← All source sheets

On Prophets

3 Mordecai Kaplan, Needed Prophets for Our Day, adapted from “The Divinity School Address” by Ralph Waldo Emerson Mordecai Kaplan, Needed Prophets for Our Day, adapted from “The Divinity School Address” by Ralph Waldo Emerson (1942)

But let us not speak of revelations as something long ago given and done. Only by coming to the God in ourselves can we grow forevermore. Let us not say that the age of inspiration is past, that the Bible is closed. Let us learn to believe in the soul of man, and not merely in men departed. Shemtob Ibn Shemtob, 1489 The mere foretelling of future events is the lowest stage of prophecy, and in the eyes of the great Prophets of Israel it was of quite secondary importance. Their aim was to fathom the secrets of holiness; and their striving, by means of admonition and moral suasion, to guide the peoples in the paths which lead mankind to spiritual and political well-being. Benjamin Jowett, The Living Power of the Jewish Prophets The moral feelings of men have been deepened and strengthened, and also softened, and almost created, by the Jewish prophets. In modern times we hardly like to acknowledge the full force of their words, lest they should prove subversive to society. And so we explain them away or spiritualize them, and convert what is figurative into what is literal, and what is literal into what is figurative. And still, after all our interpretation or misinterpretation, whether due to a false theology or an imperfect knowledge of the original language, the force of the words remains, and a light of heavenly truth and love streams from them even now more than 2,500 years after-they were first uttered

4 Hidushei haRamban Hidushei haRamban, Baba Batra 12a

B. Baba Batra 12a What the passage means is this: Even though the prophecy of the prophets has been removed, that is, revelations and visions, the prophecy of the sages, that is, the method of wisdom, has not been taken away. For they know the truth through the holy spirit within their inmost being (be-qirbam). According to the needs of the moment God makes his presence dwell on the pious, even if they are not sages

5 Robert Alter, Exodus Robert Alter, Exodus 15:20

The reason God commands him to circumcise himself (Gen. 17) is that this act of self-perfection will make the spirit of Prophecy more accessible to him (PdRE 29; Tanh. Lech Lecha 20

6 Seforno, Genesis Seforno, Genesis 28:16

ואנכי לא ידעתי. שאלו ידעתי הייתי מכין עצמי לנבואה ולא כן עשיתי

Churchill Every prophet has to come from civilization, but every prophet has to go into the wilderness. He must have a strong impression of a complex society and all that it has to give, and then he must serve periods of isolation and meditation. This is the process by which psychic dynamite is made.”

7 Philo, Special Laws 1.65, translation in F. H. Colson, Philo (Cambridge, Mass. Philo, Special Laws 1.65, translation in F. H. Colson, Philo (Cambridge, Mass., 1937), 5.137

A prophet possessed by God will suddenly appear and give prophetic oracles. Nothing of what he says will be his own, for he that is truly under the control of divine inspiration has no power of apprehension when he speaks,but serves as the channel of the insistent words of Another’s promptings. For prophets are interpreters of God, Who makes full use of the organs of their speech to set forth what He wills. Philo,“Who Is the Heir,”pp.264-65, in Colson, Philo 4.419 When the light of God shines, the human light sets; when the divine light sets, the human dawns and rises. This is what regularly befalls the fellowship of prophets. The mind is evicted at the arrival of the divine Spirit, but when that departs the mind returns to its tenancy. Mortal and immortal may not share the same home

