1
00:00:00,000 --> 00:00:01,820
Just for *Pesach* I got a very interesting

2
00:00:01,820 --> 00:00:03,399
shayla *Sha'ala* that I have been looking for

3
00:00:03,399 --> 00:00:05,379
the opportunity to give a *Shiur* about because

4
00:00:05,379 --> 00:00:07,259
I think it touches upon two very fascinating

5
00:00:07,509 --> 00:00:10,160
*Sugyas*, not that it's so relevant to anyone

6
00:00:10,160 --> 00:00:12,460
sitting here, but I think in *Lamdus* it

7
00:00:12,460 --> 00:00:15,049
touches on two very fascinating *Sugyas*. The shaylah?

8
00:00:15,049 --> 00:00:16,039
*Sha'ala* was as follows: it was a woman

9
00:00:16,039 --> 00:00:17,818
from my shul who was in Eretz Yisrael

10
00:00:17,818 --> 00:00:22,179
*Eretz Yisrael* for *Pesach* and her family is

11
00:00:22,179 --> 00:00:25,460
among the unique group of people that ask

12
00:00:25,460 --> 00:00:26,928
a *Sha'ala* about Yom Tov Sheni *Yom Tov

13
00:00:26,928 --> 00:00:28,420
Sheini* to the same rabbi that they ask

14
00:00:28,420 --> 00:00:30,339
all their other *Sha'alos* to. So *L'maaseh* they

15
00:00:30,339 --> 00:00:31,600
were keeping two days Yom Tov *Yom Tov*

16
00:00:32,039 --> 00:00:33,539
even though they were in Eretz Yisrael *Eretz

17
00:00:33,539 --> 00:00:35,889
Yisrael*. So she wanted to know, since Yom

18
00:00:35,889 --> 00:00:36,960
Tov *Yom Tov* fell out on Thursday and

19
00:00:36,960 --> 00:00:38,428
Friday, and the first days Yom Tov *Yom

20
00:00:38,428 --> 00:00:39,859
Tov* was Thursday and Friday, could she have

21
00:00:39,859 --> 00:00:41,380
a bas eretz yisrael *Bas Eretz Yisrael* put

22
00:00:41,380 --> 00:00:43,848
makeup on her face on Yom Tov Sheni.

23
00:00:43,848 --> 00:00:45,399
*Yom Tov Sheini* on that Friday so that

24
00:00:45,399 --> 00:00:46,740
she could freshen up her face? Is there

25
00:00:46,740 --> 00:00:48,679
anything wrong with doing that, doing amira l'Yisrael,

26
00:00:48,679 --> 00:00:51,619
*Amira l'Yisrael*, asking a Jewish person who's not

27
00:00:51,619 --> 00:00:53,100
observing Yom Tov *Yom Tov* that day and

28
00:00:53,100 --> 00:00:54,858
is rightfully not observing Yom Tov *Yom Tov*

29
00:00:54,858 --> 00:00:57,437
that day because they're a Bas Eretz Yisrael

30
00:00:57,437 --> 00:00:58,960
*Bas Eretz Yisrael*, to put makeup on her,

31
00:00:59,060 --> 00:01:01,389
on her body, on her face on Yom

32
00:01:01,389 --> 00:01:03,159
Tov Sheni *Yom Tov Sheini*? So really what

33
00:01:03,159 --> 00:01:04,719
it touches on is two things. First of

34
00:01:04,719 --> 00:01:06,407
all, is amira, *Amira l'Yisrael* mutar, *Mutar*? Are

35
00:01:06,407 --> 00:01:08,077
you is a ben chutz la'aretz *Ben Chutz

36
00:01:08,077 --> 00:01:10,168
la'Aretz* allowed to ask a ben eretz yisrael

37
00:01:10,168 --> 00:01:10,939
*Ben Eretz Yisrael* to do melacha *Melacha* for

38
00:01:10,939 --> 00:01:12,508
them on Yom Tov Sheni *Yom Tov Sheini*

39
00:01:12,508 --> 00:01:13,879
while they're in Yisrael *Eretz Yisrael*? And second

