
00:26:44,091 --> 00:26:45,119
So it's automatically mima nafshach it's muttar. I

694
00:26:45,119 --> 00:26:47,453
was trying to think of a phrase, thank

695
00:26:47,453 --> 00:26:53,019
you. Yeah. But I think the answer is,

696
00:26:53,039 --> 00:26:54,660
and I think Ari already pointed this out,

697
00:26:54,740 --> 00:26:56,220
is that when you look in Kiddush HaChodesh,

698
00:26:56,259 --> 00:26:59,339
the way he says it is really what

699
00:26:59,339 --> 00:27:03,168
it is is it's a takana, takanas chachamim

700
00:27:03,168 --> 00:27:06,319
hu she'yizahru b'minhag avoseichem she'beyadeichem. That what it

701
00:27:06,319 --> 00:27:08,599
is is the way again the Gemara has

702
00:27:09,839 --> 00:27:12,759
it is shalchu mitam, that the reason is

703
00:27:12,759 --> 00:27:15,599
hizahru b'minhag avoseichem b'yadeichem. The way the Rambam

704
00:27:15,599 --> 00:27:17,473
adds in is it's a takana that hizahru

705
00:27:17,473 --> 00:27:19,299
b'minhag avoseichem. What that means is there was

706
00:27:19,299 --> 00:27:22,200
a takanas chachamim that said the way that

707
00:27:22,200 --> 00:27:24,880
your forefathers held of Yom Tov sheni, that's

708
00:27:24,880 --> 00:27:27,640
what you should be doing. That's really what

709
00:27:27,640 --> 00:27:29,160
the takana is. Now if that's true, well,

710
00:27:29,160 --> 00:27:30,700
comes out something interesting, which is the other

711
00:27:30,700 --> 00:27:32,759
thing that Ari said. If we think about

712
00:27:32,759 --> 00:27:35,099
what happened in the time period of the

713
00:27:35,099 --> 00:27:37,380
Beis Hamikdash, so if you were living in

714
00:27:37,380 --> 00:27:39,460
America, did you have a minhag to keep

715
00:27:39,460 --> 00:27:45,680
two days? No. It's not a minhag, it's

716
00:27:45,680 --> 00:27:48,079
not de'oraisa, but it's midina, it's a safek.

717
00:27:48,180 --> 00:27:49,880
A safek isn't a minhag. This is what

718
00:27:49,880 --> 00:27:51,240
I have to do. There's no like, oh

719
00:27:51,279 --> 00:27:52,440
this is part of my custom that I

720
00:27:52,440 --> 00:27:54,539
keep two days. A minhag is something that

721
00:27:54,539 --> 00:27:59,019
developed you know, the minhag developed gebrochs. So

722
00:27:59,119 --> 00:28:00,740
there was a community that decided we don't

723
00:28:00,740 --> 00:28:04,440
want to do this. This was a sfeika

724
00:28:04,440 --> 00:28:07,400
de'dina. It was midina. The halakha was you

725
00:28:07,400 --> 00:28:10,059
had to keep two days. No no, outside,

726
00:28:10,279 --> 00:28:12,339
in America. Right? You had to keep two

727
00:28:12,339 --> 00:28:14,880
days. So it wasn't a minhag then. So

728
00:28:14,940 --> 00:28:18,599
it's a strange concept, hizahru b'minhag avoseichem b'yadeichem.

729
00:28:18,599 --> 00:28:21,819
Exactly yes, yes I apologize. Right, they didn't

730
00:28:21,819 --> 00:28:23,759
have the calendar so they it was a

731
00:28:23,759 --> 00:28:25,920
real safek. I don't know if Pesach is

732
00:28:25,920 --> 00:28:28,019
today or tomorrow. So it's not a minhag

733
00:28:28,019 --> 00:28:29,440
to keep two days. I have to keep

734
00:28:29,440 --> 00:28:31,380
two days because that's the only way I

735
00:28:31,380 --> 00:28:34,980
can possibly keep Yom Tov, to avoid a

736
00:28:35,559 --> 00:28:38,660
lav of an issur kares. Yeah. So so

737
00:28:38,779 --> 00:28:41,380
so because of that, so that's really what

738
00:28:41,380 --> 00:28:42,383
it is. So it's a funny thing, hizahru

739
00:28:42,383 --> 00:28:44,400
b'minhag avoseichem b'yadeichem. Be careful with the minhag

