The workshop · Torah

The Podcast of Jewish Ideas, against the Thirteen Principles

J.J. Kimche's Podcast of Jewish Ideas (Torah in Motion) brings academics on to talk about the Bible, the Talmud, philosophy and Jewish history. I cut every transcript into sections of about three minutes. Then I asked Jev how far each section departs from each of the Rambam's thirteen principles of faith, on a scale from 0 (not relevant) to 4 (openly denies it). That's 429 sections across 22 episodes so far.

How to read this. These are a classifier's ratings of the ideas discussed. They are not a ruling on anyone. The podcast's guests often explain what Spinoza, a Bible critic or a medieval thinker held, and Jev can't reliably tell explaining from endorsing. Its guess about the speaker's stance is shown on each card, but treat it loosely. The transcripts are machine-made and have no speaker names, so nothing here says who said a line. Listen to the moment before you draw a conclusion.

Flags by principle

How many sections Jev puts at implies doubt or open denial, with at least 40% probability. Tap one to filter.

0 Not relevant1 Consistent2 Academic framing3 Implies doubt4 Open denial

93. The English Haskalah | Dr. David Ruderman (Anglo-Judaism #1)

18 Jun 2026 · 74 min · 22 sections · 3 flagged · transcript: Spreaker

3 flagged moments
  1. 20:37 #8 Torah from Heaven · 2.7 · 76%#9 Torah is unchanging · 2.5 · 56%
    “Is that really a text that came from from Moses and you know, from the original version, or is it all these these these points, these these vowels, all of these marks added later on to distort the text to bring out a Jewish version of the text as opposed to a Christian reading of …”

    Stance, per Jev: described or quoted, not clearly adopted

  2. 27:32 #8 Torah from Heaven · 2.6 · 64%#9 Torah is unchanging · 3.0 · 83%
    “And therefore I propose that I retranslate the King James version myself, and that by doing so I can create not only a Bible for Christians, but a Bible for Jews, in other words, a universal Bible. Now, of course this lacked all of the massoretic stuff that later goes on with with Ginsburg and …”

    Stance, per Jev: described or quoted, not clearly adopted

  3. 37:03 #2 God is one · 2.4 · 56%#3 God is incorporeal · 2.7 · 73%#4 God is eternal · 2.1 · 41%
    “They come out of a certain deistic view of the world where God is a part of nature. Dietro himself gets into a whole controversy over whether he means is nature God or is God, you know, and he's accused of being as pinosas as That's another part of our story.”

    Stance, per Jev: described or quoted, not clearly adopted

92. Analytic Philosophy (Repent!): Dr. Noam Oren

12 Jun 2026 · 56 min · 18 sections · 2 flagged · transcript: Spreaker

2 flagged moments
  1. 39:33 #1 God exists · 2.6 · 68%#11 Reward and punishment · 1.8 · 44%
    “You don't need God in the picture, okay. Repentance is a natural phenomenon, so God does not give needs to give us the gift of repentance, so to say we can just repent, and I don't think it's up bad feature of this explanation.”

    Stance, per Jev: said as the speaker’s own view

  2. 42:17 #11 Reward and punishment · 1.7 · 41%
    “So, for example, it seems that if I'm not the same person, I'm not guilty anymore if the thing I have done in the past, but I'm not praise of word anymore for the good things I've done in the past, And this seems kind of weird. Again, if you go to the perfiting kind …”

    Stance, per Jev: described or quoted, not clearly adopted

91. The Halakhic Man | Dr. Lawrence Kaplan

14 May 2026 · 83 min · 24 sections · 3 flagged · transcript: Spreaker

3 flagged moments
  1. 38:52 #1 God exists · 2.4 · 41%
    “I mean this part this is also part of what he basically accepted cons of view that you can no longer prove the existence of God, you cannot prove the existence of life. So what you have is you have again is influenced by phenomenology, which is a study of the structures of conscience.”

    Stance, per Jev: described or quoted, not clearly adopted

  2. 49:21 #1 God exists · 2.4 · 53%
    “Again, the point is, we can't really prove the existence of God to make absolute theological statements, but we can speak humans, beings experienced or consciousness, different modes of consciousness, how it's directed. And certainly existentialism certainly speaks about different types of individual in terms of you know, why he oftentimes likes to have constiosts …”

    Stance, per Jev: said as the speaker’s own view

  3. 1:18:53 #12 The Messiah · 2.0 · 49%
    “It's it's a non Messianic view. It's more of the status than either the God's great active I said to the Jewish people, it's sort of laboratory.”

    Stance, per Jev: described or quoted, not clearly adopted

90. Joseph B. Soloveichik's Existentialism | Dr. Daniel Rynhold

17 Apr 2026 · 67 min · 20 sections · 2 flagged · transcript: Spreaker

2 flagged moments
  1. 48:47 #13 Resurrection · 2.5 · 72%
    “He like man is a this worldly He has no interest in transcendent worlds afterlife. That doesn't factor in to his religious life whatsoever.”

    Stance, per Jev: described or quoted, not clearly adopted

  2. 1:00:05 #11 Reward and punishment · 2.8 · 85%
    “And that's why therefore, the the kind of the emphasis on on the this worldly life of Judaism, how it can be you know, seen as an expression of your you know, of your innermost experience as he experiences halacha, right, the life him isn't some kind of imposition, it kind of it's his expressing …”

    Stance, per Jev: said as the speaker’s own view

88. Walter Benjamin | Dr. Vivian Liska

20 Mar 2026 · 68 min · 17 sections · 6 flagged · transcript: Spreaker

6 flagged moments
  1. 24:48 #7 Moses' prophecy · 1.8 · 44%#8 Torah from Heaven · 2.7 · 77%#9 Torah is unchanging · 2.9 · 91%
    “Does it mean that one would have to reread the Torah in different ways and new or even create a new one. He leaves that open, but the critique that it is a world.”

    Stance, per Jev: described or quoted, not clearly adopted

  2. 28:47 #6 Prophecy · 2.0 · 48%#12 The Messiah · 2.4 · 46%
    “And Benjamin insists that one cannot reach a messianic world in any straight way. So let's say, as in the religious idea, that with good deeds and prayer, if all the Jews would keeps about, for example, then the Messiah would come.”