40
00:01:13,879 --> 00:01:15,400
of all, does it make a difference that

41
00:01:15,400 --> 00:01:17,439
it's physically on her body? Does the fact

42
00:01:17,439 --> 00:01:19,257
that it's on the ben chutz la'aretz *Ben

43
00:01:19,257 --> 00:01:22,200
Chutz la'Aretz*'s person make a difference? So let's

44
00:01:22,200 --> 00:01:23,879
start with the first question. Rav Moshe was

45
00:01:23,879 --> 00:01:26,614
asked this *Sha'ala* in *Igros Moshe* Orach Chaim

46
00:01:26,614 --> 00:01:26,864
*Orach Chaim* gimmel: *Cheilek Gimmel* siman *Siman Ayin

47
00:01:26,864 --> 00:01:28,797
Gimmel*. You are a chutz la'aretz *Ben Chutz

48
00:01:28,797 --> 00:01:29,689
la'Aretz*, you're in *Eretz Yisrael*, you're keeping Yom

49
00:01:29,689 --> 00:01:30,760
Tov Sheni. *Yom Tov Sheini*, can you ask

50
00:01:30,760 --> 00:01:31,780
a ben eretz yisrael. *Ben Eretz Yisrael* to

51
00:01:31,780 --> 00:01:33,760
do melacha *Melacha* for you? Rav Moshe points

52
00:01:33,760 --> 00:01:36,640
out that the most logical parallel to think

53
00:01:36,640 --> 00:01:38,658
of in halacha *Halacha* is the halacha *Halacha*

54
00:01:38,658 --> 00:01:40,915
*Psuka* in *Shulchan Aruch* Orach Chaim *Orach Chaim*

55
00:01:41,165 --> 00:01:41,980
*Siman Reish Samech Gimmel* *Sif Yud Zayin* where

56
00:01:41,980 --> 00:01:43,760
the *Shulchan Aruch* says, and this is very

57
00:01:43,760 --> 00:01:48,202
relevant for us, Shabbos melacha *Yesh Omrim shemi

58
00:01:48,202 --> 00:01:48,202
shekibel alav Shabbos kodem she'chasheicha mutar lomar l'Yisrael

59
00:01:48,202 --> 00:01:51,459
chaveiro la'asos lo melacha*. If you make an

60
00:01:51,459 --> 00:01:53,319
early Shabbos *Shabbos* and you're *Mkabel* Shabbos *Shabbos*

61
00:01:53,319 --> 00:01:54,939
early and you realize that you forgot to

62
00:01:54,939 --> 00:01:56,099
turn off the light, turn on the light,

63
00:01:56,180 --> 00:01:57,739
whatever, shut the light in the fridge, and

64
00:01:57,739 --> 00:01:59,739
you see that there's your neighbor who's a

65
00:01:59,739 --> 00:02:01,358
frum Jew but has not been *Mkabel* Shabbos.

66
00:02:01,358 --> 00:02:02,780
*Shabbos* yet because they're making late Shabbos. *Shabbos*,

67
00:02:03,079 --> 00:02:04,829
you're allowed to ask them to do melacha

68
00:02:04,829 --> 00:02:07,200
*Melacha* for you. There is no violation because

69
00:02:07,200 --> 00:02:08,500
it may be Shabbos. *Shabbos* for you, but

70
00:02:08,500 --> 00:02:10,180
it's not Shabbos *Shabbos* for them and there's

71
00:02:10,180 --> 00:02:12,238
no technical issur *Issur*, there's no amira lenochri

72
00:02:12,238 --> 00:02:15,138
*Amira l'nachri*, there's no violation. The Magen Avraham

73
00:02:15,138 --> 00:02:17,438
*Magen Avraham* explains, but it's the real *Svara*

74
00:02:17,438 --> 00:02:19,319
says *Magen Avraham* is because even for you

75
00:02:19,319 --> 00:02:20,639
it didn't have to be Shabbos? *Shabbos*. You

76
00:02:20,639 --> 00:02:22,797
could have chosen not to be *Mkabel* *Shabbos*.

