1
00:00:01,460 --> 00:00:05,060
Continuing in Hilchos Milah, Yoreh Deah, siman Reish

2
00:00:05,060 --> 00:00:09,779
Samech Vav. We are up to Sif-Ches, and

3
00:00:09,779 --> 00:00:13,900
this is another super exciting Sugya regarding Yom

4
00:00:13,900 --> 00:00:18,339
Tov Sheni Shel Galuyos. So by way of

5
00:00:18,339 --> 00:00:20,440
preview we have to go back to Sif-Beis.

6
00:00:20,539 --> 00:00:24,086
In Sif-Beis we learned Mila Docha Yom Tov

7
00:00:24,086 --> 00:00:27,899
VeShabbos Bizmana. If it's a Mila Bizmana, the

8
00:00:27,899 --> 00:00:30,059
eighth day, we know that it's Docha Shabbos

9
00:00:30,059 --> 00:00:31,440
and docheh Yom Tov. we do the Bris

10
00:00:31,579 --> 00:00:33,670
on Shabbos, we do the Bris on Yom

11
00:00:33,670 --> 00:00:36,299
Tov, Aval Shelo Bizmana, but if the Mila

12
00:00:36,299 --> 00:00:42,340
is Shelo Bizmana, Eina Docha. So

13
00:00:42,340 --> 00:00:45,679
even if it's about Mila Shelo Bizmana, if

14
00:00:45,679 --> 00:00:47,700
it's not the eighth day, so it's not

15
00:00:47,700 --> 00:00:50,579
Docha Shabbos and it's not docheh Yom Tov.

16
00:00:51,960 --> 00:00:54,979
On this Eina Docha, there should be a

17
00:00:54,979 --> 00:00:56,659
little Beis. That little Beis takes us down

18
00:00:56,659 --> 00:01:00,000
to the Gilyon Maharsha. So we're in Sif-Beis.

19
00:01:00,380 --> 00:01:03,100
In Sif-Beis there's another Sif-Katan Beis in the

20
00:01:03,219 --> 00:01:05,900
Gilyon Maharsha and the Gilyon Maharsha gives us

21
00:01:05,900 --> 00:01:09,500
a preview of coming attractions, Eina Docha. So

22
00:01:09,500 --> 00:01:11,760
Mila Shelo Bizmana is not Docha Shabbos, not

23
00:01:11,760 --> 00:01:14,171
docheh Yom Tov. What about Yom Tov Sheni

24
00:01:14,171 --> 00:01:17,219
Shel Galuyos? Says the Gilyon Maharsha Sif-Katan Beis,

25
00:01:17,219 --> 00:01:22,040
VeYom Tov Sheni Docha LeDa'as HaRambam. According to

26
00:01:22,040 --> 00:01:25,253
the Rambam, Mila Shelo Bizmana is Docha Yom

27
00:01:25,253 --> 00:01:28,500
Tov Sheni. VeHaRosh Savira Lei De-Eina Docha and

28
00:01:28,500 --> 00:01:31,060
the Rosh holds that it is not Docha

29
00:01:31,060 --> 00:01:33,379
Yom Tov Sheni. So we have a major

30
00:01:33,379 --> 00:01:37,340
league Machlokas Rambam-Rosh, is Mila Shelo Bizmana Docha

31
00:01:37,340 --> 00:01:39,500
Yom Tov Sheni? The Rambam says yes, the

32
00:01:39,500 --> 00:01:42,439
Rosh says no. Why the Gilyon Maharsha put

33
00:01:42,439 --> 00:01:44,480
it over there is not so clear to

34
00:01:44,480 --> 00:01:47,739
me, the Sugya is over here in Sif-Ches.

35
00:01:48,760 --> 00:01:52,980
Now, the Sugya in Sif-Ches starts from the

36
00:01:52,980 --> 00:01:56,040
Mishnah in Shabbos Daf Kuf-Lamed-Zayin. There the Mishnah

37
00:01:56,040 --> 00:01:59,753
tells us that a Katan is Nimal LiShmona

38
00:01:59,753 --> 00:02:04,219
LiTisha LaAsara LaAchad-Asar ULeYwais-Asar. The baby has a

39
00:02:04,219 --> 00:02:06,483
Bris on the 8th, 9th, 10th, 11th, 12th

40
00:02:06,483 --> 00:02:10,740
day. And then the Mishnah explains: Nimal LiShmona

41
00:02:10,740 --> 00:02:13,020
Kedarko. Normally the baby is supposed to have

42
00:02:13,020 --> 00:02:15,520
a Bris on the 8th day. LiTisha, that's

43
00:02:15,520 --> 00:02:18,020
if the baby's born Bein Hashmashos, Safek Monday,

