1
00:00:00,000 --> 00:00:01,980
We started to have a discussion about the

2
00:00:01,980 --> 00:00:04,059
laws of Amira L'Nochri and we gave a

3
00:00:04,059 --> 00:00:07,120
background fundamental shiur about what is the reason

4
00:00:07,120 --> 00:00:09,859
why Amira L'Nochri is prohibited. Why are you

5
00:00:09,859 --> 00:00:11,880
not allowed to ask a Gentile to do

6
00:00:11,880 --> 00:00:14,820
forbidden activity for you on Shabbos when in

7
00:00:14,820 --> 00:00:17,239
fact the Gentile themselves is not obligated to

8
00:00:17,239 --> 00:00:18,640
keep Shabbos. So what is the problem? We

9
00:00:18,640 --> 00:00:20,480
spoke about that last time and now we're

10
00:00:20,480 --> 00:00:23,620
going to talk about an extension of this

11
00:00:23,620 --> 00:00:26,179
issue which is not exactly the same but

12
00:00:26,179 --> 00:00:27,980
is something that comes up all the time

13
00:00:27,980 --> 00:00:30,339
and is very interesting and very very important

14
00:00:30,339 --> 00:00:32,140
and it has a number of different variations

15
00:00:32,140 --> 00:00:34,240
to the question. First variation that we're going

16
00:00:34,240 --> 00:00:36,200
to talk about is the following. What happens

17
00:00:36,200 --> 00:00:38,840
when you have a Jew in the summertime

18
00:00:38,840 --> 00:00:42,799
when Shabbos comes in at 7:45. I don't

19
00:00:42,799 --> 00:00:44,500
want to wait until 7:45 so I am

20
00:00:44,619 --> 00:00:47,000
mekabel Shabbos early. I bring in Shabbos let's

21
00:00:47,000 --> 00:00:49,579
say at 6:30 or 6:00 and then I

22
00:00:49,579 --> 00:00:51,479
have plenty of members of my community who

23
00:00:51,479 --> 00:00:53,340
do not accept Shabbos at the same time

24
00:00:53,340 --> 00:00:55,399
as I do. And then I realize after

25
00:00:55,399 --> 00:00:58,000
I already accepted Shabbos that I forgot to

26
00:00:58,000 --> 00:01:00,539
do something but it's already Shabbos for me.

27
00:01:01,020 --> 00:01:02,280
Am I allowed to ask one of the

28
00:01:02,280 --> 00:01:05,480
Jews that I am familiar with to do

29
00:01:05,480 --> 00:01:08,579
an activity that for me, I myself would

30
00:01:08,579 --> 00:01:10,280
not be allowed to perform because it's already

31
00:01:10,280 --> 00:01:12,519
Shabbos. I have accepted it upon myself at

32
00:01:12,519 --> 00:01:14,680
six and for them they're not going to

33
00:01:14,680 --> 00:01:18,200
accept Shabbos until 7:45. That's question number one.

34
00:01:18,200 --> 00:01:20,500
Which is then going to lead us into

35
00:01:20,500 --> 00:01:24,640
question number two. Question number two is I'm

36
00:01:24,640 --> 00:01:26,379
sure many of us have been in Israel

37
00:01:26,379 --> 00:01:29,560
for the Chagim for Yom Tov and when

38
00:01:29,560 --> 00:01:31,620
a ben Chutz L'Aretz, when a member of

39
00:01:31,620 --> 00:01:33,659
the diaspora goes to Eretz Yisrael for Yom

40
00:01:33,659 --> 00:01:35,739
Tov you are supposed to keep two days

41
00:01:35,739 --> 00:01:37,819
of Yom Tov contrary to what many people

42
00:01:37,819 --> 00:01:39,920
think. We are supposed to keep two days

43
00:01:39,920 --> 00:01:41,280
of Yom Tov when we're in Eretz Yisrael.

44
00:01:41,900 --> 00:01:44,599
There are certain permutations when people don't but

45
00:01:44,599 --> 00:01:47,280
the I can't say the consensus but it

46
00:01:47,280 --> 00:01:49,700
seems the overwhelming opinion in the poskim is

47
00:01:49,700 --> 00:01:51,000
that you're supposed to keep two days of

48
00:01:51,000 --> 00:01:52,799
Yom Tov when you're in Eretz Yisrael. So

49
00:01:52,799 --> 00:01:54,239
I'm keeping the second day of Yom Tov

50
00:01:54,239 --> 00:01:58,319
but my Israeli neighbor who has the house

51
00:01:58,319 --> 00:02:00,379
or the apartment right next door obviously it's

52
00:02:00,379 --> 00:02:02,219
not Yom Tov for them. Am I allowed

53
00:02:02,219 --> 00:02:04,260
to ask them to do something that I

54
00:02:04,260 --> 00:02:06,239
myself would not be allowed to do because

55
00:02:06,239 --> 00:02:07,700
for me it's Yom Tov and for them

56
00:02:07,700 --> 00:02:09,620
it's not? Or would you say that the

57
00:02:09,620 --> 00:02:11,800
same rules that apply by Amira L'Nochri on

58
00:02:11,800 --> 00:02:16,400
Shabbos should also apply to this situation and

59
00:02:16,400 --> 00:02:18,240
this circumstance? Which is going to lead us

60
00:02:18,240 --> 00:02:21,979
to discussion number three which is let's say

61
00:02:21,979 --> 00:02:23,840
there was something on Shabbos that I am

62
00:02:23,840 --> 00:02:26,699
careful not to do. For example there are

63
00:02:26,699 --> 00:02:28,840
many people that don't carry in the eruv.

64
00:02:29,500 --> 00:02:30,939
The Mishnah Berurah says even if you have

65
00:02:30,939 --> 00:02:32,780
a good eruv and people are checking it

66
00:02:32,780 --> 00:02:34,780
and people are vigilant the Mishnah Berurah says

67
00:02:34,780 --> 00:02:36,919
ba'al nefesh yachmir. A person should try if

68
00:02:36,919 --> 00:02:38,360
they don't have to use the eruv they

69
00:02:38,360 --> 00:02:39,740
shouldn't use the eruv. So let's say I

70
00:02:39,740 --> 00:02:41,400
don't use the eruv but I have a

71
00:02:41,400 --> 00:02:43,639
next door neighbor who does. Am I allowed

72
00:02:43,639 --> 00:02:45,139
to ask the next door neighbor to carry

73
00:02:45,139 --> 00:02:46,683
something for me on Shabbos to shul that

74
00:02:46,683 --> 00:02:49,919
I forgot to bring before Shabbos? Or if

75
00:02:49,919 --> 00:02:52,500
I do not open up bottle caps on

76
00:02:52,500 --> 00:02:54,780
Shabbos and I have somebody sitting at my

77
00:02:54,780 --> 00:02:56,659
table who does, am I allowed to ask

78
00:02:56,659 --> 00:02:58,379
them to do something, can they be my

79
00:02:58,379 --> 00:03:00,400
Shabbos goy, right? Can that Jew sitting at

80
00:03:00,400 --> 00:03:02,139
my table be the person who is going

81
00:03:02,139 --> 00:03:03,960
to do something that I believe is forbidden

82
00:03:03,960 --> 00:03:06,639
or perhaps not? Let's discuss all of this

83
00:03:06,639 --> 00:03:08,400
because I think it's really interesting and really

84
00:03:08,400 --> 00:03:10,680
important for us to know because these kinds

85
00:03:10,680 --> 00:03:13,500
of situations come up all the time. Yes.

86
00:03:13,639 --> 00:03:15,639
Is this the same as an Ashkenaz person

87
00:03:16,319 --> 00:03:18,240
asks a Sefard? Correct. Same same thing. Yes.

88
00:03:18,599 --> 00:03:20,520
All part of the same discussion. We don't

89
00:03:20,520 --> 00:03:21,879
have enough time so let's try to get

90
00:03:21,879 --> 00:03:23,379
through as much as we can so that

91
00:03:23,379 --> 00:03:25,039
we can discuss the issue. In order to

92
00:03:25,039 --> 00:03:27,639
understand the beginning of this problem or the

93
00:03:27,639 --> 00:03:29,840
beginning of the solution to this problem let

94
00:03:29,840 --> 00:03:31,139
us first give a little bit of background

95
00:03:31,139 --> 00:03:33,759
about the prohibition of Tosefes. First of all

96
00:03:34,060 --> 00:03:36,060
when we talk about Tosefes Shabbos. What is

97
00:03:36,060 --> 00:03:38,000
Tosefes Shabbos? How do you add on to

98
00:03:38,000 --> 00:03:40,439
Shabbos? What does that mean? Either it's Shabbos

99
00:03:40,439 --> 00:03:43,060
or it's not Shabbos. What does Tosefes mean?

100
00:03:43,379 --> 00:03:44,860
This is an idea, this is a concept

101
00:03:44,860 --> 00:03:47,150
that is born from the idea of Yom

102
00:03:47,150 --> 00:03:49,440
HaKippurim. The Gemara says in Masechet Yoma daf

103
00:03:49,440 --> 00:03:52,360
pey-aleph amud-bet that we have a concept of

104
00:03:52,360 --> 00:03:55,479
Tosefes Yom HaKippurim which means Yom Kippur is

105
00:03:55,479 --> 00:03:57,900
really from sundown to sundown but the Torah

106
00:03:57,900 --> 00:03:59,680
seems to indicate that we are supposed to

107
00:03:59,680 --> 00:04:03,979
already usher in Yom HaKippurim before sundown even

108
00:04:03,979 --> 00:04:06,060
comes to be. So we're supposed to take

109
00:04:06,060 --> 00:04:07,879
a little bit of the day before Yom

110
00:04:07,879 --> 00:04:10,719
Kippur add it on to extend it on

111
00:04:10,719 --> 00:04:12,919
to Yom Kippur itself and that is called

112
00:04:12,919 --> 00:04:15,280
Tosefes Yom HaKippurim. If you look in the

113
00:04:15,280 --> 00:04:18,040
Rambam, the Rambam says that is limited to

114
00:04:18,040 --> 00:04:20,019
Yom HaKippurim. That's the only place the Gemara

115
00:04:20,019 --> 00:04:22,740
talks about this idea of Tosefes. And surprisingly

116
00:04:23,240 --> 00:04:25,060
the Rambam does not mention it by Shabbos

117
00:04:25,060 --> 00:04:26,899
or Yom Tov, which is very shocking. We're

118
00:04:26,899 --> 00:04:29,100
all familiar with the fact that women light

119
00:04:29,100 --> 00:04:32,620
candles 18 minutes before sunset, right? Or in

120
00:04:32,620 --> 00:04:35,120
Yerushalayim they light candles I think more than

121
00:04:35,120 --> 00:04:38,540
that. 40 minutes before sunset. So we all

122
00:04:38,540 --> 00:04:40,339
have this idea, this notion in our heads

123
00:04:40,339 --> 00:04:43,740
of Tosefes, but surprisingly the Rambam himself doesn't

124
00:04:43,740 --> 00:04:45,360
mention it. How does the Rambam leave it

125
00:04:45,360 --> 00:04:47,220
out? Good question but all the other Rishonim

126
00:04:47,220 --> 00:04:49,379
disagree and they all say the same way

127
00:04:49,379 --> 00:04:50,959
the Gemara tells us that there's a concept

128
00:04:50,959 --> 00:04:54,040
of Tosefes that you're supposed to extend Shabbos,

129
00:04:55,079 --> 00:04:57,139
you're supposed to extend Yom Kippur so too

130
00:04:57,420 --> 00:05:00,480
there's a concept of extending every every Shabbos

131
00:05:00,480 --> 00:05:02,579
and every Yom Tov as well. How much

132
00:05:02,579 --> 00:05:04,459
you're supposed to extend is an excellent question.

133
00:05:05,000 --> 00:05:06,680
Is there a limit? Rav Moshe Feinstein writes

134
00:05:06,680 --> 00:05:08,000
in a Teshuvah just a couple of minutes

135
00:05:08,000 --> 00:05:10,680
would be sufficient. My father has a very

136
00:05:10,680 --> 00:05:13,000
interesting shita which is based on a comment

137
00:05:13,000 --> 00:05:14,899
of Rabbeinu Peretz in Maseches Beitzah daf lamed

138
00:05:15,240 --> 00:05:17,879
where Rabbeinu Peretz seems to say that tosefes,

139
00:05:18,019 --> 00:05:20,259
that adding on to Shabbos or Yom Tov

140
00:05:20,259 --> 00:05:22,699
or Yom Kippur would only be thirty minutes.

141
00:05:23,019 --> 00:05:25,319
So my father himself is machmir that he's

142
00:05:25,319 --> 00:05:27,639
mekabel Shabbos thirty minutes early every Shabbos, which

143
00:05:27,639 --> 00:05:29,660
doesn't sound like a big deal, but in

144
00:05:29,660 --> 00:05:32,220
the wintertime when Shabbos is at 4:15 and

145
00:05:32,220 --> 00:05:35,019
you're accepting Shabbos at 3:45, it's not so

146
00:05:35,019 --> 00:05:36,791
pashut. It's not so easy, but my father's

147
00:05:36,791 --> 00:05:39,120
a yarei Shamayim and that's what he does.

148
00:05:39,439 --> 00:05:41,939
He's always mekabel Shabbos thirty minutes early. Okay,

149
00:05:42,040 --> 00:05:43,779
but that's the details of Kabbalas Shabbos, we

150
00:05:43,779 --> 00:05:45,680
could talk about that another time, but now

151
00:05:45,680 --> 00:05:47,879
for the purposes of our discussion, we need

152
00:05:47,879 --> 00:05:49,879
to know that there's a concept of Tosefes

153
00:05:49,879 --> 00:05:52,600
Shabbos that we generally think about. Now in

154
00:05:52,600 --> 00:05:54,899
that time of Tosefes, this is the question

155
00:05:54,899 --> 00:05:57,199
that we presented: when it's already Shabbos for

156
00:05:57,199 --> 00:05:59,680
me, but it's not Shabbos for you because

157
00:05:59,680 --> 00:06:01,779
I extended Shabbos and I brought it in

158
00:06:01,779 --> 00:06:04,939
two hours early, would I be allowed to

159
00:06:04,939 --> 00:06:07,360
ask somebody who has not yet accepted Shabbos

160
00:06:07,360 --> 00:06:09,680
to do something on my behalf or perhaps

161
00:06:09,680 --> 00:06:11,980
not? So here we go. You ready? Here

162
00:06:11,980 --> 00:06:13,830
we go. We have a concept in Hilchos

163
00:06:13,830 --> 00:06:16,339
Shabbos that is referred to as Issur Techumin.

