A mapping project · Version 2 · 8 November 2026
The blessing on seeing a great Torah scholar — Baruch Atah Hashem Elokeinu Melech HaOlam, shechalak mechochmato lire’av, “who apportioned of His wisdom to those who fear Him” (Berakhot 58a; Shulchan Arukh, Orach Chaim 224:6) — is a dated, located, face-to-face encounter between two named rabbis. Each attested saying is therefore a data point: who recognised whom, where, when, and across what boundary.
ברוך אתה ה׳ אלקינו מלך העולם, שחלק מחכמתו ליראיו
This is a study, not a psak. Where the poskim disagree, the disagreement is stated, not resolved. Nothing here was invented: every row carries its source and a confidence rating, and widely repeated stories without a traceable source are marked anecdotal.
Each arrow runs from the sayer to the rabbi blessed upon. Click a name to highlight its blessings; click again to clear. Use the era buttons to filter the graph and the register below.
Click a rabbi’s name in the graph to see their blessings here.
26 of the 37 sayings have a known encounter place. Each marker is a place; the number is how many blessings happened there. Click a marker for the sayings at that place. The era buttons above filter the map as well as the network and the register.
Not on the map — place unknown: A4, A5, A9, A19, V03, V04, V09, V10, V11, V12, V15 (V03–V04: United States, city unknown). Babylonia (A1/A1b) is plotted approximately, in the Baghdad area. Places with several blessings: Jerusalem (9), Bnei Brak (4), Tiberias (3), Babylonia (2).
In-degree among the 37 sayings only. Designations and refusals are not counted here. Click a number to expand who blessed on that rabbi.
| Recipient | Community | Sayings |
|---|---|---|
| Ovadia Yosef | Sephardi | |
| ||
| Chazon Ish — Avraham Yeshaya Karelitz | Ashkenazi-Litvish | |
| ||
| Yosef Shalom Elyashiv | Ashkenazi-Litvish | |
| ||
| Chafetz Chaim — Yisrael Meir HaKohen | Ashkenazi-Litvish | |
| ||
| Dov Kook | Ashkenazi-Litvish | |
| ||
| Gryz of Brisk — Yosef Dov HaLevi Soloveitchik | Ashkenazi-Litvish | |
| ||
| Rav Chanina son of Rav Ika | Amora | |
| ||
| Aderet — Eliyahu David Rabinowitz Teomim | Ashkenazi-Litvish | |
| ||
| Aharon Kotler | Ashkenazi-Litvish | |
| ||
| Avraham Shapira | Dati Leumi | |
| ||
| Chaim Kanievsky | Ashkenazi-Litvish | |
| ||
| Dov Berish Weidenfeld (Tchebiner Rav) | Ashkenazi-Litvish | |
| ||
| Dovid Friedman of Karlin | Hasidic | |
| ||
| Elazar Menachem Shach | Ashkenazi-Litvish | |
| ||
| Elchanan Wasserman | Ashkenazi-Litvish | |
| ||
| Ephraim Greenblatt | Modern Orthodox | |
| ||
| Isser Zalman Meltzer | Ashkenazi-Litvish | |
| ||
| Meir Simcha HaKohen of Dvinsk | Ashkenazi-Litvish | |
| ||
| Mordechai Eliyahu | Sephardi | |
| ||
| Moshe Feinstein | Ashkenazi-Litvish | |
| ||
| Moshe Mordechai Epstein | Ashkenazi-Litvish | |
| ||
| Moshe Mordechai Karp | Ashkenazi-Litvish | |
| ||
| Moshe Sternbuch | Ashkenazi-Litvish | |
| ||
| Rogatchover Gaon — Yosef Rosen | Ashkenazi-Litvish | |
| ||
| Yaakov Chaim Sofer | Sephardi | |
| ||
| Yitzchak Yosef | Sephardi | |
| ||
Out-degree among the 37 sayings only. Rav Chaim Kanievsky’s seven sayings run to six recipients (the Gryz twice); the next-highest sayers have two each. Click a number to expand whom each sayer blessed.
