Daf Yomi Arcade, Bekhorot 19, 7 October 2026
בְּכוֹר לְדָבָר אֶחָד לָא הָוֵי בְּכוֹר
The Torah calls the firstborn both bekhor, "first," and peter reḥem, "the one that opens the womb." Usually they're the same animal. Today's daf asks what happens when a caesarean birth splits them apart, and then buys a goat from a gentile who can't say whether she has ever given birth.
A baraita builds the definition of a firstborn out of a general term and a detail that need each other. Each phrase is a sieve that catches one kind of newborn the others would let through. Drop each newborn and choose the sieve that catches it, or send it all the way through to the kohen.
A ״קַדֶּשׁ לִי כׇל בְּכוֹר״: "all the firstborn" (Exodus 13:2)
B ״הַזָּכָר״: "every firstborn male" (Deuteronomy 15:19)
C ״פֶּטֶר כׇּל רֶחֶם״: "that which opens any womb" (Exodus 13:2)
The mishna: a male is born by caesarean section (יוֹצֵא דּוֹפֶן), then a second male is born through the womb. Each one holds only one of the two keys. Pick a judge, then rule on both animals.
Caesarean male
🗝 first out
🗝 opens the womb
Male after it
🗝 first out
🗝 opens the womb
Rav Sherevya spots something odd in the sieve baraita. To exclude a male born after a female, it uses sieve C ("opens the womb") instead of sieve A ("firstborn"). To exclude the male after a caesarean, it uses A. Does one key count as a firstborn or not?
New mishna: you buy a female animal from a gentile who can't tell you whether she has ever given birth. Now she bears a male. Rabbi Yishmael says that if she is young enough, the male is certainly the kohen's; past that age it's a doubt. For each species, tap the last year of age that's still certain.
The Gemara asks: why is an older goat only a doubt? Most animals conceive and give birth within their first year, so follow the majority. Its first answer is that the Rabbis only follow a majority that is "in front of us" (רוּבָּא דְּאִיתֵיהּ קַמַּן). Picture a piece of meat lying in the street:
Sort each majority: can you look at it right now, or is it a statistic?
Play the five parts above.
Bekhorot 19 closes the second chapter with the caesarean mishna and Abaye's rule that "a firstborn in one respect is not a firstborn," then opens chapter three with the animal bought from a gentile. The daf ends mid-sentence on "Rather, Rava says:", and his answer is on 20a.
Part of the Daf Yomi Arcade, a new game from every daf. Texts and links via the Sefaria API.