164
00:06:17,180 --> 00:06:19,819
What does Issur Techumin mean? Issur Techumin means

165
00:06:19,819 --> 00:06:21,899
we have a prohibition for a person to

166
00:06:21,899 --> 00:06:24,420
go out of a certain designated location on

167
00:06:24,420 --> 00:06:26,180
Shabbos. That is actually learned from a pasuk

168
00:06:26,180 --> 00:06:28,379
in this week's parsha. In this week's parsha

169
00:06:28,379 --> 00:06:29,720
we read the Jewish people come out of

170
00:06:29,720 --> 00:06:32,959
Mitzrayim. What happens after they come out of

171
00:06:32,959 --> 00:06:34,720
Mitzrayim, they realize we don't have any food,

172
00:06:34,879 --> 00:06:36,120
what are we going to do? And the

173
00:06:36,120 --> 00:06:37,759
Jewish people start looking around, where are we

174
00:06:37,759 --> 00:06:38,939
going to find food? We're in the desert,

175
00:06:39,079 --> 00:06:41,559
we're stuck. Let's go back to Egypt. Moshe

176
00:06:41,559 --> 00:06:42,620
Rabbeinu says no no we're going to stay

177
00:06:42,620 --> 00:06:44,500
here. We came out of Egypt, we're out

178
00:06:44,500 --> 00:06:45,800
of Mitzrayim, God's going to take care of

179
00:06:45,800 --> 00:06:48,720
us. Hakadosh Baruch Hu sends the mann. What

180
00:06:48,720 --> 00:06:50,879
was the infrastructure, what did everyone have to

181
00:06:50,879 --> 00:06:53,959
do? The process was that you go and

182
00:06:53,959 --> 00:06:57,259
collect your mann every day and that is

183
00:06:57,259 --> 00:06:58,480
what you were going to feed your family

184
00:06:58,480 --> 00:07:01,480
with. Okay. Hakadosh Baruch Hu tells them I

185
00:07:01,480 --> 00:07:03,997
want you to know: Re’u ki Hashem nasan

186
00:07:03,997 --> 00:07:06,300
lachem es haShabbos. I want you all to

187
00:07:06,300 --> 00:07:07,779
know that I'm giving you the mitzvah of

188
00:07:07,779 --> 00:07:10,319
Shabbos, which is really interesting because if you

189
00:07:10,319 --> 00:07:12,079
were to ask nine out of ten people

190
00:07:12,579 --> 00:07:14,220
when did Hashem give us the mitzvah of

191
00:07:14,220 --> 00:07:17,639
Shabbos, what would they say? At Har Sinai.

192
00:07:17,779 --> 00:07:20,000
It's one of the Aseres Hadibros, correct? So

193
00:07:20,000 --> 00:07:22,100
we would have said, our natural response would

194
00:07:22,100 --> 00:07:23,660
have been that Hashem gave us the mitzvah

195
00:07:23,660 --> 00:07:26,399
of Shabbos at Har Sinai. After all, on

196
00:07:26,399 --> 00:07:28,888
the luchos it says: Zachor es yom haShabbos

197
00:07:28,888 --> 00:07:30,680
lekadesho. But yet, if you look in the

198
00:07:30,680 --> 00:07:32,160
pesukim in this week's parsha, it is clear

199
00:07:32,160 --> 00:07:35,540
that Hashem actually gave us the mitzvah of

200
00:07:35,540 --> 00:07:38,339
Shabbos before we got to Har Sinai. The

201
00:07:38,339 --> 00:07:40,399
mitzvah of Shabbos was given right when the

202
00:07:40,399 --> 00:07:42,439
Jewish people came out of Mitzrayim, right when

203
00:07:42,439 --> 00:07:43,879
they engaged with the mann for the first

204
00:07:43,879 --> 00:07:45,800
time, Hashem gave them the instructions and he

205
00:07:45,800 --> 00:07:47,959
said: I know that every day you are

206
00:07:47,959 --> 00:07:49,540
going to be collecting mann and bringing it

207
00:07:49,540 --> 00:07:52,495
into your home, however, on Shabbos, Al yeitzei

208
00:07:52,495 --> 00:07:54,734
ish mimekomo beyom hashevi’i. Sorry, beyom hashevi’i. Shevu

209
00:07:54,734 --> 00:07:59,759
ish tachtav. Everyone has to stay in their

210
00:07:59,759 --> 00:08:02,339
place, Al yeitzei ish mimekomo. Now what does

211
00:08:02,339 --> 00:08:05,660
that mean Al yeitzei ish mimekomo? Really? You

212
00:08:05,660 --> 00:08:07,660
believe there were no young toddlers in the

213
00:08:07,660 --> 00:08:11,180
days of Yetzias Mitzrayim? Every single young child

214
00:08:11,279 --> 00:08:13,079
the entire duration of Shabbos had to stay

215
00:08:13,079 --> 00:08:15,160
locked up in their little tents and wasn't

216
00:08:15,160 --> 00:08:16,459
allowed to go play with their neighbor? Of

217
00:08:16,459 --> 00:08:18,100
course that's not what it means. What does

218
00:08:18,100 --> 00:08:20,660
the Torah mean when it says that on

219
00:08:20,660 --> 00:08:23,579
Shabbos everyone has to stay exactly where they

220
00:08:23,579 --> 00:08:26,920
are? Well, the answer to that is you

221
00:08:26,920 --> 00:08:30,939
have to define what is my makom? What

222
00:08:30,939 --> 00:08:32,100
does it mean I have to stay in

223
00:08:32,100 --> 00:08:34,039
my place? What is my place? Does my

224
00:08:34,039 --> 00:08:36,360
place mean my home or is there a

225
00:08:36,360 --> 00:08:39,019
more expansive definition of my place? The answer

226
00:08:39,240 --> 00:08:41,460
again, a very complicated set of halachos, but

227
00:08:41,460 --> 00:08:42,620
I'm just going to boil it down very

228
00:08:42,620 --> 00:08:45,899
simply as follows. My home is not considered

229
00:08:45,899 --> 00:08:47,379
to be my only place that I'm allowed

230
00:08:47,379 --> 00:08:48,879
to go on Shabbos. Of course, all of

231
00:08:48,879 --> 00:08:50,000
us know we go to shul, we go

232
00:08:50,000 --> 00:08:51,600
to friends, we eat out, we go all

233
00:08:51,600 --> 00:08:52,919
over the place on Shabbos, or we're allowed

234
00:08:52,919 --> 00:08:54,960
to. The answer is if I'm part of

235
00:08:54,960 --> 00:08:57,679
a Jewish community, the entire community is considered

236
00:08:57,679 --> 00:08:59,899
to be part of an extension of my

237
00:08:59,899 --> 00:09:04,460
home and I'm allowed to walk within any

238
00:09:04,460 --> 00:09:06,879
of those locations on Shabbos. What happens when

239
00:09:06,879 --> 00:09:08,539
I get to the edge of the town?

240
00:09:08,539 --> 00:09:11,480
And now nobody else from the community lives

241
00:09:11,480 --> 00:09:14,360
there anymore. That is when it's considered to

242
00:09:14,360 --> 00:09:17,519
be I'm walking out of my techum. I'm

243
00:09:17,519 --> 00:09:21,879
walking out of my personal space and I'm

244
00:09:21,879 --> 00:09:23,580
not allowed to go further than a certain

245
00:09:23,580 --> 00:09:25,960
distance outside of the city, a certain minimal

246
00:09:25,960 --> 00:09:28,360
distance outside of the city. But let's say

247
00:09:28,419 --> 00:09:29,720
for example I don't live in a city,

248
00:09:29,840 --> 00:09:31,980
I live in the desert by myself and

249
00:09:31,980 --> 00:09:34,000
I have a little hut that I live

250
00:09:34,000 --> 00:09:36,820
in and that's I'm just alone. So then

251
00:09:36,820 --> 00:09:38,500
I have a very limited amount of space

252
00:09:38,500 --> 00:09:40,159
that I'm allowed to go on Shabbos because

253
00:09:40,159 --> 00:09:43,600
my own space, personal space is considered to

254
00:09:43,600 --> 00:09:46,240
be very restricted and the only amount of

255
00:09:46,240 --> 00:09:47,559
room that I get around that is a

256
00:09:47,559 --> 00:09:50,215
very limited area of space. With that background,

257
00:09:50,215 --> 00:09:52,551
yeah? I have a question. Yeah, you can

258
00:09:52,551 --> 00:09:56,340
wait? So let's wait. With that background, we're

259
00:09:56,340 --> 00:09:59,919
going to go to this following scenario. One

260
00:09:59,919 --> 00:10:01,483
of the students in our last class drew

261
00:10:01,483 --> 00:10:03,379
it on the, if you don't like the

262
00:10:03,379 --> 00:10:05,799
drawing, you can speak to her, but she

263
00:10:05,799 --> 00:10:07,059
drew it for us so it will become

264
00:10:07,059 --> 00:10:08,820
a little bit easier for us to understand.

265
00:10:09,279 --> 00:10:10,659
Let's take two names of people who are

266
00:10:10,659 --> 00:10:12,379
here now and who wants to volunteer to

267
00:10:12,379 --> 00:10:16,379
be the name here? Gittel? Okay. Gittel, okay.

268
00:10:20,299 --> 00:10:23,527
Gittel, great, amazing. And you, you want to

269
00:10:23,527 --> 00:10:27,059
be next? Ally. Ally. Okay, Gittel and Ally

270
00:10:27,059 --> 00:10:28,840
are going to be the two people that

271
00:10:28,840 --> 00:10:31,259
we're talking about here. Gittel and Ally have

272
00:10:31,259 --> 00:10:33,679
a certain problem that they need to deal

273
00:10:33,679 --> 00:10:36,139
with on Shabbos. What's the problem? One second.

274
00:10:38,099 --> 00:10:40,639
This is Ally, your last name is Nagel,

275
00:10:40,720 --> 00:10:44,440
right? Ally Nagel's house. And this is Gittel,

276
00:10:44,519 --> 00:10:47,019
your last name is? Friedman. So this is

277
00:10:47,019 --> 00:10:50,139
Gittel Friedman's house. Good? Okay, here's the situation.

278
00:10:50,279 --> 00:10:51,100
You ready? We're going to set it up

279
00:10:51,100 --> 00:10:53,399
as follows. You have two people. Gittel and

280
00:10:53,399 --> 00:10:55,059
Ally are very close friends and they love

281
00:10:55,059 --> 00:10:57,419
each other very much. Great? Fair? Okay, you're

282
00:10:57,419 --> 00:11:00,240
not in a fight. Good. Okay, the problem

283
00:11:00,240 --> 00:11:02,500
is as follows. You each own a lot

284
00:11:02,500 --> 00:11:04,620
of farmland and you have a lot of

285
00:11:04,620 --> 00:11:06,279
produce on that farm. If you're going to

286
00:11:06,279 --> 00:11:08,600
leave the farm unattended for an entire Shabbos,

287
00:11:08,700 --> 00:11:10,559
obviously no one's working the farm, no one's

288
00:11:10,559 --> 00:11:13,139
working the land, but you need to have

289
00:11:13,139 --> 00:11:14,980
someone who's watching that nobody should steal the

290
00:11:14,980 --> 00:11:17,419
produce. So the question is, what are you

291
00:11:17,419 --> 00:11:20,039
going to do? To pay a security guard

292
00:11:20,039 --> 00:11:22,179
to go watch my field for the entire

293
00:11:22,179 --> 00:11:23,679
duration of Shabbos is going to cost me

294
00:11:23,679 --> 00:11:25,539
a lot of money. Now that's a waste

295
00:11:25,539 --> 00:11:27,159
of money because I don't need a security

296
00:11:27,159 --> 00:11:29,620
guard. I can go myself. I'm not afraid

297
00:11:29,620 --> 00:11:31,360
that people are going to come armed and

298
00:11:31,360 --> 00:11:33,059
start stealing things. If they see me there,

299
00:11:33,120 --> 00:11:35,639
they're going to walk away. So if I'm

300
00:11:35,639 --> 00:11:37,899
there it will already be sufficient. Here's the

301
00:11:37,899 --> 00:11:40,600
problem. You ready for the problem? The problem

302
00:11:40,600 --> 00:11:44,259
is logistically Ally's field is very far away

303
00:11:44,259 --> 00:11:47,240
from her house. Ally lives on the edge

304
00:11:47,240 --> 00:11:49,980
of the community on this side, okay, and

305
00:11:49,980 --> 00:11:51,919
her field is on the opposite edge of

306
00:11:51,919 --> 00:11:55,840
the community on the other side. Gittel's field

307
00:11:55,840 --> 00:11:59,559
is on this side, on this edge of

308
00:11:59,559 --> 00:12:01,019
the community, and her house is on the

309
00:12:01,019 --> 00:12:03,220
opposite side. So it turns out that Gittel

310
00:12:03,220 --> 00:12:05,879
happens to live right near Ally's field and

311
00:12:05,879 --> 00:12:08,220
Ally happens to live right near Gittel's field.

312
00:12:08,720 --> 00:12:11,460
Here's the problem. When you look at how

313
00:12:11,460 --> 00:12:13,720
far Ally is allowed to go on Shabbos,

314
00:12:14,220 --> 00:12:16,659
here is the invisible line that allows her

315
00:12:16,659 --> 00:12:19,299
to travel on Shabbos. You ready? Okay, this

316
00:12:19,299 --> 00:12:21,299
is considered to be her tchum, her makom.

