← All source sheets

On Left-Handedness

1 Torah Leviticus 21:19

א֣וֹ אִ֔ישׁ אֲשֶׁר־יִהְיֶ֥ה ב֖וֹ שֶׁ֣בֶר רָ֑גֶל א֖וֹ שֶׁ֥בֶר יָֽד׃

no man who has a broken leg or a broken arm;

The anchor verse of Bekhorot 45's catalogue of blemishes: a broken foot or a broken hand disqualifies the priest from service. The daf's question is which bodies the law will accept — and on what terms. (The English continues verse 18's 'For no man who has a defect shall draw near.')

2 Torah Leviticus 23:40

וּלְקַחְתֶּ֨ם לָכֶ֜ם בַּיּ֣וֹם הָרִאשׁ֗וֹן פְּרִ֨י עֵ֤ץ הָדָר֙ כַּפֹּ֣ת תְּמָרִ֔ים וַעֲנַ֥ף עֵץ־עָבֹ֖ת וְעַרְבֵי־נָ֑חַל וּשְׂמַחְתֶּ֗ם לִפְנֵ֛י יְהֹוָ֥ה אֱלֹהֵיכֶ֖ם שִׁבְעַ֥ת יָמִֽים׃

On the first day you shall take the product of hadar trees, branches of palm trees, boughs of leafy trees, and willows of the brook, and you shall rejoice before the ETERNAL your God seven days.

The verse the Maharam's answer turns on: the Torah says only 'take' (ולקחתם), not 'with the right hand'. The Maharam of Rothenburg, answering a question from Regensburg (his responsa, Lemberg edition), ruled that a left-handed man takes the lulav in his left hand, which counts for him as the right hand of others: what matters is a significant taking (נטילה חשובה), not the anatomical right — it is not 'taking in an awkward manner'. (See position 9 for the responsum itself: Teshuvot Maharam, Lemberg Edition, siman 419.)

3 Mishnah Bekhorot 45a

יָתֵר בְּיָדָיו וּבְרַגְלָיו, שֵׁשׁ וָשֵׁשׁ — עֶשְׂרִים וְאַרְבַּע, רַבִּי יְהוּדָה מַכְשִׁיר וַחֲכָמִים פּוֹסְלִין. הַשּׁוֹלֵט בִּשְׁתֵּי יָדָיו — רַבִּי פּוֹסֵל וַחֲכָמִים מַכְשִׁירִין.

If there was an extra appendage on his hands and on his feet, six on each for a total of twenty-four, Rabbi Yehuda deems the priest fit and the Rabbis deem him disqualified. With regard to one who is ambidextrous and has control of both of his hands, Rabbi Yehuda HaNasi deems the priest disqualified, as his halakhic status is like that of one who is left-handed, and the Rabbis deem him fit.

The daf's own dispute: the man with extra fingers and toes — six and six, twenty-four in all — Rabbi Yehuda permits, the Sages disqualify; and the man who 'rules with both hands' (שולט בשתי ידיו), Rabbi disqualifies, the Sages permit. Even the man who can use his right hand is disputed, because the question is whether his left counts as a right at all.

4 Talmud Shabbat 103a

גְּמָ׳ בִּשְׁלָמָא אַיָּמִין לִיחַיַּיב מִשּׁוּם דְּדֶרֶךְ כְּתִיבָה בְּכָךְ, אֶלָּא אַשְּׂמֹאל אַמַּאי? הָא אֵין דֶּרֶךְ כְּתִיבָה בְּכָךְ! אָמַר רַבִּי יִרְמְיָה: בְּאִטֵּר יָד שָׁנוּ. וְתֶהֱוֵי שְׂמֹאל דִּידֵיהּ כְּיָמִין דְּכוּלֵּי עָלְמָא, וְאַשְּׂמֹאל לִיחַיַּיב, אַיָּמִין לָא לִיחַיַּיב! אֶלָּא אָמַר אַבָּיֵי: בְּשׁוֹלֵט בִּשְׁתֵּי יָדָיו.