77
00:02:23,795 --> 00:02:24,698
mekabel shabbos *De-ha'ei ba'ei lo hayah mikabel shabbos

78
00:02:24,698 --> 00:02:27,620
alav*. *Kol she'yesh lo heter mutar amira*. Anytime

79
00:02:27,620 --> 00:02:29,300
it could have been *Mutar* for you yourself,

80
00:02:29,620 --> 00:02:30,840
then there's not going to be a problem

81
00:02:30,840 --> 00:02:32,960
of *Amira*. So says the *Magen Avraham*. So

82
00:02:32,960 --> 00:02:34,639
one might have said this is exactly the

83
00:02:34,639 --> 00:02:36,159
same case. It's Yom Tov. *Yom Tov* for

84
00:02:36,159 --> 00:02:37,608
me, it's not *Yom Tov* for the other

85
00:02:37,608 --> 00:02:39,319
person, so let me ask the other person

86
00:02:39,319 --> 00:02:40,389
to do a melacha *Melacha* for me. Says

87
00:02:40,419 --> 00:02:42,120
Rav Moshe it is not at all the

88
00:02:42,120 --> 00:02:45,199
same case because you can't just decide, meaning

89
00:02:45,259 --> 00:02:47,219
based on that *Magen Avraham*, the whole *Svara*

90
00:02:47,379 --> 00:02:49,219
about being *Mkabel* *Shabbos* early is that you

91
00:02:49,219 --> 00:02:51,680
could have decided that it's not *Shabbos* for

92
00:02:51,680 --> 00:02:54,528
you. You can't decide that it's not *Yom

93
00:02:54,528 --> 00:02:55,340
Tov* for you. Rav Moshe says I know

94
00:02:55,340 --> 00:02:57,340
what you're thinking, yes you can, because anyone

95
00:02:57,340 --> 00:02:58,879
that's in *Eretz Yisrael* could just decide to

96
00:02:58,879 --> 00:03:01,180
stay. And if you decide to stay, then

97
00:03:01,180 --> 00:03:02,677
it won't be Yom Tov Sheni *Yom Tov

98
00:03:02,677 --> 00:03:03,580
Sheini* for you anymore, then you'll only have

99
00:03:03,580 --> 00:03:05,379
to keep one day. He says come on,

100
00:03:05,500 --> 00:03:06,879
you know you're not going to stay, your

101
00:03:06,879 --> 00:03:08,780
kids are in school in *Chutz la'Aretz*, your

102
00:03:08,780 --> 00:03:10,780
job is in *Chutz la'Aretz*, you're not going

103
00:03:10,780 --> 00:03:13,000
to decide in the spot on the spot

104
00:03:13,000 --> 00:03:15,360
to stay. So therefore Rav Moshe says it's

105
00:03:15,360 --> 00:03:17,360
left as a *Safek*, and if it's left

106
00:03:17,360 --> 00:03:19,020
as a *Safek* you have to just, meaning

107
00:03:19,419 --> 00:03:21,719
we're left without any *Rayas* and without any

108
00:03:21,969 --> 00:03:23,269
*Rayas* you have to assume that there's an

109
00:03:23,269 --> 00:03:24,978
issur *Issur Amira*. Just like there's issur amira

110
00:03:24,978 --> 00:03:26,340
l'nochri. *Issur Amira l'nachri*, there's got to be

111
00:03:26,340 --> 00:03:28,219
an issur *Issur Amira*. Then Rav Moshe points

112
00:03:28,219 --> 00:03:30,599
out that in fact is two *De'os* in

113
00:03:31,120 --> 00:03:32,988
*Acharonim*, quoting the teshuvah *Sha'arei Teshuva* in *Siman

114
00:03:32,988 --> 00:03:34,659
Tof Tzadi Vav* *Sif Katan Gimmel* where the

115
00:03:35,158 --> 00:03:37,139
*Birkei Yosef* in the name of *Marikash* writes

116
00:03:37,139 --> 00:03:39,360
that a *Ben Chutz la'Aretz* that's working in

117
00:03:39,858 --> 00:03:41,695
*Eretz Yisrael* is allowed to tell a ben

118
00:03:41,695 --> 00:03:43,639
eretz yisrael *Ben Eretz Yisrael* that to do

119
00:03:43,639 --> 00:03:45,228
melacha *Melacha* for him on Yom Tov Sheini?

120
00:03:45,228 --> 00:03:47,278
*Yom Tov Sheini*, and *Marei Melka* and *Marei

121
00:03:47,278 --> 00:03:49,968
Prago* all disagree and say that it's not,

122
00:03:49,968 --> 00:03:52,099
that it's not allowed and Rav Moshe thinks

123
00:03:52,099 --> 00:03:53,837
that we should be machmir *Machmir*. In fact,

124
00:03:53,837 --> 00:03:55,979
Rav Shlomo Kluger in *Chachmas Shlomo* *Siman Tof

125
00:03:55,979 --> 00:03:58,419
Tzadi Vav* gives two reasons to assur. *Asser*

126
00:03:58,419 --> 00:04:00,998
this, to *Asser* *Ben Chutz la'Aretz* doing *Amira

127
00:04:00,998 --> 00:04:02,468
l'Yisrael* to a ben eretz yisrael *Ben Eretz

128
00:04:02,468 --> 00:04:04,240
Yisrael*. Number one he says why should it

129
00:04:04,240 --> 00:04:05,797
be any different than amira l'nochri *Amira l'nachri*?

130
00:04:05,797 --> 00:04:07,907
amira l'nochri. *Amira l'nachri* is *Assur*, *Daber Davar*,

131
00:04:07,907 --> 00:04:09,419
you're speaking in melacha *Melacha*, you're asking to

132
00:04:09,419 --> 00:04:10,860
do melacha *Melacha*, it should be just like

133
00:04:11,358 --> 00:04:12,680
*Amira l'nachri*. Number two he says it's worse

134
00:04:12,680 --> 00:04:15,879
than *Amira l'nachri* because *Amira l'nachri* is, one

135
00:04:15,879 --> 00:04:17,899
of the *Svaras* for *Amira l'nachri* *Rashi* writes

136
00:04:18,019 --> 00:04:20,800
is that *Shlichus l'Akum l'chumra*. You know what?

137
00:04:20,879 --> 00:04:23,665
When it comes to *Yisrael*, *Yesh Shlichus* *Mi-ikar

138
00:04:23,665 --> 00:04:26,079
hadin*. Forget about *L'chumra*. They can actually be

139
00:04:26,079 --> 00:04:28,278
your *Shliach*. So it's even worse than *Amira

140
00:04:28,278 --> 00:04:31,920
l'nachri*. *Nafka mina* between those two *Svaras* of

141
00:04:31,920 --> 00:04:33,839
Rav Shlomo Kluger whether it's the same as

142
00:04:34,338 --> 00:04:36,259
*Amira l'nachri* or worse than *Amira l'nachri* is

143
00:04:36,259 --> 00:04:37,939
let's say you're in a situation where you're

144
00:04:37,939 --> 00:04:39,860
allowed to do *Amira l'nachri*. You're in one

145
00:04:39,860 --> 00:04:41,500
of those cases where you have a *Heter*

146
00:04:41,500 --> 00:04:43,600
of *Amira l'nachri*. Is it better to do

147
00:04:44,098 --> 00:04:46,180
*Amira l'nachri* than *Amira l'Yisrael*? Or does it

148
00:04:46,180 --> 00:04:48,139
not make a difference? So that would be

149
00:04:48,139 --> 00:04:51,519
a potential *Nafka mina*. It's interesting Rav Moshe

150
00:04:51,519 --> 00:04:54,106
has another teshuvah *Teshuva* in *Orach Chaim* *Cheilek

151
00:04:54,106 --> 00:04:54,720
Gimmel* *Siman Ayin Aleph* where he says that

152
00:04:54,720 --> 00:04:56,519
if you are an American and you have

153
00:04:56,519 --> 00:05:00,160
a company or an office, a factory factory

154
00:05:00,160 --> 00:05:03,660
in Israel that works, your employees are allowed

155
00:05:03,660 --> 00:05:05,779
to work for you in Israel. Rav Moshe

156
00:05:05,779 --> 00:05:07,699
writes in teshuvah no problem, your employees can

157
00:05:07,699 --> 00:05:09,139
continue to work for you on Yom Tov

158
00:05:09,139 --> 00:05:10,899
Sheini. in Israel. So then of course Rav

159
00:05:10,899 --> 00:05:13,740
Moshe has a third teshuvah that says what

160
00:05:13,740 --> 00:05:15,920
just happened over here it's a stira. In

161
00:05:15,920 --> 00:05:18,560
one Rav Moshe says that a is not

162
00:05:18,560 --> 00:05:20,886
allowed to tell a to do melacha? for

163
00:05:20,886 --> 00:05:22,079
them. In a second he says well if

164
00:05:22,079 --> 00:05:23,339
you have people that work for you in

165
00:05:23,959 --> 00:05:25,439
yeah let them keep working for you on

166
00:05:25,779 --> 00:05:28,379
So hay how can how could both be

167
00:05:28,379 --> 00:05:30,278
true? So Rav Moshe writes in Chelek Daled

168
00:05:30,278 --> 00:05:32,740
Siman Kuf Hey he doesn't even understand the

169
00:05:32,740 --> 00:05:34,439
kasha. He says in the case where you

170
00:05:34,439 --> 00:05:35,939
have an office a factory something like that

171
00:05:36,100 --> 00:05:37,620
you hire people and you tell them I

172
00:05:37,620 --> 00:05:39,100
want you to work on all the weekdays

173
00:05:39,379 --> 00:05:40,899
so they work on every day that's a

174
00:05:40,899 --> 00:05:43,319
weekday. But when you specifically ask a person

175
00:05:43,319 --> 00:05:45,079
to do melacha for you on a day

176
00:05:45,079 --> 00:05:47,220
that is for you that's going to be

177
00:05:47,779 --> 00:05:49,259
He says mashal lema hadavar domeh let's say

178
00:05:49,259 --> 00:05:51,439
a person gets lost he wanders somewhere and

179
00:05:51,439 --> 00:05:52,860
he gets lost and he has no idea

180
00:05:52,860 --> 00:05:55,959
what day is. So whatever day he thinks

181
00:05:55,959 --> 00:05:58,519
might be he has to be and not

182
00:05:58,519 --> 00:06:00,959
do anything. But people back home that work

183
00:06:00,959 --> 00:06:03,319
for him that know what day is are

184
00:06:03,319 --> 00:06:04,879
allowed to do melachos on days that aren't

185
00:06:05,129 --> 00:06:07,959
So Rav Moshe says you're in you're not

186
00:06:07,959 --> 00:06:09,560
allowed to do any melacha on but the

187
00:06:09,560 --> 00:06:11,889
people in know what day is and they

188
00:06:11,889 --> 00:06:14,019
are therefore allowed to do melacha on You

189
00:06:14,019 --> 00:06:16,100
just can't ask them on that day to

190
00:06:16,100 --> 00:06:17,660
do melacha for you. So it seems very

191
00:06:17,660 --> 00:06:19,899
clear Rav Moshe. would this this that we're

192
00:06:19,899 --> 00:06:21,839
talking about would be a non-starter according to

193
00:06:21,839 --> 00:06:23,579
Rav Moshe. You're not allowed to ask. However

194
00:06:24,100 --> 00:06:27,440
in Chelkas Yaakov in Siman Pey Hey Rav

195
00:06:27,440 --> 00:06:29,600
Breisch disagrees and he says no this is

196
00:06:29,600 --> 00:06:31,879
even better than the kabalas shabbos case because

197
00:06:31,879 --> 00:06:33,600
the kabalas shabbos case what does the say?

198
00:06:33,920 --> 00:06:35,920
That you could have decided not to make

199
00:06:35,920 --> 00:06:38,339
it Yeah you could have but you didn't.