317
00:12:21,759 --> 00:12:23,259
So Ally's house is over here. You got

318
00:12:23,259 --> 00:12:25,519
it? This is her little house, good. And

319
00:12:25,519 --> 00:12:27,720
we're going to draw this imaginary dotted line,

320
00:12:27,720 --> 00:12:30,179
circle around her house. That is how far

321
00:12:30,179 --> 00:12:31,840
she's allowed to go, which includes the local

322
00:12:31,840 --> 00:12:34,519
shul. That's in the middle. Good. Go in

323
00:12:34,519 --> 00:12:37,259
the other side. You have Gittel lives over

324
00:12:37,259 --> 00:12:39,600
here. What's the imaginary line that she's allowed

325
00:12:39,600 --> 00:12:42,500
to go around on Shabbos? So that's going

326
00:12:42,500 --> 00:12:44,399
to be this. So they overlap over here.

327
00:12:44,519 --> 00:12:46,720
You got it? They're overlapping in the middle,

328
00:12:46,720 --> 00:12:49,820
but Ally is not allowed to go here

329
00:12:49,820 --> 00:12:51,519
and Gittel is not allowed to go here.

330
00:12:51,879 --> 00:12:53,511
So far so good, everyone with me? Why

331
00:12:53,511 --> 00:12:55,847
can't they go there if it's the same

332
00:12:55,847 --> 00:12:58,659
community? So you have to explain, meaning they're

333
00:12:58,659 --> 00:13:01,559
living at different parts. Okay, so they're living

334
00:13:01,559 --> 00:13:03,559
at different parts which means my tchum ends

335
00:13:03,559 --> 00:13:05,600
here and her tchum ends here. Which means

336
00:13:05,600 --> 00:13:08,019
that Ally would not be allowed to walk

337
00:13:08,019 --> 00:13:09,899
to her field and Gittel will not be

338
00:13:09,899 --> 00:13:11,600
allowed to walk to hers. They show up

339
00:13:11,600 --> 00:13:13,139
in shul together and say, we have a

340
00:13:13,139 --> 00:13:16,340
great idea. Instead of hiring security to be

341
00:13:16,340 --> 00:13:17,480
there and pay them to be there the

342
00:13:17,480 --> 00:13:19,240
whole Shabbos, I have a great idea. Why

343
00:13:19,240 --> 00:13:21,639
don't you watch my field on Shabbos and

344
00:13:21,639 --> 00:13:23,600
I, in turn, will watch your field on

345
00:13:23,600 --> 00:13:25,879
Shabbos? After all, your field is right near

346
00:13:25,879 --> 00:13:27,620
my house, it's a two-minute walk, I can

347
00:13:27,620 --> 00:13:29,379
go there. And my field is a two-minute

348
00:13:29,379 --> 00:13:31,960
walk from your house. So let's just switch.

349
00:13:32,320 --> 00:13:33,879
I want you to watch mine and I'll

350
00:13:33,879 --> 00:13:35,639
watch yours and all will be good. Is

351
00:13:35,639 --> 00:13:37,539
that allowed on Shabbos? Am I allowed to

352
00:13:37,539 --> 00:13:40,379
instruct you to watch my field that I

353
00:13:40,379 --> 00:13:42,240
would not be allowed to walk to myself

354
00:13:42,240 --> 00:13:45,100
on Shabbos because it's outside of my tchum?

355
00:13:45,139 --> 00:13:47,360
It's outside of my area that I'm allowed

356
00:13:47,360 --> 00:13:49,100
to walk. What do you say? Yes. Yes.

357
00:13:49,720 --> 00:13:53,139
Why yes? Why is that any different? Let's

358
00:13:53,139 --> 00:13:54,860
get into the trap. You ready? Tova, you

359
00:13:54,860 --> 00:13:56,860
good? Yeah, let's go right into the trap.

360
00:13:57,159 --> 00:13:59,039
Why yes? The answer is yes, is correct.

361
00:13:59,179 --> 00:14:00,899
But why? What do you mean? You're going

362
00:14:00,899 --> 00:14:02,600
to say yes because, let's hear. Because it's

363
00:14:02,600 --> 00:14:05,399
permissible for me to go and walk there,

364
00:14:05,759 --> 00:14:07,960
but if I lived in the other person's

365
00:14:07,960 --> 00:14:09,879
house it wouldn't be allowed. Okay, but you

366
00:14:09,879 --> 00:14:13,100
don't. So ostensibly what are you saying? They're

367
00:14:13,100 --> 00:14:15,220
not doing anything wrong. Excellent, you walked right

368
00:14:15,220 --> 00:14:16,799
into it. You ready? Why? Let me tell

369
00:14:16,799 --> 00:14:18,379
you why you walked right into it. Because

370
00:14:18,379 --> 00:14:20,799
what happens with amira l'nochri that we spoke

371
00:14:20,799 --> 00:14:22,959
about last year? It's the other person, they're

372
00:14:22,959 --> 00:14:25,340
not walking outside their tchum. Okay, and the

373
00:14:25,340 --> 00:14:27,379
non-Jew that I'm asking to do something for

374
00:14:27,379 --> 00:14:29,700
me on Shabbos is not doing anything wrong

375
00:14:29,700 --> 00:14:31,203
because they don't have to keep Shabbos. But

376
00:14:31,203 --> 00:14:33,879
it's permissible for me. Okay, and right now

377
00:14:33,879 --> 00:14:35,480
when I'm asking you to watch my field,

378
00:14:36,080 --> 00:14:37,580
you're doing something that I would not be

379
00:14:37,580 --> 00:14:39,599
allowed to do. No, watching the field is

380
00:14:39,599 --> 00:14:41,399
not assur, only travel. Walking to the field

381
00:14:41,399 --> 00:14:42,759
is not allowed, but I'm asking you to

382
00:14:42,759 --> 00:14:44,519
walk to the field that I would not

383
00:14:44,519 --> 00:14:46,135
be allowed to walk to. But you're not

384
00:14:46,135 --> 00:14:48,179
asking them to walk outside their tchum. But

385
00:14:48,179 --> 00:14:49,480
I'm asking you to do something that I

386
00:14:49,480 --> 00:14:51,859
can't do. The same way when I ask

387
00:14:51,859 --> 00:14:52,735
a non-Jew, the same way when I ask

388
00:14:52,735 --> 00:14:55,580
a non-Jew to do something on Shabbos, they're

389
00:14:55,580 --> 00:14:58,039
allowed to do it on their own, it's

390
00:14:58,039 --> 00:14:59,639
just I'm asking them to do something that

391
00:14:59,639 --> 00:15:00,915
I'm not allowed to do. allowed to do.

392
00:15:01,519 --> 00:15:03,691
So this is the question, yeah? But if

393
00:15:03,691 --> 00:15:05,151
I was in their position, if I lived

394
00:15:05,151 --> 00:15:06,960
in that house, the question would be different,

395
00:15:07,080 --> 00:15:10,659
whereas I couldn't be a non-Jew. Correct. Okay,

396
00:15:10,820 --> 00:15:12,379
so these are all good points. We're going

397
00:15:12,379 --> 00:15:13,899
to touch on them in a minute, yeah?

398
00:15:14,139 --> 00:15:15,940
You're not asking them to do the thing

399
00:15:15,940 --> 00:15:17,080
that you're not allowed to do. The thing

400
00:15:17,080 --> 00:15:18,320
you're not allowed to do is cross the

401
00:15:18,320 --> 00:15:19,851
techum. You could walk to the field, but

402
00:15:19,851 --> 00:15:21,071
it just happens to not be in your

403
00:15:21,071 --> 00:15:23,159
techum. When you're asking them, you're not asking

404
00:15:23,159 --> 00:15:24,679
them to cross the techum, you're asking them

405
00:15:24,679 --> 00:15:26,860
to stay in it and just... but ostensibly

406
00:15:26,980 --> 00:15:28,100
it should be the same as amirah l'akum.

407
00:15:28,460 --> 00:15:29,960
You're asking them to do something that you

408
00:15:29,960 --> 00:15:32,679
yourself cannot do. The bottom line the Gemara

409
00:15:32,679 --> 00:15:35,100
says is this case is permissible. So you're

410
00:15:35,100 --> 00:15:37,679
all right. You're all right that it's permissible.

411
00:15:38,200 --> 00:15:39,860
The hard part here is to figure out

412
00:15:40,059 --> 00:15:42,139
why is it allowed? How do you draw

413
00:15:42,139 --> 00:15:45,919
the distinction between this and amirah l'akum? What's

414
00:15:45,919 --> 00:15:47,639
the difference between this case where I'm asking

415
00:15:47,639 --> 00:15:49,200
a Jew to do something that I'm not

416
00:15:49,200 --> 00:15:51,580
allowed to do myself and the case of

417
00:15:51,580 --> 00:15:54,139
me asking a non-Jew to do something that

418
00:15:54,139 --> 00:15:55,860
I'm not allowed to do myself? That's the

419
00:15:55,860 --> 00:15:58,139
question here, the million-dollar question. But let's leave

420
00:15:58,139 --> 00:15:59,340
that question for a moment. We're going to

421
00:15:59,340 --> 00:16:01,340
get back to it. But the basic, yeah?

422
00:16:01,799 --> 00:16:04,139
Does it have anything to do with the

423
00:16:04,139 --> 00:16:07,220
fact that they're both Jewish? That is what

424
00:16:07,220 --> 00:16:08,600
we're talking about, but we have to figure

425
00:16:08,600 --> 00:16:10,759
out why is that a difference. We have

426
00:16:10,759 --> 00:16:11,779
to figure out why is that a difference.

427
00:16:11,779 --> 00:16:13,279
Of course that's a distinction, but we have

428
00:16:13,279 --> 00:16:14,860
to figure out why that's a difference. So

429
00:16:14,860 --> 00:16:16,480
let's just hold on to all these thoughts

430
00:16:16,480 --> 00:16:19,220
for a moment. From here, from here the

431
00:16:19,220 --> 00:16:20,730
Rashba quotes in the name of the Ba'alei

432
00:16:20,730 --> 00:16:23,080
haTosafot. From here we can learn to another

433
00:16:23,080 --> 00:16:26,279
case, and that is if I accept Shabbos

434
00:16:26,279 --> 00:16:30,919
early and my friend has not yet accepted

435
00:16:30,919 --> 00:16:33,820
Shabbos. So even though I am not allowed

436
00:16:33,820 --> 00:16:36,399
to go do a melacha, forbidden activity, because

437
00:16:36,399 --> 00:16:38,340
it's Shabbos for me, but there's no problem

438
00:16:38,340 --> 00:16:39,840
for me to ask my Jewish friend to

439
00:16:39,840 --> 00:16:41,960
do a melacha because for them it's not

440
00:16:41,960 --> 00:16:45,139
Shabbos, for them there's nothing wrong. Say the

441
00:16:45,139 --> 00:16:47,259
Ba'alei haTosafot you can prove that from this

442
00:16:47,259 --> 00:16:50,320
case. Because over here I am asking a

443
00:16:50,320 --> 00:16:51,600
Jew to do something that I am not

444
00:16:51,600 --> 00:16:52,980
allowed to do, but for them it's totally

445
00:16:52,980 --> 00:16:55,919
permissible. Similarly I'd be allowed to ask a

446
00:16:55,919 --> 00:16:58,159
Jew when it's already Shabbos for me but

447
00:16:58,159 --> 00:17:00,440
not Shabbos for them to do something on

448
00:17:00,440 --> 00:17:02,299
my behalf. That is what the Rashba says

449
00:17:02,299 --> 00:17:05,299
in the name of the Ba'alei haTosafot. Yeah?

450
00:17:05,299 --> 00:17:08,440
Is it like the idea of like a

451
00:17:08,440 --> 00:17:10,740
non-Jew is like an extension of you but

452
00:17:10,740 --> 00:17:13,420
a Jew would be like a separate... A

453
00:17:13,420 --> 00:17:15,180
Jew even more so is an extension of

454
00:17:15,180 --> 00:17:17,415
me. Well I would think with the whole

455
00:17:17,415 --> 00:17:21,599
thing in this legal case. Legally we would

456
00:17:21,599 --> 00:17:24,279
say that it applies equally, meaning shlichut for

457
00:17:24,279 --> 00:17:25,799
sure works by a Jew. The question is

458
00:17:25,859 --> 00:17:26,980
why does it work by a non-Jew? We

459
00:17:26,980 --> 00:17:30,500
never accept a non-Jew as the shaliach. Okay

460
00:17:30,720 --> 00:17:32,500
now go to the back end of Shabbos.

461
00:17:32,660 --> 00:17:34,559
Anybody here have a custom in their family

462
00:17:34,559 --> 00:17:36,539
to wait Rabbeinu Tam's zman after Shabbos is

463
00:17:36,539 --> 00:17:40,240
over? Yeah, so you wait extra time. How

464
00:17:40,240 --> 00:17:43,980
much extra? Seventh. So you're probably an extra

465
00:17:43,980 --> 00:17:47,440
25 minutes more than other people, right? Okay.

466
00:17:47,859 --> 00:17:49,920
So in that extra 25 minutes, remind me

467
00:17:49,920 --> 00:17:53,660
your name? Talia. Talia really wants to have

468
00:17:53,660 --> 00:17:55,839
something taken care of. Problem is for her

469
00:17:55,920 --> 00:17:58,339
it's still Shabbos, but for everybody around her

470
00:17:58,940 --> 00:18:01,960
they already ended Shabbos 25 minutes ago. So

471
00:18:01,960 --> 00:18:04,359
would Talia be allowed to ask one of

472
00:18:04,359 --> 00:18:09,400
her Jewish neighbors who already said Havdalah and

473
00:18:09,619 --> 00:18:13,660
davened Maariv to do a forbidden activity that

474
00:18:13,660 --> 00:18:15,299
she would not be allowed to do? Would

475
00:18:15,299 --> 00:18:17,619
you say that that's allowed or not? Would

476
00:18:17,619 --> 00:18:20,700
that fall under ve'daber davar? Why wouldn't this

477
00:18:20,700 --> 00:18:22,831
fall under ve'daber davar? Oh well that's not...

478
00:18:22,831 --> 00:18:23,415
that's not the same as asking, that's not

479
00:18:23,415 --> 00:18:27,039
the same as taking a... forget this case.

480
00:18:27,319 --> 00:18:29,599
Why would Tosefet Shabbos fall under ve'daber davar?