GEMARA: The Gemara questions the beginning of the mishna: Granted, for writing with the right hand let one be liable, as that is the typical manner of writing. However, for writing with the left hand, why is one liable? That is not the typical manner of writing. Rabbi Yirmeya said: When the mishna taught that one who writes with his left hand is liable, they taught it with regard to one who is left-handed. The Gemara asks: And if so, let his left hand have the same legal status as everyone’s right hand; for writing with his left hand, let him be liable, for writing with his right hand, let him not be liable. Rather, Abaye said: This mishna refers to an ambidextrous person, who is liable for writing with either hand.

The principle is stated and then tested: a left-handed man's left should count as everyone else's right (שמאל דידיה כימין דכולי עלמא) — but the Gemara will not let it stand unqualified, and Abaye limits the case to one who rules with both hands.

5 Talmud (Rava) Sukkah 37b

וְאָמַר רַבָּה: לוּלָב — בְּיָמִין, וְאֶתְרוֹג — בִּשְׂמֹאל. מַאי טַעְמָא? הָנֵי תְּלָתָא מִצְוֹת, וְהַאי חֲדָא מִצְוָה. אֲמַר לֵיהּ רַבִּי יִרְמְיָה לְרַבִּי זְרִיקָא: מַאי טַעַם לָא מְבָרְכִינַן אֶלָּא ״עַל נְטִילַת לוּלָב״ — הוֹאִיל וְגָבוֹהַּ מִכּוּלָּן. וְלַגְבְּהֵיהּ לְאֶתְרוֹג וּלְבָרֵיךְ! אֲמַר לֵיהּ: הוֹאִיל וּבְמִינוֹ גָּבוֹהַּ מִכּוּלָּן.

§ And Rabba said: One takes the lulav bound with the other two species in the right hand and the etrog in the left. The Gemara explains: What is the reason for that arrangement? These species constitute three mitzvot, and this etrog is only one mitzva. One accords deference to the greater number of mitzvot by taking the three species in the right hand. Rabbi Yirmeya said to Rabbi Zerika: What is the reason that we recite the blessing only with the formula: About taking the lulav, with no mention of the other species? Rabbi Zerika said to him: Since it is highest of them all and the most conspicuous, the other species are subsumed under it. Rabbi Yirmeya asks: And if that is the only reason, let him lift the etrog higher than the lulav and recite the blessing mentioning it. Rabbi Zerika said to him that he meant: Since the tree of its species is the tallest of them all, it is the most prominent, and therefore it is appropriate for the formula of the blessing to emphasize the lulav.

The source of the right-hand rule for the lulav: three mitzvot in the right hand, one in the left. The hand is chosen for prominence, not named by the verse — which is what leaves room for the Maharam's answer.

6 Talmud (Resh Lakish) Menachot 10a

אָמַר רַבָּה בַּר בַּר חָנָה, אָמַר רַבִּי שִׁמְעוֹן בֶּן לָקִישׁ: כׇּל מָקוֹם שֶׁנֶּאֶמְרָה אֶצְבַּע וּכְהוּנָּה, אֵינָהּ אֶלָּא יָמִין.

§ Rabba bar bar Ḥana says that Rabbi Shimon ben Lakish says: Any place in the Torah in which it is stated that an action is performed with a finger or by the priesthood, i.e., that one uses his finger to perform the action or that a priest performs it, this teaches that it is performed only with the right hand.

The other pole: where the Torah says 'finger' and 'priesthood' — the metzora's purification, the priest's service — only the right hand counts. Here the hand is named, and no substitution is possible.

7 Tanakh II Samuel 21:20

וַתְּהִי־ע֥וֹד מִלְחָמָ֖ה בְּגַ֑ת וַיְהִ֣י ׀ אִ֣ישׁ (מדין) [מָד֗וֹן] וְאֶצְבְּעֹ֣ת יָדָיו֩ וְאֶצְבְּעֹ֨ת רַגְלָ֜יו שֵׁ֣שׁ וָשֵׁ֗שׁ עֶשְׂרִ֤ים וְאַרְבַּע֙ מִסְפָּ֔ר וְגַם־ה֖וּא יֻלַּ֥ד לְהָרָפָֽה׃

Once again there was fighting, at Gath. There was a giant of a man who had six fingers on each hand and six toes on each foot, twenty-four in all; he too was descended from the Raphah.

The daf's extra-finger blemish embodied: the giant of Gath with six fingers on each hand and six toes on each foot, twenty-four in all — the same count the Mishnah on Bekhorot 45a rules on.

