Daf Yomi Arcade · Bekhorot 56 · בכורות נ״ו
מָה בָּנֶיךָ — אֵין בְּלָקוּחַ וּבְמַתָּנָה
Bekhorot 56 asks whose animals owe the animal tithe. A bought or gifted animal is exempt, because the flock is compared to "your son", and you can't buy a firstborn son. Then two brothers inherit their father's coins and goats. Whether they owe the tithe, the kalbon (the premium added to the half-shekel), both, or neither depends on what they have divided.
Score: 0 / 0 right on the first try
"So you shall do with your oxen and with your sheep… on the eighth day you shall give it to Me" (Ex. 22:28–29). The verse puts the flock next to "the firstborn of your sons", so whatever animal it means can't be bought or received as a gift, just like a son. But which animal is it? Five suspects. Ask the questions the Gemara asks, one trait of "your son" at a time, and flip down every card that doesn't match (56a:1–5). Fewer questions is better.
Ask the verse:
You can't buy a son at all. So why does Rabbi Asi say in Rabbi Yoḥanan's name that ten fetuses bought in the womb all go into the pen to be tithed? Rava and Rabbi Elazar (who saw Rabbi Yoḥanan in a dream) answer from the same verse: "So you shall do." Buying only exempts an animal if it happens at the "time of doing" (56a:6–10). Tap a moment on the lamb's life to sell it then, and rule.
A baraita says a prostitute's fee "that he gave her and then bought back from her" goes into the pen. But bought animals are exempt! The answer: he gave it while it was still in the womb, and bought it back from a gentile prostitute (56a:11–56b:2). Why not a Jewish one, who could tithe it herself? Because of Abaye, whose two rulings point in opposite directions (56b:3–6). Fill in his board.
The mishna: חַיָּיבִין בַּקָּלְבּוֹן — פְּטוּרִין מִמַּעְשַׂר בְּהֵמָה. Brothers who owe the kalbon are exempt from the animal tithe, and brothers who owe the tithe are exempt from the kalbon (56b:7–8). Partners pay the kalbon, while a single owner, like a father, owes the tithe. "That shall be yours" (Ex. 13:12) excludes partners, and "shall be" brings back an undivided inheritance (56b:9–10). Rabbi Yirmeya says all four combinations happen (56b:11–14). Divide or reunite the estate, predict both lamps, and collect all four.
Your prediction:
Rabbi Yirmeya's four:
They divided, then joined up again. Does the old single estate come back, or are they strangers who have pooled their animals? It depends on how they divided (56b:16–21). The father left 18 large goats and 20 kids, and 9 large goats are worth 10 kids. Big 🐐 are large goats and small 🐐 are kids. Tap an animal to move it between the brothers, then rejoin and read the four amora'im.
Reuven
Shimon