481
00:18:29,599 --> 00:18:32,160
It probably should. But yet we just said

482
00:18:32,160 --> 00:18:34,799
it's allowed. And the Shulchan Aruch actually quotes

483
00:18:34,799 --> 00:18:36,539
that l'halacha and says you'd be allowed to

484
00:18:36,539 --> 00:18:39,428
do that. The Shulchan Aruch in siman reish

485
00:18:39,428 --> 00:18:41,805
samech gimmel seif yud zayin writes yeish omrim

486
00:18:41,805 --> 00:18:44,599
mi shekibel alav shabbos kodem chasheicha. If somebody

487
00:18:44,599 --> 00:18:47,200
accepts Shabbos before it gets dark outside I'm

488
00:18:47,200 --> 00:18:49,799
allowed to tell Yisrael chaveiro la'asot lo melacha.

489
00:18:49,900 --> 00:18:52,140
I'm allowed to instruct my Jewish friend to

490
00:18:52,140 --> 00:18:55,680
do an activity on my behalf. But why

491
00:18:55,680 --> 00:18:58,200
would that not violate ve'daber davar? So hold

492
00:18:58,200 --> 00:18:59,759
on to that for a second. You're a

493
00:18:59,759 --> 00:19:03,279
million percent right. That's the bomb question here.

494
00:19:03,680 --> 00:19:05,380
That's what we need to ask. But let's

495
00:19:05,380 --> 00:19:07,559
first get down the facts. So one second.

496
00:19:07,680 --> 00:19:09,700
The Rema says well the same way that

497
00:19:09,700 --> 00:19:12,019
we say when Shabbos comes in during that

498
00:19:12,019 --> 00:19:14,140
extra period of time, the extended part of

499
00:19:14,140 --> 00:19:16,299
Shabbos, I'd be allowed to instruct somebody else

500
00:19:16,299 --> 00:19:18,220
to do an activity for me, so too

501
00:19:18,220 --> 00:19:20,220
on the extended part of Shabbos on the

502
00:19:20,220 --> 00:19:21,940
other end it would be the same. And

503
00:19:21,940 --> 00:19:24,420
I'd be allowed to instruct someone when I'm

504
00:19:24,420 --> 00:19:26,240
waiting for Rabbeinu Tam's zman and somebody else

505
00:19:26,240 --> 00:19:28,640
is not, I would say that I'm allowed

506
00:19:28,640 --> 00:19:30,880
to ask them to do some forbidden activity

507
00:19:30,880 --> 00:19:32,480
that I myself am not allowed to do.

508
00:19:32,819 --> 00:19:34,599
Now the million dollar question that all of

509
00:19:34,599 --> 00:19:37,180
you are asking is I don't understand, why

510
00:19:37,180 --> 00:19:39,680
wouldn't this be a violation of ve'daber davar

511
00:19:40,079 --> 00:19:42,160
or shlichut or all the other reasons that

512
00:19:42,160 --> 00:19:44,079
we said for amirah l'akum not being allowed

513
00:19:44,079 --> 00:19:46,980
on Shabbos should also apply here and should

514
00:19:46,980 --> 00:19:49,119
also lead us to the conclusion that you

515
00:19:49,119 --> 00:19:50,940
would not be allowed to instruct somebody else

516
00:19:50,940 --> 00:19:53,900
to do something on your behalf because you're

517
00:19:53,900 --> 00:19:55,740
not allowed to talk about melacha on Shabbos

518
00:19:55,740 --> 00:19:57,559
or because it's like a shlichut, it's like

519
00:19:57,559 --> 00:19:59,579
the person is an extension of me, so

520
00:19:59,579 --> 00:20:01,359
how is that... not allowed. If you look

521
00:20:01,359 --> 00:20:03,259
in the Magen Avraham and the Taz and

522
00:20:03,259 --> 00:20:06,599
the Mishnah Berurah and the Shulchan Aruch HaRav

523
00:20:06,660 --> 00:20:08,960
and the Beis Yosef, everyone tries to explain

524
00:20:09,839 --> 00:20:11,980
away why it is that this is permissible

525
00:20:11,980 --> 00:20:13,579
and why it is that it's not doesn't

526
00:20:13,579 --> 00:20:15,740
fall into the neat category of Amirah l'akum,

527
00:20:16,039 --> 00:20:17,519
it should be just as prohibited as that.

528
00:20:18,059 --> 00:20:19,480
I was talking to my father the other

529
00:20:19,480 --> 00:20:22,443
day. He said, he said, you know, all

530
00:20:22,443 --> 00:20:24,460
of them are giving very technical answers. Meaning

531
00:20:24,460 --> 00:20:26,259
the Taz writes, the Taz says the answer

532
00:20:26,259 --> 00:20:30,019
is Davar Davar only applies. Davar Davar again

533
00:20:30,099 --> 00:20:31,980
just to remind ourselves, Davar Davar means there's

534
00:20:31,980 --> 00:20:33,740
certain things you're not allowed to talk about

535
00:20:33,740 --> 00:20:36,400
on Shabbos. Writes the Taz, if you look

536
00:20:36,400 --> 00:20:39,460
here, the Taz is on number hei. The

537
00:20:39,460 --> 00:20:41,720
Taz says the only time Davar Davar applies

538
00:20:41,720 --> 00:20:44,079
is when I'm talking about something that is

539
00:20:44,079 --> 00:20:48,000
assur lechol Yisrael. Davar hashaveh lechol adam miYisrael.

540
00:20:48,119 --> 00:20:49,599
It's only when I'm talking about an activity

541
00:20:49,599 --> 00:20:51,619
that no Jew is allowed to do on

542
00:20:51,619 --> 00:20:53,799
Shabbos. But if I'm talking about something that

543
00:20:53,799 --> 00:20:55,539
half the Jewish community is allowed to do

544
00:20:55,539 --> 00:20:57,079
and half the Jewish community is not allowed

545
00:20:57,079 --> 00:20:58,559
to do right now, that wouldn't be a

546
00:20:58,559 --> 00:21:02,960
violation of Davar Davar. Okay, not so convincing,

547
00:21:03,140 --> 00:21:04,680
but that's what the Taz says. If you

548
00:21:04,680 --> 00:21:06,059
look in the Magen Avraham, he's not so

549
00:21:06,059 --> 00:21:07,480
convinced of that either, he gives his own

550
00:21:07,480 --> 00:21:09,740
variation to explain it. And in shlichus as

551
00:21:09,740 --> 00:21:12,380
well, the Shulchan Aruch HaRav tries to explain

552
00:21:12,380 --> 00:21:14,559
why it's not a problem of shlichus. My

553
00:21:14,559 --> 00:21:18,220
father said a much simpler answer that goes

554
00:21:18,220 --> 00:21:21,180
as follows. Here's the simpler answer: we all

555
00:21:21,180 --> 00:21:24,119
go to shul on Yom Kippur, correct? At

556
00:21:24,119 --> 00:21:25,500
the end of Yom Kippur, what's the last

557
00:21:25,500 --> 00:21:28,119
thing we do before we davven Maariv? What?

558
00:21:29,299 --> 00:21:31,279
Ne'ilah. What's the last part of Ne'ilah before

559
00:21:31,279 --> 00:21:36,440
we davven Maariv? It's not a trick. Shofar,

560
00:21:36,539 --> 00:21:38,079
we blow the shofar. Let me ask you:

561
00:21:38,099 --> 00:21:39,160
are you allowed to blow a shofar on

562
00:21:39,160 --> 00:21:43,339
Shabbos and Yom Tov? What? No. You're not

563
00:21:43,339 --> 00:21:46,319
allowed to. It's prohibited. So then how do

564
00:21:46,319 --> 00:21:48,160
we blow the shofar on Yom Kippur before

565
00:21:48,160 --> 00:21:50,980
we say Havdalah? We do, of course we

566
00:21:50,980 --> 00:21:55,599
do. Right? What? It is after Tzeis. It

567
00:21:55,599 --> 00:21:57,440
is, but it's still Shabbos, it's still Yom

568
00:21:57,440 --> 00:22:00,380
Kippur. Are you allowed to eat then? Why

569
00:22:00,380 --> 00:22:03,819
not? It's after Tzeis. So what's the answer?

570
00:22:06,420 --> 00:22:08,231
Have you ever heard somebody scream out Hamavdil?

571
00:22:08,231 --> 00:22:10,900
No. So what's going on? What do you

572
00:22:10,900 --> 00:22:14,119
davven? Atah Chonantanu. How is Rabbi Rice allowed

573
00:22:14,119 --> 00:22:17,059
for them to blow the shofar on, how

574
00:22:17,059 --> 00:22:18,279
does he blow the shofar on Yom Kippur?

575
00:22:18,279 --> 00:22:19,380
You're not allowed to blow the shofar on

576
00:22:19,380 --> 00:22:20,920
Shabbos and Yom Tov. I'm going to have

577
00:22:20,920 --> 00:22:22,319
a word with him. Right, so what's the

578
00:22:22,319 --> 00:22:24,460
answer? Every single shul in the world does

579
00:22:24,460 --> 00:22:26,259
the same thing. How do we do it?

580
00:22:26,539 --> 00:22:28,880
This is not my question. This is the

581
00:22:28,880 --> 00:22:30,299
question of the Ba'alei HaTosfos in Masechet Megillah

582
00:22:30,299 --> 00:22:33,319
on daf daled amud aleph where they say,

583
00:22:33,420 --> 00:22:34,700
I don't understand, it's still Yom Kippur, you

584
00:22:34,700 --> 00:22:35,920
didn't say Havdalah yet. If you didn't say

585
00:22:35,920 --> 00:22:38,220
Havdalah, you're not allowed to do any prohibitions

586
00:22:38,220 --> 00:22:40,180
on Shabbos. How are you allowed to blow

587
00:22:40,180 --> 00:22:41,900
the shofar if you're generally not allowed to

588
00:22:41,900 --> 00:22:43,500
blow the shofar on Shabbos and Yom Tov?

589
00:22:44,079 --> 00:22:46,759
Very simple straightforward question. The answer that Tosfos

590
00:22:46,759 --> 00:22:48,740
says is blowing the shofar is not one

591
00:22:48,740 --> 00:22:50,400
of the melachos. It's what he refers to

592
00:22:50,400 --> 00:22:53,720
as a chochmah she'einah melacha. Which means Tosfos

593
00:22:53,720 --> 00:22:56,180
is telling us that in the time of

594
00:22:56,180 --> 00:22:58,200
Tosefes Shabbos, meaning by the time we get

595
00:22:58,200 --> 00:22:59,819
to the blowing of the shofar, Yom Kippur

596
00:22:59,819 --> 00:23:01,750
is already basically over. You said it's Tzeis

597
00:23:01,750 --> 00:23:04,220
hakochavim, right? It's just we didn't say Havdalah

598
00:23:04,220 --> 00:23:07,519
yet, so we extended Yom Kippur. Says Tosfos,

599
00:23:07,599 --> 00:23:10,240
whenever you have the extended part of Shabbos

600
00:23:10,240 --> 00:23:12,819
or Yom Tov, the only prohibitions that you

601
00:23:12,819 --> 00:23:16,359
have at those times are actual 39 melachos

602
00:23:16,460 --> 00:23:19,539
or the categories of melacha, our forbidden activities

603
00:23:19,539 --> 00:23:21,680
then. But if you have some other area

604
00:23:21,680 --> 00:23:23,359
of the laws of Shabbos that is not

605
00:23:23,359 --> 00:23:26,240
a melacha but is a separate prohibition of

606
00:23:26,240 --> 00:23:28,920
Shabbos outside of the categories of the 39

607
00:23:28,920 --> 00:23:31,799
melachos, Tosfos says you're allowed to do one

608
00:23:31,799 --> 00:23:34,160
of those even though you haven't yet said

609
00:23:34,160 --> 00:23:36,920
Havdalah. My father likes to give the following

610
00:23:36,920 --> 00:23:39,279
example: we know that on Shabbos there's a

611
00:23:39,279 --> 00:23:41,680
prohibition of hachanah. What does that mean? Means

612
00:23:41,680 --> 00:23:43,819
let's say we're having a big sheva brachos

613
00:23:43,819 --> 00:23:45,700
in my house tonight and we have to

614
00:23:45,700 --> 00:23:47,880
set up, and we're nervous because people are

615
00:23:47,880 --> 00:23:49,339
going to come an hour after Shabbos, we're

616
00:23:49,339 --> 00:23:50,380
not going to have enough time. When are

617
00:23:50,380 --> 00:23:51,539
we going to set everything up? So you

618
00:23:51,539 --> 00:23:53,240
know what? Let's just start setting up on

619
00:23:53,240 --> 00:23:56,099
Shabbos afternoon. Would that be allowed? Obviously not.

620
00:23:56,259 --> 00:23:58,000
Why not? Because you're in violation of the

621
00:23:58,000 --> 00:24:00,131
prohibition of hachanah. Now if I were to

622
00:24:00,131 --> 00:24:02,039
ask you, is hachanah one of the 39

623
00:24:02,039 --> 00:24:05,319
prohibitions of Shabbos? No. It's a separate prohibition

624
00:24:05,319 --> 00:24:07,079
of Shabbos that is not connected to the

625
00:24:07,079 --> 00:24:10,420
39 melachos, correct? Would you be allowed to

626
00:24:10,420 --> 00:24:14,900
do hachanah during the time of Tosefes Shabbos?

