← All source sheets

On Holiness

1 R. Joseph B. Soloveitchik, Family Redeemed, Marriage, p. R. Joseph B. Soloveitchik, Family Redeemed, Marriage, p. 64

Judaism has always maintained that holiness is not something objective inherent in an object, prevailing independently of the way this particular sacred object is treated. We denied the idea that there is sanctity per se, a metaphysical endowment which persists irrespective of man's relationship to the object. Such an approach to the idea of the sacred would border on fetishism and primitive taboos. Sanctity is born out of man's actions and experiences and is determined by the latter. The very instant man adopts a coarse attitude towards the hallowed object - the moment of sacredness is eliminated. Sanctity expresses itself not in the formal quality of the object or institution but in a relationship between the latter and man. It is an experience rather than an endowment. If something is not experienced as sacred, the object or the institution forfeits its uniqueness and numinous character

3 R. Joseph B. Soloveitchik, Divrei Hashkafa, p. R. Joseph B. Soloveitchik, Divrei Hashkafa, p. 117

Holiness is not a supernatural designation that descends from heaven to earth, becoming attached to a certain object. Things do not become sanctified of their own accord. Would things receive automatic sanctification, Judaism would turn into a magical cult, God forbid. Holiness is a human creation. It is through human innovation that holiness becomes applied to the external world. Holiness gives expression to a spiritual stance of man in set places and times; it focuses exclusively upon his psychic [=spiritual] reaction to special cognitions

4 Elizabeth Browning, Aurora Leigh (as quoted in Dennis Prager, The Rationalist Bible: Exodus on Exodus Elizabeth Browning, Aurora Leigh (as quoted in Dennis Prager, The Rationalist Bible: Exodus on Exodus 3:3)

Earth's crammed with heaven, And every common bush afire with God, But only he who sees takes off his shoes... Jacob Milgrom, Numbers Holiness . . . is not innate. The source of holiness is assigned to God alone. Holiness is the extension of his nature; it is the agency of his will. If certain things are termed holy . . . they are so by virtue of divine dispensation. Moreover, this designation is always subject to recall. Thus the Bible exorcises the demoniac from nature; it makes all supernatural force coextensive with God

5 R. Norman Lamm R. Norman Lamm, Words - Scarce and Sacred (1960)

Yeshayahu Leibowitz, Judaism, human values, and the Jewish state, p. 121 Eliezer Berkovitz, Faith After the Holocaust, p. 59 Sources: The Meaning of Holiness in Judaism, David S. Shapiro, Tradition Holiness: A Command to Imitatio Dei, Warren Zev Harvey, Tradition

● The Workshop · weekly

Everything I build, in one email a week.

Torah tools, daf games and AI experiments, with the story behind each one. Sign up and this week’s issue arrives within the hour.