daf yomi arcade ·bekhorot 36·2026-10-25
לָאו אֲנָא דִּיהֵיבְתֵּיהּ לָךְ?
A firstborn has a blemish, and the priest who will eat it says it happened by itself. Who is believed, and why? Hearsay, the better lie he could have told, a showdown with the masters of the shields at Yavne, a teaching garbled in transmission, and a Sage who forces his sore eyes open. Eight rounds, straight from the daf.
Score: 0 / 0
ROUND 1 · 36a:2–4
Is hearsay testimony (עֵד מִפִּי עֵד) accepted for a firstborn's blemish? Rav Asi forbids, Rav Ashi permits. Rav Asi quotes the school of Menashe against him. Rav Ashi answers by emending the baraita. Tap the gap to insert his reading.
אֵין עֵד מִפִּי עֵד כָּשֵׁר אֶלָּא לְעֵדוּת הָאִשָּׁה
“Hearsay is valid only for the testimony of a woman” (that her husband died).
ROUND 2 · 36a:5–11
Rabbi Ile'a: a priest brings an animal nobody knew was a firstborn and says “it's a firstborn, and its blemish came with it.” He is believed. Mar bar Rav Ashi objects with a donkey. The owner said: don't take the Nehar Pekod road, it has water; take Neresh, it's dry. The renter took Nehar Pekod, the donkey died, and he came back saying “I went by Nehar Pekod, but there was no water.” Tap the road he could have lied about instead.
ROUND 3 · 36a:12–16
Rabbi Tzadok, a learned priest, put barley in wicker baskets for his firstborn. While it ate, its lip split. He asks the same question three times: “Didn't we distinguish between a priest who is a ḥaver and one who is an ignoramus?” Predict each answer.
ROUND 4 · 36a:17–36b:3
Rav Yehuda in Rav's name: a priest is believed to say “an Israelite gave me this firstborn with its blemish,” because מִילְּתָא דַּעֲבִידָא לְאִיגַּלּוֹיֵי לָא מְשַׁקְּרִי אִינָשֵׁי: people don't lie about what is likely to come out. Rav Sheizevi tests it against the mishna in Demai (4:5). Rule on each agent.
ROUND 5 · 36b:4–6
Rabbi Yirmeya bar Abba hears Rav Yehuda's teaching and asks: where did Yehuda get that? “I set it in Giddul's mind, and Giddul set it in his own way.” The teaching travelled down the chain and arrived changed. Tap the tiles Giddul corrupted, then restore.
What arrived: “A priest is believed to say: an Israelite gave me this firstborn with its blemish.”
ROUND 6 · 36b:7–8
In Pumbedita, Rafram gave his firstborn calf to a priest unblemished. The priest blemished it. One day Rafram's eyes were sore, and the priest brought it to him for a ruling: “An Israelite gave me this firstborn with its blemish.” Hold the button (or Space) to force your eyes open, and while you can see, tap the two marks you remember on the calf you gave.
YOUR MEMORY
The calf I handed over was a firstborn with no blemish at all, a white star on its brow, and one black foreleg.
EYE STRAIN
Marks found: 0 / 2
ROUND 7 · 36b:9–15
A firstborn with one eye larger than the other comes before Rav Ashi. Nobody knows whether a priest or an Israelite brought it. Rav Yehuda's rule: don't examine an Israelite's firstborn unless a priest is there with him. Seat the priest, or don't.
ROUND 8 · 36b:16–22
Mishna: a firstborn whose eye was blinded, foreleg severed or hind leg broken may be slaughtered on the word of שְׁלֹשָׁה בְּנֵי הַכְּנֶסֶת, three ordinary synagogue-goers. Rabbi Yosei: even if twenty-three are there, only an expert. The Gemara narrows the first tanna twice (Rava; Rav Yehuda for Rabbi Yirmeya bar Abba). For each case, may the three permit it?
| Case | First tanna (as narrowed) | Rabbi Yosei |
|---|
Top works linked to this daf: