daf yomi arcade ·bekhorot 42·2026-10-30

Omit the Tumtum

סְמִי מִיכָּן טוּמְטוּם

Six times the Gemara says "strike the tumtum from this baraita," and once it can't. Take the red pen, fix a list that comes up one short, test where an animal urinates, and follow the tumtum through betrothal and ḥalitza.

Score: 0 / 0

1 · The red pen

Rabbi Yoḥanan's question is whether a tumtum (genitals concealed) is a person of doubtful sex or a third kind of creature, like a hermaphrodite. Each baraita seems to treat it as a third kind. The Gemara's fix is to cross out the word. For each baraita, what does the Gemara do?

2 · Five animals, now four

Rabbi Elazar's baraita says five animals are neither consecrated nor make others consecrated (42a:10). Tap the tumtum to strike it, then see the count.

5 listed. Strike the tumtum.

3 · Where does it urinate?

A firstborn animal with concealed genitals. Rabbi Elazar rules by where it urinates, and the Gemara says that only follows one Sage (42b:2). Set the three controls and read the lamp.

male place female place

Why would the Rabbis still worry?

4 · The tumtum in marriage

The baraitot on betrothal and ḥalitza (42b:8-9). Because "since it changed, it changed" applies to everyone here, the two baraitot split on something else. Flip the switch for the dispute that explains them (42b:13).

Therefore:

The Gemara ends the amud with Rabbi Yehuda against Rabbi Yosei son of Rabbi Yehuda on a tumtum who was torn open and found male (42b:15-18), then asks Rava what practical difference remains. The answer is on the next daf.

Learn the real daf

The game only samples it. Read the whole page on Sefaria:

Simplified for play. The daf has more cases than the game shows. All daf games

● The Workshop · weekly

Everything I build, in one email a week.

Torah tools, daf games and AI experiments, with the story behind each one. Sign up and this week’s issue arrives within the hour.