627
00:24:15,460 --> 00:24:17,920
Let's say the end of Shabbos and now

628
00:24:17,920 --> 00:24:20,380
everybody, you know, everyone's just sitting around, they

629
00:24:20,380 --> 00:24:21,880
didn't say Havdalah yet and they didn't go

630
00:24:21,880 --> 00:24:23,099
to shul, whatever it is. We're going to

631
00:24:23,099 --> 00:24:25,420
davven in an hour for whatever hypothetically, I

632
00:24:25,420 --> 00:24:27,220
don't know. Are we all allowed to come

633
00:24:27,220 --> 00:24:28,640
around and say, 'You know, hey, we're all

634
00:24:28,640 --> 00:24:30,359
here, why don't we start setting up for

635
00:24:30,359 --> 00:24:32,759
the sheva brachos tonight now?' Instead of waiting

636
00:24:32,759 --> 00:24:34,200
until after Shabbos. The answer to that my

637
00:24:34,200 --> 00:24:36,960
father writes is yes. Why? Because in the

638
00:24:36,960 --> 00:24:39,519
time of Tosefes Shabbos, in that period of

639
00:24:39,519 --> 00:24:42,099
time, the only prohibitions that you are bound

640
00:24:42,099 --> 00:24:45,779
by are actual melachos. The Mishnah Berurah writes,

641
00:24:46,160 --> 00:24:48,309
and again it's somewhat restricted, but the Mishnah

642
00:24:48,309 --> 00:24:51,160
Berurah says in theory, amirah lenakhri does not

643
00:24:51,160 --> 00:24:53,799
apply during Tosefes Shabbos. So say for example

644
00:24:54,319 --> 00:24:56,099
on a winter, on a summer Shabbos when

645
00:24:56,099 --> 00:24:58,440
I make Shabbos at 6 o'clock and Shabbos

646
00:24:58,440 --> 00:25:01,339
really doesn't officially come in... until eight o'clock,

647
00:25:01,779 --> 00:25:04,059
let's say, and then I realize, I come

648
00:25:04,059 --> 00:25:05,799
home and I realize, oy, I forgot to

649
00:25:05,799 --> 00:25:07,059
set the lights and I forgot to do

650
00:25:07,059 --> 00:25:08,839
this and I wanted to do that, would

651
00:25:08,839 --> 00:25:10,960
I be allowed to have a non-Jew come

652
00:25:10,960 --> 00:25:13,160
into my home and can I instruct them

653
00:25:13,160 --> 00:25:14,720
to do all of these activities that I

654
00:25:14,720 --> 00:25:17,000
didn't do before Shabbat began? The answer to

655
00:25:17,000 --> 00:25:20,099
that is yes. Why? Ay, there's a prohibition

656
00:25:20,099 --> 00:25:22,579
of amirah l’akum. You're not allowed to ask

657
00:25:22,579 --> 00:25:23,900
a non-Jew to do things for you on

658
00:25:23,900 --> 00:25:27,599
Shabbat, and it's officially already Shabbat, right? I

659
00:25:27,599 --> 00:25:30,299
accepted Shabbat upon myself. The answer is that

660
00:25:30,299 --> 00:25:33,619
during that time of tosefet Shabbat, during that

661
00:25:33,619 --> 00:25:36,480
additional extended period of time on Shabbat on

662
00:25:36,480 --> 00:25:39,660
both ends, we would say that amirah l’akum

663
00:25:40,000 --> 00:25:42,660
is permissible. And my father explains the reason

664
00:25:42,660 --> 00:25:44,140
why, again, the Taz and the Magen Avraham

665
00:25:44,140 --> 00:25:46,140
don't say this, but my father's explanation is

666
00:25:46,140 --> 00:25:49,000
because we assume that the only prohibitions that

667
00:25:49,000 --> 00:25:51,940
apply during this period of time are a

668
00:25:51,940 --> 00:25:54,339
melachah per se, but not any of the

669
00:25:54,339 --> 00:25:57,079
other ancillary prohibitions of Shabbat that are not

670
00:25:57,079 --> 00:26:01,380
directly connected to the 39 melachot. So that

671
00:26:01,380 --> 00:26:03,960
is with regard to that. We good so

672
00:26:03,960 --> 00:26:06,299
far? I just have a question. Yes. Do

673
00:26:06,299 --> 00:26:07,991
all people hold that you can do hachanah

674
00:26:07,991 --> 00:26:11,519
during, after tosefet? I'd have to check that

675
00:26:11,519 --> 00:26:14,400
up again. I worked at Camp Peale as

676
00:26:14,400 --> 00:26:16,640
a waitress and I remember we weren't allowed

677
00:26:16,640 --> 00:26:19,579
to clean up Shalosh Seudos because they said

678
00:26:19,579 --> 00:26:21,720
it was preparing for after. When did they

679
00:26:21,720 --> 00:26:27,460
finish Shalosh Seudos? Usually it's late. I think

680
00:26:27,460 --> 00:26:28,539
most of the time we don't do it

681
00:26:28,539 --> 00:26:30,400
because we're afraid that people are then going

682
00:26:31,500 --> 00:26:33,099
to draw conclusions and do things that they're

683
00:26:33,099 --> 00:26:35,920
not supposed to do. Yeah, and also it

684
00:26:35,920 --> 00:26:37,680
can cause a major zilzul Shabbat, meaning once

685
00:26:37,680 --> 00:26:38,799
that happens, people are going to say, 'Ah,

686
00:26:38,880 --> 00:26:40,559
Shabbat is already over anyway, so I may

687
00:26:40,559 --> 00:26:42,339
as well turn on my phone,' and it

688
00:26:42,339 --> 00:26:44,140
could lead to other things. But theoretically, yes.

689
00:26:44,640 --> 00:26:46,660
Yeah. So in the case of tosefet Shabbat,

690
00:26:46,700 --> 00:26:48,099
you wouldn't have to hint to the non-Jew?

691
00:26:48,500 --> 00:26:51,299
Correct. You can ask the non-Jew directly, 'Turn

692
00:26:51,299 --> 00:26:55,319
on my lights.' Yes, correct. Yeah. When you

693
00:26:55,319 --> 00:26:58,960
say the 39 melachot apply during tosefet Shabbat,

694
00:26:59,180 --> 00:27:01,599
is that including all the toldot and everything?

695
00:27:01,839 --> 00:27:05,279
Yeah, all the categories, yes. Let me give

696
00:27:05,279 --> 00:27:06,819
you an example in the other direction a

697
00:27:06,819 --> 00:27:09,380
little bit. Tosafot in the last perek in

698
00:27:09,440 --> 00:27:11,319
Masechet Pesachim, daf tzadik tes, Tosafot talks about

699
00:27:11,319 --> 00:27:12,980
the following issue, which is discussed in the

700
00:27:12,980 --> 00:27:14,960
Taz and the Magen Avraham as well. Let's

701
00:27:14,960 --> 00:27:17,079
say I accept early Shabbat on a summer

702
00:27:17,079 --> 00:27:19,720
Shabbat, six o'clock. And it's just me and

703
00:27:20,259 --> 00:27:21,539
my and my wife, or me and my

704
00:27:21,539 --> 00:27:23,700
siblings, and we're all exhausted, we had a

705
00:27:23,700 --> 00:27:25,420
very exhausting week, we just got back from

706
00:27:25,420 --> 00:27:27,019
vacation, and we want to have a very

707
00:27:27,019 --> 00:27:28,640
quick meal. So we accept Shabbat at six

708
00:27:28,640 --> 00:27:30,160
o'clock. We say, 'You know what? We're going

709
00:27:30,160 --> 00:27:31,420
to have a meal, 25 minutes, we're going

710
00:27:31,420 --> 00:27:34,579
to sleep.' That means you're going to finish

711
00:27:34,579 --> 00:27:36,940
your entire meal before it's even dark outside,

712
00:27:37,000 --> 00:27:39,159
before it's officially Shabbat for most of the

713
00:27:39,159 --> 00:27:41,160
people. The Taz discusses, would that work or

714
00:27:41,160 --> 00:27:44,680
not? Are you in fulfillment of the mitzvah

715
00:27:44,680 --> 00:27:48,480
of Seudat Shabbat if you started and finished

716
00:27:48,480 --> 00:27:50,500
your entire meal of Shabbat before it's even

717
00:27:50,500 --> 00:27:53,660
Shabbat for most of the people? What do

718
00:27:53,660 --> 00:27:57,500
you say? So the Taz writes, you should

719
00:27:57,500 --> 00:27:59,279
be machmir and you should wait to have

720
00:27:59,279 --> 00:28:01,900
at least a kezayit after sunset, after it's

721
00:28:01,900 --> 00:28:05,380
dark outside, because otherwise you basically ate your

722
00:28:05,380 --> 00:28:07,160
whole meal before it's even Shabbat. But what

723
00:28:07,160 --> 00:28:08,579
do you mean? It is Shabbat, I accepted

724
00:28:08,579 --> 00:28:11,299
Shabbat. The answer is, yeah, you accepted Shabbat,

725
00:28:11,359 --> 00:28:13,859
but it's not like 100%, it's not Shabbat

726
00:28:13,859 --> 00:28:15,940
all the way. So once you've accepted Shabbat,

727
00:28:15,960 --> 00:28:18,140
you're not allowed to do melachah obviously. Of

728
00:28:18,140 --> 00:28:19,339
course, you're not allowed to do other things.

729
00:28:19,559 --> 00:28:21,720
You're allowed to make Kiddush, but you can't

730
00:28:21,720 --> 00:28:23,779
have the entirety of the meal before Shabbat

731
00:28:23,779 --> 00:28:27,359
even officially begins. That's the discussion. That's the

732
00:28:27,359 --> 00:28:29,400
discussion but that's somewhat related to this. Yes,

733
00:28:29,539 --> 00:28:32,150
quick question. How is tosefet Shabbat not bal

734
00:28:32,150 --> 00:28:36,740
tosif? tosefet Shabbat is not bal tosif because

735
00:28:36,740 --> 00:28:39,140
we have it learned from a pasuk. The

736
00:28:39,140 --> 00:28:42,519
Torah says it by Yom Kippur. Wait, how

737
00:28:42,519 --> 00:28:44,191
is it not like adding on to a

738
00:28:44,191 --> 00:28:46,259
mitzvah? It's not because the Torah says you're

739
00:28:46,259 --> 00:28:48,819
allowed to. The Torah says by Yom Kippur

740
00:28:48,819 --> 00:28:50,079
that you have to add on to Yom

741
00:28:50,079 --> 00:28:51,380
Kippur, so from there we learn that such

742
00:28:51,380 --> 00:28:54,180
a concept exists. Once the Torah says it,

743
00:28:54,200 --> 00:28:55,220
then of course we're allowed to do it.

744
00:28:55,539 --> 00:28:58,447
Yeah. So in the case of if you

745
00:28:58,447 --> 00:29:01,119
have a meal before, and you finish after

746
00:29:02,180 --> 00:29:05,440
already counts as, and you said Kiddush before,

747
00:29:05,740 --> 00:29:08,980
the idea of like, oh you can just

748
00:29:08,980 --> 00:29:11,740
say it often during the day. If you

749
00:29:11,740 --> 00:29:14,359
said Kiddush before since Friday night, should you

750
00:29:14,359 --> 00:29:16,900
do a particular thing here? No, the Gemara

751
00:29:16,900 --> 00:29:18,900
says explicitly that you're allowed to say Kiddush

752
00:29:18,900 --> 00:29:22,160
even while it's erev Shabbat. The Gemara says

753
00:29:22,220 --> 00:29:24,240
Rav tzalay shel Shabbat b’erev Shabbat, meaning even

754
00:29:24,240 --> 00:29:25,839
while it's light outside, Kiddush for sure you're

755
00:29:25,839 --> 00:29:27,019
allowed to do. The question is the meal.

756
00:29:29,520 --> 00:29:31,599
Okay, yeah. Okay. Yeah. Isn't it, it's interesting

757
00:29:31,599 --> 00:29:33,180
because there's certain places in the world where

758
00:29:33,180 --> 00:29:35,420
Shabbat in the summer doesn't start till 11:00

759
00:29:35,420 --> 00:29:38,460
PM. Right. You go to like Russia, Saint

760
00:29:38,980 --> 00:29:41,420
Petersburg, yeah, then you have to wait till

761
00:29:41,420 --> 00:29:43,319
11:00 PM for... It's a bigger problem the

762
00:29:43,319 --> 00:29:44,480
other way. What do you do about Havdalah

763
00:29:44,480 --> 00:29:48,039
on motzei Shabbat? In England, right? So it's

764
00:29:48,039 --> 00:29:49,880
a big issue. There are a lot of

765
00:29:49,880 --> 00:29:51,039
people who go to sleep and make Havdalah

766
00:29:51,039 --> 00:29:53,779
Sunday morning. Right? You're not going to keep

767
00:29:53,779 --> 00:29:55,480
your kids up till 11:00 o'clock at night.

768
00:29:55,880 --> 00:29:58,640
So, big question. Okay, which now leads us

769
00:29:58,640 --> 00:30:00,699
to the next, to the next... Okay, which

770
00:30:00,699 --> 00:30:01,575
now leads us to the next shlav, to

771
00:30:01,575 --> 00:30:03,460
the next part of this discussion. And that

772
00:30:03,460 --> 00:30:05,400
goes as follows: What happens if I'm in

773
00:30:05,400 --> 00:30:08,619
Eretz Yisrael and I'm observing two days of

774
00:30:08,619 --> 00:30:11,079
Yom Tov because I'm a ben Chutz La'aretz,

775
00:30:11,500 --> 00:30:14,240
I live in the diaspora, I'm visiting Eretz

776
00:30:14,240 --> 00:30:16,480
Yisrael for Yom Tov, but there are many

777
00:30:16,480 --> 00:30:19,039
Jews who are Bnei Eretz Yisrael who live

778
00:30:19,039 --> 00:30:21,240
there who are only observing one day. Would

779
00:30:21,240 --> 00:30:22,819
I be allowed to ask them on my

780
00:30:22,819 --> 00:30:24,380
second day of Yom Tov, can I ask

781
00:30:24,380 --> 00:30:26,559
them to do some kind of activity on

782
00:30:26,559 --> 00:30:29,240
my behalf or not? Well, let's first back

783
00:30:29,240 --> 00:30:31,640
up a step. Let's try to understand, what

784
00:30:31,640 --> 00:30:33,700
is this Yom Tov Sheni all about? What's

785
00:30:33,700 --> 00:30:35,173
going on? Why do we have Yom Tov

786
00:30:35,173 --> 00:30:36,880
Sheni? Yeah? This is like during the whole

787
00:30:36,880 --> 00:30:38,900
like half a day, keep a day and

788
00:30:38,900 --> 00:30:40,480
a half. No, you're getting fancy. That's like

789
00:30:40,480 --> 00:30:43,480
advanced Talmud. This is somebody who goes to

790
00:30:43,480 --> 00:30:46,240
Israel from Chutz La'aretz who's keeping two days

791
00:30:46,240 --> 00:30:49,980
legitimately, wants to know whether they're allowed to

792
00:30:49,980 --> 00:30:52,160
ask somebody else to do a melacha for

793
00:30:52,160 --> 00:30:55,740
them. Okay, so let's try to understand what

794
00:30:55,740 --> 00:30:57,119
is this whole Yom Tov Sheni about in

795
00:30:57,119 --> 00:30:58,339
the first place. Why do we have two

796
00:30:58,339 --> 00:31:00,299
days of Yom Tov? It's referred to as

797
00:31:00,299 --> 00:31:04,000
Yom Tov Sheni shel Galuyos. People say Golias,

798
00:31:04,079 --> 00:31:07,119
it's not, it's Galuyos, right? When I was

799
00:31:07,119 --> 00:31:08,980
in fourth grade, I had a Brachos bee.