200
00:06:38,360 --> 00:06:40,459
You already made it So once you made

201
00:06:40,459 --> 00:06:42,649
it there's no backing out. Once you're un-mekabel

202
00:06:42,649 --> 00:06:45,779
shabbos. you can't But he says with this

203
00:06:45,779 --> 00:06:48,639
case you actually can decide to become a

204
00:06:49,459 --> 00:06:51,680
You could still do it meaning at any

205
00:06:51,680 --> 00:06:54,000
point you could decide to become a so

206
00:06:54,000 --> 00:06:56,199
it's even more beyado it's even better than

207
00:06:56,199 --> 00:06:58,220
the kabalas shabbos case so of course you're

208
00:06:58,220 --> 00:07:00,800
allowed to ask a to do for you.

209
00:07:01,079 --> 00:07:02,600
The Debreciner Rav in Beer Moshe Chelek Zayin

210
00:07:02,660 --> 00:07:05,250
dinei bnei eretz yisrael vechutz la'aretz Perek Resh

211
00:07:05,250 --> 00:07:07,220
Nun Ches disagrees. He says it doesn't work

212
00:07:07,220 --> 00:07:08,920
that way. He says if you decide in

213
00:07:08,939 --> 00:07:11,720
middle of that you're making aliyah doesn't go

214
00:07:11,720 --> 00:07:14,038
away. It's it's all based on when started.

215
00:07:14,038 --> 00:07:16,879
When started you were a so you're gonna

216
00:07:16,879 --> 00:07:18,860
have to suffer through that even if you

217
00:07:18,860 --> 00:07:20,839
decide to make aliyah right in the middle

218
00:07:20,839 --> 00:07:23,870
of Happens to be in Kovetz Teshuvos Chelek

219
00:07:23,870 --> 00:07:26,420
Alef Siman Nun Daled Rav Elyashiv paskens like

220
00:07:26,420 --> 00:07:28,164
the Chelkas Yaakov not like Reb Moshe, Rav

221
00:07:28,164 --> 00:07:30,399
Elyashiv holds that you are allowed to ask

222
00:07:30,399 --> 00:07:33,240
a to do for you. He says you

223
00:07:33,240 --> 00:07:34,560
should only do it if there's a real

224
00:07:34,560 --> 00:07:36,560
tzorech for it a tzorech mitzvah or something

225
00:07:36,560 --> 00:07:38,600
like that some sort of real tzorech for

226
00:07:38,600 --> 00:07:41,120
it. So let's assume like the Chelkas Yaakov

227
00:07:41,259 --> 00:07:43,500
like Rav Elyashiv is this worse? I'm not

228
00:07:43,500 --> 00:07:45,300
just asking the person to do for me.

229
00:07:45,639 --> 00:07:47,639
The woman is asking the Bas Eretz Yisrael

230
00:07:47,639 --> 00:07:50,399
to put makeup on her face. Does that

231
00:07:50,399 --> 00:07:52,939
make it worse? So the first thing that

232
00:07:52,939 --> 00:07:54,959
comes to mind is the pasuk in this

233
00:07:54,959 --> 00:07:56,980
past week's parsha lo takifu pe'as roshchem. The

234
00:07:57,279 --> 00:07:59,914
Gemara Makos Daf Chaf Amud Beis says echad

235
00:07:59,914 --> 00:08:02,759
hamakif ve'echad hanikif that there's an issur to

236
00:08:02,759 --> 00:08:05,560
cut off your peyos and that's true of

237
00:08:05,560 --> 00:08:07,540
both the person giving the haircut and the

238
00:08:07,540 --> 00:08:09,420
person receiving the haircut. Even though the person

239
00:08:09,420 --> 00:08:12,279
receiving the haircut is it's just happening on

240
00:08:12,279 --> 00:08:14,920
their body they're not they're not doing anything.