    Stance, per Jev: described or quoted, not clearly adopted

  3. 44:24 #6 Prophecy · 2.6 · 73%
    “So God is absent, he is unreachable. But that is where God manifests himself in modernity.”

    Stance, per Jev: described or quoted, not clearly adopted

  4. 48:44 #9 Torah is unchanging · 1.6 · 40%
    “It says the Jewish law has to be suspended because it turns us all into signos, because it cannot be fulfilled. And Benjamine has no problem with Jewish law.”

    Stance, per Jev: described or quoted, not clearly adopted

  5. 59:51 #12 The Messiah · 2.3 · 44%
    “This is maybe the most interesting thing that he at the same time does invoke such the idea of redemption and at the same time takes it out of human hands because of the dangers that this could bring about. And the same thing with there's a little sentence of in the context of where …”

    Stance, per Jev: said as the speaker’s own view

  6. 1:04:01 #8 Torah from Heaven · 1.7 · 42%#9 Torah is unchanging · 3.4 · 93%
    “Ben writes, No, No, the key mood moment is when the doorkeeper slams the door shut, because finally we are rid of the law, and that would be a kind of fulfillment the suspension of the law, as Paul did to Jewish law. So the law is suspended now, and that would be Benjamini, just …”

    Stance, per Jev: described or quoted, not clearly adopted

86. The Meaning of Life | Dr. Alan Mittleman

19 Feb 2026 · 70 min · 18 sections · 8 flagged · transcript: Spreaker

8 flagged moments
  1. 11:32 #1 God exists · 2.5 · 53%#10 God knows our deeds · 1.8 · 40%
    “So to an extent, it's a modern thing that reflects, if not the death of God, to use Nietzsche's phrase, but a very distant God or a very disconnected God. The attempts by the German thinkers in the late eighteenth early nineteenth century to make sense of this question, the meaning of life comes in …”

    Stance, per Jev: described or quoted, not clearly adopted

  2. 18:49 #10 God knows our deeds · 1.5 · 44%#11 Reward and punishment · 2.5 · 76%
    “I think that Cohela has an experience somewhere along those lines, that the world is accident and it all ends in death, and the universe is indifferent to our striving in the sense and doesn't requite us according to our worth we die, the death of dogs and cats and sheep and goats doesn't matter.”

    Stance, per Jev: raised in order to argue against it

  3. 31:05 #8 Torah from Heaven · 2.8 · 72%#9 Torah is unchanging · 2.4 · 48%
    “But as an academic Bible scholar, he shows that the affirmations Genesis one, with all of those ketovs and toved, that's like the latest development of the Biblical literature, that kind of triumphant endorsement of the divine fully in control and creating without opposition. That's like the cherry on the cake of a longer history …”

    Stance, per Jev: described or quoted, not clearly adopted

  4. 40:04 #6 Prophecy · 2.6 · 62%#7 Moses' prophecy · 2.6 · 66%#8 Torah from Heaven · 3.2 · 98%#9 Torah is unchanging · 2.6 · 71%
    “But you complicate this picture a little bit in your treatment of revelation and speak of Jewish law of the divine revelation as neither entirely divine command nor entirely human construction, but at some kind of hybrid model or some kind of intertwining or intersection between divine and human effort. And I wonder if you …”

    Stance, per Jev: said as the speaker’s own view

  5. 43:46 #6 Prophecy · 2.4 · 50%#8 Torah from Heaven · 2.7 · 75%
    “A quote from Sam Fleishack or another fine philosopher from my book, he says, revelation is not given until it is received. I'm interested in the human role in these matters because it has to do with decision, choice, and action, and those are clearly places let's just call it using the philosophical umbrella term …”

    Stance, per Jev: said as the speaker’s own view

  6. 47:28 #1 God exists · 2.5 · 70%#4 God is eternal · 1.6 · 46%#6 Prophecy · 2.8 · 85%#7 Moses' prophecy · 2.1 · 55%#8 Torah from Heaven · 2.7 · 82%#9 Torah is unchanging · 1.9 · 53%
    “If Israel stops giving God to he looked, God has no home in this world. There's this dimension of human agency that is contingent on our continuing to find it meaningful, and our contingent on it are continuing to want to do it.”

    Stance, per Jev: described or quoted, not clearly adopted

  7. 52:24 #12 The Messiah · 2.3 · 41%
    “They really asked the question, can human beings bring about a Messianic age?”

    Stance, per Jev: described or quoted, not clearly adopted

  8. 1:00:30 #6 Prophecy · 2.0 · 50%#8 Torah from Heaven · 1.9 · 49%
    “I mean, co Helet gives no indication in the book, even if they're being revelation. It's all his own experience, working out of his own reasoning about what this can mean.”

    Stance, per Jev: described or quoted, not clearly adopted

85. Halakhic Codes & Responsa | Dr. Chaim Saiman

29 Jan 2026 · 70 min · 23 sections · 1 flagged · transcript: Spreaker

1 flagged moment
  1. 30:01 #9 Torah is unchanging · 2.0 · 43%
    “So the act of applying law two concrete situations changes it and molds it and modifies it. And in that sense, I think that is at least the first cut is done in chew vote.”

    Stance, per Jev: said as the speaker’s own view

84. The Mesorah & the Masoretes | Dr. David Moster

15 Jan 2026 · 59 min · 23 sections · 14 flagged · transcript: Spreaker

14 flagged moments
  1. 3:36 #8 Torah from Heaven · 2.9 · 78%#9 Torah is unchanging · 2.4 · 46%
    “They're adding materials to the biblical texts that weren't written. So for example, when the Book of Esther was written, originally it.”

    Stance, per Jev: described or quoted, not clearly adopted

  2. 6:02 #8 Torah from Heaven · 2.3 · 49%
    “So this didn't come with the tanaka was added and the note says that this appears bet two times. The letter bet stands for the number two.”

    Stance, per Jev: described or quoted, not clearly adopted

  3. 11:19 #8 Torah from Heaven · 2.6 · 65%#9 Torah is unchanging · 2.4 · 46%
    “I mean, this word needs to be taken out so scribes are saying this word was a mistake. They're putting in little scribal notations.”