44
00:02:18,199 --> 00:02:20,240
Safek Tuesday, so we don't want it to

45
00:02:20,240 --> 00:02:22,259
be on the 7th day, so we have

46
00:02:22,259 --> 00:02:25,259
to err on the side of caution, so

47
00:02:25,259 --> 00:02:27,060
we do it on the 9th day, meaning

48
00:02:27,060 --> 00:02:29,020
it's a Safek 9th day, Safek 8th day,

49
00:02:29,080 --> 00:02:32,620
we're calling that the 9th day. If it's

50
00:02:32,620 --> 00:02:35,500
Bein Hashmashos Shel Erev Shabbos when the baby's

51
00:02:35,500 --> 00:02:37,319
born, then the 9th day is Shabbos and

52
00:02:37,319 --> 00:02:39,120
it's Safek if it's a Mila Shelo Bizmana.

53
00:02:39,759 --> 00:02:41,259
So therefore we can't do it on the

54
00:02:41,259 --> 00:02:43,080
9th day, maybe the baby was really born

55
00:02:43,080 --> 00:02:46,039
the day before and it's the 9th day,

56
00:02:46,199 --> 00:02:48,120
it's not Mila Bizmana, it can't be Docha

57
00:02:48,120 --> 00:02:52,039
Shabbos. So therefore the baby, the Bris is

58
00:02:52,039 --> 00:02:56,860
LaAsara, is on Sunday. If Sunday is Yom

59
00:02:56,860 --> 00:02:59,500
Tov. then the Bris will be ULeAchad-Asar, it

60
00:02:59,500 --> 00:03:00,900
will be on the 11th, we'll push it

61
00:03:01,000 --> 00:03:03,180
till after Yom Tov. And then the end

62
00:03:03,180 --> 00:03:05,924
of the Mishnah ULeYwais-Asar BiShnei Yamim Shel Rosh

63
00:03:05,924 --> 00:03:09,280
Hashanah. If Sunday-Monday is Rosh Hashanah, so then

64
00:03:09,280 --> 00:03:10,800
the Bris is going to be pushed off

65
00:03:10,800 --> 00:03:14,860
until Tuesday, and that will be 12 days

66
00:03:14,860 --> 00:03:17,599
possibly after the birth of the baby. The

67
00:03:17,599 --> 00:03:19,199
baby again we're talking about a baby that's

68
00:03:19,199 --> 00:03:23,699
born Bein Hashmashos. So it's Safek 11, Safek

69
00:03:23,699 --> 00:03:26,840
12, we're calling it 12. Let's see that

70
00:03:26,840 --> 00:03:29,860
now in Shulchan Aruch. Says the Shulchan Aruch,

71
00:03:29,860 --> 00:03:33,280
Yoreh Deah Resh-Samech-Vav. Sif-Ches: Mi SheNolad Bein Hashmashos

72
00:03:33,280 --> 00:03:37,419
SheHu Safek Yom Safek Layla, Bein Hashmashos is

73
00:03:37,419 --> 00:03:40,750
Safek Yom Safek Layla, between Shkia and Tzeis

74
00:03:40,750 --> 00:03:43,319
HaKochavim, we'll discuss that more in the next

75
00:03:43,319 --> 00:03:48,419
Shiur. Safek Yom Safek Layla, Monim Min HaLayla.

76
00:03:48,699 --> 00:03:52,360
So we count, we pretend, we do Ke'ilu

77
00:03:52,520 --> 00:03:56,680
the baby was born at night, VeNimal LaTshii,

78
00:03:56,879 --> 00:03:59,240
and the baby's born nine days from the

79
00:03:59,240 --> 00:04:01,979
day. Because SheHu Safek Shmini, the 8th day

80
00:04:01,979 --> 00:04:05,639
from the night. We'd rather do 8, Safek

81
00:04:05,639 --> 00:04:07,819
8, Safek 9 than Safek 8, Safek 7

82
00:04:07,960 --> 00:04:11,699
because we already discussed how complicated it is

83
00:04:11,699 --> 00:04:13,020
for the baby to have a Bris before

84
00:04:13,020 --> 00:04:14,620
the 8th day, so we'd rather do Safek

85
00:04:14,620 --> 00:04:17,220
8, Safek 9 than Safek 7, Safek 8.