800
00:31:09,700 --> 00:31:11,279
So what happens at a Brachos bee? Ever

801
00:31:11,279 --> 00:31:13,291
been part of such a thing? So at

802
00:31:13,291 --> 00:31:14,700
a Brachos bee they ask questions and everyone

803
00:31:15,099 --> 00:31:17,140
studies, fine. So what happened? So I won

804
00:31:17,140 --> 00:31:18,700
the Brachos bee, which means then you go

805
00:31:18,700 --> 00:31:22,640
to the, I don't know, inter-school and thing,

806
00:31:22,720 --> 00:31:24,460
whatever. So then, what do they do? There's

807
00:31:24,460 --> 00:31:26,539
only so many Brachos you can ask about.

808
00:31:26,839 --> 00:31:28,619
It gets to a point where like there's

809
00:31:28,619 --> 00:31:30,539
nothing left in the material to ask. So

810
00:31:30,539 --> 00:31:32,599
we were at the, you know, whatever, the

811
00:31:32,599 --> 00:31:36,299
finals championship, whatever, I have no idea. And

812
00:31:36,299 --> 00:31:37,920
the question I got, they were making up

813
00:31:37,920 --> 00:31:39,859
new questions that we were just supposed to

814
00:31:39,859 --> 00:31:42,240
know without studying. So they asked me, the

815
00:31:42,240 --> 00:31:44,480
question I got out on was: who instituted

816
00:31:44,480 --> 00:31:47,779
Yom Tov Sheni shel Galuyos? I was in

817
00:31:47,779 --> 00:31:49,339
fourth grade. How am I supposed to know

818
00:31:49,339 --> 00:31:53,160
that? Right? So I said obviously it was

819
00:31:53,160 --> 00:31:56,500
Golias, right? Like why else would we call

820
00:31:56,500 --> 00:31:58,740
it that? Which I stepped right into their

821
00:31:58,740 --> 00:32:01,140
trap. That's not the right answer. It doesn't

822
00:32:01,140 --> 00:32:03,880
mean Golias. It's Yom Tov Sheni shel Galuyos,

823
00:32:03,980 --> 00:32:05,799
which means Jews who live in the exile,

824
00:32:05,960 --> 00:32:07,359
Jews who live in the diaspora have to

825
00:32:07,359 --> 00:32:09,380
keep two days of Yom Tov. Why do

826
00:32:09,380 --> 00:32:10,759
they keep two days of Yom Tov? What's

827
00:32:10,759 --> 00:32:13,220
this all about? So the reason why is

828
00:32:13,220 --> 00:32:15,423
because we read in last week's parsha how

829
00:32:15,423 --> 00:32:18,720
are we, how do we determine Rosh Chodesh

830
00:32:18,720 --> 00:32:23,259
every month? The answer is the moon becomes

831
00:32:23,259 --> 00:32:25,380
visible, a small sliver, a small crescent of

832
00:32:25,380 --> 00:32:27,400
the moon becomes visible and we have witnesses

833
00:32:27,400 --> 00:32:30,480
who come to the Beis Din in Yerushalayim

834
00:32:30,480 --> 00:32:32,339
and say, by the way, we want you

835
00:32:32,339 --> 00:32:34,339
to know, we're reporting that we saw the

836
00:32:34,339 --> 00:32:36,539
moon. And we interrogate them, we make sure

837
00:32:36,539 --> 00:32:38,259
they're telling the truth, okay, whatever, fine. Then

838
00:32:38,259 --> 00:32:39,660
we're going to send out messages that everyone

839
00:32:39,660 --> 00:32:41,880
should know today is Rosh Chodesh. Sounds good.

840
00:32:42,240 --> 00:32:43,299
Here's the problem. How are we going to

841
00:32:43,299 --> 00:32:44,599
get the message out? We didn't have emails,

842
00:32:44,720 --> 00:32:46,351
we don't have text messages, no WhatsApp. How

843
00:32:46,500 --> 00:32:47,960
is everyone going to find out? So in

844
00:32:47,960 --> 00:32:49,900
the early days, the mishna says, they used

845
00:32:49,900 --> 00:32:52,099
to go on the top of every mountaintop

846
00:32:52,099 --> 00:32:54,460
in Yerushalayim, they would light a big fire.

847
00:32:55,059 --> 00:32:56,400
And if somebody is standing on top of

848
00:32:56,400 --> 00:32:57,799
it holding a big fire, then the person

849
00:32:57,799 --> 00:32:59,140
at the next mountain and the next town

850
00:32:59,140 --> 00:33:00,680
is going to do the same thing, and

851
00:33:00,680 --> 00:33:02,259
within a couple of hours everyone's going to

852
00:33:02,259 --> 00:33:04,859
find out very efficiently. Here's the problem. There

853
00:33:04,859 --> 00:33:06,579
was a group of Jews by the name

854
00:33:06,579 --> 00:33:09,420
of the Kusim who were trying to undermine

855
00:33:09,420 --> 00:33:12,839
the whole system of traditional Orthodox practice. So

856
00:33:12,839 --> 00:33:14,279
they decided we're going to go two days

857
00:33:14,279 --> 00:33:15,920
in advance and we're going to start lighting

858
00:33:15,920 --> 00:33:18,240
the fires on the mountaintops. And then everyone's

859
00:33:18,240 --> 00:33:20,140
going to think today is Rosh Chodesh, which

860
00:33:20,140 --> 00:33:21,559
means it's going to throw off the whole

861
00:33:21,559 --> 00:33:24,099
calendar. And then it caused major confusion. So

862
00:33:24,099 --> 00:33:26,180
they decided, you know what? Because of that,

863
00:33:26,259 --> 00:33:28,160
we're not going to have this system anymore.

864
00:33:28,400 --> 00:33:29,380
We're going to come up with a new

865
00:33:29,380 --> 00:33:32,099
system. What's the new system? New system they

866
00:33:32,099 --> 00:33:34,259
came up with is after we declare Rosh

867
00:33:34,259 --> 00:33:36,359
Chodesh in Yerushalayim in the Beis Din, we're

868
00:33:36,359 --> 00:33:39,299
going to send actual messengers to every community

869
00:33:39,299 --> 00:33:41,559
to make sure that they become aware of

870
00:33:41,559 --> 00:33:43,759
the fact that we declared Rosh Chodesh. Okay,

871
00:33:44,400 --> 00:33:46,460
sounds like a great idea. Here's the problem.

872
00:33:47,460 --> 00:33:49,385
You're a messenger coming out of the Beis

873
00:33:49,385 --> 00:33:51,460
Din in Yerushalayim traveling on your horse and

874
00:33:51,460 --> 00:33:53,880
buggy. How far are you going to get?

875
00:33:54,720 --> 00:33:56,000
How much time is it going to take

876
00:33:56,000 --> 00:33:57,579
you to get to the furthest place in

877
00:33:57,579 --> 00:34:02,200
the land of Israel? Anybody know? What? What's

878
00:34:02,200 --> 00:34:03,640
the longest amount of time it could take

879
00:34:03,640 --> 00:34:05,180
you, back in the days of the mishnayos,

880
00:34:05,180 --> 00:34:08,440
before cars and before planes and helicopters? What's

881
00:34:08,440 --> 00:34:10,400
the longest period of time it could take

882
00:34:10,400 --> 00:34:13,559
a person to get from Yerushalayim to the

883
00:34:13,559 --> 00:34:15,360
furthest place in the land of Israel? Anybody

884
00:34:15,360 --> 00:34:20,440
know? A day or two? A day or

885
00:34:20,440 --> 00:34:24,960
two? No, forget the two days for a

886
00:34:24,960 --> 00:34:27,760
minute. You're thinking too much. Just think, how

887
00:34:27,760 --> 00:34:30,539
much? Two to three weeks. So you say

888
00:34:30,539 --> 00:34:34,320
two weeks. You're correct. You are correct. How

889
00:34:34,320 --> 00:34:35,860
do I know you're correct? The mishna says,

890
00:34:36,000 --> 00:34:38,626
when in Israel do they start saying vesein

891
00:34:38,626 --> 00:34:41,960
tal umatar after Succos? When do they start

892
00:34:41,960 --> 00:34:46,139
saying it? Anybody know? Shemini Atzeres? No, they

893
00:34:46,139 --> 00:34:48,500
start saying mashiv haruach on Shemini Atzeres. No,

894
00:34:48,599 --> 00:34:50,527
December 4th is in Chutz La'aretz. A week

895
00:34:50,527 --> 00:34:55,679
later? No. Zayin Cheshvan. Zayin Cheshvan. Why do

896
00:34:55,679 --> 00:34:57,440
we start saying it on Zayin Cheshvan? Anybody

897
00:34:57,440 --> 00:34:59,000
know? Think about the calendar for a minute.

898
00:35:00,500 --> 00:35:03,679
Zayin Cheshvan is two weeks after Yom Tov

899
00:35:03,679 --> 00:35:06,539
is over. And the Gemara says if we're

900
00:35:06,539 --> 00:35:07,940
going to start saying the same Tal Umatar

901
00:35:07,940 --> 00:35:09,579
right away after Sukkos, what's going to be

902
00:35:09,579 --> 00:35:11,099
with all those farmers who came all the

903
00:35:11,099 --> 00:35:12,400
way from the Galil or all the way

904
00:35:12,400 --> 00:35:14,930
from the bottom of the country from Otef

905
00:35:14,930 --> 00:35:17,519
Aza and are now traveling back and they're

906
00:35:17,519 --> 00:35:18,619
all going to get stuck in the mud

907
00:35:18,619 --> 00:35:20,639
and stuck in the rain? That's not right,

908
00:35:20,679 --> 00:35:21,539
then they're not going to want to come

909
00:35:21,639 --> 00:35:22,739
Olei Regel, they're not going to want to

910
00:35:22,739 --> 00:35:24,420
visit the Beis Hamikdash next time. So we

911
00:35:24,420 --> 00:35:27,139
hold off the whole Bakasha for rain for

912
00:35:27,139 --> 00:35:29,480
two weeks because we're afraid that the farmers

913
00:35:29,480 --> 00:35:30,400
are going to get stuck on the way

914
00:35:30,400 --> 00:35:32,800
home. Which means the Mishna says that the

915
00:35:32,800 --> 00:35:34,679
maximum amount of time it could take anyone

916
00:35:34,679 --> 00:35:37,679
to get from Yerushalayim to the furthest location

917
00:35:37,679 --> 00:35:40,260
in the land of Israel is two weeks.

918
00:35:40,880 --> 00:35:44,219
Okay. So good. So you have the Shaliach,

919
00:35:44,579 --> 00:35:46,340
you have the messenger goes, the emissary of

920
00:35:46,340 --> 00:35:48,980
the Beis Din goes out and they're sending

921
00:35:48,980 --> 00:35:50,980
people all over to inform everybody. It's going

922
00:35:50,980 --> 00:35:52,860
to take some communities two weeks until they

923
00:35:52,860 --> 00:35:54,719
find out when Rosh Chodesh was, which is

924
00:35:54,719 --> 00:35:58,880
still okay because Pesach is on the 15th

925
00:35:58,880 --> 00:36:00,539
day of the month. So imagine the guy

926
00:36:00,539 --> 00:36:03,019
shows up on Erev Pesach, he says, I

927
00:36:03,019 --> 00:36:04,260
got some great news for all of you,

928
00:36:04,320 --> 00:36:05,500
I want you to know tonight is the

929
00:36:05,500 --> 00:36:07,699
Seder. And everyone's like, what do you mean?

930
00:36:07,739 --> 00:36:09,019
I didn't clean the house, I didn't prepare

931
00:36:09,019 --> 00:36:11,599
anything, I didn't make Matzah. So this is

932
00:36:11,599 --> 00:36:14,159
very distressing. But what about the community that's

933
00:36:14,159 --> 00:36:16,659
16 days out? What do you do about

934
00:36:16,659 --> 00:36:18,420
them? You think there were no Jews who

935
00:36:18,420 --> 00:36:19,860
lived a little bit further out of the

936
00:36:19,860 --> 00:36:22,239
boundaries of Eretz Yisrael? There were. There were

937
00:36:22,239 --> 00:36:24,239
Jews who lived in other locations too. So

938
00:36:24,239 --> 00:36:25,480
what do you do if you're the community

939
00:36:25,480 --> 00:36:29,099
that lives 16, 17 days out or if

940
00:36:29,099 --> 00:36:30,480
you live in the United States, they're never

941
00:36:30,480 --> 00:36:32,500
going to get to you? The answer is

942
00:36:32,920 --> 00:36:35,019
you have to observe two days of Yom

943
00:36:35,019 --> 00:36:38,039
Tov because you're not 100% sure when it's

944
00:36:38,039 --> 00:36:39,579
Rosh Chodesh. You see when the moon shines,

945
00:36:39,639 --> 00:36:41,000
you're not sure, is today the first day

946
00:36:41,000 --> 00:36:42,360
that the moon shined or the second day?

947
00:36:43,099 --> 00:36:44,840
So that's why we observe two days of

948
00:36:44,840 --> 00:36:48,860
Yom Tov. Good? This way we're never going

949
00:36:48,860 --> 00:36:53,199
to have this issue. Okay. So in exile,

950
00:36:53,360 --> 00:36:55,480
in diaspora, the Jews observe two days of

951
00:36:55,480 --> 00:36:56,719
Yom Tov, and in Eretz Yisrael they only

952
00:36:56,719 --> 00:37:01,639
observe one. Okay. Along comes the Maharikash. You

953
00:37:01,639 --> 00:37:04,239
probably never heard of the Maharikash. I never

954
00:37:04,239 --> 00:37:06,659
heard of him either. Who is the Maharikash?