241
00:08:14,920 --> 00:08:17,620
Yeah they maybe if they move so then

242
00:08:17,620 --> 00:08:19,360
it's called a lav she'yesh bo ma'aseh. If

243
00:08:19,360 --> 00:08:21,240
they don't move it's a lav she'ein bo

244
00:08:21,240 --> 00:08:23,019
ma'aseh. Either way though it's a lav even

245
00:08:23,019 --> 00:08:25,100
though they're not the ones doing the action

246
00:08:25,480 --> 00:08:27,060
they're the ones sitting there. Why is it

247
00:08:27,060 --> 00:08:30,139
a lav? Because because it's happening on their

248
00:08:30,139 --> 00:08:33,100
body. So it makes you gives the impression

249
00:08:33,100 --> 00:08:35,679
that whenever an issur is done on your

250
00:08:35,679 --> 00:08:39,120
body it's your issur also. It's not so

251
00:08:39,120 --> 00:08:41,480
clear though that that applies to all issurim

252
00:08:41,480 --> 00:08:43,440
in the Torah. The Minchas Chinuch discusses in

253
00:08:43,840 --> 00:08:45,599
Mitzvah Taf Samech Zayin the issur of lo

254
00:08:45,599 --> 00:08:47,500
sisgodedu that you're not supposed to cut yourself

255
00:08:47,500 --> 00:08:49,037
like the real lo sisgodedu not the not

256
00:08:49,037 --> 00:08:51,440
the that you're not supposed to cut yourself

257
00:08:51,440 --> 00:08:54,120
in mourning over so what if someone else

258
00:08:54,120 --> 00:08:56,480
cuts you in mourning over? So is that

259
00:08:56,480 --> 00:08:59,340
your issur also? Minchas Chinuch says yeah because

260
00:08:59,340 --> 00:09:01,600
it's said in the plural. So since it's

261
00:09:01,600 --> 00:09:03,919
said belashon rabbim it probably includes the person

262
00:09:03,960 --> 00:09:06,850
it's happening on also. Minchas Chinuch in Mitzvah

263
00:09:06,850 --> 00:09:07,980
Reish Tzadi Alef talks about the issur of

264
00:09:07,980 --> 00:09:11,279
sirus that you're not allowed to castrate an

265
00:09:11,279 --> 00:09:14,150
animal or a person or anything. So Minchas

266
00:09:14,150 --> 00:09:16,440
Chinuch says what if you are not the

267
00:09:16,440 --> 00:09:18,519
doctor you are the patient meaning you're getting

268
00:09:18,519 --> 00:09:21,039
a vasectomy? You didn't you're not the surgeon

269
00:09:21,039 --> 00:09:23,440
doing the vasectomy you're just the patient lying

270
00:09:23,440 --> 00:09:25,620
on the table getting the vasectomy. So is

271
00:09:25,620 --> 00:09:28,639
that just an issur of is it an

272
00:09:28,820 --> 00:09:30,679
of lifnei iver or is it no you're

273
00:09:30,679 --> 00:09:33,919
doing the actual you're involved in the actual

274
00:09:34,500 --> 00:09:36,340
because it's happening on your body? Minchas Chinuch

275
00:09:36,340 --> 00:09:39,299
says he's he's not sure. What this really

276
00:09:39,299 --> 00:09:40,740
boils down to this is the beauty of

277
00:09:41,120 --> 00:09:42,320
it's all over the place. What it really

278
00:09:42,320 --> 00:09:44,289
boils down to is a machlokes Shach and

279
00:09:44,289 --> 00:09:46,980
Tas machlokes Shach and Tas Hilchos Niddah. In

280
00:09:46,980 --> 00:09:48,600
Hilchos Niddah there's a machlokes Shach and Tas

281
00:09:48,600 --> 00:09:50,799
Siman Kuf Tzadi Ches Yoreh Deah as follows:

282
00:09:50,799 --> 00:09:53,600
That the is the Rama writes that a

283
00:09:53,600 --> 00:09:54,980
woman is supposed to cut her nails before

284
00:09:54,980 --> 00:09:56,899
going to the mikvah. What if she forgot

285
00:09:56,899 --> 00:09:58,159
to cut her nails before going to the

286
00:09:58,159 --> 00:10:10,240
mikvah and now it's ask

287
00:10:10,240 --> 00:10:12,820
a nochri manicurist to cut your nails for

288
00:10:12,820 --> 00:10:15,980
you because it's happening on your body, just

289
00:10:15,980 --> 00:10:18,340
like lo sakifu. It's happening on your body,

290
00:10:18,500 --> 00:10:20,960
you are doing the chillul Shabbos when it

291
00:10:20,960 --> 00:10:22,919
happens on your body, even though the other

292
00:10:22,919 --> 00:10:25,679
person is doing the maiseh. Says the Shach,

293
00:10:25,799 --> 00:10:28,039
what on earth are you talking about? He

294
00:10:28,039 --> 00:10:31,409
says, 'chada d'afilu chaschom bikli', well, leaving out