| Sayer | Community | Sayings |
|---|---|---|
| Chaim Kanievsky | Ashkenazi-Litvish | |
| ||
| Dov Kook | Ashkenazi-Litvish | |
| ||
| Dovid Yitzchak Shapira | Ashkenazi-Litvish | |
| ||
| Prominent US rabbi (unnamed) | ||
| ||
| Steipler — Yaakov Yisrael Kanievsky | Ashkenazi-Litvish | |
| ||
| Avi Zakutinsky | Modern Orthodox | |
| ||
| Baruch Ber Leibowitz | Ashkenazi-Litvish | |
| ||
| Chol HaMoed crowds (unnamed) | ||
| ||
| Congregation in Vienna (crowd) | ||
| ||
| Daniel Buchsbaum | Ashkenazi-Litvish | |
| ||
| David Baharan | Ashkenazi-Litvish | |
| ||
| Graduates of Yeshivat Kef HaChaim (crowd) | ||
| ||
| Meshiv KeHalacha author (unnamed) | ||
| ||
| Mordechai Cohen | Ashkenazi-Litvish | |
| ||
| Mordechai Yosef HaKohen | Ashkenazi-Litvish | |
| ||
| Netziv — Naftali Zvi Yehuda Berlin | Ashkenazi-Litvish | |
| ||
| Ovadia Yosef | Sephardi | |
| ||
| People who blessed on Elyashiv (crowd) | ||
| ||
| Prominent New York Sefardic Rav (unnamed) | Sephardi | |
| ||
| Rav Huna son of Rav Yehoshua | Amora | |
| ||
| Rav Papa | Amora | |
| ||
| Sarya Deblitzky | Ashkenazi-Litvish | |
| ||
| Shlomo Gordon | Rabbi | |
| ||
| Unnamed Jew | ||
| ||
| Yechiel Yaakov Weinberg (Seridei Esh) | Ashkenazi-Litvish | |
| ||
| Yisrael Abuchatzeira (Baba Sali) | Sephardi | |
| ||
| Yosef Chaim Sonnenfeld | Ashkenazi-Litvish | |
| ||
One row per attested saying. “Crowd” rows are mass blessings with no named sayer. A19 (Rav Ovadia on Rav Moshe Feinstein) rests only on a forum post and is marked anecdotal. The Aderet’s dream blessing (Aderet — Eliyahu David Rabinowitz Teomim on Ben-Zion Sternfeld of Bielsk) is not in this table — a dream is not a waking act.
| # | Sayer | Recipient | Date / place | Era | Confidence | Source |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| A1 | Rav Papa | Rav Chanina son of Rav Ika | undated · Babylonia Meeting on the road (Babylonia plotted approximately, Baghdad area) | Talmudic | confirmed | Berakhot 58b |
| A1b | Rav Huna son of Rav Yehoshua | Rav Chanina son of Rav Ika | undated · Babylonia Meeting on the road (Babylonia plotted approximately, Baghdad area) | Talmudic | confirmed | Berakhot 58b |
| A2 | Netziv — Naftali Zvi Yehuda Berlin | Aderet — Eliyahu David Rabinowitz Teomim | undated · Ponovezh Netziv happened to be in Ponovezh | 19th century | reported | Melamed Revavim 826 |
| A3 | Congregation in Vienna (crowd) | Rogatchover Gaon — Yosef Rosen | undated · Vienna Rogatchover arrived in Vienna | Early 20th century | reported | Shevet HaLevi 10:13 |
| A4 | Shlomo Gordon | Chafetz Chaim — Yisrael Meir HaKohen | 1930-06-01 · Assembly of rabbis of Vilna Grodno and Suvalk Chafetz Chaim entered the hall aged ~90 | Early 20th century | reported | Halacha Yomit 2332 |
| A5 | Steipler — Yaakov Yisrael Kanievsky | Chafetz Chaim — Yisrael Meir HaKohen | undated · Poland 1920s meeting | Early 20th century | reported | Orchos Rabbeinu 1:110 |
| A6 | Steipler — Yaakov Yisrael Kanievsky | Meir Simcha HaKohen of Dvinsk | undated · Dvinsk 1920s meeting | Early 20th century | reported | Orchos Rabbeinu 1:110 |
| A7 | Chaim Kanievsky | Gryz of Brisk — Yosef Dov HaLevi Soloveitchik | 1941 · Jerusalem Steipler travelled with son Rav Chaim to greet the Gryz on arrival in Israel 1941 | War and upheaval | reported | Divrei Siach 531 |