955
00:37:07,699 --> 00:37:09,820
The Maharikash was one of the great, great

956
00:37:09,820 --> 00:37:12,460
Gedolim, one of the great Poskim in Mitzrayim,

957
00:37:12,460 --> 00:37:14,519
in Egypt, in the second half of the

958
00:37:14,519 --> 00:37:17,500
1500s. He passed away in 1612. His name

959
00:37:17,500 --> 00:37:20,619
was Rabbi Yaakov Castro and he was a

960
00:37:20,619 --> 00:37:22,400
Talmid of the Radbaz. The Radbaz was one

961
00:37:22,400 --> 00:37:25,719
of the great Rishonim. And the Maharikash is

962
00:37:25,719 --> 00:37:28,679
quoted by the Birchei Yosef and by the

963
00:37:28,679 --> 00:37:32,139
Shaarei Teshuva as saying what happens when somebody

964
00:37:33,199 --> 00:37:35,440
from outside of the land of Israel goes

965
00:37:35,440 --> 00:37:38,780
to visit for Yom Tov? Now why is

966
00:37:38,780 --> 00:37:42,460
he the first person to ask this? Why

967
00:37:42,460 --> 00:37:43,539
is he the first person to ask it?

968
00:37:46,099 --> 00:37:48,280
Because nobody before him ever thought to do

969
00:37:48,280 --> 00:37:50,039
such a thing. You had in the days

970
00:37:50,039 --> 00:37:52,300
of the Rishonim in the 1200s, 1300s, they

971
00:37:52,300 --> 00:37:54,760
lived in France and in Spain. The Ramban

972
00:37:54,760 --> 00:37:55,940
moved to the land of Israel, but he

973
00:37:55,940 --> 00:37:57,519
moved there so he didn't have this question.

974
00:37:57,579 --> 00:37:59,659
There was no such phenomenon as Jews who

975
00:37:59,659 --> 00:38:01,480
lived in the diaspora who are coming to

976
00:38:01,480 --> 00:38:03,239
visit for Yom Tov and they're going to

977
00:38:03,239 --> 00:38:05,340
go back. It wasn't like today where this

978
00:38:05,340 --> 00:38:07,539
is something we go back and forth. So

979
00:38:07,539 --> 00:38:11,739
the Maharikash asked this question: What do you

980
00:38:11,739 --> 00:38:13,699
do if you're living like me in Egypt

981
00:38:14,219 --> 00:38:16,599
and you're going to go travel to the

982
00:38:16,599 --> 00:38:18,179
land of Israel for Yom Tov? It's not

983
00:38:18,179 --> 00:38:20,199
so far. But you want to go visit

984
00:38:20,199 --> 00:38:21,960
some family or friends who live in Israel.

985
00:38:22,759 --> 00:38:24,980
Would you be able to ask somebody on

986
00:38:24,980 --> 00:38:27,539
Yom Tov Sheini to do Melacha for you

987
00:38:27,539 --> 00:38:28,760
when it's still Yom Tov for you and

988
00:38:28,760 --> 00:38:30,199
it's not Yom Tov for them? That's the

989
00:38:30,199 --> 00:38:32,079
question that he asked, which is amazing. I

990
00:38:32,079 --> 00:38:34,460
always think whatever you want to understand what

991
00:38:34,460 --> 00:38:36,579
was going on in the times of any

992
00:38:36,579 --> 00:38:40,119
particular generation of Jews, just look in the

993
00:38:40,119 --> 00:38:42,800
Tshuvos books. Look at the Shailas that they

994
00:38:42,800 --> 00:38:45,039
asked. Why is he asking this question? He's

995
00:38:45,039 --> 00:38:46,920
asking it because nobody before him talked about

996
00:38:46,920 --> 00:38:48,480
such a thing because such a thing didn't

997
00:38:48,480 --> 00:38:50,900
exist. This was a new phenomenon. So this

998
00:38:50,900 --> 00:38:53,380
is a major, major question as to whether

999
00:38:53,380 --> 00:38:54,559
or not you'd be allowed to do that.

1000
00:38:54,860 --> 00:38:57,320
It seems for the Sfardiyos in the room,

1001
00:38:57,559 --> 00:38:59,579
Rav Ovadia Yosef is Meikel. How many Sfardiyos

1002
00:38:59,579 --> 00:39:01,440
do we have? Rav Ovadia Yosef says he

1003
00:39:01,440 --> 00:39:02,900
thinks we can be Meikel and he says

1004
00:39:02,900 --> 00:39:04,780
he doesn't see any issue. The same way

1005
00:39:04,780 --> 00:39:06,800
we allow this case of the Tchum and

1006
00:39:06,800 --> 00:39:08,239
the same way we allow the case during

1007
00:39:08,239 --> 00:39:10,239
Tosefet Shabbos on both ends that you're allowed

1008
00:39:10,239 --> 00:39:11,380
to ask a Jew to do something for

1009
00:39:11,380 --> 00:39:13,300
you, so too you'd be allowed to ask

1010
00:39:13,300 --> 00:39:15,420
a Jew here on the second day of

1011
00:39:15,420 --> 00:39:16,679
Yom Tov to do something on your behalf

1012
00:39:16,679 --> 00:39:19,320
as well. However, the overwhelming majority of the

1013
00:39:19,320 --> 00:39:22,420
Poskim seem to say that they don't agree

1014
00:39:22,420 --> 00:39:24,920
with that. The overwhelming majority, Rav Akiva Eiger

1015
00:39:24,920 --> 00:39:27,059
writes like this and the overwhelming majority of

1016
00:39:27,059 --> 00:39:29,159
other Poskim seem to say that this is

1017
00:39:29,159 --> 00:39:31,659
something that is not advised. This is something

1018
00:39:31,659 --> 00:39:33,280
that should be avoided and it's something that

1019
00:39:33,280 --> 00:39:35,599
should not be done. And the question you

1020
00:39:35,599 --> 00:39:37,440
need to ask yourself is why? What's the

1021
00:39:37,440 --> 00:39:39,900
difference between the case of Tosefet Shabbos where

1022
00:39:39,900 --> 00:39:42,260
you're allowed to ask someone and the case

1023
00:39:42,260 --> 00:39:47,659
that we're describing here of second day of

1024
00:39:47,659 --> 00:39:49,760
Yom Tov where you would be allowed, where

1025
00:39:49,760 --> 00:39:51,059
you would not be allowed to ask someone,

1026
00:39:51,179 --> 00:39:53,440
correct? What's the difference? So how can you

1027
00:39:53,440 --> 00:39:55,247
think of a difference? It's not Tosefet for

1028
00:39:55,247 --> 00:39:58,820
you. What? It's not Tosefet for you. Good,

1029
00:39:58,920 --> 00:40:01,400
good. You're correct. Yeah. The answer is, speak

1030
00:40:01,400 --> 00:40:02,935
it out a little more. It's not Tosefes

1031
00:40:02,935 --> 00:40:05,271
for you because the extra day is only

1032
00:40:05,271 --> 00:40:08,559
because it actually might be Yom Tov. Exactly,

1033
00:40:08,800 --> 00:40:13,079
meaning Tosefes means right now I decided to

1034
00:40:13,079 --> 00:40:15,639
accept upon myself something extra. So there are

1035
00:40:15,639 --> 00:40:17,679
leniencies during that extra period that you took

1036
00:40:17,679 --> 00:40:19,880
upon yourself. Here on Yom Tov Sheni this

1037
00:40:19,880 --> 00:40:21,900
is not optional. Yom Tov Sheni is an

1038
00:40:21,900 --> 00:40:24,300
obligation that you have. It's not the same

1039
00:40:24,300 --> 00:40:26,659
as Tosefes and therefore we would assume that

1040
00:40:26,659 --> 00:40:28,900
many say that this is something that cannot

1041
00:40:28,900 --> 00:40:31,780
be transferred to that Halacha. We would not

1042
00:40:31,780 --> 00:40:33,199
say that Yom Tov Sheni is the same

1043
00:40:33,199 --> 00:40:35,460
as the Zman of Tosefes. Here's the major

1044
00:40:35,460 --> 00:40:38,800
problem. Ready for the problem? We keep how

1045
00:40:38,800 --> 00:40:43,519
many days of Succos? Eight? No, not overall.

1046
00:40:43,519 --> 00:40:44,960
Seven. How many days of Yom Tov do

1047
00:40:44,960 --> 00:40:49,300
we observe? One. Two. Which one? Two. Good,

1048
00:40:49,380 --> 00:40:50,579
two days of Succos. How many days of

1049
00:40:50,579 --> 00:40:53,431
Pesach? Two. Two. How many days of Shavuos?

1050
00:40:53,431 --> 00:40:55,500
Two. How many days of Rosh Hashanah? Two.

1051
00:40:56,340 --> 00:40:57,995
How many days of Yom Kippur? One. Oh.

1052
00:40:57,995 --> 00:41:02,960
Wow. Can I ask you, why does anyone

1053
00:41:02,960 --> 00:41:06,260
observe one day of Yom Kippur? You observe

1054
00:41:06,260 --> 00:41:09,291
two days of everything else. What's with Yom

1055
00:41:09,291 --> 00:41:15,199
Kippur? It's like right after Rosh Hashanah. Okay,

1056
00:41:16,039 --> 00:41:17,159
but how do you know about Rosh Hashanah?

1057
00:41:17,159 --> 00:41:18,780
The Shluchim had no time to get to

1058
00:41:18,780 --> 00:41:23,800
you for Rosh Hashanah. Right? Rosh Hashanah you

1059
00:41:23,800 --> 00:41:25,239
need two days because you really don't know.

1060
00:41:26,039 --> 00:41:27,199
That's on the first day of the month.

1061
00:41:28,099 --> 00:41:29,820
So Rosh Hashanah you're really stuck. You can't

1062
00:41:29,820 --> 00:41:31,139
say Yom Kippur is ten days later and

1063
00:41:31,139 --> 00:41:33,039
therefore we know because we weren't actually sure

1064
00:41:33,039 --> 00:41:35,199
when Rosh Hashanah is. Even in Eretz Yisrael

1065
00:41:35,199 --> 00:41:36,539
when they don't keep two days of anything

1066
00:41:36,539 --> 00:41:39,199
else, they keep two days Rosh Hashanah. So

1067
00:41:39,199 --> 00:41:40,679
is this a question you ever thought about?

1068
00:41:41,119 --> 00:41:42,840
We keep two days of everything else and

1069
00:41:42,840 --> 00:41:45,019
somehow Yom Kippur falls through the shuffle. What

1070
00:41:45,019 --> 00:41:45,920
are you going to say? Yom Kippur is

1071
00:41:45,980 --> 00:41:48,199
D'rabbanan? No, Yom Kippur is actually as D'oraisa

1072
00:41:48,199 --> 00:41:50,360
as it comes. It's Shabbos Shabboson. It's pretty

1073
00:41:50,360 --> 00:41:53,739
serious. So we're not worried? Why do we

1074
00:41:53,739 --> 00:41:55,760
not have two days Yom Kippur? In fact,

1075
00:41:56,940 --> 00:41:59,239
the Tur v'Hagahos Minhagim quotes that there were

1076
00:41:59,239 --> 00:42:01,400
some Rishonim. In the days of the Rishonim,

1077
00:42:01,480 --> 00:42:03,199
there were Chasidim v'Anshei Maaseh who used to

1078
00:42:03,199 --> 00:42:05,300
keep two full days of Yom Kippur. They

1079
00:42:05,300 --> 00:42:07,051
used to fast two full days straight. Who

1080
00:42:07,051 --> 00:42:10,079
used to fast two full days? One second.

1081
00:42:10,239 --> 00:42:11,800
They used to fast two full days straight.

1082
00:42:12,360 --> 00:42:14,239
Why do we not do it? Says the

1083
00:42:14,239 --> 00:42:15,500
Rema, the reason why we don't do it

1084
00:42:15,500 --> 00:42:18,159
is because Bella is correct, that people are

1085
00:42:18,159 --> 00:42:19,659
going to lose their lives. It's not healthy.

1086
00:42:19,760 --> 00:42:21,179
It's hard enough to fast one day of

1087
00:42:21,179 --> 00:42:23,159
Yom Kippur. How do you expect that major

1088
00:42:23,159 --> 00:42:25,219
communities are going to have every person observing

1089
00:42:25,219 --> 00:42:27,440
two full days of Yom Kippur in a

1090
00:42:27,440 --> 00:42:30,800
row? So because it's a potential Pikuach Nefesh,

1091
00:42:31,079 --> 00:42:33,639
because it's something that is just untenable, therefore

1092
00:42:33,639 --> 00:42:35,340
we say now that we have a fixed

1093
00:42:35,340 --> 00:42:37,099
calendar, we know when Yom Kippur is, we're

1094
00:42:37,099 --> 00:42:38,420
only going to keep that day, we're not

1095
00:42:38,420 --> 00:42:39,940
going to keep two days, and this is

1096
00:42:39,940 --> 00:42:41,599
what standard practice is all over the world.

1097
00:42:42,119 --> 00:42:44,880
Okay. Writes the Tur, you ready? Here's the

1098
00:42:44,880 --> 00:42:47,519
problem. Let's say you have the following scenario.

1099
00:42:47,679 --> 00:42:49,000
You're living in the days of the Rishonim

1100
00:42:49,239 --> 00:42:51,079
where you have many people who are Machmir

1101
00:42:51,079 --> 00:42:52,800
for themselves to keep two days of Yom

1102
00:42:52,800 --> 00:42:54,480
Kippur. I don't know anyone that does that.

1103
00:42:54,539 --> 00:42:55,760
It could be there are, but in the

1104
00:42:55,760 --> 00:42:58,039
days of the Rishonim people did. Okay. Good.

