1
00:00:00,000 --> 00:00:02,080
So great to be learning together Ashrei Raz

2
00:00:02,500 --> 00:00:04,419
Teshuvah of the week and this week I'd

3
00:00:04,419 --> 00:00:07,059
like to talk about an important topic and

4
00:00:07,059 --> 00:00:09,859
that is if someone who is observing one

5
00:00:09,859 --> 00:00:11,839
day of Yom Tov in Eretz Yisrael for

6
00:00:11,839 --> 00:00:15,240
whatever reason are they permitted to fly back

7
00:00:15,240 --> 00:00:19,000
on Yom Tov Sheni board a plane on

8
00:00:19,000 --> 00:00:22,179
Yom Tov Sheni in Israel and return to

9
00:00:22,179 --> 00:00:25,239
the United States? So first of all who

10
00:00:25,239 --> 00:00:28,399
is observing one day? Generally speaking the accepted

11
00:00:28,399 --> 00:00:31,000
position for generations at least from the time

12
00:00:31,000 --> 00:00:32,780
of the Beit Yosef probably already to the

13
00:00:32,780 --> 00:00:34,880
time of the Geonim maybe even earlier than

14
00:00:34,880 --> 00:00:37,520
that is that a Ben Chutz La'aretz someone

15
00:00:37,520 --> 00:00:42,100
who resides outside of Eretz Yisrael has a

16
00:00:42,100 --> 00:00:45,700
misfortune of residing outside of Eretz Yisrael and

17
00:00:45,700 --> 00:00:49,119
visits Eretz Yisrael for the Yamim Tovim has

18
00:00:49,119 --> 00:00:52,700
to must observe Yom Tov Sheni. Now there's

19
00:00:52,700 --> 00:00:54,479
a minority opinion that he only has to

20
00:00:54,479 --> 00:00:58,880
observe one day but Lubavitch held from that

21
00:01:00,640 --> 00:01:03,579
Rav Soloveitchik essentially held that so some of

22
00:01:03,579 --> 00:01:06,900
his talmidim will tell their congregants to or

23
00:01:06,900 --> 00:01:09,491
the talmidei talmidim to observe one day and

24
00:01:10,000 --> 00:01:12,439
Rav Ovadia Yosef based on the Chida will

25
00:01:12,439 --> 00:01:15,703
say that for certain people that there's either

26
00:01:15,703 --> 00:01:19,959
it's their so the young young people young

27
00:01:19,959 --> 00:01:23,319
unmarrieds who if they have the chance they

28
00:01:23,319 --> 00:01:24,620
get the opportunity to get married they would

29
00:01:24,620 --> 00:01:27,340
stay in Eretz Yisrael so they already can

30
00:01:27,340 --> 00:01:33,439
observe which they should observe one day. And

31
00:01:33,439 --> 00:01:36,400
so a group of people observe one day

32
00:01:36,400 --> 00:01:40,099
so can they are they allowed to board

33
00:01:40,099 --> 00:01:42,131
a plane? So I would think that it's

34
00:01:42,131 --> 00:01:44,260
a terrible idea for them to board a

35
00:01:44,260 --> 00:01:48,459
plane because the second they leave Israeli airspace

36
00:01:48,459 --> 00:01:50,260
they're already in Chutz La'aretz because what's the

37
00:01:50,260 --> 00:01:53,439
whole basis for the for the minority opinion

38
00:01:53,560 --> 00:01:55,400
the Chacham Tzvi and the others that hold

39
00:01:55,400 --> 00:01:59,239
that you observe one day in Eretz Yisrael?

40
00:01:59,379 --> 00:02:02,079
They believe that it's a land-based issue. If

41
00:02:02,079 --> 00:02:03,859
you're in Eretz Yisrael it's one day outside

42
00:02:03,859 --> 00:02:05,299
of Eretz Yisrael two days. So as soon

43
00:02:05,299 --> 00:02:08,020
as you leave Eretz Yisrael pashut that it's

44
00:02:08,020 --> 00:02:14,139
no longer an

45
00:02:14,139 --> 00:02:17,479
ordinary day and now it's Yom Tov Sheni.

46
00:02:17,479 --> 00:02:19,099
So chol becomes kodesh. You can change in

47
00:02:19,099 --> 00:02:20,900
the middle of the day why not? We

48
00:02:20,900 --> 00:02:22,719
know the halacha is determined by where a

49
00:02:22,979 --> 00:02:26,419
person's located. halachically for tefillah for tefillin for

50
00:02:26,419 --> 00:02:28,919
all your halachic obligations wherever you are located

51
00:02:28,919 --> 00:02:30,580
on the plane as well wherever you're located

52
00:02:31,139 --> 00:02:34,740
you have to observe the halacha based on

53
00:02:34,740 --> 00:02:36,623
where you are. You find this in the

54
00:02:36,623 --> 00:02:37,241
Gemara in Shabbat on kuf yod chet amud

55
00:02:37,241 --> 00:02:40,300
bet that says oh it's great to be

56
00:02:40,300 --> 00:02:43,240
someone who starts Shabbat early in Teveria and

57
00:02:43,240 --> 00:02:45,500
late in Tzipori. Tzipori is a higher elevation

58
00:02:45,759 --> 00:02:49,560
Teveria is a much lower elevation about 200

59
00:02:49,560 --> 00:02:53,379
feet below sea level about 200 feet above

60
00:02:53,379 --> 00:02:58,219
sea level in Tzipori. So you're talking about

61
00:02:58,960 --> 00:03:03,280
that based on where the halacha is determined

62
00:03:03,280 --> 00:03:12,960
where you are. Even

63
00:03:12,960 --> 00:03:14,039
if you're a resident of Teveria if you're

64
00:03:16,060 --> 00:03:18,960
located in Tzipori you have to observe Shabbat

65
00:03:18,960 --> 00:03:23,319
according to Tzipori. And if you are a

66
00:03:23,319 --> 00:03:26,300
resident of Tzipori and you're in Teveria you

67
00:03:26,300 --> 00:03:31,919
have to follow the halacha as is in

68
00:03:31,919 --> 00:03:35,199
Teveria. So that's very very clear so wherever

69
00:03:35,199 --> 00:03:39,500
you are located in the plane that's where

70
00:03:39,699 --> 00:03:42,000
that's your location that's your halacha. So if

71
00:03:42,400 --> 00:03:44,500
you once you leave Israeli airspace that's it

72
00:03:44,900 --> 00:03:48,280
you should have the status of it's now

73
00:03:48,379 --> 00:03:50,400
it's Yom Tov Sheni. That means you can't

74
00:03:50,400 --> 00:03:52,232
use the bathrooms on the plane because it's

75
00:03:52,232 --> 00:03:54,780
all you close the doors it's electronic. You

76
00:03:56,520 --> 00:03:58,460
are going west the whole how is how

77
00:03:58,460 --> 00:03:59,240
are you going to be able to handle

78
00:03:59,240 --> 00:04:03,840
that? You have all the obligations of Yom

79
00:04:03,840 --> 00:04:08,099
Tov the Yom Tov meal Hallel Musaf. How

80
00:04:08,099 --> 00:04:09,500
how are you going to do that on

81
00:04:09,500 --> 00:04:10,759
the plane? Okay I guess you could do

82
00:04:10,759 --> 00:04:12,020
that on the plane but more than that

83
00:04:12,080 --> 00:04:13,159
you should not be on a plane on

84
00:04:13,159 --> 00:04:14,860
Yom Tov you should not put yourself in

85
00:04:14,860 --> 00:04:18,860
a situation of being in on a plane

86
00:04:18,860 --> 00:04:21,279
on Yom Tov. There's an obligation obligation of

87
00:04:21,699 --> 00:04:23,100
v'samachta b'chagecha to enjoy the chag. How are

88
00:04:23,100 --> 00:04:25,939
you enjoying the chag? That's a simchat chag

89
00:04:26,060 --> 00:04:28,899
to sit on a plane and even if

90
00:04:28,899 --> 00:04:30,699
you have a comfortable seat you have more

91
00:04:30,699 --> 00:04:35,079
legroom still that's not simchat Yom Tov to

92
00:04:35,079 --> 00:04:39,560
be in a plane like that. That's and

93
00:04:39,560 --> 00:04:41,319
now you'll tell me well you can't change

94
00:04:41,319 --> 00:04:42,480
status in the middle of the day. You

95
00:04:42,480 --> 00:04:46,180
started the day as ben Chutz La'aretz as

96
00:04:46,180 --> 00:04:47,879
observing chol you have to finish the day

97
00:04:47,879 --> 00:04:50,459
as chol. No absolutely not. We find the

98
00:04:50,459 --> 00:04:53,399
Gemara in Yevamot lamed gimmel amud bet that

99
00:04:53,399 --> 00:04:57,500
speaks about someone a katan who reached physical

100
00:04:58,459 --> 00:05:00,879
maturity he higia l'shteis sa'arot. on the middle

101
00:05:00,879 --> 00:05:03,000
of on the middle of Shabbat. That's it.

102
00:05:03,500 --> 00:05:05,899
He is Shabbat full-fledged Shabbat for him as

103
00:05:05,980 --> 00:05:08,519
as a gadol even though it's middle of

104
00:05:08,519 --> 00:05:10,620
Shabbat even though he started Shabbat as that

105
00:05:10,620 --> 00:05:12,399
he's not a gadol now he he changes

106
00:05:12,399 --> 00:05:13,699
status in the middle in the middle of

107
00:05:13,699 --> 00:05:15,379
Shabbat so too on the plane you change

108
00:05:15,519 --> 00:05:18,459
status. Begins a day one day changes changes

109
00:05:18,459 --> 00:05:20,740
in the middle of the day. And and

110
00:05:20,740 --> 00:05:23,579
so therefore all the rabanim that are that

111
00:05:23,579 --> 00:05:26,759
are that I'm aware of will say that

112
00:05:26,759 --> 00:05:29,579
you have that that's it. You change your

113
00:05:29,579 --> 00:05:32,139
status on the mid-flight and therefore you should

114
00:05:32,139 --> 00:05:34,399
not not not not take that flight. I

115
00:05:34,399 --> 00:05:36,540
know Rav Shmuel Karshkaman said that's what the

116
00:05:36,920 --> 00:05:44,100
Sefardic poskim will say. And

117
00:05:44,100 --> 00:05:50,699
and and the Lubavitchers,

118
00:05:50,860 --> 00:05:53,899
Lubavitcher poskim also who they say one day.

