← All source sheets

On Judging People Favourably

1 Pirkei Avot Pirkei Avot, 1:6

יְהֹוׁשֻעַ ּבֶן ּפְרַחְיָה וְנִּתַאי הַָארְּבֵלִי קִּבְלּו מֵהֶם. יְהֹוׁשֻעַ ּבֶן ּפְרַחְיָה אֹומֵר, עֲׂשֵה לְָך רַב, ּוקְנֵה לְָך חָבֵר וֶהֱוֵי דָן אֶת ּכָל :הָָאדָם לְכַף זְכּות גם במה שאמרנו שכל אדם חיב לדון חברו לכף זכות, שהוא בכלל המצוה, יהיה סבה להיות בין אנשים שלום ורעות, ונמצא שעקר כל כונת המצוה להועיל בישוב בני אדם עם ישר הדין ולתת ביניהם שלום עם סלוק החשד .איש באיש .דבר אחר: "בצדק תשפט עמיתך" הוי דן את כל האדם לכף זכות

Joshua ben Perahiah and Nittai the Arbelite received [the oral tradition] from them. Joshua ben Perahiah used to say: appoint for thyself a teacher, and acquire for thyself a companion and judge all men with the scale weighted in his favor. Sefer HaChinuch #235 Sifra, Kedoshim 4

2 Vayikra Leviticus 19:15

ֹלא־תַעֲׂשּ֥ו עָ֙וֶל֙ ּבַּמִׁשְּפָ֔ט ֹלא־תִּׂשָ֣א פְנֵי־דָ֔ל וְֹל֥א תֶהְּדַ֖ר ּפְנֵ֣י גָדֹ֑ול ּבְצֶ֖דֶק ּתִׁשְּפֹ֥ט עֲמִיתֶָֽך׃

You shall not render an unfair decision: do not favor the poor or show deference to the rich; judge your kinsman fairly

3 Shevuot Shevuot 30a

ת"ר (ויקרא יט, טו) בצדק תשפוט עמיתך שלא יהא אחד יושב ואחד עומד אחד מדבר כל צרכו ואחד אומר לו קצר דבריך ד"א בצדק תשפוט עמיתך הוי דן את חבירך לכף זכות הוי דן את חבירך לכף זכות. ואל תכריעהו לכף חובה. הוי שש בחלקך. והתנאה במיעוטך. ואל תשנא את :המוכיחך. יהי חלקך מבורך לעולם. עין טובה ונפש שביעה ,וֶהֱוֵי דָן אֶת כָל הָָאדָם לְכַף זְכּות. בשעה שעל האדם לקבוע את עמדתו כלפי זולתו וכלפי התנהגותו ראוי שישקול את כלל הנתונים אלה לעומת אלה כבמאזניים (ראו להלן ב, יב), את חובותיו של האדם מכאן ואת זכויותיו .מכאן, וישתדל להטות את כף הזכות כדי שזו תכריע ...והוי דן את כל האדם לכף זכות. ענינו כשיהיה אדם שלא תדע בו אם צדיק הוא אם רשע ותראהו שיעשה מעשה או יאמר דבר שאם תפרשהו על דרך אחת יהיה טוב ואם תפרשהו על דרך אחרת יהיה רע קח אותו על ...הטוב ולא תחשוב בו רע וֶהֱוֵי דָן אֶת ּכָל הָָאדָם לְכַף זְכּות. ּכְׁשֶהַּדָבָר ּבְכַף מֹאזְנַיִם וְאֵין לֹו הֶכְרֵעַ לְכָאן ּולְכָאן, ּכְגֹון ָאדָם ׁשֶאֵין ָאנּו יֹודְעִים מִּמַעֲׂשָיו אִם צַּדִיק אִם רָׁשָע וְעָׂשָה מַעֲׂשֶה ׁשֶאֶפְׁשָר לְדּונֹו לִזְכּות וְאֶפְׁשָר לְדּונֹו לְחֹובָה, מִּדַת חֲסִידּות הִיא לְדּונֹו לְכַף ,).זְכּות. אֲבָל ָאדָם ׁשֶהֻחְזַק ּבְרָׁשָע, מֻּתָר לְדּונֹו לְחֹובָה, ׁשֶֹּלא ָאמְרּו אֶּלָא הַחֹוׁשֵד ּבִכְׁשֵרִים לֹוקֶה ּבְגּופֹו (שבת צז :מִּכְלָל ׁשֶהַחֹוׁשֵד ּבִרְׁשָעִים אֵינֹו לֹוקֶה והוי דן את כל האדם לכף זכות :ומכ"ש לרבך וחבירך, שכשלא תדונם לכף זכות לא תרוויח מהם כלום