86
00:04:17,220 --> 00:04:21,699
Ve-Im Nolad Erev Shabbos Bein Hashmashos continues the

87
00:04:21,699 --> 00:04:24,873
Shulchan Aruch. Now it's Erev Shabbos Bein Hashmashos,

88
00:04:24,873 --> 00:04:26,939
so Eina Docha Es HaShabbos, SheEina Dochina Es

89
00:04:26,939 --> 00:04:29,040
HaShabbos MiSafek. As a Safek, it can't be

90
00:04:29,040 --> 00:04:30,879
Docha Shabbos. The Bris is going to be

91
00:04:30,879 --> 00:04:34,386
pushed off till Sunday. VeChen Eina Docha Yom

92
00:04:34,386 --> 00:04:37,579
Tov MiSafek. It can't push off, the Bris

93
00:04:37,579 --> 00:04:41,199
is not Docha Yom Tov. MiSafek either. Ve-Afilu

94
00:04:41,199 --> 00:04:44,199
Yom Tov Sheni Shel Galuyos. Even Yom Tov

95
00:04:44,199 --> 00:04:46,720
Sheni Shel Galuyos you can't do the Bris,

96
00:04:46,779 --> 00:04:48,459
you have to push the Bris off till

97
00:04:48,459 --> 00:04:51,379
after Yom Tov Sheni Shel Galuyos. The Mechaber

98
00:04:51,379 --> 00:04:57,459
here Paskens like the Rosh. Look

99
00:04:57,459 --> 00:05:02,500
at the Shach Sif-Katan Ches. veafilu Yom Tov

100
00:05:02,500 --> 00:05:04,100
Sheni shel Galuyot, velifi aniyas da'ati, ikkar k'haRambam

101
00:05:04,100 --> 00:05:06,019
de-docheh Yom Tov Sheni shel Galuyot. The Shach

102
00:05:06,019 --> 00:05:08,579
disagrees with the Mechaber. The Mechaber paskins like

103
00:05:08,579 --> 00:05:12,413
the Rosh. No, bris shelo bizmanah on Yom

104
00:05:12,413 --> 00:05:14,480
Tov Sheni. Shach says the ikkar is like

105
00:05:14,480 --> 00:05:16,800
the Rambam and it is Docha Yom Tov,

106
00:05:16,800 --> 00:05:20,051
Yom Tov Sheni shel Galuyot, velifi aniyas da'ati,

107
00:05:20,051 --> 00:05:23,303
ikkar k'haRambam de-docheh Yom Tov Sheni shel Galuyot,

108
00:05:23,303 --> 00:05:26,555
ve-chein hu gam kein da'as ha-Smag, ve-hakabbalah, ve-chein

109
00:05:26,555 --> 00:05:29,807
hu da'as ha-Bartenura she-peireish shnei yamim tovim shel

110
00:05:29,807 --> 00:05:32,750
Rosh Hashanah di-kdusha achas hein. When it's shnei

111
00:05:32,750 --> 00:05:34,860
yamim tovim shel Rosh Hashanah, it's not Docha

112
00:05:35,000 --> 00:05:37,294
like the Mishnah said. It's not docheh Yom

113
00:05:37,294 --> 00:05:39,180
Tov Sheni shel Rosh Hashanah, but it will

114
00:05:39,180 --> 00:05:46,040
be docheh Yom Tov Sheni shel Galuyot. Look

115
00:05:46,040 --> 00:05:51,265
at the Biur HaGra. Biur HaGra siff katan

116
00:05:51,265 --> 00:05:56,563
yud-daled. veafilu Yom Tov, u-mah shekasav be-masnisin Yom

117
00:05:56,563 --> 00:06:01,500
Tov Sheni shel Rosh Hashanah. That sounds like

118
00:06:01,500 --> 00:06:03,204
only Rosh Hashanah but not Yom Tov Sheni

119
00:06:03,204 --> 00:06:05,660
shel Galuyot, says the Gra, no, that's not

120
00:06:05,660 --> 00:06:08,740
a diyuk mishum de-masnisin nishnis be-Eretz Yisrael. The

121
00:06:08,740 --> 00:06:11,800
Mishnah was taught in Eretz Yisrael and there

122
00:06:11,800 --> 00:06:13,600
is no Yom Tov Sheni shel Galuyot. And

123
00:06:13,600 --> 00:06:15,626
that's why it says Yom Tov Sheni shel

124
00:06:15,626 --> 00:06:17,879
Rosh Hashanah. But i hachi nami chutz la-aretz

125
00:06:17,920 --> 00:06:19,360
even Yom Tov Sheni shel Galuyot is not

126
00:06:19,360 --> 00:06:22,459
Docha like the Rosh and the Mechaber. That's

127
00:06:22,500 --> 00:06:25,666
shitas ha-Rosh aval haRambam kasav de-docheh Yom Tov

128
00:06:25,666 --> 00:06:30,199
Sheni shel Galuyot. Now to properly appreciate this

129
00:06:30,199 --> 00:06:32,339
sugya, we have to understand that there's two

130
00:06:32,339 --> 00:06:36,279
different scenarios where a bris shelo bizmanah would

131
00:06:36,279 --> 00:06:39,620
come out on Yom Tov Sheni shel Galuyot.