    Stance, per Jev: described or quoted, not clearly adopted

  4. 16:30 #8 Torah from Heaven · 2.5 · 56%
    “And so even though I told you no two texts are the same, there are absolutely no two texts that have ever been written enough that are exactly the same. The ben Asher family scribes preferred them, and of them they preferred one scribe, in particular, arm Banasher.”

    Stance, per Jev: described or quoted, not clearly adopted

  5. 21:42 #8 Torah from Heaven · 2.5 · 52%
    “I've been studying to not for many eight years, and I've often sat in the lecture and somebody has given the lecture and Biblical studies, and they're saying, I believe that this particular text was by an editor, or this particular text used to have something that was deleted by an editor, and so that's …”

    Stance, per Jev: described or quoted, not clearly adopted

  6. 23:55 #8 Torah from Heaven · 2.5 · 47%
    “Is there space to say that the musura also verges on biblical interpretation at some point? In other words, is this preservation entirely neutral?”

    Stance, per Jev: described or quoted, not clearly adopted

  7. 34:01 #8 Torah from Heaven · 2.5 · 53%
    “He said, I'm gonna If I sense a mistake and the other ones are better, I'm gonna go with the other ones. And he followed the Masaronic advice as.”

    Stance, per Jev: described or quoted, not clearly adopted

  8. 36:40 #8 Torah from Heaven · 2.8 · 72%#9 Torah is unchanging · 2.5 · 55%
    “And now and he's essentially making a noose, a new version. I don't want to say it's like a Frankenstein from giant pieces.”

    Stance, per Jev: said as the speaker’s own view

  9. 39:10 #8 Torah from Heaven · 2.5 · 52%
    “Let's say they are doing something either eclectic or like semi eclectic, like allowing for the possibility of diverging from the lepo or the learning rerec codicies. How do they make such a decision on?”

    Stance, per Jev: described or quoted, not clearly adopted

  10. 41:23 #8 Torah from Heaven · 2.5 · 62%
    “So you imagine arm Benascher was actually walking around with his codex for decades and making it better and better and better. And if you just want to know how many mistakes can appear in a tana right, how many mistakes can describe?”

    Stance, per Jev: said as the speaker’s own view

  11. 44:00 #8 Torah from Heaven · 2.6 · 62%
    “So it doesn't mean that it's the original text. What it means is it's the most it's the most masseratic.”

    Stance, per Jev: said as the speaker’s own view

  12. 47:09 #8 Torah from Heaven · 2.9 · 89%#9 Torah is unchanging · 2.5 · 52%
    “It all depends on who you're copying from and how much access do you have. Now the Ellipto Codex, let's this is a great example because it was in Aleppo for hundreds of years and scholars had very limited access to it.”

    Stance, per Jev: described or quoted, not clearly adopted

  13. 53:12 #8 Torah from Heaven · 2.9 · 92%#9 Torah is unchanging · 2.7 · 75%
    “You can also look at the targets, the Aromatic, you can look at the Latin, et cetera, all of a sudden you could say, well, the master in a tradition we have might not exactly be what was the original, and you can all of a sudden say, oh, maybe there's a different way to …”

    Stance, per Jev: described or quoted, not clearly adopted

  14. 55:44 #8 Torah from Heaven · 2.4 · 46%
    “And so so in that sense, the Master retic tradition and the pointings and the cancelation wasn't necessarily absolute, meaning it's something that you can can handle with, which is common in biblical scholarship today, but was something that needed to develop over in the years and over the centuries. Interesting, Okay, I think I …”

    Stance, per Jev: no clear stance

83. The Biblical Canon(s) | Dr. Hindy Najman

09 Jan 2026 · 66 min · 22 sections · 22 flagged · transcript: Spreaker

22 flagged moments
  1. 0:20 #8 Torah from Heaven · 2.7 · 70%
    “Far from being an age of decline or repetition, it was a time of extraordinary literary and theological creativity, when Jewish authors were composing not only some of the later Biblical books themselves, but also an expanding constellation of related works known by us today as the Apographer the Pseudopigrapher, along with various early commentaries …”

    Stance, per Jev: no clear stance

  2. 2:56 #7 Moses' prophecy · 2.6 · 71%#8 Torah from Heaven · 3.6 · 99%#9 Torah is unchanging · 3.8 · 99%
    “But the very reality of Judaism is that it keeps changing, and it changes over time. This is a very very complicated critique, and I know I can't just do it on one foot, but I want to start there.”

    Stance, per Jev: raised in order to argue against it

  3. 6:09 #8 Torah from Heaven · 2.4 · 60%#9 Torah is unchanging · 2.4 · 59%
    “So the first point is challenging originary moments. The second is to recognize ongoing expressions of integration.”

    Stance, per Jev: said as the speaker’s own view

  4. 8:55 #8 Torah from Heaven · 2.9 · 82%#9 Torah is unchanging · 2.6 · 64%
    “My answer in my twenty fourteen book Losing the Temple Recovering the Future is revelation inflected by destruction. But and I already began this third point with you know, signaling towards a contemporary context.”

    Stance, per Jev: said as the speaker’s own view

  5. 12:07 #8 Torah from Heaven · 2.9 · 85%#9 Torah is unchanging · 3.2 · 90%
    “But I want to say that it's not just Christian scholars that have narrated the death or the end of Judaism, that many Jewish scholars have also adopted or integrated certain norms of the field without asking why do you throw the later material out, or why do you say that anything after yoshiahu after …”

    Stance, per Jev: raised in order to argue against it

  6. 15:16 #8 Torah from Heaven · 2.2 · 49%#9 Torah is unchanging · 2.4 · 57%
    “Ultimately that can give way to important conversation, conversation that recognizes difference, but also conversation that acknowledges and celebrates the ongoing growth of a dynamic tradition. It goes to the very heart of my discipline, and it's not been an easy road for me as a result.”

    Stance, per Jev: said as the speaker’s own view

  7. 19:14 #8 Torah from Heaven · 2.9 · 87%#9 Torah is unchanging · 3.0 · 89%
    “So we have earlier iterations, for example, from the Dead Sea scrolls or from translations in Greek and other languages, but we also need to understand the larger context in which these texts are growing and transforming, and to study different moments, if you will, different snapshots, so we can see the growth of the …”

    Stance, per Jev: no clear stance

  8. 22:00 #8 Torah from Heaven · 3.0 · 92%#9 Torah is unchanging · 3.0 · 88%
    “So I don't think it's just not realistic to say that we have that the text that we study exists in a single pure form and every thing else is either derivative or an interesting. They're different ways of talking about pluriformity.”