295
00:10:31,409 --> 00:10:33,137
that one, he says, 'd'kan lo shayach mesaya

296
00:10:33,137 --> 00:10:35,133
davka b'hakafa'. It's davka by hakafa by payos

297
00:10:35,133 --> 00:10:38,077
that we say that echad hamakif v'echad hanikaf,

298
00:10:38,860 --> 00:10:41,100
it's because it's said in the plural. But

299
00:10:41,100 --> 00:10:43,679
someone does chillul Shabbos on your body, someone

300
00:10:43,679 --> 00:10:46,679
writes on you, you violate kosev? Someone does

301
00:10:46,679 --> 00:10:49,224
chillul Shabbos on your body, it's your meheichi

302
00:10:49,224 --> 00:10:52,399
taysi? The Shach in Nekudos Hakesef rejected. How

303
00:10:52,399 --> 00:10:55,569
do we paskin on that Mishnah Berurah Shin

304
00:10:55,569 --> 00:10:59,139
Mem seif katan v'ishah sheshachachah litol tzipporneha m'erev

305
00:10:59,139 --> 00:11:01,919
Shabbos v'chal tevilasah b'leil Shabbos, woman forgot to

306
00:11:01,919 --> 00:11:03,460
cut her nails erev Shabbos and she has

307
00:11:03,460 --> 00:11:04,779
to go to the mikvah on Friday night,

308
00:11:04,779 --> 00:11:07,694
muskam haMagen Avraham shetomar l'oved gilulim litol beyada

309
00:11:07,694 --> 00:11:11,160
mishum shvus d'shvus b'makom mitzvah v'im ee efshar

310
00:11:11,160 --> 00:11:14,580
beyad mutar al yadah afilu bikli. He says

311
00:11:14,580 --> 00:11:16,940
you're allowed to do He talks about the

312
00:11:16,940 --> 00:11:18,679
details about maybe not using a nail clipper,

313
00:11:18,679 --> 00:11:21,120
but you're allowed to do because he views

314
00:11:21,120 --> 00:11:23,639
it as only He doesn't view it as

315
00:11:23,639 --> 00:11:27,000
you violating the even though it's happening on

316
00:11:27,000 --> 00:11:28,940
your body. So long story short, can this

317
00:11:28,940 --> 00:11:31,240
woman get her makeup put on by a

318
00:11:31,988 --> 00:11:35,879
on According to non-starter. No way. There's an

319
00:11:36,129 --> 00:11:39,100
of you're not allowed to ask a to

320
00:11:39,100 --> 00:11:41,899
do for you on But if you assume

321
00:11:42,179 --> 00:11:44,039
like the Chelkas Yaakov or you assume like

322
00:11:44,220 --> 00:11:46,899
Rav Elyashiv that from that perspective it would

323
00:11:46,899 --> 00:11:49,178
be so then you're talya in this machlokes

324
00:11:49,178 --> 00:11:50,720
Taz and the Shach. And it seems that

325
00:11:50,720 --> 00:11:52,639
we paskin like the Shach, that it's not

326
00:11:52,639 --> 00:11:55,019
a problem even though the is being done

327
00:11:55,019 --> 00:11:57,519
on your body, it's not considered that it's

328
00:11:57,519 --> 00:11:59,860
any more than an that it's not considered

329
00:11:59,860 --> 00:12:02,360
that you're doing the yourself. I told her

330
00:12:02,360 --> 00:12:03,379
she could do it. She ended up not

331
00:12:03,379 --> 00:12:06,059
doing it. So it ended up all's well

332
00:12:06,059 --> 00:12:07,740
that ends well. I think she survived without

333
00:12:07,740 --> 00:12:08,779
the makeup, Baruch Hashem.