| A8 | Chaim Kanievsky | Gryz of Brisk — Yosef Dov HaLevi Soloveitchik | 1959-02-28 · Bnei Brak Sheva brachot of the Gryz's son R' Meir Soloveitchik (wedding 22 Feb 1959), Ulam Vagschal, Rehov HaRav Meltzer 13 — blessed through a window then went home | 1948-1967 | reported | Divrei Siach 531 |
| A9 | Baruch Ber Leibowitz | Dovid Friedman of Karlin | undated Litvish rosh yeshiva on a Hasidic rebbe | Early 20th century | reported | Orach Yosrael p.255 |
| A10 | David Baharan | Chazon Ish — Avraham Yeshaya Karelitz | undated · Bnei Brak Visit with Rav Shlomo Zalman Auerbach early 1950s | 1948-1967 | reported | Halichot Shlomo Tefilla 23 n.157 |
| A11 | Dovid Yitzchak Shapira | Ovadia Yosef | 2013-04 · Jerusalem Shiva call at Rav Ovadia's home (shiva for his son Yaakov Yosef) | Digital age | reported | Halacha Yomit 3010 |
| A12 | Sarya Deblitzky | Ovadia Yosef | 2011 · Jerusalem Visit to Rav Ovadia's home — after Elyashiv told him not to bless in our times | Digital age | reported | Halacha Yomit 3010 |
| A13 | Daniel Buchsbaum | Yosef Shalom Elyashiv | undated · Jerusalem Engagement party of Dov Kook's son Yisrael Meir Kook | Digital age | reported | Etz Chaim |
| A14 | Dov Kook | Yosef Shalom Elyashiv | undated · Jerusalem Blessed with Shem uMalkhut; Dov Kook said everyone blessed on Elyashiv | Digital age | reported | Etz Chaim |
| A15 | Dov Kook | Moshe Mordechai Karp | undated · Tiberias Karp came to Dov Kook's room | Digital age | reported | Etz Chaim |
| A16 | Chol HaMoed crowds (unnamed) | Moshe Sternbuch | undated · Jerusalem Chol HaMoed crowds streaming to Sternbuch's home 2020s | Digital age | reported | Dirshu |
| A17 | Avi Zakutinsky | Ephraim Greenblatt | undated · Memphis First in-person meeting after a decade of correspondence | Digital age | confirmed | OU Torah 80533 first-person |
| A18 | Prominent New York Sefardic Rav (unnamed) | Yitzchak Yosef | undated · New York Prominent New York Sefardic Rav blessed on seeing Rav Yitzchak Yosef; author present | Digital age | reported | OU Torah 27245 |
| A19 | Ovadia Yosef | Moshe Feinstein | undated Forum claim only — treat as anecdotal lead not fact | Unknown | anecdotal | Forum Mizrach post 67 |
| V01 | Chaim Kanievsky | Elazar Menachem Shach | undated · Bnei Brak Kanievsky visited Shach's apartment every 30 days to re-recite the blessing | Jet age | reported | Jewish Observer Feb 2002 pp.12-13 (via grandson Asher Bergman); OU Torah 80533 |
| V02 | Dovid Yitzchak Shapira | Chaim Kanievsky | undated · Bnei Brak Shiva visit; Shapira blessed on Rav Chaim; Rav Chaim answered 'tzarich lomar Baruch Shem' and accepted the kibbud-av argument | Digital age | reported | Divrei Siach Emor 5783 (first-person via hesped) |
| V03 | Prominent US rabbi (unnamed) | Mordechai Eliyahu | undated · United States Festive reception 1000+ people for the two Chief Rabbis 1983-1993; whole congregation blessed jointly with Shem uMalkhut | Jet age | reported | harav.org Eliyahu biography; Wikishiva |
| V04 | Prominent US rabbi (unnamed) | Avraham Shapira | undated · United States Same event as V03; Shapira protested 'bracha levatala' and did not answer Amen | Jet age | reported | harav.org Eliyahu biography; Wikishiva |
| V05 | Yosef Chaim Sonnenfeld | Moshe Mordechai Epstein | 1925 · Hebron Epstein arrived to head Hebron yeshiva; 5000 greeters; Sonnenfeld blessed shechalak in his honour | Early 20th century | reported | Hamichlol 'Yeshivat Chevron'; Bidspirit lot (same wording) |
