Daf Yomi Arcade · Bekhorot 57 · בכורות נ״ז

Under the Rod

Once a year (well, three times) the shepherd herds the year's newborns into a pen, and they file out one by one under his rod. Every tenth gets a dab of red ochre: it is holy. Today's daf asks who gets into the pen at all, and which lambs are counted together.

1 · Work the gate

The mishna: הַכֹּל נִכְנָסִין לַדִּיר לְהִתְעַשֵּׂר, everything enters the pen to be tithed, except five (57a:6). The Gemara takes the exclusions from the verse on offerings, "under its mother," via a gezeira shava with the tithe's "under the rod" (57a:7–8). Admit each animal, or turn it away by tapping the words that exclude it.

Leviticus 22:27 (offerings)

Leviticus 27:32 (animal tithe)

2 · Two students of Rabbi Yehoshua

A baraita: Rabbi Elazar of Bartota, quoting Rabbi Yehoshua, keeps only some of the mishna's five out of the pen. Rabbi Akiva says he heard from Rabbi Yehoshua that the rest are excluded too (57a:17). Tap each chip to set what Rabbi Elazar of Bartota excludes.

3 · Ten lambs for a dog

Rabbi Yoḥanan holds that brothers who split an estate are purchasers from each other, not heirs each receiving what was "always" his; they even return the land to each other at the Jubilee (57a:1–3). The Gemara tests the other view, retroactive designation (bereira), against a baraita. Two partners split their flock: one takes ten lambs, the other nine lambs and a dog. All ten lambs are forbidden on the altar as "the price of a dog" (Deut. 23:19). With bereira, why not say one lamb was the price of the dog and free the other nine (57a:4)?

Tap a lamb to make it "the one that paid for the dog."

4 · The year wheel

The animal tithe has three gorens, "threshing floors" for the herd (57b:6–7): Rabbi Akiva puts them near Pesach, Shavuot and Sukkot; Ben Azzai on 29 Adar, 1 Sivan and 29 Av; Rabbi Elazar and Rabbi Shimon on 1 Nisan, 1 Sivan and 29 Elul (not 1 Tishrei, which is Rosh HaShana, a festival on which one can't tithe). But a goren doesn't split the count. Only the new year does (57b:8–9):

  • Rabbi Meir: the tithe year begins 1 Elul.
  • Rabbi Elazar & Rabbi Shimon: it begins 1 Tishrei.
  • Ben Azzai: since we don't know which, lambs born in Elul are tithed by themselves.

Free pasture

Move two lambs around the year and watch all three lamps.

5 · Reports from Arkat Leveina

Rabbi Yishmael ben Satriel of Arkat Leveina testified before Rabbi Yehuda HaNasi: back home, when a ewe dies giving birth, they flay her and dress the newborn in her hide. "You've told me the reason for the mishna," said Rebbi: the hide stands in for the mother (57b:3). Then he kept testifying (57b:4–5). Tap each report.

Learn the real daf

● The Workshop · weekly

Everything I build, in one email a week.

Torah tools, daf games and AI experiments, with the story behind each one. Sign up and this week’s issue arrives within the hour.