The Sages taught: The verse states: “But in righteousness shall you judge your colleague” (Leviticus 19:15), from which it is derived: The court must ensure that there will not be a situation where one litigant is sitting and one litigant is standing, or a situation where one litigant says everything that he needs to say to present his case and one litigant, the judge says to him: Curtail your statement. Alternatively, it is derived from the verse: “But in righteousness shall you judge your colleague,” that you should judge another favorably, and seek to find justification for his actions, even if when interpreted differently his actions could be judged unfavorably. Tractate Derekh Eretz Zuta 3:2 Judge your fellow in the scale of merit and do not turn the scale against him. Rejoice in your lot and enjoy the little you have. Hate not him who reproves you. Your lot will always be blessed if you possess a bountiful eye and a contented soul. Avigdor Shinan , English Explanation of Mishnah Judging every person with favor is perhaps some of the sagest advice the mishnah can give in teaching a person to succeed in society. One who is constantly skeptical of others’ actions and motives will certainly not be able to have the friends or teachers mentioned in the previous two clauses of the mishnah. We saw this ideal in Mishnah Sanhedrin when the Rabbis actually legislated that a court is obligated to search for means to exonerate the accused. Rambam Its subject is when there is a person whom you do not about him if he is righteous or if he is wicked and you see him doing an act or saying something and if you interpret it one way it will be good and if you interpret in another way it will be bad - [in this case,] take it to the good and do not think bad about it. But if the man is known to be famously righteous and of good deeds; and an action of his is seen that all of its aspects indicate that it is a bad deed and a person can only determine it to be good with great stretching and a distant possibility, it is fit that you take it that it is good, since there is some aspect of a possibility that it is good. And so [too] when it is an evildoer and his deeds are famous, and afterwords we see him that he does a deed, all of the indications about which are that it is good but there is an aspect of a distant possibility that it is bad; it is fit to guard oneself from him and not to believe that it is good, since there is a possibility for the bad. Bartenura "and judge every person as meritorious": when the matter is hanging in the balance and there is no way to decide it in this way or that way. For example, a man from whose actions we do not know if he is righteous or wicked, who preforms an act that is possible to judge favorably and possible to judge unfavorably, it is pious to judge him favorably. Rabbi Israel Lipschitz, Yachin We can extrapolate to this to the case of your friend and teacher from an argumentum a fortiori, since if one does not judge them favorably, then they will not gain from them at all

4 Shabbat Shabbat 97a

ָאמַר רֵיׁש לָקִיׁש הַחֹוׁשֵד ּבִכְׁשֵרִים לֹוקֶה ּבְגּופֹו,, ּדִכְתִיב: ״וְהֵן ֹלא יַאֲמִינּו לִי וְגֹו׳״ וְגַלְיָא קַּמֵי קּודְׁשָא ּבְרִיְך הּוא .ּדִמְהֵימְנִי יִׂשְרָאֵל. ָאמַר לֹו: הֵן מַאֲמִינִים ּבְנֵי מַאֲמִינִים, וְאַּתָה אֵין סֹופְָך לְהַאֲמִין

On the topic of Miriam’s leprosy, the Gemara cites that which Reish Lakish said: One who suspects the innocent of indiscretion is afflicted in his body, as it is written: “And Moses answered and said: But they will not believe me and will not hearken to my voice, for they will say, God did not appear to you” (Exodus 4:1), and it is revealed before the Holy One, Blessed be He, that the Jewish people would believe. The Holy One, Blessed be He, said to Moses: They are believers, the children of believers; and ultimately, you will not believe

5 Shabbat Shabbat 127b

ּתָנּו רַּבָנַן: הַּדָן חֲבֵירֹו לְכַף זְכּות ּדָנִין אֹותֹו לִזְכּות

The Sages taught in a baraita: One who judges another favorably is himself judged favorably

● The Workshop · weekly

Everything I build, in one email a week.

Torah tools, daf games and AI experiments, with the story behind each one. Sign up and this week’s issue arrives within the hour.