740
00:28:44,400 --> 00:28:46,259
of our forefathers. What minhag are we talking

741
00:28:46,259 --> 00:28:48,380
about? So the answer, at least one way

742
00:28:48,380 --> 00:28:49,759
to look at the answer, is that we

743
00:28:49,759 --> 00:28:51,480
don't mean minhag in the sense of minhag

744
00:28:51,599 --> 00:28:55,759
like gebrochs or minhag is to wear this

745
00:28:55,759 --> 00:28:57,579
type of tallis. We don't mean a minhag

746
00:28:57,579 --> 00:28:59,640
like that. We mean minhag in the translation,

747
00:29:00,880 --> 00:29:03,440
the actions, the customs of your forefathers, what

748
00:29:03,440 --> 00:29:05,539
they acted when they were in galus. hizahru,

749
00:29:05,779 --> 00:29:08,960
keep those. Meaning what the takana is according

750
00:29:08,960 --> 00:29:11,059
to the Rambam is to do what they

751
00:29:11,059 --> 00:29:13,400
did as they did it. That's really what

752
00:29:13,400 --> 00:29:16,000
the takana is in essence. So if that's

753
00:29:16,000 --> 00:29:17,420
true doesn't the Gemara give a reason, right?

754
00:29:18,079 --> 00:29:21,720
The Gemara right there with Geziras Hamalchus. Yeah.

755
00:29:22,400 --> 00:29:24,339
That one day it must become we're not

756
00:29:24,339 --> 00:29:26,640
going to be so clear, they burn our

757
00:29:26,640 --> 00:29:28,680
books, we don't know what to do, we

758
00:29:28,680 --> 00:29:31,220
don't know how to calculate anymore. So what

759
00:29:31,220 --> 00:29:32,119
does that have to do with anything? Well

760
00:29:32,160 --> 00:29:33,355
no, because now if you only if you

761
00:29:33,355 --> 00:29:35,579
don't hold by what they did, their customs,

762
00:29:35,759 --> 00:29:38,099
their practices of two days, you won't know

763
00:29:38,099 --> 00:29:39,519
which day and then you'll No no, I

764
00:29:39,519 --> 00:29:40,740
agree with you that that's why there was

765
00:29:40,740 --> 00:29:42,279
a takana though. That's the point. Meaning the

766
00:29:42,279 --> 00:29:44,579
takana was that we're afraid something may happen,

767
00:29:44,960 --> 00:29:48,279
so do what they did. It's not just

768
00:29:48,279 --> 00:29:50,160
keep the minhag alive, it's do what they

769
00:29:50,160 --> 00:29:51,275
did. hizahru b'minhag avoseichem, that's why you have

770
00:29:51,299 --> 00:29:53,940
to but that's the takana. That's the proof

771
00:29:53,940 --> 00:29:55,131
of why it should be a takana and

772
00:29:55,131 --> 00:29:57,380
not a minhag. Yeah, yeah, oh that's yes,

773
00:29:57,400 --> 00:30:00,660
yes, yes. So really though in America it

774
00:30:00,660 --> 00:30:04,400
makes their ancestors did two days. Yeah, but

775
00:30:04,400 --> 00:30:07,539
once again, their ancestors and ancestors. Well, okay,

776
00:30:07,640 --> 00:30:09,460
but I'm saying Ashkenazim, right, if they don't

777
00:30:09,460 --> 00:30:11,460
have a reason why their ancestor did it

778
00:30:11,460 --> 00:30:13,079
and now they're not in the place. No,

779
00:30:13,140 --> 00:30:14,819
but yeah, shalchu matam is that when you're

780
00:30:14,819 --> 00:30:16,900
in chutz la'aretz, you have to keep, do

781
00:30:16,900 --> 00:30:18,159
chazaka k'minhag avoteichem. Once you move to Eretz

782
00:30:18,159 --> 00:30:20,380
Yisrael, so that's the place where, where you

783
00:30:20,380 --> 00:30:21,759
only need. I'm just saying but if it's

784
00:30:21,759 --> 00:30:23,480
dependent on what your ancestors did, then you

785
00:30:23,599 --> 00:30:25,240
came from a place that never kept one

786
00:30:25,240 --> 00:30:27,839
day. But, but, meaning shalchu matam is that

787
00:30:27,839 --> 00:30:29,166
they sent from Eretz Yisrael to the bnei

788
00:30:29,166 --> 00:30:31,339
chutz la'aretz. So it was only talking to

789
00:30:31,339 --> 00:30:32,799
people in chutz la'aretz. I get the idea.

790
00:30:32,940 --> 00:30:34,099
I'm just saying like if you're coming from

791
00:30:34,099 --> 00:30:38,019
your ancestors, we change what ancestors did. If

792
00:30:39,660 --> 00:30:41,660
you move locations, you change what they did.

793
00:30:41,660 --> 00:30:43,539
Yeah, but, but again, if you were living

794
00:30:43,539 --> 00:30:45,599
in America. My point is it goes by

795
00:30:45,599 --> 00:30:47,215
the location, not the, not what you did

796
00:30:47,215 --> 00:30:48,500
before. Even if ancestors were living in chutz

797
00:30:48,500 --> 00:30:51,359
la'aretz, if they went to Eretz Yisrael, they

798
00:30:51,359 --> 00:30:54,240
only keep one day. Exactly. But, but that's

799
00:30:54,240 --> 00:30:55,380
only meaning and then they would go back

800
00:30:55,380 --> 00:30:57,000
and they would keep two days. But why

801
00:30:57,000 --> 00:30:58,039
would they keep two days? They'd keep two

802
00:30:58,039 --> 00:31:00,440
days because that's what their ancestors kept. They'd

803
00:31:00,440 --> 00:31:02,299
keep one day because they're in Eretz Yisrael,

804
00:31:02,380 --> 00:31:04,700
they don't need, they don't count. But if

805
00:31:04,700 --> 00:31:05,559
this is true, if this is the way

806
00:31:05,559 --> 00:31:07,460
to understand that what the takkanah is, the

807
00:31:07,460 --> 00:31:09,640
takkanah is to do what they did. So

808
00:31:09,640 --> 00:31:11,259
now, let's think of this. So A, it

809
00:31:11,259 --> 00:31:12,839
wasn't a safek, it was, I mean it

810
00:31:12,839 --> 00:31:14,259
was a safek, it wasn't a minhag, it

811
00:31:14,259 --> 00:31:15,920
was a safek and they did what we

812
00:31:15,920 --> 00:31:18,140
call midina. Now B, what, what happened if

813
00:31:18,140 --> 00:31:19,200
you lived in America in the time of

814
00:31:19,200 --> 00:31:22,099
the Beit HaMikdash? Second night of Shavuot comes.

815
00:31:22,920 --> 00:31:24,900
Would you start early or... no, no, definitely

816
00:31:24,900 --> 00:31:28,000
not. You can't. It's a sefeika d'yoma. So

817
00:31:28,420 --> 00:31:31,309
when we say the concept of hizaharu b'minhag

818
00:31:31,309 --> 00:31:32,920
avoteichem biyadeichem, that really means the takkanah is

819
00:31:32,920 --> 00:31:34,559
to do what they did. So that means

820
00:31:34,559 --> 00:31:35,640
do what they did and in the same

821
00:31:35,640 --> 00:31:36,740
way in the second night of Shavuot they

822
00:31:36,740 --> 00:31:40,755
couldn't start early because it could be... and

823
00:31:40,755 --> 00:31:41,046
wouldn't it be for every Yom Tov Sheni?

824
00:31:41,046 --> 00:31:44,960
For every, no, there's tosefes by Yom Tov

825
00:31:45,319 --> 00:31:47,839
Shavuot doesn't have tosefet right? Shavuot is the

826
00:31:47,839 --> 00:31:50,259
unique holiday that doesn't have tosefet, In this

827
00:31:50,259 --> 00:31:51,880
case you can't because the second day could

828
00:31:51,880 --> 00:31:53,380
be, could be the first day and then

829
00:31:53,380 --> 00:31:54,940
you would have a problem of temimot, you'd

830
00:31:54,940 --> 00:31:57,039
have a problem with whatever it is, but

831
00:31:57,039 --> 00:31:58,960
you would have an issue. So that's what

832
00:31:58,960 --> 00:32:00,759
even the second day. So that's perhaps that's

833
00:32:00,759 --> 00:32:02,480
what the Knesset HaGedolah that we started with,

834
00:32:02,799 --> 00:32:05,500
that's the logic. The logic, the reason to

835
00:32:05,500 --> 00:32:07,319
say that even the second day of Shavuot

836
00:32:07,319 --> 00:32:10,579
I shouldn't keep, I shouldn't start early, I

837
00:32:10,579 --> 00:32:12,700
should wait to start late, is not because

838
00:32:14,240 --> 00:32:16,180
the gezeirat hakatuv like we said. No, the

839
00:32:16,180 --> 00:32:17,579
idea is no, really is a din in

840
00:32:17,579 --> 00:32:19,680
temimot, but you need a full week. But

841
00:32:19,680 --> 00:32:21,579
the idea of Yom Tov Sheni is a

842
00:32:21,579 --> 00:32:24,420
takkanah to be hizahir b'minhag avoteinu and the

843
00:32:24,420 --> 00:32:26,240
way that they kept Yom Tov Sheni and

844
00:32:26,240 --> 00:32:27,743
the way that they kept Yom Tov Sheni

845
00:32:27,743 --> 00:32:30,059
shel Shavuot obviously was not to start early

846
00:32:30,059 --> 00:32:31,160
because it could have been the first day.

847
00:32:31,680 --> 00:32:33,059
So perhaps that's where the Knesset HaGedolah. So

848
00:32:33,059 --> 00:32:34,579
where does the Pri Megadim disagree and really

849
00:32:34,579 --> 00:32:37,420
where we disagree? So presumably what he says

850
00:32:37,420 --> 00:32:39,599
is that now, now that we are experts.

851
00:32:40,360 --> 00:32:42,940
So what hizaharu b'minhag avoteichem biyadeinu according to

852
00:32:42,940 --> 00:32:44,700
the Pri Megadim is just that what we

853
00:32:44,700 --> 00:32:46,140
call the kedushat hayom has to be the

854
00:32:46,140 --> 00:32:47,720
same, meaning that we keep a second day

855
00:32:47,720 --> 00:32:49,579
of Yom Tov. But that means just like

856
00:32:49,579 --> 00:32:50,680
they kept a second day of Yom Tov.

857
00:32:50,680 --> 00:32:52,640
misafek, so we still keep a second day

858
00:32:52,640 --> 00:32:54,579
because again we're worried that if something happens

859
00:32:54,579 --> 00:32:56,240
we won't know, we're going to lose the

860
00:32:56,240 --> 00:32:58,220
calendar, so we always just keep two days.

861
00:32:58,220 --> 00:33:00,319
But it doesn't mean the way you keep

862
00:33:00,319 --> 00:33:01,740
it is exactly the way they did it.

863
00:33:01,779 --> 00:33:04,039
That's probably where the Pri Megadim is coming

864
00:33:04,039 --> 00:33:06,000
from. But I thought it was just at

865
00:33:06,000 --> 00:33:07,211
least an interesting way to understand the Knesset

866
00:33:07,211 --> 00:33:09,059
HaGedolah. Yeah. When you said experts, it's a

867
00:33:09,059 --> 00:33:10,559
fixed calendar. That's what I mean by experts.