132
00:06:39,879 --> 00:06:43,980
The case of the Mishnah is that the

133
00:06:44,240 --> 00:06:46,860
baby's born on bein hashmashos of Erev Shabbos.

134
00:06:47,000 --> 00:06:49,779
We can't do the bris the next week

135
00:06:49,779 --> 00:06:53,040
on Shabbos, even though that's the eighth day,

136
00:06:53,120 --> 00:06:55,100
that's when it should be, but it's Shabbos,

137
00:06:55,339 --> 00:06:57,339
so we push it off to Sunday. Sunday,

138
00:06:57,480 --> 00:06:59,819
Monday is Yom Tov. so we can't do

139
00:06:59,819 --> 00:07:02,980
it on Sunday, and we're discussing doing it

140
00:07:02,980 --> 00:07:05,019
on Monday which is Yom Tov Sheni shel

141
00:07:05,019 --> 00:07:08,180
Galuyot, two days of Sukkos, Shavuos, whatever it

142
00:07:08,180 --> 00:07:12,079
is. That's one scenario. Now there's another scenario

143
00:07:12,079 --> 00:07:15,339
where the baby's born bein hashmashos and we

144
00:07:15,339 --> 00:07:16,839
said it's supposed to be, we're going to

145
00:07:16,839 --> 00:07:18,420
count the eighth day from the night which

146
00:07:18,420 --> 00:07:20,339
the Mishnah calls the ninth day, and the

147
00:07:20,339 --> 00:07:22,432
ninth day turns out to be Yom Tov

148
00:07:22,432 --> 00:07:25,339
Sheni shel Galuyot. In the first situation, the

149
00:07:25,339 --> 00:07:27,800
ninth day turns out to be Shabbos and

150
00:07:27,800 --> 00:07:29,560
then you're doing the tenth day, eleventh day,

151
00:07:30,280 --> 00:07:32,920
we're danim on the eleventh day, we say,

152
00:07:32,920 --> 00:07:34,699
maybe it's a machlokes Rambam Rosh if you

153
00:07:34,699 --> 00:07:36,980
push it off to the twelfth day. That's

154
00:07:36,980 --> 00:07:38,600
what the Mishnah says and the Mishnah talks

155
00:07:38,600 --> 00:07:40,420
about two days of Rosh Hashanah. What do

156
00:07:40,420 --> 00:07:42,160
we do about Yom Tov Sheni shel Galuyot?

157
00:07:42,360 --> 00:07:44,399
But what the Mishnah does not discuss is

158
00:07:44,399 --> 00:07:46,439
what if the baby's born bein hashmashos and

159
00:07:46,439 --> 00:07:48,680
the ninth day is not Shabbos and it's

160
00:07:48,680 --> 00:07:50,384
not Yom Tov but it's Yom Tov Sheni

161
00:07:50,384 --> 00:07:53,279
shel Galuyot? In that case it could be

162
00:07:53,680 --> 00:07:57,620
safek tisha safek shmona. So in that case,

163
00:07:58,000 --> 00:08:00,720
maybe everyone will agree that the bris is

164
00:08:00,720 --> 00:08:04,750
docheh Yom Tov, Look at Rebbe Akiva Eiger.

165
00:08:04,750 --> 00:08:06,834
Rebbe Akiva Eiger siff katan hey. veafilu Yom

166
00:08:06,834 --> 00:08:09,357
Tov Sheni shel Galuyot, lichora kasha ha havei

167
00:08:09,357 --> 00:08:11,879
sfek sfeka, safek zemanno ve-safek she-hu yom chol.

168
00:08:11,879 --> 00:08:15,819
keivan de-hu Yom Tov Sheni shel Galuyot, right,

169
00:08:15,819 --> 00:08:18,120
Yom Tov Sheni shel Galuyot, right, we don't

170
00:08:18,120 --> 00:08:19,790
know which is the proper, which is the

171
00:08:19,790 --> 00:08:21,443
real Yom Tov So maybe it's Yom Tov.

