← All source sheets

על החושים

On the Senses

Seeing, hearing, smelling, tasting, touching — and what each one knows

The five senses in Tanakh and its commentators: moments when a sense does the knowing — a smell that identifies, a taste that tests, a touch that deceives.

Isaac's four senses

1 Arnold B. Ehrlich (Mikra Kifushuto, Berlin 1899–1901) Ehrlich on Genesis 27:4

מכל הספור הזה נראה שיצחק היה חושד את יעקב שיבא במרמה לקחת ברכתו של עשו … בדקו בכל ארבעת החושים הנותרים לו. ובשביל הדבר הזה אמר לעשו לעשות לו מטעמים כאשר אהב, והיה עשו יודע לעשותם

From this whole story it appears that Isaac suspected Jacob would come in deceit to take Esau's blessing … and so he tested him with all four senses remaining to him. And for this reason he told Esau to make him delicacies as he loved them — and Esau knew how to make them.

Isaac the detective: the blessing scene as a four-stage forensic examination — touch (27:22), hearing (27:22), taste (27:25), smell (27:27). The delicacies are not hospitality; they are the test — only Esau knows the recipe, so a fraud gives himself away by taste. Ehrlich's point is that the old blind man was suspicious from the first verse. Source: Mikra Kifushuto, vol. 1 (Pentateuch), p. 83.

● The Workshop · weekly

Everything I build, in one email a week.

Torah tools, daf games and AI experiments, with the story behind each one. Sign up and this week’s issue arrives within the hour.