| V06 | Mordechai Yosef HaKohen | Dov Kook | undated · Tiberias Gathering of rabbanim at Dov Kook's home 'years ago'; Dov Kook trembled from humility | Unknown | reported | Matzav.com (Oct 2025, eyewitnesses quoted) |
| V07 | Mordechai Cohen | Dov Kook | 2024-02-08 · Tiberias Motzaei Shabbat Parashat Yitro; gathering of Tiberias kollel/kehilla heads; Cohen blessed with Shem uMalkhut as Dov Kook entered | Digital age | reported | JDN 8 Feb 2024 |
| V08 | People who blessed on Elyashiv (crowd) | Yosef Shalom Elyashiv | undated · Jerusalem Repeatedly over years, people blessed on Elyashiv when they met him; responses varied: dismissive wave, bracha-levatala warning, 'say Baruch Shem' | Digital age | reported | Dirshu Likrat Shabbat Achrei Mot-Kedoshim 5778 (from Gedola Shemushah) |
| V09 | Chaim Kanievsky | Chazon Ish — Avraham Yeshaya Karelitz | undated In his youth after a month at Lomza yeshiva, on the Steipler's instruction, blessed once on the Chazon Ish | War and upheaval | reported | Dirshu (first-person recollection) |
| V10 | Chaim Kanievsky | Aharon Kotler | undated Same instruction as V09: blessed once on Rav Aharon Kotler 'since he is held to be gadol hador' | War and upheaval | reported | Dirshu (first-person recollection) |
| V11 | Chaim Kanievsky | Dov Berish Weidenfeld (Tchebiner Rav) | undated Diary entry: 'I blessed shechalak on the Tchebiner Rav and R. Aharon Kotler and R. Isser Zalman'; speaker confirmed as Kanievsky by gilyon framing | Unknown | reported | Divrei Siach 477 Shelach 5782 |
| V12 | Chaim Kanievsky | Isser Zalman Meltzer | undated Same diary entry as V11 | Unknown | reported | Divrei Siach 477 Shelach 5782 |
| V13 | Yechiel Yaakov Weinberg (Seridei Esh) | Elchanan Wasserman | undated · Berlin Wasserman came to give a shiur in Berlin (pre-1941); Weinberg blessed; Wasserman protested with tears / fainted from grief (variant) | Early 20th century | reported | Seridei Esh memoirs p.62 via Mizrach forum; Dirshu (fainting variant) |
| V14 | Meshiv KeHalacha author (unnamed) | Ovadia Yosef | undated · Jerusalem Eve of the Knesset elections in Ovadia's final days; author blessed before a congregation at Ovadia's home; all answered Amen | Digital age | reported | meshiv.co.il Yitro article (first-person; author unidentified) |
| V15 | Unnamed Jew | Chazon Ish — Avraham Yeshaya Karelitz | undated Unnamed Jew blessed on the Chazon Ish; the Chazon Ish answered Amen, explaining from humility that it is not levatala since the blesser thinks it may be blessed | Unknown | reported | Zilberstein via Kanievsky (Ladaat gilyon 1186; Dirshu gilyon 40) |
| V16 | Graduates of Yeshivat Kef HaChaim (crowd) | Yaakov Chaim Sofer | 2026-02 · Jerusalem 50th-anniversary graduates' gathering of Yeshivat Kef HaChaim; graduates blessed on Sofer; Rav David Yosef endorsed it on the spot | Digital age | reported | Kol Barama 12 Feb 2026; Mizrach forum |
| V17 | Yisrael Abuchatzeira (Baba Sali) | Ovadia Yosef | undated · Netivot Whenever Ovadia came to him Baba Sali stood full height and blessed shechalak with Shem uMalkhut | Jet age | reported | Halacha Yomit 759 |
Rabbis and blessings, with places, dates, confidence and sources — version 2.
A rabbi ruled or taught that one may or should bless on the named person. These are not sayings, and they are not in the graph or the hub counts — but they show who counted as blessable, when, and by whom.
| # | Designator | Designated | Context | Source |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| B1 | The Chazon Ish | The Steipler | Bnei Brak, pre-1953 | Orchos Rabbeinu 1:109 |
| B2 | Rav Yaakov Kamenetzky | Rav Aharon Kotler | Ruling relayed by Rav Taplin | Orach Yosrael p. 255 |
| B3 | Rav Moshe Feinstein | “A Torah scholar proficient in all of Shas” (unnamed class) | Reported in his name by Rav Taplin | OU Torah |
| B4 | Rav Ephraim Greenblatt, Rivevos Ephraim 8:128 | Rav Shach, Rav Elyashiv, Rav Chaim Kanievsky | Written ruling | OU Torah |
| B5 | Rav Ben-Zion Abba Shaul | Rav Ovadia Yosef and Rav Elyashiv | Taught to his students | Halacha Yomit Q&A 31 |
| B6 | Rav Elyashiv | The Steipler and Rav Moshe Feinstein | Relayed in Gedola Shemushah | Dirshu |
| B7 | Rav Elyashiv (via Rav Yitzchak Zilberstein) | Rav Moshe Feinstein, “among the three gedolei hador” — the third is Rav Aharon Kotler in one version (see B19); another version names only two | Told in Simcha BaBayit | Dirshu |
| B8 | Rav Elyashiv (secondhand) | The Tchebiner Rav at 80, and Rav Ben-Zion Abba Shaul at 40 | Tisha BeAv shiur by Rav Eitan Cohen — anecdotal, third-hand | darashty.co.il |
| B9 | Rav Ovadia Yosef | Rav Moshe Feinstein — “there is one you can certainly bless on… and I don’t know if there is another” | Sermon, undated | Halacha Yomit, HalachaID 468 (the “3530” citation does not exist) |
| B10 | Rav Ovadia Yosef (forum claim) | Rav Shmuel Wosner, Rav Shlomo Mashash, Rav Shlomo Amar | Cited as Ma’ayan Omer vol. 1, siman 38 — verify in print; anecdotal | Forum Mizrach |
| B11 | Rav Shlomo Amar | Rav Avraham Shapira | 2007 eulogy, secondhand | yeshiva.org.il |
| B12 | Rav David Yosef | Rav Yaakov Chaim Sofer | Feb 2026, Yeshivat Kef HaChaim graduates’ event — now also an act (V16): the graduates had already blessed when he endorsed it | Kol Barama, 12 Feb 2026 |
| B13 | Rav Dov Kook | Rav Chaim Kanievsky — “the only one in our generation” | 2021 article | Etz Chaim |
| B14 | The Minchas Elazar of Munkatch | Torah scholars generally (no names) | Minchas Elazar 5:7 | OU Torah |
| B15 | Rav Chaim Kanievsky | Rav Shach — “one can still make a beracha pronouncing Hashem’s name on Rabbi Shach… ‘Rabbi Shach,’ said Reb Chaim, ‘is the Gadol Hadar’” | 1993 | Jewish Observer, Feb 2002, pp. 12–13 |
| B16 | Rav Mordechai Eliyahu | Rav Tzvi Yehuda Kook | Asked if there is a sage on whom one can bless shechalak | Har Bracha, Revivim 255 |
| B17 | Rav Moshe Shmuel Shapira (Rosh Yeshivat Be’er Ya’akov, 1917–2006) | Rav Chaim Kanievsky | Standing instruction to his son, before 2006 | Divrei Siach, Emor 5783 |
| B18 | Rav Elyashiv | Unnamed “gedolei hador” of our generation | Undated | Dirshu Likrat Shabbat 5778 |
| B19 | Rav Elyashiv | Rav Aharon Kotler — third of three, with the Steipler and Rav Moshe Feinstein | Undated; conflicts with the two-name version (B6/B7) — Kotler died 1962, so the three-name list cannot be a post-1962 practical list. Both versions carried, not merged. | Kol HaLashon PDF, Zilberstein shiur, Chayei Sarah 506 |
| B20 | Rav Chaim Kanievsky | Rav Dov Landau — “נחשב מופלג בדורו” | Undated | Mishpacha, “גאונות האדם” |
The blessing survives as a designation partly because almost everyone declines it for himself.
