R. Shai Held, Heart of Torah, p. 63 It is one thing to be grateful when everything is wonderful, when all our dreams have been fulfilled and all our hungers sated. But it is quite another to be grateful when life is complicated, when some of our most cherished dreams have remained painfully unrealized, when some of our yearnings are so intense that they threaten to burn right through us. Leah is the first person to feel and express gratitude even and especially amid profound sorrow and enduring disappointment. Louis Feldman, JOSEPHUS' PORTRAIT OF JOSEPH, p. 413 It has been appropriately remarked by Rabbi Gedalia Dov Schwartz, author of “Divrei Regesh,” that Jews of America ought to be grateful to the Pilgrims for having celebrated the first Thanksgiving with the turkey, a clean bird, instead of using for their festive occasion an unclean animal or fowl which would have caused so many of our brethren to violate Kashruth. R. Shai Held, Heart of Torah, p. 129-130 (Shemot) Commenting on Pharaoh’s purported ignorance of Joseph, a midrash asks, “But how can this be, for to this very day, the Egyptians know the kindness Joseph did for them?!” Rather, the midrash answers, “Pharaoh knew Joseph but did not pay him adequate attention, and was ungrateful to him. And in the end, he was ungrateful to God as well, as it says, ‘I do not know the Lord.’ From this we learn,” the midrash adds, “that ingratitude is closely related to rejection of God” (Midrash Ha-Gadol to Exod. 1:8).10 When the Torah tells us that Pharaoh did not “know” Joseph, in other words, it means to suggest not that Pharaoh was unacquainted with Joseph, but rather that he did not acknowledge Joseph and the great debt that Egypt as a whole, and Pharaoh in particular, owed him. . . . If we are ungrateful, if we don’t acknowledge the reality of just how much has been given to us rather than made or achieved by us, we will actually be incapable of worshipping anything but ourselves. It is not surprising, then, that the prophet Ezekiel imagines Pharaoh insolently declaring, “The Nile is mine; I made it for myself ” (Ezek. 29:3). R. Shai Held, The Heart of Torah, p. 16-18 (Tsav) I’d like to propose another (perhaps complementary) way of thinking about why the thankful person needs to invite others to share in his or her meal: The nature of gratitude is such that it is inherently outward looking. ... The simple requirement that there not be any le+overs from the thanksgiving o!ering thus teaches us a fundamental theological and spiritual lesson. We are not meant to rest content with being recipients of God’s gifts but are asked to becoming givers ourselves. God’s gifts are meant to )ow through us and not merely to us. Studies suggest that gratitude can help you sleep, eat, and feel better, and that the simple act of writing down three things you’re thankful for each day can improve your health. But while it's easy to acknowledge the advantages, we don’t always take the time to build the habit, especially when we’re experiencing negative emotions. To help you take that step, consider this your extra encouragement to begin regularly practicing gratitude. If you get stuck, here are 492 things to be grateful for, including the warm morning sunshine, the kindness of a stranger, and the breath in our lungs. How Gratitude Changes You and Your Brain https://greatergood.berkeley.edu/article/item/how_gratitude_changes_you_and_your_brain