← All source sheets

עַל הַנִּשּׂוּאִין

On Marriage

What holds a marriage together — and how it comes apart?

A growing sheet on marriage in Jewish thought: its formation, its obligations, and the laws of divorce.

Minchat Asher — Divorce among Noahides

1 Rav Asher Weiss Minchat Asher (Rav Asher Weiss)

כיון שנצטוה (בראשית ב' כ"ד) "ודבק באשתו", אבל היא שלא נצטותה בכך יכולה לגרשו, ושיטה זו מחודשת ביותר, ולפיו האשה יכולה לגרש את בעלה בע"כ אבל הוא אינו יכול לגרשה. ונמצא ד' מחלוקות בדבר, לשיטת רבינו דוד אין גרושין בב"נ כלל, לשיטת הרמב"ם והר"ן כל אחד יכול לגרש שכנגדו, הבעל יכול לשלוח את אשתו מביתו, והיא יכולה לצאת בע"כ ובשני האופנים פקע קשר האישות שביניהם, לשיטת ר' חנין בשם ר' יוחנן עפ"י המתנות כהונה יש להם גירושין רק בהסכמת שניהם הבעל ואשתו, ולשיטת ר' יוחנן עצמו האשה יכולה לגרש את בעלה אבל אין הבעל יכול לגרש את אשתו.

Since he was commanded (Genesis 2:24), "and he shall cleave to his wife" — but she, who was not commanded in this, can divorce him. This approach is exceedingly novel: according to it, the wife can divorce her husband against his will, but he cannot divorce her. Thus we find four disputes on the matter: according to Rabbeinu David there is no divorce at all among Noahides; according to the Rambam and the Ran, each can divorce the other — the husband can send his wife out of his home, and she can leave against his will, and in both cases the marriage bond between them is dissolved; according to R' Chanin in the name of R' Yochanan, following the Matnat Kehuna, they have divorce only by the mutual consent of both, husband and wife; and according to R' Yochanan himself, the wife can divorce her husband, but the husband cannot divorce his wife.

Four medieval positions on whether Noahides can divorce — from "no divorce at all" (Rabbeinu David) to "only the wife can divorce" (R' Yochanan), the last grounded in a close reading of Genesis 2:24: the command "and he shall cleave to his wife" binds the husband, leaving the wife free to walk away.

● The Workshop · weekly

Everything I build, in one email a week.

Torah tools, daf games and AI experiments, with the story behind each one. Sign up and this week’s issue arrives within the hour.