    Stance, per Jev: said as the speaker’s own view

  9. 24:46 #8 Torah from Heaven · 3.0 · 95%#9 Torah is unchanging · 3.0 · 92%
    “There might be so much incoherence between the different versions that we can't talk about a singular form of a text. I'll give you one more example, which is possibly a less provocative example, and that's a safer to helium.”

    Stance, per Jev: said as the speaker’s own view

  10. 27:41 #8 Torah from Heaven · 3.3 · 97%#9 Torah is unchanging · 3.5 · 96%
    “And the answer I want to say, in a very simple and clear way, is that scriptural traditions, interpretative traditions grow and they continue to grow over time. In this this is the life and breath of a tradition that we come to know as Judaism.”

    Stance, per Jev: said as the speaker’s own view

  11. 30:23 #7 Moses' prophecy · 2.1 · 45%#8 Torah from Heaven · 3.3 · 98%#9 Torah is unchanging · 3.2 · 95%
    “As the texts are finalized, as they're being written and rewritten, as they're being refined and commented upon, we sometimes can discern the hand of the scribe or the hand of the of the priest or the hand of an interpretive community, modifying, smoothing, changing, but also contributing and also keeping together traditions. I have …”

    Stance, per Jev: said as the speaker’s own view

  12. 33:20 #8 Torah from Heaven · 3.0 · 89%#9 Torah is unchanging · 2.7 · 71%
    “You can see seams within the text as it grows and changes, so it is itself a dynamic growing text. And if Ibertikolar is right, and I think he is right, some of the texts that are so called to be like wanna Be or pseudo Jubilees text might also be signs of the growth …”

    Stance, per Jev: described or quoted, not clearly adopted

  13. 35:58 #8 Torah from Heaven · 2.9 · 82%#9 Torah is unchanging · 2.4 · 47%
    “But we get emerging if you will, of the texts, and there are many recognizable pzuchem, if you will, that are embedded, or traditions that are embedded, and they're recontextualized again and again and again. Now, early on, figures like Vachholder and Bencion Wachholder and others kind of said, oh, this is a replacement of …”

    Stance, per Jev: said as the speaker’s own view

  14. 40:35 #8 Torah from Heaven · 3.1 · 96%#9 Torah is unchanging · 3.0 · 92%
    “First of all, normativity is a topic that I would want to problematize for us, because we need to think and rethink what normativity is, and also the proliferation of law and meaning and practice, of course, but there's something else that's really important here with respect to the period, which is to understand the …”

    Stance, per Jev: described or quoted, not clearly adopted

  15. 44:11 #8 Torah from Heaven · 3.2 · 94%#9 Torah is unchanging · 3.0 · 83%
    “I'm less convinced, but there's something deep about his insight, which is the canon is forming, and it's forming, perhaps in different ways for different communities, but it's forming. Nevertheless, we don't have to wait to track tape patro when we say who wrote what to really argue that we have something like an emerged …”

    Stance, per Jev: said as the speaker’s own view

  16. 46:50 #8 Torah from Heaven · 3.1 · 94%#9 Torah is unchanging · 3.3 · 97%
    “So the fixity or the fact that some text settle and our generate other texts, doesn't mean that the textual tradition itself becomes rigid, nor does it mean that the legal traditions or the normative ritual practice associated with those texts are fixed. In time, it allows for Judaism to define itself again and again.”

    Stance, per Jev: said as the speaker’s own view

  17. 49:54 #7 Moses' prophecy · 2.4 · 56%#8 Torah from Heaven · 3.1 · 95%#9 Torah is unchanging · 3.1 · 94%
    “The problem started when I was studying at Harvard and people just assumed that Deuteronomy was a forgery because of course Moses didn't write it, and it's just derivative or its propaganda like the rest of the Deuteronomistic history. And I didn't understand, Like, I just didn't understand, why would you think it's a forgery?”

    Stance, per Jev: raised in order to argue against it

  18. 53:00 #6 Prophecy · 2.5 · 62%#7 Moses' prophecy · 2.9 · 85%#8 Torah from Heaven · 3.4 · 99%#9 Torah is unchanging · 3.2 · 94%
    “We know about this from the rabbis, but we also have come to understand that this claim that materials go back to Sinai or the scribes are are correcting as a way of authorizing and underwriting the practices of writing and correction, or the apologies for Isaiah or Daniel. We know, we know that it …”

    Stance, per Jev: said as the speaker’s own view

  19. 55:56 #7 Moses' prophecy · 2.3 · 51%#8 Torah from Heaven · 3.3 · 99%#9 Torah is unchanging · 3.0 · 87%
    “And if we find out right you know that Mosha did or didn't write a text right, or that you know it didn't bother the rabbis, for example, that it might have been Joshua Yehoshua who wrote the end of Seyfrid Varreim, this didn't bother them because it wasn't about whether or not he authored …”

    Stance, per Jev: said as the speaker’s own view

  20. 59:00 #8 Torah from Heaven · 2.9 · 84%
    “But of course, the problem with our conversation today is that it's sort of radically complicated the question of authorship and composition and who would be responsible for the ultimate generation of the text. So I actually don't know how to exactly formulate this particular yeah, but if you could answer it, despite the halting …”

    Stance, per Jev: no clear stance

  21. 1:02:18 #8 Torah from Heaven · 2.7 · 76%#9 Torah is unchanging · 2.4 · 52%
    “It's also to understand these questions of assembly, of refinement, of fixity, and of growth of scripture. So in a way I've been thinking with Filo now since I was in graduate school.”

    Stance, per Jev: said as the speaker’s own view

  22. 1:05:16 #8 Torah from Heaven · 2.4 · 66%
    “We don't know if he was a school that produced some of the work or if it was his hand. And in a way it doesn't really matter, like the Rembrandt school and its legacy.”

