← All source sheets

ענווה

On Humility

humility in Jewish thought

Humility — ענווה — in Jewish thought: the scholar who re-learns from scratch, the posek who says “I don’t know,” the teshuva that retracts without rewriting history. Seeded with Rav Asher Weiss on the aging posek who cites himself.

1 Rav Asher Weiss Rav Asher Weiss, Safek Berachos Lehakel (TorahAnytime 458203)

Many times a posek, in his elderly years, always relies on כבר כתבתי — “I already wrote it.” And his main source, on which he bases his פסקים, is himself. And I don't want that to happen to me. So from time to time I say: נחזור ונשנה פרק זה — let's go back and learn this chapter again. And my son Alor Benesh, who was my right hand — from time to time I say: we need to revisit the סוגיא, start from aleph-beis. Maybe we're mistaken. People make mistakes. Maybe we got it wrong. So from time to time, just the fundamental סוגיות, I say: we need to start this again and learn it again. In חלק ד׳ there's a תשובה in which I retracted what I wrote in חלק א׳. And I didn't change what I wrote in חלק א׳, because it's not the right thing to do.

On the aging posek who cites himself as his own primary source — כבר כתבתי as a psak. Rav Asher's counter-practice: periodically relearning fundamental sugyos from scratch with his son, and publicly retracting in a later volume (Minchat Asher) without silently rewriting the earlier one. Lecture: Safek Berachos Lehakel, TorahAnytime 458203 @ 00:03:05. Listen: https://yutorah-rss.netlify.app/transcripts/#458203@00:03:05

2 Rav Asher Weiss Rav Asher Weiss, Safek Berachos Lehakel (TorahAnytime 458203)

שתי המילים החשובות ביותר שמורה הוראה צריך לדעת לומר הן אינני יודע. ומי שלא יכול לומר את שתי המילים האלה, לא יכול להיות מורה הוראה. שיחפש עבודה אחרת.

The two most important words that a מורה הוראה needs to be able to say are אינני יודע — I don't know. And if you can't say those two words, you can't be a מורה הוראה. Look for another job.

The humility of the posek: admitting ignorance as a professional requirement, not a failing. Pairs with the sheet's first source — the same shiur's warning against the aging posek who cites כבר כתבתי as his own authority. Lecture: Safek Berachos Lehakel, TorahAnytime 458203 @ 00:04:06. Listen: https://yutorah-rss.netlify.app/transcripts/#458203@00:04:06

● The Workshop · weekly

Everything I build, in one email a week.

Torah tools, daf games and AI experiments, with the story behind each one. Sign up and this week’s issue arrives within the hour.