1105
00:42:58,360 --> 00:43:00,800
Here's the question. Yom Kippur falls out on

1106
00:43:00,800 --> 00:43:03,280
a Thursday, which means you're going to observe

1107
00:43:03,280 --> 00:43:07,719
Yom Kippur when? Thursday and Friday. Problem is,

1108
00:43:07,820 --> 00:43:09,360
once Yom Kippur is over, it's now going

1109
00:43:09,360 --> 00:43:11,440
to be Shabbos. I'm not allowed to cook

1110
00:43:11,440 --> 00:43:13,400
food and this is in the days before

1111
00:43:13,400 --> 00:43:15,480
we had a refrigerator. So what am I

1112
00:43:15,480 --> 00:43:17,960
going to do? I'm going to be fasting

1113
00:43:17,960 --> 00:43:21,280
Thursday, Friday, and now Shabbos I have no

1114
00:43:21,280 --> 00:43:23,519
food because I couldn't cook on Friday. And

1115
00:43:23,519 --> 00:43:25,780
I couldn't cook the food on Wednesday because

1116
00:43:25,780 --> 00:43:27,719
I had nowhere to store it. So what

1117
00:43:27,719 --> 00:43:30,719
do you do? Writes the Tur, would I

1118
00:43:30,719 --> 00:43:33,920
be allowed to go and ask my neighbor

1119
00:43:33,960 --> 00:43:36,340
who's not such a Tzadik like me, who's

1120
00:43:36,340 --> 00:43:38,400
not fasting two days Yom Kippur? Am I

1121
00:43:38,400 --> 00:43:40,179
allowed to ask my neighbor on Friday, look,

1122
00:43:40,280 --> 00:43:42,960
I'm really hungry, I need Shabbos food, can

1123
00:43:42,960 --> 00:43:44,460
you cook food for me so that I'll

1124
00:43:44,460 --> 00:43:46,119
have food for Shabbos tonight to break my

1125
00:43:46,119 --> 00:43:48,500
fast? Would I be allowed to do that

1126
00:43:48,500 --> 00:43:50,619
or perhaps not? What do you think? No.

1127
00:43:50,940 --> 00:43:54,460
No? Why not? Because it's still the same

1128
00:43:54,460 --> 00:43:56,283
thing that it might be really Yom Kippur

1129
00:43:56,283 --> 00:43:58,059
just on the other side? Oh. You are

1130
00:43:58,059 --> 00:44:00,460
a thousand percent correct. Asks the Magen Avraham,

1131
00:44:00,679 --> 00:44:03,079
why is it that in Hilchos Yom HaKippurim

1132
00:44:03,360 --> 00:44:05,340
the Shulchan Aruch says that if you observe

1133
00:44:05,340 --> 00:44:07,239
two days Yom Kippur you would not be

1134
00:44:07,239 --> 00:44:08,860
allowed to ask somebody else to cook for

1135
00:44:08,860 --> 00:44:12,039
you on the second day? Whereas, whereas, in

1136
00:44:12,039 --> 00:44:14,539
the Zman of Tosefes Shabbos, if I've accepted

1137
00:44:14,539 --> 00:44:17,360
upon myself that I want to say keep

1138
00:44:17,360 --> 00:44:18,880
Shabbos a little bit longer than everyone else,

1139
00:44:18,960 --> 00:44:20,500
I would be allowed to ask someone. What's

1140
00:44:20,500 --> 00:44:23,239
the difference? Answers the Magen Avraham like you

1141
00:44:23,239 --> 00:44:27,500
very correctly stated, because really everyone should be

1142
00:44:27,500 --> 00:44:30,980
observing two days Yom Kippur. Right? I'm observing

1143
00:44:30,980 --> 00:44:32,500
two days Yom Kippur but really this is

1144
00:44:32,500 --> 00:44:34,260
something that everyone is supposed to be doing.

1145
00:44:34,760 --> 00:44:36,519
When I see my neighbor eating on the

1146
00:44:36,519 --> 00:44:38,000
second day Yom Kippur I say to myself

1147
00:44:38,599 --> 00:44:40,079
I really don't understand why they're doing it.

1148
00:44:40,139 --> 00:44:41,800
They're very strong, very healthy, they don't have

1149
00:44:41,800 --> 00:44:43,960
a problem, there's no reason why they're not

1150
00:44:43,960 --> 00:44:46,139
fasting. Everyone should be doing what I'm doing.

1151
00:44:46,920 --> 00:44:49,059
And because of that, I'm not allowed to

1152
00:44:49,059 --> 00:44:50,960
ask someone to do something that I believe

1153
00:44:50,960 --> 00:44:53,800
is wrong, that's absolutely wrong. I'm not allowed

1154
00:44:53,800 --> 00:44:55,440
to ask someone to do that. And that

1155
00:44:55,440 --> 00:44:56,899
is why on the second day of Yom

1156
00:44:56,899 --> 00:44:58,599
Kippur I would not be allowed to ask

1157
00:44:58,599 --> 00:45:09,000
my neighbor who's a Jew.

1158
00:45:09,760 --> 00:45:11,099
You have a right to decide when you

1159
00:45:11,300 --> 00:45:12,940
want to take Shabbos in, I've a right

1160
00:45:12,940 --> 00:45:14,280
to decide when I want to take Shabbos

1161
00:45:14,280 --> 00:45:16,300
in, but I don't look at you and

1162
00:45:16,300 --> 00:45:18,000
say \"why are you not accepting Shabbos right

1163
00:45:18,000 --> 00:45:19,280
now?\" That's not my business, you can do

1164
00:45:19,280 --> 00:45:20,320
what you want, I'll do what I want.

1165
00:45:20,960 --> 00:45:22,800
And because of that, since you're not doing

1166
00:45:22,800 --> 00:45:24,579
anything wrong, there would be no problem for

1167
00:45:24,579 --> 00:45:27,119
me to instruct you to do this. Now,

1168
00:45:27,400 --> 00:45:28,820
you'll say \"why am I even talking about

1169
00:45:28,820 --> 00:45:31,559
this, it's so irrelevant?\" Because nobody observes two

1170
00:45:31,559 --> 00:45:35,379
days Yom Kippur. Where is it relevant? It's

1171
00:45:35,379 --> 00:45:38,739
relevant every Shabbos. If you don't open bottles

1172
00:45:38,739 --> 00:45:41,460
on Shabbos, and you want to ask somebody

1173
00:45:41,460 --> 00:45:43,539
else to open a bottle for you. Are

1174
00:45:43,539 --> 00:45:45,460
you allowed to do that or not? Well,

1175
00:45:45,500 --> 00:45:48,380
it depends. What's the reason you're not opening

1176
00:45:48,380 --> 00:45:50,099
bottles? Is it because you're just taking a

1177
00:45:50,099 --> 00:45:51,960
little extra chumrah upon yourself or you believe

1178
00:45:51,960 --> 00:45:55,280
it's actually assur? If you believe, like my

1179
00:45:55,280 --> 00:45:57,219
father believes and Rav Asher Weiss believes that

1180
00:45:57,219 --> 00:45:59,780
opening bottles is absolutely not permissible on Shabbos,

1181
00:46:00,320 --> 00:46:03,659
if you believe that's the case—there are others

1182
00:46:03,659 --> 00:46:05,119
who disagree don't worry, Rav Shlomo Zalman Auerbach,

1183
00:46:05,400 --> 00:46:06,500
you have what to rely on don't worry,

1184
00:46:06,719 --> 00:46:11,000
great people, not people, great tzaddikim. But if

1185
00:46:11,000 --> 00:46:12,900
you believe that the reason why you're not

1186
00:46:12,900 --> 00:46:15,300
opening bottles on Shabbos is because you think

1187
00:46:15,300 --> 00:46:19,119
it's absolutely forbidden, it's assur, then you would

1188
00:46:19,119 --> 00:46:20,599
not be allowed to ask somebody else either.

1189
00:46:22,260 --> 00:46:23,920
If you believe the only reason why you're

1190
00:46:23,920 --> 00:46:25,860
not opening it is because I'm just not

1191
00:46:25,860 --> 00:46:27,940
sure, this whole thing has so many opinions,

1192
00:46:28,099 --> 00:46:29,820
I don't know what it is, it's just

1193
00:46:29,820 --> 00:46:31,780
a chumrah, so then maybe there's what to

1194
00:46:31,780 --> 00:46:33,880
talk about, maybe. My father still thinks he

1195
00:46:33,880 --> 00:46:35,079
wouldn't be allowed to even if it's just

1196
00:46:35,079 --> 00:46:36,860
a chumrah, but most disagree with my father

1197
00:46:36,860 --> 00:46:39,880
on that point. This would be the distinction.

1198
00:46:40,519 --> 00:46:41,800
Writes the Magen Avraham, what do you see?

1199
00:46:42,219 --> 00:46:44,139
You see from Yom Kippur, we can use

1200
00:46:44,139 --> 00:46:46,260
that as a test case for us. You

1201
00:46:46,260 --> 00:46:47,940
see from the case of Yom Kippur that

1202
00:46:47,940 --> 00:46:50,059
if the reason why I'm not doing something

1203
00:46:50,059 --> 00:46:52,099
is because I believe that it's really assur

1204
00:46:52,099 --> 00:46:53,739
to be done, this is how you have

1205
00:46:53,739 --> 00:46:55,699
to keep halacha as a Jew, then I'm

1206
00:46:55,699 --> 00:46:57,340
not allowed to request of somebody else to

1207
00:46:57,340 --> 00:46:59,139
do it either. But if all I'm doing

1208
00:46:59,139 --> 00:47:02,079
is just a chumrah upon myself, then okay,

1209
00:47:02,320 --> 00:47:04,760
I'm being machmir, you're not being machmir, maybe

1210
00:47:04,760 --> 00:47:06,500
there's room to argue that that would be

1211
00:47:06,500 --> 00:47:08,659
okay. Take for another example, if I do

1212
00:47:08,659 --> 00:47:10,659
not carry in the eiruv, can I ask

1213
00:47:10,659 --> 00:47:12,739
somebody else to carry something on my behalf

1214
00:47:12,739 --> 00:47:18,860
or not? Clearly no. So most poskim say

1215
00:47:19,039 --> 00:47:21,340
it depends why you're not carrying. If you're

1216
00:47:21,340 --> 00:47:23,079
not carrying because you believe that the eiruv

1217
00:47:23,079 --> 00:47:24,960
is not a good eiruv, is not acceptable,

1218
00:47:25,239 --> 00:47:26,460
it's very hard to make a good eiruv.

1219
00:47:26,860 --> 00:47:27,980
If you live in a community where you

1220
00:47:27,980 --> 00:47:29,820
have somebody who really knows eiruvin, the eiruv

1221
00:47:29,820 --> 00:47:31,579
is probably very good. But it's not so

1222
00:47:31,579 --> 00:47:33,579
simple to do it. So if the reason

1223
00:47:33,579 --> 00:47:35,179
you're not carrying in the eiruv is because

1224
00:47:35,179 --> 00:47:36,860
you're not sure that the eiruv is actually

1225
00:47:36,860 --> 00:47:39,280
acceptable, then you're not allowed to ask anyone

1226
00:47:39,280 --> 00:47:41,219
else because you believe that they're doing wrong

1227
00:47:41,219 --> 00:47:43,691
also. But if you're not carrying in the

1228
00:47:43,691 --> 00:47:45,966
eiruv only because the Mishnah Berurah says, ba'al

1229
00:47:45,966 --> 00:47:48,760
nefesh yachmir, a person who doesn't need the

1230
00:47:48,760 --> 00:47:50,139
eiruv shouldn't use it if they don't have

1231
00:47:50,139 --> 00:47:53,980
to, then that's my personal chumrah. Who said

1232
00:47:53,980 --> 00:47:56,019
that that includes me asking you to do

1233
00:47:56,019 --> 00:47:59,480
something on my behalf? That's a question. But

1234
00:47:59,480 --> 00:48:02,400
this is a major discussion and again, what

1235
00:48:02,400 --> 00:48:04,719
I find fascinating about all this is that

1236
00:48:04,719 --> 00:48:06,260
if you put all of these different sugyas

1237
00:48:06,260 --> 00:48:09,285
together, number one, tosefes Shabbos, Chuman, Yom Tov

1238
00:48:09,285 --> 00:48:13,619
Sheini, Yom Kippur, and then Hilchos Shabbos with

1239
00:48:13,619 --> 00:48:15,639
the chumras, and Sephardim and Ashkenazim also is

1240
00:48:15,639 --> 00:48:17,619
the same question about we have different rules

1241
00:48:17,619 --> 00:48:19,500
about heating things up on Shabbos, right? Sephardim

1242
00:48:19,500 --> 00:48:23,159
and Ashkenazim about heating up liquids, correct? Would

1243
00:48:23,159 --> 00:48:24,659
a Sephardi or an Ashkenazi be able to

1244
00:48:24,659 --> 00:48:26,800
ask one another to do something that the

1245
00:48:26,800 --> 00:48:28,719
other gender is not the right word but

1246
00:48:28,719 --> 00:48:31,739
the other community believes is acceptable and I

1247
00:48:31,739 --> 00:48:33,500
believe is not allowed? Can I do that

1248
00:48:33,500 --> 00:48:35,219
or not? Well, it's a question. Am I

1249
00:48:35,219 --> 00:48:37,239
not doing it because I believe you shouldn't

1250
00:48:37,239 --> 00:48:38,719
be doing it either, or am I not

1251
00:48:38,719 --> 00:48:40,699
doing it because I just believe it's okay,

1252
00:48:40,800 --> 00:48:42,300
a chumrah, we're going to be machmir, the

1253
00:48:42,300 --> 00:48:43,960
Rama says to be machmir. So these are

1254
00:48:43,960 --> 00:48:47,159
all interconnected, again, a little bit technical and

1255
00:48:47,159 --> 00:48:50,139
complicated but a really fascinating area of halacha

1256
00:48:50,139 --> 00:48:52,019
to realize how it all ties together from

1257
00:48:52,019 --> 00:48:54,119
so many different angles and so many different

1258
00:48:54,119 --> 00:48:56,780
examples. But something as I mentioned that comes

1259
00:48:56,780 --> 00:48:58,480
up all the time, literally, this is something

1260
00:48:58,480 --> 00:49:00,360
that we're confronted with all the time and

1261
00:49:00,360 --> 00:49:02,400
something we should be...
