Daf Yomi Arcade, Bekhorot 23, 13 October 2026

The Last Eater

עַד שֶׁלֹּא יֹאכְלֶנָּה

A carcass is impure for as long as someone would still eat it. But who counts as someone? A ger toshav, a dog, or nobody at all? Bar Padda and Rabbi Yoḥanan disagree, and the answer depends on which creature is at the end of the line. Then the daf asks whether impurity that was swallowed by a majority can wake up, and whether a rule Rav gave about the anonymous Mishna has any exceptions.

Rulings right: 0

I. The line of eaters

Bar Padda reads Deuteronomy 14:21 ("give it to the ger who is within your gates") to mean that a carcass is only a carcass while a ger toshav could eat it. For severe impurity, the carcass stays impure that long. For light impurity, it stays impure until a dog would no longer eat it. Rabbi Yoḥanan says that both kinds stay impure until a dog would no longer eat it. Move the carcass down the line and rule for each sage.

Severity of the impurity

A dog

A ger toshav

Your ruling at this stage: is the carcass still an impurity-bearing carcass?

Bar Padda's reasoning is about what a ger toshav would eat. Rabbi Yoḥanan's reasoning is about the dog. The Gemara notes that a carcass decayed from the outset (dust) is not a carcass at all, and bar Padda needs no verse for that. Rabbi Yoḥanan needs the verse to exclude it, which is why the two sages read it differently.

II. Does the swallowed one wake?

Rav Dimi and Rabbi Yirmeya hold that when impurity is swallowed by a majority, it can still revive if it meets its own kind. Abaye raises four objections. Three of them say the same thing: if the swallowed impurity counts as present, the mixture should still impart impurity through carrying. The fourth is different. Sort each objection.

Rav Dimi's answer to the red-heifer ash objection (Para 9:7) comes from Rabbi Yosei son of Rabbi Ḥanina. Which ruling is it?

III. How much water is suspicious

Makhshirin 6:3: brine that was pure, taken from an am ha'aretz, becomes impure when any amount of water falls into it. Rav Naḥman says the reason is that an am ha'aretz is suspected of mixing in half a portion of water. The Gemara asks why half, since less would also make the mixture impure. Its answer is a specific threshold.

Which threshold does the Gemara's answer use for the am ha'aretz's suspected water?

The Gemara also offers a second route: the impurity of foods belonging to an am ha'aretz applies by rabbinic law, and so does the impurity of liquids. Then the brine's impurity is two rabbinic decrees stacked on each other, and the decree on water-majority brine is not the same decree as the one on half-and-half.

IV. Which mishna is Rav's rule about?

Rav Naḥman in Rav's name: the halakha follows the anonymous tanna throughout the chapter, except where a dispute is recorded. Rav Sheshet says Rav was dozing. Which mishna could the ruling be about? Sort the candidates.

The question continues on 24a

Today's page ends mid-argument: if Rav's rule is about Rabban Shimon ben Gamliel, what do we do with the baraita on 24a that disagrees with him? The daf is still open.

Read the Gemara and commentaries on Sefaria. The game is a door into the daf, not a replacement for it.

● The Workshop · weekly

Everything I build, in one email a week.

Torah tools, daf games and AI experiments, with the story behind each one. Sign up and this week’s issue arrives within the hour.