| # | Who | What happened | Source |
|---|---|---|---|
| C1 | Rav Elyashiv (recipient) | Did not answer Amen; demurred on the word lire’av — “‘שחלק מחכמתו’, מילא, אבל ‘ליראיו’?” (“the wisdom, yes; ‘those who fear Him’, no”) — wording now confirmed verbatim from a second print source | Yalkut Yosef 455 (2024); Dirshu Likrat Shabbat 5778 (from Gedola Shemushah) |
| C2 | Rav Elyashiv (as posek) | Told Rav Sarya Deblitzky the blessing should not be recited in our times — Deblitzky blessed on Rav Ovadia anyway (A12) | Halacha Yomit 3010 |
| C3 | Rav David Yosef (recipient) | Angrily refused: “I ask you not to bless on me” (anecdotal; in tension with B12) | Forum Mizrach |
| C4 | The Lubavitcher Rebbe | “A Rebbe is above this” — the blessing does not apply to a Rebbe (chronology problem: the Rayatz died in 1950; verify against Kuntres Birkhot HaHitgalut) | Chabadpedia |
| C5 | Rav Aharon Leib Steinman | Shown rare video of the Chafetz Chaim (Apr 2015): “it is not applicable to bless shechalak” — a video image is not “seeing” | Behadrei Chareidim via Kooker |
| C6 | Rav Yitzchak Yosef (recollection) | Does not remember the blessing being said on the previous generation’s Sephardi gedolim (Attiya, Hadaya, Adas, HaKohen) — the revival is largely Rav Ovadia’s doing | Yalkut Yosef 455 (2024) |
| C7 | The Chozeh of Lublin | For the 16 years the Berditchever lived, set aside an hour every day to thank Hashem for sending such a soul — the thanksgiving the blessing institutionalises, as a daily practice | Hamichlol |
| C8 | Rav Avraham Shapira (recipient, V03/V04) | Stood and called out: “זו ברכה לבטלה ולא עניתי עליה אמן”. Rav Eliyahu publicly disagreed: “Amen v’Amen” — one Amen meaning “it is true” (about Shapira), the other “may it be so” (about himself). The only recorded defence of a blessing by a fellow recipient. | harav.org; Wikishiva |
| C9 | Rav Chaim Kanievsky (recipient, V02) | Answered humbly “צריך לומר ברוך שם” — one should say Baruch Shem [Kevod Malchuto]. Shapira replied that saying Baruch Shem would violate kibbud av, since his father had commanded him to bless — “ורבינו סבר וקיבל” | Divrei Siach, Emor 5783 |
| C10 | Rav Elchanan Wasserman (recipient, V13) | Protested with tears that it was bracha levatala; Dirshu variant: fainted from grief | Seridei Esh memoirs; Dirshu |
| C11 | Rav Meir Mazuz (d. 19 Apr 2025) | On hearing someone had blessed shechalak on him, publicly expressed displeasure, said it was bracha levatala, and was very angry. Sayer unnamed, date unknown. | Hamichlol bio (unsourced) |
| C12 | Rav Chaim Pinchas Sheinberg (Torah Ore) | People often blessed on him; he showed displeasure; asked why, he answered: “‘שחלק מחכמתו’, מילא, אבל ‘ליראיו’?” — doubting his own yir’at Shamayim. He himself held there were gedolim one could bless on. | Dirshu Likrat Shabbat 5778 |
Three camps. Yes, with Shem uMalchut: Chayei Adam, Rav Ovadia Yosef (Yechaveh Daat 4:16 — the fullest modern treatment), Rav Shmuel Wosner (Shevet HaLevi 10:13), Rav Mordechai Eliyahu. No, or only without Shem uMalchut: Aruch HaShulchan 224:6 (“how great must he be? It was not explained — so nowadays we refrain”), Yosef Ometz, Ben Ish Chai, Tzitz Eliezer. Reshut, and fragmented: Rav Asher Weiss, Minchat Asher, Corona 53 — the blessing is optional, and “in early days gedolim were accepted by the entire people; not so today — every circle has its own gadol, each disqualifying the other’s witnesses,” so ruling either way risks a vain blessing or an insult to Torah.
