-
0:00 #3 God is incorporeal · 1.6 · 46%#11 Reward and punishment · 2.9 · 94%
“This book appears to be written in order to address the age old topic or of theodicy, or the phenomenon of innocent people who undergo undeserved suffering. Yet, as might be expected, this work does not provide anything like an easy way out of this religious conundrum, and ultimately leaves the reader with far more …”
Stance, per Jev: described or quoted, not clearly adopted
-
2:45 #11 Reward and punishment · 3.0 · 96%
“And Job is left with absolutely nothing, and yet he retains his piety and refuses to curse God. I think you have a second quite similar scene in heaven in which God again brags, and Satan says, "Ah, but if you let me afflict his body with illnesses, then Job will surely fold, and surely …”
Stance, per Jev: described or quoted, not clearly adopted
-
8:08 #6 Prophecy · 2.5 · 64%#11 Reward and punishment · 2.5 · 68%
“That's very interesting and especially because the religiosity of Job he's seen or he's presented as an exemplar of religious excellence except of course he doesn't fulfill any of the precepts, any of the misvod that are seen as hallmarks of religious excellence often throughout the rest of the Hebrew Bible and therefore this seems …”
Stance, per Jev: said as the speaker’s own view
-
14:21 #8 Torah from Heaven · 1.9 · 46%#9 Torah is unchanging · 2.1 · 50%
“The lack of a resolution or solution at the end, maybe someone thought, "I'd better revise this and stick something in there that solves that issue," whether he succeeded or is a other question. So I don't even say when was it written well, it's probably not all written at once.”
Stance, per Jev: said as the speaker’s own view
-
17:12 #11 Reward and punishment · 2.6 · 76%
“The narrative in which the innocent sufferer is restored and gets back what he lost and lives to a ripe old age of 140 and dies happily. So I would say it's full of theological ideas, the logic debating theological ideas.”
Stance, per Jev: said as the speaker’s own view
-
20:08 #11 Reward and punishment · 3.0 · 98%
“And that presents to me the sharpest possible case of a righteous person who has suffering, the best person, worst suffering for the flimsiest possible excuse. Is that what is going on?”
Stance, per Jev: raised in order to argue against it
-
22:54 #11 Reward and punishment · 2.5 · 75%
“And then very, very quickly, everything becomes horrendous to a degree which is hard to believe that could all happen at once. So I think that's right.”
Stance, per Jev: said as the speaker’s own view
-
25:15 #11 Reward and punishment · 2.7 · 74%
“Because it seems, as you say, from the plain text that he is of the greatest possible caliber in terms of his conduct. They're trying to engage in Sidu Gudin and the justification of the Divine Judgment.”
Stance, per Jev: described or quoted, not clearly adopted
-
27:51 #3 God is incorporeal · 1.7 · 41%#11 Reward and punishment · 2.8 · 86%
“Is he really righteous if he's only acting as a conditioned animal? Does the word, does the name Pavlov ring any bells for you?”
Stance, per Jev: said as the speaker’s own view
-
30:52 #11 Reward and punishment · 3.0 · 96%
“He's presented as resulting in a severing of that nexus of good deed and reward. He's now going to experience adversity.”
Stance, per Jev: said as the speaker’s own view
-
33:51 #11 Reward and punishment · 3.0 · 96%
“And here comes along the book of Job, or at least the Satan in the book of Job with God's tacit approval, that that is suspect and ought to be tested if not denigrated. What does the view that people have that there's an ethic of that deed, consequence, nexus, that is very prominent in …”
Stance, per Jev: raised in order to argue against it
-
36:39 #11 Reward and punishment · 3.0 · 96%
“And a personal God is not a change machine where you always get out the equivalent of what you put in. On the other hand, having said all that, it's certainly true that Job is trying very, very high, hard, the book of Job is trying very, very hard to question that whole notion to …”
Stance, per Jev: said as the speaker’s own view
-
39:18 #3 God is incorporeal · 1.5 · 40%#11 Reward and punishment · 3.0 · 96%
“He referring to God, laughs at the suffering of the innocent. It's not just he allows the innocent suffer.”
Stance, per Jev: described or quoted, not clearly adopted
-
42:00 #8 Torah from Heaven · 2.6 · 74%#9 Torah is unchanging · 2.4 · 56%#11 Reward and punishment · 2.4 · 67%
“I mean, if that's true, it could very well be that somebody saw the older story and just thought it was too saccharin, too sweet and not realistic enough and took a knife and split it in half and inserted it in the middle, spliced in this angry, impatient Job and his, as you say, …”
Stance, per Jev: said as the speaker’s own view
-
44:39 #8 Torah from Heaven · 1.9 · 43%#11 Reward and punishment · 2.6 · 68%
“It's really not true that from the beginning that those three comforters are just telling Job, "You're a miserable disgusting sinner, why don't you just admit it?" The truth is that they have a fairly supple conception of adversity. Sometimes they see it as judgment for sin, it's punishment, okay?”
Stance, per Jev: raised in order to argue against it
-
47:29 #11 Reward and punishment · 2.2 · 59%
“And sometimes they take it as something that can happen, especially the beginning, to the righteous, something that one should simply bear with trust, confidence, betachon, the God will eventually restore the person. And those wait patiently for God to restore you.”
Stance, per Jev: described or quoted, not clearly adopted
-
50:25 #11 Reward and punishment · 2.6 · 78%
“It's not your piety or confidence, your integrity, your hope." And he says, "Think now what innocent man ever perished." Now you're right. When Job hears that, "Wait a minute, I am an innocent man." On the one hand, that is galling.”
Stance, per Jev: said as the speaker’s own view
-
52:50 #11 Reward and punishment · 2.7 · 87%
“Now if you think about it from the standpoint of the people who are supposed to be reading this book, not as a realistic historical psychological book, but as something that helps to the situation of suffering, do you ever really know why you've suffered when you have a catastrophe?”
Stance, per Jev: described or quoted, not clearly adopted
-
55:35 #11 Reward and punishment · 3.4 · 99%
“It doesn't, justice for human beings is not the center of the situation. I'll give you an analogy if I have a minute to do this.”
Stance, per Jev: said as the speaker’s own view
-
58:20 #11 Reward and punishment · 3.2 · 99%
“Job is restored and his comforters, who had so often asserted that deed consequence nexus, are said to be in the wrong. And Job lives happily after to the age of 140.”
Stance, per Jev: said as the speaker’s own view
-
1:01:03 #1 God exists · 2.3 · 54%#11 Reward and punishment · 2.8 · 86%
“And God is small or maybe not even on the scene at all. And so the God that Job said would never show up in the spirit of his ever showing up.”
Stance, per Jev: raised in order to argue against it
-
1:03:43 #11 Reward and punishment · 3.0 · 95%
“And the so that in the last analysis, the deconseless nexus is re-instituted, but with a serious qualification, some suffering we now know can be probative, it can be a test, and we don't have to take suffering and adversity as signs of sin. They may be signs of sin.”
Stance, per Jev: said as the speaker’s own view