    Stance, per Jev: said as the speaker’s own view

81. The Revolutions of 1782 | Dr. Shmuel Feiner

11 Dec 2025 · 70 min · 18 sections · 1 flagged · transcript: Spreaker

1 flagged moment
  1. 44:54 #8 Torah from Heaven · 2.0 · 45%
    “He created, without being aware, he created the modern Jewish intellectual, meaning the intellectual who is not part of the orbanical need, who does not rely on his authority as a wherebi, who is not rely on let's say, religious texts, but only on his belief, his way of reading the historical context of his …”

    Stance, per Jev: said as the speaker’s own view

80. Contemporary Attitudes | Dr. Alon Goshen-Gottstein (Universalism & Particularism #5)

04 Dec 2025 · 57 min · 18 sections · 5 flagged · transcript: Spreaker

5 flagged moments
  1. 17:48 #2 God is one · 1.9 · 44%#5 Worship God alone · 2.0 · 43%
    “But I built it Uncovenant in a much more expansive sense, in a sense that maintains the original commitment to God and enhances it through dimensions of meanings rather than being brought from contemporary philosophy that seek to empower the human person in partnership with God, and partnership for sax and Greenberg is a very …”

    Stance, per Jev: said as the speaker’s own view

  2. 21:19 #5 Worship God alone · 1.8 · 41%#6 Prophecy · 2.0 · 43%#7 Moses' prophecy · 2.5 · 70%
    “Pluralism is parallel in theory, equally valid paths to go a past of the spiritual life or revelations depending on the nuance, all of which achieved the same thing. Now, pluralism has multiple particularities.”

    Stance, per Jev: described or quoted, not clearly adopted

  3. 40:52 #7 Moses' prophecy · 1.8 · 51%
    “It's much better to be engaged in processes of growth and to have the humility that we all grow together, and to put aside the question of superiority, recognizing that our particularity comes across simply through our experience of God, and to the extent that God is with us in a special way than our …”

    Stance, per Jev: said as the speaker’s own view

  4. 45:56 #2 God is one · 2.6 · 72%#5 Worship God alone · 2.2 · 56%
    “I have a book that basically calls same God, other God, which I try to reframe the question of adasa rah with strong impact of them a h the impact of Avedazaah. Not as are they legitimate?”

    Stance, per Jev: said as the speaker’s own view

  5. 50:55 #5 Worship God alone · 1.9 · 43%
    “So in this museum we're designing, I'm planning and having a section where people if we can realize this technology, people can speak to let's say twelve figures from different religions whose corpus we're going to upload to AI and they can address their contemporary questions to them and see what the AI comes up …”

    Stance, per Jev: said as the speaker’s own view

79. Early Modern Attitudes | Dr. Jeremy Fogel (Universalism & Particularism #4)

21 Nov 2025 · 71 min · 21 sections · 10 flagged · transcript: Spreaker

10 flagged moments
  1. 3:43 #9 Torah is unchanging · 2.8 · 73%
    “And I always try to encourage people to realize that Judaism as a historical phenomenon is always changing. You know, there's a semi pagan cult of sacrifices on the Temple Mount, and then there's a revolutionary a rabbinic movement, and then there's the highly as tract philosophical Judaism of Rambam, and there's the mythical Judaism …”

    Stance, per Jev: said as the speaker’s own view

  2. 9:50 #6 Prophecy · 1.9 · 50%#7 Moses' prophecy · 2.8 · 85%#9 Torah is unchanging · 1.7 · 43%
    “Wolf the Great Metaphysician gives this lecture about how, you know, civil philosophy of China is superior to the European one. He gets kicked out of university because how could they be superior to us if they don't have Christianity.”

    Stance, per Jev: said as the speaker’s own view

  3. 12:38 #6 Prophecy · 2.7 · 75%#7 Moses' prophecy · 2.4 · 65%#8 Torah from Heaven · 2.5 · 60%#9 Torah is unchanging · 2.1 · 42%
    “We're talking about equality and you're walking around being superior because you're the chosen people were thinking about universalistic ethics and you're focused on the particularistic ethics of the Alha and you know, we want a world of reason, and you keep clinging onto your mythological, ancient, sanctified books. Of course, the great hero or …”

    Stance, per Jev: described or quoted, not clearly adopted

  4. 15:51 #1 God exists · 2.1 · 40%#2 God is one · 2.7 · 66%#4 God is eternal · 2.1 · 44%#5 Worship God alone · 2.3 · 48%#6 Prophecy · 3.2 · 85%#7 Moses' prophecy · 3.6 · 97%#8 Torah from Heaven · 3.3 · 89%#9 Torah is unchanging · 3.3 · 89%#10 God knows our deeds · 1.8 · 42%#11 Reward and punishment · 3.1 · 82%#12 The Messiah · 2.6 · 66%#13 Resurrection · 1.6 · 42%
    “That's of course more in the theological political treatise, whereas Pinoza will depict Judaism as you know, essentially a political movement, a national movement, moses like Alexander Great and other leaders which you know, plenty of such leaders we can bring to the mind even today that use the image of proximity to God for …”

    Stance, per Jev: said as the speaker’s own view

  5. 20:35 #6 Prophecy · 3.6 · 96%#7 Moses' prophecy · 3.9 · 100%#8 Torah from Heaven · 3.9 · 100%#9 Torah is unchanging · 3.4 · 89%#11 Reward and punishment · 3.3 · 87%
    “So Moses is just another leader that uses a sense of proximity to God to push for overd his political agenda. And he has a brilliant idea of Moses.”

    Stance, per Jev: said as the speaker’s own view

  6. 23:47 #1 God exists · 2.3 · 50%#2 God is one · 2.1 · 50%#6 Prophecy · 3.7 · 95%#7 Moses' prophecy · 3.8 · 98%#8 Torah from Heaven · 3.9 · 100%#9 Torah is unchanging · 3.6 · 95%#10 God knows our deeds · 2.0 · 53%#11 Reward and punishment · 3.0 · 78%
    “The Alaha is a political ploy for complete domination by a certain kind of leadership. And it's something that is that that generates a learned helplessness, right, It makes people passive.”

    Stance, per Jev: described or quoted, not clearly adopted

  7. 32:47 #11 Reward and punishment · 2.0 · 47%
    “And then you know, I walk down the street and I've got like a piano falling on my head, and if I were a good person or a creep or whatever doesn't matter now, and that doesn't make any sense, doesn't make any sense. So there has to be a life eternal.”