Two rules shape the data. Face to face only: seeing a gadol in a photo or on a screen does not count, so every edge in the graph is a real journey by somebody. The 30-day rule: the blessing is repeated only after thirty days without seeing the sage — Rav Chaim Kanievsky visited Rav Shach every thirty days precisely to say it again (V01, Jewish Observer, Feb 2002), turning a halachic interval into a monthly pilgrimage. The modern mass form inverts it: thousands blessing on Rav Sternbuch at Chol HaMoed, the recipient correcting the grammar.
Who qualifies? No source gives a quantitative threshold. The working definitions: outstanding in Torah and fear of Heaven, a teacher of rulings in Israel (Yechaveh Daat / Yalkut Yosef); “asked everywhere and answers” (Rav Eliyahu); proficient in all of Shas (reported in Rav Moshe Feinstein’s name). A rosh yeshiva who does not know halacha, or who “only knows Mishnah Berurah”, does not qualify. Whether the blessing may be said on a woman scholar, no posek found so far addresses directly — an open question, not filled in by inference.
At n = 37 none of these can be tested yet — but version 2 gives the first readings. The top five recipients take 14 of 37 edges (38%), short of the half that hypothesis 6 predicts; the cross-community share grows with the Baba Sali and joint Chief Rabbis cases; and the Tiberias cases pull against hypothesis 2 (Israel as the hub) by reproducing the practice at the periphery. The full statements, with predictions and falsifiers, are in the project notes; the short forms:
Three null checks travel with them: source volume (are there more recent cases because more happened, or because more was printed?), survivorship, and reporting bias — Sephardi sources and English-language sources report this blessing far more than others do.
Version 2 is a web sweep (Hebrew and English, November 2026) plus a grep of 2,085 transcripts from the Weiss, Wieder, Fuerst, Headlines, Breitowitz and Schachter archives — zero genuine mentions of the scholar’s blessing (the 39 שחלק hits are ASR garble; the only adjacent find is the king’s blessing, שחלק מכבודו, in two Weiss shiurim). Sources: OU Torah, Halacha Yomit, Yeshiva.org.il, Dirshu, Etz Chaim, Kol Barama, Chabadpedia, Harav.org, and the seforim they cite. It is not a census. No instance was found on the web for Rav Kook, Rav Soloveitchik, Rav Lichtenstein, Rav Shach as sayer, Rav Hershel Schachter, or Rav Asher Weiss — recorded as “not found”, not “did not happen”. The four dead ends share a profile: men whose writings discuss the blessing but whose anecdote literature is thinnest in the hagiographic genre where the blessing is documented.
The book-length treatment — Rav Yechezkel Moskowitz, Birkat Chachamim (Bnei Brak, 5784) — was not located anywhere: NLI, HebrewBooks, WorldCat and bookstores are empty, and its only attestation anywhere is a “Further reading” line in Hebrew Wikipedia. Version 3 needs it in print (NLI catalog, Otzar HaHochma, Bnei Brak stores), plus the fifteen open leads: the Eliyahu/Shapira US date, the Meshiv author’s identity, Piskei Teshuvot 224 n. 17 (reportedly several testimonies of rabbis who blessed with Shem uMalkhut), the unnamed gadol of Tzitz Eliezer 14:37, and a print check of Minchat Asher Corona 53. Rav Ovadia on Rav Moshe Feinstein as an act is still unverified — no dated meeting, and the “Halacha Yomit 3530” citation does not exist (the real article is HalachaID 468).
Corrections welcome. If you can source an instance — or correct one — the dataset is the place to fix it, not the prose.