868
00:33:10,960 --> 00:33:12,940
That's what I mean. Experts, meaning the Gemara

869
00:33:12,940 --> 00:33:15,180
says right bekiin b'kivya deyarcha that we're, I

870
00:33:15,180 --> 00:33:16,920
mean we know the calendar until Eliyahu came.

871
00:33:16,920 --> 00:33:20,019
Yeah, so that was, I thought that was

872
00:33:20,019 --> 00:33:22,000
an interesting discussion between the Knesset HaGedolah and

873
00:33:22,000 --> 00:33:24,779
the Pri Megadim and specifically to understand the

874
00:33:24,779 --> 00:33:26,779
Knesset HaGedolah and understand what it means or

875
00:33:26,779 --> 00:33:28,940
at least one way of understanding hizaharu b'minhag

876
00:33:28,940 --> 00:33:30,900
avoteichem biyadeichem according to the Rambam that that's

877
00:33:30,900 --> 00:33:33,740
the takkanah to do what they did. Just

878
00:33:33,740 --> 00:33:35,940
maybe to conclude with a little bit of

879
00:33:35,940 --> 00:33:39,180
I guess what we call divrei agaddah. I

880
00:33:39,180 --> 00:33:42,619
remember a few years ago I heard the

881
00:33:42,619 --> 00:33:45,450
following from Rav Eliyahu Brudny, who's the Rosh

882
00:33:45,450 --> 00:33:47,819
Yeshiva in the Mir in Brooklyn. So he

883
00:33:47,819 --> 00:33:49,180
had the following he'arah which I thought was

884
00:33:49,180 --> 00:33:54,240
very interesting. The question that he posed was

885
00:33:54,240 --> 00:33:57,680
why it is that we begin Shavuot, the

886
00:33:57,680 --> 00:34:00,400
first thing we do is a chumra. The

887
00:34:00,400 --> 00:34:02,500
first thing we do is this chumra not

888
00:34:02,500 --> 00:34:04,039
to start Shavuot early. So we wait until

889
00:34:04,380 --> 00:34:07,359
tzait hakochavim. Again, that's a minhag. That's the

890
00:34:07,359 --> 00:34:10,000
minhag is to wait. But it's not midina.

891
00:34:10,119 --> 00:34:11,400
You can start early if you really wanted

892
00:34:11,400 --> 00:34:13,719
to. There's no din d'Oraisa. This was a

893
00:34:13,719 --> 00:34:15,491
minhag that the Magen Avraham brings down, the

894
00:34:15,619 --> 00:34:17,460
Taz brings down. But why do we start

895
00:34:17,460 --> 00:34:18,320
it with a chumra? That was the question

896
00:34:18,320 --> 00:34:20,179
he posed. So the way he answered it

897
00:34:20,179 --> 00:34:21,960
was based on something that the Gaon writes

898
00:34:21,960 --> 00:34:24,050
in the Gemara in Berachos on daf chof

899
00:34:24,050 --> 00:34:27,663
amud bais. The Gemara says the following: Darash

900
00:34:27,663 --> 00:34:30,099
Rav Avira, Rav Avira says, zimnin amar lah

901
00:34:30,099 --> 00:34:34,403
mishmei d'Rabbi Ami, some say it was in

902
00:34:34,403 --> 00:34:35,221
the name of Rabbi Ami, v'zimnin amar lah

903
00:34:35,221 --> 00:34:35,658
mishmei d'Rabbi Assi, some say it was in

904
00:34:35,658 --> 00:34:36,133
the name of Rabbi Assi. Amru malachei hashareit

905
00:34:36,133 --> 00:34:37,015
lifnei HaKadosh Baruch Hu, the malachim said to

906
00:34:37,015 --> 00:34:44,059
Hashem, Ribbono shel Olam, God, kasuv b'Torascha, it

907
00:34:44,059 --> 00:34:46,092
says in your Torah, asher lo yisa fanim

908
00:34:46,092 --> 00:34:48,599
v'lo yikach shochad, that you can't show favoritism,

909
00:34:48,719 --> 00:34:51,026
you can't collect bribes. V'halo Atah nosei fanim

910
00:34:51,026 --> 00:34:52,860
l'Yisrael, but you show favoritism to the Jewish

911
00:34:52,860 --> 00:34:54,318
people, dichsiv as a pasuk says, yisa Hashem

912
00:34:54,318 --> 00:34:59,760
panav eilecha, that Hashem will show favoritism to

913
00:34:59,760 --> 00:35:02,019
you. Turn his face towards you. That was

914
00:35:02,019 --> 00:35:03,966
what the Malachim asked. Hashem responded amar lahem:

915
00:35:03,966 --> 00:35:08,800
V'chi lo esa fanim leYisrael? Can I not

916
00:35:08,800 --> 00:35:11,319
show favoritism to them? she-katavti lahem ba-Torah I

917
00:35:11,319 --> 00:35:13,546
wrote in the Torah ve'achalta vesavata uverachta et

918
00:35:13,546 --> 00:35:16,920
Hashem Elokecha that they shall eat be satisfied

919
00:35:17,039 --> 00:35:18,900
and make a bracha and thank me. Meaning

920
00:35:19,119 --> 00:35:21,411
the Birkat Hamazon is when I'm satisfied. ve-hem

921
00:35:21,411 --> 00:35:24,880
medakdekim al atzman and they were scrupulous on

922
00:35:24,880 --> 00:35:27,213
themselves ad k'zayit ad k'beitzah that even a

923
00:35:27,213 --> 00:35:28,579
kzayit and a kbeitza they're going to make

924
00:35:28,579 --> 00:35:31,599
a bracha. So they're so scrupulous how can

925
00:35:31,599 --> 00:35:32,920
I not be yisa panim? How can I

926
00:35:32,920 --> 00:35:37,023
not turn my face towards them? So what

927
00:35:37,023 --> 00:35:39,719
the Gemara what clearly emerges from the Gemara

928
00:35:39,719 --> 00:35:42,679
is the way that we get favoritism from

929
00:35:42,679 --> 00:35:45,599
Hashem is when we're noseh panim to him

930
00:35:46,159 --> 00:35:48,053
as the Gra writes that if we're noseh

931
00:35:48,053 --> 00:35:49,860
panim la-Torah Hashem is yisa panim to us.

932
00:35:50,260 --> 00:35:52,626
What does noseh panim la-Torah mean? So noseh

933
00:35:52,626 --> 00:35:54,619
panim la-Torah means this that even though the

934
00:35:54,619 --> 00:35:57,460
Torah tells us strictly speaking satisfied make a

935
00:35:57,460 --> 00:35:59,260
bracha achrona we're machmir and say no even

936
00:35:59,260 --> 00:36:01,820
less we're going to ensure that we're going

937
00:36:01,820 --> 00:36:03,780
to make a bracha achrona. But that's what

938
00:36:03,780 --> 00:36:05,780
to be noseh panim means is a chumra.

939
00:36:05,880 --> 00:36:07,780
The Gemara b'Shabbat daf yud gimmel the Gra

940
00:36:07,780 --> 00:36:10,360
quotes talks about a talmid chacham that died

941
00:36:10,360 --> 00:36:12,559
very early and the Gemara his wife was

942
00:36:12,559 --> 00:36:14,251
complaining what exactly how could he have done

943
00:36:14,251 --> 00:36:15,960
died so early he did all these amazing

944
00:36:15,960 --> 00:36:19,320
things basically Eliyahu Hanavi comes and says that

945
00:36:19,320 --> 00:36:21,360
he wasn't noseh panim ba-Torah. Whatever that means