    Stance, per Jev: described or quoted, not clearly adopted

  8. 40:00 #1 God exists · 2.2 · 50%#2 God is one · 2.4 · 54%#6 Prophecy · 2.4 · 68%#7 Moses' prophecy · 2.2 · 60%#8 Torah from Heaven · 2.7 · 76%#9 Torah is unchanging · 2.0 · 46%
    “Right, Mendossin believes for arguments that aren't awfully original, that you know, God gave on Mount Sinai Torah, and here I completely disagree with the interpreditions that started with kant And and there's a contemporary scholars as well that Menderssine is a hidden days who pretended to be a traditionalist Jew for his for whatever …”

    Stance, per Jev: said as the speaker’s own view

  9. 59:49 #9 Torah is unchanging · 2.9 · 89%
    “He might one day choose to rebuild the sovereignty with another people. You know, that's just what God does.”

    Stance, per Jev: described or quoted, not clearly adopted

  10. 1:02:39 #7 Moses' prophecy · 2.0 · 59%#8 Torah from Heaven · 1.6 · 44%
    “He says explicitly that Providence might very well have made available to other cultures different means. Oh yeah, thats exactly my point, right.”

    Stance, per Jev: described or quoted, not clearly adopted

78. Medieval Attitudes | Dr. Menachem Kellner (Universalism & Particularism #3)

13 Nov 2025 · 72 min · 22 sections · 4 flagged · transcript: Spreaker

4 flagged moments
  1. 19:59 #8 Torah from Heaven · 2.4 · 67%#9 Torah is unchanging · 1.9 · 42%
    “If it had been a shaman in Nevada today, a Navajo who was the first human being after the corruption of humanity after the flood to rediscover God, then the Torah would have been given in the Navajo language. The narratives of the Torah would reflect the history of the Navajou people, the holokhauv of …”

    Stance, per Jev: described or quoted, not clearly adopted

  2. 23:48 #8 Torah from Heaven · 2.8 · 77%#9 Torah is unchanging · 3.3 · 91%
    “Now that means there's it could have been different, just like the laws of Juraism could have been different if they have been given in a different period.”

    Stance, per Jev: said as the speaker’s own view

  3. 40:20 #11 Reward and punishment · 2.4 · 63%
    “Rambam the philosopher has no way to keep him out.”

    Stance, per Jev: raised in order to argue against it

  4. 1:02:00 #8 Torah from Heaven · 2.1 · 47%
    “Various passages have been excised or simply changed a little bit. Doesn't take a lot of work to change them to make them sound from more religious, which is why it's important to use a correct text, because very often his text has been subjected to for Titians for our bessert translated and improved.”

    Stance, per Jev: described or quoted, not clearly adopted

77. Rabbinic Attitudes | Dr. Marc Hirshman (Universalism & Particularism #2)

07 Nov 2025 · 60 min · 18 sections · 2 flagged · transcript: Spreaker

2 flagged moments
  1. 39:53 #6 Prophecy · 2.6 · 61%
    “Once the rabbis decided that Torah was the arbiter and understanding Torah, prophecy was gone.”

    Stance, per Jev: described or quoted, not clearly adopted

  2. 43:36 #6 Prophecy · 2.3 · 41%
    “Tadbaba, who also has a strong sense of prophecy, was that because it's later, or is this and there was a stream within rabbinic Judas called the hasid dien which Cephrai and others have written about, who thought that the Holy Word was still accessible. There was a real minor stream.”

    Stance, per Jev: said as the speaker’s own view

76. Biblical Attitudes | Dr. Ethan Schwartz (Universalism & Particularism #1)

30 Oct 2025 · 64 min · 22 sections · 4 flagged · transcript: Spreaker

4 flagged moments
  1. 22:03 #8 Torah from Heaven · 2.2 · 41%
    “Right there are entire sections of the Book of Proverbs that look like they were copy and pasted from Egyptian Egyptian wisdom collections. I'm not saying that literal copy and paste is necessarily, like, you know, the exact best model of how to explain that, but the similarities are profound.”

    Stance, per Jev: said as the speaker’s own view

  2. 54:18 #9 Torah is unchanging · 2.6 · 72%
    “But so he's talking about why now that Christ has come, right, the law is not necessary at a minimum for these people that he's talking to, right, and that they can have a relationship with.”

    Stance, per Jev: described or quoted, not clearly adopted

  3. 56:56 #5 Worship God alone · 2.2 · 58%#7 Moses' prophecy · 2.1 · 58%#9 Torah is unchanging · 3.5 · 92%
    “So Paul says, now that faith has come, we are no longer subject to a disciplinarian, that is to say, the law right the Torah. For in Christ Jesus, you are all children of God through faith.”

    Stance, per Jev: described or quoted, not clearly adopted

  4. 1:00:24 #9 Torah is unchanging · 2.1 · 47%
    “Right, once anybody in principle has access to a covenantal relationship with God through faith, and it's no longer restricted to a particular ethnic group. You can't not not buying into.”

    Stance, per Jev: said as the speaker’s own view

3. Dogma and Heresy | Dr. Marc Shapiro

04 May 2023 · 62 min · 21 sections · 7 flagged · transcript: local Whisper

7 flagged moments
  1. 18:21 #7 Moses' prophecy · 2.6 · 63%
    “So, you know, one imagines sort of belief in the resurrection of the dead, although belief in God's absolute unparalleled unity, or things like that, which are, I mean, the unity position perhaps, but perhaps the belief in the supremacy of the prophecy of Moshe, these seem to be odd, or not necessarily what one …”

    Stance, per Jev: described or quoted, not clearly adopted

  2. 21:04 #7 Moses' prophecy · 2.6 · 66%
    “There's certain Drosic passages that imply that, that say, actually, that the Mashiach will be greater, and we have figures who claim that the Messiah will be greater than Moses. So why the insistence on that, people have claimed that this is direct response to Islam.”

    Stance, per Jev: described or quoted, not clearly adopted

  3. 24:02 #7 Moses' prophecy · 2.3 · 57%
    “But I mean, whether you believe Moses is the greatest prophet, let's say you're wrong on that. Why should that remove you from immortality?”

