Daf Yomi Arcade, Bekhorot 21, 9 October 2026

Under the Rod

כֹּל אֲשֶׁר יַעֲבֹר תַּחַת הַשָּׁבֶט

Once a year the herd files out of a pen through a narrow gate, and every tenth animal is marked with the rod as ma'aser, the animal tithe. Today's daf asks which kids get into that pen, and whether the tithe behaves like a firstborn or like an ordinary sacrifice. Then it hands the case to a shepherd and goes to market, where a seller keeps quiet and three Amoraim read his silence three different ways.

Score:

I. Four gates to the pen

A baraita has Rabbi Shimon say: "I saw a single kid that yielded a tithe within its first year." Its daughters had a tinuf, a murky discharge, around the start of their seventh month. The first tanna doesn't add "within its first year". So what do they disagree about? The Gemara offers four answers (21a:2–5), and each one opens a different gate for Rabbi Shimon's kids while the first tanna keeps it shut. Each round shows the Gemara's own words. Tap the gate they name. Watch what happens to the gate from the round before: ve-i ba'it eima, "if you like, say everyone agrees on that one".

II. Firstborn or sacrifice?

Rabbi Shimon's fourth gate has a source. Rabbi Shimon ben Yehuda reports in his name that a kid "before its time", not yet eight days old, enters the pen: "just as a firstborn is holy before its time and offered after its time, so too" (21b:1). But why compare the tithe to the firstborn? Ordinary sacrifices can't be consecrated before their time at all. The Gemara answers with two strings of mnemonic words. Play each tile to the side it pulls the tithe toward, and throw out the tiles that aren't true.

← בְּכוֹר firstborn sacrifices קֳדָשִׁים →
מעשר

III. Show it to a ḥakham

The mishna said a tinuf counts as a birth and exempts the next offspring from firstborn status. What does one look like, and who can tell (21b:4–5)?

IV. The silent seller

The mishna dealt with an animal bought from a gentile. Now a Jew buys a cow from a Jew, and the seller says nothing about whether she has given birth before. Her next male calf: firstborn or not (21b:6–7)? For each Amora, fill in the seller's thought bubble, then rule on the calf.

V. The clot in the field

רַבִּי אֱלִיעֶזֶר בֶּן יַעֲקֹב אוֹמֵר: בְּהֵמָה גַּסָּה שֶׁשָּׁפְעָה חֲרָרַת דָּם…

The new mishna (21b:9): a large animal expelled a mass of congealed blood. Perhaps a male fetus was in there.

Learn the real daf

Bekhorot 21 opens by closing out yesterday's question: even if a goat can recover from a tinuf and give birth within her year, one that actually gave birth to a live kid cannot (21a:1). Then comes Rabbi Shimon's kid and the four readings, the firstborn-or-sacrifice analogy with its mnemonics, the shepherds' word for a tinuf, Rav Ḥisda's unanswered question, the silent seller, and Rabbi Eliezer ben Ya'akov's mishna. Rashi spells out each mnemonic word; Rabbeinu Gershom works the calendar of 21a day by day, and Rashi offers two readings of it.

Part of the Daf Yomi Arcade, a new game from every daf. Texts and links via the Sefaria API.

● The Workshop · weekly

Everything I build, in one email a week.

Torah tools, daf games and AI experiments, with the story behind each one. Sign up and this week’s issue arrives within the hour.