119
00:05:54,019 --> 00:05:56,100
No, do not take a plane. Only is

120
00:05:56,100 --> 00:05:58,319
one day only in Eretz Yisrael. As soon

121
00:05:58,319 --> 00:06:02,000
as you leave that's it. So and I

122
00:06:02,000 --> 00:06:05,374
spoke this past week to Rav Schachter and

123
00:06:05,374 --> 00:06:06,220
Rav Willig they think you shouldn't board a

124
00:06:06,220 --> 00:06:09,279
plane. Thinks it's a horrible thing to board

125
00:06:09,420 --> 00:06:13,139
to board the plane and I've heard the

126
00:06:13,139 --> 00:06:16,759
rabanim that that say no you don't that

127
00:06:16,759 --> 00:06:22,399
believe that you don't that there's no obligation

128
00:06:24,120 --> 00:06:26,513
to that that to go into Yom Tov

129
00:06:26,513 --> 00:06:28,500
Sheni on the flight. It's only that when

130
00:06:28,500 --> 00:06:30,879
you land then it becomes Yom Tov Sheni

131
00:06:31,339 --> 00:06:32,959
then you have to stay in the airport

132
00:06:33,819 --> 00:06:35,480
the rest of the chag. I hear there

133
00:06:35,480 --> 00:06:38,279
are rabanim that that have that do say

134
00:06:38,279 --> 00:06:40,439
that. I've heard that. I just wonder what

135
00:06:40,439 --> 00:06:42,800
their raya is. I haven't heard any rayot.

136
00:06:42,939 --> 00:06:45,959
What's the svara? What's their evidence for it?

137
00:06:46,019 --> 00:06:47,639
It just seems to be very very weak.

138
00:06:47,800 --> 00:06:50,139
I don't seem to I don't understand the

139
00:06:50,139 --> 00:06:53,779
basis for it. And but even according to

140
00:06:53,779 --> 00:06:56,879
those opinions let's say you have to stay

141
00:06:56,980 --> 00:06:58,833
once you've arrived that's it. It's Yom Tov

142
00:06:58,833 --> 00:07:01,500
Sheni. You can't go you can't that's it

143
00:07:01,540 --> 00:07:03,160
for you for sure it's Yom Tov Sheni

144
00:07:03,160 --> 00:07:07,000
once you've landed even according to this opinion

145
00:07:07,000 --> 00:07:09,019
that I don't understand. But you have to

146
00:07:09,019 --> 00:07:10,939
still but even according to that you must

147
00:07:10,939 --> 00:07:11,959
stay in the airport. What are you going

148
00:07:11,959 --> 00:07:14,240
to do? You can't take your baggage it's

149
00:07:14,240 --> 00:07:16,379
just going to sit there in the airport

150
00:07:16,379 --> 00:07:18,819
with with all your bags even if you

151
00:07:18,819 --> 00:07:20,379
don't have bags you're just going to sit

152
00:07:20,379 --> 00:07:22,860
in the airport. That's Yom Tov setting yourself

153
00:07:22,860 --> 00:07:24,300
up to be a situation like that on

154
00:07:24,300 --> 00:07:25,600
Yom Tov? What kind of a Yom Tov

155
00:07:25,600 --> 00:07:29,139
is that with all the obligations of Yom

156
00:07:29,139 --> 00:07:33,459
Tov Hallel Musaf with the simchat Yom Tov

157
00:07:33,459 --> 00:07:36,139
with the fruit? That's just just seems to

158
00:07:36,139 --> 00:07:38,980
be a horrible just seems to be a

159
00:07:38,980 --> 00:07:42,360
horrible idea. I know there's is there's the

160
00:07:42,360 --> 00:07:47,800
convenience factor and and pricing maybe better. But

161
00:07:47,800 --> 00:07:50,120
still better spend the time in Eretz Yisrael

162
00:07:50,740 --> 00:07:53,379
and bottom line is I think it's a

163
00:07:53,379 --> 00:07:57,079
horrible horrible idea to board these flights on

164
00:07:57,079 --> 00:08:01,600
the on the second day of Yom Tov.

165
00:08:01,600 --> 00:08:04,439
Eretz Yisrael you're observing one day then for

166
00:08:04,439 --> 00:08:08,899
whatever reason you're observing one day and that's

167
00:08:08,899 --> 00:08:10,800
it you observe you do it properly and

168
00:08:11,279 --> 00:08:15,399
you don't you don't get on a plane

169
00:08:15,399 --> 00:08:17,500
on Yom Tov Sheni even if you're observing

170
00:08:17,500 --> 00:08:19,379
one day in Eretz Yisrael. Wishing everybody a

171
00:08:19,379 --> 00:08:20,920
great week full of bracha and beriut.