946
00:36:21,360 --> 00:36:23,900
on this person's level but there was a

947
00:36:23,900 --> 00:36:26,079
certain chumra that he didn't do wasn't m'dina

948
00:36:26,079 --> 00:36:28,619
but there was a chumra. There wasn't what

949
00:36:28,619 --> 00:36:30,960
that's called noseh panim ba-Torah. That's what that

950
00:36:30,960 --> 00:36:33,780
phrase means. And that's what again that's what

951
00:36:33,780 --> 00:36:35,059
the Gaon says here that when we are

952
00:36:35,380 --> 00:36:37,457
noseh panim la-Torah then Yisa Hashem panav elecha

953
00:36:37,457 --> 00:36:39,400
veyasem lecha shalom and if not then Hashem

954
00:36:39,400 --> 00:36:40,639
is not going to be noseh panim because

955
00:36:40,639 --> 00:36:44,199
lo yisa panim velo yikach shochad. So anytime

956
00:36:44,199 --> 00:36:46,559
we want that nesiat panim we want the

957
00:36:46,559 --> 00:36:49,079
favoritism we have to show favoritism to Hashem

958
00:36:49,519 --> 00:36:51,820
which means a chumra which means now for

959
00:36:51,820 --> 00:36:54,519
each person that means something different right a

960
00:36:54,519 --> 00:36:57,480
person has to see within themselves what chumra

961
00:36:57,480 --> 00:37:00,159
makes sense to show Hakadosh Baruch Hu I'm

962
00:37:00,159 --> 00:37:02,719
turning towards you I'm showing favoritism towards you

963
00:37:03,219 --> 00:37:04,800
but that's the way that nesiat panim works

964
00:37:04,800 --> 00:37:07,599
yeah. So giving up Tosefet Yom Tov is

965
00:37:07,599 --> 00:37:09,291
a chumra? No we're not up to that

966
00:37:09,291 --> 00:37:10,458
one second one second we're not up to

967
00:37:10,458 --> 00:37:11,500
that. We ran very fast through that we're

968
00:37:11,500 --> 00:37:16,139
getting there we're not so says it's not

969
00:37:16,139 --> 00:37:17,260
giving up Tosefet Yom Tov is a chumra?

970
00:37:18,119 --> 00:37:20,079
The chumra is that you're not allowed to

971
00:37:20,079 --> 00:37:22,460
start before tzeit hakochavim which means giving up

972
00:37:22,460 --> 00:37:23,595
tosefet. Yom Tov is a chumra why would

973
00:37:23,595 --> 00:37:24,178
you do that? Some say yes and some

974
00:37:24,179 --> 00:37:30,300
say no but the point that

975
00:37:30,300 --> 00:37:31,900
he made is so when Klal Yisrael as

976
00:37:31,900 --> 00:37:34,699
a whole are being machmir into a Yom

977
00:37:34,699 --> 00:37:37,900
Tov of Matan Torah so the way that

978
00:37:37,900 --> 00:37:40,599
we want to express our Kabbalat HaTorah that

979
00:37:40,599 --> 00:37:42,199
Hashem is giving us the Torah is when

980
00:37:42,199 --> 00:37:44,539
we're noseh panim ba-Torah as we're entering into

981
00:37:44,539 --> 00:37:46,019
the Yom Tov so that Hakadosh Baruch Hu

982
00:37:46,019 --> 00:37:48,300
can be noseh panim to us. But it's

983
00:37:48,300 --> 00:37:57,960
specifically in the context of Matan

984
00:37:57,960 --> 00:38:01,380
Torateinu on the day of Shavuot we begin

985
00:38:01,380 --> 00:38:03,460
it with again what he refers to as

986
00:38:03,460 --> 00:38:06,400
a chumra not to begin until tzeit hakochavim.

987
00:38:06,440 --> 00:38:09,539
Or like coming in on a Thursday night

988
00:38:09,539 --> 00:38:12,019
for a little extra learning avada avada that's

989
00:38:12,019 --> 00:38:15,380
being noseh panim la-Torah and Hakadosh Baruch Hu

990
00:38:15,380 --> 00:38:19,239
should be noseh panim aleinu.