8 Plato, Timaeus 71-72

No man, when he is in his wits, attains prophetic truth and inspiration; but when he receives the inspired word, either his intelligence is enthralledinsleep,orheisdementedbysomedistemperorpossession.Andhe who would understand what he remembers to have been said, whether in a dream or when he is awake, by the prophetic and inspired nature, or would determine by reasonthemeaningoftheapparitionswhichhehasseen,andwhatindications theyaffordtothismanorthat,ofpast,present,orfuturegoodandevil,mustfirst recover his wits. But while he continues demented he cannotjudge ofthe visions which he sees or the words which he utters” (Plato, Dialogues 3.493-94). “SaidR.Joshuathe Priest . . . Even Elihu prophesied without knowing what he was prophesying, as itiswritten,‘Whatmylipsknowtheyhavespokenclearly’[Job33:3;i.e.,mylips know, but Ido not]. R. Efazar in the name ofR. Yose b. Zimra: Even Samuel, the master of the prophets, prophesied and did not know, as it is said, ‘[And Samuel said to the people: . . .] And the Lord sentJeruba'al . . . and Samuel . . .’[i Sam. 12:11]. It does not say ‘and sent me,’ but ‘Samuel,’ for he did not know what he wasprophesying”(seeYalqutSimoni841[adPs.90]andparallels). RobertLowth,LecturesontheSacredPoetryoftheHebrews,trans.George Gregory, 4th ed. (London, 1839)5 PP- I9 4- 95 (lecture 18). It is sufficiently apparent, that the word Nabi was used by the Hebrews in an ambiguous sense, and that it equally denoted a prophet, a poet, or a musician, under the influence of Divine inspiration. For the contrary position, seeJohann Gottfried von Herder, The Spirit ofHebrew Poetry, trans. James Marsh, Burlington, Vt., 1833), 2.50: “The conception [of the prophet] now given, obviously did not include that of a musician and poet. . . . By the term seers, . . . they were clearly distinguished fromminstrels.”

9 Ralbag (Gersonides) Ralbag on I Kings 19:12

וזכר ג"כ כי לא באש השם לסבה שזכרנו וכאילו באר בזה שאלו הרעות שיבאו להם בהדרגה אינם מכוונות מהש"י אך הסתיר פניו מהם ועזבם כמו מטרה לחצי הרעות הנכונות לבא עליהם היה זה כן לפי שהרעו' הבאות על צד הקנאת המוסר לא יועילו להם הלא תראה כי מפני עצירת הטל והמטר שלש שנים לא נכנעו מפני הש"י: והנה אחר האש קול דממה דקה. ר"ל קול נמוך מהש"י כאילו הוא מורכב מהקול והשתיקה

And he mentioned also that God was not in the fire, for the reason we mentioned — as if to explain hereby that these evils which will come upon them in stages are not directed by God, but He hid His face from them and left them as a target for the arrows of the evils ready to come upon them. This was so because evils that come by way of zealous discipline will not help them — do you not see that because of the withholding of dew and rain for three years they did not humble themselves before God? And then, after the fire, a still, small voice — that is, a low voice from God, as if composed of voice and silence.

Ralbag (Gersonides) on I Kings 19:12, the theophany at Horeb. See also 19:11: it is not the way of God to bring evils unless some good will come of them. The voice composed of voice and silence is the true prophecy, after wind, earthquake and fire — the answer to the zeal of Elijah.

10 Rav Moshe Sternbuch Rav Moshe Sternbuch, Ta’am VaDa’at on Genesis 25:19

ועיין במדרש תנחומא כאן דבר פלא, שלאברהם אבינו גופא היה חשד על דברי הליצנים ... ותמוה היאך חשש אברהם לדברי המתלוצצים, והלוא נביא היה וידע שאבימלך לא נגע בה לרעה.

He notes that the Tanchuma attributes suspicion to Abraham himself, then asks how Abraham could have been concerned when, as a prophet, he knew Abimelech had not touched Sarah. His answer is that Abraham feared Sarah might have had thoughts about Abimelech around the time of conception, which could affect the child’s appearance. God made Isaac resemble Abraham, providing testimony “that she had not, God forbid, entertained thoughts of Abimelech.”

Verified against the printed page (HebrewBooks req 20033, p. 113 — first comment on Toldot, headed אברהם הוליד את יצחק (כ״ה יט)). The ellipsis in the quoted passage omits this clause from the page: והקב״ה אמר למלאך שיעשה כל איקונין שלו כדמות אביו, ע״ש. The answer paragraph on the same page: ונראה שאברהם חשש דכיון ששרה נתעברה סמוך ליציאתה מבית אבימלך, אולי הרהרה אי-אילו הרהורים באבימלך, והדבר משפיע על צורת הולד, לכך עשה הקב״ה כל איקונין שלו כדמות אביו, והיה בזה עדות שלא הרהרה ח״ו באבימלך. Source: https://hebrewbooks.org/pdfpager.aspx?req=20033&pgnum=113

● The Workshop · weekly

Everything I build, in one email a week.

Torah tools, daf games and AI experiments, with the story behind each one. Sign up and this week’s issue arrives within the hour.