8 Shulchan Arukh Shulchan Arukh, Orach Chaim 651:3

אטר נוטל לולב בימין כל אדם ואתרוג בשמאל כל אדם דבתר ימין ושמאל דעלמא אזלינן ולא בתר ימין ושמאל דידיה: הגה וי"א דאזלינן בתר ימין דידיה ויש ליטול הלולב בימין דידיה ואתרוג בשמאל דידיה [הרא"ש ורבי' ירוחם ומהרי"ו] וכן נהגו וכן עיקר ואם היפך יצא [מהרי"ל ומנהגים] ושולט בב' ידיו נוטל הלולב בימין ואתרוג בשמאל ככל אדם [כל בו]:

A leftie holds the lulav in their right hand and the etrog in their left, following the strong and weak hands of everybody else and not their strong and weak hands. Rema: And some say that we go according to their dominant hand and the lulav should be held in their "right" hand, which is their left hand (Ros"h, Rabbeinu Yerucham, and Mahari"v), and this is the practice and the law. If one switched them, he has fulfilled his obligation (Mahari"l and Minhagim). One who is ambidextrous should hold the lulav in their right and the etrog in their left hand, like everybody else (Kol Bo).

The codified dispute: the Mechaber follows the world's right and left — a left-handed man takes the lulav in his anatomical right hand; the Rama follows the lefty's own right — lulav in his left, etrog in his right (Rosh, Rabbeinu Yerucham, Mahari Weil), and that is the Ashkenazic practice. The ambidextrous person takes the lulav in the right like everyone (Kol Bo). If he reversed them, he has still fulfilled the obligation.

9 Maharam of Rothenburg Teshuvot Maharam, Lemberg Edition 419

מעשה בריגנשפורק ששאלו את רבותינו על איטר יד ימינו אם יש לו ליטול לולב בשמאלו שהיא חשובה לי' כימין דעלמא כדאמר בשבת (דף ק"ג.) הכוחב בין בימינו בין בשמאלו וליחשב שמאל דידי' כימין דעלמא ונר' דהיינו טעמא דלא כתב יד ימין אלא סתמא כיון דבעינן מלאכה חשיבה מה לי שמאל מ"ל ימין וכן נראה דבהא אינו אלא משום נטילה חשובהסצ"ל ולא שנוטל כלאחר יד והרי הוא כו'. שנוטל כלאחר יד הרי הוא נוטל בימין כלאחר יד אבל היכא דהקפידה תורה על ימין גבי מצורע ועבודה בכהן (מנחות ד' י'.) התם דוקא בימין ואפי' שולט בשתי ידיו פלוגתא דר' וחכמים (בכורות דף מ"ה.) אם הוא כשר לעבודה אפילו בימין והכא אינו אלא מצוה בעלמא דבדיעבד לעולם כשר

An incident in Regensburg: they asked our rabbis about a left-handed man, whether he may take the lulav in his left, which is important to him like the right of the world, as it says in Shabbat (103a) — one who writes, whether with his right or his left — and let his left count as the right of the world. And it seems that this is the reason [the Torah] did not write ‘right hand’ but just [take]: since we require a significant act, what difference whether left or right? And so it seems that this is only because of a significant taking, and not that he takes in an awkward manner. But where the Torah insisted on the right — regarding the metzora and the priest’s service (Menachot 10a) — there specifically the right, and even one who rules with both hands is disputed by Rabbi and the Sages (Bekhorot 45a) whether he is fit for service even with his right. But here it is only a mitzvah in the general sense, which after the fact is always valid.

Maharam of Rothenburg, Teshuvot Maharam (Lemberg edition), siman 419 — the question came from Regensburg, opening ‘an incident in Regensburg’ (מעשה בריגנשפורק). The citation was in the Nov 2, 2026 Daily Reader’s build data (Jev linked source #8 for Bekhorot 45), though the printed prose did not give the siman. Sefaria’s text reads הכוחב where the sense demands הכותב, one who writes — evidently a misprint, kept here as printed. The responsum continues with further proofs (Sukkah 42a, the etrog, Rava, and tefillin from R. Natan, Menachot 37a); the excerpt above is the ruling and its reasoning.

● The Workshop · weekly

Everything I build, in one email a week.

Torah tools, daf games and AI experiments, with the story behind each one. Sign up and this week’s issue arrives within the hour.