    Stance, per Jev: raised in order to argue against it

  4. 35:02 #8 Torah from Heaven · 1.7 · 42%#9 Torah is unchanging · 2.1 · 56%
    “The Ramam proposes it because if he's saying, and this is quite well known, Ramam believes that the Torah is to be understood slightly differently in different generations in the sense that now we have a more advanced philosophical understanding of religion and therefore certain texts have to be reinterpreted in certain ways. But that …”

    Stance, per Jev: described or quoted, not clearly adopted

  5. 39:58 #3 God is incorporeal · 2.6 · 57%
    “By definition, God can have a physical form. A physical God is going to be subject to corruption and it can't be perfect.”

    Stance, per Jev: described or quoted, not clearly adopted

  6. 42:39 #3 God is incorporeal · 2.9 · 79%
    “Shaddal says that this is the biblical teaching and the rabbinic teaching that God is a physical form, but the most perfect physical form as can be imagined. But a physical form nonetheless.”

    Stance, per Jev: described or quoted, not clearly adopted

  7. 50:07 #8 Torah from Heaven · 2.1 · 41%
    “Well, but it's a basic principle in Kabul, the idea of Gilgal, and in the Biawah Hasidin, they add on the capitalistic teachings were given to Moshe Rabinu. That's a new principle of faith.”

    Stance, per Jev: described or quoted, not clearly adopted

2. Theodicy and Job | Dr. Jon D. Levenson

19 Apr 2023 · 69 min · 25 sections · 22 flagged · transcript: local Whisper

22 flagged moments
  1. 0:00 #3 God is incorporeal · 1.6 · 46%#11 Reward and punishment · 2.9 · 94%
    “This book appears to be written in order to address the age old topic or of theodicy, or the phenomenon of innocent people who undergo undeserved suffering. Yet, as might be expected, this work does not provide anything like an easy way out of this religious conundrum, and ultimately leaves the reader with far more …”

    Stance, per Jev: described or quoted, not clearly adopted

  2. 2:45 #11 Reward and punishment · 3.0 · 96%
    “And Job is left with absolutely nothing, and yet he retains his piety and refuses to curse God. I think you have a second quite similar scene in heaven in which God again brags, and Satan says, "Ah, but if you let me afflict his body with illnesses, then Job will surely fold, and surely …”

    Stance, per Jev: described or quoted, not clearly adopted

  3. 8:08 #6 Prophecy · 2.5 · 64%#11 Reward and punishment · 2.5 · 68%
    “That's very interesting and especially because the religiosity of Job he's seen or he's presented as an exemplar of religious excellence except of course he doesn't fulfill any of the precepts, any of the misvod that are seen as hallmarks of religious excellence often throughout the rest of the Hebrew Bible and therefore this seems …”

    Stance, per Jev: said as the speaker’s own view

  4. 14:21 #8 Torah from Heaven · 1.9 · 46%#9 Torah is unchanging · 2.1 · 50%
    “The lack of a resolution or solution at the end, maybe someone thought, "I'd better revise this and stick something in there that solves that issue," whether he succeeded or is a other question. So I don't even say when was it written well, it's probably not all written at once.”

    Stance, per Jev: said as the speaker’s own view

  5. 17:12 #11 Reward and punishment · 2.6 · 76%
    “The narrative in which the innocent sufferer is restored and gets back what he lost and lives to a ripe old age of 140 and dies happily. So I would say it's full of theological ideas, the logic debating theological ideas.”

    Stance, per Jev: said as the speaker’s own view

  6. 20:08 #11 Reward and punishment · 3.0 · 98%
    “And that presents to me the sharpest possible case of a righteous person who has suffering, the best person, worst suffering for the flimsiest possible excuse. Is that what is going on?”

    Stance, per Jev: raised in order to argue against it

  7. 22:54 #11 Reward and punishment · 2.5 · 75%
    “And then very, very quickly, everything becomes horrendous to a degree which is hard to believe that could all happen at once. So I think that's right.”

    Stance, per Jev: said as the speaker’s own view

  8. 25:15 #11 Reward and punishment · 2.7 · 74%
    “Because it seems, as you say, from the plain text that he is of the greatest possible caliber in terms of his conduct. They're trying to engage in Sidu Gudin and the justification of the Divine Judgment.”

    Stance, per Jev: described or quoted, not clearly adopted

  9. 27:51 #3 God is incorporeal · 1.7 · 41%#11 Reward and punishment · 2.8 · 86%
    “Is he really righteous if he's only acting as a conditioned animal? Does the word, does the name Pavlov ring any bells for you?”

    Stance, per Jev: said as the speaker’s own view

  10. 30:52 #11 Reward and punishment · 3.0 · 96%
    “He's presented as resulting in a severing of that nexus of good deed and reward. He's now going to experience adversity.”

    Stance, per Jev: said as the speaker’s own view

  11. 33:51 #11 Reward and punishment · 3.0 · 96%
    “And here comes along the book of Job, or at least the Satan in the book of Job with God's tacit approval, that that is suspect and ought to be tested if not denigrated. What does the view that people have that there's an ethic of that deed, consequence, nexus, that is very prominent in …”

    Stance, per Jev: raised in order to argue against it

  12. 36:39 #11 Reward and punishment · 3.0 · 96%
    “And a personal God is not a change machine where you always get out the equivalent of what you put in. On the other hand, having said all that, it's certainly true that Job is trying very, very high, hard, the book of Job is trying very, very hard to question that whole notion to …”

    Stance, per Jev: said as the speaker’s own view

  13. 39:18 #3 God is incorporeal · 1.5 · 40%#11 Reward and punishment · 3.0 · 96%
    “He referring to God, laughs at the suffering of the innocent. It's not just he allows the innocent suffer.”

    Stance, per Jev: described or quoted, not clearly adopted

  14. 42:00 #8 Torah from Heaven · 2.6 · 74%#9 Torah is unchanging · 2.4 · 56%#11 Reward and punishment · 2.4 · 67%
    “I mean, if that's true, it could very well be that somebody saw the older story and just thought it was too saccharin, too sweet and not realistic enough and took a knife and split it in half and inserted it in the middle, spliced in this angry, impatient Job and his, as you say, …”

    Stance, per Jev: said as the speaker’s own view

  15. 44:39 #8 Torah from Heaven · 1.9 · 43%#11 Reward and punishment · 2.6 · 68%
    “It's really not true that from the beginning that those three comforters are just telling Job, "You're a miserable disgusting sinner, why don't you just admit it?" The truth is that they have a fairly supple conception of adversity. Sometimes they see it as judgment for sin, it's punishment, okay?”

    Stance, per Jev: raised in order to argue against it

  16. 47:29 #11 Reward and punishment · 2.2 · 59%
    “And sometimes they take it as something that can happen, especially the beginning, to the righteous, something that one should simply bear with trust, confidence, betachon, the God will eventually restore the person. And those wait patiently for God to restore you.”

    Stance, per Jev: described or quoted, not clearly adopted

  17. 50:25 #11 Reward and punishment · 2.6 · 78%
    “It's not your piety or confidence, your integrity, your hope." And he says, "Think now what innocent man ever perished." Now you're right. When Job hears that, "Wait a minute, I am an innocent man." On the one hand, that is galling.”

    Stance, per Jev: said as the speaker’s own view

  18. 52:50 #11 Reward and punishment · 2.7 · 87%
    “Now if you think about it from the standpoint of the people who are supposed to be reading this book, not as a realistic historical psychological book, but as something that helps to the situation of suffering, do you ever really know why you've suffered when you have a catastrophe?”

    Stance, per Jev: described or quoted, not clearly adopted

  19. 55:35 #11 Reward and punishment · 3.4 · 99%
    “It doesn't, justice for human beings is not the center of the situation. I'll give you an analogy if I have a minute to do this.”

    Stance, per Jev: said as the speaker’s own view

  20. 58:20 #11 Reward and punishment · 3.2 · 99%
    “Job is restored and his comforters, who had so often asserted that deed consequence nexus, are said to be in the wrong. And Job lives happily after to the age of 140.”

    Stance, per Jev: said as the speaker’s own view

  21. 1:01:03 #1 God exists · 2.3 · 54%#11 Reward and punishment · 2.8 · 86%
    “And God is small or maybe not even on the scene at all. And so the God that Job said would never show up in the spirit of his ever showing up.”

    Stance, per Jev: raised in order to argue against it

  22. 1:03:43 #11 Reward and punishment · 3.0 · 95%
    “And the so that in the last analysis, the deconseless nexus is re-instituted, but with a serious qualification, some suffering we now know can be probative, it can be a test, and we don't have to take suffering and adversity as signs of sin. They may be signs of sin.”

    Stance, per Jev: said as the speaker’s own view

1. Hasidut | Dr. Ariel Mayse

22 Mar 2023 · 66 min · 22 sections · 9 flagged · transcript: local Whisper

9 flagged moments
  1. 2:49 #5 Worship God alone · 2.5 · 68%
    “So the major ideas of Hasidism are well known, and of course you've pointed out several of them, you're the social dimensions, the idea of a charismatic leader as the central authority, the Tzadik, the holy person, or the Reba, as the kind of nucleus of the Hasidic cell, that for sure is an important …”

    Stance, per Jev: said as the speaker’s own view

  2. 5:49 #2 God is one · 2.3 · 56%#3 God is incorporeal · 2.3 · 57%
    “In Hasidism uplifts prayer as a moment of awakening, as a moment of embodied encounter with the divine, one in which the voice of God and the voice of the human being become interwoven one with the other. So this is another key development of Hasidism.”

    Stance, per Jev: described or quoted, not clearly adopted

  3. 9:07 #2 God is one · 2.9 · 81%#3 God is incorporeal · 3.0 · 91%
    “The Zohar's own way of seeing everything in the physical world is connected to the spiritual, and everything in the spiritual is having physical manifestations. That's true of God, that's true of all aspects of the cosmos that are, again, filled with this kind of divinity.”

    Stance, per Jev: described or quoted, not clearly adopted

  4. 28:57 #3 God is incorporeal · 2.2 · 64%
    “God is in need of human action, and each one of the commandments fulfills that divine need in a different kind of way. And all the details really, really matter.”

    Stance, per Jev: described or quoted, not clearly adopted

  5. 31:44 #2 God is one · 2.4 · 56%#5 Worship God alone · 2.1 · 47%
    “At least to me, this notion that the Hasidic attitude towards the Mitzvot, towards the commandments, takes, in a certain fundamental way, takes the side of, let's say, my monadian rationalistic position against the earlier capitalistic position, because generally, I mean, one finds that even today when Hasidim are about to perform a certain Mitzvah, …”

    Stance, per Jev: said as the speaker’s own view

  6. 34:55 #9 Torah is unchanging · 2.0 · 45%
    “And that when there are these kind of, if unstable in the sense of, you know, humanity is constantly trying to rework its philosophical positions and we're moving toward a greater understanding, he has a kind of flexible theology. He understands what the ceremonial script of Judaism, that's his phrase, the ceremonial script of Judaism, …”

    Stance, per Jev: described or quoted, not clearly adopted

  7. 37:57 #3 God is incorporeal · 2.9 · 82%
    “And yet here is lots of lines about God's head or here is the do that trickles down God's beard or the 300, you know, descriptions of the wrinkles on the divine forehead, etc, etc that we have in the address. So the yes and dimension of this is in, I think it's in the …”

    Stance, per Jev: described or quoted, not clearly adopted

  8. 47:26 #2 God is one · 2.7 · 79%#3 God is incorporeal · 1.6 · 44%#5 Worship God alone · 1.6 · 40%
    “He stitches together thought and action and it's that that transforms his actions into religious ones or better, imbues them with a religious meaning, it is transformative, cosmological, theergic, it's also the unification of Kuchadri who ishchinte, it's the blessed holy one and the feminine aspect of the divine coming together. But Enoch is so …”

    Stance, per Jev: said as the speaker’s own view

  9. 53:11 #5 Worship God alone · 2.4 · 58%
    “He is the great pillar upon which the world stands. He is the illuminated master.”

    Stance, per Jev: said as the speaker’s own view

0. Prologue

13 Mar 2023 · 7 min · 3 sections · 0 flagged · transcript: local Whisper

Still transcribing

These 78 episodes have no transcript in the feed, so they're running through Whisper on my own machine. They'll show up here when they're done.

● The Workshop · weekly

Everything I build, in one email a week.

Torah tools, daf games and AI experiments, with the story behind each one. Sign up and this week’s issue arrives within the hour.