Daf Yomi Arcade · Bekhorot 59 · בכורות נ״ט

Two Doors

To tithe his flock, the owner drives his lambs into a pen and lets them out one at a time under the rod. Every tenth is sacred. But what if the pen has two doors, and the lambs don't all reach ten at the same one? Rava answers with one rule: מִנְיָן הָרָאוּי פּוֹטֵר, a tally that is fit to reach ten exempts (59b:6). If you were counted at a moment when enough lambs were left to make ten at your door, you're free, even if the ten never came.

tenth: tithe exempt counted, not yet fit waits for the next gathering

1. Fourteen lambs, two doors

Rava gives three ways fourteen lambs can split between the doors, and for each, two endings (59b:12–15). The setup has already happened. Read the ending, call the fate of each group, then let them out.

2. Run the pen

Now you drive the lambs. Pick a flock, send lambs through a door one at a time, let a lamb die if the case calls for it, and end the gathering when you're done. Each lamb is judged the moment it passes: its door's count plus the lambs still in the pen. If that reaches ten, it's fit and exempt.

The pen runs Rava's rule as one mechanical test. The Gemara rules on the cases in the goals; if you find some new way to split a flock, that's this game's reading, not a ruling.

3. The shepherd's slip

Counting out loud is easy to get wrong. The daf weighs what happens when the shepherd calls the ninth lamb "tenth!" (59a:3–59b:5). Rava holds that a real tenth left standing in the pen is holy on its own, even though it never walked out (59a:2). Stamp each lamb on the tape.

Break the kal va-ḥomer

Rabbi Shimon ben Yehuda, in the name of Rabbi Shimon, says a ninth lamb called "tenth" stays ordinary unless the real tenth was called "ninth." His logic (59b:1–2): the eleventh, called "tenth," becomes a peace offering only if the tenth's name was taken off it. So surely the ninth, which only waits for a blemish, needs that too. The Gemara gives two ways the ninth and the eleventh differ. Pick both.

Learn the real daf

  • Bekhorot 59a and 59b on Sefaria
  • Rashi (40 comments) on the two doors, including his line that the six left in the pen "can be thrown here or there," which is what makes the tally only possibly fit
  • Ktav Yad Rashi (38), Rabbeinu Gershom (29) and Steinsaltz (25)
  • The ruling in the Rambam: Mishneh Torah, Firstlings 8
  • The mishna behind the slips: Mishna Bekhorot 9:8 (the ninth, tenth and eleventh), and the verse Lev. 27:32, "whatever passes under the rod," which Rava reads as "not what has already passed"
  • The opening of the amud: Abba Elazar ben Gomel's tithe "by estimate and by thought," and Rabbi Yosei son of Rabbi Yehuda, for whom an uncounted animal set aside as tithe is still tithe (59a:1)

● The Workshop · weekly

Everything I build, in one email a week.

Torah tools, daf games and AI experiments, with the story behind each one. Sign up and this week’s issue arrives within the hour.