172
00:08:21,459 --> 00:08:23,410
maybe it's not. But even if it's Yom

173
00:08:23,410 --> 00:08:25,699
Tov, maybe it's the eighth day and it

174
00:08:25,699 --> 00:08:28,259
is docheh Yom Tov, So we have a

175
00:08:28,259 --> 00:08:29,680
safek if it's the eighth day or the

176
00:08:29,680 --> 00:08:31,300
ninth day, and even if it's the ninth

177
00:08:31,300 --> 00:08:33,600
day, maybe it's a yom chol because it's

178
00:08:33,600 --> 00:08:36,395
a safek Yom Tov safek chol. It's Yom

179
00:08:36,395 --> 00:08:38,500
Tov Sheni shel Galuyot. That's the question of

180
00:08:38,500 --> 00:08:40,679
Rebbe Akiva Eiger. You can do the rest

181
00:08:40,679 --> 00:08:42,860
of Rebbe Akiva Eiger for homework. So these

182
00:08:42,860 --> 00:08:46,019
are the two different scenarios that we are

183
00:08:46,019 --> 00:08:50,120
discussing within doing a bris quote-unquote shelo bizmanah

184
00:08:50,120 --> 00:08:52,506
on Yom Tov Sheni. Is it mamash shelo

185
00:08:52,506 --> 00:08:55,960
bizmanah and that's a machlokes Rambam Rosh and

186
00:08:55,960 --> 00:09:01,220
Mechaber Shach? Or is it safek shelo bizmanah

187
00:09:01,220 --> 00:09:04,480
because baby's born bein hashmashos and what the

188
00:09:04,480 --> 00:09:06,403
Mishnah calls the ninth day is Yom Tov

189
00:09:06,403 --> 00:09:08,039
Sheni shel Galuyot, and then you have a

190
00:09:08,039 --> 00:09:10,019
sfek sfeka says Rebbe Akiva Eiger and a

191
00:09:10,019 --> 00:09:11,733
good reason to do the bris on Yom

192
00:09:11,733 --> 00:09:15,379
Tov Sheni even according to the Mechaber. Look

193
00:09:15,379 --> 00:09:17,670
at the Pis-chei Teshuva siff katan zayin. Yom

194
00:09:17,670 --> 00:09:20,840
Tov Sheni shel Galuyot ayin be-Birkei Yosef beshem

195
00:09:20,840 --> 00:09:24,011
Shach ve-ayin bi-teshuvas Noda bi-Yehuda chelek Orach Chayim

196
00:09:24,011 --> 00:09:27,182
siman lamed she-he'erich be-zeh ela de-mah she-kasav ha-Mechaber

197
00:09:27,182 --> 00:09:30,299
ve-chein be-Yom Tov Sheni shel Galuyot. When the

198
00:09:30,299 --> 00:09:32,139
Mechaber says the bris is not docheh Yom

199
00:09:32,139 --> 00:09:35,366
Tov Sheni shel Galuyot, kavanasso im hu vadai

200
00:09:35,366 --> 00:09:37,783
shelo bizmanah like the case of the Mishnah,

201
00:09:37,783 --> 00:09:40,775
kegon she-nolad be-erev shabbos bein ha-shmashos u-ve-shavua she-le-achar

202
00:09:40,775 --> 00:09:44,020
safek shemini chalu shnei yamim tovim shel galuyos

203
00:09:44,020 --> 00:09:51,840
be-echad be-shabbos u-ve-sheni be-shabbos she-nimol le-yom yud-bais. That's

204
00:09:51,840 --> 00:09:54,012
the case of the Mishnah. Baby's born Erev

205
00:09:54,012 --> 00:09:57,759
Shabbos bein hashmashos and then you can't do

206
00:09:57,759 --> 00:09:58,899
it on Shabbos, so you push it off

207
00:09:58,899 --> 00:10:00,440
to Sunday, Sunday's Yom Tov... And so you

208
00:10:00,440 --> 00:10:02,536
can't push it up to Monday, Monday's Yom

209
00:10:02,536 --> 00:10:04,360
Tov sheini shel galuyos, and you're going to

210
00:10:04,360 --> 00:10:07,080
push it off till the day after, because

211
00:10:07,080 --> 00:10:09,379
that's vaday shelo bizmano. Aval mi she-safek shemini

212
00:10:09,379 --> 00:10:12,159
shelo b'Yom Tov sheini, and the Noda Biyehuda

213
00:10:12,159 --> 00:10:18,620
held even in Rosh Hashana, that's

214
00:10:18,620 --> 00:10:21,899
controversial, not everyone agrees with that, nimol b'sheini,

215
00:10:21,960 --> 00:10:23,639
then the bris will in fact be on

216
00:10:23,639 --> 00:10:25,820
Yom Tov sheini shel galuyos. De-hava safek sfeika,

217
00:10:25,820 --> 00:10:30,620
shema hayom zmano, maybe today's the right zmano

218
00:10:30,779 --> 00:10:32,240
because the baby was really born at night.

219
00:10:32,240 --> 00:10:35,320
V'im timtza lomar eino zmano, and even if

220
00:10:35,320 --> 00:10:37,813
it's not the proper zmano, shema hayom chol,

221
00:10:37,813 --> 00:10:41,175
maybe it's really chol, v'lo hava davar she-yeish

222
00:10:41,175 --> 00:10:43,740
lo matirin keivan d'chazar l'issuro, we're not going

223
00:10:43,740 --> 00:10:46,283
to get into that right now. Continues the

224
00:10:46,283 --> 00:10:49,008
Pischei Teshuva, v'chasav od, le-inyan plugta she-bein ha-Rambam

225
00:10:49,008 --> 00:10:52,659
v'ha-Rosh, bi-mila vaday she-lo bizmanah im docheh Yom

226
00:10:52,659 --> 00:10:56,200
Tov sheini shel galuyos, nireh ikar k'ha-Rosh, the

227
00:10:56,200 --> 00:10:57,650
ikar is like the Rosh, like the Mechaber,

228
00:10:57,650 --> 00:11:01,603
d'ein docheh. Mi-kol makom, mi she-rotzeh lismach al

229
00:11:01,603 --> 00:11:04,620
ha-Shach she-hichriya k'da'as ha-Rambam, ein mochin b'yado. Someone

230
00:11:04,620 --> 00:11:06,639
wants to be someich on the Shach and

231
00:11:06,639 --> 00:11:08,240
the Rambam, we're not going to stop them.

232
00:11:09,700 --> 00:11:11,799
Ayein sham. Continues the Pischei Teshuva in the

233
00:11:11,799 --> 00:11:16,737
brackets, v'ayein bi-teshuvas Chasam Sofer siman reish-nun she-he'erich

234
00:11:16,737 --> 00:11:19,899
b'inyan zeh v'he'elah be-hachlet le-hachmir k'ha-Rosh. Ha-halacha is

235
00:11:19,899 --> 00:11:22,000
like the Rosh, like the Mechaber, no option

236
00:11:22,000 --> 00:11:26,519
to follow the Shach. U-k'haskamas ha-Tashbetz, she-ra'ah divrei

237
00:11:26,519 --> 00:11:29,850
ha-Rambam v'ha-Smag, and he rejected the Rambam and

238
00:11:29,850 --> 00:11:31,122
the Smag, v'hiskim im ha-Rosh. V'ha-Shach lo ra'ah,

239
00:11:31,122 --> 00:11:33,071
teshuva l'ha-Shach lo ra'ah teshuvas ha-Tashbetz. V'chol heicha

240
00:11:33,071 --> 00:11:35,200
d'divrei rishonim ne'elmu m'einei acharonim halacha k'rishonim, whenever

241
00:11:40,460 --> 00:11:43,679
the acharonim didn't see the rishonim, so we're

242
00:11:43,679 --> 00:11:45,159
going to go with the rishonim. And the

243
00:11:45,159 --> 00:11:47,991
Shach didn't see the Tashbetz. Ach, bi-safek im

244
00:11:47,991 --> 00:11:53,988
ha-mila hi hayom bizmano, nireh li k'ha-Nodeh Biyehuda

245
00:11:53,988 --> 00:11:57,720
ha-na'al. But when this day, Yom Tov sheini

246
00:11:57,720 --> 00:12:01,419
shel galuyos is a safek yom shemini, so

247
00:12:01,419 --> 00:12:03,183
then we will do the bris on Yom

248
00:12:03,183 --> 00:12:05,543
Tov sheini. Limol b'Yom Tov sheini shel galuyos

249
00:12:05,543 --> 00:12:08,672
al kol panim, v'lo m'ta'amei d'Nodeh Biyehuda mishum

250
00:12:08,672 --> 00:12:10,679
d'hava safek sfeika. Says I don't like the

251
00:12:11,120 --> 00:12:12,779
reason of the Nodeh Biyehuda safek sfeika, I

252
00:12:12,779 --> 00:12:15,146
have a different reason. Rak mi-ta'am acher, d'asi

253
00:12:15,146 --> 00:12:20,039
safek kiyum mitzvas asei d'Oraisa of mila bi-zmanah

254
00:12:20,379 --> 00:12:22,840
on the eighth day, v'dachi, and it's going

255
00:12:22,840 --> 00:12:26,259
to push away the safek kal d'Rabanan of

256
00:12:26,480 --> 00:12:30,080
Yom Tov sheini. U-vifrat idna, nowadays that we

257
00:12:30,080 --> 00:12:31,903
really know what the right day is, and

258
00:12:31,903 --> 00:12:34,940
Yom Tov sheini eino ela minhag. U-masik, the

259
00:12:34,940 --> 00:12:37,841
conclusion of the Chasam Sofer, she-ha-zariz u-meikel b'Yom

260
00:12:37,841 --> 00:12:41,860
Tov sheini u-machmir l'molo b'yomo, who's machmir to

261
00:12:41,860 --> 00:12:43,528
do the bris on Yom Tov sheini shel

262
00:12:43,528 --> 00:12:46,612
galuyos when it's a safek shmona, b'yomo safek

263
00:12:46,612 --> 00:12:51,080
shemini safek tshi'i, harei hu min ha-zrizim, that's

264
00:12:51,080 --> 00:12:52,601
the proper thing to do, says the Chasam

265
00:12:52,601 --> 00:12:56,019
Sofer. Okay, then he brings down another teshuvas

266
00:12:56,019 --> 00:12:59,220
Chasam Sofer in two teshuvos later, reish-nun-beis. Before

267
00:12:59,220 --> 00:13:01,333
we did reish-nun, reish-nun-beis, gam kein teshuva me-inyan

268
00:13:01,333 --> 00:13:03,620
zeh v'sham ein da'ato kein. Here he has

269
00:13:03,620 --> 00:13:06,129
a different opinion. Ela d'afilu sfeika eino docheh

270
00:13:06,129 --> 00:13:08,580
Yom Tov sheini shel galuyos, he changes his

271
00:13:08,580 --> 00:13:13,279
mind. Ach kefi ha-nireh, says the Pischei Teshuva,

272
00:13:13,620 --> 00:13:16,120
lo nidpas al ha-seder. These teshuvos are not

273
00:13:16,120 --> 00:13:18,500
written in order. It should be, it looks

274
00:13:18,500 --> 00:13:20,899
like reish-nun and later comes reish-nun-beis. Reish-nun he

275
00:13:20,899 --> 00:13:23,000
says do the bris on Yom Tov sheini,

276
00:13:23,000 --> 00:13:24,426
reish-nun-beis says don't do the bris on Yom

277
00:13:24,426 --> 00:13:28,100
Tov sheini. No, it's out of order. V'osa

278
00:13:28,100 --> 00:13:30,340
teshuva d'siman reish-nun-beis she-nidpasa rishona, it was printed

279
00:13:30,340 --> 00:13:32,840
first and it comes first in the teshuvos,

280
00:13:32,840 --> 00:13:36,399
hushav b'achrona. He really responded to reish-nun came

281
00:13:36,399 --> 00:13:39,320
before reish-nun-beis, b'erech esrim shana v'yoser, at least

282
00:13:39,320 --> 00:13:43,860
20 years later. Min ha-kosev al shaar ha-sefer

283
00:13:44,080 --> 00:13:46,720
v'habu chazei, v'hi ikar d'ikar. Teshuva is the

284
00:13:46,720 --> 00:13:48,100
first one not the second one, the first

285
00:13:48,100 --> 00:13:49,919
one came at least 20 years later where

286
00:13:49,919 --> 00:13:52,299
he chazar bo and he held like the

287
00:13:52,299 --> 00:13:54,559
Nodeh Biyehuda but from a different reason, that

288
00:13:54,559 --> 00:13:57,200
if it's a safek shemini, the bris should

289
00:13:57,200 --> 00:14:01,100
in fact be done on Yom Tov sheini.

290
00:14:01,419 --> 00:14:04,927
So bottom line, if it is a vaday

291
00:14:04,927 --> 00:14:08,220
mila she-lo bizmanah, so then the poskim say

292
00:14:08,580 --> 00:14:10,527
not to do the bris on Yom Tov

293
00:14:10,527 --> 00:14:16,919
sheini like the Mechaber and the Rosh. That's

294
00:14:16,919 --> 00:14:20,679
Rav Shloime Zalman, Rav Elyashiv, Rav Wozner. If

295
00:14:20,679 --> 00:14:23,940
it is a safek shemini, so the Orchos

296
00:14:23,940 --> 00:14:27,580
also machmirim, but the consensus of poskim hold

297
00:14:27,919 --> 00:14:30,639
that the minhag is that the bris will

298
00:14:30,639 --> 00:14:32,980
be on Yom Tov sheini when it is

299
00:14:32,980 --> 00:14:36,269
a safek shemini, either because of the safek

300
00:14:36,269 --> 00:14:41,159
sfeika of the Nodeh Biyehuda or because of

301
00:14:41,159 --> 00:14:44,580
the sevara of the Chasam Sofer. And that

302
00:14:44,580 --> 00:14:47,480
is the psak also of Rav Shloime Zalman,

303
00:14:47,480 --> 00:14:50,139
Rav Elyashiv, they bring down Rav Aharon Kotler,

304
00:14:50,559 --> 00:14:52,720
and that's found towards the end of the

305
00:14:52,720 --> 00:14:56,820
first perek of Yom Tov sheini k'hilchasah. In

306
00:14:56,820 --> 00:15:01,120
terms of Yom Tov sheini shel Rosh Hashanah...

307
00:15:01,379 --> 00:15:04,679
But there are many achronim that are machmir

308
00:15:04,779 --> 00:15:06,141
that if you do Yom Tov Sheni shel

309
00:15:06,141 --> 00:15:08,080
Rosh Hashanah, then it should in fact be

310
00:15:08,080 --> 00:15:11,355
pushed off. Let's finish off the Michaber. Va'afilu

311
00:15:11,355 --> 00:15:14,200
hotzi rosho bein hashmashos, so the baby stuck

312
00:15:14,200 --> 00:15:18,000
out its head bein hashmashos of Leil Shabbos.

313
00:15:18,200 --> 00:15:21,379
Af al pi sheyatzah kulo beShabbos, the whole

314
00:15:21,379 --> 00:15:23,600
baby, the baby came out, the whole body

315
00:15:23,600 --> 00:15:26,960
came out on Shabbos itself, Eino nimol beShabbos.

316
00:15:27,019 --> 00:15:28,500
We go after the head, and the head

317
00:15:28,500 --> 00:15:30,179
came out bein hashmashos of Leil Shabbos, and

318
00:15:30,179 --> 00:15:32,580
therefore the bris cannot be done. It's a

319
00:15:32,580 --> 00:15:35,519
safek Friday, safek Shabbos, the bris cannot be

320
00:15:35,519 --> 00:15:38,720
done on Shabbos because of the safek, and

321
00:15:38,720 --> 00:15:40,460
therefore the bris should be pushed off till

322
00:15:40,460 --> 00:15:44,360
Sunday. Now we discussed this at length in

323
00:15:44,360 --> 00:15:46,600
Reish Samech Vav Daled, exactly what part of

324
00:15:46,600 --> 00:15:48,179
the head and what part of the woman's

325
00:15:48,179 --> 00:15:50,120
body has to come out of, and how

326
00:15:50,120 --> 00:15:51,879
much time are we talking about when the

327
00:15:52,080 --> 00:15:54,659
baby's born Leil Shabbos, just a very quick

328
00:15:54,659 --> 00:15:57,580
review. In Yalkut Yosef they bring down in

329
00:15:57,580 --> 00:15:59,480
the month of Nissan and Tishrei, if the

330
00:15:59,720 --> 00:16:01,980
baby's born in Eretz Yisroel, twenty minutes after

331
00:16:01,980 --> 00:16:07,000
shkia, that that is enough to be considered

332
00:16:07,000 --> 00:16:09,460
vaday Shabbos for the bris to be on

333
00:16:09,460 --> 00:16:12,539
the following Shabbos. In Shulchan Shlomo they bring

334
00:16:12,539 --> 00:16:16,480
down from Rav Shlomo Zalman, that in Nissan

335
00:16:16,480 --> 00:16:19,179
and Tishrei it is twenty-five minutes after shkia.

336
00:16:19,340 --> 00:16:20,840
In the winter it's a little shorter, they

337
00:16:20,840 --> 00:16:22,320
bring down twenty-two minutes, in the summer a

338
00:16:22,320 --> 00:16:24,779
little longer, twenty-eight minutes, and when I called

339
00:16:24,860 --> 00:16:27,240
one of the poskim in America, so he

340
00:16:27,240 --> 00:16:31,519
wanted to say that in New York area,

341
00:16:31,980 --> 00:16:34,379
fifty minutes, if the baby's born fifty minutes

342
00:16:34,799 --> 00:16:38,299
after shkia, that's for sure considered born on

343
00:16:38,299 --> 00:16:40,639
Shabbos, even if you're makpid on Rabbeinu Tam

344
00:16:41,019 --> 00:16:43,320
to end Shabbos seventy-two minutes. And if it's

345
00:16:43,320 --> 00:16:45,100
a bit less than fifty minutes, it sounded

346
00:16:45,100 --> 00:16:48,279
like it depends on when you finish Shabbos.

347
00:16:48,360 --> 00:16:50,519
If you finish Shabbos forty-five minutes, so then

348
00:16:50,519 --> 00:16:51,980
if the baby's born forty-five minutes after shkia

349
00:16:51,980 --> 00:16:55,059
on Leil Shabbos, that would be considered Shabbos,

350
00:16:55,419 --> 00:16:57,820
vaday Shabbos, and the bris can be done

351
00:16:58,350 --> 00:17:02,720
on Shabbos. So that is your daf, no,

352
00:17:03,059 --> 00:17:03,879
Siman Resh-Samech-Vav
