Daf Yomi Arcade, Bekhorot 20, 8 October 2026
אֵין טִינּוּף פָּחוֹת מִשְּׁלֹשִׁים יוֹם
A Jew buys a young goat from a gentile, and nobody knows whether she has ever given birth. Did a tinuf, a murky discharge that counts as a birth, already "open her womb"? Today's daf finds the hidden hinge under one dispute five different ways, counts a goat's year down to the last day, swaps two sages' names, and fills a tithe pen from a single kid.
A baraita (20a:3–5) sets out three positions on the goat bought from a gentile. Rabbi Yishmael: if she gives birth within her first year, that kid certainly goes to the kohen. Rabbi Yehoshua: "You erred." A tinuf also exempts. And he adds his own view on top of the one he heard from the Rabbis. The Gemara keeps asking what the two sides really disagree about, and it finds a different hidden hinge each time. In every round, pick the hinge. Hinges that both sides already agree on are locked.
Rabbi Akiva has his own rule: known to have given birth, the kohen gets nothing; known not to, the kid goes to the kohen; in doubt, the owner eats it once it is blemished (20b:3). So how is he different from Rabbi Yehoshua?
The animal tithe needs ten animals born in the same year. A baraita (20b:8): a young kid bore three daughters, and each daughter bore three, so all of them go into the pen to be tithed. Rabbi Shimon says, "I saw one that was tithed within her own year." Set the litters (up to triplets, as in the baraita) and get ten newborns into the pen.
Play the three parts above.
Bekhorot 20 opens by finishing yesterday's cliffhanger. Rava says Rabbi Yishmael follows Rabbi Meir and worries about the minority. Ravina says the Rabbis don't follow a majority when it depends on an act, like whether a young goat has mated (20a:1–2). Then comes the baraita of Rabbi Yishmael, Rabbi Yehoshua and Rabbi Akiva, played above. Rashi and Rabbeinu Gershom work through the calendar arithmetic of 20a:11–20b:2 day by day.
Part of the Daf Yomi Arcade, a new game from every daf. Texts and links via the Sefaria API.